Free Claim Construction Chart - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 1 of 3

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE ON SEMICONDUCTOR CORP. and SEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, L.L.C., Plaintiffs, v. SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD., SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS AMERICA, INC., SAMSUNG TELECOMMUNICATIONS AMERICA GENERAL, L.L.C., SAMSUNG SEMICONDUCTOR, INC., and SAMSUNG AUSTIN SEMICONDUCTOR L.L.C., Defendants. SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD., SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS AMERICA, INC., SAMSUNG TELECOMMUNICATIONS AMERICA GENERAL, L.L.C., SAMSUNG SEMICONDUCTOR, INC., and SAMSUNG AUSTIN SEMICONDUCTOR L.L.C., Plaintiffs, v. ON SEMICONDUCTOR CORP. and SEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, L.L.C., Defendants. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

C.A. No. 07-449 (JJF)

C.A. No. 06-720 (JJF)

FINAL JOINT CLAIM CONSTRUCTION CHARTS Pursuant to the Scheduling Order entered by the Court on October 5, 2007 (D.I. 47 (C.A. No. 07-449-JJF)), and as amended on March 24, 2008 (D.I. 86 (C.A. No. 07-449-JJF); D.I. 113 (C.A. No. 06-720-JJF)), ON Semiconductor Corp. and Semiconductor Components Industries, L.L.C. (collectively "ON Semiconductor") and Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Electronics America, Inc., Samsung Telecommunications America General, L.L.C.,

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 2 of 3

Samsung Semiconductor, Inc., and Samsung Austin Semiconductor L.L.C. (collectively "Samsung") hereby submit their Final Joint Claim Construction Charts. I. STIPULATED CONSTRUCTIONS. During the meet and confer process, the parties agreed on the constructions set forth in Exhibit A. II. CLAIM TERMS REQUIRING CONSTRUCTION BY THE COURT. The parties' Joint Claim Construction Charts for U.S. Patent No. 5,000,827 (the "'827 Patent"), U.S. Patent No. 5,361,001 (the "'001 Patent"), U.S. Patent No. 5,563,594 (the "'594 Patent"), U.S. Patent 6,362,644 (the "'644 Patent") and U.S. Patent No. 5,252,177 (the "'177 Patent") are attached hereto as Exhibits B, C, D, E and F, respectively. Each chart identifies the first occurrence of disputed claim terms in each patent, the parties' proposed constructions for the disputed claim terms, and the parties' identification of the intrinsic and/or extrinsic evidence supporting its proposed construction.

MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL LLP

YOUNG, CONAWAY, STARGATT & TAYLOR LLP

/s/ Richard J. Bauer
__________________________________ Karen Jacobs Louden (#2881) Richard J. Bauer (#4828) 1201 N. Market Street P.O. Box 1347 Wilmington, DE 19899 (302) 658-9200 [email protected]

/s/ Andrew A. Lundgren
__________________________________ John W. Shaw (#3362) Andrew A. Lundgren (#4429) The Brandywine Building 1000 West Street, 17th Floor Wilmington, DE 19801 (302) 571-6600 [email protected]

Attorneys for ON Semiconductor Corp. and Attorneys for Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., Semiconductor Components Industries, Samsung Electronics America, Inc., Samsung L.L.C. Telecommunications America General, L.L.C., Samsung Semiconductor, Inc. and Samsung Austin Semiconductor, L.L.C.

2

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 3 of 3

OF COUNSEL: Kenneth R. Adamo JONES DAY 2727 North Harwood Street Dallas, TX 75201-1515 (214) 220-3939 Tharan Gregory Lanier Behrooz Shariati JONES DAY 1755 Embarcadero Road Palo Alto, CA 94303 (650) 739-3939 March 31, 2008

OF COUNSEL: John M. Desmarais John T. Hohenthaner James E. Marina KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 153 East 53rd Street New York, NY 10022 (212) 446-4800 Edward C. Donovan KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP 655 Fifteenth Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20005-5793 (202) 879-5000

3

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2 EXHIBIT A

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 1 of 42

ON Semiconductor Corp. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Case No. 07-449-JJF) Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., v. ON Semiconductor Corp. (Case No. 06-720-JJF)

STIPULATED CONSTRUCTIONS

U.S. Patent No. 5,000,827 First appearing in Claim 1: · flow rate: "a measure of volume flowing per unit of time"

U.S. Patent No. 5,361,001 First appearing in Claim 4: · latching: "holding data in a ready position or condition"

U.S. Patent No. 6,362,644 First appearing in Claim 12 · semiconductor package: "package, such as an enclosure, for a semiconductor device"

1

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 2 of 42

EXHIBIT B ON Semiconductor Corp. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Case No. 07-449-JJF) Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., v. ON Semiconductor Corp. (Case No. 06-720-JJF)

Disputed Terms from U.S. Patent No. 5,000,827 Asserted Claims 1. A method of forming metallized bumps on predetermined terminal areas of a planar substrate, said bumps being of substantially uniform height across said substrate, wherein said method comprises: ON Semi Proposed Constructions metallized bumps: ON Semiconductor notes that this term appears only in the preamble of the asserted claim. Because this term does not recite limitations or give life, meaning, and vitality to the claim, no construction is needed. If the Court is inclined to construe this term, however, ON Semiconductor contends that it should be construed as follows: "the non-planar accumulation of a metal layer or layers" Samsung Proposed Constructions metallized bump: "A small mound formed of metal on a semiconductor pad that is utilized as a contact for face down bonding." The preamble is a limitation. ON Semiconductor's Support Samsung's Support

'827 Patent: col. 1:9-13, 1:1518, 1:30-37, 1:50-52, 1:53-60, 2:29-35, 2:36-41, 5:46-49, and related Figures. C R M Grovenor, Microelectronic Materials 36768 (B. Cantor ed., 1998). Stephen Beeby et al., MEMS Mechanical Sensors 33-34 (2004). Nasser Kanani, Electroplating: Basic Principles, Processes and Practice 4-5 (2004). Jack Arabian, Computer Integrated Electronics Manufacturing and Testing 486

'827 Patent, Abstract, Figs. 3C, 4, Col. 1:9-13; 1:15-18; 1:30-37; 1:50-52; 3:31-48; 3:63-65; 4:1-3; 4:20-24; 4:28-30; 5:46-49 '827 Patent Prosecution History, 5/24/90 Office Action at 3; Response to Office Action dated 7/23/90, at pp. 2-5 Japanese Kokai Patent HEI 1198,017 Japanese Kokai Patent 123,089 Japanese Kokai Patent SHO 5328039 U.S. Patent No. 4,906,341

2

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 3 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support (1989). Fred W. Kear, Printed Circuit Assembly Manufacturing 35-38 (1987).

