Free Letter - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

I _ Case 1 :07-cv-00787-SLR Document 68 Filed 04/25/2008 Page 1 of 3
Stephen Lim , 5 __
Smartdevil Inc. D QE jg U $67
2156 Rousseau, Montreal, Quebec, H8N 1K7 Canada ""*~—~¥—»m.;2*** {
Tel: 514-823-9401 Email: [email protected] l jj
APR Q 5 TNQ
April 15, 2008 SUE
L. ROBlNc
U_ SON
Judge Sue L. Robinson S D'SmlCT JUDGE
844 North King Street, Lockbox 18
Wilmington, Delaware, 19801 USA
Re: Girafa.com Inc vs. Amazon LLC et al., Case No. 07-787-SLR
Dear Judge Robinson,
Since the last conference with your Honor, we contacted the plaintiff attorney to settle this but we were
offered 1) to stop our service immediately without financial damages, otherwise, 2) plaintiff will seek
financial damages and injunction. The plaintiff is unwilling to offer other alternatives.
Your Honor, we plea that you set aside the default judgment because we cannot afford to defend
ourselves financially. Smartdevil believes that the Girafa patent is invalid due to the substantial prior
arts obtained by us and other defendants. Additionally, the Girafa application for patent in Canada has
not been approved. Smartdevil offers an Internet service that is available globally for free download and
for fee. Smartdevil does not have any paid clients in Delaware.
Your Honor, we would like to be given the chance for the patent to be validated via pre-trial or trial by
the other defendants. Should the outcome be in favor of the plaintiff, we'II take the proper steps to
respect the laws of the U.S.
To date, we always showed our good faith in this case. Even as a small Canadian company without
attorney, we actively participate with other defendants in their joint defense counsel. We make
appearance to conference calls, discuss matters with the plaintiff attorney and spent months searching
for an US attorney without success.
As an Internet company that is present globally, we strongly believe in respecting laws of other
countries including the US. Laws such as copyright, taxation, patent, etc.. No doubt, patent litigation is
the most complex and expensive in the US, we believe the Court must have in place a way for small
companies like us to deal fairly in this environment.
Your Honor, please contact me to let me know what are our options.
Thank you fgxr your time and consideration.
I- .
. "i i i·
\`L 05 . ) `
ste

_ _ _ Case 1 :O7—cv-00787-SLR Document 68 Filed O4/25/2008 Page 2 of 3
ANNEXE 1
Smartdevil Inc. is a privately owned company incorporated in Quebec, Canada since 2001 without
external fundings. The company physically operates from home located ln Montreal, Quebec. We
provide web thumbnail images as a free and paid service over the internet. Due to the nature of the
internet, anyone from anywhere in the world is able to download our free images. The company has not
been profitable since its inception and remains a small business.

