Free Response to Motion - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM

Document 792-8

Filed 04/16/2004

Page 1 of 13

00081

, ..... ":"';"".

~& ..

. ..
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM

' .

....

-'

.'

. "

".- -

Document 792-8

Filed 04/16/2004

Page 2 of 13
~:I

NAc mstorical Spent Fuel Shipments Through Aprlll999
;Wpmcots by Truck

Nnmber of

Origla.

Destination
INEL
GE- Va11ecitos

Assemblies .

Shipment NttmbetoC Date' ShipmentS
1977

PhDadelphia Electric Peach Bottom 2 . PubUcServie Electric & Gas Hope Creek Rochester Gas and Electric
RJ!. GUiDa .

5 rods

1993
1973 1914 . 1976 1985

NFS
NFS . NFS' R.E. Ginna

Ginna
RE. Ginna

NFs .
NFS South Carolina Electric & Gas

R.E.Ginna
ABCL-Chalk River
6 rods .

1986'

V~c. Summer
f (tthem California
. .4

Summer Edison

19'0
1995

AECL-ChalkRiver
MSF MSF MSF MSF
ABCL-Chalk River
6 rods

)) Onofte 1
Onofte 1

1976 1977

San Onofte 1 .
San Onofte 1

1978
1980
1991

Union Electric Callaway

Virginia Electric Power Co. Suny
Wisconsin Electric Power Co. Point Beach 1 Point Beach 1 Point Beach 2 Point Beach 1 Pomt Beach 2
Point Beach 2'

Battelle Co.

1983

Point Beach 2 Point Beach 2 Point Beach 1

NFS MSF MSF MSF Battelle Co. MSF MSF* MSF
PNL **

1 + 16 rods 1 + 16 rods

1974 1975 1975 1975 1976

i976
1976 1977 1978

First shipped to Battelle Columbus Laboratories, then to EMAD. i,rst shipped to NPS , then to PNL.

00082

.......,. " .. ,

..

. . ' ..
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM Document 792-8

.,

::. '" '
Page 3 of 13

~. ..... . ..

Filed 04/16/2004

~b.

NAc

Hi~torical

Spent Fuel

Shipments Through

Aprlll999
Sblp...ent . Number Date Shl~ments ;
1983 1983

)bjpments by Truck

Number of

Oripa
WISconsin Electric Power Co.

. Destination

Assemblies

MSF NFS NFS

MSF

. Point Beach 1 Point Beach 1 Point Beach 1 Point Beach 1

:13 .

101

1984' 1984.
1985

101

Point Beacb I'

PNL

00083

..

:)(
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
0 . . ..

. . ...
Document 792-8

.. _. . ..,
Filed 04/16/2004

,. "

. . .. . :.

0 . . o.
'0.

Page 4 of 13
. "0 0 .. ..,
. 0 .. '

NAC mstorica1 SPentFuel ShipmentS Through April 1999
Shipments by Truck

Number of

Shlp~ent Number.
. Dat
$~lplU~DtS

Origin
AtJamsas Power and Light

Destina(lon .
B&W-Lynchburg
AECL-Chatk River
Battelle Co~ Calvert Cliffs

Assemblies

ANOI
.ANO 1

6 rods 7 rods

1987
1990

:Baltimore Gas and Electric
Cat v crt . Cliffs

rodSt,

19~1
.-INEL

l1attell~ Co.

rodst, *19841N
LI-1/2 Calvert Cliffs PNL rods t, *1985 ll2 Calvert Cliffs ABCL-Chalk River 6 rods 1990 INLI:'1I2Carolliiil

l~I-

Power and Light

;:;bwick2
" . Jbinson 2

Battelle Co, ABCLt

Rob~on 2 8 rods*
. 10 rods

1981

1986
1973 1974 1976 1978 1982 1983
1983

Commonwealth Edison
Dresden 1

Dresden 1

DreSden 2
Dresden 1
Zion 1

NFS NFS Battelle Co.

