Free Sur-Reply Brief - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

: Case 1:07-cv-00632-GIVIS Document 8 Fnled 01/23/2008 Page 1 014 1,
1 1 1
~.¢r,~
V · *1 1*1*-
V JV? *5 § @g
4 — ie 1 -1 1 r
1 V1? `''' ·1’-*51;:. ’f,
- Vr · f '* , 1;.; 1
V ‘ . V -- 1 1 V 3 _ ,* zz ·
VVVVV. eV » nv;-V“ FV? -
4 1 , 1111 1
"·..-1 V . _
V VV' j 5 * .= V e {jg ‘? * - `-1 5 = ‘¤ Q VV *1-2 *V
_ x L L<;A‘§·`LhJ 5jM]__£gjt¥:w 1, 1.11 1L1_% ,7 541. X.] ~.. 1 3 5, gi
1 ‘ _ $1,1 -· “ 1V V ;
V -V·' V 1 E1. r- `- 1=· -‘ »
1.·~1-1!1·w1x.¤ 2,1-1 -5 1=e·» · 1
1 -i’/1] - 1 [V .1 1 VH. 1 `
_ >--¢¥* E; f11.11.%¢1-'V`<-°"’i*"1~-*V·‘F—· ·
- i 11 ‘ B- {Ts ,1 1 1 E 1— 1 v `
H Vi - ··1_?· TS E 5 ¥' . - §* 11* 2. 1 . -1 J , . {V n Q4 a. 1 -1 -- -n 1 ,- up 1¢r`=
‘ * 1 1 1;*,,,; , ;;xV_1¤.*-#·, ,;-1,1 ,__, 1. »}1s.1.=*11-%.J1 1¤i1;11--=¤¤¤&.11¤ ·
V · , F . :1 ; : ,,1 1 .— .»'?- ·V" -; ·=‘“z - 1-1.··.r -.“ >—» V-, 1. Q
1 ,1 11 -. 11 ` V; 1 ' 4 Q 1 1`” 1;: BS s ‘1*a?3# 5 i V"' $*1 3,-· 1-F11: ;" I- ‘ E1 _
_ -4 é qw LJ;. 1 ,<: ·¤ iu,. -i ; ay gg Q g é_};V§ g 1 { 1_.: ·..,.·,1J"») Q5-*.11 -·1 ··
‘ 3 i .< ; ' V <1:· .
@1 _ ‘ _Vi F`} r} _= _. -75 'iw V , .g. _1$ 3
1 $11.,-1,1m·.».1».1-1.111 K- L1 ‘·· - - 1-1; ‘ >-1 1 -· · La ~# - ---= 1 *1-- *--**1*- *1 1
-1 11 11 s
1 E 4* ,_ 1 . ,1 1. é, 1** 5 ,1 -1 1» _· ,,4
V? ]_ Qé I if,_I,{__l°'· ‘--,,g4g§1,1¤,, . .1".Q$L‘§ £1=£J$, 11-1-* ¥* &,¥;2zZ1‘¥¤*— _ .i'·,x:k1J ··L,§{1%»X& 6*- .». -11} %.*v"=
1 1- VV z- Ji 1 A ‘ 11 1. { JE ,1. *1 V
=,,*Z G. é' 1. 1 :j¥ ,j -: - ‘_ E Li? ? is 111 ‘_;5·=_,g_:· $1;*; wg; $$..4
$,"%£._¤1;1 1,},5.; 1111:1%.15 ,1 {.11;, E. i._1,11.V_g3_.,,_,11;11.1,V11 gg #11511 1·
-€·’ 5 1 VV? as ,1, .¤¤, —V 1x
@1-2;, 2¢;4.¢5-1-11g:..¢’.,L»:..2, 1.11-¤*~1¢%<~=»‘¢1--1 -1E-· ~#-· * 1
#1 ‘··* * @13 *‘ 1 = 1 1 ‘ · 1. 1 - 14 1 1 -1 1. 1 1 1
·‘ V1. 1 i-lL_£_11L,&__V1;_1 _V;,,,1;,_V§ -1132-i ‘ ‘ ' % e - " wa ;;1&·;.e1,4-3,;,
V V VV — r- 5% ·· ' V 1: - 1 e -
` ~, V! ·-·-$1 1 » 5 1 = . F L1 .- ‘; I 5 é 1.; r; U V VV · 5 rg? YV? : · 1+ 1*2 1f $**5;
‘,-Q.! 4 7 ‘—’-‘· 4
1 F 44 :5 -4 e » 1
;·—1 V 1>~" °’111 1 .1 _ .= 2 = !’ 1; 51 ·_ * 1·· fi' f ’1·;`
1 ig} ;_;”,g14_ ,;1;gg£_T¢,g 4 1;;/*1_,4,_V_,¤1,_;.¤g*,Vg__;,2 - 1},1% J, 1_},L4J1='.1»¥,L1·'1£·~1-¢¤1i11{»J 1%,;,% _
1 VIR- V ‘ Ei 1 1,;. 5 ’ V € 2
nf ~ _1< ‘ ,_ V, J ,4 1; _, j- '- A ,11,, , 1, _1 51 , 1z
QQ bg ,13 , £.j,,i__;_r‘1 gid;} 1»g,;_&,L4L¥?§1¥1€!E,$!,.Q;.1;1§ Q René 4.1‘%e1é·¢..e;¥r, ai; =1£==`¥. -
V V · 1 ig P? rf; V?“‘¤ V 1 4`4'r 7 {VV .""€ ¤ :1 *1 * _ V -‘ V 1-4 1 ¤,;_ JV { EV? sg;
§Qii,i1§F¢=».;·;i;~1i.é’s·C,;i!;;$? ¢.,~i;= 11 11 WLQ; -35--* "1;<~M11-* -·-eas-!?¢%;1»§ ` · V VV 1 ,VVV gl? 1 V 1 ; S 1 1—&- 1·-
. V EV V ’- , , V k 1, .1: -_ = 1 E`; 1 Y Yi A 1 F2 ,
Ai xl 5- :3-21...%-L
· 1V i 1V= V 11-= , 1 1 V1 G V z VV; _ .¤;‘ _ ` · 1V Vg, ‘ QE VV? i§“’*{>~W-i.Q€»11*L€V?? *V-V’·¤*V‘·V€~ -s`iE1, -N-‘=·” ·»
e` - A 1 » ·- 1 . V
‘ ; ~1~ 1 1 1'1 . - * 1- . . * 1‘‘’ a1 . S 1c 11 =1 E?1 1- -1 -F J
- j%£,.L§§¤ a%;£,&!\ V"*~g% V VV _V· V_ ¥·-A- ·---— 1 J
· 1 V -3 V a .1 1 ·r · “a A V ~ s ri .
‘ V 11 if F , -?_' i` $1 { {1 14; ‘ 1 . _ g 2 Mm; 1 · Q
1 -»·‘ 21 1 11 1 =; 11* 1#— 1 Veil}? { J2 1* 1; 1: € -· -·
1 1 !,1;;gj_’j_51*{_E!‘> .1 >.;;s1i.€1¥.,1gV 21. ‘i [ in-_1s1A,E-g- *;,,1 .¤·e1¥_,· *¤£»*n·' 1*1,5 ° ·
V ¤ V V V VV V V { 1 F- 1 V= : 1; SV 2 z"? V : VV V ’V? 1 V
11.. 1 1 ja ; i 4
f_IV:g,`;i=;§ {E jj -PS;1--;,,1% V4 5_1¤,1»`¤1, 1 EN.1-L J L ~ --1- — - - F1`,
1,
1 ; 14 1 e-: I . ;° · ,` 113;, ,1 1* 1V 1 V 1* {V1 1~ 1.
‘ ` 1-
4 1 1 1111 E
V {JV ; VV V " I A j- sl 1 A V; i 1 - 11 LL jj r
= ¢ . . , 1. 1 · " 1 1: Ti, " Ti: · P;1. .1V. Y 11*`§z>=’*.-" · " -··· - 1
11»11+e;¤111.11 @@.111-.1 1x1i;=11·1-11¤1¢*-Mum ·-~- - -- ""*‘ ·· · ·~ “ "
‘ 1, V _
I `
l

