Z msec - mqsqn · s¤m+». nz Hq
>1¤0•& S. w·Ivv•0+ Rd-
1 #.0-B¤=< @Ué!c>&.· IU THE otnltrbb shares :>Is·ru¢·r cvuB.‘r
___"r'•»
j- 'V FILED __ LODGED
I ___RECEI\/ED __*_COPY
L WI I IQ I
OIYIYIDYI Icjwqe HQMHELQI I NDV 1 6
I ; CLERK L; g_‘IQ§gHIé3T COURT
I DIST I A IZONA I
—·- { Use Ne LI 6 **3***
PLAIMTIFPS RESPONSE TO pzrswmnmr vAI.u.•2<:•I>T10M.S’
i§%VCx`uQOp+Im$,1nQ- e4- cr`., I MOTIOrsJ T0 STRIKE AFFIDHVIT OV MICHHEL R08IM.SOM,
·( Dehéwdnwk,
I Lcsw
P|¤.?»+.°m,5L¤nn¤¤ m:d1azICIufI<, responds +0 AJe¤A¤m+ v¤'I¤.¤e0p+.`¤»·»s' mc-Hm 4¤ swika ¤¥Y:éc¤vH
L 2 m|.Cl1G€` Rvhhqscarh LCSW.
De-[evId¤m+`s m¤+€¤rI should be denied as TI- Qcils ~I¤ mee+ ·H¤a reqirrevnen-I-S ·|¤ _j·¢s{-Try
, mQ+;0H 40 IH. ¤.Adrr'{’JbYl> d€‘C€\'lédH"·`$ QI"SlA|1/IQYI+$ HH \"€¢?L(.:\`t'Y13 d€HI'G.’ G? W
Iv•·I0+¤:9vI +0 $‘H‘·:I<€.
. C ee upnn ¤ p¤F+y7S. u··u1+¤BYI. ¤r..··•.p.cm wlu. cvuI#¥`s own »}¤P+P¤.+·'v€ (KH`: :¤ur+ mq}, order ..
_ .s+r$cI
QI;-rL2.re·Y¤r¢=. shuié w+ Le s·|·r}c4¤en.
De-fevId¤n+ argues —H·»¤+ **1w. q,£$}4S¤u2·I· was déclasec} Beyond %.v. Msccvefy cu+o·p;
5IIé·¤+e and ‘|'|~zr`€£ct`Q Shcuu he si-r·TqkerI. This cu—3u»·»ugrI+ calls Bcccm;2 pI¤·'n·H£·F Is eXe•·wP{-
ljqxrom ?m'·H¤J dwkdasure requ}remen1$ under ReIQ8»(¤ (¢D(¤},Fe¤3.R.CTu-P,, P».¢rs»Icm+ +¤
;1Ru\9.R(¤ (COCDCEU C}$;).,I:ed·R(·'u·R qwd has up cmsga-‘}-Ibn ·\-0 c\IgL\0$Q mr·Rc>bI.rISOYI +1::
;%§¢\2p·2··I¢$q·.»·‘I’ »u•xI€$S ¤le£endan+ sPec`I-Qkqlly re¢?u_e$·$~$ +kmu3I·¤ clssmvéry HIP;. pepeneiavfr
no Suck re?ueS·+-, V10? any 0°I"·¤zI" cUSCcN€I"y F€¢?u€$+5»
{\·I¢"|1m¤,rm0rQ, pI¤¤`n·Hq:` ¢¥:cI r¤¤+ know +·L¤+ he I,u¤u|J he usrhj ¥I’Ir.R¤B;ns0n‘s •t¤:[Jqv7—I·
.:é€'·*| °n\·L $\··iV‘•¤¤·’W·¤lI"\f __i.u.¢‘19Yh€H+ Pf`OC€€Ar·V\jS ¤·'+ "FLD. 'Hhvvré ¢`II.$LO•}€|">( 3Y)&€d` YIOY does IRL kWO'··<·•’
€T§~·~I~¤.·=I&u I/•7¢—.E¤bTnson »».»2I| he eseé q+ 4-¤~}¤\. I-? pI¤».ln+‘.$x :Y1+€T|.A.S ·I¤ usi Wir.
