Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

EXHIBIT A

Message Page 1 of 1
Clay Townsend -
From: Satia Anand [[email protected]]
Sent: Friday, November 17, 2006 3:07 PM
To; Tanya lmming; Vanessa Braeley; Lizabeth Cowan; westerberg@gmmattorneyscom;
[email protected]; Clay Townsend; [email protected]; lra S. Sacks
Cc; [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected];
[email protected]; [email protected]; Dana Massarsky
Subject: Defendants' Exhibit 1095
All,
ln reviewing Defendants' Exhibit 1095 we realized that we produced the wrong version. Attached please find the
correct version of this exhibit. The only difference is the footnote at the end regarding Style H8501. Please swap
this exhibit out for the current one.
Thank you.
Very truly yours,
Safia
Safia A. Anand I
Associate
DREIER '’‘‘''
499 Park Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Tel: (212) 328-6100
Direct: (212) 652-3773
Fax: (212) 328-6101
[email protected]¤m
This e-mail message may contain legally privileged and/or confidential infomation. If you are not the
intended recipient(s), or the employee or agent responsible for delivery of this message to the intended
recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this e-mail
message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this message in error, please immediately notify the
sender and delete this e-mail message from your computer.
IRS CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE: To ensure compliance with Treasury Department regulations, we
inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this correspondence (including any
attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding
penalties that may be imposed under the U.S. Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or
recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein.
1 1/17/2006

E
E
9* xo
“ $
Z ¤\ N
QF **2
ni: 8 ·-·
ea xo N
"" G; S oo
EE $9 Ch ·-·
ggu »-a" 06 [\
©‘E icq. gig Q mr;
(gd-• “l\
E0 ·~ ‘
§=·,.:¤< § Q wr
zggi % W g 2
QNOVT q- c`
VJ Q org I; <=•'·> N ox
ya tx; N; gg oo
E 2 Q ·~ N 3
Q 66 q- 95 __‘ q-
F- N“ N; N
;.. °‘§¤a¤c 2 N c j xo
°° $’¤r5;¤!\ 99 °° "‘ as " g
o¤=·-·¤>;<»~ c6 vi ‘°
E 5~2=~$ — a 2 S 2 2
¤‘3\¤¢ l\,` •~ I; \O
>[<’— trio Fl ¢\ ·—
Q °2$ Qi Q § N - Q
°m 66 ·~ ' wr \O
7* `S V @`t T9? W "° .<
_ xo ¤ © wr
N ug Eq- (Wn] % lh lf}
m Q q:`(\l 4/* V" V
5 GCE Q mv; xo§ [\ oo" oo
m [\ ;*9 *,3 ···.¤ w ,,{`<: .»~ cn N
- ‘•·· 5 <1: cc? "‘\° ·-¤ xo* ¤<
Q Q \O [\ »-< ’_‘° Q »-4 Q-
6: Q5 cc N $3 NQ ,,;»` ee cn
... N" V? §`xo ¤~§ x¤‘
2 N N E2 $8 'Q-N <: AT}
·¤ °"' 66 qs nn
;·_ °m<-· 2 c> N 5;* xo§ ox
N *"'¤-E gg . · "' x¤\¤ xD
m 8¤E ¤ Q Q 5N QA
2 UGH: 2 ·-· q- Q Ng r\§ 1\
£ B 8 ¤ ” 5 6 b ”~ 3E 3
*·’ \¤ 66 • 99; GN
= 5 G ~¤ ~¤" ° xr;
:·. . G E 2* S Q, ""’ .: 3 69
69 G c ¢\ . ·
< Q N M " Si ~
»-n »-4 \Q %
eu N ya <: *° "‘ °°
*5 ox g Oi Q N· xo
F V "‘ ‘° xo gg $ Q
©” 6 es c Q
·-· cn SS `° N N *¤ S4 @
__ N“ c6 as c _
xo ¤\ <: . xo oo
“‘ on GN N l\ N
B`: cg · "‘ vw ua
Egg Q E <: 95 "" xo
go Q on 1\ c § r\ Q
c/J w ya O; ,4 Go Q6 2 \O
N c ‘° " *0 ee N c ¤\
"‘ C gg . N; V" ln
L .-. [\ N .
Q M oo m
·— x6` N VQ G9 O ·—< © ’_° lh
U ·¤ "" E fi oa
\ A4 xr? xm nn · ea
:... ,__> ___ In __ oo
“ Bwgm ¤ Q 3 2
~ aN·3 A
·— ¤¤:m>_‘ __‘ !\ ·-Y ·-I
Q4 Swan N xo xo c>
una X" Q % 2* lg
°')E mQE<<: m M ,0 GN
¤nE‘§N·g2 '1 ea <1·
ut ··]-—¤·:Li§ >`°f; ‘° <1-“
2 Og ,¢;—,>~.N°°c<:\¤ ‘° oo •~f*•
C/J gx; Svgcligm rl: \O
<: ‘¤ ¤ °
° <: [-·<¤§___<\ §
E ~ §E¤=®¤Q A W
3 0. G.)(·q!l) rq
<> _q..g¤t·¤< x M
E so ¤5‘£; ¤@~ M
© 3 F
E N Gum A
3 ¤E=$S
E ~ %¤?éaaw
O Ou
Q q_) Nguz
E g >-]-E¤§
c O EYE?
en S : :
"" N
III <:
O 2
Q N
CQ 0
gg c>
W E
CD
I

