Free Response to Motion - District Court of California - California

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 1 of 21

EXHIBIT A

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 2 of 21

suPERloR , oF cALtFoRNtA, cou: couNTlJF sANDtEGo
HEARING DATE
H E A R I N GI M E T

GIC7B95BB

os/tr/oz or/26/a4

HON. S. C}IARLES WICKERSHAM

I N T IF F l P E T I

OSI COLLECTION SERVICES INC
m a t t e r c a m eo n f o r h e a r i n g @

JA]VIESM KINDER

ATTORNEY RECORD OT

(add,I signatures - use attached sheet)

IT IS MDERED FOLLOIJS: AS

PURSUANT CRC 225 AND/OB SUPERIORCOURTRULES D I V I S I O N TO ]I
AND THE NOTICtr OF DISMISSAL PREVIOUSLY SERVED ON
THtr PAl?TTE-A

RIILE 2 .73 , BY THE COURT,

THE ABOVE-ENTITLED CASE IS DISMISSED.

E S T I M A T ET R I A L I I I " I E : D

day(s ) . without preJ udI ce .

JURY NON-JURY /

o r d e n e d i s m i s s e dw r t h d n IT IS SOMDERED: o a r e a , 0 1 ,/ 2 6 / o 4

J U D G E / C O M H I S S I O O F R H E S U P E R I OC O U R T NE T R

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 3 of 21

E,XHIBIT B

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 4 of 21

suPERloR couh t oFcALtFoRNtA, couNT\uFsANDtEGo
330 W. Broadway, Dept. 73 San Diego, CA 92101 5r9_685_511_9

TO:

FILE COPY: pAGE 1 oF r
3 NOTICES PREPARED

OSI COLLECTION SERVICES INC
Ptaintiff(s)

case o.: GIC789588 N

NOTICE DISMISSAL COURT OF BY
JA]VIES M KINDER
Deferdant( s )

U N L E SO N E F T H EF o L L O I I I N G c u R ST H EC C I J R T L L D t s M r s sT H E B O V E - E N T T T L E D S O Oc , ur A C A S E, J r r H o uP R E J U D TO N r T CE

o:./26/04

1) ?)

F i t e a j u d g r n e n t r d i s m i s s a [ ( s e e s u p e r i o rc o u r t R u t e s ,D i v i s i o n o I I , R u l e2 . 4 0 , i f a p p l . i c a b l . e ) . ApParex parte in the department tisted beton and show good cause why the case shouLdnot be dismissed. Report to .Iudge S. CIIARLES WICKERSITAM

onty one continuance il.t be granted. r Att irquiries regarding this notice shoutdbe referred to the court and phone nuber tisted above. CERTIFICATE SERVICE OF I certify that: I amnot a Party to the above-entitl.ed ase; on the date shown elol, c b I served th.is notice on the parties shoun by ptacing a true coPy in a separate enveLope,addressedas shownl each_envel,ope Has then seatedard, w i t h p o s t a g et h e r e o n f u t t y p r e p a i d , d e p o s i t e d i n t h e U n i t e d s t a t e s p o s t a I s e r v i i e u t S a n nj-;do"' Catifornia.

D A T E Dt:c / t t / n i
, I v J

BY: CLERK THESUPER|OR OF COURT

KENNETH . KAI.JAEATA S M A X I E R H E I I T I H E I I .SE R P H E } I& V R E V I c H.,. . I TE S 600 UESTBROADUAY,UITE 9OO S sAN DtEGO, CA 92101-3354 JAI.IES KINDER H 5775 CAI,IINITO ULSERA P LA JoLLA, CA 92037-7160

J A I ' I E SM . K I N D E R 3129 INDIAST sAN DIEGO, CA 92't03-601t,

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 5 of 21

EXHIBIT C

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 6 of 21

suPERloR cotrri, oF cALlFoRNlA, couN',t \,rsAN DIEGO
CILEI)AR IIO.

c r c 7 89 5 8 8
HON.