I · GI\/IS Document 8 Filed 01/23/200
` Z fc`;
3 1 · , . — zi T ·.,
. ¥wI-LL @**4 1 ~ F `¤ * z » ,» x
’ `% { *""T`a`y°1""j* ki lm W ‘-L `“¤ af `- {G ’=€ ? ? -
• , W 4 `tfrfi {*3 5,7-,,.,-2$='3'§.§Q · ;§‘;. 31 ; 4 a
L';. L y _. ZL .. _ ’ " GW F gs J;} ,-,i _.-f
` " " *~·’¤2~— aa 1 h at ‘ E ., 3 4, 7 . , ` 7 7 4 `- ”
W" . ,.
‘ i ` ‘*” ”>*' "·?· = :-! ?s. - , 4 = ·&
, .--+2 :.. ; V · » z» Q A; F L, ~»,;A.a¤ ya,-,= - , ; J ;- ,
1{ A, _ _A, . ., , . ¤,.,¤ ,.W€..f W ·~ P E
7.4 i' -@·L ;£;é_*;{..é $3* 1% i :42 0 ¥ J Z 5 r if
'L NI ( -¤= < ~ -._,~; Egg - ,G §__ $_F _ :;*2 gig); `§-(.,773} VA'; r E: ` ~ -
5%-°!=¥; ,; -% ‘ ’ * `*`¥ "" Lf; ii if
¤· :..` 1- · -‘ v···v , 44 : `: " ”‘ a4 "'5
_ i *· "~"~ ~`%2L,zu;;_~; ary-, , ,¢ , :»c* V
' · ` ' ' -¥ =- °¥i¤£-’€:‘{·* a-2 j“~»= - —¢ » . 4 I
,~ ,,, A _ { _ J; _ ,..,_ · _; = ’ ·=z ra . A ·.= = y ; H
—·*» = —..e < w . 5:- 5 sf — 5 3 "°’ ’* ·€—¥*¢!
L - f aww -p :.-:4 ;-, 4 , . ` ,5 » , J ~—**·é¢
5; g Fg `·"* *··~ ;= » 2 1 E,.-éJ2_=.4 E H .-1 R 4 f V J ( .3 4
Q ig 2- _ " " ` ' ""*·’—~·M·-al-&.Jb_§" {g. iw; ,4 :2;* T
¤ 5: { a IL. . ;· ._ - s " ' ' 7* g $4.HiM é 3 5 , . .
· ~> ·*‘4 'ljn ~.‘, » . ._, *‘ ·?é#»~—€·<;,i.;
z` ‘"»“‘= ‘¤ 4,· >< = ·· its .v....a.,=·.- —~ ¤ P .· mn * » . · ’·
'L;· _ ;:` qJ‘r*¤Z`<£»¢4; wg g 1 1*; f — 4_ 9; — 1 : ’¤§ ~
’ J'- ,_ -2 ‘,. _ k _ " "’;2‘4 T " Mw "·i j_ %= E ‘;,7~’ 6, , 3 _ _;F
;g,§g.,,`L Li , ; if, { E 3 "; "‘” ` Lbyk ¤
- 4. . _` - ·»· - »= —<;.· —, , · : ~ . ·· ;·; ¤_;q4_ ~ V J q > ., ~·' ‘
”* T QE ‘· ij; · @2 €;xL.ei` ~ ; [
1 ,· —¤ _ ‘· we ~. -.. » 9.;.-1 { g jg >-· L, Q z
· nga}; , [Ln A , ` ;"_ g J L _I 1 E___ I ` _ - 1- ` -_ V ~ ` _;;* ;z· J-5
` W V $‘»·€..(r-%*‘_$;gp_i;;'I; 2 EEZ ya rg`; 7 31 £ { 5 { ra =_ `Q J ,.· .
·· V 3 i · ` F ar gi 1; : - .· , , _ gr ‘ : ·
m' gu `. ·‘ ' ¤-M * *2-* .4 "‘ F `; ·· ;~ “ -<· if
‘ #$1*2,* _ · _ _: ‘ 4 J. . ’ i VE · V V A xr J` ‘
L' ‘u£¤ z Mg ={.¢¤‘°E£.: ip aq 4 s: { Z ‘~ `·*‘L‘#r#¤iT
