Free Lodged Proposed Document - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

1 SINGHHOH m. CIGY`k ADC#II337a~
ASPC ¢4c..50Y\ ·S¤¤1·l’clR•+ FED I LODGED
1 IOOID. Soulla \·J•lm¤+ Enacmven COPY
2 I
9.0. Box JWO6 APR 0 3 gggg
3 I
COURT
Tu CSCI}, AIWZOYIG CLE;l§TLé|g1?§gl2f§§-&°N
4 ;` ’ ’a·-_;a__;_:;;;‘Z;:‘:;‘_';.iT‘T1°:Ei`.Q5... _
5 _.
6 .. .. . S. . .. . I ,. - -
7 . IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
8 DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
9 Shannon Michael Clark, Case N0. CIV 03-1344-PHX-EHC (MS)
Plaintiff, NE\·dLY DISCOVERED
10 V Evzcvzuce 0PP0s:m&
11 I SUMMARY JUDGMENT
12 ValueOpti0ns, Inc.,
Defendant.
13
14 P\¤.;n·}-Tu; Su.I:nm:{·S Wewty dISC¢3v€Y`6¢I €.V¢`J9kC.€ ofappglxqj gqmpyqp),
15 I~u:lgv—¤en+.
16 P)M],.|.,`[.[Z'; mgm}? é;5q¤vere·I 2w`c£@•1c2 prqeludes summaq, iludjweyd
17 €Yl.I»€1"€<‘I I"* CI.€£€h¢I¤e1•1+'$` pQ_u¤f‘].aI: VIQMJQJ In 4{g__ high-|· More Qucrable
` +0 FI¤\`vn+i•I1;,
19 Ile m°*r;‘°P°~ C°‘*”*‘{ $~•P¤¤·¤f` G>ur+ *’lov:»+orLs Review Ihr ¢-luv. year
20 6*000, M ....—.._.._.*°*"‘°l°‘ "· S°~"*" ”°·C‘ "*3é\3$S,(Ex\¤.D., ·`s cverwhomluj
21 €V¤‘CI€Y\CQ ¢$ 22 23 de1e1·wP¤a+·bns)Aq+»H3 but +o |‘¥°l€. ‘
24 T"°` °°“`* "*‘°"‘:'*°"'$ "‘“'I€"·’ °·’°¤"ly <=l¤¢¤M¤·¤+5 ***4+ 25 ***9-; "°*"*°OF`I"°"*$ ****5 °~ P°‘;°)/>°‘·*$'*‘°"·* ef P*’¤¢·l-ice mc denyh-.3 H;
26 consumers ¤.Aeq¤.¢o.-I-Q •Mem+qI lw.q,I1»h qsscsswenfs.
28 ¢h`gn+$ ••:w¤l\|€ Case 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE Docuénent 223 Filed O4/O3/2006 Page10f4
1)

