Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB
Document 42-9
Filed 08/15/2008
Page 1 of 8
EXHIBIT 8
((~~
~
Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB
lnired States
Document 42-9
Filed 08/15/2008
., -.~
(. .
Page 2 of 8
Forest
Deparrrnem of .-\griculture
Semce
Sacramento Ranger District
Cloudcroft NM 88317 U\
(505) 682-2551
P.O. Boi: 288 _ 'f )
File Code: 2230/2210/2670
Route To:
Date: May 5, 1998
Subject: Amendment to 1998 Anual Operating Plan for the Sacraento Allotment
To: Sacraento Grazing Association
RETU RECEIPT REQUESTED
c/o Jimy Goss, Pres.
475 Weed, New Mexico 88354
Box
CERTIffD-
clearly understood the followig provisions are to be included as an 1998
In order to insure that Forest Service policy regardig grg use in riparan exdosures is amendment to your cUrent
Anual Operatig Plan (AOP). The riparian exclosures on the Sacraento Allotment
listed below ar offcially excluded from livestock grg activities:
Mauldi Exclosue - Upper Wills Canyon, Sect. 29 T. 17S., R.l2E. Hubbell Sprigs ExcloSu- Hubbell Canyon, Sect. 32 T.17S., R.12E. Western Ripanan (Kgsbury) Exclosure - South of Wright Spr., Sect. 35 T. 18S., R.l IE.
Bluff Sprigs Exclosure - Penaco River. Sect. 17 T.17S., R12E.
Upper
Sacramento Late Éxclosure - Sacraento Lake, Sect T.18S.; R. I IE. Penasco Exclosure - Headwaters óf the Penaco", Sect: i 1 and.i 4 T.17S., R ii E. ..
\
- A' map of each of the exclosures listed above is anached to inure all paries are fuy aware of
their location. fences is the resonsibility of
mai in the exclosue). - . . .
Rio Penaco Road and the Sunspot Highway durg .pase moves, but are not to -re-
(Livestock may be drven across tle nortern comer oftbs exclosuieadjâeèriùá thè.
Every effort must be made to keep livestock out of these areas. Maintenace of
the exclosure
the Forest Servce. . We will make ever eftòrt to -inure these fences are properly maitained. ft is your responsibility to tae prompt action in removig live-. stock from these areas when they are found inide an exc1osue. Failur to do so is a violation .
of the Terms and Conditions of cancelation of
your g:g permt which could result in possible suspension or
your grg permt.
received in Januar (copy attched) and the above amendments are .'hereby made
The AOP you
a par of the Term Graing Pennt on the Sacramento Allotment". I must also inform you that failure to sign and reru a copy of your AOP, which you have failed to do in 1998 and 1997, does not diminsh its authority or direction in any way. - AOP's :ire not required to be signed by the pennnee. Failure to comply with the provisions Contained in AOP's is clearly a violation of
the Terms and Conditions of your grg pert. .
æ
Caring for the
Laed and Servn!! Peoole
Prinled en Reç"lced ?3~
v.
8001693
Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB
Document 42-9
Filed 08/15/2008
Page 3 of 8
'appeal rights under 36CFR251 if
not attable. .
r encourage your cooperation in this matter. but r want you to know as a permittee, you do have you feel instrctions contained in AOP's are uneasonable or
Ifyau have any additional questions abôut the above matter, please contact Rick Newman or
Mark Cadwallader at (505) 682-2551. .
Ì\1AE. GOODWI
Distrct Rager
cc:
. Forest Supervisor
ltL~
I concur: M.Caçiwallader 05(05198
D2:M.Cadwallader:cm: 05/05/98
SG01694
Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB
Document 42-9
Filed 08/15/2008 /-.
