___nEcEnvn;¤ __c0pv
§¢r;;1n;q;S?;;;#§f;;;- Ejmm MAR 1 4 2[]{]5
ggégggnft cLLgr?é
Ik} THE UIUITYZD STATES DISTFQICT COURT
Fm? THE DISTZWCT OF- ARIZONA
\
P}cun1:i$C,
M REPN ml SUPPORT OF PJHINWFFS
MOTION To c0mPEL~
STATE OF HQJZOMA, e&, arg J
D€1C%rrdc2nt$.
P/cambffl Kwm M, 5%·j,_*·;0;,, hgaiby Mas his :?e.pl¤3 iv De{m¢(anf$' ‘
Response fc P/c1ml:i-Fpé. Mcivbrr £¤ Cumpel as ,4;;/Owe.:
'Delimclmés state, dvaf P!¤m£iHY§' mcbm should be d,;,»¤;S;@d
GS mad: because ffverub haw, swf/,*€q' Uhc, Feguested ¤#gc¤vc.·j, in
“Lmdermcn§ Second Supfvfemenfnf ??esp¤r¤5e, To P/Mah-PB Riguesf {Br
Producbon 0{ Dcbcpmmfs. and 7VrM<3S.†(FHi¤¢h*°"‘W’£ A)- TM ’$ °'"'b'm'2"
In Inv; Motion im Compef, P/ambff (f4eremaF£er"7?¤·3’*) P?¢M?*j
Iâ€C%x.A£SfLCd Graaf Defgndgnfs be, Ordered in pruwéfe cm Updated
°'Cu~rrm{: Approved ??¢!r<5i¤us Iiems I.i$fZ,†7?¤<»b·E<. mcéicrz C/€llf`{*`j
e,,4P|mng 1;{/mt this Irsi fs refevemi because, F15 wi/F demonstrate
that ih; ffems “»?¤
gr; no more Q ¤$€CU{l;£-I? r"rS}< Zi/mq dg; r`£€mS currenffj, aH<¤bU€r{ `
Other :'¤m¢a1‘.2s.
'beqcendqnts dd rmi provide an updated â€Cun·e,m’; Hplarvved
r J.
Case 2:O3—cv—O2150-SRB—I\/IEA D0cument126 Filed O3/14/2006 Page10f3
’R’eI€¤5r¤u$ ZUM5 L·‘·s1Q° but f`·¤U’¤¢F *1 °`€L*‘$‘£» f‘?Pf"`°"*w/ "?*!"'25i‘°“S Iblmg
{Lp ;Qn‘zprm` De»p¢m':mm·lE C¤r.rgq{:i.~:»n5 Inmwlzcs wm have declared
¤;5¤l;<.»;¢. clm—$—l;.··M as their r<:Ir%s~¤r»" (seg nwchmwt A me 2.),
Wea Fs. cn recladiecl version mc Tie,. list 7¤?¤=j, Y`E·‘Zu€Sf€Cl{
In tlnair Qspcnse} T>c{`cnclcm·’;$ léziwl 'UEJJS Gounf °& bdfcvcl
thmi men? have coopefaiécl with Une. Drscpvefg pmcess bc;
gufpllgln? emmglnz what foci, re<5ues~£ed_ In Lxndermank Second
SUFPIQMQW-[;Q{ 'i?45€gr1s,g,} lqcbqguer} In; cbseclzs {:0 The 0!r;;l;[¤5qre.
bmw! 0,4 gym sad: ¢>{· °’lrrele·~/Gm'? lf? ‘b}>'*¢ and S°°P€I,"`€‘*`·'—‘·*""""‘§»’·i[
Slsciad %4,4i£€. plajnlcbj DLPLHJGH5 dire, being, urr‘l:fu'U1·Q( 6’~n0( C!/f;
de,|ib
gl,·S4,,;Ner<.B Fcréuegé is burdems¤m2/ 0‘¤Fre$Sl`vej or Zj7c;`é Ji presml;5
carp? hype. Securlfiz tlaremfi, Thanx ar; srmphj, bemcb uncc0percfv`ue,
and waslmry 1?¤Lbé and ‘Ef4iS Gwrké {-me and resources-
CMASEJ j,qf;{(F¤sgg CL rglgvcmcg, vbjecbbnl hewn/g,{) Such J';
gnamgmlgndtb an 0{;,<;(;¤va~B as H; was nefllizer famed in The wqrsé
Pmduddvn rzsponsg and Counsel {rms no place ii¤ ¢*¤»·`S¢ @1:- See.
Ogeenhefméf Fund IHC. V. Scw¤1d€fSJ, ’-{37 US- $#0, 35J (l?'7Q),
Defcngfgntg mz, Q&u5i`r')% unnecessary dam-}, ns there rs no
{e¢8I£¤}wqé;, reason Pb: Them ·l:¤ re1C4sg,—l:.> pmvlde 'C!’H`S uxcdaéecl
d,sc»uer @0;,5 lqghg czctgd m céfygd -[·`a,·z% 75 cbiczm This updated {esi
m me Fwmdt ¥"€?U?f`CC{ thi FEM Z CFMR and HI TK f`€l£U&tA1’:
{:0 Urn`; Case., /lcc¤rv(ma5lg_, This dgwrb Slccufd order Defmdméx
f`¢P¤rcmc¢ l:¤> the *=»?¤¤Frcme ¤P this kmusbm';.
Z.
Case 2:O3—cv—O2150-SRB—I\/IEA D0cument126 Filed O3/14/2006 Page20f3
fo I'.7{T>U|`d€.~ 'd0•1$ [?St.
1?.·;$F‘EcT'FuUJ{ 5v13rmTTE_p d<¢sJ.5_d.;z? ¤{ March, Zcm
KEWM MICHAEL. fm/I @>g
ww
wm rr'?. ? , Plain i
me um. A Owco wm
?tf“;‘¢£;i’»L www ‘
The Honorable $uScm E Egfban
uneied Sbaécs D»s£nz;£ judy,
and OME TFUE AMD c¤?‘¤?Ec:T“ 6cPY
mailed io:
hmndcz E. Hof /1 -
;¢}d::>rne<3 Gr Dgznccggcfcnix
gx] ;KM;(J, Q2;
3
Case 2:O3—cv—O2150-SRB-I\/IEA D0cument126 Filed O3/14/2006 Page30f3
Case 2:03-cv-02150-SRB-MEA
Document 126
Filed 03/14/2006
Page 1 of 3
Case 2:03-cv-02150-SRB-MEA
Document 126
Filed 03/14/2006
Page 2 of 3
Case 2:03-cv-02150-SRB-MEA
Document 126
Filed 03/14/2006
Page 3 of 3