i%%`R0h1;·ISOh ·I+ ¢p.'qI pIq5¤I§$IE will prwide AeY€,»,A¤m+.s proper d»`scl0s.u.re. II. w»··IPN¤,nce
[»·»·'+£» *1%. +f·~·e se+B>r··I·L ¥» Rude Rb (¤D(¤3 l¢5,Fed·R.C·'v.?-
Cese 2:03—cv—01344-EHC-HCE Doculment 171 Filed 11/16/2005 Page 1 014
0000020000000 2 02000 2 00000020000000000 0002 TT
. 0 .
‘DeCenc1an+ $er=l»Ler er3v.e.s her ·+he e£$IA¤w{¥ Reds 4e wmply ¤·+h Yule 709. ami
be S'H`;QR€V\»-TI\:S G.I"3U•YY\€?’I+` P¤.1`.$.71tQ I`€hq,L|`,¤`*-7 S"-<1’n¢5CtI"& :.5 €S+¤.u¤%L.¢L<'}.
Ru.\€ 70RlS re
Vw °¤Mpl:¤~¤¤•?— =·~=$'|·qn ‘W¤:¤ *0 ‘#¤. 1¤¢s+ el; {kiwi-Cp: q$¤{\.‘·Ly, cc¤sPc\2•‘mj p}q`C.¤—\¢.pcj;
Egexkemei, ktmaerea access iv ¤¤»~m.M»I¤e+e win vv/r.12¤L1».wm 4.; HAP Ln-. 4e
Qgiiom me .(C£1.aM;+. mr,1?¤1¤:m—.¤,.,·s reliekilwr ;: L—$+q1.1r$1.€4,..$ is we Cm ·¤..¤.+
Fc>\¤Ynson is ¤ Conner \/¤J¤eO{¤+{¤ns,1nq. ewplagee ...5-/·L ex1¤er$`ev¤<.es from Lérj
%!§e.~.p\¤5eA —H‘¤,re, whfek ere re\e~¢·=m+ 4e ·=¢4»is wsa and MH pmulde ¤·ke ~+·¤—¤'er J
~.··'+k necessary T»P¤rv».q+Q¤».q.
De$Yer»Aq»+'s ·-»ex+ ¤r_T4me¤+ re_q¤,ra.`r3 W/Tr.R’O$¤.'ns¤¤·'s qméqvir is Leyeqd p1¤i.·»+I@3
iiieb.'1/+7 4c comprehend, and ke is mekle. ·+¤ Ecru may eeumler erHw»ee41+· "Ua.FeJere’
2 . 2 Hh€`u\c,se_¤$ EV:<’)€¤,£.Q..`..I1@£¤.DA:!13.AE;€i],¢§C¢H+'$ 2 qr3»w4e¤+ me CONCMSIIYS, ic ,~·{e·€¤+f{-\[·\»
JRII J: ‘H·»_ rudes de¥en;{¤.r»+ argues, in P\q·}¤+‘.£P's »H~IerPre+¤—|-rim, only ehqly +.9
IwwZ+v»esse.s fi gl. Zn. aA¤iH·;¤»,+k¤ msc c;.`+4H¤»¤s de-Qen
S+¤+es, v· Ubble , Ageggr, Marx Mg QQ. mul 14.5. ~.». iekgkl were qw
·-»\»¤`ek Mu p|¢u°n+F$$S End pregessknal lager] repre:>e,n+¤1·;0~1 ¤¤¤<$ M45
»;nc.¤r<.@ro.·}-Q6, and were Cdwreccre Lejé ·~f¤ ar. klgxnev $+cmJ¤U`c{ e? K`¥¤g
1
§§IYLerq1\y camshmeé as TL YS pcu‘+ of ·=H»Zs pre Swalprlscner f»\¤,;`¤+?[I`;s
§§1+1~·=**·*ix·
De$enA¤,n+'$ £?mJ ¤u·3e»·-.en+ €s 4ke+ Mr·?¤b·`»·1sem's e££.`A¤~i+ C»·1,¤r¤per{y .
