) 4
» ———;3$E¤
Awn21rtrIOI<. Arms IU.
:°I$PC· EJIITIAII /I€‘l¥'iYl|‘sI(;• lJTil{_ = CL%T;(TgIgTDgSg l `T m H
I7I0TCfIC.Er’L $512,1
i
XI xm rn-Ir ummm arrrwr mmm mm
_. FDIC THE DISTRICT OF f\I·€IZDI*Ii\
:\riMm~1I;»0 ROIZIERTO Ama im. @*./0*-1- ion.}- Fnx- BRE [1.0AW
-| I~Im.II~ #
V5. REPLY TD DEFEr¤IDAMT `
ROBmt$m\I at 21] ESPDNSE T0 PLAINTIFF5
D·a¥zncI.mI$. Frm 5AIxIcTIa>M.$
_I
-| IJI;II¤IIII Arman i; Fl. Array, Tlll rm sc hereby TE hes
{0 {hc Dc‘·I£r1cI:mL5‘ RES oust I.0 has I’I¤In0TI For 52rI;I.nm'l5
{Wed f>nI;>bcr Z Zzmfp. As Eztnhlmhcd harem {he
D¤IamIant$‘ Asijcrimns {hai PIZIIIIIUH has {ned h:»11mIr.1¤I-
tht Court Ahnut TCIEVJIIII {anis and that I?InmI.¤II ’{,.1I|E(I
I.0 'ITICCIZ Lhc In r1are·1·nenI.$ OI LRLIIJ TL Cj} ntni Siicd
PIJIIIIIII as 6nt¤’LIerI In thc Marianna hr has Icgurzird.
-| "WIc DeI`cmI:1nIs have 1r `¤erI that PI;1m£.{{*5 I“I¤fum
IB III Dlswucry r»m»»> M mr M MI
{D hrs rr uest Im has mc;I.a;1I records and hrs ;I»;I¤I.fa¤~r¤,1I {
ITItEY"I'0 3..I;DI'IE5 in Dcpcndanis Schrwg zmrl Esvas
-|
_! Case 2:04-cv-00306-SRB Document 76 FiIed11/08/2006 Pa é10f4
heeauae {hee had 30 dam l;e> eres unel he {huge ewerhurei
and Plaxntillw MCD was Plled new {eu the ex wralresn al
l.l'lé1l. llnme; erumil. ‘{ha$ vnew emnvenaenili D\/€TlDDl(5 the
eiemduet neeessilalam {he `rnetnun lu be nra mth. 7/he
Defendants have a eo v mf th Cr>e¤rl.‘i Nedulsed Seheduhn
Seder CDKL. U and were Chels 21 Taseel ebll {he Ceauria Al
Se, iernber Bb ZDOQ drscemierv elna ute eleadlme. it
was mth this deadline nn mend ‘Lh:1l.lPlamlll`l wrote {eu
elelenie ecxunsel TE LlEI>“l..lTlD nelnFaeal1m’r {Al hear eluenlb
lnlenlmns Telaiaue lc h as ebukslandln v YE ueales by
Se temlwev IE ence,). See Mem ae eelnble E ¤ . 2-3.1
lib? Lemme Plal·ntil;l*;¤ Ieeeer Tnuai. he vaewecl an the a
hashemeal Lunleel ul thas ease/l'hel21s.e’E¤1ne Plaanelll
ne leeeed le n¤’e¤l1theCeeerL e>l an e>uaL:md¤n elasem/elw
e uest [vas-a-xm {he Ceelrtps ml mal Sehedellun Order`!
he Delendanea Used lem awed elleelgaure he ar enn {hal
lJ\a:·nLlll mulaeed A Lcurl. ezlnveelnue . See enerallv B
Dlits. SL. and 57 . Aware of {hea lhslelrv elelense counsel
had ee l
1rhl.e·nl11>‘n$ an a reasonable almewunl. ml Jennie Tam' lb lhe
Ct>url.`$ Cl:see>verv‘ edaa ute eleael.laa‘ae wbulel Qbllcl e l)laen’elll
Le;$eek the Ceuelw assxsianee. llad nplamlncl allowed {he
deadlme its come and QD alnsenl Lmnunenl The
Delendanla would have esnduulnledlv {med. _ _
r selosue . aa {hel d.d beeeee bv glr erdal {hal ljlamlall
had vmlaled the (LeewL‘z lnmelalgle.
