Free Answering Brief in Opposition - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv—O0177-SLR Document 42 Filed O2/14/2006 Page 1 of 4
4444 4 4 44 4 4 4 4 . 4 44 44 4 44Zt{2.·@@· 44 4 4
“” ` 4; 4 4-4f4Z Y44;l44 44,4-.444, ` ` U
4 4 4 444 O‘·{·\`|`I LSU?) 4 Q4 F 4 4
E M 7 **"=-=·--¤ =¤¤44.....,,___ V 3
44 \_ 2= FEBl420U6! g
!·§c>~¤.c2f=4¤";;;`&e. Bu?. I,. . Q~c:>cw»&4¤~m, 4 4 4 444444 MJ
‘ 4 = ¤ · · · V LQ: LA`·fw%}_€E V ’ ‘
4 _ 4 4 4 BD sr
44 4 4 4 4 _ 44 4 Ong; Oqigékxvx IM ·.»~.»<*~\x~¤ -.€i.{"
4 C`.4\v\\ v\`xC,.·'.; qgviwé- - <‘>=r—; \` ‘$¤·r·¤‘\K‘%4‘>¤ 4li &.4<;:~\4g:;\ ·‘é{\4~r~·4\ 4
4 444f‘(*‘•w·14Q,4 3;. é¤v·\"‘\`4 ('€3.,,¢€; J~\?lrvé`:.. ·J‘v`=c>'¥.\C;w·~—, {*;;;,6*444 “T;4>¤4,;w§4~»·;‘a->·e<¤f2,.~44£< FBT,} »;§~,¢7`·]f`·¤'%Q-bfil 4
4 44,@Y°“ "*·"\`\2“E.\*—?‘§k GQ4 ;;4C3*‘#‘ §}‘¤`€b¤`¥°·*~`5$’»‘\T>\‘*?·»444 {.€···€}CE¥U4¤"1E· `·(i=??4;¤f=,5 \rx%~»’*“·e
4 4 4 4§?.\/;4_·,`4¤2.4¥‘·¤t;1€‘.E,I4, ii NO; 4 4’~.4?p `g*'%*"=@¤-*“·"i ¥@J *·E$\\€I.€..; JiLxA'§• ¥;¥\i€ 4 44; jQ~m;;_€; ;£"··-»¤:44 . ¢=>="¤*-{ **3 ·¢*= 0*44+* '¥ vv?T·aj 4 4*?§1<·¥*4\`\}:?·=-g "°`3 E-‘@¤"ew
\r‘\»¤`v»P.~ {:4 ~;~.`4Q4*§4 *'?1>’·*`-:E¢‘ Eu `S\`\x•:=...{{` =\<:.4\; 'qiln \?s€;4.·¤\.ug&·.,,4 Q; T 4 4
4 4 4 Lx-JQRJ xii; Cav!} '$¥"“\’?.. imp EYE '·"¤ ’Q*Lg44. Q '?>ST’%xr \V\ 4
4H `#\·*~.4<‘_ ¤~;mX·¤` Q; W2 Cc, {L ,5,; ,·—,.-, m nm 1/ —Th¤..J»·:Ea$w\ 4Q`§· XE? ·q°w~. y; sv 44-gg;444 L4,
*`* Xé ·- L ¢ ~\ · fn *· I MW ‘ I- [\ C \‘F. Ch *-R ·¤ *- ·#·"*‘U ` vg.? w
4_ 44_~-14 gg; -1;; <4444¤m·4,».4,_44§, :..44 ---4 4 ;;4 -;£5-4.li..rF· 4 {`An 44 4_4{_y~,=;,1;a:__4¤.¢;.44 a...· pw ge ,4 —· _» 4 4
4 _ 4 Ig @4 4r»·»g-`f.¤v-4 =g§¢•4,, {bu w“v—4—¢aG?.~4J[ ¤3U=4.¢cEc]_¤·4»»@\4y#x4?*¢_r_ \‘]"WC`lL.r‘{\/'\*·3 af 44
. ~~ a . 4 W 4
44 44, S Ck \¢’w12.¤M.¤·¤"·;/ \C>$. ~i :.§—*L#"“r ~4 `¤¤w\\ ¤~\‘~\**2..%(¢\:‘¢·3··`- ¤Z?;L=~ COW‘$4!@\¤f*»—¢¤·4K4 4QF?. U•E'..—4·..14·(LC!
4 4 44 4 (HDL.] f` 3:%* l|`+\ @2 44 {U5! ?g)¤’2¤L·*’ Q;&”`&\!f'i·~;§% QNX? 44 garuggkif 171;; Q? QQ ¤‘¢‘*€;`%”‘sQ=_\$=’§4<§j 4 @4*% ng 3 ___4
' 4 \ 4 ¤— 4 ¤_ g —-E4 "\ g4 a w} _ » . M E FA
4 4 4 4. UNJ? *€%g €11’i¥»§F\\€;4;§ 4 L?‘¤ Y"@\4¤ 4 )YW*·—» he €‘*~‘*"‘*Y:*®’+?4"? 44 `*Y\¤A· r WW 3 4 4}@°¢Sn§A. §h\‘J\°?>(
4 4 4 44 *:4 44 *.2 T‘·°=·—"‘eJ$:'§·Ur£3, » Q CEC \\a*3¤x4a"`¤`?/f 4 @*.31 *'1‘¥$»·i;·§%L Z Q¤v‘\é 2*-J *'¥\\¢E4\j GK; 4€i?4&J.*·L·r*1 44 FMT
4 4 4444 4 4 “'¤?¤Ls$ **;*3 QQFL ?¥“=&x €*i2(€;i' 4 &""?-E , `WX4 4@wx44»,}4 &ii4M·~Lr$x M Y-¤x1*‘\q·€~f`4`B 4QFQ 4444
` ` ` ` *3 B L I 4 i p·,:'¢·j . I A
44 44 44,L:"4|.`€.>—?·-4 @46 U". @*4 \§Q\A\ 4 v‘v"\Q$¥° Qc‘~VC>V`*?:`O\€., LW3 QZ24¥"af?'gY%;E T4 *9**1 4?K\f\\‘§4 @3 Y¤¤ZJr€2—€E€·&=.·€2\. 4
x ‘ ·»—’· ’‘‘" " 4 4;.___; » _ [ [*1- i 5;* - - _
44 44 4 4 4 4 · hg - 1*- grwz wm-4¤;¤é ~¤¤¥ 4<é~r`4_<;;4¤.e··<~·@-x—- *.4 4 f;1#i~¤“rfT¥ r¥L~€» 44 »4¤;_;·:~444 44 4 4
4 44 4 44 44f4J@G4v·w LM !’\·c,\/~. *5;; ;}·»»4C`!{§w·> 44 €' . 44 44 44 4 4 4 44 4
E. :*44 ""‘ ‘ ‘ 4 *- 4 .· lt-I ~
4 44 4444 4 4 Pi\\;=.af I ¥€*'€·»4\ 4‘§”xr·ne1 F M \i*4\)i‘»‘%iM4&i4(_i4 Z‘.;.¢i>r**+F%%]¤1x4m<§j 4 k>4¢;Q¤¤u454¤£ 44
4 4 Q- €.·*"~.£§r1i§ v\ *;.,42 V 1 @4** iLv'“·—4Q, . Q? ?iv444 ’ZY·~¥**“>Q %é4F*°—:& 44 {I3 4 44 4

