Free Motion to Dismiss/Lack of Subject Jurisdiction - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1 :04-cv-O1 268-***-M PT Document 35 Filed O3/O2/2005 Page 1 of 3
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
In re: ) Chapter Ai I
)
THE IT GROUP, INC., et al ) Case No O2»IOJ 18 (MTW)
Debtors, ) Jointly Aciministered
J
J
IT LITIGATION TRUST, )
Plaintiff, ) Civ. A No O4-CV-1268 (KAJ)
)
v- )
)
DANIEL A UANIELLO, FRANCIS I )
HARVEY, JAMES C McGILL, )
RICHARD W POGUE, PHILLIP B )
DOLAN, E MARTIN GIBSON, ROBERT )
F PUGLIESE, CHARLES W SCHJVILDT, )
JAIVES DAVID WATKINS, ANTHONY )
J DeLUCA, HARRY J. SOOSE, THE )
CARLYLE GROUP, THE CARLYLE )
GROUP, L L C , CARLYLE PARTNERS ) TURY TRIAL DEMANDED
H, L P , CARLYLE SBC PARTNERS, II, )
L P , CARLYLE INTERNATIONAL )
PARTNERS H, L P , CARLYLE )
INTERNATIONAL PARTNERS HI, C/S )
INTERNATIONAL PARTNERS, )
CARLYLE INVESTMENT GROUP, L P , )
CARLYLEJT INTERNATIONAL )
PARTNERS, LP , CARLYLE—IT )
INTERNATIONAL PARTNERS II, L P , )
CARLYLE-AIT PARTNERS L P , and T C )
GROUP, L L C., )
Defendants )
DEFENDANTS’ JOINT MOTION TO DISMISS
FOR LACK OF SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION
Pursuant to Federai Rule of Civil Procedure I2(b)(I), Defendants Daniel A
D’Aniello, Francis J. Harvey, James C MeGiIl, Richard W. Pogue, Philiip B Dolan,
E Martin Gibson, Robert F Pugiiese, Charies W Schmidt, James David Watkins,
Anthony J DeLuca, Harry .J Soose, Jr , The Carlyle Group, The Cariyie Group L L C ,
Carlyle Partners I1, L P , Carlyie SBC Partners I1, L P , Cariyle International Partners II, L P ,

Case 1 :04-cv-01268-***-MPT Document 35 Filed O3/O2/2005 Page 2 of 3
Carlyle International Partners, HI, C/S International Partners, Carlyle Investment Group,
L P , Carlyle—IT International Partners, LP, Carlyle-IT International Partners, II, L P,
Carlyie~l'1" Partners LP, and TC Group, LLC (collectively, "Det`endants"), by and
through their respective undersigned counsel, hereby move this Court to dismiss Counts}
through V and IX of the First Amended Complaint tiled on January 28, 2005 against
Defendants as set forth in the Amended Complaint at Civil Action No 04-l268 in the United
States District Court for the District of Delaware for all of the reasons set forth in the
supporting Brief
Dated; March 2, 2005 Respectfully submitted,
__/s/ /s/
Ronald S Geliert (ID No. 4259) Roger D Anderson (ID No 3480)
Ecuear, Sanivutiws, Crianm & Miztitorr, LLC Stvriru, Iearzensrsm & Foiuow LLP
The Towne Center 800 Delaware Avenue, 7th Floor,
4 East 8°§‘ Street, Suite 200 PO Box 410
Wilmington, DE l980l Wilmington, DE l9899
Telephone: (302) 425-0430 Telephone; (302) 652-8400
Email: rgellert@,ecl Mark A. Willard Charles A De Monaco
Paul D Steinman KimberiyL Hacidox
F Timothy Gneoo Dream McC.ruvtar & Ci-ra.cor12,P C
Ecruzat Sizaivinus Ci—raiuN & Misteor, LLC Two PPG Place, Suite 400
US. Steel Tower Pittsburgh, PA l5222
600 Grant Street, 44th Floor Telephone; (rtl 2) 392-5 523
Pittsburgh, PA i52l9—2788 Telecopier: (412) 392-5367
Telephone: (4l2) 566-6000 Email: demonac@,dn1claw.c0m
Telecopier: (412) 566—6099
Email; m;u»]q_wii1&y-d{;QaSCm_cOm At!or11e_y.s]‘or Dejhndrnir, Hcrrijy J Soose, Jr
Aimrneys for Dejizncfnrrr, Anthony J DeLuca
2

Case 1:04-cv-01268-***-MPT Document 35 Filed O3/O2/2005 Page 3 of 3
fsl
Mark D. Collins (TD No 2981)
Marcos A Ramos (ED No 4450)
Rrcrmzins, Lrwron & FLNGER, P A.
One Rodney Square
P O. Box 55}
Wilmington, Delaware i9S99
Telephone: (302) 651-7700
Facsimile: (302) 65l·770“l
Email: ramos@ri£com
Thomas L. Patten
LaurieB Smilan
David A Becker
LA`§l·§A1\»1 imo Wnrians, LLP
555 Eleventh Street, N W , Suite 1000
Washington, D C. 200044 304
Telephone: (202) 637—2200
Telecopierz (202) 637—220l
E-mail. to1n.geaen(cQ,lw.co1n
Airorne ysi for Defemlants Daniel A.
D klniello, Francis J Harvey, James C (
A/fcGill, Ricliarcl W Pogne, Phillip B Dolan,
E Marlin Gibson, Roberr}? Pugliese,
Charles W Seluniclz, James David Watkins,
The Carbrle Group, The Carlyle Group
L L C , Carlyle Parlnerzs IL LP , Carlyle
SBC Parlners IL L P , Carlyle lnremalional
Partners H, L P , Carlyle lnrernarional
Parlners HL C/S lnlernalional Partners,
Carlyle lnyesnnenl Group, LP, Carlyle—1T
Inleirnalioival Parlners, L P , Carlyle-! T
lniernalional Parlners ll, LP, Carl_yle—lT
Parrners L P and TC Group, L L C
3