Free Exhibits - District Court of Colorado - Colorado

Case 1:03-cv-02579-RPM

Document 148-5

Filed 01/11/2007

Page Page 1 of 5

of5

Westiaw
Slip

Copy Copy 2006

Page

Slip

WL

2329460

Cite as Slip

Informatica Briefs

Informatica

and

Documents

Discovery Objects the

Order
papers

carefUlly considered arguments

Informatica Integration
citation
is

Corp
currently
States

Business

Data

parties the

and
legal

and
cause

Inc.N.D.Cal.2006.Only

relevant

and
hereby

appearing

Court

DENIES

Defendants

United

CourtN.D

California

objections

AFFIRMS
Court

the Discovery

INFORMATICA
Corporation

Delaware The
District

may
to

modify
ruling be

or on

set

aside

any

portion

of

nondispositive erroneous see also

BUSINESS

DATA
known
as

pre-trial

clearly

INC

formerly

Acta Defendants

Inc

contrary

to

law
City

72a
County of San Cir.1991
court
left

e.g
951

Delaware
andRelated

Grimes
F.2d

and 9th

Counterclaims 02-3378

236
if

clearly after

No

JSW

erroneous the

evidence

definite been

firm

Aug

2006

conviction United States

mistake

395
Albert

68

Gypsum L.Ed 746

Co

Lukas West

Sieber

Aparna

Rajagopal-Durbin The
dispute waiver
to at

Fenwick Shanberg
Carolyn

LLP
Coie

issue concerns
relies

the scope

of

Perkins

LLP

San David Douglas

the

on

advice

Chang Darren David Schumann
West Fenwick

Donnelly Lynn

counsel

defend

allegations

Pasahow

infringement attorney Phil

November

2000
advise Albert

hired

Fenwick

CA
West

Townsend

Maher
for

LLP

Palo

Alto

CA

and

Crew

LLP

Townsend
patents

to

several

Informatica opinions Informatica

Mr
27

Theodore Greco Townsend
Saffer

Herhold
Robert

Furniss

written

on

June
this

2002
lawsuit

July

15

and Crew

2002

CA
Townsend
Joseph

ACTA
BODI Jr
its

BODI
had

acquired

ACTA

Townsend

and Leonard

Crew

on August Fumiss with
since

as

Denver Townsend
Francisco

CO
and

patent

litigation

1996

After
to

Crew Defendants

LLP

purchasing represent

ACTA
BODI
in

BODI

asked

Mr
June

Furniss

CA

lawsuit opinions
in

communicating

2002

Mr

ORDER DENYING OBJECTIONS AND
DISCOVERY
JEFFREY

Albert

has with occurred issued

conversations

on

background

THE

issues

which
Court the Integration

on

at Townsend November 14

After

WHITE
the Business

District
is

claim asked

construction Riter an
to

ruling attorney provide

August

Now
Defendant

2005 BODI
Inc
not
affiliated in

Bruce

who

Data

Townsend
light that

BODI
Judge
part

ACTA
James and

known
to

as

Acta

Technology

Inc
in

opinions

the Larson

order

issued

BODI
14
granting

represents

has product
to

dated part

communications and

and

by
their

Mr

Albert

in

motion

Mr

Riter

2007

Thomson/West

No

to

Orig

Works

rIB1T
https

//web2

.westlaw.comlprint/printstream.aspxsvSplitdestinationatputid%7b70..

