Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 1 of 6
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
In re:
f/k/a ResMAE Mortgage Corporation
Merrill Lynch Bank USA , Merrill Lynch Mortgage Lending Inc. , and Merrill Lynch Funding Corporation
Appellants
Civil Action No. 07- 428 (SLR)
ResMAE Mortgage Corporation , RMC Mortgage Holdings LLC, and the Liquidating
Trust of ResMAE Mortgage Corporation
Bankruptcy Case No. 07- 10177 Bankruptcy Appeal No. 07-
Appellees.
CONSENT MOTION TO ENLARGE TIME PERIOD STAYING MEDIATION PURSUANT TO RULE 9006(b) OF THE FEDERAL RULES OF BANKRUPTCY PROCEDURE The Liquidating Trust of
through its undersigned counsel ,
Trust ), by and
hereby files this
Staying Mediation Pursuant to Rule 9006(b) of the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure (the
Motion
). In support of the Motion ,
which has been
appellants (the " Appellants " and the other Appellees , collectively with the Trust , the " Parties
and the Mediator (defined below), the Trust hereby represents as follows:
INTRODUCTION
The Parties are mindful of the Court' s order advising them that there would be no
further extensions of the stay pending appeal following the current July 18 , 2008 deadline , but
respectfully request a further extension given the substantial developments affecting the appeal
596. 002- 21115
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 2 of 6
and the Debtor
s estate. Specifically, on July 3
2008 , the Parties filed with the bankruptcy court
Global Settlement" ) with numerous
a motion seeking approval of a
parties , including the Appellants.
The Global Settlement resolves dozens of claims filed by warehouse lenders and
loan purchasers that aggregate in excess of $1.0 billion dollars , including Appellants '
claims.
The claims resolved by the Global
unsecured claims asserted against the estate.
resolution of the Debtor
s case ,
and expedites and maximizes distributions to
entry of a final order approving the Global Settlement , Appellants have agreed to withdraw this
appeal.
The hearing on the Global
, 2008.
However , this Court' s order requires the Parties to proceed with mediation on July 18 , 2008
with mediation papers to be submitted on July 25 ,
five days before the expected approval of the
Global Settlement. Given these circumstances ,
the Parties respectfully submit that there is good
cause to further extend the deadline for a short period of time in order to obtain approval of the
Global Settlement ,
which will moot this appeal.
JURISDICTION
This Court has jurisdiction over this Motion under 28 U.S. c.
g 158(a).
this proceeding and this Motion is properly in this district pursuant to 28 U.S. C.
1409.
gg 1408 and
The statutory predicates for relief
and 9006(b).
596. 002- 21115
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 3 of 6
BACKGROUND
On February 12 , 2007 , ResMAE
, f/k/a RMC
Holdings LLC (" ResMAE ) filed a voluntary petition for relief under chapter
United States Code , 11 US. C. gg 101
District of Delaware (the " Bankruptcy
et seq.
in the United States
Court
On June 5 , 2007 , the Bankruptcy Court entered its Findings of Fact , Conclusions
of Law , and Order Confirming the Second Amended Plan (the " Plan ) of Reorganization of the
Debtor Proposed by the Debtor and Sponsored by RMC Mortgage Holdings , LLC , Dated June 5
2007 (the " Confirmation Order ) confirming the Plan.
On June 14 ,
2007 , the Appellants filed an appeal to the Confirmation Order (the
Appeal ), and on July 9 , 2007 , the Bankruptcy Court transmitted the record of the Appeal to the
United States District Court for the District of Delaware.
Pursuant to the Standing Order of the Court dated July 23 , 2004 , the Appeal was
referred to the Appellate Mediation Panel , and
mediator (the " Mediator
, Esquire was appointed as
The Parties initially
, 2007 ,
and
submitted a stipulation to the Court reflecting this agreement and requesting the stay, which the
Court approved on September 26 , 2007. Thereafter , the Parties conferred and agreed to further
stipulations extending the stay, all of which were approved by the Court.
Pursuant to the Court' s order approving the Parties ' latest request for a stipulation
extending the stay, the stay is currently set to expire on July 18 , 2008. The Court noted on the
order that no further stays would be granted and that the Parties were to submit a report on the
status of the Appeal on or before August 29 2008. (Docket No. 13).
596. 002-21115
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 4 of 6
After expending
inter alia
the matters
which are the subject of this Appeal , on July 3 , 3008 the Parties filed with the Bankruptcy Court
a Motion Pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule 9019 to Approve a Stipulation of
Claims (the " 9019 Motion ), seeking approval of the Global
Motion is attached hereto as Exhibit A. The Parties are
Motion and believe it will be approved on or before the July
RELIEF REQUESTED
10.
The Trust respectfully requests this Court to enter an order
period staying mediation until thirty (30) days after the Bankruptcy Court' s order approving the
9019 Motion becomes final.
BASIS FOR RELIEF
11.
Bankruptcy Rule 8011
motions for
orders , including any motion under Rule 9006 , may be acted on at any time , without awaiting a
response thereto and without hearing. Any party adversely affected by such action may move for
reconsideration, vacation , or modification of the action. " Fed. R. Bankr. P. 8011(b).
12.
Bankruptcy Rule 9006 provides , in relevant part:
(W)hen an act is required or allowed to be done at or within
a specified period by these
thereunder or by an order of the court , the court for cause shown may at any time in its discretion (1) with or without motion or notice order the period
therefor is
originally prescribed or as extended by a previous order.
Fed. R. Bankr. P. 9006(b).
13.
As mentioned above ,
approval of the Global
s bankruptcy case and maximize
way for final
596. 002- 21115
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 5 of 6
creditors ,
it will
, the Appellants will
withdraw the Appeal once the order approving the 9019 Motion becomes final , which the Parties
expect to occur in early August.
14.
Without a further extension of the stay of mediation , the Trust will be forced to
incur the expense of preparing a mediation statement on issues that are likely to be resolved in
the near term.
recovery to the Debtor s creditors.
15.
The Parties and the
mediation is warranted given the recent development of a Global Settlement , and that all Parties
will be prejudiced if forced to continue with the mediation process.
16.
Accordingly, the Trust
existing stay of the appellate mediation
Global Settlement.
WHEREFORE , the Trust respectfully requests this Court to enter an order , substantially
in the form attached hereto as Exhibit B , enlarging the time period staying mediation until thirty
(30) days after the Bankruptcy Court' s order approving the 9019 Motion
, and
grant such other and further relief as may be just and proper.
Dated: July 16 ,
2008
LANDIS RA TH & COBB
Wilmington , Delaware
Richard S. Cobb (No. 3157) Kerri K. Mumford (No. 4186) Mona A. Parikh (No. 4901) 919 Market Street , Suite 600 Wilmington , Delaware Telephone: (302) 467- 4400 Facsimile: (302) 467- 4450
596. 002-21115. doc
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 6 of 6
-and -
Mark S. Indelicato Mark T. Power Janine M. Cerbone
HAHN & HESSEN LLP
488 Madison Avenue
New York , New York 10022 Telephone: (212) 478- 7200 Facsimile: (212) 478- 7400
Co- Counsel to the Liquidating Trust of ResMAE Mortgage
596. 002- 21115
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 1 of 90
EXHIBIT A
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 2 of 90
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
Inre:
LIQUIDATING TRUST OF RES MAE MORTGAGE CORPORATION, flkJa RESMAE MORTGAGE CORPORATION
Debtor.
