___REcEhvED ____CDPY
K; rr!. e? drzrmq
A£:’.;‘m Egman MAR 1* Zim
Meadvws Uni CLERKUg,D1sTnnQT G0URT
EG. T$¤v 3300 D]$TRI.GT GF AF**Z¤g'€pU.w
F}O(€!7C€l AZ
Pfmnhff, !L~ 2 `
ID TI-IE ULMTED STATES D:s‘rmcT CGUET
Fm THE D:$Tf€‘:cT OF r }(Ev¤»¤l M. 1?·.¤~/, wg. cv 03-zrsm my- sms (mm)
PImnb`{I,
v_ REPIY IM SUPPORT c>F r°lAu.mFFé
Mcmou T0 YEMOVE I,JfHU¤>A E.
STW OF r4€¢Z<>MF’¤
Flmk:I:i{`1E, KcvM M. ?¤*—k¤ @0 gy hmbj Sig hp; mpi? bv: D<=J`mdc¤»¢JS’
‘*1?g5Fcnse iso Moisrorz Lv femnvg wana/ca E. !·}¤Fm¤.·1n· as De-Purse C¤u.nse//’ as
Bxlcwsr
D] qGFOS|%]Ofâ€I {LD {I'}€:'€lYTQ‘pf€(` clylclzghgi D¢fenS¢
CGJHSPJ C!q4re,;};q·F{;er ‘*'H0Fm;:,70") {dfsg on éusi ;9m_ `carbcrr 0; the E‘d4r?:¢¤(
Wufza Gnd 0f‘B¢»f€S thai her mmpvczl woqfd wc>r${ .$ubS£¢f¤'3`¢’J !’?
Qsuft ]{] [_A_]'Q$·£jq_ Q-? VQ/qqbfg ._StC!’éE, QSOMFCZS (Jf’?!?e»C°€S$(L'·y
cost {:0 Anzanc. t¢yP¢z·2{»2r$,â€
H0¤[rrl¤nr; does mab, hcweveg ey?/am whe? this JS Sc nor does S/vg
P{pV,`d@i any 2u,¤He,•qc@ 1223 3uf‘0Or`C 'WIFS C»0nc[q_g·g{`f·b· 8'i*Z"@£€W?€r1‘f. HO·rr'H¢r7ry
Shoufq have pfvwdecl cv·I;{encg_ {:0 den~w0Sffc1f2 Wai Onfg G new Se/ect
i In 0t`d€f‘ 1:0 guard ·R4r'd4er’ C0frR1si0f{ Fir Co¤.mse[ (Howcmann), P!¢20??£'·"•cp w¤;H
f`¢$e,!t in h.;,qg;$ef€ LIS 7?c<6 Gem 1],/rms POF/It 00. H01Emcmn$ Q!/u$:bn f:D 7·?¤%·3
Smégneg ag passive K incorrect! as Chem IS mn Si?/;1.·1F1¢ -P{m,.a rgfher-
»t rg an cxssemfiva stcicmwé with agcmpnntc. SUA] ui--verb· oéjemt ·¤·2[ree men¢,
éwm tjlqiil R’¤Fn4c’wn was re{°ern`n·2 in The “P¢fS0¤¢'$ $0 this
jg chcncbgd {D Surf h€»{`.
1.
Case 2:O3—cv—O2150-SRB—I\/IEA D0cument128 Filed O3/14/2006 Page10f4
m¢;j_O,-,»,€,LbS M me ,4,·;;OpmL3 (;,me,~¤1§ 0{`Qae, Rm 3uc:H’red iv defend Sm/q
Q ws; cagwrlst ca pg; gg inmate! wh;) has /r1':!.l:, or mc ¤r;m.m.>·.»j
m cm; l.‘{;r%c:¥:1`c>n_ Hofmann pmmdgd no Such ewE!e.»vca_
Hxrmermoml ;—}O{m¤,·»,q doe; nm': demo; Chai; Them rg cn SQAQL45
COn,F(l`C‘l; [}".I£@rg§‘& if! [Off" d€·‘F€l7G{¤’f)% 'UQNB OQSZ, HOF O-{0*25 Shi S&f?,
um $1% informed her mméa 0% ws ¤<»»~»Ff··"<»f of *~*¤f¤Si·
Etlm`¢c.( fuk, l.7(z)(b) prawdesc
nr ra :1 me is 1- 12 Pme ~e··¤¢~*¤b°’*
0,C;,U?;rc?»‘¢;% Sm r;|;r;»?;gm·5! cfiizrtéd by i1=»¢,..
