Free Reply to Response to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

C ‘3§§i'="e‘2.c“2a2%‘f‘;`,4'i$·?ZF. .l§E£"`°"
&L.§§ }JéLZ¤°£?:;"qqO6 Iv THE uwxrzn $T4T'E$ GISTRICT C0uP.T
·- FOR THE DISTRICT ·,.,, · Z. 'ZDNH
'4 **—E¤ _ __L¤¤GE¤
} ‘ A -···*i“··" “‘“"““"""“"`””—'"°" “·— ' ’ ___c0p=y -
S.E2»·m1¤m.mL-‘:}M¢&QQ{_q;9_g»* ..»~-- ~..~ »-—-SEP- M5
[I _M___ m »,,¢@i __._ .f, _
HH-~-`--.\iL...*r..,......_______,_ Oc ,• CIV 0 -13 '·f'—f- ;_§>· ¤ Hm
_, ___% M_w____wW % g_;.,; »
V¤L&Qp;,j¤m£_,;¤w;;Q. E;:.+s; mq g_i¤_E1¤jL¤};€E”.3.m_n¤{i¤l»_J§¤[“.1.Q¤L¤e,- OL W »,»`. ..-*4
________ U m_C¤¤¤zr a.Q&_Q¤!1,&13;¤ .+W1»u
|
. »
· mM1P.4W¤m,¤1¤.;¤·¤.. .2rL;sh.;¤$.h;;+.~;».la.L .....n
P _hg,se,A gg. · r f
·_ r;cL.u\.2£..._".,,_..m...... -_.,........,.~,..».~ .-~.~.~#»--~·——-—- —————·—·-·
- Egj1¤_e.;+;fLuJk.$.xm:4$E¤ _~rc.zS__ a;f‘im,-j£_&,4&mx£¤,.,z¤;¤;. __.“%w , M

fl -
M 2:. F + N. .M..~,.m..-m.‘m.....`..*.~vH»».—~“....~».m.m...»».»-»-mm
_m__ __H ____§?1¢.,·m+_:£§?_ Eiga ..A4 .g;§m m%.wMmF s¤.¤ ¢-M~J».»1y ...¤m¤¤.¤3»Cm£LO»mA—»g,¤¤i.¤29~
mpga¤Q;.PE1&a&_,,mmaQa_b;5.mp1dm$A,JM;§i¤L¤11,1¤LgL¤j.;1;;g_@:
waga ¤w.,,;1q:m+.(1$é4,_1_g A.Pi§;£;4eL§£EQT$ Q;- ..AL (- .},.
,, m.p1¤I.m.i.w¤.¤__Y!|¤,§(vM,Q,0_,m@xQQJ .».. , l. e. . ¤.. a .._e• . . ' ' Q.-
» ·». ·- · • -·· .. .· q·· ·. *1.-·
.1 fsnxvma »[I>k+- ‘~£9].TL4,,K ,»c;cur£A._3ram+.ed . 1e¤.u.z2.. and .~.$`[.eJ...p{qjm£1-E£j.Hgmge · - ··
ii m,¤x¤I¤+ , f¤. _' £,4mLgL;;¤+g¤.¤.1LI2; >m;A]*@1L-Q¤e¤LzLLL,aQ:2L.#v - ». - .. ;
2=03·<>V·01344-EUQ;H_Q Ew£ Lx>wp_em1;42_&@g_0..9./26/2005 ..1=;age1 ¤f4 n