Chapter 11
Case No. 07- 10177
(KJC)
Hearing Date: July 30, 2008, 3:30 p. m. (ET) Objection Deadline: July 23, 2008, 4:00 p. m. (ET)
NOTICE OF MOTION
TO:
The Office of the United States Trustee for the District of Delaware; Counsel to each of
the Claimants; the Oversight Committee; and all other parties on the Post Effective Date
Service List.
The Liquidating Trust of ResMAE Mortgage Corporation has filed the attached Motion
Pursuant to Bankruptcy Rule
Claims (the " Motion
Objections , if any, to the relief States Bankruptcy Court , 824 N. Market Street , 3rd Floor, Wilmington , Delaware 19801 , on or before July 23, 2008 at 4:00 p. m. (ET).
At the same time ,
you must also
m. (ET) on July 23, 2008.
counsel so as to be received no
A HEARING TO CONSIDER THE RELIEF BE HELD ON JULY 30, 2008 AT 3:30 P. M. (ET) BEFORE THE
CAREY , UNITED , UNITED BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE , 824 N. MARKET STREET TH FLOOR , COURTROOM #5 , WILMINGTON , DELAWARE 19801.
596. 002-21017. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 3 of 90
IF YOU FAIL TO RESPOND IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS NOTICE , THE COURT MA Y NOTICE OR HEARING.
Dated: July 3 ,
2008
LANDIS RATH & COBB LLP
Wilmington , Delaware
Jiu;
. hard S. Cobb (No. 3157)
1!!
Kerri K. Mumford (No. 4186) Mona A. Parikh (No. 4901) 919 Market Street , Suite 600 Wilmington , Delaware Telephone: (302) 467- 4400 Facsimile: (302) 467-4450
-and-
Mark S. Indelicato Mark T. Power Janine M. Cerbone
HAHN & HESSEN LLP 488 Madison Avenue New York , New York 10022
Telephone: (212) 478- 7200 Facsimile: (212) 478- 7400
Co- Counsel to the Liquidating Trust of ResMAE Mortgage
596. 002-21017. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 4 of 90
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
In re:
Chapter 11
LIQUIDATING TRUST OF RESMAE
Case No. 07- 10177
(KJC)
MORTGAGE CORPORATION
flkJa RESMAE MORTGAGE CORPORATION
Debtor.
Hearing Date: July 30, 2008, 3:30 p. m. (ET) Objections Due: July 23, 2008, 4:00 p. m. (ET)
MOTION PURSUANT TO BANKRUPTCY RULE 9019 TO APPROVE A STIPULATION OF SETTLEMENT RESOLVING CLAIMS
The
Trust"),
by
undersigned co-counsel , Hahn & Hessen LLP and Landis Rath & Cobb LLP, hereby moves this
Court (the " Motion ) pursuant to section 105(a) of chapter 11 of title
Code (the " Bankruptcy Code ) and Rule 9019 of the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure (the
Bankruptcy Rules ) for entry of an
Stipulation ) entered into by the Trust
Stipulation (the " Claimants
, and collectively, with the Trust , the " Parties
). A copy of
Stipulation is attached hereto as Exhibit A. In support
as follows:
, the Trust hereby represents
JURISDICTION
This Court has jurisdiction over these cases and this Motion pursuant to 28 U.
~~ 157 and 1334(b). Venue is proper in this district pursuant to 28 U.
C. ~~ 1408 and
The statutory predicates for relief sought herein are section
Bankruptcy Rule 9019.
596. 002-21015. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 5 of 90
GENERAL BACKGROUND
On February 12
2007 (the " Petition Date ), ResMAE Mortgage Corporation (the
Debtor ), filed a
Bankruptcy Code
), 11 U.
C. ~~ 101- 1330
in the United States
District of Delaware (the " Court"
On February 12
2007 , the Debtor filed with the Court its Schedules of Assets and
Liabilities (as amended from time to time , the " Schedules
By order dated March 26, 2007 (the " Bar
April 30 ,
Date Order
), the Court
2007 at 5:00 p. m. (prevailing Pacific Time) as the last date and time for the filing of
proofs of claim in this chapter
Bar Date
On June 5 , 2007, the Court entered the Findings of Fact , Conclusions of Law and
Order under 11 U.
C. ~~ 1129(a) and (b) and Fed. R. Bankr. P. 3020 Confirming the
Amended Plan of Reorganization of the Debtor Proposed by the Debtor and Sponsored by RMC
Mortgage Holdings LLC Dated June 5 , 2007 (the " Confirmation Order
On
, 2007
Effective Date ), the Second
Reorganization of the Debtor
Holdings LLC Dated June 5 , 2007 (as supplemented , modified , or amended , the " Plan ) became
effective.
Pursuant to the Plan , on the
Declaration of Trust , Estate Administration and
, the Trust was
Trust
Agreement" ) was executed appointing Alan M. Jacobs as Liquidating Trustee of the Trust (the
Trustee
596. oo2-21015. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 6 of 90
Pursuant to Section 3.4 of the Trust Agreement,
as of the Effective Date ,
the
exclusive right to object to the allowance of any claim was reserved by the Trust and the Trustee
was given the authority and power to file objections regarding the allowance and disallowance of
claims.
THE CLAIMS
On or about July 11 ,
2007, DB
DBSP" ) filed claim
number 234 (the " DB Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be a general unsecured claim seeking an
unliquidated amount of
Repurchase Agreement dated as
modified from time to time) and that
841 737.13 arising out of
, 2005 (as amended , supplemented and
Servicing Agreement dated as of November 1 , 2006 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
modified from time to
The DB
previously timely filed claims.
10.
DBSP is listed on the Debtors ' schedule F as having an unliquidated , contingent
and disputed unsecured claim in the
DBSP
together with the DBSP Filed Claim , the " DBSP Claims
11.
On or about July 11 ,
2007 , Aspen Funding Corp. (" Aspen ) filed claim number
235 (the " Aspen Filed Claim ), which is
unliquidated amount of
Repurchase Agreement dated as
modified from time to time) and that
841 737.13 arising out of
, supplemented and
Servicing Agreement dated as of November 1 2006 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
modified from time to
596. 0o2-21o15. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 7 of 90
previously timely filed claims.
12.
Aspen is listed on the Debtors ' schedule D as having a claim in the
zero dollars (the "Aspen Scheduled Claim " together with the Aspen Filed Claim , the "Aspen
Claims
13.
On or
, 2007 , Newport Funding
Newport" )
filed claim
number 236 (the "Newport Filed Claim ), which is
seeking an unliquidated amount of not less than $55 841 737.13 arising out of that certain Master
Repurchase Agreement dated as
modified from time to time) and that
, supplemented and
Servicing Agreement dated as of November 1 2006 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
modified from time to time). The
previously timely filed claims.
14.
Aspen and Newport are affiliates ofDBSP (collectively, the " DBSP Entities
15.
On or about April 24 , 2007 , Lehman Brothers Bank FSB (" Lehman ) filed claim
number 128 (the " Lehman Filed Claim ), which is
seeking an unliquidated amount of not less than $20 727, 715. 28 arising out of that
Second Amended and Restated Master Repurchase Agreement Governing Purchases and Sales
of Mortgage Loans , dated December 21 2005 (as amended).
16.
Lehman is listed on the Debtors ' schedule F as having an unliquidated , contingent
and disputed unsecured claim in the amount of zero dollars (the " Lehman Scheduled Claim
together with the Lehman Filed Claim , the " Lehman Claims
17.
On or about April 2 , 2008 , Aurora Loan Services LLC (" Aurora
Filed Claim
) filed claim
number 253 (the " Aurora
), which is alleged to be a
596. oo2- 21015. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 8 of 90
unliquidated amount of not
representations and warranties in
000 248. 78
s breach of
respect of mortgage loans it originated and sold to
entities for which Aurora is the master servicer. The Aurora Filed Claim amends and
one or more previously filed claims.