_I Z
asa 2:04-cv-00306-SRB Document 76 FiIed11/08/2006 Page20f4
All Thai was Tieeded here fen reelude PIllT1i|F{"
Â¥1"0TFt Iâ€l2vm JL0 TT!0{Zr0Tt {he C.0ur’E Yehitnué L0 his
Weeleeal Tecoerds amd P0il0w·r.1 IT\tCTT'£J J1[0B1'lfS was
-l 5¤m \c 00d- Meth Petter {T\‘FD‘:"|’F}lTI hem that
ns ee‘ 0 {has: ere uesis WETE Purihcomm . "/me
Defendants Instead m ted Pear sslence md be $0
dmm ece.: eteeed ein Un·nee.e5;.;1r>’ ‘m0w[.¤em +.0 00m el
Y€ :l`FCllf`| C[¤sc{0s0re$ {he Bvndenllv mtended {0
THAKQ. If, I5 ?I2n1nf{H'5 C.0r·1f€‘r1fa0‘1'a that such
0m*me.s$10r1$ are c0vered bf Uwe Ieiicnf And s emi 0{
Rule 37 f.1}(*i){A} Fed. E. Cm. P. And {hai {he
'Zlf“KfLtIDT}5 Te uesjeed "remzm A YO mah.
_I C0ee0us.lv {he Defendants ne leeted {0 e;0mmenk
0n the 0’Lher d¤se.0verv issues that Plzmtdf uh Purth.
As esizhlnshed mnhes Mc;0 P| :henl.¤H Ima; Severn}
_' e ueah. 1°0ed¤0umeeei5 that ,;leeTe|ev;1n{ {0 hes cause
Arid {HAL have been endm sence Nev 5 1000. Sec
NLD sf . *%-5 , As mebrejned |T'l has I"}0’L10r1 Far
521t'iLl-lL‘»T15 plnaretewii Tt u€§[ IDDY _&e>mper|j2{e0FJ I;
based 0n___’Lhc Alicvnateve *Lhe0rr thee that Q0rr1pm_;;é»0r1
au warranted ef the [wrt Tulei Ural {he ducumggjj
Te ucsied 5h0u|d have bcere Pmwded. jg; Kr;qM5L_£Q_,»
S;1·· L ns ;1tp.5. 0 me
I Fmzllv Aa €$L1bI»5|’1ed run A seuernte m0L101’1 __ V
Med C.z>ug_e1rrenHv herewnth , Plamhaff Has] 21dg_;~‘uete·fy
__ @.0m \eed_ uwth the ‘reg‘0we·mer1L§ 0f LRllw TZ [J). Sec
N P|:m1LeF{;;__KepH {0 the DeTcnd;1r1je_$' Qespnmse {0 pIJ|'I’lL__|_{t{`i$
Case 2:04-qc-_QO306-SRB Docurgent 76 FiIed11/08/2006 Page30f4 H
{ - ..
MLB at . 1-3- 1
em11.3.m
Fur 1.hE`}'C25OTlS lx/CF`} lT'l pII1|1'iL1{{`5 RF UEAL ’F/JY
$£|f‘i.LJLlL>T1§ 3113 I'C§(’£'I1'. RE l1’ p].11r'i[1H TCS`£Lt1fLlH>'
` ZISKS UWE Cbplft {QD JWJFA SJHLLIDTIJ ’YC Ll€5f.CCl.
II Hmm.,/U :,1..m,m tins $,1 111 ef Mmm 26610 1,,
CI MM
.|b\L`I`h"nHl'IL`{D R. Ares III.
_I 1,1 .11
11mm and 111 TMA 11111
M 111 11 111 1.1.111 M, 11,;
em O1 11161.11
11.111111 Mm1>.5»m.1 em I
em 1,1. 11//,11.»14/.1>11,/1 51. _
1111.11111 gm, . 6 ,
new w1;11}e;1 11115 11.111 ez 1 1
pm.r.m me 111,111;.11.11 1
Pkszazta l» . 1 1111./W CMH1
121*5 Lx/. 1/\/AShl"I'"l 'I;DFl St. nl
Phecmw www
_' Case 2:04-cv-00306-SRB Document 76 Filed 11/08/2006 Page 4 of 4
0 l -
Case 2:04-cv-00306-SRB
Document 76
Filed 11/08/2006
Page 1 of 4
Case 2:04-cv-00306-SRB
Document 76
Filed 11/08/2006
Page 2 of 4
Case 2:04-cv-00306-SRB
Document 76
Filed 11/08/2006
Page 3 of 4
Case 2:04-cv-00306-SRB
Document 76
Filed 11/08/2006
Page 4 of 4
United States Free Forms
Canada Free Forms
United Kingdom Free Forms
Australia Free Forms