8
('\l V}
Q {Q_
S Q 0
oo 45 VL **9
Y O M
lh M gl 9%
M Q: M N
"'2 <"'¤ Q an
fl' W `° M
l\ __; 3 V" ln
Q * Q Q
Q 9 E Q E S
· Q ' N.
E g ¤\ E S M
· Q .-4 In ln Q £
Q ~¤ 9% **2 ~¤ V
~q M Q ¤~ lf; *6
nn 66 *° -1 "7 M
as [T *9 Q as
2 ¤= E3 ~
• VT A Q Q
Q M ¤ 2 2 Q X Q za :
¤<= 6 Q 2 Q QA ~¤?~; Q
Qq pq OO 9% GQ <"'igg ln
M ,., 9% QE: [\ · 1\=-#
V, xo lh/Q Q} wm 9%
0 en ¤~’;"?·§ "'T Vfir-#
— ¤>¤— qw M
9% O'? ~nN°Q"`£ wm
A QA M-;Q`M ""' C,
gf £‘* "· x G; •-¢_` Q ('\I
Q'? ~¤<~a www S4 *2 Q
N'? nn} `°·¤* N" 0 W Q
QA Q"} mm 9% 0 i` "‘
’? x¤M rgb M" In 0,: Q *5
A gq bv 66 hi ... vm
vii " ,14 %
[T wg $5 ·-· ‘7' lc; 3
*` M" 0 Q "° P3 $ 3 2 =¤
¤\ · vg
oo 'T x § S Eh 0 vw
Q 2 °* S4 °’° 2 67->
N ¤‘ ‘ 0 ¢ vu
S °` (I`] ("I = »—•
l\ ® 9% (.,.1 Q •-• 99
[E 2 0 €> Q 0
·-· O ·-· . .-•
Q (**5
9% M O \Q 1\ 95 `O oo
3 G ¤\ (2 C ce °°»
.*9 * ¤< E ¤2 — 2
[\ pq l\ 9% v-I oo M
G6 xc co . ,5
Q 0 *9 Q ‘·°
•` V1!
V? 66 xc N $2 cx 9**
<·A xc °` “ N ¤\
O . »—< ON Q- c` ("I
2 ; 1 v M ¤~
• ·-• 9% M
*9 i` "L vu Q
S Q 3 9% c` M
¤\ nn <·/9 ‘°
Q 1\ eg . E
Sr N ¤\ $$1 nn g C¤ 3
M W N § VM" U] ' 4-l
99 O " s- E\ .*·=·°[_‘
M M_ ”' xg (ML N/\ ,·-·[-4:u:l-· O
3 »— \ 3 A c/J$`8-EQVO CD
¤~ · Q s: -¤ qt »-. -
2 Q ¤»~‘6?>_,§< QQ? T1 >
NA \QE Exgmgug E [-· CJ
,54Cg;-E$·JlE·‘>`3’Ec{?i$=1¤t:E[-4 [_, rn
;;,Mc¤°°¤:» °>...¤‘-’i-· M
,»·4 G):Fk >...·-·N (-4-]
.¤ j ¤==.2<¤~-—-·¤.· M I
-¤;>`·§[_‘ `gggg 2 2 M
¤-> ¤.>q_,=°© U M I
>`¤¢_M°,3O EQ2 g M
g¤»·g¤5,¤.£— .,, ,., m
=¤:E ‘-’i—·¤¤ c> °° E
Q) vu M E
, 0 M
g 3 Q Q
N Q M E
0 M "°
0 QQ Z
Q CD
gp N
I