(
Page 4 of 8
l:~f~~¿l~*~~~ifJllØl!~~;~:;~~~I:I~ .. ..../'...1.. .,,:,:~../../...,.' ..' '-'. .,....lj~,?~,/,:/;./,~~ . 1/. .,'I.,.',..--..'~" .~~
,.;;::..:,.....'.;.;;- .-"t':~'Ç(.'(./(' ./::./-;;~g:./.;/.: ..' .....,. ..' --- r. :: ./: ./ l(/,-:~., '-' .,,..! .. --....:/..,'-'., .~~.~::;;... '..,./:. "''''' - ~-;;"-=-".". ..' -.:....,, /'~r='-;"'".'r :: í :,- /,/, ~;._.." ~ .\.: .:. ~ I, . .' . .:'. ,,';'.' ~.-- . .:,. -;, _;., . '. :: ._ ~~. ...~;Z ~,~..: ..;'~.~~¡j¡; fl ,/':-:
..\ '.'... " . :. -:.. --.. '.:'~~;:';-" ~~ ;,,:,~/.,,: ':...~~.."::;,: . ......: ¡:. ','..'.--.-:,. /:;':;'r.' ,"'--,,///1//.,., ..' .. ."/!~-¿:'///-'" , ..-- _..........V~.:.1"0~/, ./ '-.: ".._,.',.~
. ,.. .....".. '....:.-. .'--, .."~ -:. , .. .~.,--.~ ...~-... .... . . " ,--' "/"., "-.....://r¿/'
~fi~:j.'.~~i~~l£~lJ~î~JI
2i:: y! :' ~) :.. :-;~-:~t~. ~~/::; /' .::.d;;'f:::,:~ ';;iÍí~:?~~'-; ., ,i.f,:; i: ;
' . ". ;'''_-' -' / .--.. -- .'-" ._'- ',.J, ' . -' ../,. , .." ,-., ..' . lí i.: i' /,,. '?;_~ '". ,
-,..-:-.. .. ~.."...,.,.:,..,'- '--....._~.----/.~~~ ..~.,~. ...... !!!"''',//.Ç: -:~.', ..",;- ,.... ..-"".-_.\..... . ...' \\,. ......',.....'. -:__". '. . .~;--:.:..:',....~.",0 ,1,:...'/,.,..'r~;/:.... :;":" ,. " ..''' f':~,. 'l" ....... ." .-~-~:.-;:""'... ...... ""',: ..;ii .ili ".,,'l~./'III';'I::l" : .. . ..,.., I' , .... .:;~'"'' ,"......._.:._,.. .....,,'..' ., -_~..:..~--'/,; 1";.1;'1.";.,;.-;'..".......' '. ~ .'_. ".: ,.. ..';: .~- i;ì.:....;..',' '. ". ..... ... ',' '."~--_'_".' .' ...'1". !ií//,/~'Ç:;;'//'// / ~:;.;:/ .' ..... . '.~ \. :it.~~L.:'.'2è:::,: ~T':,;! ~ _......, ':: ,../..;--':'.')//11 Ii;, ! ì '. .' / ( "..'.,. _.,'., ......, i" .;. ..../~'. ,'.. '.1 '. . \ . . '. " ....\; ;i.; ;, ,: -~~.~,:, ß ~ (1,!:;;i*i;';;X:~~Y;.;
':-". ..~..~',..:,:.: / "-:¿:/, " . ~.;..J ; ~..::,:.::'. '- ~':;~.L/?//,." '. -:~.~"~.~~~.,.. '.. /.'í;;,~f1:~X-';.~..// .:.~,~\! \
(X(K?:r'/ ,~: \:
... .' '-,' :-.:"...,,,..: ,,,,,.~-: ......../ ,....~...,..;¡.. -~....,.~..,_Ii'i¡!"i',%'/;//-- '.: __' ........:
.._~.;-: - ._~:~~:~.::..::;):;w ;\:.~&tniæÈ4?~i í :--, . .~~::~.::2:.~~~,~\ \lì.~\(~\\(\(~.G\,)./.,_.\LS i
',. -... ,'" ,..,-....=--'".,... ':' ': ',,, .-- ~ /.- -/-:.0.ij~ ~I l i ,.,..:' ':.:~\l.'\ i, ',\ '~.\"'.,\~\ìi.i (I' \, , ! ~. . ". " ......"":.¡'. f' - ~,/ , o-,:~¿:. .' . .-=..',..'." I.. '\\' \ . ¡ ,,. '-
