Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

'P;...."
maze;
E*a$
EEE.
§$?
*
-¤ ~<•-1
gi §§g 2 E 1
B. OQ 0 m °° 7* 3 UN
gr sc gggji R Q E ;· ¤ S g > ,,-
-¤<.¤ I,.-U, -1 Z ; c > O C m ,1.,
E 5m m ; C -.1 *' W -¤ X X H1 W
.. mg .5* , T, ¤ "’ I Q, "’ > E2. QQ m >< c:E
1 m .1xC 1-4 #11 I 1 D ‘¤ Z C K"! Q U1
T U\U’* 1- 7*7 1*11 1- B rn 1.-1 m c; HE
? <7~' BS Q ¥ $3 m 5 '5 $ E ¤ 5 .%¤
1- 1· )
?¤" Eg VN U E ·¥ ~• "* L. *'“ § g
'* zu 1.1. > *-1 ""* "'I
S 3 ¤ . ¤ 1 Q 3 3 :3
I Z C C E rn > 71:1
cn Us . au 1-, Z ,.
: U! §
¤ I °‘ 1-1 Z >
.7 G E? Z é é '.T. gl
-. O NI g- p
1* R —I Zi g '2 rn r1:
**·U•.·"N E Z En., E gg
,-...3s.p D l'\'l L4 -.
»..=.~~S 1 1- 0 ¤
Q,`¤j§‘ 2 g S
EQ2; g U
Q I_
"nn
.1.
Eg w
12 1
QE. 1: U,
Z
EE ·· 5. 1
‘5··{• § S` 9.
gz 1- °‘ E §
¤-S E 5 § if Q éi
Q-H'} -•` -l : R ca g L
hx 1 11 30. 1 :1 D —»
g. o n 9__¤ .:.;¤. -, R
-•-. E g :`< '** Q 4 1
.,0 N H -•»E_ . D
`U‘ ) ? g ,;*3... ) -1-.
wa. 1 a § mz. 2 1
;,*_¤¤ g' a Eg agp. D ; 4* lh
> **1..3 O ° g` xs m
-. '¤ B 5- O 3 17 D 3
'I O Q
2 1 `° 1 Q <> S0 Q
P. "’ 12 E
-I-
C
¤
N ffl
g §
m
¤_ )
=: : =¤ *2 Ev
¤=· ~ rc <~· Q?-...§
1 1 ~ -.1 % ·-¤¤
·=· ¤ = u§
LD ‘U _ ZT
N F ¤ — ¤ RNE
;¤ 3 `B B’ B' ;:.. .1·—·¤
~ ?’· *8 Qi Vg r. °‘ = %...*§
n N 1 4» N n *1: 1 #1
¤ D 07 E . .,___ 0 D Nv
- G Q• G ‘¤ QE u:.
1 >< · 2 é E A ° D 1 EE
S, U X #1 »·~ S "I lg "‘•' 'L Hz
-+ 1 w as -1 u. n 1... "* r·
0 N.-` = = Q —~.. ·~.. = G m
E sg GT'?. $1 A 1 Q °‘3 S >< ?·¤` 5%
__ CID = nn A) gd
—- ><¤ -—¤· 5 u1 ... >< * . c> U.
3 . ·- - —
UI" :><1> "‘ - 5 Ul 0- "‘ · =
; un :3. SUSE; of 5. Q ....3 _ 2 X .3 X Q
-- ’*’ -..3 [2 3_ 0· "· 1.-. Th -1 up W
3 ·¤ J "€ °2 23.* -¤ =. §
-- "' ·-· __; *9 Ul ..
Q " 1:111
I'\J
un 3
'°·•·.
0 . 3
¤~
> 1:1-
°“ 9.. ‘-1 *3 r-.
1; .1 O 5 2 §
: ~.. 1* <-. `—
cn . .... »-. :: 3 ,,
‘····. ’"‘ ‘ D v.
cu ¤* W Q S —<
Q` E"` E 2 E 1` E 1::
M z c 9•-. D *-4 E w vs
¤ "‘ R 1.:: S E S G S
F QQ QQQQ E Q; A Q. Q ·r· L4 Ul
.1 9*91 >.»€ Q D .. :.— 1; ;_- 5 5 g
2 5*; $:11 .~ > 1 :1 .?— 5*. ‘°
.·-· s »-.,.., mn; 10 9. g E ,-. g 1 N

§ 9 J, .§§ `BE‘¤ *-1 9; at Q ,§ G T.: a a
7 ru 1 3,3 9*2.2, E. ru L L Q L fu B 94.
Z ‘-” ¤ ;"’ {@3; "" I" `*— —.. · 2:: c ‘{‘ ‘?
¤ Z E!. pg =¤¤ 3 '¤ S" ru E .1; 5,, un u1
'3 ¤ --. ¤—‘*‘* 9. 2 ° P° ¤¤ N · "‘· T:
U\ 0. num ·- N p
sg 3 ~·.., 1.:111 M A 5 0 ‘¤ 0 O
N ¤~¤~ —··.u·1u• * · · 5 E 5+ '4 3* —C
'{ S ¤~ `*__··;*···.. w`“·-"°··· 2 Q $__-”__ I -1- 0 1: cz
O '“ 02*** ru N ... c~ ,5. L -1. 5 El-
UI O •
-| U1 q·» CD '*·— •···.. "‘·- 1 U
> ¤ —~ L; U. N 5 0- Q).
1 -..4 ··* P ····-. ,_,..|
I F 1 .. " 1 5 21*
{A Y 1
D. *1 Ss -3,--· QT I., E 1:1
“ ~ S iq @3% & a § a % . Q 1 5
`°` " 3 2. 2-. 2 12 E S F `.;.~
cas 1 1 1 .1 i 1
e 2.04-cv-00363-JWS Doc N R U
ument16g
'3 Fnled 05/19/2006 n
..... . 6991012