n J" » ~ M W5 *·-‘ F 2:; ‘ ·¤ .— I J; ; , si . :4
“ Li} i§?2 A.5, z= } . ` “ *“**’**d `44- iéki --4.
* - 1 ""` Liv--3} Q-? {Jie { $ . ,1 3 . .- 3 _ " ,, ir! p
. _ { _j V 4 4 ,-, J jx.; _ _ a, g Ji 4 #1 _ L _
, ` ’ V ‘ ` “"‘¤- "”" **1 1·£ég¥—2*i*` rx éé ` `
= 5 J Q V ,. Q ‘, k 4 2; ; " *·» xi
‘ ‘*·‘ ‘·=’ @11;;:; ‘ W ab; ~s Q , , , " ` 5
:.»‘» E 1,, - ` . ; ` *-·*“` “· X ~ * é`: ,1 V; ; g~ r
_ ` · J Ic·~ fi 'L *·¢‘-{ :4 .j· ' -· ' ‘ E., ‘ = :¥` ·$-J5 RJ _=< 5 < g
~r’ ` - ‘Y—»—@.¢¥1£i,¤ { sg x , é .~ — · =M;.¤
. ._ ig : * 4 i ’ _
‘ Q _ 3 "‘ gx * E ·1-iz 2;;. V, y . 5 _;.j E ,-> .7 .
ns L .5; ig ` , . 3 ‘ " " ’ . { --:¤_.»._;&__» E .; .= E ; _
_ * -» -4--
. V ‘ '· · . ”'¤=¢ ._;ér{ _`;§;§;J FL gy 1 { Y r Ip J ` V »¤·
; 5 4. "’ 2-‘ `5~._ 7 ` ”'° "" '. ’ ,9(,:i· ,-; .1: e ;.
E- ` {_ M-) E.-.5 ' <% ' I ' `--V »",;·'}•E:‘-~-ébgf v-
" “’*""¥"*$’£=-’b»?°—4·$¤3L;i§q¥ VL L; ,~1 A J 5 Q 4 4 4
l - L ·~. V- ·r~— ir - ~;q;(,? fyi 5'_.,§Ug A E E1 i_ E by qgz li. ` =;;_ iii; M - : `
3* , i‘ 7 “ "’ — ’°*“ < M- $ * _ _~# A ; A ¤<=
A , ‘>:é ~ . 2`- 4: 5 4 ,¢ , i ` { *2 Fx (S Qi ·?· s ~¤1 JT
·"* *54 - Q gg} si·+L{¤ T l S 5 ye e \ , ‘ " 5 ‘ 5%-* ’
. -_ ' " " `— ’*~-~— ’ Y EH ‘i· · ri F" 5 1-:., 4 #» ~ *` ,- ;»
“ .·=..g *¤ e ; F 7 Q Q' ”‘$‘}" L·“"‘Q*;* ix JA `§%A,;i '_Q J &
: " _ if }@;§ ; : I L ` ' ¤ V * a·»r**%¤ - _ , in -
* M g Q é ik ea .,.,g , I 2 — ». F _ .
` 51 ’ ; _ r_'£p_g%I: gy ELM; ..»Qé {3 :1 qi] LE jg eh I. é,. 3
`» -' ; e` — , g 5 ' · · ·` A, V; J .r ` _» ,; y _ ( `
r ¤¢* {\- 4 ·;;b-`§§,,»_;@_{_Jj y, ·
Li 7 HT "~ ‘ " 7
` ' 5 · `· ;:‘j_ *·=.•j... `_ :5% 5%. V __ ,
, . if 4 {V ; w§_;_;, $;__5E§;f§ j JL f.:
` V ‘ 2 "' ‘ *··` s — 1-- H ; q —· S 4 .
· yy . » .-, ? @$,5,..; gg A é ; r ·¤:—¤ A e~»
` ` { 5 -’ ,< ri - . 2 “' " M *‘ * E- {ir M *? "· ` ~ ¤ .
I i, E· 2;% @5; ‘» ` li ·"‘ %» i-I!)-la?
, ' · ·! . ¥ q=·— - *5.,- , g° =_: ., _ :, " 3*, an 4 Us
. : I kdgzc »;; ¤* qw 11E;:*¥q{J_ A E;-3 ii {
* . A