Samsung's Support U.S. Patent No. 4,855,251 U.S. Patent No. 4,263,606 Modern Dictionary of Electronics, 6th Ed. (1984), at p. 121 ("bump")

Frank Porter, Zinc Handbook: Properties, Processing, and Use Dictionary of Electronic in Design 520-21 (1991). Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at pp. 16 ("bump," "bumped chips"), 85 ("metallization") See generally regarding electrodeposition, Electroplating and Electrorefining of Metals, Alexander Watt, Arnold Philip (2005, originally published in 1902)

said bumps being of substantially uniform height across said substrate: ON Semiconductor notes that this phrase appears only in the preamble of the asserted claim. Because this term does not recite limitations or give life, meaning, and vitality to the claim, no construction is needed. However, if the Court is inclined to construe

said bumps being of substantially uniform height across said substrate: "Small mounds of metal utilized as contacts having substantially the same height above the semiconductor pad on which they are formed across the wafer." The preamble is a limitation.

'827 Patent: col. 5:50-59, 5:606:3, and related Figures. Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary 1287 (10th ed. 2001). The American Heritage Dictionary 1321 (2nd College ed. 1985).

'827 Patent, Abstract, Figs. 3C, 4, 6 (prior art), 9, 10, Col. 1:9-13; 2:18-23; 2:28-41; 2:67-68; 3:1-8; 3:9-13; 3:31-48; 4:4-6; 4:14-16; 4:17-19; 4:20-24; 4:28-30; 5:3142; 5:50-6:9 '827 Patent Prosecution History, Response to Office Action dated 7/23/90, at p. 3 Japanese Kokai Patent HEI 1-

3

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 4 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions this, ON Semiconductor contends that the phrase can be understood with the following construction: bumps: (separately construed below); substantially uniform height: (separately construed below).

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support 198017 Japanese Kokai Patent SHO 5328039 U.S. Patent No. 3,855,083 U.S. Patent No. 4,170,959 See also support for "metallized bump"

said bumps: see "metallized bumps"

bumps: see proposed construction for "metallized bump"

See "metallized bumps."

see support for "metallized bump"

substantially uniform height: "approximately the same distance between the top of the bump and the top surface of the substrate."

substantially uniform height: see proposed construction for "said bumps being of substantially uniform height across said substrate"

See "said bumps being of substantially uniform height across said substrate."

see support for "said bumps being of substantially uniform height across said substrate"

(a) providing a planar substrate having thereon a multiplicity of terminal areas; (b) applying an electrical potential having a first electrical polarity to said terminal areas; (c) applying an electrical potential having a second electrical polarity to an electrical terminal immersed in a container of an electroplating solution;

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

4

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 5 of 42

Asserted Claims (d) exposing said substrate to said electroplating solution to permit the growth of said metallization bumps on said terminal areas; (e) controlling the growth of said metallization bumps in a predetermined region of said substrate by altering the metallic ion concentration of said electroplating solution in said predetermined region; (f) providing said container with an opening whose shape approximates that of said substrate; (g) positioning said substrate proximate to said container opening; (h) providing an inlet within said container for pumping said solution into said container, said solution exiting said container through said opening; wherein said metallic ion concentration of said electroplating solution is changed by:

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support

(k) in step (h) altering the flow rate of said solution through said opening.

altering the flow rate of said solution through said opening: "changing the volume of electroplating solution per unit of time flowing out of the opening." flow rate: (separately construed in Exhibit A).

altering the flow rate of said solution through said opening: "Changing the volume of electroplating solution per unit of time through the opening of the solution container during the formation of the metallic bumps to control their growth in a predetermined region of 5

'827 Patent: col. 4:65-68, 5:1830, 5:43-45, and related Figures.

'827 Patent, Abstract, Figs. 7, 11, Col. 2:42-47; 2:59-62; 3:1-8; 3:31-48; 4:7-10; 4:20-24; 4:3841; 4:65-68; 5:1-11; claim 1 '827 Patent Prosecution History, 5/24/90 Office Action at 3; Response to Office Action dated 7/23/90, at pp. 2-6 Japanese Kokai Patent HEI 1-

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 6 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions the substrate."

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support 198,017 Japanese Kokai Patent 123,089 Japanese Kokai Patent 242,797 Japanese Kokai Patent SHO 5328039 Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary (1988), at p. 75 ("alter") Webster's Third New International Dictionary (1986), at p. 63 ("alter")

2. The method of according to claim 1, wherein said metallization bumps comprise metal selected from the group consisting of silver and tin.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

6

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 7 of 42

EXHIBIT C ON Semiconductor Corp. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Case No. 07-449-JJF) Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., v. ON Semiconductor Corp. (Case No. 06-720-JJF) Disputed Terms from U.S. Patent No. 5,361,001 Asserted Claims 4. A method of analog trimming, comprising the steps of: ON Semi Proposed Constructions analog trimming: ON Semiconductor notes that this term appears only in the preamble of the asserted claim. Because this term does not recite limitations or give life, meaning, and vitality to the claim, no construction is needed. If the Court is inclined to construe this term, however, ON Semiconductor contends that it should be construed as follows: "modifying an analog value or quantity" Samsung Proposed Constructions analog trimming: "Making a fine adjustment of capacitance, inductance, or resistance of an analog circuit component." The preamble is a limitation. ON Semiconductor's Support Samsung's Support

'001 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:6-2:5, 2:15- 4:51, Figs. 1, 2. Response to Office Action dated 6/27/94, pp. 2-4. Eduard Sackinger and Walter Guggenbuhl, An Analog Trimming Circuit Based on a Floating-Gate Device, IEEE J. of Solid State Circuits, vol. SC-23. no. 6, Dec. 1988, at 1437-40. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 39-40 (1984). Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary 41 (10th ed. 2001). See e.g. American Heritage Dictionary 106, 1295 (2nd College

'001 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:6-26; 1:39-43; 1:57-61; 2:8-9; 2:15-19; 2:42-45; 2:63-68; 3:1-21 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 140 ("trimming") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at p. 2265 ("trim") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 554 ("trimming") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 650 ("trim," "trimmer") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of

7

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 8 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support ed. 1985).

