Free Objection to Report and Recommendations - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

U I Shannon lll. Clark &1>(,#II33'7Sl _
FILED ____LODGED
A$l°C*Tqc.S_0h-Sanlq Rf+¤I 1REQE|\]ED __•;;0I==v
1 IGOIR S¤¤+l» wiIm¤+ RA. APR 26 gggg
2 P'O• Box CLERK LJ $5 $lSTFllC·T COURT
3 _ DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
'lucsvm A···z¤v—·=~ W-i,mm;ii.i,;i;-.;£.°EP““
4 95'73*l·‘·l'il0b
5
7 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
8 ’ N `_ DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
9 Shannon Miéhacl Clark, Case-: N0. CIV 03-1344-PHX-EHC (MS)
I piiiiiififf, PLAINTIFVS OBJECTTONS T6
10 V. MAGISTRATEIS REPORT AND
11
12 ValucOpti0ns, Inc., REWHMENDATIONS
Defendant.
13
I4 Pl·G.l`|4'l"lE‘I;`,.Sl\0I.YlrP‘\OY] Wll`Cl‘|O\€l CIQFK, r€S €C“l‘Iull Su|.hYVlf`+.S l'|ls Ob·QC+l·OVl.S +0
P Y J
15 M¤.SZs~I-m·l—·z Si`+ver's Rei:>e;·r+ CMI R¤<;¤mm¤vI&¤+:Bns(DkL&RS). PI¤{.··I+LI-TZ;
I6 ¤l;_iec.+l0ns are suFP¤»r+e¢I kr A 17 as well us Federal rul¤5 qncl 4i¤f·l¤.¢¢1l¤l€. Cmsclaw-
18
19 l'l0.€il$‘l*·1"al"Q S¤·‘l‘v€\" •lr1C€>HQc+ly ¢.0vIclu¢lQ<.l "l’l·¤.¤‘l‘ f>l¤.·l»v‘l·:l:C3 V|•1¤·l·;vw 4p $1-{-Ike
20 M°"`°"$’ V€*`l¤°~`l'l•*"¥ *l’lw. Wr¢D+l0v1 +0 S·l-rllce mlcd lay Delieneluwf VQlkQOPl“I0H5}’•
21 (1]**-¢?IR$,Pg·•I,‘IT5l8 Z- P_gi.R,1Ti). l\l0+ only -5 1%;: »'nc¤rr•2c;·I—., I+ Zs qlsa
22 l\ffele~J0.n*l"· Fll'l‘l4eu.3l. plu'··•1·}Tl:·p cl:] v¤In·u'•; Wm. COF»·m+ and releuqrvf-
23 U·\$¢‘?»l¤c*~?·, I+ elves **0+ *Ml7"f`0f` “\iQU'l:)Cl'l'\AW7r: Pl¤T•1+•·£p I`H£CP.C'lL :•"ICOI`P0|"Cl'l·Q 24 MIS own ar‘5q•·n9n+$.`7‘l¤.0. C0rwz¤.+ ol: lu`5 m¤+lcn Ps Irrel¢au¢:n‘.l—. .T.*l·
25 is vw-? em erm.- +o seek +o apply Mw. cxqx;-P same S·l-nnclarcls
26 +0 VQ.luL€C'p·l·I0|#LS', €XP€?I`+ q$·l:¤·cl¤.u;+,., wl·1:CL Wim. Mqjls-I-v~¤.·!—e
27 In·l:¤.4·I- QPPIV 4-p Plq:.·i·F.`£I;/5 exPe·r+ ql:-l::q,l¤.Lu:+ upon ¢l0l2em:I¤n‘}·°;
28 r’Gqu€S+-, cme] <:l¤;er¤clq•n'?‘ SQQKS +0 cmce, q_3q,.'»·, apply -I-ip pIq_(,·yI·.·[.`P;
Case 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE Docuglgnt 230 Filed O4/26/2006 Page10f4

vi -¢ `
' · .
" I;·• " b' · ..•_ I ’ ·’
M q .\ 1 { _
1- . e ° ’ g o · nn:. ’•a .4.e 1 •·- ez · 7
\/J g' e . -.; -.n-‘•· r |`l'5 ’ *-*1 " 4- -· ·1 .•
\ Y1 1
I .e¤¤ ¤ {·'-il 1• - 114:.; -_.•_,•4;4': ,. UO
-I ~
· ; N ` I
14 iz ·.n.e;"‘ • ‘ ·! ' . ' Q .•¢' •· ·‘ ·
. ` · " ,4 * V ,. `· '·' V ·J* M6? - ,- , ;..* - f ‘ 4- ” ` < -_ - ' · wr" " *.7 ` ` V Yi- J V": -*·{E·`$· " *.3.
_.,,·;_A =¢ '. '—.¤r · = · ' 7 4 -“ * " L •· { - ,
---_ _, “.--..“- .... - .... --- - » · ..p]¤.m-i:; .. -..S;Q@!J...i¢2.-..S:};-1:- \· W nr -· -- - — ·
I * R _ IA • ¤ • I
1.· n . ' ·• `J· `n.: 5 \ 01+ I er- .*:•· » -’ •