rgqévqncas »`nc1év··¤}ssPUe. ¤»FZv¤}.·pns on lege} c¤m:.\·»
2:03—cv—01344-EHC-HCE Docurgent 171 Filed 11/16/2005 Page 2 014
llldleifher Hm 0.rgu.men+ ln +lm, Federal Rules ep Eqlzlcngz- Plalnllllp :508.5 n¤+ l:»J·¤é any 0Pln¤'0»1.$
legal c¤ncl»¢s{¤ns €0Y|+¤l•Y1EA Wn |TIr.R¤l¤.}•5cn2: ql?Yld¤v»'+.`In p|a·h—l».’l—`p°s ¤l1·l·
d\¤·I€\F\Al‘H·€I•’¢`l' wZ¤l¤+{¤va wculcl he :1 illegal conclusr-cm". l'Y·lr.R¤L»l·n.S0v‘1?» oplfllblil
`ul¤lu€O`>*l*lOY|$’ amf.l¤5eas exH.l;{+ i•·n¢li;l·:erznc.€ 15 nc+ 0. illegal cm1cl~·cslc•·=W·
R¤l¤»}1s¤n is more Hun quqlilleg., as ¤. ·l:¤rmer \fqlu2OP+]¤ng emplcgee qné p¥¤l@sSlc>»¤l,
{crm cm cplvmlcn -rl.¤+ \lcJueOP—l-.'¤»·¤s°° employees exlu°.l;H·li.ndlCFqrenc•€.'i. In pl¢=u'»·l·$l-`·l`L<
l;_¥n+er.pre+a.+$¤¤ JP ¤le$em;l¢m+'s ar3¤.mev1+., ¤lel:e»·¤¤lp.n+ ¤.sS<=.r·+s ·+hc»,+ 14m. wc>¥`
ll,exc.lv•·$lv& ln ¤Plu. .pr¤.t.·l-r`¢;0. wl: Law, 'TLL word ls a.r`_quc.¤.l¤ly usacl more n·l:·l·ev¤ ln
l@S<><;1'¤l »Jcrl<,Bgl·m,v.`¤rql H¢a¤l°l’l-· and psyclnlqivy ¤Ph¤¤ Qu Law- YVlr.R¢>L[ns¢>n|s
lll¤pY¤·`¢:•v» Ys w+ a legal canclusebn.
- .... N .. -... l?lq.l¤+}l:l?. llms ¤¤mm.u.nlc¢+¤};3. .w·?l·|• VM¢.R¤l¤¤l¤s0m `hBz¤c•usz. lll_ufy`l§=.lul*t§¤ffl.
ls n.·:>+ an ul-\-vrnzy, law vllnhe or cm.u+l¤cuse,°l‘lw. llrlzcnu Dep¤.$`·l·M@n+ ci C¢>•*r2,c+l0/F5
AU€$ •Vl¤+ (`€€.D’SV\l2.E, l?.+'l*QT`S +0 QYIA Yfgnq Ml`- Rcxlnsow as â€l.€g0.l it- Nklcn"'
Mail n Fs open qné »'l¤spg4+•zJ Ly Prhgan m.4°l£.;>;—'.+.'g; wluih delays elelhrazry rl; all
and ¤u.·@clnj mall ¤.¤l»lc,l» c¤.u.sc5 o. Aelive.), Aelay a-l` @#0 6lO <:l¤7·s."ll·.»3 .}¤¢.i¤u:le$
Rcklnscrfs cmmmunlcqlixvmi do ,¤l¤.a`n*}.3cl:. .