Samsung's Support Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 2070-71 ("trim," "trimmer capacitor")

enabling conduction through a passive element in response to a first state of a control signal;

control signal: "an electrical effect that conveys information about regulation or guidance"

control signal: "A signal that enables or disables conduction through an associated passive element of a trim circuit."

'001 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:11-13, 2:24-62, 3:22-4:17, 4:43-47, Figs. 1, 2 Response to Office Action dated 6/27/94, pp. 2-4. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 917-20 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 133-39 (1977). Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary 252 (10th ed. 2001). American Heritage Dictionary 319, 1139 (2nd College ed. 1985).

'001 Patent, Abstract, Col. 2:10-11; 2:28-42; 2:46-49; 2:57-59; 3:24-27; 3:33-35; 3:40-43; 3:57-60; 4:3-6 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 121 ("signal") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at p. 514 ("control signal") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 114 ("control signal," "control circuit"), 484 ("signal") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 589 ("signal") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 454 ("control signal"), 1823 ("signal")

disabling conduction through said passive

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

8

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 9 of 42

Asserted Claims element in response to a second state of said control signal; activating said control signal in response to a data signal to enable and disable said conduction through said passive element, said activating step including the steps (a) latching said data signal, and (b) logically combining said data signal with a logic signal for providing said control signal; and setting said control signal to a fixed value after removal of said data signal.

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support

fixed value: "a state that is not fluctuating or varying during a specified or predetermined time or condition"

fixed value: "A value that does not change."

'001 Patent: Abstract, col. 4:14-17, claim 5, Figs. 1, 2. Response to Office Action dated 6/27/94, pgs. 2-4. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics, 380-81 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 258-59 (1977).

see support for "setting said control signal to a fixed value"

setting said control signal to a

setting said control signal to a 9

See "fixed value" and "control

'001 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:6-10;

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 10 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions fixed value: The Court need not construe this, however, if the Court is inclined to construe this, ON Semiconductor contends that the phrase can be understood with the following constructions: fixed value: (separately construed above); control signal: (separately construed above);

Samsung Proposed Constructions fixed value: "Permanently setting the state of the control signal."

ON Semiconductor's Support signal."

Samsung's Support 1:26-29; 1:48-56; 1:61-2:2; 2:3-5; 3:45-54; 3:66-4:2; 4:7-17; 4:18-30; 4:35-47; 4:49-51; claim 5 Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at p. 1964 ("set") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 479 ("set") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 584 ("set") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 1801 ("set")

10

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 11 of 42

EXHIBIT D ON Semiconductor Corp. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Case No. 07-449-JJF) Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., v. ON Semiconductor Corp. (Case No. 06-720-JJF) Disputed Terms from U.S. Patent No. 5,563,594 Asserted Claims 8. A data conversion circuit, comprising: ON Semi Proposed Constructions N/A Samsung Proposed Constructions N/A ON Semiconductor's Support Samsung's Support

N/A

N/A

a register having an input coupled for receiving parallel input data and having an output;

a register having an input coupled for receiving parallel input data and having an output: It is ON Semiconductor's position that the Court need not construe this entire phrase. Instead, ON Semiconductor believes that the phrase can be understood according to the plain and ordinary meaning of its constituent terms or words. If the Court is inclined to construe this phrase, ON Semiconductor contends that it can be understood simply by construing the following terms:

a register having an input coupled for receiving parallel input data and having an output: "A storage circuit that receives each bit of the input data simultaneously over several input lines."

See "register."

'594 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:7-22; 1:25-27; 1:36-45; 1:57-59; 2:6-15; 2:26-29; 3:3-12; 3:18-29; 4:15-17; 5:38-44; claim 14 Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at pp. 586 ("data"), 1571 ("parallel input/output"), 1824 ("register," "register circuit") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 132 ("data"), 382 ("parallel," "parallel input/output"), 448 ("register") The Illustrated Dictionary of

11

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 12 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions register: (separately construed below). coupled: (separately construed below).

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at pp. 156-57 ("data"), 480-81 ("parallel," "parallel output"), 554 ("register") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 517 ("data"), 1443-45 ("parallel," " parallel input/output," "parallel transmission"), 1678 ("register")

register: "a device capable of retaining or storing information."

register: see proposed construction for "a register having an input coupled for receiving parallel input data and having an output"

'594 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:7-60, 2:7-6:28, Figs. 1, 3. Response to Office Action dated 2/22/96, p. 2. Donald L. Schilling, Electronic Circuits, Discrete, and Integrated 648-56 (1979). Nicholas L. Pappas, Digital Design 411-17 (1994). M. Morris Mano, Digital Logic and Computer Design 289-94 (1979). Edward J. McCluskey, Logic Design Principles 303 (1986). Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics, 843-44 (1984).

see support for "a register having an input coupled for receiving parallel input data and having an output"

12

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 13 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 575-76 (1977). John Markus, McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 448 (1994).

Samsung's Support

coupled: "linked together"

coupled: The meaning of this term requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the term should be construed as "directly connected."

'594 Patent: col. 3:31-65, Figs. 1, 3. Response to Office Action dated 2/22/96, p. 2. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 208-09 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 146-48 (1977). John Markus, McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 119 (1994).

a multiplexer having an input coupled to said output of said register for providing serial data;

a multiplexer having an input coupled to said output of said register for providing serial data: The Court need not construe this, however, if the Court is inclined to construe this, ON Semiconductor contends that the phrase can be understood with the following construction:

a multiplexer having an input coupled to said output of said register for providing serial data: "A circuit that sequentially transmits the parallel input data from the register one bit at a time over a single output line."

See "multiplexer."

'594 Patent, Abstract, Col. 2:15-18; 2:29-31; 4:24-27 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 91 ("multiplexer") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at

13

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 14 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions multiplexer (separately construed below).

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support pp. 586 ("data"), 1426 ("multiplexer"), 1960 ("serial," "serial data," "serial input/output") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp.132 ("data"), 352-53 ("multiplexer"), 478 ("serial," "serial input/output," "serial transfer") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at pp. 156-57 ("data"), 433 ("multiplexer"), 581-82 ("serial," "serial transfer") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 517 ("data"), 1309 ("multiplexer"), 1797-98 ("serial," "serial input/output," "serial transfer")

multiplexer: "a device capable of manipulating multiple streams of digital information."

multiplexer: see proposed construction for "a multiplexer having an input coupled to said output of said register for providing serial data"

'594 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:11-18, see support for "a multiplexer 2:14-17, 4:25-28, 5:35-41, Figs. 1, 3. having an input coupled to said output of said register for providing Response to Office Action dated serial data" 2/22/96, p. 2. Nicholas L. Pappas, Digital Design 231-46 (1994).

