Free Trial Brief - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

& + .

! " # $& % ' ( ) *% * " "% " , $ ! / 0 12# 5 5 5 6 ' '7 6 . . . . . . . . . . . . ! 4 & " "4 3 ( 43 6 ' 78 6 7 '; & 0 & & 6 <= 8 > 6 0 6 8 8

&( #

2

*"%

( % & " "4 ( 43%

) 3 5 (0 ( 9 +% : ( ( % 54 : 3

+3 # " 3 #" 2

"3 * 4 ? 3 9 % :" @ 5 4 : ) !

# 5 3A ! C3 * (3 " %

:2 3+@ 1 (0 ( 2% *" ( A 1 : + + 4' 3 :" # 9 + - 9 +. : ( : ( : ) " 8 : *". * :% 3 + 9 +% 1+ : ( % 2* "B 3+ " - 3

@ + ( 4 " #A ! ; : >3 4 +3 ( ! 4 @ : * 9: " @ ( 2 ) ! ) ( B1" 3 " + : ) +2 3 "( *" - ) " + 2 3+ 2 * : 2 : 3 + + :@ #" ! : . 3 *" 1 3 +3 "

( 3 0*3 : "

) (:3 *+ 1 : * 3 2 : ""B+3 3 #" ) " 4

+ A 2 (

D + * 3 1" * + *" " + , (3" A : + 4 !: + " 3

3 A "B 3 * 9 + 8 : * 9: " @ 3 A % 2 2 ) ! + ) +2 % 4 2 B" 4 + "( " 4 4 3 *" : ) " : : 2* B % 3"

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 137

Filed 03/06/2006

Page 1 of 7

"* 2 3 8 : * 91 3 2 1 : *3 3 2 54 : "4 (" ! B ( 3* : ( * : ! +

)

: %

: + A ! 2 ( ): 2 2 ( 3+ 13% + + + 3" " ( ! 4 )( 4 3 @ 2* 3

) ( B3E ( " + 3(1 ( " * ! A

1+ "1 3 3 * 94 # @ + : +3 " " 2 " " 3 #A

9 + ( 5& : ( : :" ( +3 3 " B

! '( 9 + + 3# ( * 9A ( : ( 2 *( 1" " ( +3 4 : + + 3 " B 4 " 2 #A 2* + A ( 3 " 2 *" ) +2 "( )" : 13 3+ 1 : +

4+3 3 #" # + # B 2 ( " 4 ! ) 1 : 9 +% + A ( " : ( " 2 9 + ( 2 " :+ + : ( 3 (# A

" : ( @4 ## " !

: ! 3 "1 3 " 2 : 1 #A #A : 2 B ( 3 + @ 2* + 3 7

2 ( : B1" + 3# ( * 9 @ + + 2 *: (" " + ( 2% * ( + 3 #" +3 (4 & " "4 " ( 43 2( : + ( 1" 33 3% 3 "": + + 4 + 13 A 6 (+ A "! ( % 2

2 :: 1 1 1" 33 3 1+ + : 9 4+ 3 " :" ( ) ) ( B@ + : 9 +% " " : (

4 1" 33"B + , (3" A

9 + ) +2 1 3 3(1( A ( B 1 !4 # +# " + : ( "( ! *( " " ) 3 1 ) +2 " + # B 2 ( F : + "( ! + (4 4 9 +>3 3 #" : ( + 1 3 ) +2 "( @2 + 9 33" + # " +3 3 " ! " @4 # + 1 # :4 :+3 3 "" " ! : 12 " ( #3

"+ + :( F+ + B ) +2 "( 2 3+

3* A " B! 9 + + 3 3" (% : ( 3* 1+ + 1 3 3 # 1+

+ + 13

+3 (4% @ + + " *

+*+ + 3 # B & " "4 ( 43 # 2 *: ( 2" 1+2 + "+ 2 3 * " 2

" : + 3 )2 3 43 ) ( , 3 " A 2 : B 2 " 9 * >3 , 3 A 3 + 2 % "" 2 3 (

% "2* "B0 # (:

9 * % 1+ 2 : 2 : + 2 " 3 * 2: A " % + 2" " 2: @! @ 3 : (% " # + : +) : *" 9 +>3 A 2 A" : ( ) % + 3A :

+ ) 2* : 3 9 + 2 " 2 : ( ( #3 + *" ) + 2 :: "( "

2 (* " 3 4 2( 3A : ::3 "

( 1 +# 3* 42 ( " 4"" " 2 #A

+ + B + + 2 " + ::A " " 3 ( #3 " *" ) +2 1 3 "(

) ( B# 9 3 "" 33"( 4 + " #A @

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 137

Filed 03/06/2006

Page 2 of 7

) +2 "( +) +) 4@4 4

+ ) # B :4 # + # B 2 ( ! 2 : + 3A : 1+2 "1 3 + "+ ) (:" + # B 2 ( ! "B + " # : !" 4 1 # 4 )( B " % )