18. 19.
Aurora is an affiliate of Lehman (together , the "Lehman Entities
On or about April 30 , 2007 , Barclays Bank PLC , individually and as agent for
buyers (" Barclays ), filed claim number 177 (the " Barclays Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be
a general unsecured claim seeking an unliquidated
arising out of that certain Master Repurchase
809,283.
, 2006 and certain
related custodial agreements and other transactional documents (as amended from time to time).
20.
Barclays is
' schedule F as having
contingent and disputed unsecured claim in the amount of zero dollars (the " Barclays Scheduled
Claim " together with the Barclays Filed Claim , the " Barclays Claims
21.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , JPMorganChase Bank NA (" JPMorganChase
) filed
claim number 146 (the " JPMorganChase Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be a
general unsecured claim seeking an unliquidated amount arising out of that certain Master Loan
Repurchase Agreement dated May 31 , 2006 and that certain Mortgage Loan Sale and Interim
Servicing Agreement dated as of December 1 2005.
22.
JPMorganChase is listed
' schedule F as having a
unsecured claim in the amount of $39, 324. 00 (the " JPMorganChase Scheduled Claim " together
with the JPMorganChase Filed Claim , the " JPMorganChase Claims
23.
On or
, 2007 ,
Nomura Credit &
Nomura ) filed claim number
Nomura Filed Claim ), which is
596. oo2- 21o15. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 9 of 90
unsecured claim seeking an unliquidated amount of not less than $1 239,427, 168. 30 arising out
of that certain letter agreement setting forth the master terms for mortgage loan purchases
October I , 2006 , that certain Master Mortgage Loan Purchase Agreement dated as of October 1
2006 and two Pool Summary and Trade Confirmations , one dated as of August 10, 2006
dated as of August 24 , 2006.
24.
Nomura is listed on the Debtors ' schedule D a having an unliquidated , contingent
and disputed secured claim in the
'Nomura Scheduled Claim
together with the Nomura Filed Claim , the "Nomura Claims
25.
On or about April 27, 2007 , Merrill Lynch Bank USA (" ML Bank") filed claim
number 187 (the " ML Bank Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be a general unsecured and/or an
unsecured priority claim seeking an unliquidated amount of not less than $11 , I 00 000. 00 arising
out of that certain Master Repurchase Agreement dated as of March 7 , 2005 (as amended from
time to time) and certain related agreements.
26.
ML Bank is
' schedule F as having
contingent and disputed unsecured claim in the amount of zero dollars (the " ML Bank Scheduled
Claim " together with the ML Bank Filed Claim , the " ML Bank Claims
27.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Merrill Lynch Funding Corp. (" ML Funding
) filed
claim number 152 (the " ML Funding Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be an unsecured , secured
and/or priority claim seeking an unliquidated amount arising out of that certain Master Mortgage
Loan Purchase and Interim Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1 2006 (as amended from
time to time) and certain related agreements.
28.
On or
, 2007 , Merrill
Lending ) filed claim number
ML Lending Filed Claim ), which is alleged
596. 002-21015. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 10 of 90
unsecured , secured and/or priority claim seeking
certain Master Mortgage Loan Purchase and Interim Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1
2006 (as amended from time to time) and certain related agreements.
29.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM1 (" ML Trust 1" ) filed claim number
ML Trust
), which is
unliquidated amount arising out of that
Servicing Agreement dated as of January
2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
30.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM2 (" ML Trust 2") filed claim number
ML Trust 2 Filed Claim ), which is
unliquidated amount arising out of that
Servicing Agreement dated as of January
2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
31.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM3 (" ML Trust 3") filed claim number
ML Trust 3 Filed Claim ), which is
unliquidated amount arising out
Servicing Agreement dated as of January
2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
32.
On or about April 27, 2007 , Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM4 (" ML Trust 4" ) filed claim number
596. 002-21015. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 11 of 90
ML Trust 4
), which is
unliquidated amount arising out
Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1 , 2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
33.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM5 (" ML Trust 5" and , collectively, with ML
Trust 1
, ML Trust 2 ML Trust 3 and ML Trust 4 , the " ML Trusts ) filed claim number 147 (the
ML Trust 5 Filed Claim ), which is
unliquidated amount arising out of that
Servicing Agreement dated as of January
2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
34.
ML Funding and ML Lending are affiliates of ML Bank and ML
sponsor of the ML Trust 1 , ML Trust 2 , ML Trust 3 , ML Trust 4 , and ML Trust 5 (collectively,
the " ML Entities
RELIEF REQUESTED
35.
The Trust requests the entry of an Order, substantially in the form attached hereto
as Exhibit B , approving the Stipulation. The salient terms of the Stipulation provide
In full and
, the
Claims , the Newport Filed Claim , and any and all other claims filed by, or scheduled on behalf of the DBSP Entities , whether secured , administrative , priority, or , the
DBSP Entities shall have a single allowed unsecured claim in the aggregate amount of ten 000 000. 00) (the " Allowed DBSP Claim ), which
Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined in the Plan.
I The following description of certain terms of the Stipulation is intended for the convenience ofthe Parties and is
qualified in all respects by the language of the Stipulation.
596. 0o2-21oI5. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 12 of 90
11.
, the Aurora Filed Claim , and any and all other claims filed by, or scheduled
In full and final resolution of the
on
the Lehman Entities ,
whether secured
administrative , priority, Entities shall have a
or general unsecured , the
amount of ten million 000 000. 00) (the " Allowed Lehman Claim ), which shall be treated as an Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined in the Plan.
lll.
In full and final resolution of the Barclays Claims and any and all other claims filed by, or , Barclays whether secured , administrative , priority, or general unsecured Barclays shall have a amount of ten million 000 000. 00) (the " Allowed Barclays Claim ), which shall be treated as an Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined in the Plan.
lV.
In full and final resolution of the any and all other
JPMorganChase , whether secured , administrative , priority, or general unsecured , JPMorganChase shall have a single allowed
unsecured claim in
($10 000, 000. 00)
Allowed JPMorganChase Claim
which shall be
defined in the Plan.
In full and final resolution of the Nomura Claims and any and all other claims filed by, or , Nomura whether secured , administrative, priority, or general unsecured
N omura shall have a
amount of ten million 000 000. 00) (the "Allowed Nomura Claim ), which shall be treated as an Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined in the Plan.
Vl.
, the ML Funding Filed Claim , the ML , the ML Trust 1 Filed Claim , the ML Trust 2 Filed Claim , the ML Trust 3 Filed Claim , the ML Trust 4 , the ML Filed Claim and any and all other claims filed by, or scheduled on behalf of, the ML Entities, whether secured , administrative priority, or , the ML
In full and final resolution of the
single allowed unsecured claim in the amount of ten
dollars ($10 000 000.
00)
Allowed ML Claim
, the Allowed , the Allowed
, the
collectively with the
Lehman Claim , the Allowed JPMorganChase Claim , and the Allowed
596. 0o2- 21015. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 13 of 90
Allowed Claims
, and individually each an " Allowed
Claim
which shall be
defined in the Plan.
Vll.
Any of
Stipulation if LaSalle Bank National Association (" LaSalle ) as trustee for such ML Trust, delivers a written certification to the
Trust on or before , 2008 which percent (50% to be measured in principal (or notional) amount
outstanding) of the
directed LaSalle to withdraw from the
Statement"
Vlll.
