Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

; Aéy / ` J / / A » `Mt` W`` ¢
‘ · · :>"<¢·~:~ ~**# 5
; / /.:¤ ¤ ~ » », _ ; A / A ,
· sv 1 IIIHI III! WWII {HINT
A » 4 · ‘·
· ` ~2>¤.;,;~;é>’ ’ ¥ AA l.4:;

`I?l!¤*’l1i, huthnimr ,gq.~y@»¤g»•»_:Am¤¤ a;=-/-wg.nAs¤·A¤¤1u·1za.n¤ at m·s¤m.».
wu5;mP¤nm11srB&w¤!nmw¤utt¤$¤m¤!hb¤Lts¤5¤A A ,
f¤r¤M·r¤¤¤¢* muws/A-w¤n¤¤A¤~¤A/nwnnnknmm t; - A,t?%$—§$P9§$§·A .` _ , ‘,% A V_ . . A,,,< A »...» A A ._ _` .., .V¤, ._.»., A, A ,., , -/ - »? ~ _
/ ~ _ . _,
*?3¤‘°‘ *1
`/*****}**9* ‘ . · i
H‘m'€5‘ M-€i'.*:·
» mm
I im “-`& `*°A iv ’'» !•= » _
1 H Q T , N ,,_AA ._ ),.. ¤:¢~»ss¤¤¤r»nt:;»
= — »
Aa¢i ’ / M
, » A
_ . - I A . / .1
' » / ·— , ’
¤, ,- . A V·-- , ‘= ;». A . ·A ¥-E}
E’*"‘*‘*·» A e "“""°"“"` ',-`s`mm a¤F` / · - I
—_. —, " Ar, §;.‘,..-or ,,,,,, A A. 1 A _. _ ., } M ` " `
' i' " Q ___ V _ b "
•`.;»~..‘............. .........»»... ;....-.a.,...........z/.¤.L·»...q•_.{·.4-..--··»··»-»-·i%¤»•v•#¤n••6¤n¤»ur•»nan•¤•¤»·vw••»iA»•{•4·•»•··--•r·-•’-··..;-A-......-.....a.
4, —
. 2 $;;? ¤J;;;k•Li•. °i*4s£:? , _ s ¤ " " '! · ¤;.*.A;,§}4.§», =¤ f
.... " ‘ ;. ;_-i·¤¥¤i|¤¤¤*A V. N -·‘'°` J ' V
A ,A¤:»¤4·¤·we ;..·=w¤¤s>¤¤» »
{ »· ¤·*F¤*¤¢PA ··4%."*¤**!`**!¥**! » A A ¤*·.-4¤•*¤¤¤*¤*A
‘ A-¢=1~ *‘*··¤¤e¤¤·¤*¤¤*»; .*~ »»·¤W
..5-»wA¤¤»¤¤¤¤ ~.·i¤¤»·V¤¤\=!v¢¤!r¤·*%¤§¤¢ivme· ¤{».AM•!·e¢
\ -¤:¤mm•m» , M-—1¤n*¤¤&¤+¤¤·
~*¢¢r»¤*¤¤¤¤·¤¤¤¤ .. .. .
@1; VA -
-¤z.A¢r1¤¤@¤ S ee., ;=A /1·¤,..·amu¤Mmw
- A / ~ = ./A.€=iéa¤74¤P¥!•¤~?¢%Mw¤¤»¥¤**¥¤¤~}*¤*¤>
,;,1BJr!¤!•W?§i¢l‘ =,.;;,;m¤pgyp¤¤»¥»’ ··-· · /
;..¢m>r¤¢¤¤· .‘A- , A . mnn¤0¤m¤n···¤¤=*·¤¤
,;;1¤mm;q=»_’ -
1 A
i j `
/ / j° A ` iii/?;? `?/i “
Case 2:04-cv-00299-DGC D umen .
http://images.cc.statc.az.us/scripts/cg1§)c§:x>sr1sp _ 4 www A2 10/6/2005
» ’,AAAAAAA.;. / / `,A, A /