an lm·=.elee¤e+eee£¢n¢+Eenql ¤sse$s»··:en·}·-(éxln.h___,P$,.‘i).,.. .. . _ e
Tlw. Vl’l¤yl··l·0r reP¢:>n\~e£ +hq·l- ¤l:e lllnqd cerre·»»+ Cc>mFrel·»ens·`ve As$essmen+s,ee»ly IG cl; <‘kLese were
ellelsoend 4e ¤.ée?e¤.+el)» eelelress +Le reewlreé qssesse1»·¢e»·lr?er]»zearlly .
e lldeserlbeé 'Hvr. Persowfs »:¤rre··~+ s+¤e~l¤.s ln 4. very l.$·»H~eel way. el·lr3’¢¤r»Eml
wluporwqllen ..,..ms generelly mc.-}- :nql»»cle&.(ExB.l,PS,R0j e
e {mi. Mewfwr rePerl—ed -l·k¤+.e·l: +L.¤. IEO Indlyiéuel Serulce Plan.: .
e §4,rev·é·.Jel·»'¤»zql..cess,essmen+(JeFf»eJ
.-2 w+ el: 3 lil-`e erees ¤.d.e?¤ql—ely .¤|¤eu»··»en+eJU.(Exl¤.|,P3.6U) e ee
Tlw. A¤~cl·`·I· Team, comprised yl? ··}·wen+.7-·l-we ¤¤ecl·`·|—0r5 use Yellmugeleee
·`¤d‘Zv£d¤els Prem -4+e OPP€ee el: ¤l·L¤. Mer¥_·+¤r§ S .·.é¢l.1e.['el»ee.B £rev·¤. eee.
_ A'[7HS}DBH$,BP5MI_§ Ll e£¤A§.».'Aeels fren v¤.l.teeP+2m,eMeenef+.e; A
_ Inélvhleelg E,—0_.~¤ AH»emq·l!.ve _BeLee_;0ml_3ewr`ee<, QM Def.l—·; umel
`l`··»ellw`é mls prem llrll-eme+i_uQ Bel1¤.v}arql $erulc·e$)_!lel_el+ Case Mqwegeuemfe
.. ;_ecLcl¤eer¤1¤le-l-eel Re ee we e..‘».ex,‘e.a1e.ql cqse eeéf+.r liar we "feeh-,
M Q. F.'¤el.‘¤gs " . (Exl-». w, vg. 6 4 20). l . . .
1, Tlw. A¤ecl.1-l- Team repcrl-&·l-Incxl Ynczcleqn-ca¢°:es Ce l
Comprehensive Aslsessveeml-s. (ext,. |,PS. 361), e { e
_ We £lucl·l+ Team r`e.fer·l-¢<:l £requ»en+ h·-lmlecguculre evuluaivfoen/le ee
g.l¤\e·l·erv~¤·l¤¤Ll<·bn mc vveeés por. "speeiql .c1.ssls-l-cmceh.(E> Tb- Iluclfl- Team repe•‘+eé ·H»»e+ Case Managers m-»e\ _C|T»»€¤;¤»l
;e‘l'ea·w¤s seem +o _l¤.¤k experteence .4-e engage c[uqleee4;l,1l¢;,S_m;1S€..§ e
e gipesfscms Cs»·l»s+e»ee qhusee/menfel illness) ln semfleces. (E2 ee The !1».¢lI·l~ Teen e re)oer+ecl *%.4+ e,ee .e.$+en W/;1lu@Op+¤`cv15eerelTue5eeS e ee
. . wwwa sewlces lFece>»·we¢enc§ed,..by #4-le. _<;l·'eir.¤J..¢e¤·»·¤.(€»l..¢__,_Q;. -.
e ge3¢·., 1]- M). __ A e l l _ M ee ee ee
i An everqll eenqlysals 0; °H¤.e. ROGO A¤¢¢lH—..de+q,cemB?»eJ w·'+l»el
·l—eqm eikélngs cena »'ml-;»¤~»·e¤.·l—z'p¤ gcz9·¥~¤.r¢-cl el>¤·d— _ Qese 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE D0cumenE£§3 Filed O4/O3/2006 Pagek2 QM- _

}
li * i

};{ [nd ; ¢1Y¢I»¢c;!s..c£u.;e».J.2dh-.nes¤ (·|—aJ { » a I?;¤4; H3 ¤¤¢.q+ c 1i¤f ¢¤.| `
- .... .I.,Asse.ssv¤en+ #`nQemmq+¢b n ·`s ¤2.¤.2LQly k..I.¤q¤leg;4¤l+g=. . (E2 _ m___ ___g$Va$ue.OP+i¤¤5 ¢¤¤ se va¤»¤¤,Sers/•;l$m`;q.|_ ·l-zqms ¤1Cc| M.»+ e.ve v». re<;uzs+, ·¤r
, , H , _ _ ___ SETVQCES , for \|\J1Aél-LQWS. b€Q%\é.§Q,_ H H ..r!§.Q..Y`@LL.$ ... ........... .-...
.. ;,v¤u+&¤r$zq+£¤n‘ pr6T•c€,SSiQS Tn p|¤4¢, ssh _\/¤.f».Le Op·H.m.<,..(Exl·».....l.,.E3...-17,.:r El
TL;. comp¤,m.3¤ns ¤P 4-he. lFIq8.,.*.‘¥°I‘£.,_¤,¤é &Q QQ .A¤»~diks c,.\e¤r ly
.. i;,S\¤¤wt ·Yl~. .V¤\¤. e O?+Z¤ n; f P¤H¢;¤`e.s.,.c¤,¤s+¤v»»s mA p¢¤.c.4»T¤ ¢asn n , J- C¤.IV}€_.»j_.. ......
M mf,-1¤.. pmviée ¤.é;? ¤.Lq¤Pe.. w»em+a}...LmI.% cz ss¢ssw¢n+s. ¤mLd..SMI .2I;3iW..Tr}y...
. . .Q!¢+cvmYn¤+€¤n 5 Are. .‘.¢m%:.S{eand·`··»3 .V dQ€P`y ev·1Led.;lg;L.q.u.<§. wel.!-sa-}-4-Lec!.
. . .1(m‘ ,s,P3.‘s 3*2.+15). . .. .
. .. N D:my Ba\cm , ,S ¤.FLe.rZ¤ p Cpu;-L ·.OP·P; Le php. °l$·a,. M¤.n.[.J—ac., -resP¤»de é
§;`¤1¤.€»·,+1CC’s mq¤€.s+_C0.—_ :¤£0mq+‘.m 44+.% bq¢;k.4.» r?=¢€..1~tm+
_ Tdc-2v·»z0>·1s·|·•~¤.—}—·s.$ .¤Ph¤.·!<· \}0.L¢»20f;.+}¤n.< had P¤U¢I.e.<....¤.r..1¤r>m•;~J-::.25..arF ¢]zn)y } 3
; g;0v»s¤y·qer·5 ¤_A2q..m,+<;a .w:ev¤4¤f lm-aq!¢L_.qss.e·:sme»+s ¤¤J .S MI eJ{?§5$.ln§,
. {Q¤£eLe¤~m:T4q+:r¤n5 Ie·{·sl-er qnd Wevrew. (E`x.|¤..!)·. . .. .
AuT¤·1EwT‘1: e.¤,·r1’0r\l
. J¤.s·|- ¤.s QH ..¤rH¤.=zr.. éocumen +.$ s»e.b»·M—·l—¤¢$ qs evCdem:e Ly f>la\n+I.C[`. .
n § _ Z» +Lis case, he has ¤u¤|’Len+:ca+ed d,¤¢.w~;en-I-; 40 .I.}»is abZI.'·!-Y qné -¥o Us ¥•xy.»~»an u¤ ..T§·zvIée»¤¢e. ?Iq}¤+?¤;. believes kg, has __ ¤.deq;,Lq+.\I H
E.d·:>c.uv··¤e»1+$, :nduA{¤j. .5=!~l»Ls- n¢¤.u zvtdenma. _
I·C •Hw. c{c¢u.mer··+s are c\e+arM£nec} ·l·c• Ec ¤’nac{equ.¤d—e[7. .. .
7 , LDur+ .’ V‘VI0[">/ SLOU.lA> LQ
. ;i3mn+eA an Gb. ..b¤.s€s .+h¤+ p\¤j¤·I·I¤-` is unable 4-0 ¤.¤£eq».».q4-ely .
.;U-I-f3¤u|—e his msv. Pm sa in ·H\¢+ you does ¤¤+ »4¤¢!er.s+q¤ ·+c> ¤·.mH»e·vP·»`C¤.·l—e é¢;>¢»w·»en+s, and H.}; case Skoulé pmeewaé W *4-ru}!
i.¤¤<}[or counsel shouh} Ba qppofn-|—u& ¢v pl4$¤·H¥-R
$$9 2:03-cv—O1344—EHC—HCE Documentggg Filed O4/O3/2006 Page30f4