I ` 7 “'i* *‘*·€“ "··‘·· ’- _ g_§__jgJA_f£&L§J_§ ég { _ _ ··~r 4 ·~ J
; *7 4 ·‘%}—{,:_U; { ¢k T », ig ·- - ya
gig; ig ##5: _; ,,
1*%- ;= . .f.-"i ¤i # 5 F ; ·=* &=~ MF? _. 4*
I E ·y`?' Lf ` Z)? ,-F {" £.;E:•'!4 13,;:* V 3 gi a ,¤` { ` { 9 5 EE 7 -5 ip ry"
. H. ‘ ‘‘*‘* sm · E 2w M 51 . ‘** ’ is
, jj ff ` =2=‘= ww} ..4;: aug;} ez! ,é¥ :5* · ‘=
; » »-1 $4;,1 ; VFUM ui _ 4 yy .» 7,; U4
· #-* * ~»M¤g.m;g gx E5 :2 w J 7 · .-»;; V 4 4 ,··
[ ; Q { v E'} gain ‘:.=»_ .4* 9 kx} F _ 4 I V`; Q Ex} A; lwsiu
{ 2 · _ _ ? _ ’· 5- %>=·2i¤:’} . *3 g ·§
~ 4 ¤ y·»~. ¢., ,, ` 4 _ , $ ` 4 ·-Q-~— Q r -;,_»,;£.— l · _,
` =-rf z%¤»::·;* :{E.‘§;;_ 1. F! -=,{ ;= ia ·~_§_ ;~:· 9;- _ ,‘ ,:7 :1 2 I , r_ " " ;
, 7 ' ` s?`~*?¢` ¥ V?-=*§,€j.j.’; = {Ei}-= if { ‘· :1 Fri Ar ‘ “ I 4 as , -..,
V »` hip?. ’¥ A{_:_‘¤g; di l i
;·=* Haag; i A .4.. E , 1 ¤ 25 a ~# “ ‘ · ‘· " ~··- —·~¤:»€
‘ ‘ » é; ,» M _` E V } J 4
~ A _ ` _ “ M 4 .éij_. ,7-j_ * l Q H 5 M 4
’- I _ ,
= ! 7%*** "" ' **72 4 { r»..; .4.. wi; = +— :7 , ..,, 4 A. F ~ ` 5
‘ ’ .. é V " ei =;-=z L :=~ ; - . 7 4 4 é __ ,
`_ V T, _ f _ Q . ., . .... ._ Aiéw `__ {E .3; _ , .... _ I
· » x H ` 3; , *5 _ ; _ .=¤i _> 4=. . ” A.,
- » L¥A&A.,;? iii H * »*: w ( { - ` “ " "L
, V -:7 ~ z :2. —= _,, hg; A- 9 —- ;? .i- -'¥* · = `€ F i` ` `
* g 7 "{ ` `:~" - ?",a;.i.’g_ré;,é-,$)r§_ F? {_, _ A 5 ; ., = , ‘ ,f
‘: Z-a 2 rs . 4 4-} ‘ ` LV" ii, 16:. ?·_,~.,§ gi {Z! .'$g‘i·.§ 4 M .,_ .<;
·=c· l .; , ~_ ` ` ’ ; V g a S _ *i= " ' " W ‘ {Ji,
‘ ‘ ‘ Mi " 5;; x , ·_ E _ V .:'·- e\»`;=;$
_ , 7 “ ‘‘‘' ·· 4 - -¤ if-;,,=__a,J 5 if ; ry ,-K 4
' V “ LV; ·_ ` :_¤ ._: ~ 4 ,
4 ` *·‘ .,_-’: :21* . . `- .»* _ { c · ‘ ’ -.. r
7 { `· T V 7 I- L Q E` r F V I i M e ig ;{i·`Y' 4 . ·r’ —. 4
, · J J ai · ~ _ _ _ ji ’ ‘ - ?~···`¤ · .,(_&¤'__ ’ r J Q`}; _ _, r _ L; j
¥·¥*»¤f3»**·"é . m.>. U rp. - w 4 . = W
, - , 4 .¤· WM —· . ;— ._ 1 _~ _ _.; J, x » _ _ [ 4
' 4444 ;, '. " ` L " ` · xi an 5,,; ,; . g
GJ s ;_v.,;_»-. ·»; $3 -r ¥¢§g-4;, ;;5’__é_g;;
2 · { ’