:@ " : ( ## " ! *" ) + 2 "( : *" 9 4 : E": 3 * : 33* B"+ :3 #" 3 2 : 1" +3 ( +3 3 + " " B + (

" 2 :4 # @ + : 3 9 + 2 " #A " : ( ( #3 " # )# 3

: 4 +

4 # + # B 2 ( % "1 *:+ ) ! (

4 9 +>3 3 #" 2 : (

3 " + ) 3* 42 ( ( 4"" )( 4 @ " 3" "" 3 B 42

* +3 * 93E ( " ) " 2 * ! + + 43 A 3 "

@ "B" 2 : #A 9 + 2 ( :1 3 : ( ( " 9 + +: ) : ( 2 :@ 5& ! 4+ # * 42 3 42 3 , 3 7 % A ( A " " >3 " 3 ; : >3 ! 3A

A ( % @ +3 #A ! 3 " * " 2 ( #"* 3 G " "# 6 ( ( 3 +! ( + & " "4 ( ( 43 3

4 #* +3 : 4 3 A " ( "

@ "B"" ( 2 "( !

" : + 3 )2 3 4 1 + # " * 4( +3 " B :3 " + ( 2 5

(& 5 % + 3 , 3" , " " + % + ) A 3 + A 2 A" 44 "* B

9 + 1 3 A @ @!" 3 : ( ( A ,# A " ( !

#" 3( A :1 3 * @ 2 ( *" ) + 2 + 1 3 "( 4 )( + @ + ! : (+ 2 *:: 1 3 (2 * ( ( 9 A 42 3 , A (& : 4

A 2 " + 1 E "9!+ 1 3 2 3"B ) *2 ( ( )( B " " + # +3 @ 9 3 " & " "4 ( ( 43 3 3( A: A " " ) : ""B 2 : ) 3 2 B " :+3 A"+% "1 3 $ " ( B

#A " + 3(1 ( +

" : + 3 )2 3 4+ # " * :4 "* 5 H * B B

H * B % & 5 % 1+ " +B ( , " 2 : :9 1(: @ " + + 3 "+! A B ( ) 1 : ( 4+ ) " @ " ( ( ( :: 2 # * + " % 3 1 ( 3 + : A 3" ( " + + ! # # ) B " : 2" 2: #%

4 9 + " : ( 3

5 H * B >3 A " " A 2" ) A ,# " : 2* 3 2

9 + 1 3 , " 2 B#" 3( A :1 3 " : ( A " 2 :+31 3* @ * ( + +3 1 3 + " *" ) +2 "(

+ (1 @ 4 " 2 2 : @ +3 " " 4+

+ 3(1

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 137

Filed 03/06/2006

Page 3 of 7

& " "4 ( ( 43 3 4" 42 3" * : , A 0 " + +3 #

" : + 3 )2 3 4' 2( " "0 ) 1 : + :2# " * 3 : A 3* D * 3 3 +! ( " ( 2 : 3

% 4#

5& 0

4 * 9 B #A ! :1" + 2" % ( + & " "4 ( 43> ; : >3 ! ( :

3 A : 2 :@ 5 4 : 3 " * ! E 334 * 3A " % 0 2>3 >3 + +)

+ " :32 3* 3 "(

A : 2" 3 4: 2 # * * -; : >3. " : A ! A A " " + + 8: ( + * 3 4 )2 % 3 " ) (: + :3 " 3 )2 " 3* + 0

9 + " : ( 3

9 + B ( ( 4( 4 :+3 2 : + + : ( * ! 3"" " 3% ' " :+ 4 !6 B ( " 3 -8 ' 6. " * + " # 4+ 2" 2: B : 3

B(() ( : * ! " B : 3

9 + 2 *: : ( (

2 + + 2 " :: "B + ( B+ 4 " + + 1 3 (# * # 3A : :+ * 3 4 E " :@ (1 * ! 3A : B " % 1" 4 + (* ( 3 "! + ; : >3 1 3 4 !