‘ ‘ ` ‘`‘`
1 -1 1Pagc-~·o?f* »< »
~¤m¤1¤¤»s1 “ ,%,,211 1
Fw A » `` · ~¤~ V 1 ,1 V
· if 1 I » ? §¥?i*1 1 V
1 — 1 »*?*¤P¤¤V¤W'**”??¤¤*¤¤4¤¤f¤¤¤¤?=5.4¤fiéw; %!{*¤¤¤i¤E*¤¤3?@°*¤”¤¤*?$¥*1¤%¤m¤i¤¤¤·P¤¥·;¤¥¥#¤¤M¤¤lh¤¢i;¤¤·1‘1 1
1 **¤¥¤r*¤vr‘¤¤¤ ¤¤•'¤¤_¤¤*i¤!¤¤*¤’¤¤F•¤¤’•¤?1¤?¤‘!@ ¤QE¤¢i¥¤B>MQ1¤§*?·%i¤¤*¤$*t4¢i>$F¢*?¤¥¤¤i**$$·»¤¤9¤E¤*¤~ ~E¤¤¤¤W¤*·‘¤”¤¤=¤¤*¥$¤•*¤¤i¤¤¥s-
.m:¤m¤¤-m¤.zne1mm¤¤¢1¤r~um¤s»¤¤»u¤¤;: mv ‘ 1 ‘ ’ · ·
m¤m¤¤·=¤<1$u¤m¤¤:;»1 v m¤¤¤»»51s¤mm 7* éaeumnennm 镤¤%s;1:wwivv‘
Mumbe¢VmE‘»h¤r¤sJGcrmi¤¤1esit¤&u¤¢t1 Bam $¤=rcsWHmn11c¤§ss=x¤—¤ny;
$.,1%1:m——-Ef»=‘¤=`>m »·*`· g"-£* _Z£11VffB¤damm2¤¤lV W1 F¤t{¤nr»m£dBn¤inzn?l?iu¤hs»¤r¤“ '’· lqav V -. 11
;¤¤¤¤¤¤¤ mwé 1‘¤#¥¤¤\ 2°W¤¥? ¤¥§·$¤ 9* "*¥¤¤¤¤=¤¥==¤?¤~°¤*¤¤**'°*»¤·<¤*;”¤**'¤ ~*”¤*¤‘”*¤¤ ’¤’9€*°$
1 » mmmmw·e¤4|n1wse V¤¤rp¤ramc¤n.;122xm¢¤1r-·;ggp¤1.;;¤: minis, mummy.
_ 1 ,_
mma E _ · O
1 1_1 _ _ Manga ‘·¤¤11¤·:i¤¤ »V » ctnaauiyi. ¥¤·u ;¤1¤t··-at.z¤e¤¤t ’
mma: ‘VA _ =.1,.· 1 ’N!nm1 ny}-<<;-ra 1 -· 1; _ 1
THIE: V: »‘ » » 1 ·T$f|$c~ 111,=‘ ”’ 1
11 —"'*;r~ i¥··> I 41 ·_ aw 1 »’1‘ 1 1 j·1 1`1sr”
$519 wipe:

THE: ’F¥¤¤??i V
si ‘-··. qi ¤qg;·»;a mw. A 1_
1V$1z£w··` ` 1 1 · V ~
‘ mwwcmgarrm- ~ ¤ar4¤4¤wng1¤f¢%¤¤i....1......_..
V B,V P1·Sl£B wan ms vrimae uiwaxlkyw Iain. th heist
=}”**‘€. 2§~ 'E"=w¤<_1 V _ 12**-hzzég
1`:m¤m¤¤111g¤mc:»¤:..,,,...,..,,,,,,,,,,_1,,_,_ ~;¤mé tén81mg·1¤1f¥¤é: ~.,,....._.____ V
gm,. `; 1V—1 gg 1;, E-4,,1 .;;1‘1,,,».1., 1 Em ·»·1 g ·’‘{ 1 1. 1 1 _ 1
I · 111iE E; .,m;*V sg .- ~1»1» ..1;, 1. ` , — 1 · »- 1 · ~ 1
~ I _,...._._.-1
w;; 1
J Q1 /M2 5 - e — N ..§z§cQ5%2 Of ” ‘
111, .11· ,.~=1 - 1 ’11 . 1111 >»» 1 »» .11111 ··11 1 V 1- 1 /6 2
»:» ¥ 005

Case 2:04-cv-00299-DGC

Document 238-4

Filed 11/21/2005

Page 1 of 2

Case 2:04-cv-00299-DGC

Document 238-4

Filed 11/21/2005

Page 2 of 2