Free Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1 :04-cv-O1 268-***-M PT Document 37 Filed O3/O2/2005 Page 1 of 3
IN TI-IE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
In re; ) Chapter ll
)
THE IT GROUP, INC , et ai ) Case No 0240118 (IVIFW)
Debtors, ) Iointly Administered
——-»~»»——··~——--~——————~#~»-i~—-—— I
IT LITIGATION TRUST, )
Plaintiff} ) Civ A No 04-CV-1268 (KAJ)
>
V >
)
DANIEL A D’AN`13§iLLO, FRANCIS J . )
HARVEY, JAMES C McGILL, )
RICHM W POGUE, PHILLIP B )
DOLAN, E MARTIN GIBSON, ROBERT )
F PUGLIESE, CHARLES W. SCHMIDT, )
JAMES DAVE WATKINS, ANTHONY )
I DeLUCA, HARRY J. SOOSE, THE )
CARLYLE GROUP, TI-E CARLYLE )
GROUP, L L C., CARLYLE PARTNERS ) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
II, L P , CARLYLE SBC PARTNERS, H, )
LP , CARLYLE INTERNATIONAL )
PARTNERS II, L.P , CARLYLE )
INTERNATIONAL PARTNERS IH, C/S )
INTERNATIONAL PARTNERS, )
CARLYLE INVESTMENT GROUP, L.P , )
CARLYLE-IT INTERNATIONAL )
PARTNERS, L P , CARLYLE·-IT )
BITERNATIONAL PARTNERS H, L..P , )
CARLYLE-ITT PARTNERS L P , and T C )
GROUP, L L C , )
Defendants )
DEFENDANTS’ JOINT MOTION TO DISMISS
FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM
Pursuant to Federal Role of Civil Procedure l2(b)(6), Defendants Daniel A
D’Aniello, Francis J Harvey, James C McGill, Richard W Pogue, Phillip B Dolan,
E Martin Gibson, Robert F Pugliese, Charles W Schmidt, James David Watkins,
Anthony J DeLuca, Harry J Soose, Jr, The Carlyle Group, The Carlyle Group L L.C ,
Carlyle Partners II, L P., Carlyle SBC Partners Il, L P , Carlyle International Partners H, L P ,

Case 1:04-cv-01268-***-MPT Document 37 Filed O3/O2/2005 Page 2 of 3
Carlyle International Partners, IH, C/S International Partners, Carlyle Investment Group,
LP , Carlyie~1'i" International Partners, LP, Carlyle-l"1` International Partners, H, L P ,
Carlyle—II Partners L P , and TC Group, L LC (collectively, "Dei:`endants"), by and
through their respective undersigned counsel, hereby move this Court to dismiss the First
Amended Complaint tiled on January 28, 2005 against Defendants as set forth in the
Amended Complaint at Civil Action No 0· District of Delaware for all of the reasons set forth in the supporting Brief.
Dated: March 2, 2005
Wilmington, Delaware Respectfully submitted,
_/s/
Mark D Collins (ID No. 298l)
Marcos A Raines (ID No 4450)
Ricrntans, Lawton & Fruoaa, P A
One Rodney Square, P O Box 551
Wilmington, Delaware l9899
Telephone; (302) 65l—7700
Facsimile: (302) 65l—7'/01
Eanail: I`&lTlOS{@,l'i£COl"i'l
Thomas L Patten
Laurie B Smilan
David A. Becker
La rr—rAM ann WAr‘r 555 Eleventh Street, N W , Suite l000
Washington, D C 20004—i304
Telephone: (202) 637-2200
'3`elecopier: (202) 637-220l
E-mail; [email protected]
Attorneys for Dejlznclants Daniel A D Lrlniello,
Francis J Harvey, Jaines C McGill, Ricliarcl
W Pogue, Philip B. Dolan, E. Martin Gibson,
Robert I? Pugliese, Cltarles W Sclnnidt, Jan-res
David Watltins, The Carlyle Group, Ellie Carlyle
Group LLC , Carlyle Partners IL L P , Carlyle
SBC Partners II, L P, Carlyle International
Partners III, C/S International l’artner.s·, Carlyle
Iirvestinent Group, LP, Carlyle—lT
International Partners, L P, Cartbtle~IT
International Partners Il, L P., Carlyle—I T
Partners L. P and T C Group, L L C.
2

Case 1 :04-cv-01268-***-MPT Document 37 Filed O3/O2/2005 Page 3 of 3
____/s/ _~_/s/
Ronald S. Gellert (ID No 4259) Roger D Anderson (ID No. 3480)
eeream, SEAMANS, Cireizin & Mizetorr, LLC S1vnr1~1, I The Towne Center 800 Delaware Avenue, "/th Floor, P O Box 410
4 East 8"‘ Street, Suite 200 Wilmington, DE 19899
Wilmington, DE i980I Telephone: (302.) 652-8400
Telephone: (302) 425-0430 Email: renderson@sl Email : rgelle1t@eclce:tsea1nens. com
Mark A Willard Charles A. De Monaco
Paul D. Steinman Kimberly L. Haddox
F. Timothy Grieco DICKEE MCCAMEY & CI-iIl..COT`E, PC.
ECI<,ER`l' Smivmns C1-rerun & Miartor, LLC Two PPG Place, Suite 400
US Steel Tower Pittsburgh, PA E5222
600 Grant Street, 44th Floor Telephone: (4} 2) 392-5523
lhttsbnrgli, PA SESZE 9-2788 Telecopier: (412) 392-53 67
Telephone: (4E.2)566—6000 Email; demo11ae@d1nclaw,com
Telecopier: (4E 2) 566-6099
Email; merl<.wiElar‘dg@,eson1.com Atf0rneys,f0r Defendant, Hcmy J Some, .]r
Afr0mey.s_;?11·‘ Dejencfcmt, Ani/tony J DeLuca
3