120

INEL
Zion 1

Battelle Co.
Zion 1

Battelle Co. Zion I Battelle Co.
Dresden 2/3 B&W-Lynchburg AECL-Chalk River

1 + rods

BattelleCo. NFS
Quad Cities Byron Dresden 2
Quad Cities

5 rods

B&WLynchburg
GE- Val1ecitos

6 rods
6 rods

1984 1985 1986 1991 1992 1993

ABCL = Atomic Energy of Canada, Ltd, B&WLynchburg= Babcock & Wilcox, Lynchburg, VA Battelle Co. == Battelle, Columbus , OR E= Combustion Engineering = Nevada Test Site Vallecitos = General Electric, California Research Facility .. ~L = Idaho National Engineering Laboratory MSF= General Electric-Midwest Storage Facility, Moms, IL ~1fS~N~c1ear' Fuel Services , West VaHey, . PNL ==' Battelle, Pacific Northwest Laboratories

* Shipment of rods not equal to an assembly t UnlmoWn number of rods shipped t First shipped to lNELthen to AECL

00084

.,. ...

..' .. '

' ..

, . ' . ,., . .
Document 792-8

, , .' . -

.'

Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM

Filed 04/16/2004

Page 5 of 13

NAb HistoricalSpent Fuel Shipments TbroughAprll1999
tbipmeIrts .by Truck

Number or
Destination
B&W-Lynchburg.
ABCL-Cha1k River

. ngJD'
Ar1caniu Power anil Light

Assemblies

. Shipment ' ~umber , $~ipmeo.ts Date. .
1987 1990
19$1 .

ANOI ANOI

6 rods 7 rods

. .1

~al~ore G~ and ~Iectric
Calved CIiffs
..
Battelle Co~

B~Ue

Calvert Cliffs

rodst: rodst,*I9841N
LI- i/2 ~vertCliffs PNLrods t, *1985

. 1

. INEL'

lNLI- 112 ~veit . Cliffs ABel-Chalk
River 6 rods 1990

INLI- 1I2 Caronna Po\ver and Light

Rob~on2
sWi~k

Battelle Co.

8 rods*
10 rods

1981 .

. jbinson2.

. AECLt
. NFS NFS Battelle Co,

1986
1973 1974 1976'
.. 1978

Common,, ealth 'Edison
Dresden 1 Dresden 1

120

Dresden2
Dresden 1
Zion 1

INEL

Battelle Co.

1982 .

Battelle Co.

. Zion 1
. Battelle Co.
Zion 1
Dresden

1 + rods
. 1

Zion 1 .
Battelle Co. NFS
Quad Cities

213

1983 1983 1984 1985

Byron Dresden 2
Quad Cities

B&W-Lynchburg ABCL- Chalk River B&W Lynchburg
GE- Vallecitos

1986
S rods
6 rods 6 rods

1991 -1992 1993

AECL = Atomic Energy of Canada, Ltd. .
B& W Lynchburg = Babcock & Wilcox,

Lynchburg, VA

Battelle Co. = Battelle, Columbus , OR
P-:~= Combustion Engineering

* Shipment of rods not" equal to an aSsembly t Unknown number of rods shipped t First shipped to INEL then to ABCL

,.;-.i,:))J)=NevadaTestSite. -../Vallecitos = General Electric, California Research Facility

.6L = Idaho National Engineering Laboratory
MSF = General Electric-Midwest Storage Facility, Morris. TT.
NFS' = Nuclear FuelServices~ West V~ltey, -NY PNL = Battelle. Pacific Northwest La'boratories

00085

.-.'..." ......--

:. '- '

..

,.
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM Document 792-8

, ,,

".

..
Page 6 of 13
'.. 0

-.-.. .
,0 . .

Filed 04/16/2004

NAC mstorica1 Spent Fuel Shipments Through April .1999

Shipments by Truck

0 rigIa

NuDiberor
Destination.
Assemblies

Shipment Date
1980 1970 1919
1981

NumJJero Shlpmenb

Connecticut Yankee APC Jladdt'm Neck . Dalijrland

Battelle Co.
SavanI18b River

Lacrosse.