Case 1:04-cv-00177-SLR Document 42 Filed O2/14/2006 Page 2 of 4
` 1 d ` lat V"-ar I; ¤;°-E {1*%% EQ E rt}?. 5 ,f\f`g L LA;
I Q b·Q.,`l VV; 1, Wx si Flé C `PPU E;•fW`\r§ii·‘°*`%, s NIF G @45
4244444 34 € ME} *+44 *··-4"¤·4¤¥ J`; 44 *32 ·4’= · 2
4 _ _ ”` 4 4
Q 4
4 I "" 4 F? .4 . F3 4 *2
j z 5 O ! iv is P4 S·.`4`\ “`€\v~..<2., cb unc? F ¤€2.€‘»4g4‘;J
4 ‘f‘v‘\ Q "%= 4 Q;} F5, & &;j;i4_é 5% 4 4- t,,,g·E& QL) EQ? gy; ,
I ; 4 4
4 4
4 4 V
I Z 2
v 44
4;* @0; 2}vf`·~J y y·::»4.»<444$,
4 4 4
A 2 {Q 4;.:;-rr » L4; _
4 I <`Iq:·({k.,4_,4,¤;44.444»- 4244;* 5 :]-512
se42*`—z22:44··e4s4*4a 2
{ 4
4'em 4 is 4442 44 ~24- E
4 2 *9 in *4:4 * _
: *
·»2. ». J 2 --42 E
2 4 4 -
’ 4
4 4
4 4 4 44 4 4 4
E ( 2 4 4 4
44 - 2 4
' 4