: ""B1" * ) ( "B + 8 ' 6 " ) + "

9 + 2 #A":1" + 8 ' 6 1" 3A 2 : ( ( + + : + + * 3 43 )2 "

4 "* :: " 3 B )

& " "4 + ) @ * + 2 " B "3 + : " % 5 ( 43 B ( #3 ) B" 2 ( B ; : >3 ! 2 #A 3 9 +>3 : ( A A : 2 *: : 3A B" 2 ( B A )" ( +" " % 2% 4 B" ( B 3* )3" A "

( 9 +% 4 ( : (

: B" 2 A 3 & " "4 + ) 3* : + : " >3 #A ! % ( B ( 43 ) ( & " "4 3 9 ( 43 ! :A " ) : # B 3 * " B" 2 2 " & " "4 #* 3 @" @ ( B ( #% ( 43 3 ( ! 3+ 9 + 1 :& " "4 : ! 4 : ( ( 43 * 4+ : + 4 3 3 *" 3 @ ( 2 3% + 2* 3 "" 2A 9 + @ 2 :+3 : ! : + + : ( + " * : ) " 3 + 423 3 4

2 4 ): 2 + " + 2 2 #3 "*

@ 2 1 3 A ,# + " & " "4 ( 43 :2

+ + ): 2 3 3 4 + @ ) 1" 3* A " ( A (

& " "4 2 " 4 B" 2 5 4 : 3% 42 * 3 % 2 ( 43> ( #3 ( B 3 4 + @) 9 + :+ : ( 9 + :: ) !+ B+ 2 *: : (" " (

: + + )2" 3" ( A ( : * " 4 " #3 #A! *( ) " + 2" : 2:

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 137

Filed 03/06/2006

Page 4 of 7

B" 2 ( B A ) "" + " ( + 9 +) ( : 6 : (" B" 2 ( B I - . + ! & " "4 #* 3 @" % ( 43 3 ( 3+ B : B3A : B 8 ' 6 I " " F B : B + + *3 " 2 4

B : B" 4 "* :: " 3F : 8 ' 6 I " ( ( B ) D 43 )2 " ): 2 + " 2* 3

B ( " 3 & " "4 #* 3 @" @ A A : * ( 43 3 ( ! 3+

9 + ) ( : ! 4 + 3 (13% + + 3 (13 1 : ("

2 :4 + 3 4 ! 4 + A @" : + + " ) ( " 1 3 A ,# *( 2 " " 4& " "4 : # B 3 ( 43> * )3" @ ; : >3 A " ! ! B" ( B 4 9 + : ( A ) "" +3 2 " & " "4 #* 3+ 1 @ ( " ( #% ( 43 3 ! 2* 3 : & " "4 + ) ( @ * + 2 " B "3 ; : >3 4 ( 43 3 B (# ! 3* )3" A " A A : B" ( B

2 4 ): 2 + ; : >3 + : : ! 3* )3 " " ! * A " 3 3 : 32" : @ ) % + : 2 # @ * + 42 + ! ): 2 "

#A ! % + "@ 2 :" : ! : + " @ 2 1 3 A ,# ( + 3 * 3 + " 4& " "4 : # B 3 ( 43> +3 2 : " 3 B : 3 & " "4 , 3> A " 3 3* A ( 43> A " A # 9 " A A 9 + + :@ : ( 4+

4( 4 " B 3"!

+ + 1 3 2 #A! B1" + 8 ' 6 " (" + 2 : 1 33 3 3* 9 1 :I 4 :2 : % :@ ; : >3F+ ! !

+ + * 3 43 )2 F+ +3 4( 42 " " " 3""

@ "* + " + : + ) @ ) 3 + 8 ' 6% 3A 242 ( I "" ( ! + 4" ( * + ; : >3 ! 3* 2 #A" 2 (

E " : + ; : >3 * !

9 + 1 3 2 #A! B1" + 3 4: ( B ( " 3F : + + : ( (" + * :9 1(: % " B + B : 3 B" ( B 2* ( 2 3 * " % 2) + + * 3 4 )2 @ 3 " ! 3 +3 " 3 +3 " + 9 + 1 3 ) ( "B + 8 ' 6 " : ( " : 3 ; : >3 ( @ 4 ! " ( :+ & " "4 2 ( 43 9 +>3 A : (

3* )3" A " 4 :2:# 3 2 * "BA @" " 3 4 *( 2

2 32 * :3 B :4 + 3 4 ! 4 + # " 3 " B "B) ( " " 8 ' 6@ !

4 + 8 ' 6 B : B + + * 3 4 )2 & " "4 " 3 " ( 43 4 2 B + + * 3 43 )2 " " 3 " " 3% 3 ): 2 :@ 2 " !

4 + @ ( ) + ; : >3 9 1"B! 2 * B : 9 + ) ( * " ! ( : ( "

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 137

Filed 03/06/2006

Page 5 of 7

+ :2# * (@ " (

! ): 2 % 3A 242 ( + :32 A 2 3 @ 1 " "" ( ! " " A :+ + : ) & " "4 4 A " ) : # B 3 ( 43 * " "" 2A 7

+ + *3

+ 1 3 A " : + + *3 + :

+ @ +5 4 : 3

& " "4 ( 43 + "( 4 +3 # "

3 ) ( 2 : ( : ): " !" 3 : "B A * " 33* * 2 % + % & " "4 4(: # " 4 ( 43 " 4 ): 2 " + '* " + " 3 33* @ 3* A # ! A( ( C! * + 3A ( " "

: 3 C !"3 * " @ 3 :* ) * 2 A 2 + ): 2 + 3 @ " & " "4 ( 43 # # "3 * " 2 +3 # " ): 2 % " (3 "" 2A :# * A 3

: ": + # " 1" * A C:2 % ( 1"B& " "4 + *" ( ( 43 1"B + " # " % " + + ' * %* A + 2 #A " ( ( ( !

