";§j,§'E° ““ mp
g%§T~<¢=v¤,Az s>s·7aw-woe, In M:!_____`¥i n/gu jcgpy
‘ NOV 1 6 mug
\M;ekqe!P_£\$$,1 °L@E‘v£;€ §JE§§8S;’“T
“‘"‘ » | E="*L.¤............ 5 uspuw
.__,° { Case Mm cxv ¢,>·;—n3·#*—¢—PHx—EHC—M$
FLPIINTIFVS SECOND AUDEUDMM TO PLAIMTIFFJS
QMV¤.\ueDP+2w$,’[n<;,,_e4deL3, I EESPGMSE TO ZDEr=er~>.m•J‘r‘s srccmn Menon Foe
me ¤ , I
Su•~1MARY ;]‘~LbG¤M:r~f‘r
Fi
’I’I¤.(n+{¤:,$R¤nn¤n |’|1{;\¤e| Cbrk, s¤b»»1{·}·.s. ·=Hm €e\\¤·.¤Z»·3 addenéum -|»c> Us respcmga
ae$e».Ae,.».+ V`cJu.aOpI*:¤ns’ Seceeé »·1¤+ip» mor Summary __]•.qd3;·•qzJ»·¤+. Pl¤.I.¤+:W wwlé
ijkava Cnekeaed +Ae cxkZR·`·|-.s e++e¢LzcE ·¢¤ =H»Ls aédendup. ·~·H¢» his response;
@,,5 were w+ i··. his posscssbn ..,¤+$I nnii November ‘8“`,5LOOS.
TM. ex\·$B{·\—; ¤.++ach2A are regerancaé 4c ln p\¤¤`·»+?N"s ¤—e•,5Pr;mSQ,,
Cee.4-r¢ver+J.·»j $+q+emen·>r O? i'ie.c.+s,'lT.5‘r. These "I¤AePeye{m·!— Raviewsh
he OPI-Tea .,52 Max:. M¤mI+e>r, & Crmea :, °Hw, Maricopa com`, Supeml
. § ;C¤u.r+ awe. cru.c:¤J 40 plcJn+Y££'s c¢x.s¢.
The 6100*1 Raxdew ?ep¤:·r+ G?x\·{·I¤·'{· K] Shews de[enA¤.n+ \f¤.\u<>.Op+I¤ns’
§,§c•var¤•.I\ ·P¤:`¤I·.wa +0 Provide. ¤d·aq·.¤¤,;l—a »4en+q\ hec¤,H-L care. and proper
§iQQWg`;lS»]»` de#grm:nq+»bn5 +o ·`+.s consumers.
'Vke, 3:05 `Revkw Rq¤¤r+ [ExLILH— L] skews deFe¤é¤m+ vq$eaDp~hbns'
§;§CO\'1+:»•1¤·L€& CQ¤*|\41`Q. h> pmuhla c.de?¤¤+¤. w»e·-ri-aj h.ecai<#m Come and proper
Cgfbi {lei-erm ;nq+e'anj ..
`mxesa Review Eepcr-I-s +2ncS -I-¤ S¥¤¤w -Huze wd! se·I··}—}e·:$ enc; w:J=zsPreq¤P
gégnsrejqré ¥¤r· °'-`Ww. $c»;e+y ané wq\;¤r·2. rp \/q\¤.zO?{·¢*¤nS' ccnsuwéri
holders pSqC.·»+1¤;fs claim ¢H¤q+ \/q{¤.eOp+{o»5f has ¤ pa{?
%.§qs€es$men+ ¤»·»c\ pmper SMI" e\»§IL{|H—y dw!-erM`T¤a+Y¤w·
2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC#HCE D0cum%nt°1:7%~ FiIed11/16/2005 Page10f2
E
I.
!§
pr ¤-e¤»s¤:>m·Jn\e, jury ._ Tp pr•.zsen·F-ed wZ•I£ 9-Ms evhience, woufé conclula ¤|4L¤+
'ii . ` .» .
i/*H»e.se rap;-;r4-*5 cure, med-ema.1 euiéevzca w\¤·cJ¤ prove. p\¤Jn+`.££ s Ql¤¢]m ¤3¤unS+
. ii,c\¢zCendqr1+ ·[·c• be -\-MMP,.
Pf¤.`I`¤+2£; r2$pc<;·\—Y·»\1Y re?u2S-X·~: =#»v·f“ WT: .¤:mr+ écmy \}cz}u€Op+_}`cms'
W7c·"’\}>f/I QJ g¢·
if %
_ Shannon Wl. Clark- |¤F`··¤+'· ·O•r0$·€
il
& Oni COP, WQUQA H!£|'}O$ C`€|-K,
Ccfby n']¤f|1&A H}[I)D.g MOT‘g`nj , ]
ii 1
if
@:2
`
g.
iw
l
1;
`_ase 2:03—cv—01344-EHC-HCE D0cument172 Filed 11/16/2005 Page20f2
ZL 0PSI
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 172
Filed 11/16/2005
Page 1 of 2
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 172
Filed 11/16/2005
Page 2 of 2