Certified
If either of the following Conditions ) is not met then each Claimant shall be entitled to provide to the Trust and each of the other Claimants written Notice
of Withdrawal" ) of such Claimant' s intent to
consent to this Stipulation: i) the Final Order shall have been entered by the Court on or before August 20 , 2008 and ii) the Trustee shall have made a distribution equal to at least 10% on
each Allowed Claim on or
, 2008
Initial Distribution
DISCUSSION
Legal Standard
36.
Section 105 of the Bankruptcy
process
(t)he court
may issue any order ,
, or judgment that is
C. ~ 105(a). Bankruptcy Rule 9019 provides
provisions " of the Bankruptcy Code.
(o)n motion by the trustee and after notice and a hearing, the court may approve a
or settlement." Fed. R. Bankr. P. 9019(a).
37.
In order to minimize litigation
estate
compromises are favored in bankruptcy.
In re Martin 91 F.3d 389 393 (3d Cir. 1996);
321, 329 (Bankr. D. Del. 2004). Pursuant
see also In re Coram Healthcare, Inc. 315 B. R.
Bankruptcy Rule 9019, " the
authority to approve a compromise settlement is within the sound
discretion of the bankruptcy court.
In re
Case No. 03- 10323 ,
2005
596. oo2- 21015. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 14 of 90
Barikr. LEXIS 2606 , at *9 (Bankr. D. Del. October 7
2005l; see In re Louise
s, Inc. 211 B.
798 , 801 (D. Del. 1997). When exercising such discretion , the bankruptcy court must determine
whether the compromise is " fair,
Key3Media Group,
reasonable , and in the best
2005 Bankr. LEXIS 2606 , at *9;
see
also
In re RFE Industries, Inc. 283 FJd
159, 165 (3d Cir. 2002);
Louise s, Inc. 211 B.R. at 801.
38.
The bankruptcy court is not required to determine that the proposed
Key3Media Group,
the best possible compromise.
2005 Bankr. LEXIS 2606, at
Coram 315 B. R.
at 329). Rather ,
the settlement should be approved as long as it " falls within
Coram 315 B. R. at 330;
see also Cosoff
the reasonable range of
Rodman (In re W
699 F.2d 599, 608 (2d Cir.
cert. denied
464 U.S. 822 (1983)
(Settlement should be approved provided it does not fall below the lowest point in the range of
reasonableness. ).
In
, it is not
, nor is it necessary for the bankruptcy
utilized in resolving the
conclusively determine claims subject to a compromise.
Key3Media Group,
2005 Barikr.
LEXIS 2606, at *
39.
Courts should consider the following four factors when
settlement is in the best interests of the estate: (1) the probability of success in the
the complexity of the litigation involved , and the expense , inconvenience and delay
attendant thereto; (3) the difficulties , if any, to be encountered in the matter of collection; and (4)
the paramount interest of the creditors and a proper deference to their reasonable
g., Protective
390 u.s. 414 , 424 (1968);
Myers v. Martin (In re Martin), v.
See
Anderson
91 F. 3d 389
393 (3d Cir. 1996).
2 A copy of the Key3Media Group decision is attached hereto as Exhibit
596. 002-21o15. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 15 of 90
The Stipulation is in the Best Interest of the Estate
40.
In the present case , the
Stipulation was negotiated in
respective professionals. The
substantially lower than the claims that the
Iength among the
, the Allowed
Trust was to examine and analyze any and all claims asserted by the Claimants
Claims
individually. The
basic factors. First , the Parties recognized that an effort to specifically determine the
any of the Claims would involve (i) unduly
production causing a drain on the resources of each of the Claimants, (ii) a thorough review
the Trustee of the documents and information produced by each of the Claimants , causing a drain
on the resources of the estate, and (iii) a very complex analysis by the Trustee likely followed by
months of negotiations between the Trustee and each of the Claimants , draining the resources of
both the Claimants and the estate.
41.
Second , the Parties determined that collectively the Claimants comprise in excess
of 90% of the claims pool and , therefore , agreeing to accept smaller claims than such Claimants
may otherwise be entitled to would essentially have little to no impact on the Claimants as
simply would be
distribution on larger claims.
, since the Claimants represent such a significant portion of
the Class 3 claimants , they would be required to fund not only their own costs in prosecuting any
such litigation but the Trust' s costs as well since it would reduce the amount otherwise
to distribute to them. Moreover , the only impact the settlement could have on other
claimants would be to provide a greater distribution to such claimants due to a decreased creditor
596. 002-21015.DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 16 of 90
pool. Accordingly, the settlement is fair , reasonable , and in the best interests of the estate.
42.
Claims is
As to the first Martin
factor, the probability of success in litigation
intensive nature of the dispute
obligations to the Claimants with respect to each of the Claims.
Martin
factor
because litigation would be factually complex and likely require extensive discovery, the costs of
litigating this matter would likely outweigh any potential benefit of litigation.
Martin
factor , there is no difficulty in collection.
43.
Finally, as to the fourth Martin
factor , at this stage in this case, the
interest of creditors is
Accordingly, the resolution and settlement of the Claims , which will result in the
reduced general unsecured claims for the Claimants in exchange for the release of filed
asserted in unliquidated amounts anticipated to be far in excess
additional fees and costs inherent in litigating the Claims, fits squarely within the Martin
factors.
44.
The Trust believes that this settlement represents a sensible compromise of
claims , and that the settlement is in the best interest of the Trust and the Trust
re Marvel Entm ' t Group, Inc. 222 B.R. 243 , 249 (Bankr. D. Del. 1998).
45.
For the foregoing reasons , the Trust
settlement is within the reasonable range of litigation possibilities and approval of the Stipulation
is justified and appropriate.
NOTICE
46.
As required by the Plan and Confirmation Order , notice of this Motion
provided to: (1)
, (2) Counsel to each of the
(3) the Oversight Committee, and (4) other parties entitled to notice.
596. 002-2 101 5. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 17 of 90
other or further notice is required.
24.
other Court.
No previous application for the relief sought herein has been made to this or any
WHEREFORE
the Trust
substantially in the form attached hereto as Exhibit B , approving the Stipulation , and grant such
other and further relief as may be just and proper.
Dated: July 3, 2008 Wilmington, Delaware
LANDIS RA TH & COBB
Kerri K. Mumford (No. 4186) 919 Market Street , Suite 600 Wilmington , DE Telephone: (302) 467- 4400 Facsimile: (302) 467- 4450
-and-
~~b
Mark S. Indelicato Mark T. Power Janine M. Cerbone
HAHN & HESSEN LLP
488 Madison Avenue New York , New York 10022 Telephone: (212) 478- 7200 Facsimile: (212) 478- 7400
Co- Counsel to the Liquidating Trust of ResMAE Mortgage
596. o02-21oI5. DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 18 of 90
EXHIBIT A
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 19 of 90
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
INRE:
LIQUIDATING TRUST OF RESMAE MORTGAGE CORPORATION, a Delaware Corporation
Debtor.
Chapter 11
Case No. 07- 10177
(KJC)
STIPULATION OF SETTLEMENT RESOLVING CLAIMS
This Stipulation of Settlement Resolving Claims (the " Stipulation ) is entered into by and
among the Liquidating Trust of ResMAE Mortgage Corporation (the "Trust" ) and the Parties
who are listed on Exhibit A annexed hereto and who are signatories hereto (the " Claimants
collectively, with the Trust, the "Parties
RECITALS
As and for the Recitals to this Stipulation , the Parties assert the following:
On February 12 , 2007 , ResMAE Mortgage
voluntary petition under chapter 11 of title
11 U.S. C. ~~ 101- 1330
Debtor
), filed a
Bankruptcy Code
in the United States
Court"
On February 12 , 2007 , the Debtor filed with the Court its Schedules of Assets and
Liabilities (as amended uom time to time , the " Schedules
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 20 of 90
By order dated March 26 , 2007 (the "Bar
Date Order ), the Court established
April 30 , 2007 at 5:00 p. m. (prevailing Pacific Time) as the last date and time for the filing of
proofs of claim in this chapter 11 case (the " Bar Date
On or about July 11 , 2007, DB
DBSP")
filed claim
number 234 (the " DB Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be a general unsecured claim seeking an
unliquidated amount of not
Repurchase Agreement dated as
modified from time to time) and that
841 737. 13 arising out of
, 2005 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
Servicing Agreement dated as of November 1 , 2006 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
modified from time to
previously timely filed claims.
