Free Exhibit List - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 1 of 14

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF FEDERAL CLAIMS SCOTT TIMBER CO., Plaintiff, v. THE UNITED STATES, ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

Case No. 05-708C (Judge Lettow)

Defendant.

DEFENDANT'S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST Pursuant to paragraph 13 of Appendix A to the Rules of the United States Court of Federal Claims, defendant submits its list of proposed exhibits as follows: Exhibit No. Bates No. Official Government Documents 1. 816-969 Record of Decision and Standards and Guidelines for Amendments to the Survey and Manage, Protection Buffer, and other Mitigation Measures Standards and Guidelines (155 pages) Report from the Forest Ecosystem Management Team ("FEMAT Report") Appendix J-2 to Final Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement

2.

3.

Documents Relating To Timber Industry Participation In Contract Development 4. Attendance List At Forest Timber Sale Contract Meeting 8/4/71 (1 page) Memo to Regional Foresters re: proposed provisions to the 2400-6 timber contract 3/19/71 (2 page) Letter from National Forest Products Association to

5.

6.

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 2 of 14

timber pages) 7.

Forest Service re: proposed provisions to federal contracts, with industry input 10/12/71 (6

Forest Service Memo to Regional Foresters, regarding proposed provisions to federal timber contracts 11/2/71 (4 pages) Notes from Staff Meeting 11/23/1987 (2 pages) Forest Service position paper on Timber Sale Contract Review 11/23/87 (9 pages) Timber Sale Contract Revision 12/87 (4 pages) Notes re: Timber Sale Contract Provisions undated (3 pages) Comments on the National Forest Products Association Summary of Meeting 12/4/87 (1 page) Electronic mail message regarding Contract Revision Meeting between Forest Service and Timber Industry 12/7/87 (1 page) Letter From Idaho Forest Industries, Inc. to Forest Service re revised timber sale contract provisions. 12/29/87 (2 pages) Letter From Forest Service to National Forest Products Association 11/1/89 (5 pages) Letter From National Forest Products Association to Forest Service 7/23/90 (3 pages) Letter From National Forest Products Association to Forest Service 7/23/90 (3 pages) Letter From National Forest Products Association 12/4/89 (6 pages) Letter from National Forest Products Association 1/5/90 (4 pages)

8. 9.

10. 11.

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

19.

2

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 3 of 14

20.

Letter from National Forest Products Association 5/1/90 (4 pages) Letter from Forest Service to American Forest and Paper Association 10/31/00 (13 pages) Letter from American Forest Resource Council 3/22/01 (2 pages) Memorandum concerning revisions to the 2400-6T Contract 3/29/01 (3 pages) Contract Documents

21.

22.

23.

24.

3834-3852

Text for newspaper ad and Timber Sale Prospectus, Umpqua National Forest, Pigout Sale, notes possible delay of award due to period for appeal of the decision not expired Procurement request and copy of ad in the Roseburg News Review: National Forest Timber for Sale, Umpqua National Forest, Pigout Sale Timber Sale Contract, Pigout Contract # 087459 Letter re: Modification of Pigout Timber Sale Contract 2/14/00 (3 pages) Letter re: Blanket Payment Bond - Pigout Contract 8/16/99 (1 page) Decrease rider, Bond 235115 061356 from $101,000 to $5050 2/18/00 (2 pages) Surety Bond Rider, Liberty Replaces Wausau 1/1/02 (2 pages) Increase rider, Bond 2351 15 061356 from $5050 to $101,000 6/12/02 (2 pages) Letter reconfirming bids on Pigout, Jigsaw, and Whitebird Timber Sales for 90 days 5/11/99 (1 page) Letter - Change of termination date of Pigout Timber Sale Contract No. 087459 due to delay awaiting 3

25.

3853

26. 27. 28.

3877-3971 3973-3975 4036

29.

4037-4038

30.

4039-4040

31.

4041-4042

32.

4105

33.

4106-4107

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 4 of 14

resolution of lawsuit, other instructions 34. Surety Rider 35. 4111 Letter - Pigout Timber Sale, Contract No. 087459, Notification of Judge Dwyer order 08/26/99 that enjoined the Umpqua NF from approving a plan of operations for Pigout Timber Sale Letter - Pigout Timber Sale, reducing downpayment on Pigout TS 12/28/99 (1 page) Letter - Pigout Timber Sale - Modification of contract to add CT9.110 2/3/00 Letter enclosing agreement to modify Pigout contract 2/10/00 (1 page) Letter Modification of Pigout Timber Sale Contract to Reduce Performance Bond 2/14/00 (1 page) Letter re: Pigout Timber Sale Contract enclosing decrease riders 3/8/00 (1 page) Letter - Pigout TS, no longer enjoined under ONRC Action lawsuit, is available for operation 6/11/02 (2 pages) Letter ­ Pigout TS returning performance bond to $101,000 6/12/02 (1 page) Analysis of Effects of Survey and Manage Results for the Pigout Timber Sale Letter - Pigout TS, annual plan of operation for Pigout, no logging activity planned for 2003 season Confidential Information Letter - Pigout Timber Sale Contract No. 087459, claim in the amount of $1,445,256 plus interest, plus attached charts of damages 4109-4110 Letter - Pigout Timber Sale - Contract No. 087459, enclosed signed Contracts, Perf. Bond, and

36.