M$F

Lacro~

MSF

~crosse
B& W~Lynchburg
Oconee 3

Dnke Power Company
Oconne 1 . B&W-Lynchburg
Oconee 1

B&W-Lynchburg
Oconee 1

B&W-Lynchburg
Oconee 3

Oconee 2
Oconee 3
)onee 1 r Jnee 1

Oconee 3 Oconee 3

134

o&W-LYnchburg
Oconee 2 .
Oconee. 1

Oconee 2 B&W-Lynchburg Crystal River 3
Oconee 3

1975 .1975 1976 1976 1976-1978 1977 1971 1978

. 1

134

Oconee 3 Oconee 3
Oconee 1

Oconee 3
Oconee 1

B&W-Lynchburg.
Oconee 3 Oconee 3 Oconee 3

B& W -Lynchburg

Oconee 3
Oconee 1&2
McGuire 1

1978 1978 1978- 1979 1979 1980 1980 1980
1981
13'

Oconee 3
Oconee 3

Oconee 1&2
McGuire 1

. 284
201

Oconee Oconee
Oconee 2

Oconee I & 2
McGuire 1 Oconee 1 2&

3*

294

Oconee Oconee
Oconee. .

McGuire 2
Oconee 1 Oconee 1

2 & 3*

2 & 3.
12 rods 3 rods

Oconee McGuire cificunit(s) not known
' \.C assumption

McGuire 1

B&W-Lynchburg B& W-Lynchburg

1982 1982. 1983 1983 1984- 1985** 1984- 1985** 1985 1986 1987 1986 1989 1994

284
201 6** 294** 21**
. 81

00086

," ".

.-

. '.
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM Document 792-8 Filed 04/16/2004

.'
Page 7 of 13

, ,. ' .;. ...--

NAC mstorica1 Spent Fuel Shipments TIuough Aprlll999
;IDpments by Truck
Number of

Shipment
"Date

Numberof
Shlpnieids

Origin
JES UtJ"Uties
Duane Arnold

Destination.
GE - Pleasanton, CA
Turkey Point 4 TUrkey Point 3

Assemblies

1 can

~998

Florida Power and Light
T1idceypoint 3 Tudcey Point 4
Tudcejr Point 3

189
. 272'

1976 1976-1977
1978 . 1977- 1978 1979 1979 1981
1981 1983

189

Battelle Co.
Turkey Pomt 4

Turkey'Point 3
T1idcey Point-)

272

Turlcey Point 3 . Tudcey Point 4
Turkey Point 3.

TudceyPoint 3 . Tuikey Point 4 ~rtey Point. , Nuclear

EMAD EMAJ)* Turkey Point 3 Turkey pojnt 4 Turkey Point 4 Turkey Point 3 Turkey Point 3
NFS NFS NFS Battelle Co.

. 168

168

. 1983
1983

sterCreek 1

1973t
136

Oyster Creek 1
Oyster Creek 1 Oyster Creek 1

1974

1975t
rods
7 rods

1981

Georgia Power
E.L HatCh
Maine Y aukee

B&W-Lynchburg

1992 1974 1974 1986 1994
1981 1983

Maine Yankee Maine Yankee

Battelle Co.
PNL**
GE. Vallecitos

7 wds 30 rods

Nebraska Public Power District. Cooper
Cooper Northern States Power Co. . Monticello Monticello Omaha Public Power District
:Fort Ca1houn Fort Ca1houn

control blade

Battelle Co, Battelle Co.

rods

Battelle Co~ Fort Calhoun

23 rods
23 rods

1982 1983

J shipped to Battelle Columbus Laboratories , then to EMAD.

00087

Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM

Document 792-8

Filed 04/16/2004

Page 8 of 13

00088

;j\:. . ..

, '.

,

..

,.

',..",. , ,
Document 792-8

, "

. . ,.., , . , . . . ,~

., .

..'" ' ..,.' ..
to .