/· Case 1:07-cv-00632-GIVIS Document 8 Filed 01/23/2008 Page 3 of 4
: %#L¤=r)
` ·S = r 'I I a = , ,,., , . 4 v ,
¤ ~ - r— K V · · 2 `_ *5 g tg; »-w V; ~. 5 z hy { · V _
j_ =—» . ’·’¤ =’*” }.=’ 5 ‘- ' i
' "" . Q_ = ai L : C _; r {C ·· V ; , w
~ · 4 ‘- { "·*¤ Tr ` =_ z _
_ :_` 8 [ gg.¤»»·L·é·~g
- V ff
‘ * V . { ~ e Ji , _ V ra J Aj `- J? ,
4 xi x i ,
-,»» i · . . ,» ·4 ,. a ~ ·- -1 `? {··%é’¥»‘F
~ -`°; z
A » -’ L — , , .», 7 . ·;i · ; » 2
*. (,f` hi;} .=r· V _ » V:. .-{ .. »= .`,.¤ 1* , —'~ 1*
‘ - \j,éka.»J# *~*P4.u.;
` ‘= . i-m`°’·=» ’
| .,-5 E fg X. M \
§..»#i'$*·¤ `
w
I 7
P l
l _

Case 1:07-cv-00632—G|\/IS Document 8 Fnled 01/23/2008 Page 4 of 4
4 !44=4..4;*i.}$V T _€;_
{4 ;·~. 44 .=·a`‘” " 3 Q 4. .4
J @#¥i,;;Qk.%.7L4.4¢=4* ...A* ti €’?€»¢ ; z2;»9=¤§~é *..- an-$4 *5* xw, 4% ng I4_,;L2i_L_ 5% 4 -
1 { _"‘i-{$4 J', 5 *:4*.- ;’—‘— .5 ··f" : ' :*3*;
M if 4
` aj r 3* E; 4 N3; V } A 5 `J .