14

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 15 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support M. Morris Mano, Digital Logic and Computer Design 175-82 (1979). Edward J. McCluskey, Logic Design Principles 507-10 (1986). Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics, 648-49 (1984). Alfred W. Barber, Practical Guide To Digital Integrated Circuits 94-95 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms, 430-31 (1977). Markus, John, McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary, 352-53 (1994).

Samsung's Support

a comparator having first and second inputs and an output, said first input receiving a first control signal, said second input receiving a second control signal, said output providing a compare signal having a first state when said first and second control signals match; and

comparator: "an electronic device comparator: "A device whose that receives input from two or output signal depends on the result more sources and provides an of comparing two data items." output responsive to a comparison of the inputs"

'594 Patent: col. 3:31-49, 4:1-10, 4:32-45, Figs. 1-3. Response to Office Action dated 2/22/96, p. 2. Donald L. Schilling, Electronic Circuits, Discrete, and Integrated 586-87 (1979). Nicholas L. Pappas, Digital Design 255-56 (1994).

'594 Patent, Col. 3:30-43; 3:66-4:4; 4:27-30; 4:31-34; 4:39-42; claims 1, 5, 7, 12 '594 Prosecution History, Response and Amendment to Office Action dated 2/2/1996, at pp. 1-3 Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at pp. 479 ("comparator," "comparator circuit"), 1323

15

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 16 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support ("match")

Mano, M. Morris, Digital Logic and Computer Design 164-67 (1979). Adel S. Sedra, Microelectronic Circuits 231-42 (2nd ed. 1987). Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 183 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 118 (1977). John Markus, McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 105 (1994).

McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 105 ("comparator," "comparison") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 127 ("comparator") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 418 ("comparator," "comparator circuit")

control signal: "an electrical effect that conveys information about regulation or guidance"

control signal: "A signal for controlling the phase of the transfer data signal."

'594 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:7-10, 2;15-19, 2:67-3:2, 3:24-30, 6:6-12, 6:15-28, 6:35-37, Figs. 1-3. Response to Office Action dated 2/22/96, p. 2. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 917-20 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 133-39 (1977). Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary 252 (10th ed. 2001).

'594 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:7-10; 2:38-60; 2:62-64; 2:67-3:2; 3:1318; 3:18-29; 3:30-43; 3:66-4:4; 4:16-21; 4:27-30; 4:31-34; 4:39-42; 6:6-7; 6:15-24; 6:35-37; claims 1, 5, 7 '594 Prosecution History, Response and Amendment to Office Action dated 2/2/1996, at pp. 1-3 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 121 ("signal") Academic Press Dictionary of

16

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 17 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support Science and Technology (1992), at p. 514 ("control signal") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp.114 ("control circuit", "control signal"), 484 ("signal") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 589 ("signal") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 454 ("control signal"), 1823 ("signal")

first and second control signals match: The Court need not construe this, however, if the Court is inclined to construe this, ON Semiconductor contends that the phrase can be understood with the following constructions: control signals: (separately construed above); match: (separately construed below).

first and second control signals match: "The data represented by the first and second control signals is the same."

See "control signals" and "match."

'594 Patent, Col. 3:30-43; 3:66-4:4; 4:27-30; 4:31-34; 4:39-42; claims 1, 5, 7, 12 '594 Prosecution History, Response and Amendment to Office Action dated 2/2/1996, at pp. 1-3 Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at pp. 479 ("comparator," "comparator circuit"), 1323 ("match") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 105

17

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 18 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support ("comparator," "comparison") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 127 ("comparator") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 418 ("comparator," "comparator circuit")

match: "corresponding, suitably associated, or harmonious"

match: see proposed construction for "first and second control signals match"

'594 Patent: col. 3:40-42, 3:66-4:4, 4:27-35, 4:40-45, Figs. 1-3. Response to Office Action dated 2/22/96, p. 2. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 604 (1984). John Markus, McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 328 (1994). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 403 (1977).

see support for "first and second control signals match"

a down counter responsive to said compare signal for initializing a count value

clock signal: "an electrical effect that conveys clocking or timing information"

clock signal: "A signal consisting of a series of pulses used for synchronizing the data conversion circuit." 18

'594 Patent: col. 1:25-32, 1:40-45, 2:7-6:12, Figs. 1-3. Response to Office Action dated

'594 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:40-41; 2:21-34; 2:35-38; 3:64-65; 4:4-10; 4:36-40; 4:51-53; 4:63-65; 5:8-10;

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 19 of 42

Asserted Claims and responsive to a clock signal for counting down to generate a transfer data signal having a symmetric duty cycle to enable transfer of said parallel input data to said register.

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support 2/22/96, p. 2. See "signal." Donald L. Schilling, Electronic Circuits, Discrete, and Integrated 618-20 (1979). Nicholas L. Pappas, Digital Design 301-07 (1994). M. Morris Mano, Digital Logic and Computer Design 202-05 (1979). Edward J. McCluskey, Logic Design Principles 335-37 (1986). Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 165-66 (1984). Alfred W. Barber, Practical Guide To Digital Integrated Circuits 78-80 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 104 (1977).

Samsung's Support 5:18-20; claims 1, 2, 7, 9 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at pp. 24 ("clock"), 121 ("signal") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at p. 447 ("clock," "clock cycle," "clock pulses") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 92 ("clock"), 484 ("signal") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at pp. 115 ("clock"), 589 ("signal") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 387 ("clock"), 1823 ("signal")

transfer data signal: "an electrical effect that conveys information regarding the transfer of data"

transfer data signal: "A periodic signal requesting that external logic write the next set of parallel input data to the register." 19

'594 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:7-10, 1:52-60, 2:18-20, 2:62-67, 3:14-30, 3:44-6:12, Figs. 1-3. Response to Office Action dated

'594 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:7-10; 1:20-22; 1:33-36; 1:36-40; 2:673:2; 3:13-18; 3:25-30; 3:44-47; 4:16-23; 5:23-30; 6:6-12; 6:13-17;

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 20 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support 2/22/96, p. 2. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 1053-54 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 732-33 (1977).