:¤>·-·-n

Q..
$71
Em"
z
E?¤<
n —<•-1 ‘¤ H To Ln JU ‘.L ¤:¤ rn m m mr
3 mz $350 E z ;+ E 0 § 0 0 c >< >< >< cg
· OFM W -1 > ¤¤ -0 m rn m rn m
g I <\‘1-1 m rn "' S P cn > H 0 fx h r-1
¤ O0 Icm 0 au ¤•~ E z c c; c; z
I 17 ·¤ h
9. sc: q>¤¤ -1 z C M m H rn ;g I;1 bj m,
5- vm prin g m QI I ‘1‘• H -¤ r- Ln < ( un
,.¤·· rn-1 ,. -1 I, M ,.,, 0 0 uw m 5, m
E 0:. ·¤ ··· 0 E3 % ··¤ °° ·* =· '“ >¤
0 mm 0% ' > s 0 0 1 2 E 0 8 QZ
·* fx *` ne 1
=` J1 0% m ¤- 0 ig m < Z *
Q f‘I U1 cn C N m H
0 QQ 0 0 0 0 0 ¤
—. av *'
0 (gx ~·· > ,- ¤·
§ M ·‘¤ gn I1`. S9 93
¤ I Z Ul Z »
§ O :1 U1 n
,0 _, z '-· a
an :*` FD 2 B
,0 E au G
*2*:** 5 §
'0T`·».~.~g §` P
‘“'~`*§§ ‘ ·
F~·°r~=..
§'_‘-5*88
‘§§ Q
U5
CU: W G3
as 0 0. 0
5.
00 °* E 2. 0
0.0 S ;, ¤· w 0
Ez 'Z § § Q ? § Q
mi gl -1 gi Q 3 3 Q
9.* -h 1 DD Dgg • D
um 3 g_ 5--< :}:0.-< > :,*•
Q? 3 cv H .0"‘• E .>
D 1 Za -•· II
-+0 Q h NN U»§§ 70 5- U1 70 :0 ¤¤ Ju xr Ju .

·"¥*‘ 0 3 $1 .%$1 Q 3 Q Q Q Q Q Q Q2 g
t¤f'|'I ¤
+P C
VA.
" ru
h
'I ‘¤ >
Q gg; >
·h
m um Ev
... R Ez;’°
···~ ... ·~·.. m0
"* N ‘···.. V
Fa I ~ 2* 0 {:5
v ° 2 = ET -¤ '·>
0 50 .0 - » 0 0%,*
'D
I 0 3* 1 Q 9 .0 g§8E
g 0 7* pq 3* ¥’ ~ ···z
"’ "’ °° °` E ··— % Q Q E
g g ¤· Q E 0* A 0. 0 >.
— — E #·- U1 -0 = »··— Ju
.° x x A `é 7: Q; rx x H r-4
:- L,} ug Jh X Q : Fx an- 'Q Q
Q 1 z N x X ·•·i Q (J!
3 Nc; N-; O`; > ** >< .. X ‘ X 0
'Z EL3 GQQ { G QN QJ Z E 0- E >¤ '£
E], xg :x5· : 0 ·- ····.. ‘···. w -¤ ·-4 **
sv ·· 3 ·· Q S 0 °t **1 °¤ Us ·¤ **1
un q& m°£& ~.4 m ua ~.» ..» -..2 -.2 Q-· —-JIT!
3 .
GQ Dv
¤ Q 0
Q ‘a· 0 0
O O"
0-1 E ··~
Z .3 Q Q 0 0 Ԥ
·-· bn § W r-1 n 4.0
I; Z. A M n u>
cc Q I3 M 'E w S
Q A Z- 0 -8 {Q rs "•
G, m 0 ··· S g g 5:.* 0 0
·— 5 3. <¤ 0 —0 5 5 2
0 0. 0., g L ...
¤~ ¤~ ~..__ *-·• J, 0 N 3
¤¤···.. U ‘* ... IZ . -•~ N
g g‘—··.(_r| 0* ¤ Z _; .:{* Q 1 _____ ru
F 9*9* gf: N g g g 5 § ;— E Q
' >-••-A r-• ` ·|·
9 ~~ .s1»—·; ,*2 an z a 2 .1. —"* 0 ·<·
B r·~···~ -..U'\¤ 1-; ···.. L L tp I: O 61 UI
S N5: I. N —··.. ···.._ ul .5 S ‘··· hp
5. 0 0 3% —$~; Q L? —· ~ 5.: -~> 0 0 ¤·.:
`,»..• 3 ` m _ ` _ `
8 Q 0 3* 00 S20 0 9 E 0 0 E Q ·> EZ
“* can ¤-;"u¤ v. D- » 5, 4 ° 5- »U
Z Z 3, :0 .51 0 0 · a~ *· `“ · *=*>
g g 0 00 0S; 0 0 0 S 0 0 0 S 05
c` ,_,,_, ,..(> Ly] \..r ua _' ar ‘··# g4 wd
Q1 g' 0 0 0
1 -2 % %
) .¤ 0* p ” I? -
`Q Q § § G 00 000 0 0 0 0 0 0 `§ E `§—
5 0 0 2 0 00 500 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 § 0,
‘S '1 1 3 -0 -. -.
·· ¤. va an n *3-% Q -•·. -•· E 3 Q 0 NU
Case 2:04-cv-00363-JWS Document 169-3 Fnled 05/19/2006 Page 2 012

Case 2:04-cv-00363-JWS

Document 169-3

Filed 05/19/2006

Page 1 of 2

Case 2:04-cv-00363-JWS

Document 169-3

Filed 05/19/2006

Page 2 of 2