{kg},. QM 4 - . -§ ? L;-§ `€£#`3q· {. 1 ri; { y 4"?4·¤..= 5 ·Z Y »
. H .,_. ~ $._%j¥:_ 1,,% ·£{__1`4§ L5., tr, €:,§>;,5r¤_-`;§·;{ $,-.2 Q- V -. rj. »£hF;El£§,i;;`;..__; if ;_;__ `
A aq j¥ _;-1 . 4 3; 4 ~1 ; J
` -r `“*· _ »
4 ‘s Y-; ln
I
E V ‘
1
` *%% 3 ; ·——r { AT Q}? ; *
! 4 ` ..
i = ·» . 4 - $4 - ,4. {_, [ a; 5 iss 2; gg;
g,,4§5;,$%_.!a§g1 ’, jgg;} .3;+% ,. { g._ af -¥
_ gi ¢ =‘~' " t
4 · , = ?· 4 .
_ 4 4z-’ 0
I -
` -
i
K `
4 .
k
I
1 R
A
{ l
r ` ,

Case 1:07-cv-00632-GMS

Document 8

Filed 01/23/2008

Page 1 of 4

Case 1:07-cv-00632-GMS

Document 8

Filed 01/23/2008

Page 2 of 4

Case 1:07-cv-00632-GMS

Document 8

Filed 01/23/2008

Page 3 of 4

Case 1:07-cv-00632-GMS

Document 8

Filed 01/23/2008

Page 4 of 4