nn N N N °° N
GT Q C2 QZ QQ ET `3 (N Q *1
N Qr M oo ' ’ ‘ M
cx 0 M oo "' (Q Q 8 E N
Q. Q. Q. Q § Q. Q N xc gi
M M M Qr , " ”
as as as as gg gg gg E2 Eg gg
nn M oo N *9
Q if Q Q 3 3 °é 3 E 5;
M oo Qs- ‘
oo lh [~ E 5; Q *3 Z? 8 Q
ox_ N N M 6 oo oo N xo .
S3 22 S3 SS gg 2}, 22 LT, 32 g
Q ·-· M N N GO
§ RQ EQ 2@%€ QQ QQQQ QQQQQQ
cx ·-·Qr Moo N_g\G~c¤ gi. $$:-5,3 §$o"‘1°N°g¤
lh ¤0M \¤cx O.lf`• xo ljlxo EM $$3-4 cg`; opodvroé 2·N$o<::;<
E'} GAO GBC (,9*993 gm ;}x`L;E'L ;E'L;}$Z6'gE',
0 ox N xo xo oo
3 3 S Ei Q C2 Q Q C2 VQ
Q Q Q Q 32 R § Q °£ S.
fi P2 QE E Q Q. Q. Q Q. Q
mf mf V; mf 0 nn Qr Qr Qr as
V ·-· lh
°‘°’ 69 °°’ °‘°’ va ee :9 5 E va
§ £ § £ 5
2 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 0
. . . . 0 0 0 0 0
lf} lf] lf} lf} •—4 •—< »—a ·—¤ y-1
Q Q Q Q *2 2 2 *2 2
ee ee ee ua ua
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 *9
Q Q Q Q ¤: Q *¤ Q 2 §
oo ox 0 0 co ' ' ‘
N N co N M lr: Q cl; Q °°
Q1 Q Q Q Q Q Q Q ¤~ 'T
M N N Q2- cx ox cx" xr? oé "‘
-· ·-· ·—· ·-· co N N N N ""
ee as as ee va ya as ee ee G'};
*3 (W hl
Qs- N xo N ox ox
N N xo xo Q 2 oo N Q g
(*6 (**1 (**1 CG of FT gx gx gx U;.
\ >\ q_) \
/\. /5
. N¤. "‘ \E N $4 ¤.>
dggf ¤— NO §<¤%Gr— ¤ °'-E <> ==
Q.) 2* x./3 E :%*:00 td "‘
\'-xc/)>\o8'-xx./cg M-·,L¤¢"'\°8 IJ gfx./·¤® ·-· QJ
83-5?29=g§®¤g§§“$¤g§ ¤©a¤¤.·=E¤¤E.8[_ x¤_... ·—-o _·-·¤-Q. oc, o gg
$m%§$£EZ"©¤SE¤mQ© §QzQ§§ 52o
.=¤ *4-4 >__ · H '¤>__'¤ c¤¤°"'P¤|
¤..[..© Q t <:E¤.>{ Dgtu 'D»..’D
Q gd 3 Q; ©;,•¤{~ (D
O A [·· L)
nn nn nn nn lh nn nn nn nn Il}
M M M M M Qr Qs- Qs- Qs- v
2 Q Q Q (fg M M M M M
CG CG UW F}
m m m m m m E m m m