4113

37.

4114

38.

4117

39.

4118

40.

4119

41.

4136-4137

42.

4138

43.

4139-4140

44.

4141

45.

4152-4178

4

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 5 of 14

46.

4186

Letter - on 11/10/2004 I received your clam dated 11/9/2004 and will not be able to render a decision by March 10, 2005 but will render a decision by May 9, 2005 Letter - Plikat Logging plans to start falling in unit 44 of Pigout June 20, 2005, operation is dangerous, please keep unauthorized parties out of the area Letter - Pigout Timber Sale, annual plan of operations Analysis of Effects of Survey & Manage Results For The Pigout Timber Sale Text for newspaper ad Timber Sale Prospectus, Umpqua National Forest, Pigout Sale Timber Sale Contract, Pigout No. 087459 Letter ­ Pigout TS adds CT9110 to Pigout Contract 2/3/00 (1 page) Letter Pigout TS - Reduction of Performance Bond 2/14/00 (4 pages) Letter - reconfirmation of bids on Pigout, Jigsaw, and Whitebird timber sales for an additional 90 days Letter - reducing downpayment ­ 12/28/99 (1 page) Letter - Pigout Sale, annual Plan of operations for 2003, no logging activity planned Letter - Pigout Timber Sale, General Plan of Operations for 2004-2006 Contracting Officer's Findings and Decision, Pigout TS Jigsaw Sale ­ Invitation for bid and Sale Prospectus

47.

4210

48. 49.

4263 4726-4728

50. 51.

6064-6083 6065-6083

52. 53.

6168-6262 6263

54.

6269-6272

55.

6384

56. 57.

6392 6442

58.

6443

59. 60.

4189-4198 9274-9358

61.

9359

Performance Bond for Jigsaw Timber Sale 7/16/99 (2 5

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 6 of 14

pages) 62. 63. 64. 9360 9427-9522 9523-9525 Performance Bond No. 223-173-01376 7/16/99 (1 page) Jigsaw Timber Sale Contract Agreement to Modify Jigsaw Timber Sale Contract by adding CT0.110 2/14/00 (3 pages) Award letter - change of termination date of Jigsaw Timber Sale Contract No. 08467 due to delay awaiting resolution of lawsuit, other instructions 7/8/99 (2 pages) Letter - approved copies of contract and performance bond for Jigsaw are enclosed. Designations of FSR and ER Letter - Jigsaw, Pigout , Whitebird. In an order dated August 26, 1999, U.S. District Judge Dwyer enjoined the Umpqua National Forest from approving a plan of operations for or proceeding with operations of above sale 8/31/99 (2 pages) Letter ­ Jigsaw TS reducing down payment to $6684 12/28/99 (1 page) Letter ­ Jigsaw TS Modification of contract to add CT9.110 2/3/00 (1 page) Letter - Jigsaw TS ­ enclosing agreement to modify contract to add CT9.110 2/10/00 (2 pages) Modification of Jigsaw TS - to reduce bond to $15,700 2/14/00 (1 page) Letter - Jigsaw TS this is annual plan of operations Court Document No. 02-35316, D. C. No. CV-01-03079-AA Memorandum, Not for Publication, Headwaters v. USBLM Letter - Jigsaw Timber Sale, Contract No. 087467, is now available for operations, performance bond will 6

65.

9540-9541

66.

9543-9544

67.

9545-9546

68.

9548

69.

9549

70.

9552

71.

9553

72. 73.

9572 9578-9580

74.