.....--- .' .... '.' ",'. ,~,..~" .,-=~~" /""%1;;::';\\"r::~,:,,,,:,,\1. e.i\1ì!\\\~~\\\\ \ if I r",~. ! r
, . ,. "--:,~...r-'~V/'-:/""'.//." .'.\ "".'., ~I\''''\\'''\''\'' ..--! .)11./
.. .. -. _.-:'// -. V,k..::._.. ~~.. '. ~__.' J. .,111 ~j " ",,,'\~,'\. ./ r-
',-",-,). .i ,;~-..W'~~. ! t .~,/;:'!':).~'i .~.~~ "~£ø- /::' ~r---~f..,'i¡)!iJ)j. ~Y' \\~\)'\\,\\\::'\\~~\:. ....\.\:.~_
," -:....q--..~..- ..,~..'" . ...) '-/ ,.- .'. , .. '. .1. -:0/:, i,/'/" '; '. .. i.-.' '..~, ,-"--/?/;;.:ï!!.Zf.... /:"'/.'"2::¿:Yll/:/// \ . . f~::...~?-:' ..: -. ==~! .:ff!¿;? i//~"!.,', ./ " /.,/.-\ \i í-.,"'//,.,'....:..:r'%;¿~~'" ...'),; ¡"'.\~::~ i. " ... /1. ?;~::'.~' ....%" 1)\1
' -",..~; Ii .- ... --K::.. -.. I( ¡¡ !! -'.;"....' '.'~ , i, ,..';-:;.1,'.. .'.. .'1/ i .. ....-../:..:~',"/.'//./... ./ ,"--/ ;'
:-.~~~~~..~~rfk~~~Y~ -ef;n~~':/';'-~~;..--::~;;i;;%%:~:~:" ~~ /~lJ)~~'))))))) !. -. . ?' C
.:.;;/ '~.) .:.....:. %-/';::::-,1'./.. ".~ ///' // \....~.......~-.\..:....\\..\ll:.! ,',:%ßW~i/ L:~.__/ -../ 1 .1
.' / / (-' \,' ''li:.... -~.""-- : ii r ,-.....\/.ý'ø" "~. .... I.......:.....~."i~.¡/"-.. J' -. ¡, I! '.' i,--.'. ~/'....
,"_..' ."..,/., ¡,';. ", \ .....~ .~, :~/./ ". . 'i/.:',~;-~,:,; "'''.'Il/ililii / _ ..\' ,'r- ,~-:.
.-.:/ ~""'. /,:,~:.=-,'.. "..'. ; ,"/,' ,,'.. -- '.\." //.--'~.:\\\\"I:~/!li l. , .. -: .,.. r": Ai/i¡.':,.: J./:'~/,-:.: ...ú;/i//-,I)I.¡1,.'/)~.-:!":;./....¡..i ....i:.!l!'úy/,,i,.I/x:i~~ '::~ ,-;.'; -' "/.',..'. -'.....' '-/ '- .. /,~/ /./ / ...., " ..,"'..: ..-z,',.,;:.,;. J¡..hZ'I¡¡;/l/t' ) ~:\ ~. 3.~.-
' '/'. '. l . :.. , ,.' - / l i . I./,. ...',._, I. .',! 1--.. ! ) i..' '!:r" :".:....... .;r:r~?,.., r. _. ~ _ / .. __
.. . .,....., ~ -- 1.'1 '~"'-'-//,l., ;:~~/ .,....,1:, \/.. ~.. II' 'rr-..,--".-:~
· :L ~1)j?H;:~ .' .::'ç-:;';:i~liF: ~~1::;:Ø:Jff(,(5;.;:E.c0::~;/;i
'-"¡ "'" '..,/,,- '/,... ",' , ...,., -~, ii\..;::?:,.... ,._.~, " '~"r.~ //,':::-;:':-3f-::::::?/ljí¡?5~'" ",..//iVr/l .',..~?~..:;/? /:(/'//_~¡..~:-~';l/'~~:"'.,-'...~,(~~::.?;;:::/,'o'/ "~2./~~.. /~./../:~~ :///.':/'/ ...:...¡:¡'//i::~ ...:~t!'X'~' 'C'/.:-rO' Is~e" .;:~''"I.
./ .. " ,.' ",:". \ ., .. ." ¡ ::.otl ll e:L . .' .;, ,E; " .; I ' U i ". :: ' /,
. ~.~' ';=:~".'" ~.
---..~ ~/\.. ~ r- ~-- .., ",
" ....; ..-..,
.~ _..... .-..... ,./ ~.
,.