I;
In ¤¤5¢X.`+¤bv>.,. .5•..m·¤v¤o.r-¥ _{¤ég»·-zen-} shawlé. ._»¤,¤ ·f< Bc jrqnivecg when A
. %5.e¤T¤.\·a··¤¢a prq¤\¤.v2r—·aJ.
. . . Qi_Q»»+Len+¢`•;¢1+·`¤w ;5¢>cuv~1 e¤+_s. ¤¤¤v·}J_ heh _____ sq,c,lq e·~»Zé e »·¤c·2 ....¤L¤m *¥-AL
. §;»mq¤.*¥{··.en+:m+eé. d¢>e»4mem.+s L¤:¤3.-..q“¤»"H»en.J—¤Zq+2<[ wodé pred u.J·a
I.`S'-£Y"l\•"Y!C¢.f1l J»¤:\_Qmen+., and possibly e.n·}>`IA·Hg pi¤u`r¤ +¤`FP +0 .Su=m.v•1¤ry......
_ ;_§u.é3men+. _ __
. .. L»xJ\’\2¢"€.fg["£, (l€C€•’}餢V1"+'$ |r‘*'Lb'}·r2DP') Qi" 5\·!.Y*1YVl¢\-Y)!
. A . ,_ s\¤»J$ be demizgi as .a v··n¤.*H—€F ¤ F—. ;¢LSa.2.. .... . .
r @$ ,m+c“ 11, $.*b.M‘.+;~a4 ¢»».:.$ 3}S“Q., .,12 MWL., same-.· - A
S\•.¤ ••¤•n M· ¢l¤.rK- Pl¤,•n·I·€ " ‘·H·¤ S;
_ _ O*`\`S;_Y\Ql #£'-VUJO C¤f•:·¢.S. 'V•1Q.;l.€é .u»5·.D.!.S+fL.C+..CO¢r+
O‘Q,0nr1 ¤I" com-_~Hw u$Q,t S{-Q.}A3'O > *|O` __Ld . \5Jq$k•»434-ew SWL?
; SPC—\:_ Pkaenhc ;4rTz0nq $$063 -5LHS
Oni Md..¢‘£é., DEV";} . ,
wav :0. swwsaaie RA.,s1¤.ae¤,s¤¤++sAq|¤ 42 ssa.s =¢
` ;
`

;; ```` ` " ` `
Q M Cggse Filed O4/O3/.200-6 H _ _ _

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 223

Filed 04/03/2006

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 223

Filed 04/03/2006

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 223

Filed 04/03/2006

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 223

Filed 04/03/2006

Page 4 of 4