Free Response to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

& + - .

! " # $& % ' ( ) *% * " "% " , $ ! / 0 12# 5 5 5 . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 ' '7 6 ! 4 & " "4 3 ( 43 6 ' 78 6 7 '; 6 & & 6 <= 7

&( #

2

*"%

( % & " "4 ( 43%

) 3 5 (0 ( 9 +( : % ( % 54 : 3

& 7 75 8 5 76 5 > 670? ; 5 7 '< @ 7 7 5 8 8 0 6 7 76 '0 76% < 0 6 ; % 7 7 8 76 & 6 0 6? 5

& " "4 A : + * + 2 * 3 ( : 3" : + ( 43% ! B * B % 54 : 3 8" ( * *B :# :3#" " 33 5 2 #A + # ; : 3 5" 33 3#" & " "4 ( 43 2 C 1+ ) A 2 C 4 + "" "B: 2 # ! " * C ): :1" " + !+"B + % :: B :> B :> ( ; : ! %" + ( 332 @ + 3 " % ) " " '(" # 7 5 2 #A %

A 3C : ! 5" 33 4 3#"

" 4 & "( * ## ! 5" 33 3#"

C 3 54 : 3 C ( ; : ! 3* 3 A

% 5 4 : 3@ * 3 ( D 3 : + & " "4 2 * ( 43 332 4 # + 3* E2 2" 7 + A 5 4 : 3@ * 3 ( 39 B 2 " + " : + "1 3 " B : :4(: + 3* E2 " A 4 + 3 A" 3 + ( 3+ " 5 4 : 3@ (" + 2 # 4#

% & " "4 2 * 3 ( ( 43@ 1

C ): " 4 # " "

332 3 + : ) ( 2 C + " :

: B 5 4 : 3@ * 3 ( 4 3 : :"3 " 2 *

" A + ) *

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 126

Filed 12/14/2005

Page 1 of 2

+ 2 C 5

" " " B :3 3 : +" 3

: B "

1" +3

: B & " "4 : " % ( 43

C 3 :3#" ( 4 + ; : C " 33

332 3 1" * C E:2 + + *" 7 7? %&

+ : ! 45 2 #A %

3F * * " B3 " # $ ** " B3 " # $ ' ( ) *% * " & + "% " , $ ! 4 & " "4 3 ( 43 + A 2 "! + ! 4 5 2 #A % % (2 " ( 2( ! 3#" : + 4 B "B: 2 # * + '( 9 3 74" * B + ' F '8 ! # 4 @ 42 3" 3 4( B : " " 3#" ( 4 " 4 (2 " 8 ( B + 4 ( 1"B 2 2 " " ( ' F '8 B3 " 3G5 ( 6 H " : ( 3 3F * * " B3 " # $

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 126

Filed 12/14/2005

Page 2 of 2