05-3r-02

01:55PM
RIS//NAPPI

S. CHARLES WICKERSHAM

HAUPT/SHIMEK P.O.BOX I20L28
IFFIPETITI

cA 92112-0i
JAMES M KINDER

OSI COLLECTIONSERVTCESINC KENIIETH S. KAWABATA (1)
1. PI,AINTIFF S.J

.I4yES M KINDER

D pnIoR To CALEI{DAR CALL E oFF.CALENDAR GRANTED E D

solos

D rno D coNTtluED vaclreo E

p+Rron .ALENDAR {rou-,. ," To .ALL

8-991y''4 n oepr / 1

D tJrTH/4rlqJT PREJUDTcE

er .2C:Zt /)-Z

\

E ALL PREVIqJS oRDERs REI{AIII FULLFoRcE IN ANDEFFECT. E TELEPHoITc E coNTINUED oRALARGUNENT roR oN oF EI,ITIRE ACIIoII E PREVAILI}IG PARTY PREPARE FILE FOR},IAL TO AND ORDER PURSUA}JTCRC TO ]91.

D onRT ARGUI,IENT TELEPfloNIc D DATED E DIsPosEs ET.ITIRE oI AcTIoN D DOES NoTDIsPosE

E uoornEo

E ornen

. , i

/ l

a l

I
Datd, Og /22 / 03

'.,i.a.,

JUDGE,/CO,IMtSSIONER SUPERIOR OF THE CqJRT

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 7 of 21

E,XHIBIT D

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 8 of 21

SUPERIOR CUUrr,OF CALIFORNIA, COUh\T, SANDIEGO I VF
CATETDAR IO.

G r c 7 8 5 88 9

05-3L-02

3r

s,${I ss

r l e r k o f t h e a ' r n g 1 i 9 g. ^ y / f

lrt Nrc'V<*,{U*rw

15 AUG ZOOi
ry. t.,,At\l,l NluhdtS, deputy

NTIFF,/PETITt

OSI COLLECTIONSERVICES INC
PLAr r FFlpErri r6nEn' NT

JAMES M KINDER

K-enn *Lv

-,

Aa-*u q V,e'-*rn-

Sawot+ /14 V^^e*

ITG

dPNION TO CALENDAR CALL E OFF.CALE},IOAR GRAITED D D

soxos

E rno El coNTtNUEDvncnreo D

D pRtoR .ALENDAR io*r. To .ALL

," 0/,F 3%V |
/

n o e e7 3 r

T D v t r H / H t r x c up R E J U D T c E

^, Z.()fi',,-,-

fJ ALL PREvIqJs oRDERs RE}IAIiI FULLFoRcE I}I ANDEFFECT. E] TELEPHO}IIC CONTINUED ORAL D TOR ARGUHEilI OII EIITIRECTIOX A D PREVAILING PARTY PREPARE FILE FORI,IAT To AND ORDER PURSUANT CRC IO 391.

tr ORAL ARGUIIENT TELEPHoI{IC D DATED E DIsPosEs EIJTIRE TIoN oF Ac D oogsttot D I S P O SO F E

D coilFrRltED xoorrreo El

E otxen

r/is/as

!

nt

rt

l l l l

,i. t- r? Lf"J-{_
JUDGE/CO''IMISSIONER SUPERIOR OF THE COURT

. ^

I

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 9 of 21

EXHIBIT E

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 10 of 21

suPERloR coun, oFcALrFoRNtA, couNTy sAN vF DtEGo
I I E A R I NT I G

CITEIDAN K,.

GIC789588 HON.

05-3I-02

t/2t/03

uselotrv-l-[ pco{nt
Clerk lheSuoer,or ol Courl

01:55PM

S. CHARLES WICKERSHAM

NOv0 2003 2
ijv D ANl,l M0RR|S, Deputy

HAUPT/SHIMEK P . O . B O XL 2 0 t 2 B S A N D I E G O , C A 92II2-OI2B IFFIPETITIONE
OSI COLLECTION SERVICES INC ATToRNEv plnTIJTFTTFETTTI ron JAMES M KTNDER