M0¤424Qhap.;z+expQ;,JmLugc+hhM,s;;aE4.44Lmk;m¤.”;~:,£ . · .. O
DL. MhM,4mM.M&4>_Q¤gM_mtmM u 444 M mm — ...
¤mMmMmmgMwQi@®mi;¤,mk ..4
:¤;;;&‘;;;$_¤¤¤.¢S.~!1Q+!zmL¤AmLa5J.@,.“;&P4¤é.L£LL_,,2L¤Q;,_m.;..t;£L;· . .
4.,mgmLM»¤-“m,h:¤_+_4c.L4.5.“¤na_1.»€.(n¤»d4q;l · · z ’ -.
_' _“mL»;uLY;».m&g£,L4glaSmm+_.iL-$¢;4¤¤h¢-£¤.A,A¤2¤;....,m¤s,.L¤»·»»;l;m.;¤.,m¤t:#»·QsmWn#w~”._.”m,.w“4.M.
W- .A.. A m.4;;w4&a+;¤n..._.4.,_.._;.xg.:,,»s.;££§.4~.n,»;§,~»$.+.“.az4, E»,Q.QS.,`,£0..9.S.-~n¤:I:...sI¤Q...w.&»2 : - -.e-
.__H,,.M..WM- ‘_,,;¤eq.»;;.mL_-.,4444.-4”..-_W__.__._.“.... ..L 4 4
4 `II».S ¤•. q , .4 . , - , , 4 . .
J xs g.£“·#¤.-Eg;LwAA41€uLg:»j42~.A“£i.`L;|i¢¤ - .- .;. » » ..
mL;14¤&_pLe¤»£l¤j,sL,ji.sLL¤.LLn...L»;.ErAee.lL;.._.q3g¤¤4.._4_.,,J»mm,LLs.+¤L 4· ` · °' { —
I . 4 . · .
4 . 4. Lg“___m__“mmh_%4r4wm_dkH,_".,____“__.___,__,__.___ 4
...._.- l "4 .-.1S M .. G.».;1].4~.Pm;¢5L¤.¤L¤1;¤_;;¤¢yl2&e:,2rL¤.+ -
.....-_________ _qme¤Ame¤4eL#p£.4L.AAplm.A@ reid-;} h¤¤;1su--.·L¤ *Pk¤ d¢:| A.w..-_ mA:&$.mxQ<..i&¤.,44C14.M.44¤,;-.;£;&¤g 4..-.s$.·¤~+@.; r» ·+n.._A¤mx£Au,p1 . ..
-..___4. un;-.g_“mtJ.£mn ¤L¢£¤¤4- »L.¤.m.—£.M.L¤.¢.¥¤m41*h¤£__.m.m*w
mPr¤aM4$£.M1»g.A.,s L+ 4.1»~.$4.»A.M¤fC£,..;¤q! , pJm§»'@ ?.%.Ku.1£A,.],S;.(£ ..
4 . . : · --wm__4___4
.m?1¤»;~l+;€£.*s 4mwA~,e.¤~+$”_1¤,mLLL; 4 J, .1 j¤44.M»m.w;1&....z·z~,&;.14>’4.¤;;“g.MLjim 4. . » , .. . --. .
{* .,;,4 e ms,;M.1_ .+4. ]my1~·é§4;,;~.T`s>2.j,;§ “(”" IHS? " g[ A A .A ` TQ Q] Q
hh I .4m.iL%·;.». +:ffm.L¤pm£;1~A£,~+&~L;A.¤¤.;z uQ.s4A;,;.qp.uz¤a;;€·.s,4”£»£j.}_>L»LL..¢c;p_+;,"
I m. qa .» -.•» . · r·
.»H...~4%HkWA.,-» 7- , $@5 ‘H*¤¤>:r ¤"c2\ES-..,.1;%.7,91c;;ucx‘Y·;.££j,.L...C.}£R.;rma.S--..£L¤]>{...‘}:f¤,1*¤ •.¢5`h d·}CQVQEy.JM¤J-Ct`sQ, ..... c{Ls‘J:.[¤,<2¢}
4 _._________ }L_!cdu~eD.P£¤ms..g¤A-.-kL¤Iu2O.p&$¤¤;;¤»¤¤.4}E1c.s+MDLsp¤.£d:L¤.2.M1éd¤i:L¤¤,,..c.s.J¤Ae;[I 4
¤¢k£¤“.;[email protected]'I;»§¤rs_Ly,41qL¤4Qp!¤I¤¤;1“};\¤éd__p1¤im ' ·. .. Q.! ·., . `
@»M4&m&£%J4 ;wj_M£,44,,i¤ .. N M. .. ,
www ww mm
J; 2:O_C§_lc;y;_Q_j_§44;§I;I_Q_)_jM—ImQ)§H___“[_Q_q_'g:_gm gq t 149 Filed O9/26/2005 Pa e 2 of 4