: : + A C:2 3 @" : *" ( 3+ 4+ 2 3 @ @ 4 *

"3 * " 3 & " "4 1" E 3 + + ' * 2 B + C !1" 2 ( 43 ( * ( + * + : " B + # + 5 4 : 3 + : (B ( @" " )3" ( B + 5 4 : 31 :+ 5 4 : 3 A 2: ( 1" 3 + " 4& " "4 2 ( 43> : B ( 1 : + ): 2 " ( " 5 4 : 3> " A 3 ) :4 + @ + 5 4 : 3> 3 #" 2 9 2 #@ " % 3 " 2 3 " : ): 2 " " * "

: 2 #A #" : + " + ): 2 1 D 3 4 "

3 " )"@ % + + ( ( ( ( 33" +

C !2 *: 33* + "1 *:@ : 3 * ( # ( ) (" " "B 3A G 3A ( " " 4+ # " 4

: 3 C !"3 * " % & " "4 ( ) * 2 ( 43 3 45 4 : 3> , A 4+ " 33* * 3 * A A G + + 4# + A + 9 2 #@ " "

E 3 : + + ' * :3 ( 1 + A " * " ( " 39: : ) A " ": 1 + "# " ) A" % 33* " #A : ( 3 2* + 3 3 (" *

+ 4 2 + + 5 4 : 3> 3 #" 2 4 45 4 : 3> 3 #" 2

9 2 #@ " % & " "4 1" " ( 43 ( ( 9 2 #@ " 39: : " ": ($ + " 3 !

A +@ 5 4 : 3> , "" A + 3 #" 2 & " "4 @( ! ( 43> " "

3 "! B + " +3 A " 4" " " B "% @ 3

E 3 + ' * :3 ( 1 ( A " 3 @ 3 :* * " ( ( " A

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 137

Filed 03/06/2006

Page 6 of 7

2 2* ) ( 3+ 1 + + 3 #" 2 (3" ! :+ ) BA 2 :5 4 : 3 " ( A 3 ) " 3A ( " " & " "4 ( ( 43 3 : 33" #" 2 "" 3 42 *9 1 42 ( * # 4+ A :+ 3 "" 2A 4+

9 :: " " 4 (" "4 2 & 43>

" 42 39: ) A " % " :4 + 1 : :4 + " @

): 2 % 5 4 : 3 3+ *: " (

+ ): " !" " 33* 4 + A 33"( @ + : + A 3 3 @" + + )2" ( 3+ " #3 : : +8 3 # 3 @" +3 ( 3+ " : 2 ): 2 + * " A 3% : 1+ " B A 3 4+ + @ 2 (9 : 2 +3 *

B A 3 1+2 : A2 + @ :)2" + "+ " * " #3 :2 ( , #" >3 " + 1 : + !@ 3% * : , A :+

: : 4 + # ( C "3 " "* + !+ ) A 3

%5 4 : 31

B + + )2" : : 4@* * " #3 " ( 3" ! # #A "

" 2* ) 3

4 + 45 4 : 3 :

2 4" 3 1" + : +2 "" 3 ( 2 + 42 & " "4 # !@ 2 #A ( : A 3 ( 43 (

:2 ( , #" >3 "

+ C !1" A * + +

@ :@ : 3 & " "4 A ): :5 4 : 3 1" + * " ( 43 " + A B A 3 " @ 2 :1+ " 2 33 ! + + (9 " 4 5 : +3 +: ! 4 " 2% + 7 7J

A B A 3 : A2"B + @ :@ : 3 & " "4 # !" + + " * " ( 43

%&

3D * * " B3 " # $ ** " B3 " # $ ' ( ) *% * " & + "% " , $ ! 4 & " "4 3 ( 43 + @ 2 "! + ! 4 2 % + % (2 " ( 2( ! 3#" : + 4 B "B: 2 # * + '( 9 74" * B + ' D '8 ! # 4 >3 42 3" 3 4( B : " " 3#" ( 4 " 4 (2 " 8 ( B + 4 ( 1"B 2 2 " " ( ' D '8 B3 " 3?5 ( 6 G " : ( 3 : 0 G+ " 3D * * " B3 " # $

Case 2:03-cv-01990-PGR

Document 137

Filed 03/06/2006

Page 7 of 7