DBSP is listed on the Debtors ' schedule F as having an unliquidated , contingent
and disputed unsecured claim in the
DBSP Scheduled Claim
together with the DBSP Filed Claim , the "DBSP Claims
On or about July 11 , 2007 , Aspen Funding Corp. (" Aspen ) filed claim number
235 (the " Aspen Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be a
unliquidated amount of not
Repurchase Agreement dated as
modified from time to time) and that
841 737. 13 arising out of
, 2005 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
Servicing Agreement dated as of November 1 , 2006 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
modified from time to
previously timely filed claims.
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 21 of 90
Aspen is listed on the Debtors' schedule D as having a claim in the amount of
zero dollars (the "Aspen Scheduled Claim" , together with the Aspen Filed Claim , the "Aspen
Claims
On or
, 2007 ,
Newport Funding
Newport")
filed claim
number 236 (the "Newport Filed Claim ), which is
seeking an unliquidated amount ofIiot less than $55 841 737. 13 arising out of that certain Master
Repurchase Agreement dated as
modified from time to time) and
, 2005 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
Servicing Agreement dated as of November 1 , 2006 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
modified from time to time). The Newport
previously timely filed claims.
Aspen and Newport are affiliates ofDBSP (collectively, the "DBSP Entities
On or about April 24 , 2007 , Lehman Brothers Bank FSB (" Lehman ) filed claim
number 128 (the " Lehman Filed Claim ), which is
seeking an unliquidated amount of not less than $20 727 715. 28 arising out of that
Second Amended and Restated Master Repurchase Agreement Governing Purchases and Sales
of Mortgage Loans , dated December 21 2005 (as amended).
Lehman is listed on the Debtors ' schedule F as having an unliquidated , contingent
and disputed unsecured claim in the amount of zero dollars (the " Lelunan
together with the Lehman Filed Claim , the "Lehman Claims
Scheduled Claim
On or about April 2 , 2008 , Aurora Loan Services LLC (" Aurora
) filed claim
number 253 (the " Aurora
Filed Claim
), which is
000,248. 78
s breach of
unliquidated amount of not
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 22 of 90
representations and warranties in respect
entities for which Aurora is the master servicer. The Aurora Filed Claim amends and
one or more previously filed claims.
Aurora is an affiliate of Lehman (together, the " Lehman Entities
On or about April 30, 2007 , Barclays Bank PLC , individually and as agent for
buyers ("Barclays ), filed claim number 177 (the "Barclays Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be
a general unsecured claim seeking an
arising out of that certain Master Repurchase
809 283.
, 2006 and certain
related custodial agreements and other transactional docwnents (as amended ITom time to time).
Barclays is
' schedule F as having
Scheduled
contingent and disputed unsecured claim in the amount of zero dollars (the "Barclays
Claim , together with the Barclays Filed Claim, the "Barclays Claims
On or about April 27 , 2007 , JPMorganChase Bank NA (" JPMorganChase ) filed
claim nwnber 146 (the " JPMorganChase Filed Claim"), which is alleged to be a
general unsecured claim seeking an unliquidated amount arising out of that certain Master Loan
Repurchase Agreement dated May 31 , 2006 and that certain Mortgage Loan Sale and
Servicing Agreement dated as of December I , 2005.
JPMorganChase is listed
' schedule F as having a
unsecured claim in the amount of $39 324. 00 (the " JPMorganChase Scheduled Claim , together
with the JPMorganChase Filed Claim , the "JPMorganChase Claims
On or
Nomura ) filed claim number
, 2007 ,
Nomura Credit & Capital Inc. and its
Nomura Filed Claim ), which is alleged
unsecured claim seeking an unliquidated amount of not less than $1 239, 427, 168. 30 arising out
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 23 of 90
of that certain letter agreement setting forth the master tenns for mortgage loan purchases dated
October 1 ,
2006 , that certain Master Mortgage Loan Purchase Agreement dated as of October 1
2006 and two Pool Summary and Trade Confi1111ations , one dated as of August 10 , 2006 and one
dated as of August 24 , 2006.
Nomura is listed on the Debtors ' schedule D a having an unliquidated, contingent
and disputed secured claim in the
Nomura Scheduled Claim
together with the Nomura Filed Claim , the "Nomura Claims
On or about April 27, 2007 , Merrill Lynch Bank USA ("ML Bank") filed claim
number 187 (the " ML Bank Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be a general unsecured and/or an
unsecured priority claim seeking an unliquidated amount of not less than $11 100 000. 00 arising
out of that certain Master Repurchase Agreement dated as of March 7 , 2005 (as amended from
time to time) and certain related agreements.
ML Bank is
' schedule F as having
contingent and disputed unsecured claim in the amount of zero dollars (the "ML Bank Scheduled
Claim , together with the ML Bank Filed Claim , the "ML Bank Claims
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Merrill Lynch Funding Corp. ("ML Funding ) filed
claim number 152 (the " ML Funding Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be an unsecured , secured and/or priority claim seeking an unliquidated amount arising out of that certain Master Mortgage
Loan Purchase and Interim Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1 , 2006 (as amended from
time to time) and certain related agreements.
On or
Lending ) filed claim number
, 2007,
ML Lending Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be an
unsecured, secured and/or priority claim seeking an unliquidated amount arising out of that
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 24 of 90
certain Master Mortgage Loan Purchase and Interim Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1
2006 (as amended from time to time) and certain related agreements.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Menill Lynch
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM1 (" ML Trust 1" ) filed claim number 190 (the
ML Trust
), which is
unliquidated amount arising out of that
Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1 , 2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
On or about April 27,
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM2 (" ML Trust 2") filed claim number 150 (the
ML Trust 2 Filed Claim ), which is
unliquidated amount arising out
Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1 , 2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
On or about April 27, 2007 , Menill Lynch Mortgage
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM3 (" ML Trust 3" ) filed claim number
ML Trust 3
), which is
unliquidated amount arising out
Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1, 2006 (as amended from time
related agreements.
AA.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Menill Lynch
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM4 ("ML Trust 4") filed claim number
ML Trust 4 Filed Claim ), which is
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 25 of 90
unliquidated amount arising out of that
Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1 2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
BB.
On or about April 27 , 2007 , Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust
Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM5 (" ML Trust 5" and , collectively, with ML
Trust 1, ML Trust 2 ML Trust 3 and ML Trust 4, the "ML Trusts ) filed claim number 147 (the
ML Trust 5
), which is
unliquidated amount arising out of that
Servicing Agreement dated as of January 1 , 2006 (as amended from time to time) and
related agreements.
CC.
ML Funding and ML Lending are affiliates of ML Bank and ML Lending
sponsor of the ML Trust 1, ML Trust 2 , ML Trust 3 , ML Trust 4 , and ML Trust 5 (collectively,
the "ML Entities
DD.
On June 5 , 2007 , the Court entered the Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and
Order under 11 U.