Y ~¢D 2 as - `_ `
1 >. C E -1-O; ·=— >·s ‘ ..0 - -
1 1 gg 3. 9 . ·C -OO787-SLR ¤ .-· Vw 1 =é1:%= é
¤_ 1 E 1g EE ~ /.•• 1 O4/25/2008 Page 3Eof E gg @1;%.;
.>• ` E"' N]; _E
1 g) `Q 1 @1 :1 1 1; E 5 ·T·? €~=—= 5
e CL D, 1 E Q = ’ ,,_ E 3 E ¥ E
u.1 1 E ¤ Eg ` m g
-i·> L1 ¤ -9 ..·; * >< W E
11 — "' --¤
1 1.. nig 1.1.1 5: 2 ~— x ~"’¤ ~ ·— ¤- *5, www
1 1 <¤ >·¤ ..- .,1 ¤. 1zig 81 EE ““"“ GK ~"§ ¤‘\'¤§ 5 gg
1%:1.* g1 EE :OO~§§1¥§€ 111 $8
I é- EL O 1 % Q ··¤*°° Lu 3 1.1.1 12 q3"*¤¤<·°$ F
13 °- 1 5, g .
1- e -. .. 2
1 Z 1 ?1§ 8 g-2
LL] qy cu E
if E 1 *1: .2 2 ig
‘V“ 1 §_`§ E 33
i 1 E 8 1*55
1 1 *3 41 S 5 52 1~ 1 . ·
S 1 E E.)? _VfU E tg I - Z
§; 1 O N1 1 X Q 5 qi 0 Q
11 1 to Lu v1 0,2 g. -3 :1 . . @
g 1 GJ Q vs; 4-» V! 7 r
Q1 >- 1 ~¤1 .11 gp 3 ¤ cu < Z 1.
V Z 1 '_ lh QJ
§; 1 K1 D. 1 xg: 2 3 gg: 3 =`I~u E
. 1 D- 1 wl; _ *· G O I V
1 a Q1 <1Z 1 " IS ¤ E °’ ·— ‘¤ I ——
1 O ¤-1-,1 0- E U 0 . O
i m1 1 gggg 5; 3 Ez E 5 I ,_¤
, ,..1 1 ¤.$ 5 "’ 5; “ j ` z Z
V $4 , ¤-.0; cu L I- Q ·"< c
11 ¤ 1 ¤ ¤ V1 % ~ ~1 ‘° q .1 ¤ G ‘; N
gz .,.,3 ;1_¤ E g ¤. ` —·
1 1.1 1 1 wv *1:1 - ` S Q
A .1 Lu 1 >2 D g Q E 8 E Q v• — F-
. 1 ’·' E *·‘ E " K" ¢
- 5 1 lh *1*2 ru W ru O *`
1 au w N-1:1 UV-: - S LLI
1; 1 — 3 cv Q, ¤¤ .,1 'U V1 —·-—— x
1; 1. Z 3 w ¤ >
V .1; 1 4, E Q, & CY"; Q: E 1 h'
1 ER gg gg g W g -I 0
1- 1 == 1% .:1 Z S E = g W
“ 1 0-* N1 L Va
55%% zz. .*1 q; Zi
1. J U =¤?¤'J—¤1 ~¤1 C 1 V}
11 ` 1 EEQQ ng •-· L
,_ _ > 1 ° X-• 3 =
. 5 ¤=V·¤V~# L"? K Q, j.
1 `I Q 1 X
. 1 1~ · . "
1 Q vs 1 %
J: O 1 `—3'
1* 1; B
1 E V. 1 .1
. 1 Lu 1 1.n
11 1— 1 S
4 11~ Q -E
1 171 1 ve .
g Q 1 E DEFACHHERE nmcuunz:1
· "* 1 E 4/ \·»
' . * 1 Q. -
.. é 2 1 ·
. 2 : 1 E Mn Q .
· 1 2 ... - gy 3
. 0 1.n .
3 0 rw 1.
1 1 1 S V1- Q. Q ‘ <
>~ — ..1 I- 1
E . - 1 2 _ (T) ·u.I
¤_ (_) G"
. 1 5. 1 g A § :1~ \ E 1
. 1 5 6-z 1—1 1- ,
`
1 .1 1.01 1 ; Q ,.1 " K Q 1'E
2 O1 1 2 j 5 QQ ·¤ 1.
~ ·i N1 1 é (C3 ? 1 S 1- 5
‘ Q -1 1 2 E CE , _ —_-_ E
1 ¤1 5 2 E 121 11 ==
lg V7 1 E G _h"\ 1
1 1 ·~ ¤ 1 2 S 111
Q 1- E r¤ ( "*w\ 1
u.1 "’ 7% Q 0
1 1 .1 Z] gg % - ` 1-1 R1 -
1. } 1 , E 1 2.1; 1,11..1 g g Q
'U — 3 1 ,
1 il D: 1 3 E -3 E x.) L6 1,1 1
. * 1 > cv Q2 Q
Â¥ U- :.: *5 C u 1, F
V 1 tn LH E 5 0 0 2; . ‘—’ g{ @$.*1
V M TE 2 3*2 QE S 5 0 H . FL ·
1 E wéé as .¤ ‘ 11 . ~= *5. —— V
. D- 41% °E1'.>~ EB -2 LE`] \1 é< 1 1
1.% ;g‘§% gg "··g `§.. i cs 3m W W.
`1 O~ ` `- g YG QE 1.11 Q. ·\3 Q 5 `·~
1 1 '( ¤¤ 0 .- lh U1 .1 . ~—1`
;1. X v¤.2?.r,0 <¤°;~ *1} 1,- ‘ ‘*`-
1 G, .. C E 1 \_/1 1;*1 x1
'*§ .YLf\ 1 ? gg § 5 S 5 o .-1**1 ; 1V\ * 1
VV¥ ··— 1 •\;l':;"·7;-E “’° 71 • vv 2 <§ 2 M Q
¤!—··——® 1 g.; 3 ua E vi 3 10 1 Q .
§ U 4:.1 ._N Qf Q Q`\ Q;
1 U'. z 5 g Q; 21 _g· , • § `U 1 . 5 QJ
1 °’ 1/·.E ¤¤ •·‘ —¤ g 1 '§ ~* Ep ‘
· ;;°` 1 " zi ¤= ·‘= ·· 3 ·¤ . xl . LJ : .1 "'~ -1
1 1:. _ ..· 1,. <¤ 0 ~¢,‘_ \ . . Qp- ··
. ><'¤ EE >. 5 E Q 9 E\,·1 1* V1 YQ 5 1 `
,,,7%-:1 ,% ,—;=. 2* 5 · ¤ 1 V1 ~— ° 3
1 g 5 §E gg g_ 1: ((3 1-
§1 gg; EE
g __z 1 SE 0 3 ; E GJ 1
2 tr cn 1 Z E ¤- 0 ¤ -¤
61 1 giigg % 8 : é @
5 1 § :.:1; § § E 111av1av111a1za11n.1.1v 111v1u11ssau.1
1 1
` 7
1 .1
1 /*V V V VVV V- -- V ·. . . . ...7,) ___, r_r_ __ f_ 777)*)*77*7 ` I —— rr 77***+ www V M *7*777777*
·. 3 3"33333+3‘V"V00V· VVVVV V

Case 1:07-cv-00787-SLR

Document 68

Filed 04/25/2008

Page 1 of 3

Case 1:07-cv-00787-SLR

Document 68

Filed 04/25/2008

Page 2 of 3

Case 1:07-cv-00787-SLR

Document 68

Filed 04/25/2008

Page 3 of 3