THIS

KENNETHS. KAWABATA (1) 1 . PLAI}ilIIFF TELE: SLIMMARY WDGMENT
c0ilE
, TllE

g4I4ES M KTNDER

a6R

To.ALENDAR rorr.lorr-cALENDAR D cnerrEo soNos El

E rno E cotrttueo D vnclreo

O PRtoRTo CALENDAR CALL fJ coIr, Io -.-

E orrrEo

D UITH/UITHoUT EJUDIcE PR IN DEPTAT-

E ALL PREvIqJs oRDERs REI.IAIN FULLFoRcE IN ANoEFFECT. CI TELEPHoNIcfJ coNTINUEo oRALARGUT,IENI FoR oN D OML ARGUMENT TELEPHoNIC D DATED

DotsposesoFENTlREAcTIoNj-offio,loiou',*'.DE,4@IFIED
D PREVAILING PARTY PREPARE FILE F.RMAL To AND .RDER PUR'UANT cRc ]91, Io tA OTIER An,/,/2../

ft{ffii't'r

Dated1L/27/03 :

t V d n r / , UJ t n .rwvl!. t l lbkM_l(ar^_
JUDGE/CO.IT{I SSIONER THE SUPERIOR OF CURT

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 11 of 21

EXHIBIT F

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 12 of 21

qm i "
o
= !

m{ fro

TT

dlNl.'\A

t H

I oH (,t 9cDX-

5 0:/

\"

(D

F E B
a

r

F

Fgfi
8F
:{o) { m

F$=

V2

o

oro

sF3;
F' F' _o
P
_ 5

srE
9 e
o

e.55'r o.5(os

3O

Hrrr

3Ffi
o
H vt

cf
lJl

a a

-

dB

Iu

c]
{ JI JI -

ts

E
t t

F O
U

o o r

cl

I o I
0 o
5

(D - D

I m

D = .

O I r O
!,

E >
o

ro o*

3*

-F 0I uJ
F

o
{ m

{
I

F

z

r-

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 13 of 21

EXHIBIT G

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 14 of 21
(-

I

1

2 3
T

F i r Clerf '' '

E
uuutt

D

"'!rl'o{

2S JUN zo0l
DePutY A' BY: Gertra'

A

5 o 1 8 o M. 1 C ) JAMI]S ICNDER ll L2
1 a I J

THE SUPERIOR COUIIT OF THE STATEOF CALIFORNIA IN A N D F ORTHE COUNTY SANDIEGO OF NO Gr C882000 ) CASE
) ) ) ) ) ) )

Plaintiff, v . ADECCO,INC. and DOES I through100, inclusive, Defendants

T4 15 t6
1'l

LIFTINGAU'|OMATIC S'fAY ORDER AND DENYINGDEFENDANT'S REQUEST FORDISMISSAL AND OR (CCP|i REQUIREMENT A SECUzuTY OF 3 9 1 e ts e q . ) ,

FOR THE NOTICE OF VEXATIOUSLITIGANT AND REQUEST AFTER REVIEWTNG THERETO. THE AS DISMISSALAND/OR SECIJRITY, WELL AS THE OPPOSITION

1 8 COURT HEREBY RULES: L9 20 2l 22 23 24
section to to Kinder is subject a pre-filingorderpursuant Code of Civil Procedure James l i i M 3 9 1 ,e t s e q . T h e o r d e rp r o h i b i t s r . K r n d e r ' f r o nfr l i n g l i t i g a t i o nn p r o p e r w i t h o u ta p p r o v ao 1 ' judge of the court rvherethe litigationis to be filed. Here, Mr. Kinder is a plaintiff the presiding filed a Notice of Chad Austin. On June8,2007, defendant in an actionfiled by an attorney, (c). l'his section391.1,subdivision Vexatious Lirigantpursuantto Cocieof Civii Procedure createdan automaticstay. Plaintiff filed an oppositionto the Notice of VexatiousLitigant on

td . w 2 5 J u n e 5 , 2 0 0 7 , h i c hi s w i t h i n t h es t a t u t o r y p e r i oo r e s p o n d( C C P $ 3 9 1 7 ( c )) 2

26

(a) that the courttmt L os rJr > subdivision states 391.1, section Codeof Civil Procedure

ttenf

er

q

of lrom filing any new litigationtn the courts htrgant 2 7 prefiiingorderwhich prohibitsa vexatrous judge of the court leaveof the presiding 2 8 this statein propriapersonawithout first obtainrng
OI{DIIR I

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 15 of 21

t

wherethe litigationis proposed be filed." The statute to doesnor,on lrs face,precludea litigant subject a pre-filingorder from filing a larvsuit to while represented counsel, in this case. by as Further,there is nothing to suggestthat the pre-fiiing order against Mr. Kinder includesa

2
a J

^ L+

prohibition against counsel filing suit on his behalf. Thus,thereis not a violation thepreof filingorder. TheCourthereby lifts theautomatic andrequires stay defendant pleaci to withrnl0 clays
f o l l o w i n gs e r v i c eo f t h i s o r d e r .