C. ~~ 1
Amended Plan of Reorganization of the Debtor Proposed by the Debtor and Sponsored by RMC
Mortgage Holdings LLC Dated June 5 , 2007 (the " Confirmation Order
EE.
On
, 2007
Effective Date ), the Second
Reorganization of the Debtor
Holdings LLC Dated June 5, 2007 (as supplemented , modified , or amended , the " Plan ) became
effective.
FF.
Pursuant to the Plan , on the
Declaration of Trust , Estate Administration and Liquidating Trust
Trust
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 26 of 90
Agreement") was executed appointing Alan M. Jacobs as Liquidating Trustee of the Trust (the
Trustee
GG.
On the Effective Date , the Debtor transferred the Trust Property to the Trust in
accordance with the Plan.
HH.
Pursuant to Section 3.4 of the Trust Agreement ,
as of the Effective Date, the
exclusive right to object to the allowance of any claim was reserved by the Trust and the Trustee
was given the authority and power to file objections regarding the allowance and disallowance of
claims.
NOW , THEREFORE , in consideration of the promises and mutual covenants
herein and other valuable consideration ,
the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged , it is
stipulated and agreed by and among the Parties , as follows:
The recitals set forth above are incorporated herein by reference.
In full and final resolution of the DBSP Claims , the Aspen Claims , the Newport
Filed Claim , and any and all other claims filed by, or scheduled on behalf of the DBSP Entities
whether secured ,
administrative , priority, or general unsecured , the DBSP Entities shall have a
single allowed unsecured claim in the aggregate amount of ten million dollars ($10 000, 000. 00)
(the " Al1owed
DBSP Claim ), which shall be treated as an Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined
in the Plan. Any distribution
provided , however, DBSP , Aspen and Newport reserve the right to detennine the
allocation among DBSP , Aspen and Newport of any distributions received from the Trust on
behalf of the Allowed DBSP Claim.
In full and final resolution of the Lemnan
, and
any and all other
, the
, whether
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 27 of 90
secured , administrative , priority, or general unsecured , the Lehman Entities shall have a single
allowed unsecured claim in the amount of ten million dollars ($10, 000,000. 00) (the " Allowed
Lehman Claim ), which shall be treated as an Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined in the
Any distribution due to the Lehman Entities under the Plan shall be paid to Lehman, provided
however, Lehman and Aurora reserve the right to detennine the appropriate allocation
them of any distributions received ITom the Trust on behalf of the Allowed Lehman Claim.
In full and final resolution of the Barclays
filed by, or
, Barclays , whether secured , administrative , priority, or
general unsecured , Barclays shall have a single allowed
million dollars ($10, 000 000. 00) (the " Allowed Barclays Claim ), which shall be treated as an
Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined in the Plan.
In full and final resolution of the
claims filed by, or scheduled on behalf of, JPMorganChase ,
whether secured, administrative
priority, or general unsecured , JPMorganChase shall have a single allowed unsecured claim in
the amount of ten million
000 000. 00) (the " Allowed JPMorganChase Claim"
which shall be treated as an Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined in the Plan.
In full and final resolution of the
filed by, or scheduled on behalf of, Nomura, whether secured , administrative, priority, or general
unsecured , Nomura shall have a single allowed
dollars ($10 000 000. 00) (the "Allowed Nomura Claim ), which shall be treated as an
Claim in Class 3 as defined in the Plan.
In
full and final resolution of the ML Bank Claims , the ML Funding Filed Claim
, the ML Trust 2 Filed Claim , the ML
the ML Lending Filed Claim , the ML Trust
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 28 of 90
Trust 3 Filed Claim , the ML Trust 4 Filed Claim , the ML Trust 5 Filed Claim and any and all
other claims filed by, or
, the
, whether secured
administrative , priority, or
unsecured claim in the
, the ML
000 000. 00) (the "Allowed ML
Claim " collectively with the Allowed DBSP Claim , the Allowed Lehman Claim , the Allowed
Barclays Claim , the Allowed
, and the Allowed
, the
Allowed Claims , and individually each an "Allowed Claim
), which shall be
Allowed Claim in Class 3 as defined in the Plan. Any distribution due to the ML
the Plan shall be paid to ML
however, ML Bank , ML Funding, ML Lending, ML Trust 1 , ML Trust 2 , ML Trust 3 , ML Trust
4, and ML Trust 5 reserve the right to detennine the appropriate allocation among ML Bank, ML
Funding, ML Lending, ML Trust 1 , ML Trust 2 , ML Trust 3 , ML Trust 4 , and ML Trust 5 of any
distributions received by ML Bank from the Trust on behalf of the Allowed ML Claim. Any
the ML Trusts , however, may withdraw its consent to this Stipulation if LaSalle Bank
Association (" LaSalle ) as trustee for such ML Trust , delivers a written certification to the Trust
on or before July 25 , 2008 which certifies that fifty percent (50% to be measured in principal (or
notional) amount outstanding) of the security holders of such ML Trust have directed LaSalle to
withdraw from this Stipulation (" Certified Statement"
The
approval by the Court and that this
Parties until the entry by the
approving this Stipulation (the "Final Order
). For purposes of
, where applicable , of an order
, a " Final Order
means an order , the operation or effect of which has not been stayed , reversed or amended and as
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 29 of 90
to which the time to appeal or such review or rehearing has expired and as to which no appeal or
petition for review or rehearing was filed or, if filed , remains pending.
If a Certified Statement is received by the Trust as set forth in paragraph 7 of this
Stipulation or if this Stipulation is not approved by the Court or the Court' s order is reversed by a
higher court, the Stipulation shall be
Stipulation shall be deemed null and void. Furthennore, if this Stipulation is not approved
Court or the Court' s order approving this Stipulation is reversed
by
by
the
a higher court , the tenns or
statements contained in this Stipulation , any motion or motions filed seeking an order from the
Court approving this Stipulation , and any correspondence related to the negotiation , drafting or
approval of this Stipulation , shall not be
Party s interest in any litigation by and among the Parties.
10.
If either of the
Conditions
) is not met then each
Claimant shall be entitled to provide to the Trust
notification (a "Notice of Withdrawal") of such Claimant s intent to withdraw its consent to this
Stipulation: i) the Final Order shall have been entered by the Court on or before August 20 , 2008
and ii) the Trustee shall have made a distribution equal to at least 10% on each Allowed Claim in
accordance with paragraphs 2 through 7 herein on or before September 30, 2008 (the "Initial
Distribution
, the
Trustee shall have five (5) business days to take any necessary steps to ensure entry of the Final
Order and/or effectuate the.Initial Distribution. If, after five (5) business days from the Trustee
receipt of a Notice of Withdrawal , the Final Order has not been entered by the Court or the Initial
Distribution has not been made , this Stipulation shall be deemed null and void and all
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 30 of 90
set forth in this Stipulation shall be deemed null and void. The Trustee shall reasonable efforts to
assure that the Conditions are met.
11.
Conditional upon the Trust' s receipt of an executed copy of this Stipulation by all
Parties , entry of the Final Order, and subject to the provisions of paragraph 10 , the Trustee, on
behalf of the Trust, and to the extent authorized
, on behalf of the Debtor, and
Releasing
each of their respective predecessors, successors and assigns (collectively, the "Trust
Parties
) hereby releases ,
waives, discharges and
, causes of
action , damages , liabilities , demands , rights and losses of whatever kind and nature, known or
unknown ,
past or present , existing before or as of the date of this Stipulation , of any nature
whatsoever, whether in tort (including, without limitation , acts of active negligence), contract or
any other theory of recovery in law , admiralty or equity, whether or not wrongful , whether for
compensatory or punitive damages , equitable relief or otherwise , and whether now known or
unknown ,
suspected or unsuspected, that any of
the Claimants and current and former officers and directors of the Claimants , which are based
upon or arise out of or in connection with any matter, cause or thing existing at any time prior to
the date hereof or anything done, omitted or suffered to be done at any time prior to the date
hereof;
provided however , that nothing herein shall release any rights that the Trust has in or to
the ResMAE Asset- Backed Pass-Through Certificates 2006- , including, but not limited to , the
Trust' s rights in the Originator Reserve Account.