.............-... ;¤»1A,# »mmP1g;¤;¤.x..g4mL;1»mM£1;¤£L£L;$u._ _. »_ . .
V 5;e¤mE_y_S;;|{g,g `, 5;;,:; $213 . .‘ iff * . ‘ . ·._.
___~_m_,m_ I E Ap . ,
..........m -...m-..~ \L¤i.,,¤D ¤.m. - . ..
__... ,£é.£§.Q.€.£.L.£`.&S.,. £.€.($_;.ku.,-. , .- .. --... .. I ' ... A, - . ‘
......._.." ~ , m. ff;,.h·usM¤¤&.bzm.s.s.¤exS_i¤;t£¤Z4.Q.;e..-;$~L¤e.mww._
.......,._w ... A _ ______ _ , __3)¤\q£QPL;Qm$? MK-;,j_L4.q:g_;1,eH..4;§4.§»:\¢:!,£L__s est.¤L r l-
__HH_M- &~.. www ¥¤;£.m,Jm¤y;¤5_1 U - m q¥ \gq.5+ *ma‘ E? www has been fn*_»;¤g$g•,;~L g.` xl ' ~'
.,.2§;,g4;,',;m,; 4-5 .. .. · ... ,. ». . '
__.---_- ..,, ._m H .· 4 .. - ..
......w.H-- · h¤.·&a¤LeA.J> ...
._...,". #MM.#.%H . f..Ap.¤l¤~c l`.§..»¤¤.iQm_I¤;.1z¤A¤L.E¤.:js___b_E_L,_.L;_g__"M
....HM-.. W. x£qL¤zO*=$é¤,¤,sm§@;¤J4cL*1¢z:&€»p¤n1Z¤~e;m Sum mq g
,..k - .... .-..-_.~---- I$.e$0;rAJZ»LMwph§¤.+LE£QL,Aed; Fw; . » Ac r-.Qlm£. J;.,..s¤¢‘j¤.;.L‘J¤Q1.S..f1£¤.\£ZD.
....m ,.., V . * , MM ‘¤- .
._._,wA..`.w+... E _. . ·1·e..,.¤¤~¤2¢c..hze¢u.,. .5.;s;l ¢¢se`;!_.- qc._<§kZ;. ..Pl¤T¤¢hP£,,,,E{m.
....-.-.- V . i i;Md2 p@:1&¢2»1:C...m\Ia1¤£Qp{::p.nJ..Jm£,.-.E.{ n¢n. .
...... `..~. .r,, _,,,, h W V ` 3•,v•q,.Q,•’1¢", .. --~... -.._-.M,-,, W- ,`~. .-._.....»...-`. ..,, ....-- »...r H--MM Jr-- .—-..........._..* -._»...W .H..____.__- ,_h_, r, ,.__ ,H,,M
FQWMVI I- - V U " · .¤• - 1 ·. " _gLn+?_§__rQq_]§;l ____ · » , ` . ,. », A .- . n A_ l
V
wwwwwm +p....m;iL%f.jr;..z.;t.4ne.,;x.q$,,.JAJ;»;Cnq.. ..&._-...m£m..q..¤.»;¤\£.&g4_.¤,_¤¤¤J¤.;¤L¤.
m.”.-..- . ¤.T 4m2;¤,M+.J.4u;¤1\ m»»eJ:Q¢.m."¤L¤w-,&mHg£,¤pL£¤¤.L1 A .. . · A, . ,.
_._.. .;¤=».e;+. ,A L¤,.m¢X`Csve£f.¤;r¢$ U°\,kLk£OP‘§;\D,V\.5 w L;+q{:1¤.•»1¤ `.¤..¤A.".. ¤.1¤{¤Sy-.§I:fu `Wpwmp.an....,-. .~u4
W .... I r·LmA.¤mAs.,._.M .M..---.m .\.,m . -A,- m . W..”.__......__...._...r.1.~..,.....m...-_.....
._..~..~. -M?J¤.; n£u.se‘¢$..»L5iEn_¤ulL...Lt}>..,4c¥~4e.,A..A.a$Z .. . .. ‘ .. .. - °
MHWM? I 4 - sa¤¤.t\:€.....¤.¤5L..¤,me¤{t,s,..,¤ - · - -» - , ' ‘ . ... . ,.. ·, »
.-_..--W . Rlg§.·;d#;££L.sM;p‘z».:i:s...¤¤>.-.·.»:»se1- j¤¤.l·l¤`..1,j,...LL»¤4M_·¢¤-A.e.Qe.<4¤!=}. ·s»¤.cl.._
MHS) 2;‘Z€;EY E‘§EEEEFEA'E,w-.P9EHC“?'?T § ?? m j‘E°1E.’?E.§C?i’9E-i’§¤QEE2J.L.”