9581

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 7 of 14

need to be restored 75. 9596-9622 Confidential Information letter - Jigsaw Timber Sale Contact No. 087467, claim in the amount of $3,489,380 plus interest, plus attached charts of damages Letter - I received your claim 11/10/04 regarding Jigsaw, I will render a decision by 01/09/05 Letter - Jigsaw TS #087467, Scott Timber Co., plans to have no activity on Jigsaw TS this operating season (3/4/05) Letter - Jigsaw Sale, Contract No. 087467, Contracting Officer's Findings and Decision, in response to claim dated 11/09/04 Timber Sale Prospectus, Umpqua National Forest, Whitebird Sale Notice of National Forest Timber for Sale, Umpqua National Forest, the Whitebird Sale, published in the Roseburg News Review Whitebird Timber Sale Contract Agreement to Modify Whitebird Contract by adding CT9.110 - Temporary Reduction of Performance Bond 2/14/00 (3 pages) Performance Bond 2351 18 061356 for Whitebird Timber Contract 7/16/99 (3 pages) Addition of Whitebird to Blanket Payment Bond 8/24/99 (1 page) Whitebird performance bond decreased from $147,000 to $23,750 2/14/00 (2 pages) Whitebird performance bond increased from $23,750 to $147,000 6/10/03 (2 pages) Request for Refund of Timber Sale Deposits $143,276 7

76.

9623

77.

9630

78.

9633-9642

79.

9899-9918

80.

9919-9920

81. 82.

9949-10094 10096-10098

83.

10118-10120

84.

10121

85.

10122-10123

86.

10126-10127

87.

10141-10143

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 8 of 14

Whitebird Timber Sale 1/19/00 (3 pages) 88. 10187 Letter ­ Whitebird TS requesting reduction of down payment 11/30/99 (1 page) Letter ­ Whitebird TS reducing downpayment 12/28/99 (1 page) Letter - Award letter, change of termination date of Whitebird Timber Sale Contract No. 087475 due to delay awaiting resolution of lawsuit, other instructions, and copy of receipt for certified mail Letter ­ enclosing decrease riders of performance bonds 3/8/00 (1 page) Letter ­ enclosing increase bond riders for performance bond 6/12/03 (1 page) Letter - Whitebird TS, Contract No. 087475, sale is available for operations except unit 40, and copy of Certified Mail Receipt Letter - I received your claim dated 11/9/04 regarding Whitehead Timber Sale, will render a decision by Jan. 2005 Letter- Whitebird Sale, Contract No. 087475, Contracting Officer's Findings and Decision Forestry Forum Newsletter, Sept. 11, 1998 Forestry Forum Newsletter, Dec. 16, 1998 Forestry Forum Newsletter, March 19, 1999 310-311 312-314 S & M Conference call notes 1/12/00 (2 pages) Request for info re: how much $ will each forest need to comply with S & M requirements 2/11/00 (3 pages) Umpqua Nat'l Forest response re S & M budget info request 2/29/00 (4 pages)

89.

10188

90.

10180-10182

91.

10194

92.

10221

93.

10219-10220

94. 9, 95.

10261

10267 - 10278

96. 97. 98. 98. 99.

100.

315-318

8

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 9 of 14

101.

448-453

FS/BLM Memorandum re: Implementation of Survey and Manage Component 2 "Survey prior to GroundDisturbing Activities" Standard and Guidelines. 11/1/96 (6 pages) FS/BLM Memorandum re: Implementation of Survey and Manage Component 2 and Protection Buffer Standards and Guidelines Regarding "Survey Prior to Ground-Disturbing Activities" (5 pages) Memorandum From Survey and Manage SEIS Team 9/23/99 (4 pages) Interim Report - Status of Survey and Manage Species on Enjoined Sales January, 2000 (5 pages) Letter - Survey and Manage Survey Protocols Bryophytes with attached Survey Strategy 2 Protocol Version 2.0 (13 pages) Memo - Survey and Manage Protocols Lichens, with attached Survey Protocol for Compinent 2 Lichen Pseudocyphellaria rainierensis Version 2.0, March 12, 1998 Letter - Survey and Manage Survey Protocols Mollusks, with attached version 2.0 Survey Protocol for Aquatic Mollusk Species from the Northwest Forest Plan Version 2.0 - October 29, 1997 Letter - Field Review of Management Recommendations: Survey and Manage Fungi and Bryophytes Memo - Extension of Draft Interim Guidance for Survey and Manage Component 2 Species: Red Tree Vole, with attached 11/04/1996 memo direction Letter - Survey and Manage/Protection Buffer Survey Questionnaire Letter - Survey and Manage Survey protocols Vascular, with attached Survey Protocols for Survey Manage Strategy 2 Vascular Plants V. 2.0 December 9

102.

487-491

103.

507-510

104.

518-522

105.

3099-3111

106.

3128-3140

107.

3206-3271

108.

3272-3274

109.

3288-3307

110.