n l V
HOL I .¢_ p I LL ‘I._ i q;_J·
p»· · zz — · ·
.» .._ ¤+- P. JDO e ‘ •¤ “ er ll · eu?} · u 4.;--
'\ x I I. •
. A. ..- .- »,
D
‘ **·¤‘ r.r<·' * `C$*L I ~ l ”g,w;._ ,;Y_,. {_,,;w -..` -14-,, =;\.-rv v ...¤·
V . . » .¤ ’ .• v .k.E er.-Wr ,Y,,
1 ·. | I ·
....-_ _t 1 nn * I · * n 1-. " ‘ -1 ,
‘ I
F ' .
*- 2 F 4 ’ • D ' '4 • ; ' P 4- ' ’A
_ . _ { p ~ »
‘ f * »·
oi,. °J-» · r. •~•· -» ·· ‘ $· GJ` 3· ` · E '••.7
H ~ · M · ~
I ` "
¤ ·• •··;• `i-{ f` ’ [AQ. U.) |°`€ \ ‘.;9 .·• Q,4 A ' GT`
E · L
‘ ? n' Q -1 -• L:- .' ‘-! PQ U- '• Ha • 1- 4 I
\
-.; I .. A 44 _-- --5- Q I =- I4 ll ·.....= - 4
ai , ' V I " iU U '.` I II' O IIC •I I '

é ¥· ‘

IE' ' * P
-•! '• D '.| ’ la. lp _.• ‘{_4 g_; • ;· • { . "
' · ¤ U'4 •.¤ at ·c · * 1* . ".• ’\ .’
_I PII · ··— I ~
- 1, · "¤ ig » A S I‘ .•_ *!e41'
—I — · ~
( r 1* xi! n! . .—' `si { Ll-! r , - a I '•. A '.! ·¤ ·‘ L
XI ·. · - I
* 1
• .,_•‘•· dg 'r_· Moi
V 2 · . - 1- ~ TIG ‘- Y - ‘is-§;»:*w·—":z<·*:*—·:.·‘-.~:.`*,;
__._...L.-- °h· ' ' ' I • - 4 ' » • 1 »
" ."• 0] FE &•’ •'• ; isasni ol .4 - gi id

_ .. .-...14 4 In-·;_II,__r,4 , ;;h '4»;u;..L_';-·¤ **1** 11 *·'1 '
HI PII. +.—I> Ice M I. .
»••• {+I 'I"O , —• L•• · W'! _• F S {L. _ •·,4-’4, · `I"
EI · I · — pc ~
•—_ he 4~• .6 -l•· • ' UJ I1 ’ ‘ ° ' dx-’ ° I"
XI — ~
\ • •’ 4 2 •· • •.• ·' L A ·’ " 4..- .·
CI — ·· · — ~
r f x
in G. "A l' ,• '; • —A;’ .0, 40 ·\3JA¤r4»
—I · ~ I · · — —
•. ' _. ¤ ta i. ‘ ·,, 4. ' · ’; · ‘.,,•¤;• "¢
_I I — ··~· — — I
QI
I wr i`____;_ I _?_;,,Q,-,,{5,j%;?,g· Y "ig" * rr" ` ' °
I ·‘ ». ·•» IRI"! . ;;__,_.5 ¤ »-- ’ . *14 . ¤·• su»·• ·
·I
l~ . - _ .
+1 ' WL - - 1 l · - · · •. 1.;- . - U
_I · ~ I Y · — ~ -
‘*a·¤4’ C g,- ·· ·’ .1 • 2 an ‘S •· ;•
` I +r 2 • ·•.¤•f.. 4.ur cg .•:»f . • · ·' ·•·'a· ' · an
PI — I I · — . —
I ‘ ·
—I — — · —
`* *’ *.1 Q- ·'.• ' " .' 1* ·- 1 ..¢44¢ ,•¢~'
*p‘• QI1 .
QI ~
I
...I ..

( . n { I-
V1
! :·’ ‘*' . , A • n‘• *1.. V •• »· ;‘• K ¢,.·‘ •
4/* % ~ f z
g .2¤¤’ 4......: .,f»L’
§ S|n.¤·•·m¤n rs . (;i.¤.r—|< — P\qin+.’
O l l ·) 'r DA. D5 lll °¢ 0 I · , ; A | 5
I-A •l: '5 r .9 ’U A f`+ I'. I I · W ` .4-•¤•4 .
Elsui, _r___,.[ r ~, . - ,.':¤L-` — ;_;m@ < , _, j .4,: ~: .5* Ca . r —< ' ,. `E " §‘..:· - .
§ S PC` ,]?hQ€..m.; § 3;B.lL__ _“[;_%“m
Q Tl G III ? +0. Le ¢.l gi lA• En' Qu'.] I -,42. `ir . 1
` l O L U• ° .3 I." · r, D I _ IQ , fg] J A »,
I _ _ M _ i _r__ ,,_,F,,.;;__ 4 ` www ..My»`,,#;Mm&i—¢-=;»¢>—~‘¥

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 230

Filed 04/26/2006

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 230

Filed 04/26/2006

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 230

Filed 04/26/2006

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE

Document 230

Filed 04/26/2006

Page 4 of 4