},& ` ` l·»J»»L,,;¤_{¤i¤L?J¤+i{%P , ,»,»iL1,,ngir,,,..»;!, ,,,, ¤;¤,m1,4L,,m¤1-;§,=i&»J.sL,,L¥`_q¤&LLLs_¤1!e.,,
,,,,..,.,,,.,,,,,,,,,, · cl Zi~,,»¢;,p;p,»¤lQg,;gj,¤,,,x!gJ».;Qp£g¤,:-j.,DmsA>.,d.L:,s4;:&L·z.<_.,·ez;aiég»1?.- .,,,,
_,__ ;’i.:.;n,eL;£F, 4,,%,;;,.,mmt -..k1Q.`.&QD.}.'[tt;.Qn€,-,,,a 'L-]¤.£-,J!’1»=·LS,i‘,{>i`Q;£A€',Q,;!4?‘d, ,, , , ,, , , _¤,mu,;¤g,,,¤),;$,,,,,¤,,n4.,;·,,.,,,E.}.,L:!,;,¤,,, ,.,,5A&,1¤1,mL,,,.£.,C¢¤AQ¤efL,¤»,}2,»,,,4,. .... 1,;,,5,, q\L.,..»,g
mt, _-_ JLAA , ,4 ?é&},,1§§2,£€‘Z`(gQLZL°§'.5_K-.-S|é\1<.,.C.2L‘1.Pl€l!IL•.-b€·5P,; J;e,,·1<&=L;,44z;·,».J¤glE,-1%,,,,
,, ,,,,,_,___ b;.,u;A,,,+p,,,,p@.,—&{;[Y,,,,,B¢, ._ qsge.;-k;_1:hg:1:,¢kL¤,;:g»¢,citYs,,, mc¤nA,,J».41,,,,Jm¤¤¢,, 4-Lan
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, _ ,gs,·¢,¤;‘i¤..»;»,ln i— L»,m;e,,,,2,nevlé,e4i,,Ly, v p\¤L»i:§,P£,,,y¤S,,\};du¢O;}f¤1u,
,),,,,,, ,,, ,,,, ,.,,, §`¤4.|"y,,,,•Lg7,, ,,,gfE,,,,P`QJ‘!'\.+: Q.&¤:|.n..S+ , LL .... d,2.;.2!d!S¢£Ii'.»;f...,-.-.- .,,77,....
;;,,r,,, , , , , , ,, , , ,,,, , , , ,, ,_T,__
4 ilgnzlzlgrgism §4:2x~:¤'<1r¤¤;•rz,,·},,,[,·?mi}S1..m2mc{m¢¢n+> ,p;,'|,g,&;-.b;»¤k.,,,+¤, ,,p,r;»aLQ¤>,¤4,,,,,
,,,,,,,,,,,, .... , ,.,, - k·L,,I?1q,i»+I,F€Y,q, ,,¤m.2m§,e;[,,,,;Qm,p\¤Lm+ ,,¤LgLg.;_,¤,,,, ¤,\¤1m, gs, ,,..
,_,,,_,,, ,, ,,,,,,,,, ,, ,, ,semL¤.g,,,,gg,¤d,,,,,qn,¤.¤s;@ap,jiAQ;. m¢>,+·é>zL,,&,c_L,e¤,v,z. ,,s,$·..¤,»,L:[_lmA· .,,,,,,,,,,,,
,,,,,,,,,, .mA,,,,,eum ,¢,Q,»,.F,1,,.;,jg,,_,»;1,,,,.,.,1,5 ____ L,¢,,,&!,@A,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,.,,,,,,,,,,,,,
,,__,,_,, ,,,,Elq,.,;+:f£, ,;;,,mQm,e. ,,4,;, ¤,5¤&.;i»},,,m,¤;Q,;,,;,,,4m;,,,,,m$, ls , ,L.u·,&,»m114¤%,;¤p`Le;
,,,,,,, ,,,, ,,,,,, ,:;{;Et’hL;,,cep[,Y,. P,{¤,£ n{·Y£C,,,L,g; ;;4L|,,,,a,·4pu3}-¤ ,pq1¤er,,,4-¢ .-w·~j.Lz--.¢|;¢:u;ee,-;¤{£Le;.-..a,n;¥-. ,.,