law ué cum sniezsts, r4nless:(r')&ch¢ Iaw=3¢r reasmabtlj
be,J;;g·ve;, The rq¤rcS¢rr¥:¤1’3v¤ wi!} n¤£· be adverse/EJ ¤{Fe¢£¢d;
and (Z) gjqe ;[,·m·[; fbonsmts ca·Pg';cr cmsuiigfabn, her:
r¢,¤msem&»:¤f:»‘vr: multipfc clients in aL Smglr. matier ·
I5 uy);/er{;a}(¢r(, Und ¢c>nS¤4!£¢b‘.:>»7 Sha!} Mc/u e. dif/¢V!¤b°’?
Op the WP/.=c;;t»'0ns... md ask? mvplveqf
9/] "(O]C{Y`}CU7f)%, ‘FG.[IU(€ {30 1179*6 G- COO';/{`Lf of f·f}£€(`€$t
éwsg [Le'} 'chgf 'd*)€("@ [S (lf] b£‘ElAjC€f] HDi;Y'*"7df?O @70/ hh"
;{;.;,.,,1;S’ P,;—;,·+;,.pn2 gy; ;mF€,,»m,;s¢£>}.g conf/,·;£ \$·)£[S£S. /¤Jcv¢r‘d¤¢f¢SSâ€/ in
FCIGEOH in gpl )_q(b)(;) {he igwzser rnw/ved €.;_ng£_{: Pauper/ez asié {Br
such (5;,4 qcbrqemeni Or I9f‘c>w’d4. (`€P(`Q$€fJtéLI&J'Or’? On We b6¢5FS ¤·F'd’7€
clsm£s’ chorus-mv/:.
GNU; Uqai Hcqfmcznn has 'pfijfdd !:¤ 0~ppr0F¤‘¢—‘€¢}? ¢<>·¤'*S€/ [OFF d'**`â€iK.·
M|V;,,L Umm the c»n{`{,z,t, have ci/m’U1·:r athcfneuti G6/Vf$C—m€r?7} 0;-
Ob-taxn dnl Ccnsznt of each cficrzfg, this U~·Y7£3Uf`VOCQ//eg demansfrcfcs
ex Pattern c*F w1¢‘dqi<.a! !:>ch¤w`vr`, Thr; Stems. {km #01Cm Mné d*`*"*"€ff*Z-Mlg
Wcsgd mtgrgg-{;$_ Hg the Ccmmznf in EK?. L7 pr¤vic{¢’.S:
{ { mum'; The demi cwnsmf affcr Cvfrsu/‘b0·i7€¤*7
git ELO? dma Indwmdcnt gy]: such mnsmi, dd? 2]
(*2, p€5gnfQEO/j {EGSO/Idbnlb. G·F0€G.(E HD1: to be G VPS cy
Rpgecged Ex? me Im..:¤ju.s Omg: m·l;
L
Case 2:O3—cv—O2150-SRB—I\/IEA D0cument128 Filed O3/14/2006 Page20f4
In 575 Gcnieml: -d,e.;$ Cas;} fqcbjgygri Bins FS Hof P/`éérlscllé, â€iZTl.l6. Th-4,
Cvmment {D »-HMS rule cypfgss/gg Pmvid¢$ ‘[jqg1Z3 H0, bd/dngh? is Y`€‘3¢»irl"€(]'
bztween Ijqef Inf-ig{€gf$ DF dri C{|'€Ht Gnd ’d’I0.S£, of thi OFIg0.$ir;3 ,O¢1.r'bj,‘°'
HGFDQQHH PNS !'}0'L €V€2’! 50 much QS` 0•'b£€f?7ft€d 'ED Sk0I..·O 'l`j7c`é I5
{I6}-i bU`fHb PfP,\gu¢3(»•2,€0{ IQKZ "d7Ig Gon-F/gf ]h[j€f€$'b, lnqe ?U€S&`O/F LS
whlmer gm) mz ifhléhb {:0 Sugar Pfgisqdgkgll IS bf!-$`€{ Of? dk
fm-gum OP the £'.c2S¢, The fmlcafkdnce, and pmbab/e icnuref
{CbJLb€(.é tc;-b;}4Oâ€(j" @,464/ dyg PmbQé:`[r_`£¢j d1G`b Thi Icmjus t€S'|£Zr,|qLZv72
wélf C»0rh€{4bfZ wfdfv that OF Other w'{m€S§eg'
In clnswerm? 'iihe
{Mahan {:0 the ggsuls (;0,qggrnm% ADC Fcficiegj and gf IS €6i$·`I¢3 apparent
that hqf ‘];£S£Iir,r’)0nLb {YIU|S‘{Z Ofdrhélffhg with l’7Zf' OLD/I CIFQHTES
·L¢s·bS·w0»¢L3. 'Unag IS Gc>n·F:`¢·mec{ bn}, f·H1{;mm’>H$ ‘1lZD`!'.'&/ ·p¢u‘furz {:0 fesroand
bo the isguig Presented In jdqc nqdbbyq ··{:0 femovc PMP.