Samsung's Support 6:19-24; claims 1, 4, 7 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 121 ("signal") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at p. 586 ("data") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 132 ("data"), 484 ("signal") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at pp. 156-57 ("data"), 589 ("signal") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 517 ("data"), 1823 ("signal")

20

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 21 of 42

EXHIBIT E ON Semiconductor Corp. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Case No. 07-449-JJF) Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., v. ON Semiconductor Corp. (Case No. 06-720-JJF) Disputed Terms from U.S. Patent No. 6,362,644 Asserted Claims 6. An integrated circuit, comprising: ON Semi Proposed Constructions N/A Samsung Proposed Constructions N/A ON Semiconductor's Support Samsung's Support

N/A

N/A

a semiconductor package having first and second pins respectively adapted for receiving first and second data signals, third and fourth pins for respectively receiving first and second termination signals, and a supply pin coupled for receiving a power supply voltage;

termination signal: "an electrical effect that terminates"

termination signal: "A signal that configures the circuit to receive data signals from one of several available logic families."

'644 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:15-5:3, Figs. 1-5. Response to Office Action dated 9/12/01, pp. 4, 10-13. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 1021-22 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 711-12 (1977).

'644 Patent, Col. 2:25-44; 3:8-34; 3:56-4:5; 4:19-23; 4:32-35; 4:4656; claims 10-11, 14-15 '644 Patent Prosecution History, Response to Office Action dated 9/12/2001, at pp. 10-13 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 121 ("signal") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at p. 2189 ("termination") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 484 ("signal"), 534 ("termination,"

21

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 22 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support "termination line") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at pp. 389 ("loading"), 589 ("signal") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 1823 ("signal"), 2004 ("termination")

third and fourth pins for respectively receiving first and second termination signals: The Court need not construe this, however, if the Court is inclined to construe this, ON Semiconductor contends that the phrase can be understood with the following constructions: pins (construed separately below); termination signals (construed separately below).

third and fourth pins for respectively receiving first and second termination signals: "Third and fourth pins that receive different termination signals (e.g., not power supply or ground pins) dependant upon the selected one of several available logic families."

See "pins" and "termination signals."

'644 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:39-46; 2:20-34; 3:2-23; 3:54-64; 4:12-14; 4:46-56; 4:57-5:3 '644 Patent Prosecution History, Response to Office Action dated 9/12/2001, at pp. 9-15 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 69 ("impedance") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at pp. 1090 ("impedance"), 1258 ("load"), 1733 ("programmable"), 2189 ("termination") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 309 ("load"), 534 ("termination,"

22

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 23 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support "termination line") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 389 ("load," "loading") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 1157 ("load"), 2004 ("termination")

pin(s): "a conductor configured to make an electrical connection."

pin(s): "A small diameter metal rod used as an electrical terminal external to the semiconductor package housing."

'644 Patent: Abstract, col. 2:15-5:3, Fig. 5. Response to Office Action dated 9/12/01, pp. 4, 10-13. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 749 (1984). Samsung data sheets for accused products. JEDEC publications, including JESD 79 (DDR SDRAM Specification).

'644 Patent, Abstract, Col. 2:20-23; 2:43-44; 3:2-5; 3:34-35; 3:47-49; 3:51-53; 4:16-31; 4:49-54; 4:62-5:3 '644 Patent Prosecution History, Response to Office Action dated 9/12/2001, at pp. 10, 13 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 101 ("pin") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at p. 1651 ("pin") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 401 ("pin") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p.

23

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 24 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support 500 ("pin") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 1510 ("pin")

coupled: "linked together."

coupled: The meaning of this term requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the term should be construed as "directly connected."

'644 Patent: col. 4:38-45, Fig. 5. Response to Office Action dated 9/12/01, pp. 4, 10-13. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 208-09 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 146-48 (1977). John Markus, McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 119 (1994).

'644 Patent, Col. 2:15-20; 2:63-3:2; 3:47-51; 4:32-35 McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 119 ("couple")

and a semiconductor load element(s): "electrical die housed in the devices capable of dissipating semiconductor package electrical energy." for operating from the power supply voltage, and having a first load element coupled between the first and third pins to terminate the first data signal, and a second load element

load element(s): "An impedance that provides a termination for a logic device transmission line to help reduce interconnect signal distortion."

'644 Patent: col. 2:15-20, 2:61-3:2, 3:47-51, 4:7-12, 4:32-35, 4:46-49, Figs. 1-5. Response to Office Action dated 9/12/01, pp. 4, 10-13. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 568-70 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of

'644 Patent, Col. 1:21-29; 2:15-20; 2:63-3:2; 3:47-51; 4:9-12; 4:32-35; claim 7 '644 Patent Prosecution History, Response to Office Action dated 9/12/2001, at pp. 10, 13 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 69

24

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 25 of 42

Asserted Claims coupled between the second and fourth pins to terminate the second data signal.

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support Electrical and Electronics Terms 378-80 (1977).

Samsung's Support ("impedance") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at pp. 1090 ("impedance"), 1258 ("load") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 309 ("load") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 389 ("loading," "load") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 1157 ("load")

terminate: "to dissipate or absorb energy."

terminate: "The use of a load at the end of a transmission line or other device whose impedance is matched to that of the line."

'644 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:15-5:3, Figs. 1-5. Response to Office Action dated 9/12/01, pp. 4, 10-13. Adel S. Sedra, Microelectronic Circuits 951-52 (2nd ed. 1987). Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 1021-22 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms

'644 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:15-29; 1:42-46; 2:15-16; 2:35-44; 2:633:2; 3:34-35; 3:47-49; 4:5-10 Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at pp. 1090 ("impedance"), 1258 ("load"), 2189 ("termination") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 309 ("load"), 534 ("termination," "termination line") The Illustrated Dictionary of

25

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 26 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support 711-12 (1977).

Samsung's Support Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 389 ("load," "loading") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 1157 ("load"), 2004 ("termination")

7. The integrated circuit of claims 6, wherein the first and second load elements are resistors.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

8. The integrated circuit of claim 6, wherein the semiconductor die includes a receiver circuit having first and second inputs coupled to the first and second pins, respectively.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

9. The integrated circuit of claim 6, wherein the semiconductor die includes a driver circuit having first and second outputs coupled to the

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

26

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 27 of 42

Asserted Claims first and second pins, respectively.