1/10/2007

Case 1:03-cv-02579-RPM

Document 148-5

Filed 01/11/2007

Page Page 2 of 5

of

Slip

Copy

Page

Slip

Copy 2006

N.D.Cal

Cite as Slip

Copy

opinions

but or

has

refused

to trial

produce counsel
at

prevent party

such defends
its

the

court

held

communications

work

by

an

Townsend
the

attorney-client attorney-client

communication
privilege regarding
as to
all

Discovery

Order

Judge

Larson

held both

that

communications Id

same

subject

matter

BODI
and the opinion

attorney-client

pre
of
its

communications on which
defense

on

the

BODI
work was communicated which

As
cited

authority

its

holding

advice-of-counsel the

on
to

held
is

same

subject

because requirement receive party opens
entire to to
is

continuing care

the

BODI
any
subjection waiver alike arguing waiver
to
its

any
attorney-client Judge
to

documents

reference

exercise continuing of

and
Therefore once

on
further

that

Larson opinion
to

held
trial

the counsel

the defense inspection course of the the

applied

BOD
Judge

the erred

Order by
the

Larson

Consequently
privilege points or

waiver

of covers
all

counsel

work

product

including also not limited the matter received of

up
to

through the advice

This discovery

Court

must apply
dispute See F.3d re

to

this

waiver opinion subject opinions

EchoStar 1294
1298

encompassed
that

Communications Fed.Cir.2006 Sys

Corp
quoting

advice
the
that

means must
be

that

Medtronic

Inc

F.3d

1294

even

those other

from
counsel...

Fed.Cir.200l
deciding materials materials

Federal
particular in

when
or patent other
if

attorneys of gained

opinion
test

whether
are

requires
to that as to

knowledge
the can

discoverable
to

case

infringer

relating

an

issue

patent
that to will

law on
of

matter

must

be

revealed

so

Where
advice
willful

party counsel

announces
response
it

make
reliance

own

determination

whether

of

an

assertion

was reasonable

infringement In re

waives

the

attorney-client
at

privilege dispute

EchoStar
the scope of

1299

Akeva
found privilege

243

F.Supp.2d defendants respect required received ..
trial

at

423
waived
the
issue

Akeva

the

court

concerns

waiver

In

re

EchoStar

the

defendant

produced which

an an

and
all

to

disclose
relating to

opinion opinion chose

from from
not EchoStar counsel with outside rely chose
it

counsel
on

EchoStar

infringement defendants

even

if

from and even
if letter

Circuit
to rely

attorneys

when

on

the

of

pre-date
opinion

or

post-date Id

in-house privilege

regard
relating to

to

communications
including in-house

the with

any same

attorney-client

subject

matter
it

The

In
light

re

EchoStar

especially

communications
counsel...
at

counsel citing

other

of

case
proposed exclude

does

not

1399

LLC 418
lead could
to

provide on the

any support
scope given of of

for

BODIs
to

Mizuno

243 The
the the

F.Supp.2d reasoned

423

waiver
trial

or

M.D.N.C.2003
selective

court

advice the matter

counsel

on

the

same

subject Albert

waiver
result for

may
party

opinion Court not
clearly finds

by

Mr

inequitable
its

Accordingly
rnling

Judge contrary

Larsons law

was

erroneous denies

privilege

on

unfavorable

advice

Id

at

1301

To

Therefore

Defendants

objections

2007

Thomson/West

No

Claim

to

Orig

Works

https//web2

.westlaw.eoSprint/printstream.aspxsvSplitdestinationatputith%7b7O..