$
Q ¤\
gg \O
o" C5 N —
lh ··* ___
as 3 Q: oo
¢>

an M ..1 Q
M ‘"' g OO
S 9% °`° ~¤ °°
lc $1% ¤~" N
S 2T S ¤~_ S
QR r\ *0 N
M M ¢> M G. 2 oo
¤¢" N $ S: ... N
N V aa ¤¤ 6
qq ·-· Q \O., ,_, 2;
°°" ,_ 6 ... lo
N N 9% O. N
lo/__ S} —_ E nn
*6\° V oo ON °6 "*
ga, 2 S4 N M 3, M
Ng C, Qi N 99 ¤\
Haq; m-· »-· 69 \O N O H}
mg §¢£%Z@ f M E §
N ~¤3¢·"-—3 ° "° —“ ¤~
. gq\O(.,{‘ 9% N
\O \/ (5 G »—¤ x K\
··* G mq; WON Q © V
Hx .-4 UG`, ;_(\ Q
N lé ld N5 q- ·-· "`• V t\ .-· N M
. K; o ..··. :<\=¤\ od N
99 M qi ··· WV N‘*:€ cx .
oc ·-·" "`• 0 °nl6§?'¤ Q N
*9 oo 9% ...· Q
oo 9% gx M -# gd Ne
N N ~¤ °° Nm ·r~¤¤
lo °° as ld N wv Mc
M § sl ii G EM Q
Q lo °° N? c€ e¤"° N'? oc
. £ N (N O1 (D} \O
Q :\ 83 ea ·— O ___ g‘* lr;
99 \O oo (N" "Di
N E 9% N °° 9* lf? FB 69
c>" oa J, {E °° E °
·— Nr N N en N
9% . 6 q- "" S °° N ·
% OO ,.: \O (N ‘\ oo (q Q"}
·· N G S} lo £ · lf;
N as Nr ln °° .. lo as MF
Q"} oo gr G 99 \'° ,,
K\ 9% Q_ __; ® M
M" M N o Ml M {E 22
M lo 69
lh 9% \O.` O; N N· 2 M M ° $»'
" oc" <|: G ;¤\Oq) N g 9% O Q .-· lh
— N lo" °° c agffa M W M . M .
Gym: \ N" O 99 N· Q M
z¤¤l¤£\.E(\] >x °° gg In 69
gééi 8¤¤:·=;,z; ··“ % Q °f»
§§§£·¤H@i*>¥§ "` N £ €
Zc>‘~#¤¤.> »..§*-· J QD ‘ Z¤§ E .. N oo N- ·
'£>. ¤§_2\-¤T¤ —" M Ml Q
:\ *·*"‘ (‘*\ KD
M N O =·»2i*i~S@~§§ Gi 3 22
Z g SUE E-¤¢¤¤.;\.§:; .-·
E s Q §$%%¤§€§$ 3
Q 2 ” i§iE€§€ 2 M
M :\ =’ =¤ ¤¤
GJ q- A
E S ”’=§=*·-=¤"
N §~c¤·..-»¤..E x
"‘ M E a>~
E 3 H ;£g§
M r\ :¤= I M r\ ¤¤¤m_Q
E E §§¤l—
M N ¤.>‘_-Em
I E Mi-—§
(Q K3
m Q
·—
Q
F'} »—¤
I 3
M
I

~r¤ M "1 Q **1 *2 °*? · °*2 **2 Q **1
M M Q Q Q **1 Q · °°. "1 Q Q
·-• \O N M M N M N -·—· N 66 GF} GF} 66 GF} % GF} GF} GF} GF}
ln xo ·—• N cx K.; W W Q Q Q · **1 °*2 Q **'
N ·—· M O oo GN O M °°. Q *1 Q 1 · Q *`*. Q ***1
N ·n c> <1- c> g oo N N N N M N N _‘ M N N N
99 66 99 69 99 so 69 99 99 09
Q (*7/N \Oc (`*¥c€`!0q'0 •¤ ’*‘c N? \Oc l";`
G ·{> ·s ·> A ·& => ·s ·> ·> ·s
Q. ***0 \O M *!' N x V1 N V Q
l\__, WN (·qNG\V'¤q-G\ \°•-4 VN lnV'¤ GCN lnO\
*"! vw; N*"! oo§~r¤*2~oQ _T*j· NQ co? N'-! ·-·‘:2
8 ·¤~ M8 ~¤L°. 99 66 99 69 99 G6 99 99 GF} 99
Q ..· .-· c> *"! "1 "! **1 Q · G1 "1 Q W
—· N M cx cx Q ·n mn 0 c
N GN 00 N N g \O M **1 Q Q ". **1 · Q Q **1 Q
M M N N N § oo N ·-· c »
M M M M M N GF} GF} GF} GF} GF} G6 GF} GF} GF} GF}
N N N N N N M M M M
N N N N N N N N N N
V3 vw vw vw ln In M M M M
**2 *2 *2 **2 **2 *1 Q Q Q Q
M M M M M M N N N N
v—• v—4 v—4 •*• Ni VN v—• v·— v—• •—•
66 09 69 66 99 G6 99 09 66 99
c> c> Q xo oo N *"* 0 c 0
we <~s Q we ¤w Q * ¤<2 N cx ,_, M ·—· B : N rn ·—·
GN M N N GN ¤~. M. `§ #2 Q {E 3,*} ¤<; N vw O N O O O
cx oo 2 oo xo Q Q cx cx oo
GF} 66 99 66 GF} G6 99 GF} 66 GF}
N O N M N g ~r¤ ko -—• N \O M M O N O M 00 N
**1 **1 **1 **1 **1 · °*1 "1 **1 **1
N N N N N 2 M N N N
\ \
w Q M ,¤ w "3¢:·.
::1-. N 1-. · ·
uv E M**,,,¤~¤.°2& ¤<>~.‘2 <¤ MQ S5 E sm
*>’¤ ·¤:s ¤:**:s¢u·—¤ .. ‘··QM ’¤ -5 :s 1
*-::2 1-· <¤"...»/..::2 ....»JI **Ms.. gg > 1.. Q3
>1©¤>\°’<¤>\—•¤—·;;;]..;..?·>\’¤.,;< ""=¤:¤ ¤>\P'°0>`\¤<¤>`
<: c/JN¤‘&·0£¤*° <¤ gx.-·O B~#&·***c/JN\.¤=c>¤.>°·>&•<:»°·>
<-· .¤ wk 0 ¤.> ¤> ·-·¤.> :s
·-•;;· *¤<¤€6**E=¤*t*·*¤:sZ 0°“*=**G ¤° €6**.¤::=¤°** ©=¤"‘“C¤
¤-MEP FO .bQ"*_Z~‘:<¤ QF QE; .2.** 3-· 0 ,4
°a np ¤— **·—c¤<¤ E" a F: · qa
>» B = *·‘e F ·¤¤ **1 *
,.1 U ¤¤
»-1 »—• •—¢ v-4 v—4 v-l (xl (xl (\] (xl
V3 vw ln vw ln lh ln ln V3 ln
Q Q $2 Q Q Q Q Q Q 2
I I I I CE E I I I I