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support

10. The integrated circuit of claim 6, wherein the first data signal is from a first logic family, and the third pin is coupled for receiving a first termination voltage characteristic of the first logic family.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

12. A method of operating an integrated circuit, comprising the steps of: applying first and second logic signals to first and second pins, respectively, of a semiconductor package of the integrated circuit;

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

and loading the first and second logic signals with first and second load elements, respectively, of the

first and second load elements are coupled to third and fourth pins of the semiconductor package to provide a programmable termination: The Court need not

first and second load elements are coupled to third and fourth pins of the semiconductor package to provide a programmable termination: "The first and second 27

See "load elements," "coupled," "pins," "semiconductor package," and "programmable termination."

'644 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:39-46; 2:20-34; 3:2-23; 3:54-64; 4:12-14; 4:46-56; 4:57-5:3 '644 Patent Prosecution History,

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 28 of 42

Asserted Claims integrated circuit, where the first and second load elements are coupled to third and fourth pins of the semiconductor package to provide a programmable termination for the first and second logic signals.

ON Semi Proposed Constructions construe this, however, if the Court is inclined to construe this, ON Semiconductor contends that the phrase can be understood with the following constructions: load elements (separately construed above); coupled (separately construed above); pins (separately construed above); semiconductor package (separately construed in Exhibit A); programmable termination (separately construed below).

Samsung Proposed Constructions load elements are connected to the third and fourth pins that receive different signals to configure the circuit to receive data signals from one of several available logic families."

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support Response to Office Action dated 9/12/2001, at pp. 9-15 Dictionary of Electronic Packaging, Microelectronic, & Interconnection Terms (1990), at p. 69 ("impedance") Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at pp. 1090 ("impedance"), 1258 ("load"), 1733 ("programmable"), 2189 ("termination") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 309 ("load"), 534 ("termination," "termination line") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p. 389 ("load," "loading") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 1157 ("load"), 2004 ("termination")

programmable termination: "an electrical circuit that can be configured to provide various levels or degrees for the dissipation or absorption of

programmable termination: "The capability to configure the circuit to receive data signals from one of several available logic families."

'644 Patent: Abstract, col. 1:39-41, 2:20-27, 3:2-7, 3:51-57, 4:52-62, Figs. 1-5. Response to Office Action dated

'644 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:39-46; 2:20-44; 3:2-34; 3:54-4:5; 4:12-23; 4:32-35; 4:46-56; 4:57-5:3; claims 10-11, 14-15

28

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 29 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions electrical energy"

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support 9/12/01, pp. 5, 13-15. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 782-85 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 528-29 (1977).

Samsung's Support '644 Patent Prosecution History, Response to Office Action dated 9/12/2001, at pp. 9-15 Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at p. 2189 ("termination") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 534 ("termination," "termination line") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at p. 2004 ("termination")

loading: "applying effects that dissipate electrical energy"

loading: "Placing an impedance at the end of a transmission line or other device to match that of the line."

'644 Patent: col. 2:15-20, 2:61-3:2, 3:47-51, 4:7-12, 4:32-35, 4:46-49, Figs. 1-5. Response to Office Action dated 9/12/01, pp. 5, 13-15. Rudolf F. Graf, Modern Dictionary of Electronics 568-70 (1984). IEEE Standard Dictionary of Electrical and Electronics Terms 378-80 (1977).

'644 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:15-29; 1:42-46; 2:15-16; 2:35-44; 2:633:2; 3:34-35; 3:47-49; 4:5-10 Academic Press Dictionary of Science and Technology (1992), at pp. 1090 ("impedance"), 1258 ("load"), 2189 ("termination") McGraw-Hill Electronics Dictionary 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 309 ("load"), 534 ("termination," "termination line") The Illustrated Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1994), at p.

29

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 30 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support 389 ("load," "loading") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms 5th Ed. (1994), at pp. 1157 ("load"), 2004 ("termination")

16. The integrated logic circuit of claim 12, further comprising the step of applying a power supply voltage to a fifth pin of the semiconductor package to bias the integrated circuit.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

30

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 31 of 42

EXHIBIT F ON Semiconductor Corp. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. (Case No. 07-449-JJF) Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., v. ON Semiconductor Corp. (Case No. 06-720-JJF) Disputed Terms from U.S. Patent No. 5,252,177 Asserted Claims 1. A method for forming multilayer wiring in a semiconductor device, said semiconductor device comprising a semiconductor substrate and insulation layers and conductive layers formed over a top surface of said semiconductor substrate, said method comprising the steps of: ON Semi Proposed Constructions N/A Samsung Proposed Constructions N/A ON Semiconductor's Support Samsung's Support

N/A

N/A

forming a contact hole by selectively etching out a region of an insulation layer disposed on a first conductive

first conductive layer: "A layer of material having electro-conductive properties on which a protective oxide can form."

first conductive layer: The meaning of this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "a 31

'177 Patent: col. 1:29-31, 2:50-61, and related Figures.

'177 Patent, Abstract, Figs. 1A-B, 2A-B, Col. 1:26-31; 1:35-38; 2:5058; claims 1, 8 Modern Dictionary of Electronics

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 32 of 42

Asserted Claims layer using a photoresist pattern to thereby expose a top surface of said first conductive layer;

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions layer of electrically conductive material."

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support 6th Ed. (1984), at p. 193 ("conductive material") Microchip Fabrication Second Edition (1990), at pp. 332-33, 504 ("conductivity," "conductor")

photoresist pattern: "A light sensitive organic material formed into a predetermined pattern and that can be removed in oxygen plasma."

photoresist pattern: The meaning of this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "a layer of photoresist material that selectively exposes an underlying layer."

'177 Patent: col. 1:44-57, and related Figures. U.S. Pat. No. 4,857,141 (filed Apr. 13, 1988) at 4:1-38. Comprehensive Dictionary of Electrical Engineering 487 (Phillip A. Laplante ed., 1999). Donard de Cogan, Design and Technology of Integrated Circuits 62-63 (1990). Badih El-Kareh, Fundamentals of Semiconductor Processing Technologies 201 (1995). John R. Hollahan, Techniques and Applications of Plasma Chemistry 351-52 (1974).

'177 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:31-33; claims 1, 8 McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific And Technical Terms Fourth Edition (1989), at p. 1420 ("photoresist") Microchip Fabrication Second Edition (1990), at p. 511 ("photoresist") Modern Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1984), at p. 743 ("photoresist")

'177 Patent: col. 1:24-44, 2:50-3:14, expose a top surface of said first expose a top surface of said first conductive layer: "The uppermost conductive layer: The meaning of 3:15-22. surface of the unoxidized this phrase requires no construction. 32

'177 Patent, Abstract, Figs. 1A-B, 2A-B, Col. 1:31-35; 1:41-62; 2:10-

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 33 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions conductive layer is uncovered by the etching step."