' "

,.--:~ ;,\

Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM

Filed 04/16/2004

Page 9 of 13

. ;M

:l~

~ ADA FROM Y
:Site Rail Spur.
. Clos~st Rail

None
The Hoosac Tunnel is 6.7 mileS southwest of site. . Hoosac' has . been used to move large equipment, inclliding the reacior vessel.

A~s:
.

Rail Carrier:
Route to Rail AccesS:

Boston & MaineRailroaci (B&MRR); SpringfieldlUilroad :
HeayY haul via Shennan Reservoir Dani Road (O~3

River Road; then south 6.4 miles to the rai1road.cro$singat~oosaC'
mites). to

tunnet .
B &MRR
CP System

Rail Route . to Albany:
National Route to

Troy, NY Troy to Albany, NY
Albany. NY to chicago, IL Chicago to Kans~ City; KS Kansas City to Amari,llo. TX . Amarillo to D~ggert, CA Daggert to Blue Di~ond, NY
Blue Diamond to Destination

Hoos8.C. MAto

Nevada:

. ConRail Union Pacific

Union Pacific/Santa Fe
Union Pacific .

Union Pacific/Santa Fe To be constructed

00089

Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM

Document 792-8

Filed 04/16/2004

Page 10 of 13

00090

.\"~:~ .," . .

.,
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM .4 Document 792-8 Filed 04/16/2004 Page 11 of 13

pA. T A AND OTHER ~ORMATION CONSIDERED IN

FORMIN~

Facility Interface Capability Assessment (FICA) Study, NAC International.
. 2)'

Near S~te Transportation I1iftastructure (NSTI) Study, NAC Int~ationa1.
.certificate of

Compliance fQr Radioactive Materials Pa~kages,. NAC' Storage Transport

Cask, rev. 2, March 25, 1999. .
Safety Analysis Report for NAG Storage Transport Cask, rev. 12 , April1999
The ShipmentofSpent Nuclear Fuel: How Big a Project Does the United States Face?,

FOCUS Nuclear Fuel Cycle Quarterly, Issue 39 Wmter 1997, as updated, MlchaelJ.

Smith.

00091

Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM

Document 792-8

Filed 04/16/2004

Page 12 of 13

00092

. .' '. , .,

. ., ' "

..

&:.

:

.. . .
. ,.
. .

. .,

.~ :: . .

Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM

Document 792-8

Filed 04/16/2004

Page 13 of 13

Ivan E Stuart,

Vice President Special Proiects
experience in the nuclear

Mr. Stuart has more than 3 0 ye~s of
indu.,t:t;y. As a 'senior
Energy Project).

consultant to NAC, Stuart isleadingNl\C'

participation in the Wyomins spent fuel storage initiative

(Owl Creek

Previous ly, Stuart served as senior vice president of EnS

(Engi~eering

Design Services), matiaging all. of, NAC' s

~gers.
. company' s

technical staff ' and proje9t Stuart oversaw the NRC licensing function . for all of the nuclear fuel storage systems, fuel transport casks and~uel

consolidation systems. This included the concept development, detailed

design, NRC licensing, testing, procurement, fabrication follow and
acceptance testing of these products. Specific project accomplishments
. ,I

include:
NAC-STC Dual Purpose 26 PWR Assembly Cask Design and Licensing

Project.
. ~C-I26 S/T Storage Cask Fabrication Project for Almaraz Nuclear
Station in Spain.

NAC-I28 SiT Storage Cask Fabrication Project for Surry Nuclear Power
Station in Virginia, United States.

Design of the DPT Dual Purpose Cask for 21 KWU fuel assemblies for
the Trillo Station, Spain.

Design of the NAC-STC (VVER) Dual Purpose Cask for 85 VVER-440 (Russian design) fuel ass~mblies.

Design of the NAC-

~C Transport Cask under U. S.

DOE contract.

Design of the NAC Fuel-Pac fuel consolidation system.

NAC-CTC Advanced 21-element design Transport Cask for DOE-OCRWM that
included advanced

A~RA hydraulic lid

design.

Previous Experience
00093