12.
Upon each Claimant's
, each Claimant
, causes of
Parties , entry of the Final Order and
hereby releases ,
waives , discharges and
damages , liabilities , demands , rights and losses of whatever kind and nature, known or unknown
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 31 of 90
past or present , existing before , or as of the date of this Stipulation , of any nature whatsoever
whether in tort (including, without limitation, acts of active negligence), contract or any other
theory of recovery in law, admiralty or
, whether for
compensatory or punitive damages , equitable relief or otherwise , and whether now known or
unknown , suspected or unsuspected , that the Claimant have or had against the Trust
Parties , which are based upon or arise out of or in
, cause or thing
existing at any time prior to the date hereof or anything done , omitted or suffered to be done or
omitted at any time prior to the date hereof, including but not limited to any and all claims filed
by, or scheduled on behalf of, such Claimant;
provided however, nothing in this paragraph shall
release the Debtor, the Trust or the Liquidating Trustee
with respect to the Allowed Claims.
13.
Each Party represents that it owns and has not assigned or otherwise transferred to
any other person or entity any of such Party s rights and claims as are being altered or otherwise
affected by this Stipulation.
14.
The Parties acknowledge that this Stipulation is a compromise of disputed claims
and that no Party admits , and each expressly denies , any liability on its part.
15.
Each person signing this Stipulation
duly authorized and has the requisite authority to execute and deliver this Stipulation on behalf
of such Party and/or to bind hislher
Stipulation.
16.
The Parties further declare that , in making this Stipulation , they rely entirely upon
their own judgment , beliefs and interests and the advice of their counsel (for whose expense each
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 32 of 90
shall be solely responsible) and that they have had a reasonable period of time to
Stipulation.
17.
The Parties agree that each Party has reviewed this Stipulation and that each
understands and voluntarily accepts all the provisions contained in this Stipulation.
further agree that this Stipulation was the product of negotiations between each of the Claimants
and the Trust and that any rule of construction
drafting party shall not apply in the interpretation of this Stipulation.
18.
The language of all parts of this Stipulation shall
whole, according to its fair meaning and not strictly for or against any of the Parties.
19.
by any
Should any immaterial provision of this Stipulation be declared or be
, invalid or unenforceable , the
validity and enforceability of the
thereby and said illegal , unenforceable or invalid part , term or provision shall be deemed not to
be a part of this Stipulation.
20.
This Stipulation sets forth the
supercedes any and all prior agreements and understandings , written or oral , among the Parties
pertaining to the subject matter hereof.
21.
No modification of this
writing and signed by each of the Parties.
22.
This Stipulation shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of the Parties, their
executors , successors , administrators and assigns.
respective heirs ,
23.
each of the
With respect to any action to enforce the tenns and provisions of this Agreement
, while the
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Jul 01 08 10:42a
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 33 of 90
Bankruptcy Cases are pending in this Court, and
Delaware and each of the Parties
other fonnn.
24.
This Stipulation may be
, and signatures
supplied by facsimile or other electronic means shall be deemed as if originals, and all of which
together shaH constitute one and the same instrument.
AGREED:
Dated:
J;J
2008
Dated:
2008
DB STRUCTURED PRODUCTS INC.
By:
Dated;
2008
ASPEN FUNDING CORP.
By:
Dated:
2008
NEWPORT FUNDING CORP.
By:
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 34 of 90
Bankruptcy Cases are pending in this Court, and
Delaware and each of the Parties expressly waives any right to commence any such action in any
other forum.
24.
This Stipulation may be
supplied by facsimile or other electronic means shall be deemed as if originals, and all of which
together shall constitute one and the same instrument.
AGREED:
Dated:
2008
THE LIQUIDATING TRUST OF RES MORTGAGE CORPORATION
By: Alan M. Jacobs , Trustee
vJn ~AmOYe...
Dated:
/3
2008
DB STRUCTURED PRODUCTS INC.
/BY:G'I.IiN~ UmKoFr
ASPEN FUNDING ORP.
2008
By:
Dated:
2008
NEWPORT FUNDING CORP.
By:
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 35 of 90
Bankruptcy Cases are pending in this
Delaware and each of the Parties expressly waives any right to commence any such action in any
other forum.
24.
This Stipulation may be
supplied by facsimile or other' electronic means shall be deemed as if originals . and all of which
together shall constitute one and the same
AGREED:
Dated:
2008
THE LIQUIDATING TRUST OF RESMAE MORTGAGE CORPORATION
By: Alan M. Jacobs, Trustee
DB STRUCTURED PRODUCTS INC.
Dated:
2008
By:
Dated:
, 2008
ASPEN FUNDING CORP.
By: Doris
Dated:
2008
NEWPORT FUNDING CORP.
By: Doris
~!J-t~ ~ih~
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 36 of 90
Dated:
2008
LEHMAN BROTHERS BANK FSB
By:
z;1~~
AURORA LOAN SERVICES LLC
By:
BARCLA YS BANK. PLC,
Dated:
2008
Dated:
2008
By:
Dated:
2008
JPMORGANCHASE BANK NA
By:
Dated:
2008
NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL INC.
By:
Dated:
2008
MERRll..L LYNCH BANK USA
By:
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 37 of 90
Dated:
2008
LEHMAN BROTHERS BANK FSB
By:
Dated:
2008
AURORA LOAN SERVICES LLC
Dated:
2008
BARCLA YS BANK PLC
By:
Dated:
2008
JPMORGANCHASE BANK NA
By:
Dated:
2008
NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL INC.
By;
Dated:
2008
MERRILL LYNCH BANK USA
By:
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 38 of 90
Dated:
2008 .
LEHMAN BROTHERS BANK FSB
By:
Dated:
2008
AURORA LOAN SERVICES LLC
By:
Dated:
2008
BARCLA YS BANK PLC,
By:
~k:O~ J,
t,SE MTl-trJR
Dated:
2008
JPMORGANCHASE BANK NA
By:
Dated:
2008
NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL INC.
By:
Da~ed:
2008
MERRILL LYNCH BANK USA
By:
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 39 of 90
Dated:
2008
LEHMAN BROTHERS BANK FSB
By:
Dated:
2008
AURORA LOAN SERVICES LLC
By:
Dated:
2008
BARCLA YS BANK PLC
By:
Dated:
2008
JPMORGANCHASE BANK
Y'
By: JO~
. MANAOI~
.I /1
II'
DlRECfOR
Dated:
2008
NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL INC.
By:
Dated:
2008
MERRILL LYNCH BANK USA
By:
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 40 of 90
Dated:
2008
LEHMAN BROTHERS BANK FSB
By:
Dated:
2008
AURORA LOAN SERVICES LLC
By:
Dated:
, 2008
BARCLA YS BANK PLC
By:
Dated:
, 2008
JPMORGANCHASE BANK NA
By:
DatOO:
2008
NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL INC.
Dated:
2008
MERRILL LYNCH BANK USA
By:
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 41 of 90
Dated:
2008
LEHMAN BRO' fIJERS BANK . FSB
By:
Dated:
2008
AURORA LOAN SERVICES LLC
By:
Dated:
, ZOOS
BARCLAYSaANK PLC.
