Free Bench Trial - Begun - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA

CIVIL TRIAL MINUTES
CIV 02-2245-PHX-EHC Year Case No Initials DATE: 5/31/06

Title: AMMAR HOLLOUM, et al vs. INTEL CORPORATION, et al Plaintiffs Defendants ============================================================================== HON: EARL H. CARROLL CrtRep: Judge # 7014

Deputy Clerk:ROBERTA HIGHTOWER

CANDY POTTER

Ammar Halloum, pro se plaintiff Michael D. Moberly Plaintiff(s) counsel Defense counsel =============================================================================== PROCEEDINGS: X Open Court Chambers Other BENCH TRIAL - DAY 1 09:04 Court convenes. The Court notes for the record that the plaintiff isn't present. Michael Moberly, counsel for defendant is present. 09:04 Recess taken. 09:09 Court reconvenes with the parties. Mr. Halloum orally moves to waive a jury trial. A recess is taken for defense counsel to confer with respect to the motion. 09:23 Court reconvenes, defense counsel agrees to waive the jury trial. IT IS ORDERED granting the oral motion, the case will be tried to the bench. The Court takes a brief recess to discharge the jury panel. 09:40 Reconvene. Plaintiff objects to the use of a laptop computer by in-house counsel for Intel during the proceeding. The Court directs that counsel not use the laptop computer suggesting that counsel can purchase a transcript. Opening statements made by plaintiff. 10:18 Recess taken. 10:48 Reconvene. Opening statements made by Defendant. 11:19 Recess taken. 11:32 Reconvene. Defense continues with their opening statement. 11:42 The Court orders that exclusion of witnesses still pertains to the bench trial. 01:16 Reconvene. Plaintiff's case: Ammar Halloum sworn and examined. 02:34 Recess taken. 02:49 Reconvene. Ammar Halloum continues direct examination. Exhibits 1-7, 9-26 are admitted without objection. 04:06 Recess taken until Thursday, 6/1/06 at 9:00 AM.

Case 2:02-cv-02245-EHC

Document 160

Filed 05/31/2006

Page 1 of 1