Stlmlllqlqy, l"l•~.l?¤l¤i»·s¤¤ K:. ¤¤+ M q+·l¤mqy,lq·.~.• ¤$·l:I¤e ·¤•— c¤¤.•··!·l»¤us<·.», so ¢l·.¤. AUG;
»·.¤+ pe¤—»~·.'+ plqG4+»'l?l-` 4:.- make "Legql Telephone mlls" 4e Wr—,l?¢:»l>2ns0v1, gr •l¤
lQlrec.e¤`va "Lqgql ’JlsI`·l-sk ·l-`wm ll."-44.
lYlr.R0lnlns¢>vu has ¤LPFlIe.cl *l¤ be q,¢l4le¢;l ·l·¤ pl¤¢·}¤+:l;l?'-s mpyrcueé uZ`s»°·l·¤r:s Ilsl-, bu? +l1F.s
q lzmjllny approval PFOCESS ¤-ncl cvén ¤Ll;·l·e1— approved ., -+%.4. Ravel allsl-ance lzrowx
lélMr.€c·l>»K·»s¤n's lwme Tn i’h¤e»;k -k> l°l==.·l1+»'l?l? l-n Tuesom WH! he. q lxarclsl-dp lh-
'R¤l¤f»·.$¤¤ up vWsi+ F.l¤I.¤+Z.l,`£.
Pl¤·¤•*¤+ll;l: lms been cloln3+l¤¤. {:25+ lag com do under ¤l·lu. dr¤,•.vu5·l»qnc.eS and for
·:¤¤.r-l- +·¤ éany 9l¤.l¤+llYl? +lw. use cl; Wlr.'rl'¤l;.`»s.¢>n[: qcl?·’é¤w,'+ 4o oppose d¢l`e»J¤»-lk
glass: 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE D0cum§nt171 FiIed11/16/2005 Page30f4
m¤+Ton for gummqry .i•.•.<§3vvsQvi+., ¤·p·I·ef pE¤.:i··+?pF has 1*0.pe¤L+¤ck\•j 1‘c?u.2s—I·eJ
;,§Q.PFO:W+H€H+ cr; C0\·L'|"1$E` and Pu-Formed 4R0. cowl- up nu excepguhal csrcumsiqnces
€gj_re_j¢r¢\;vj +%;.3 PI`D$bW‘|` wcudé be improper,
?$q`../,+%FF r¢$Pe¤+$u\1y reqqes+s +1.% ¢¤¤.r+ +4: deny ¤\e¥em£¤n+‘» »»¤·h`¤»¤ +¤ Ffrike
¤.W»}§q»•i+ ¤-K; Y7I¤'<-Jane! Rcbhsvm, LCSW.
In case -%-3 60*·¢(`+ gsrqrrl-s de{:er><5an`+'; m¤+T¤n 4v s*I-rfke, p1a,ln+:·¤> f`Q\J~€S+.$
"FLQ. CO\.·LI`°'I" Oh :+*-5 6MJH Q_CCOT`C§’ ¤pPO:h+ P`¤.,:Y|+.¤£\O €0\A|’>S€` ¢·¥Id.J0f
éaépermrséicvz for p\a.·}»+$C'1: ·h¤ CH2 ¤. su,PpI<2men+ 44; his resp.-mS¢L ip ·=1e£en<,(q»n+ is
§ ;;••·1.¤+:¤n pc? Swvwvnafy _{uc`8v•4€·3+-
1 . _ fw
SunLJm•++e.c` ·Hvs I day as; P\1¤~.»emLef,;ZOOS-
1 sit 1 ... . .h.. ..,. , .¤ . 0 . 0 . . . .
1.; Orzainuj X- One. copy m¤`.[·¤.d H(;|J¤5 {-pg C1.2rk_ Ll.5.DYs+n`c+ C¤ur+ , Sandra Dm! O°C¤nm9r~
C.mr+h¤as•a, Sie. FSO , “IO\ w. w·=¤sL2»j+¤n 5+. , SPCA ,Ph¤emfx Az 85003
wp? mqifed ¤lIrr[¤s +o; Nor\»}B3K01srqd,Siqerman¤F~·Oaw`S,P.LL, W¤"¢°&“? AJ-
Q;%$
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 171
Filed 11/16/2005
Page 1 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 171
Filed 11/16/2005
Page 2 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 171
Filed 11/16/2005
Page 3 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 171
Filed 11/16/2005
Page 4 of 4
United States Free Forms
Canada Free Forms
United Kingdom Free Forms
Australia Free Forms