Case 1 :04-cv—OO177-SLR Document 42 Filed O2/14/2006 Page 3 of 4
c;ER."§ij; §·°I¢;.=e»"§"7Z3_ 3_@ze»; ~1.;4
I \’\·Q.€"£·i,M q,,·»m ‘~.R,. ..__*`“ x
Q .¥ \ 2 wz V; @"°:){‘“F “‘“‘%" ”°\‘“‘°:`· ‘·—··•-ilrkhx v`*m:»·£·'w·»
.. ~·— "’1"`,, Ek ~ ;
""”` Cd'·~*"·"@·€¥> *-5-T"‘*·‘£E¢>‘?> ·=F‘¢— ·~—»>¤<=— <»¢~;s‘w,.»a»& mr —%¤`r (JFQA
HQ gr<:§q\4;_ *2 » :. · ‘
U _ ` fm; <>‘¢me as? ~a—m_am,k
""}*‘E#é §3**‘··"$*¤—“—~ E3i&##¤·€&: -*3ewi U ·4\.D&g q = ·
@L.5.L;; M r_kL_ v_ qi *"‘ ‘·"‘ =¤~-·=¤·—¤<;® \1:$X»[email protected]»r}%
‘°’* · ‘‘*‘ age; ¤·¤.>A&~:»,~,~ .,;%-QA
Leek (?;.¢>4>4, E`! 5
W""`°‘*“"$&‘*¤—··~.?i`-·`€ *“*Qm , my W
W" {“* ;·-g`%.>»·»4 ,`5§€ !‘;?‘i§»é···- ?.>$“"Ei}`
b'°‘x°é‘ F°`*\·=¤·‘¤·=-w ¤2.?<><><—» Va %
‘°·""·i *`V\Y n;@¤.4F§§
Q e i} ; $ * 1% J _
d*-····J¤Q¢2d Imyfueg
¥v’~rz.*r“.c.i
*?»¤¤

wl`m§»··\5h·¤_EE` !‘i@g*;'#`§

Case 1 :04-cv-00177-SLR Document 42 Filed 02/14/2006 Page 4 of 4
x 0
` · i
. j ~
; _.·:‘% r5°:.E. s_Q*·· ·
= »·"<`¤?}’_. 0 L °;;F;§$`T¤ 0
¤ ?¥?é’ QE`; Ja, » i
0 0 5;% r E5`:
\ 4 EA, ’**‘ ; ·
` XV ` * l "">, - I J ..·x'|°2"‘& v: I
~ ` 1*99 "'v~»a»•v"‘°:g\\q`r"v
j H ‘··:£{_Q{n
I `\l
0 { ...-·::
A 4 5 N ‘H’»=» -
— 1 K A
? (ge ` 4
_ 5 -..;:
2 Ei ` 5] nu-.:
cz
` 1,.. [;1_ Q eg a.; ;·_-·-
` lg fw ·'“" _,@· gg;
4/,1, p 0, il ::
_ as 4: Mix
ay?} ,,..-3 % _:
. ’ ri =¤ 0 , I Q
X. 3; Mi m ,,..
.. __i_ my $""
0 lj, m` fp
’ gi '??‘ W
V? »s gg E?
. E `- · . T`? Q? S 0“ ·*“
' ` Qu; ri" , , { ,-4
4 0 A _; ·:·
‘ 4 M » =¤ §
LL Xj » **5 { ·¤.'
- _ .£. , .. .·=
0 0 0 4 0 C-? rx .§
##1* 3* ' —
LZ E; ?
_ .
0 » - l"*
G 2 gl"'
-` *-:7.
ii ‘ in
r
· · ez] ·—==· K}
2 me- an —
}" -@ ie —:.‘
‘ Q3 EA {Y dw-Q
’ d N `*€ Q
‘ EY in mw # ;
, · ll _ -7**
0 [L) .j§ --1* z~2"` §
· Mn §..rY'

Case 1:04-cv-00177-SLR

Document 42

Filed 02/14/2006

Page 1 of 4

Case 1:04-cv-00177-SLR

Document 42

Filed 02/14/2006

Page 2 of 4

Case 1:04-cv-00177-SLR

Document 42

Filed 02/14/2006

Page 3 of 4

Case 1:04-cv-00177-SLR

Document 42

Filed 02/14/2006

Page 4 of 4