1/10/2007

Case 1:03-cv-02579-RPM

Document 148-5

Filed 01/11/2007

Page Page 3 of 5

of

Slip

Copy

Page

Slip

Cite

Copy 2006 WL as Slip Copy

N.D.Cal

and

the

Order

14

Corporations Discovery

Request
to

to

Re-Open

Liability

2006
should

And

Submit

New

Report

Dec

2006
Nevertheless require pertaining explained
this

not of

be

construed

to

2006
and

3761479
Affidavit

Trial Brief

Memorandum
on Merits

wholesale
to in
trial

or

litigation

strategy

As the court Computer

Discovery

2006
3761475
Trial Business Opposition the
to

Concolve F.R.D
that

Inc

2006 and
Integration Corp.s Counterclaim Patent

Memorandum
Data
Informatica

Corp
counsels of

224

S.D.N.Y.2004
on advice
of
in

trial

Defendant
Inc.s Brief That

reasonableness

reliance

must be
the context
trial

Dismiss

disclosed of counsel strategy enforcement

even

if

it

on

the

Unenforceability

374

preparation surely concerning
in

But

at

the

same
the

time

Dec
3761476
Trial

2006 and and
Affidavit of

Motion
Corporations Brief
to

validity not implicate therefore opinions matter Albert of

advice-of-counsel required advice given
to

that ways defense trial

Support
is

Court

Excercising

Its

Discretion on the

BODI

Dismiss Patent

Bodis

Counterclaims

374

disclose address

or

Dec

2006
3761474
Statement Trial Filing

2006
withhold or
trial

Mr
and
not
as

may
to litigation

Management 2006 and
Affidavit

Nov
Trial Brief
in

2006
Motion
Support
to

communications
strategy

that

3609589

implicate

the Larson

of
Strike

Plaintiff

defense

Thus

Magistrate opinions
to

ordered and

Informatica Asserted

Corporations Opinions

Motion

Newly

legal

Invalidity in

Declaration of
to

strategy
relies

unrelated

the

on from

which

BODI
to

of

P.J

Kelly

Support

Objects Informatica

may
to

be

be

Data

Integration

Inc.s
Partial

Opposition

produced

Informatica

Corp.s Motion

Summary Judgment
Motion
Objects
to

12 2006 BODI
the
is

to

produce log

all

2006
with

2882310

Trial

documents

and Order no

and

Affidavit Inc.s

Defendant
Opposition

Data
Corp.s of

later

than

900 a.m on

Integration

Informatica
to

Friday August

11

Motion
Supplemental

Administrative Declaration

Relief

Allow
to this

Objections

Evidence Document

IT

Sep

28

2006
2882309

Image

of

PDF
N.D.Cal.2006
Informatica Integration
Slip

2006

Trial

Motion
Business
to

Corp
Inc

Objects

Data

and
Integration Inc.s
Strike

Defendant
Opposition

Data

Informatica

Copy 2006
and
Related

N.D.Cal
Documents

Motion
this

to

2006
Declaration of Informatica Objects

Image

of

Document

PDF
2646127
in to

Briefs

Back

to

top

2006 Mcgoveran

of

Support Business

2006
Expert

3761220

Informaticas

Supplemental

Opposition Inc.s

Integration

McGoveran

Dec
Statement

2006
Joint

Motion and
Inequitable

Judgment

2006 Case

WL
Management

Trial Conference

Filing

Noninfringement

Aug

Dec

25 2006
2006 and
Affidavit

Image of 2702659
Trial

Document

PDF
Data
Informatica

2006
2006 and
Integration

Memorandum
Objects
to Partial

Memorandum
Defendant
Inc.s Business

Defendant
Opposition

Data

Integration Corporations

Motion

for

Summary

2007

Thomson/West

No

Claim

to

Orig U.S Govt Works

https//web2

.westlaw.com/print/printstream.aspxsvSplitdestinationatputid%7b70..