Samsung Proposed Constructions To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "exposing a top surface of a layer of electrically conductive material [by etching]."

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support 17; 2:19-34; 2:58-61; claims 1, 8 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance

removing said photoresist pattern positioned on said insulation layer by plasma etching simultaneously forming a protective oxide layer on the exposed top surface of said first conductive layer; and

removing said photoresist pattern positioned on said insulation layer by plasma etching simultaneously forming a protective oxide layer: "getting rid of all the photoresist on the insulation layer by plasma etching and forming a protective oxide layer at the same time as removing the photoresist."

removing said photoresist pattern: The meaning of this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "removing photoresist."

'177 Patent: col. 2:10-16, 1:41-2:2, 2:19-22, 2:24-35, 2:58-3:13, 3:2338, and related Figures. U.S. Pat. No. 4,857,141 (filed Apr. 13, 1988) at col. 4:34-5:15. John R. Hollahan, Techniques and Applications of Plasma Chemistry 354-55 (1974). Donard de Cogan, Design and Technology of Integrated Circuits 74-75 (1990). U.S. Pat. No. 5,210,042 (filed Jan. 29, 1991) at col. 3:17-24. JP3-082127 (pub. Apr. 8, 1991). JP2-133939 (pub. May 23, 1990). JP61-134015 (pub. June 21, 1986). JP61-140161 (pub. June 27, 1986).

'177 Patent, abstract, Col. 1:44-57; 2:10-16; 2:19-34; 2:61-68; 3:1-13; 3:23-28; claims 1, 3, 6-10 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific And Technical Terms Fourth Edition (1989), at p. 1420 ("photoresist") Microchip Fabrication Second Edition (1990), at p. 511 ("photoresist") Modern Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1984), at p. 743 ("photoresist")

This claim is invalid for failure to

plasma etching: The meaning of 33

'177 Patent: col. 1:26-35, 1:44-2:2,

'177 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:31-33;

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 34 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions comply with the requirements of 35 U.S.C. § 112. To the extent the Court construes this term, ON Semiconductor contends that the phrase can be understood with the following construction: plasma etching: "An etching process for forming a contact hole using a plasma of ionized gases in which the ions are accelerated toward the material desired to be removed."

Samsung Proposed Constructions this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "a process of removing one or more materials using plasma."

ON Semiconductor's Support 2:3-9. Response to Office Action dated 3/30/93 (amendment to claims). Comprehensive Dictionary of Electrical Engineering 491 (Phillip A. Laplante ed. 1999). Donard de Cogan, Design and Technology of Integrated Circuits 87-88 (1990). Rossnagel et al., Handbook of Plasma Processing Technology 1617 (1990). John R. Hollahan, Techniques and Applications of Plasma Chemistry 355-62 (1974). Williams et al., Semiconductor Industrial Hygiene Handbook 28 (1995). JP61-140161 (pub. June 27, 1986) at pp. 4-5 of translation. Burba et al., Selective Dry Etching of Tungsten for VLSI Metallization, J. of the Electrochemical Soc'y, Oct. 1986, at 2113-18 (1986).

Samsung's Support 2:3-7; 2:23-34; 2:61-68; 3:1-2; 3:23-28; claims 1, 3, 6-10 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance '177 Patent Prosecution History, Response to Office Action dated 3/30/93 Microchip Fabrication Second Edition (1990), at pp. 162-66 ("lithography"), 227-232, 507 ("etch") Modern Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1984), at pp. 352 ("etching"), 754 ("plasma," "plasma etching")

simultaneously form[ing] a 34

'177 Patent, Abstract, Fig. 2A, Col.

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 35 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions protective oxide layer: "During the process of removing photoresist through plasma ashing or etching, creating an oxide layer sufficient to protect the underlying first conductive layer."

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support 2:23-34; 2:61-3:7; 3:23-32; claims 1, 8 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reason For Allowance Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary (1988), at pp. 946 ("protect") Webster's Third New International Dictionary (1986), at p. 1823 ("protective")

simultaneously forming / simultaneously form: "forming at the same time" / "form at the same time"

simultaneously forming / simultaneously form: "forming as part of the plasma ashing/etching also used to remove photoresist."

See "simultaneously forming a protective oxide layer."

'177 Patent, Abstract, Col. 2:23-34; 2:61-3:7; 3:23-32; claims 1, 8 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance see also support for "simultaneously form[ing] a protective oxide layer"

protective oxide layer: "An oxide layer of a predetermined thickness(e.g., a thickness of 30 to 80 Å for an aluminum conductor) that is used to prevent damage to an underlying layer by preventing reaction between the wiring, an organic solvent and water in subsequent processing steps."

protective oxide layer: "An oxide layer sufficient to prevent damage to an underlying layer."

Badih El-Kareh, Fundamentals of Semiconductor Processing Technologies 39 (1995). John R. Hollahan, Techniques and Applications of Plasma Chemistry 354-55 (1974). Donard de Cogan, Design and

'177 Patent, Abstract, Figs. 2A-B, Col. 2:19-23; 2:45-46; 2:61-68 3:18; 3:23-38; claims 1, 8 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance Webster's Third New International Dictionary (1986), at p. 1823

35

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 36 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support Technology of Integrated Circuits 74-75 (1990). U.S. Pat. No. 5,210,042 (filed Jan. 29, 1991) at col. 3:17-24.

Samsung's Support ("protective") McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific And Technical Terms Fourth Edition (1989), at p. 1350 ("oxide") see also support for "simultaneously form[ing] a protective oxide layer"

exposed top surface: "the uppermost surface of the unoxidized conductive layer is uncovered by the etching step."

exposed top surface: The meaning of this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "the exposed top surface of a layer of electrically conductive material."

'177 Patent, Abstract, Figs. 1A-B, 2A-B, Col. 1:31-35; 1:41-62; 2:1017; 2:19-34; 2:58-61; 3:23-28; claims 1, 8 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance see also support for "expose a top surface of said first conductive layer"

removing said oxide layer before forming a second conductive layer on said exposed top surface of said first conductive layer.

removing said oxide layer before forming a second conductive layer on said exposed top surface of said first conductive layer: "getting rid of the entire protective oxide layer before forming a second conductive layer such that the top surface of the first conductive layer is completely

removing said oxide layer: The meaning of this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "removing the protective oxide layer."