)~. " \~ ; .- );~._) ..' ::-..,.,:....:.i:.....'.,..:'.:"._,'.~~..',,'.....'.Y~..~:.:~~.':.~_(__i..~~'~.." ~:\\. \ ~2./¿i;\ :-/t?r\ j .;~/~
;~~r~;;~--~,~~: :~ .-' - -~, -- :~,\\ / '~:'~¡1('::~~
SG01695
Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB
Document 42-9
Filed 08/15/2008
Page 5 of 8
~ \. !,
SG01696
Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB
Document 42-9
Filed 08/15/2008
Page 6 of 8
". '\ ......... . ....:
.,
\', .. . /.
/,Ä , ""', '~..' ,;.,/., ';' '~-_, "'r '-:,~, ~;,.'...=O'l ",'
.~?~~;5;:~~~~:i~ttj~~~:Z~â\l¡ -"-/ "', ~"""", ~" ~'....~~~.b:-,=,;,,=..-cv'''='''=~_, """'" ~ '..,' '" ~
:. ',\: ~,; ;: \ ","$,2''',,,¿;;..,,/. .-='" ~~%.~~ .. ' j~~'~)"¡)¡H -, ',,,-"::;,,',,,. "'''I'~' ....',.~..,;'//, / ~:~~-=ø, "'~,,:;,
','/--- ' """"-----~~-=,~, ,,', ~ ,''''''
::~:::~).. '- -',', ~;.:.': '~CÇ~, , t,'~~~k= "~', , ' .:: ~ ='~ " '~'. 'V,,",',;\. ,.'.i;: "",,''',;',''c '/i~~j,/~\,~~~: ¡, :,;':' '_, ,,'-'~' ,~ d.~~;\, -:' :'-'\::~:~\\~:;;f;;;;;:;:,-;~~; ,X" "~;;__ ";', -,,', '.-\ d\,'t;,
- ''-' '..../;" "/'" . "0~"..,/, _=":'~'-==%_""'" =-~,.."",, :', ~':', " ":~",\i ,:';;~~ / _-' _." _ ~", '"--:",' ,'.,....."" (.....~'\. ,..~::;£.;... -- ,;... '.~',..'''"=,,=~.-;.". ~ i, '!', "" " , '\,. '",'M.." , \~"':'::::-"--.':~'::'~"""". ì . . \,=..~~, -. ,..~.#.. '0""" ,,', ~, ~-'''-='''''~ 3"~""""'."\"~',': ~ ~. .~~,; .: (_ -,,',', '~"","\"'¡' ~~'~~~""':'''''':''''~'''''''0-,.."" _
-"'''', ',''''.'', "-~~' ,~,~,"" 'v,,,,,,
"~,i-Ø:'':-' ' .' ~-, /,-.'??, -"if,.-'7"'~ -"~--' ~~' ~"'J~/" "::~~..-*~~.~~j\('*V~:_0':":/~\\(~J"'~~~;::~J)JJ)!jll - , """ "("--,' ,'~& ~ -~&/~ ~~ 1,)7'" " ','/ '.-= '"
.. '- "'" ',,,~~,, .., ~ /-"'/~' ý"~~ ,,~,"". /0/0,,,=
""'','
..-':::/:..¡,!. ~"'~"'~"'ù",; , """, ' ~9i ø!'?///H~~ :.
' ,,:~&/í!': \~~~j?,~~~:::,¿~,::.", !~):;iJ ,; .: """:'_;""":'" ", ",~_ / ,~~~-;:i#îif:~ '.r....~'".\...~ :.¡ " =~ ",'=---A:/- .",' ,/';w,//,".-', .. '',/A" '.-'-:. '.-:."" ~'. .-.--~'-: -'.''', ~..~~..; '..~-.;;, ~"~~ /;:"',,~, '~-%/.~'7r :: '"''~'/~''.'.'''.,''--'' '~?''':..:/~_... -: .I;;~ :,/1,.;.:;:., ~"'..;- ..' r- ø~,,:~ // , ~/'//'/"':.':""~;~"'''0-%~' ''/,-- "-"" ~ ' , ""'~ /.; " , '~/// 7~.. '" '.. ~,,/, r-~,/ '/"'--""""-"=. "~ '-~ 'h'ff/'/." .:.~"'!/i¡f/:'~'~~Z~~~~./;,;~~~.~"" "'~%.'--'-...~~:~'~f':G-J~~/~
~ - 2- '\ ,~:.' . . 'i\ i. ;,i;~,'¡;.:::?(- ~;.~~J\;;~i r-
""'~-','''' "';''/''~Y''''' ""'~,=- "'..,'1 - Y//".,
' ''''/1 i' :'::,": ' '.v. 'i'iJ.'''Y', ': ,I), :-~''',.., ',"/; #"/ ;:.. y;" ¡: :,;11 ,// ,=~¿: =---:¡,v..