3324-3332

111. and

3333-3432

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 10 of 14

1998 112. 3472-3475 Umpqua National Forest Standards for Non-vascular Plant and Survey & Manage Species, re: Forest guidance on protocols and management recommendations Letter - Survey and Manage Survey Protocols Protection Buffer Bryophytes v. 2.0, with attached Survey Protocols for Protection Buffer Bryophytes version 2.0 Memo - Transmittal of Survey Protocol for Seven Survey and Manage Protection Buffer Fungi (v. 1.3), with attached Survey Protocols Version 1.3 Letter - Survey and Manage Protocol - Oregon Red Tree Vole (Arborimus lonicaudus) Version 2.0, with attached survey protocol Version 2.0 Survey and manage Fungi, Lichen, & Bryophytes found in the Enjoined Sales Letter - Survey and Manage Survey Protocols Mollusks, with attached version 2.0 Survey Protocol for Aquatic Mollusk Species form the Northwest Forest Plan Version 2.0 - October 29, 1997 Letter - Survey and Manage Survey Protocols - Fungus, with attached Version 2.0 Survey Protocols for Fungi Letter - Survey and Manage Survey Protocols Vascular, with attached Survey Protocols for Survey Manage Strategy 2 Vascular Plants V 2.0, December 1998 Umpqua National Forest Standard for Nonvascular Plant and Survey & Manage Species, re: Forest guidance on protocols and management recommendations Letter - Survey and Manage Survey Protocols Protection Buffer Bryophytes v. 2.0 with attached Survey Protocols for Protection Buffer Bryophytes 10

113.

3476-3522

114.

3523-3534

115.

3535-3570

116.

7289-7290

117.

8041-8106

118.

8113-8122

119.

8168-8267

120.

8307-8310

121.

8311-8357

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 11 of 14

version 2.0 122. 8358-8369 Memo - Transmittal of Survey Protocol for Seven Survey and Manage Protection Buffer Fungi (v.1.3) With attached Survey Protocols Version 1.3 Letter - Survey and Manage Protocol Oregon Red Tree Vole (Arborimus lonicaudus) Version 2.0 with attached survey protocol Version 2.0 Attachment 1-RTV Survey Protocol Revisions, replaces sections in Version 2.0 FS/BLM Memorandum re: Interim Guidance for Survey and Manage Component 2 Species: Red Tree Vole 11/4//96 (5 pages) Biology and Interim Survey Protocol for the Red Tree Vole September, 1996 (9 pages) Letter re: Red Tree Vole Surveys 1/24/00 (1 page)

123.

8370-8405

124.

12843-12847

125.

454-458

126.

462-480

127.

529

128.

7370

FY 2000 Red Tree Vole Climbing Needs: Diamond Lake R.D. Survey and Manage Botany Surveys Survey and Manage Red Tree Vole Surveys Survey and Manage Mollusk Surveys Solicitation for Survey Services (20 pages) Various Botany (fungi, lichen bryophyte) Surveys for Units 1,2,3,4,5,7,8 of the Jigsaw Timber Sale Various Red Tree Vole Surveys for Units 1,2,3,4,5,7,8 of the Jigsaw Timber Sale Various Terrestrial Mollusk Surveys for Units 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8, and a right-of-way on the Jigsaw Timber Sale

129. 130. 131. 132. 133.

4498-4587 4588-4622 4623-4725 7344-7364 12525-12559

134.

12560-12596

135.

12597-12736

11

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 12 of 14

136.

12849-12900

Various Red Tree Vole Surveys for Whitebird Units 9, 25, 32, 33, 40, 41 Various Botany Surveys for Whitebird Units 9, 25, 27, 32, 33, 40, 41 Various Mollusk surveys for Whitebird Units 9, 25, 27, 32, 33, 40, 41, 42(R/W)

137.

12901-12947

138.

12948-13087

12

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 13 of 14

Respectfully submitted, GREGORY G. KATSAS Acting Assistant Attorney General JEANNE E. DAVIDSON Director s/Bryant G. Snee BRYANT G. SNEE Deputy Director OF COUNSEL: Rebecca Harrison Office of General Counsel USDA - Forest Service 1734 Federal Building 1220 S.W. Third Avenue Portland, Oregon 97204 s/Joan M. Stentiford JOAN M. STENTIFORD ELLEN M. LYNCH Trial Attorneys Commercial Litigation Branch Civil Division Department of Justice Attn: Classification Unit, 8th Flr. 1100 L Street, NW Washington, D.C. 20530 Tel. (202) 616-0341 Fax (202) 616-8624 Attorneys for Defendant

May 30, 2008

13

Case 1:05-cv-00708-CFL

Document 57

Filed 05/30/2008

Page 14 of 14

Certificate of Filing I hereby certify that on this 30th day of May, 2008, a copy of "Defendant's Exhibit List" was filed electronically. I understand that notice of this filing will be sent to all parties by operation of the Court's electronic filing system. Parties may access this filing through the Court's system. s/Joan M. Stentiford Joan M. Stentiford