5 6 7 8
()

IT IS SOORDERED

r0
l1 12 l3 T4 15
lo

D A T ED :

JUNzBIC'
HON JANIS SAMMARTINO PRESIDING JIIDGE

17 t8 19 20 2l 22
aa L)

24 25 26 27 28
ORDER - 2

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 16 of 21

EXHIBIT H

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB Detaiis Document 55-4 -p Routing Adrninistration rduct Telcordia

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 17 of 21

PageI of

DataSource(TDS) Telemarketing Telcordia@
(NXXs)are most ltkelyceilular, landline, pagrng,the Telemarketing or Data lf you havea needto know which exchanges way up Sourceis an economical to t
Clic kh e r et o r e q u e st rei n fo rma ti oo n TDS. mo n T e Sam p l e D SA v ai l a b l (5 5 MB )
c oncethe filetds_eval_setup_3_0 is downloaded exe O d o u b l e l i c k n i t t o i n s t a ltlh e T D S s a m p l e c o c O a d e s k t o ip o nw i l lt h e nb e i n s t a l l e d o ( 1 00 M B a v a i l a b ls p a c e e q u i r e d n h a r dd r r v e ) e r o Lrslrns netufnla P-(o!ucl

hnp://www.telcordia,com/products_services/trainJb/catalog_details.html

5/16/2007

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 18 of 21

EXHIBIT I

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 19 of 21

408275 408278 408280 408282 40828 3 408288 408289

408237 4082 50

310875 408208 408223 408231 4 0 8 23 3 408236

3r-0869 310870

npanxx

408607 408 6r_9 4 0 8 61 3
PA.'a 1

4 0 8 59 9

408290 2 408 91 408301 408302 408303 408304 40830s 408 06 3 408 0B 3 408 12 3 408322 408327 408337 408344 408348 408 64 3 408 81 3 408388 408397 408403 4084Q7 408415 40843 1 408432 408439 408442 408443 4Q8444 408456 408473 40848 5 408488 408496 408 04 5 408506 408 07 5 408534 , 1 055 2 8 408 81 5 408587 408589 408 96 5

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 20 of 21

npanxx 408651 408652 40867 4 408696 408 97 6 408698 408699 408703

408725 44 4087 47 4087 4087 60 4087 68 408769 408772 4087 87 408 88 7 408798 408814 1 4088 5 4 0 B1 6 B 408819 408820 408860 408 64 I 408865 7 4088 0 408880 4OBBB1 40888 5 408909 4089L7 408920 408925 408928 4 0 8 92 3 408939 408943 408948 408949 40891 5 4 0 8 95 408977 408989 408 91 9 408992 408993 408994 4 0 8 95 9 408999 4L520L 4r5204 4]-5207 4L5208 4r5270 41-52r2 4r5219 415220 4]-5224 4\5227 4L5232

408709 408720

Page 2

Case 3:07-cv-02132-DMS-AJB

Document 55-4

Filed 04/11/2008

Page 21 of 21

npanxx

4L529Q 415 03 3 415 13 3 415 19 3 415327 475342 41530 5 4L5372 415 89 3 4L5394 415 99 3 4t54r4 415420 4L5442 4I5443 4154 9 5 4r5463 41 5 4 8 1 4 1 5 45 8 415491 415 15 5 415 21 5 4r5527 415 30 5 4r.5533 415 40 5 415 41 5 415558 415560 4r557 6 415 88 5 4t5604 415 05 6 4t5607 4r5620 4r5629

4t5270 415280

4L5245 4t5246 41.525r 4 1 5 23 5 4]-5256 4r5257 415 58 2 415259

4r5579

Page 3