oo
¤ *3* g` . l\ N`:
2 lj co v-g_ O Q M v-•
3 Q —·` Q *° M $1 E
<+» Gp, ’“ M 95 E G9 V'} an E
E
GN [\ gg ··*
V \O gy Q M Q O .
2 Q oo FL [Q r~ ,.. G 2
§ cx {F ~c 2 0; cx Q Q
99 ’*‘ »~ I` YT <:|· (G" •· ¤
99 65 v-t ·— »-· N1
ya en " w- °’
U`) 99 ua EP
»-J .
§A p,._·¤/__ Q {T jg
_c gp v-4
vi ~s$,;§ dx vv?-1»-C; $4; g #2
Sw EQ2? SM 5%%* d? ¤$ %
JN Avi ·¢·§ ,5** ¢•1"?¤··»°Q -""~ ==¢¤ <¤
*"·`£ `£¤¤ »¤"' ¤c*\¤§°° qv; "L"! -°
99 wvwv m‘° —-.—L'L *° vv ¤>
x.¢ v-<("°T
s:
O
c>
c O »-< Pl · . ’”‘ xg O
Ln l\ Lp, Q\ (*1 x l{ • 2
A Q OO x "‘ F"} q- x go
c> A 2; oa *°. ·q ¤ ,2*, M
<"’¤ an N »-1 O Q 6 .. 3
99 69 59 hl (*1 gr; (G v-I ;_,
% 99 99 (,5 ¤\ O
66 2
V3
•—< '_, ’__‘ ’-{ Q
Q S °'* M @ § ¤¤ oo .»
(.,5 Ol pq <|- 2
V'} (*6 eq QO OO co V (\]
E fi *¤ ~¤ % § 5 $ 0*
N ' · . .
:9 :2 gs, ¤ ss ss gg Z3 5
::
G gg G $ ¤
°`? "`: *0 'i ° ° <:> c 2
cj ¤c> ,4; leg Q c> c 4.
VL ln Q ri ··· S QQ 2 3
w sf ~==* 2 §· 33 ¤ ¤ fi
**9 99 ES ·r> *6 **9 66 ya »-• _.::
ua 3 2
=...
*"• oo 00 O
’*‘ rn S N *0 N N E
Y cg oo eq E N — * 5 J Q w » ¢
F·¢ F-. Us Q
M E
g i n
rx r~¢U x *5
Sm sim z > > ~
#\ xm; — £¤¤~§2 ¤ 8
%¥@2~¤?>@* &Z&”2£ ~ Q
~3~zB<£—¤< &-@m”\~ Q m
Ez©;¤>~—>F S gE-<@»5< ~
— =‘*o°”=····O as :==<·¤“<¤[-¤ —·
>& ¤€a‘Ep §gZ¤E3*E5© ¤
Sc gxw Q ¤O;g:$‘2 F Q
O gm m :¤= ‘¤ ° E
UQ C.): C.) D
N N N IE'
lg lr} lf) 9} "‘ r< F_' _k U]
M Q "‘ ***2 ° ° <=> ·-· as
Z Q °° no I0 O
E ¤ m E z
*