By:
Dated: .
2008
JPMQfWANCHASE BANK NA
By:
Dated:
2Q08
NOMURA CREDIT & CAPITAL INe;
By:
Dated:
2008
MERRILL LYNCHBANKUSA.
- US
G0'
t1.99
6\;,p ZTC=
HjI~:J.. 1
~~ : 9~
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 42 of 90
P2! . d ll;;jJ,O,l
Dated;
2008
Dated;
2008
By:
K~tatl Par$~h VlcePr&sraent:
Da.ted:
2008
J....ASALLEaANK NA TIONAL ASSOCIATION, ,sOLliL Y iN ITS CAP ACITY A$ "TRUSTEE FOR
ME~LL LYNCH
INVESTORS TRUSTMORTGAOE LOAN
ASS~T :BACKED CERTIFIGA TE SERlES, ZOO6
By:
Dated:
2008
LASALLE
ASSOCIA
CAPAC.ITY AS
MER~ILL LYNCH MQR'ItlAGE INVESTORS TRUST MORtGAGE LOAN ASSET BACKED CERTIFlCA TES SERIES 2006 RM 2
By:
Dateq:
2008
LASALLE BANK NA TlONAL ASSOCIATION, SOLELY IN
E0'
E1.99 Gill' Ere:
HjN..." ,
111;:j;:J31..J,
to;;:
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 43 of 90
Dated:
2008
MBRRn.L LYNCH FUNDING CORP
By:
Dated:
2008
MERRILL LYNCH MORTGAGE LENDING INC.
By:
D_:
200S
LASALLE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, SOLELY IN ITS AS TRUSTEE FOR CAPACITY MERRilL LYNCH INVESTORS TRUST MORTGAGE LOAN ASSET BACKED CERTIFICATES
SE
Dated:~2008
LASALLE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, SOLELY IN ITS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE FOR MERRILL LYNCH MORTGAGE 1NVESTORS TRUST MORTGAGE LOAN ASSET BACKED CERTIFICATES
SE
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 44 of 90
Dared:~2008
LASALLE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, SOLELY IN ITS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE FOR MERRILL L YNCR MORTGAGE INVESTORS TRUST MORTGAGE LOAN ASSET BACKED CERTIFICATES
BY:
VICe President
Dated:
2008
LASALLE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, SOLELY IN ITS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE FOR MBRRll-L L YNCR MORTGAGE INVESTORS TRUST MORTGAGE LOAN ASSET BACKED CERTIFICATES
WES
tJIJL
BY:
Vice President
DatOO:
2008
LASALLE BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, SOLELY IN ITS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE FOR MERRILL LYNCH MORTGAGE INVESTORS TRUST MORTGAGE LOAN ASSET BACKED CERTIFICATES
006RM5
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 45 of 90
Exhibit A
Claimants that are Parties to the Stipulation of Settlement Resolving
DB Structured Products Inc.
Aspen Funding Corp,
Newport Funding Corp,
Lehman Brothers Bank FSB
Aurora Loan Services LLC
Barclays Bank PLC
JPMorganChase Bank NA
Nomura Credit & Capital Inc,
Merrill Lynch Bank USA Merrill Lynch Funding Corp.
Merrill Lynch Mortgage Lending Inc.
LaSalle Bank National Association , Solely in its Capacity as Trustee for Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust Mortgage Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM LaSalle Bank National Association , Solely in its Capacity as Trustee for Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust Mortgage Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM 2
LaSalle Bank National Association , Solely in its Capacity as Trustee for Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust Mortgage Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM 3
LaSalle Bank National Association , Solely in its Capacity as Trustee for Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust Mortgage Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM 4
LaSalle Bank National Association , Solely in its Capacity as Trustee for Merrill Lynch Mortgage Investors Trust Mortgage Loan Asset Backed Certificates Series 2006 RM 5
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 46 of 90
EXHIBIT B
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 47 of 90
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELA WARE
In re:
Chapter 11
LIQVIDA TING TRUST OF RESMAE
Case No. 07- 10177
(KJC)
MORTGAGE CORPORATION
f/kla RES MAE CORPORATION
Ref. No.
Debtor.
ORDER GRANTING MOTION PURSUANT TO BANKRUPTCY RULE 9019 TO APPROVE A STIPULATION OF SETTLEMENT RESOLVING CLAIMS
Upon consideration of the motion (the "Motion
l of the Liquidating Trust of
ResMAE Mortgage Corporation (the " Trust") for entry of an order pursuant to section
chapter 11 of title
Bankruptcy Code ) and Rule 9019 of the
Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure (the " Bankruptcy Rules ) for approval of a stipulation of
settlement (the " Stipulation
) between the Trust and the parties listed on Exhibit A
the Stipulation; it appearing that the Court has jurisdiction to consider the Motion pursuant to 28
U.S. C. 99 157 and
157(b )(2);
C. g
interests of the Debtor , its Estate and its creditors; and it appearing that due notice of the Motion
has been given , and that no further notice need be given; and sufficient cause appearing therefor;
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:
The Motion is GRANTED on the terms set forth herein. The Stipulation attached hereto is hereby approved,
1 Unless otherwise defined herein
, all capitalized terms shall have the meanings ascribed to them in the Motion.
596, 002-21018, DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 48 of 90
The Trust is
instruments that may be reasonably necessary to consummate the resolution contemplated by the
Stipulation,
This Court retains jurisdiction (i) to interpret , implement and enforce the
terms and provisions of the
, implement and
provisions of this Order.
Dated: July
Wilmington, Delaware
The Honorable Kevin J. Carey United States Bankruptcy Judge
596, OO2.21018, DOC
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 49 of 90
IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
INRE:
LIQUIDATING TRUST OF RES MAE MORTGAGE CORPORATION, a Delaware Corporation
Debtor.
Chapter 11
Case No. 07- 10177
(KJC)
STIPULATION OF SETTLEMENT RESOLVING CLAIMS
This Stipulation of Settlement Resolving Claims (the " Stipulation ) is entered into by and
among the Liquidating Trust of Res MAE Mortgage Corporation (the " Trust") and the Parties
who are listed on Exhibit A annexed hereto and who are signatories hereto (the " Claimants
collectively, with the Trust, the " Parties
RECITALS
As and for the Recitals to this Stipulation, the Parties assert the following:
On February 12 , 2007 , ResMAE
voluntary petition under chapter
II U.
Debtor
), filed a
Bankruptcy Code
C. ~~ 101- 1330
in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of
Court"
On February 12 , 2007 , the Debtor filed with the Court its Schedules of Assets and
Liabilities (as amended from time to time, the " Schedules
Case 1:07-cv-00428-SLR
Document 14-2
Filed 07/16/2008
Page 50 of 90
By order dated March 26 , 2007 (the "Bar
Date Order
), the Court
April 30 , 2007 at 5:00 p. m. (prevailing Pacific Time) as the last date and time for the filing of
proofs of claim in this chapter 11 case (the Bar
Date
filed claim
On or about July 11 ,
2007 , DB Structured Products Inc. (" DBSP" )
number 234 (the " DB Filed Claim ), which is alleged to be a general unsecured claim seeking an
unliquidated amount of not
Repurchase Agreement dated as
841 737, 13 arising out of that
, 2005 (as amended , supplemented and
modified from time to time) and that
Servicing Agreement dated as of November 1 , 2006 (as amended , supplemented and otherwise
modified from time to
previously timely filed claims.
DBSP is listed on the Debtors ' schedule F as having an unliquidated , contingent
and disputed unsecure