Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

/" 4 J. ULBV J VL J
/
, -;` A V A _ ¤=¥éium¢?¢r¤1¤AV1 A M
A AA A . ‘_ A A A A
`4 V .V» ` *A°‘‘‘‘ V

? ` v·»’` V· 1* ` ‘ * ‘ ‘ ‘ * g ·» ` _ g
¤ VV A ,_ _& ‘*?°*’““· .v·_ ”F‘?°?f?*°"**’”’* AV A AA
‘ V WZWDQEEE'.: =1¥¥1=@;€¢V’i#£\*E2»,_;— ;f¥¥,§;*I¥V£°¤;A-%» £¢iV.;.V .*,., A M
· V ¤zmm=ea¤dw#p¤¢%w&¤ V MA iw `EII mV ‘ ‘ fwiixmz V w:¤1V2T6E1VVV AA AV V A A
V AV.V ;;V.VAV,VV.;. -,_` .4 A. .·.: . 5;; ° » ? *$5¤¥`¤¤€$ Y ’ A» -V T=‘ ¤V&‘¥¤¤¤V H A ?¤·¤ ¤¤¤V& ` QQASHQ BQA f
* ‘ As » ‘ ‘ ' V
A ,_,.,, _ . A A » `MDA Mm mn
A A
V V .‘ V VV Vj"*¢ V? * T A V A A ·—,. V
iV~¤¤ "`A ‘ ' Vi V " ` A
‘ ¤u;1né?=p¤3¤V1¤;Vd¢iip¤m;¤n¤V¤u¤rV A V »
I '»£Ji?*?-*•.-‘*A“*°“¥`**w A J ’ — -
* , A l ` ·E
’ A.; . ``, ` 2 VA A V _
‘ V WLM r;_.__ 1 V SA a I ‘
" :
A A 1 ‘*?*'<*@*¥*?*'“F@¤?¤!'¥¥;*¥!FY¤?”¢? = V V ·
¤ A ¤ V 1 V A
V * I ‘ ' i
i » IQ V -
= VV§5¢§!?‘»0Q¤>e ·’iF¤¤ ·‘2¤¤* V 95Q,A4V!>w
} -A»* ‘ T ‘ ‘ ‘ ` ‘
A ~ V E
{ V ‘ 4 V
* »··A — V · ‘
E V ·V »:»A a · —‘. V ~ V _
€ _ 55¤aA3V|1¤i @¤¤z2·¤¤i V$¤¤.af2¤r¤ AA V·9:5uV,‘a’0¤
g "'¥7£$¥# 1- `V ` X » `’-} i
¥ AA A A AV [ · ‘ AA A A
# · 2 A »V_2 °v.Vz .A~sVV¤.;·V VV * — = ‘ V V· I · · A V
j *’*§ _ ATV, A _».. ~ A E A A A
V _ A V ~ ;V~§¤V-» Q 3 % `°?¤¤~ VV ¥2¥¤¤¤£ V V-2»5··_¤¤¤ _ _
V · T / 1 I 1
' Y A;A,;VV;.,. V:@¤su¤§é35A¤¥·i 3i£11¢ ~¤m1A» V 1¥I§E¢g»€!¤¤ V
A QA 3* {ZA " ' ` ’ ‘ ‘
2 ~ ` *· f _ V A V _
égr I - A. A
` ` -` 1. , 4;** ],·;.,~.,;;.A; ,, 5 *A.,;· .I V . —A A. V
=~·f¤.V¤rnqVA¤¤¤¤¤¤¤wx¢*»¤p¤» V
W V~"F{ V; AA. A.A,.AA;VA.,_,:A:;A, A;A‘V;,AA.·V.A.iV§$:$ V
‘ V QQ A, , A,_ , A
H V V V A - _
;V##‘ W V =¤¤¤ V ¤@·3¤¤¤- AV
?¥¥ EV fi? A r V ,A,' A A » V
· · AVA; ,A_A,AAmVAA,A§ 5 VA} $§V¤¤i.VA AVz¤¤;;w1i¤ei V2¤¤A~ ¢nAcm<¤A A _AVAA _ AVAV A _ ¤
LAA ‘ V’`A V A. `AAV. V ` A
A V . ‘ ` ‘° j "* ”:1é;;m¤&mT4am;¤§; -A,,<¥*AAV A V A AA ;£-UDMA ’.. A AA A A AA V ,
1 A
1
Y AV AAAV V A VAV AA A AAAA AA AAA A AAAAA __ ` ' “
* A V A ` “VA fi ‘ A
# I V VV`VV V V 3 A
r V j A Y &A A
1 http://m@QcO4t@&®@29©GBQEZcgi sw i_ ` VV VAV A AAs r·—» ·jV »VV A ¢ A ;:gA A_A _ Oflpm/2005
i

Case 2:04-cv-00299-DGC

Document 238-12

Filed 11/21/2005

Page 1 of 1