'177 Patent: col. 2:19-22, 3:14-22, 3:23-38, and related Figures. U.S. Pat. No. 4,857,141 (filed Apr. 13, 1988) at col. 5:1-15. JP3-082127 (pub. Apr. 8, 1991). JP2-133939 (pub. May 23, 1990).

'177 Patent, Col. 2:19-34; 3:8-13, claims 1, 5, 8, 15 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific And Technical Terms Fourth Edition (1989), at p. 1350 ("oxide")

36

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 37 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions exposed"

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support

JP2-10856 (pub. Jan. 16, 1990). JP61-140161 (pub. June 27, 1986). 2. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said first conductive layer is aluminum. N/A N/A N/A N/A

3. The method as claimed in claim 2, wherein during said plasma ashing, said semiconductor substrate is heated to a temperature of 250°C.350°C. in a reaction room having an oxygen atmosphere at a pressure of 4-5 Torr.

This claim is invalid for failure to comply with the requirements of 35 U.S.C. § 112. To the extent the Court construes this term, ON Semiconductor contends that the phrase can be understood with the following construction: plasma ashing: "A process for removing an organic material, such as a photoresist in a plasma of oxygen."

plasma ashing: The meaning of this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "a plasma etch designed to remove photoresist."

'177 Patent: col. 1:41-2:2, 2:24-35, 2:58-3:13, 3:23-38, and related Figures. U.S. Pat. No. 4,857,141 (filed Apr. 13, 1988) at col. 4:1-33. Response to Office Action dated 3/30/93 (amendment to claims).

'177 Patent, Abstract, Col. 1:49-57; 2:23-34; 2:61-68; 3:1-2; 3:23-28; claims 1, 3, 6-10 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance '177 Patent Prosecution History, Response to Office Action dated 3/30/93

Donard de Cogan, Design and Technology of Integrated Circuits 75 U.S. Patent No. 5,228,052 (1990). Modern Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1984), at p. 754 ("plasma") John R. Hollahan, Techniques and Applications of Plasma Chemistry 352-55 (1974). Williams et al., Semiconductor Industrial Hygiene Handbook 28 (1995). 37

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 38 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support U.S. Pat. No. 5,210,042 (filed Jan. 29, 1991) at col. 3:17-24.

Samsung's Support

4. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said oxide layer is aluminum oxide layer and has a thickness of 30Å-80 Å.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

5. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said oxide layer is removed by argon sputtering etching.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

6. The method as claimed in claim 1, wherein said plasma etching is performed in 500 SCCM of oxygen gas and at a pressure of 4-5 Torr.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

7. The method as claimed in claim 6, wherein during said plasma ashing a temperature of said semiconductor substrate is 250°-350° C.

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

38

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 39 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions

Samsung Proposed Constructions

ON Semiconductor's Support

Samsung's Support

8. A method for forming an electrical connection on a semiconductor substrate between a first conductive layer and a second conductive layer through an intervening insulation layer formed over said first conductive layer, said method comprising the steps of:

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

forming a photoresist pattern on said insulation layer;

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

after forming said photoresist pattern, forming a contact hole by selectively etching out exposed regions of said insulation layer to expose a top surface of said first conductive layer;

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

removing remaining

removing remaining photoresist

removing remaining photoresist: 39

'177 Patent: col. 2:10-16, 1:41-2:2,

'177 Patent, abstract, Col. 1:44-57;

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 40 of 42

Asserted Claims photoresist positioned on said insulation layer by plasma ashing to simultaneously form a protective oxide layer on said exposed top surface of said first conductive layer; and

ON Semi Proposed Constructions positioned on said insulation layer by plasma ashing to simultaneously form a protective oxide layer on said exposed top surface of said first conductive layer: "getting rid of all the remaining photoresist by plasma ashing and forming a protective oxide layer at the same time as removing the photoresist."

Samsung Proposed Constructions The meaning of this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "removing photoresist."

ON Semiconductor's Support 2:19-22, 2:24-35, 2:58-3:13, 3:2338, and related Figures. U.S. Pat. No. 4,857,141 (filed Apr. 13, 1988) at col. 4:34-5:15. JP3-082127 (pub. Apr. 8, 1991). JP2-133939 (pub. May 23, 1990). JP61-134015 (pub. June 21, 1986). JP61-140161 (pub. June 27, 1986).

Samsung's Support 2:10-16; 2:19-34; 2:61-68; 3:1-13; 3:23-28; claims 1, 3, 6-10 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance McGraw-Hill Dictionary of Scientific And Technical Terms Fourth Edition (1989), at p. 1420 ("photoresist") Microchip Fabrication Second Edition (1990), at p. 511 ("photoresist") Modern Dictionary of Electronics 6th Ed. (1984), at p. 743 ("photoresist")

simultaneously form: "forming at the same time"

See "simultaneously simultaneously form a protective oxide layer: "During the process of form"/"simultaneously forming" removing photoresist through plasma ashing or etching, creating an oxide layer sufficient to protect the underlying first conductive layer." removing said oxide layer: The meaning of this phrase requires no construction. To the extent a construction is necessary, the phrase should be construed as "removing the protective oxide 40 '177 Patent: col. 2:19-22, 3:14-22, 3:23-38, and related Figures. U.S. Pat. No. 4,857,141 (filed Apr. 13, 1988) at col. 5:1-15.

See support for "simultaneously form" and "protective oxide layer"

removing said oxide layer before forming said second conductive layer on said exposed top surface of said first conductive layer.

removing said oxide layer before forming said second conductive layer on said exposed top surface of said first conductive layer: "getting rid of the entire protective oxide layer before forming a

'177 Patent, Col. 2:19-34; 3:8-13, claims 1, 5, 8, 15 '177 Patent Prosecution History, Reasons For Allowance McGraw-Hill Dictionary of

Case 1:07-cv-00449-JJF

Document 90-2

Filed 03/31/2008

Page 41 of 42

Asserted Claims

ON Semi Proposed Constructions second conductive layer such that the top surface of the first conductive layer is completely exposed."

Samsung Proposed Constructions layer."

ON Semiconductor's Support JP3-082127 (pub. Apr. 8, 1991). JP2-133939 (pub. May 23, 1990). JP2-10856 (pub. Jan. 16, 1990). JP61-140161 (pub. June 27, 1986).

Samsung's Support Scientific And Technical Terms Fourth Edition (1989), at p. 1350 ("oxide")

9. The method a