~.:/--.... ::..~:.. '::i.'.II':'" ........:;~.:_~";~...:...::.!.:'.. ~ .///:'. .;.,:,;./.._~~~~... .... -- ',,",",', .. i.":iil .'// .-::...:.;.:;'..,.. .'i"~ -----.... / _-. ,'~ .~/,.--~--~..=""~r~ '-~ :/,=:.:. ""\" .,i.~:, r- _..~~..-...-:.-..... :.. . ';;'1 1/ '::~~=~"'~)~J""'~~"_~;:/~~-, """', -"', ''''''"""",=----,- ", '.::, /ó- '~"'''''''~''', /.,.'11.' ? ""., ~ "-% :,,':, i/, -:.;i.:.:\""''';;1'''';''=-_, ','/ '/ù",.., ..,~__--~''''''--~~,Y/d_ ,~ ,', I'i".~" " ,",""" "'-- ' """"/;?,/i;, 'i!Y';':,~_,.. ~":'./ '" _:5,'/://=-~!/,ú","= "'",, í.91!'!1~ '~/",-",,, ''"'''''~'' '. \'.' ',~',~ --~ "Ø".,',~,'''f/- ~//f/~
' ("/_'" "
~0f~c~'Æi:j¡KJ:~'¡"Wi'?:i'! 'v~'/:1/~ ~ :.,~, ";:'~.!'ii/ '.:',''--..:. :::;~:::~,,~;;. '¡¡I'I/'i:::~ ~~~~"-/~-;/;/:/ '-:'~-':~~.._~:.L._~ ~,,:,," ';'d, '~, '-", '~""'l " '.""" =æ:t",/,,,,,,,~. '/,
~~~~-,'~-:;"J ¿~~~''//''~'''1'/"2=~;?i I,: ¡.:/'?'--, , ~'" //- "',Fw.,,p/= ',", ~..~,"" .. ~,,,O' 'Ii" ,///:.=.':/1.:;,(-''rr'?/~ ',,, \'N ,0 ~ ,-,~--:,"....~+.~\.i.lli)/A, '/',......,:'.,/! ...-~~..z~~ ~~~~~~t:~ \j¡II~WI(LQQJI~
~::-; . ~:. .:~:? . Í'?'~PV~~*i)(l-~
~.'.~/./..\ .¡I~i:~:~~:ß~,,/ ~ '~"'/' -L '//f~~.." '", '.. , i-,';""- '.;r.v~ '"r., ",' ~"""// :~-./:..;::~~;;~/: -:~4rß/."~.. /('/;:~.!i;.;:!: .'/1/.;:/ ':~;;~~?Æ"'i/ ';;/z~
. ';~;;~-, ,; "'b~'7 0í i (;7.§n~ ~-:;;/". ;;/;1'~:/. j;;;,-- '/:"//';';":: if",:*
~....::~ :'... '/,";./~,¡ ',- -,"~' ",,~, --- .' ~/_; .- ~'.-:::,/;il!i iJ..:.-.'.;. -'.;.--X.i:....::::...~'l/..~:--.. \~.. ,.0 ''''., . .:' 'ii ~'.'0-:-;;: \,.,~ /... " '..-".'.--,:'/......'f/' ,,'=,.._ ",," _._" " _\:""", ''', " "".. ',,, '-~', --- d",'",.. -,"'=b, "'..,=,,~ '~ '
~~~~As:r~,l~1~~~:,:~.2\':Y~\\\:~Gf!~::~r2r~~~~i
f-- '''',.", '. '-' '." ,', " ""'=_..,,,.. " """,' '.. ,,~' _ ' "', , ' _
;.L~b~l~1~l'1i;iD.qM~~"~t~tl;;fJß;: :::~~~:s0t~;) \~
SG01697
Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB .,7-" .
Document 42-9
Filed 08/15/2008
.'...:".
Page 7 of 8
\. .\
SG01698
..
Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB
Document 42-9
Filed 08/15/2008
Page 8 of 8
SG01699