Hvfma/mg SOM (G/II-ance, O,] buf; un; Qyeynfgbbd bc 5.123.7 TS
5.h4p|¤?j UAQVCUPIIH? javw Une Comment tv that fuk, me rcccf dock
pa_)qd»z,e bs T30? rs like/»b.
Afgpl /—}»¤][mq,q,q3 qssexbbn Uraf She Skcu/d mpi be removed
beams; ‘<-dwfe {S no jqganwj or Hmf Cafgqdgrgj aé Mrs bmf
(-‘R·'e$POn_S_€_’ YS fbi 00h? rh COITECT; (7:+/ff! i'-S 0~`S€é£/tfhé/{Zi
QOWPQI-Qnge SCPPEG/0I'[€6{ Tcbr IQ Zak): bu-L rk works
is 0~0‘€%u0·&€, {ahve. kn imnsfer cm; cage wzzhcut Causmj Substczméaur
|,,a[.d5h,`p" gn Mgr C»{icn‘£S,
3
Case 2:O3—cv—O2150-SRB—I\/IEA D0cument128 Filed O3/14/2006 Page30f4
A; can be Seen hub, Huycrnanné. ucnethkcf Conducif describedyéey
she. rS fnmpablz. of represenémg fh:. 0W"$"""Q’ yntemsfs W/°"=“h wm
ww; ka an substmfiaf hardship M her 6/fenis. fm:/emf Lhrs Ccwt
Canngf even ccnsilcr Ilofmanné fespmse 6% She VMS pm`/fd tb WMF/3
ujffh ld']?. {U./{S UI; S£'Cl'£€0/ .*2éOl/Z.
Mcrcgvec geo? expresyg cancun témé defzndapég mma us;
thm fp mw,. QO{,&,,-ggggi should an capfceal .64. necessarcg @,3, a comcreci
0F mteresé c;Ic:.m·1).
A.;-wp;{,y;%{».b) zi; is Che/11(Om, neeesscwg T6 ordcr H·0{`m¢zm·7é.
each rndrwkfuczf devcandmf 07C fhrs €°“'{'/"°`!¥·
;?g5Fggr,€;_;LLy SuBrr?¢7'T'.~*5£> Dhrsjé. da? cnc MMG?. 2009
Kavm Mmzmex. T?¤% EIQGE
wm 04.% , Jam
0‘R6:»|AL and OMB (BOF Oh dm
[cha Mcufed 1:h:sJ;}/L dcwy
rhmgzl mm ¤*:·><
Th Hu mf S ‘F?. Ealévn
U,,$1·,€d"§2c&§ ¤Z*2.Z2d. guage
and ONE 7'FUE /+:09 <2¤??EcT c¤F*{
may/ed iw:
1,J 4 E. Hqqrrmn
Agkgrgav 1’-?>r De{€f>6(6W'£$`
B
YKMK
Case 2:O3—cv—O2150-SRB—I\/IEA D0cumJjnt128 Filed O3/14/2006 Page40f4
Case 2:03-cv-02150-SRB-MEA
Document 128
Filed 03/14/2006
Page 1 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-02150-SRB-MEA
Document 128
Filed 03/14/2006
Page 2 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-02150-SRB-MEA
Document 128
Filed 03/14/2006
Page 3 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-02150-SRB-MEA
Document 128
Filed 03/14/2006
Page 4 of 4