1/10/2007

Case 1:03-cv-02579-RPM

Document 148-5

Filed 01/11/2007

Page Page 4 of 5

Slip

Page

Slip

Cite

WL Copy as Slip Copy

Judgment Document 2006 and
to for

25

Image

this

Original

PDF
2702660
Trial Corporations Integration of

2006

WL

Image of 1785805 Reply

Document
Trial
to

PDF
Informatica

Memorandum
Opposition Inc.s

Corporations Counterclaims
this

Second

Amended
Image

Informatica

2006

Business

Data Judgment

Motion and

Document

PDF
1785881
Trial

Summary

2006 and
Its

Memorandum
Response
in

Inequitable

Conduct Document

Aug

25

2006 Awez

Original

Affidavit

Informaticas
to

Support

of

Image of 2006
Support Opposition

PDF
Declaration
in

Motion

Compel

May

2006 Memorandum
Data

Image of 2006
and Integration

Document 1785880

PDF
Trial

Business
to

Objects

Data

Integration

Inc.s
Partial

Informatica

Corp.s

Defendant
Inc.s Brief

Summary
of

Aug

24 2006
Declaration

Image

Document 2006

PDF
John Data
to

Motion
this

to

Compel

2006
Pleading

Image of Second and

Document

PDF
1785804
to First

Kelly Integration

Support Inc.s
Partial

of Informatica

2006

WL

Corp.s

Amended
Counterclaim

Motion

for

Summary
Document
Trial

24

2006

Original

Image

this

2006
2006 and
Objection Granting Original
to

Image

PDF
Memorandum
to

Document 2006 Case

PDF
WL
2632152
Trial Statement
Joint

Motion

Plaintiffs

Response
Judge
to

Defendants

Management
Original

Conference

Apr

21

Magistrate

Larsons

2006 2006
2006 and

Part

Motion
this

Compel

WL

Document Image of 397999 Trial

PDF
Strike

Image

2006
Kelly Integration

2525282
Support Inc.s of

John

Data Data

Integration Patent Rule

Inc.s Claims Final Original
in

Motion

to

Asserted Local

Corporations Infringement

Motion and

Summary Judgment

of

3-6

Non-Infringement

Inequitable

Aug

Jan

23

2006

Image

of

this

Document

2006
2006 and
Integration

Image of 2579819
Trial

Document

PDF
Memorandum
Data
of

PDF
2006 and
Opposition Integration Patent Final Original Claims
to

397998

Trial

Memorandum
Corporations

Defendant
Inc.s

Business

Plaintiff

Motion and

Summary Judgment
and

Defendant Motion
Plaintiff to Strike

Data

Non-Infringement

Conduct

Memorandum
Civ Document 2006 and
Integration

of

Points

YFed
Image

Corporations

56 Aug

2006
Trial Business
to

Jan
Image of Document
Trial Informatica

20

2006

PDF
2429320

PDF
Corporations

Memorandum
Data
Judge

2006 and

WL
to

397996

Defendant
Inc.s

Plaintiff

Magistrate

Opposition Integration

Defendant Motion
to

Data
Shorten Patent
its

Larsons Order Granting in Part Motion to and Request Stay Civil 72-2 28 Jul 28 2006

Compel

Motion
Original
Plaintiff

to

Strike

Claims
3.6

636b1A
Document 1785882 Defendant
Inc.s

Informatica Contentions

Image of 2006 and
Integration Informaticas Original

Final

WL

Memorandum
Business

Original

Data Opposing

2003

Image of this Document 25278093 Trial
Corporations

PDF
Plaintiff

Informatica Construction

Motion

Image 2632153 on

to Compel Document

30
Status

Under Image of 25278092

Patent

Lr

4-5c

25

PDF
19

2003
2003

Original

Document
Trial

PDF
Inc.s

2006
Report

WL

Representative

Business

Integration

2007

No Claim

to

Orig

Works

https

1/10/2007

Case 1:03-cv-02579-RPM

Document 148-5

Filed 01/11/2007

Page Page 5 of 5

of

Slip

Copy 2006

Page

Slip

WL

2329460

N.D.Cal

Cite

as

Slip

Copy

Responsive

Claim 18

Patent

L.R

4-5b Aug

Document 2003

WL WL

25278066

of

Mcgoveran 2003 25278091
Corporations Brief Patent

Pleading Opening Claim

Informatica Construction

L.R

4-5a

2003
2003 and

Original

WL

Image of 25278090
Informatica

Document

PDF
Reply
to

Affidavit

Amended
Image of 2003 Answer
Counterclaim

Counterclaims
this

23

2003 Amended
and
of
this

Document 25278089

PDF
Trial

Pleading

to

First

Complaint

May
25278088

2003

Original

Image

Document 2003 Management Order
Trial Filing

Case Proposed
of

Statement

and Image

Apr WL

11

2003
Trial

Document 2003 and

PDF
25278087 Motion

Memorandum

Affidavit

Defendant
Inc.s

Integration Informatica Local Rules

Motion
to

to

Compel
with the Patent of

Corporation

Comply

10 2003

Original

Image

Document 2002

PDF
WL
Complaint
Original Trial Patent Infringement

Amended
17

2002
2002

Image of

Document Pleading

PDF

WL
Jul

for

15

2002

Image of this Document 302cv03378 Docket 2002 Inmon

PDF
15 2002
Declaration of Business Objects

WL
in

Support Inc.s

Data

Integration

Claim Construction

2002
Expert Original

002
Report of
this

WL
of

Informaticas

McGoveran

2002

Image

Document

PDF

END OF

2007

ThomsonlWest

No Claim

to

Orig U.S

Works

https//web2

.west1aw.conprint/printstream.aspxsvSp1itdestinationatputid%7b7O..

1/10/2007