,,,,,,,,,,,, ,e·;ma,sel-S 1‘f··2.¤._c¤;,?;r;i;,,,,¤.¤;¤S,,e,c,, %g.,c},,¢;rk.,,4¤e,,,,,send ,,,,, in Km , ,¤..-.m;aLy! .... .--..--.---.-.. .. ----_
,,,,,,,, ,,‘f?z$fm+,£MM,,_$M,L,;,;¢,¤,€& ,~#-vis AST; {my JG ,S,e,L1£m,b£¤—, 4;,0 ma., ,,,, ,, ..... ----
, , ,, ,,,,,, , ,,,,
Slmewaun m. ciark-Pt¤»$··+1 C Se _
,,,,,,,,,,, Qgm4L,,4*aQ»,e,,,c,¤¢z4w,~:+~#€,»,,,,m,»,,,mat,4,,2/As1,¢,s;¢,-,;,,c1¤¤$,.<.¤,,.$. D.L:L+;r:¤{ cmv}..-,.,-
Q, , ,, J;,5q,m;l,::q,,,E>¤y O,tC<¤¤»¤nc>r ur,,5,.,,C·>»».,p+,Lq,¢sg ,,5,£a, 1,242,,,}+1cf w- wQ;L.L34¤¤ 5+, $.·PC-{
,,,, ,,,,, ,,, PLQ:-z,»·i>L,,,,»OE»;¤>,»1s;,,,,,3,Sc1¢D3.;,·1\,l2, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,.,,,,
,,, , , ,,,, , AQ, ,,L.,mAJ,.».— .'·L4e¤,,;¤M, mi 14,4 ,,9ia,5!,¤,$ ,4,¤,,;, J;l¤,¤\,},»3, ,,,kQ,|;¢,.;,&, ,»»¤,¤»,,,4,L£l;¤ Ls ,,,
,,,,, ,,,,, ,, EL-Q,,,,,},£¤?}&,7 ,,,S,w,·hLs·A,g·,L:: KJ ,$L&0,,,,,,Sm++;;$g]¤;,, ,Hrc1;Q,e¢,9,
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,T i?.’>`a,·s:1,,,, ,,,_,,,,,,,,_ , ,,,, ,,,_,_,,,,,,__,_,,,,,,,_,,,,,,,,, ,,,,, ,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

,,,,, ,, ,_,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,, , , ,, , , ,,,,,, ,, ,,,, ,,,,,_?,?, ,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,_
{
,,,,,,,,,, ,,Q $¢,2,¤0,3v<>v-01344&;E,H,Q¢HQE,, D¤¤¤m¤¤t14*9 ,,Fi'¢¤,,Q9/26/2,925,,,,,,,F’,&Q€,4,9% , ,,,,

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 149

Filed 09/26/2005

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 149

Filed 09/26/2005

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 149

Filed 09/26/2005

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 149

Filed 09/26/2005

Page 4 of 4