Free Lodged Proposed Document - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF ARIZONA CIVIL EXIHIBIT LIST ___Preliminary ___Injunction ___TRO ___Non-Jury Trial __x_Jury Trial Case Number _CIV 04-429_ Judge Code _MHM_ Date __July 31, 2007___

Alexander Jung vs. John Potter __x__ Plaintiff/Petitioner ___ Defendant/Respondent

Exhibit No. Description Relevant* Only to Equitable Remedy/Other Objections

P1

P2

Authorizations for Medical Attention A. 07/21/00 JUNG.PSMF.00038 B. 03/06/01 JUNG.PSMF.00047 C. 09/25/01 JUNG.PSMF.00051 D. 10/10/01 JUNG.PSMF.00054 E. 01/07/02 JUNG.PSMF.00058 F. 03/01/02 JUNG.PSMF.00065 G. 05/22/02 JUNG.PSMF.00070 Request for or Notification of Absence A. 02/06/01 Trujillo Dep Ex 25 B. 02/14/01 Trujillo Dep Ex 26 C. 09/20/01 Trujillo Dep Ex 27 D. 11/17/01 Trujillo Dep Ex 28 E. 12/20/01 Trujillo Dep Ex 29 F. 01/07/02

P1A Relevance P1B through P1G None

P2A through P2J Relevance; Hearsay and Foundation; FRE 403

* Defendant reserves the right to object to whether exhibits are relevant to the jury trial or, if applicable, the Court's decision concerning equitable remedies. Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM Document 124-3 Filed 06/01/2007 Page 1 of 7

P3

P4

P5

Trujillo Dep Ex 31 G. 02/25/02 Trujillo Dep Ex 45 H. 05/28/02 Trujillo Dep Ex 46 I. 06/24/04 Trujillo Dep Ex 47 J. 07/01/02 Trujillo Dep Ex 48 Supervisor's Light Duty Form A. 02/06/01 JUNG.PSMF.00045 B. 10/10/01 JUNG.PSMF.00053 C. 01/07/02 JUNG.PSMF.00059 D. 03/01/02 JUNG.PSMF.00064 Memo Re: Light Duty Assignment 03/04/02 Unsigned 4 hours Jung Dep Ex 17 MC signed 4 hours Jung Dep Ex 18 MC Signed 8 hours Jung Dep Ex 16 Notice of Removal 08/12/02

P3 None

P4 None

P6

P7

Email From Hemphill to Humberto Trujillo re: Alex not being removed from the Roles of the Postal Service 02/03/04 Job Description ­ Distribution Clerk PS-05

P5 Incomplete exhibit ­ no objection if offered with a return receipt P6 Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Confusing; FRE 403 P7 None

P8

Employee Everything Report 03/14/03

P8 None

* Defendant reserves the right to object to whether exhibits are relevant to the jury trial or, if applicable, the Court's decision concerning equitable remedies. Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM Document 124-3 Filed 06/01/2007 Page 2 of 7

P9

Managers Guide to Reasonable Accomodation; Publication 317 Reasonable Accomadation; an Interactive Process. Handbook EL-307 Letter from Disabled Veteran's Administration re: Alex's 20% Disability 12/08/00 Mesa Family Physician's Medical Records A. 09/21/00 JUNG.MFP.00037 B. 05/22/01 JUNG.MFP.00030 C. 02/28/02 JUNG.MFP.00025 D. 03/18/02 JUNG.MFP.00023 E. 05/22/02 JUNG.MFP.00022 Doctor's Notes: A. 03/06/01 Dr. BerryJUNG.PSMF.00048 B. 09/10/01 Dr. Michaels JUNG.SUPR 00101 C. 09/25/01 Dr. Armstrong Trujillo Dep Ex 11 D. 01/02/02 Mesa Family Physicians JUNG.USPS00250 E. 02/08/02 Dr. RutterJUNG.RUT.00021 F. 02/28/02 Dr. Jensen JUNG.SUPR.001 G. UNDATED Dr. Hiller re: 03/12/02 Appointment JUNG.VA.00122 Certification by Employee's Health Care Provider for Employee's Serious Illness ­ FMLA A. 01/20/01 JUNG.MFP.00065

P9 None

P10

P10 None

P11

P12

P11 Misleading; Hearsay; FRE 403; Incomplete VA Information P12A through E Foundation; FRE 403

P13

P13 A None P13B Foundation; Relevance; Confusing; misleading P13C None P13D & E Foundation; Relevance; Confusing; misleading P13F None P13G Foundation

P14

P14 A and B Relevance; Confusing; Misleading; Prejudicial

* Defendant reserves the right to object to whether exhibits are relevant to the jury trial or, if applicable, the Court's decision concerning equitable remedies. Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM Document 124-3 Filed 06/01/2007 Page 3 of 7

B. 05/22/01 JUNG.MFP.00067 P15 Medical Certification A. 01/07/01 JUNG.PSMF.00042 B. 02/06/01 Trujillo Dep Ex 7 C. 10/10/01 JUNG.PSMF.00052 D. 02/28/02 JUNG.PSMF.00063 E. 03/08/02 JUNG.LAB.00026 F. 05/22/02 JUNG.PSMF.00036 Medical Records of Dr. Mendlick 09/26/01 JUNG.VA.002XX Return to Work Authorization from Dr. Shank 10/29/01 JUNG.PSMF.00127 Duty Status Report 12/05/01 JUNG.MFP.00061 Veterans Administration Health Summaries A. Page 18 JUNG.VA.00018 B. Page 19 JUNG.VA.00019 C. Page 20 JUNG.VA.00020 D. Page 21 JUNG.VA.00021 E. Page 26 JUNG.VA.00026 F. Page 27 JUNG.VA.00027 G. Page 29 JUNG.VA.00029 H. Page 30 JUNG.VA.00030 I. Page 31 JUNG.VA.00031 P15 A ­ F None

P16

P16 Foundation;

P17

P17 Foundation; Hearsay P18 None

P18

P19

P19 Foundation; Relevance; FRE 403

* Defendant reserves the right to object to whether exhibits are relevant to the jury trial or, if applicable, the Court's decision concerning equitable remedies. Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM Document 124-3 Filed 06/01/2007 Page 4 of 7

P20

Evaluation of Dr. Chang 01/07/05 Employment and Placement: Handbook EL312 The Reasonable Accommodation Process Poster 315 Collective Bargaining Agreement: A. Pages 18 through 23 B. Pages 72 through 79 EEO Investigative Affidavit of Humberto Trujillo Employer Response to Employee Request for Family or Medical Leave Step 2 Decision Letter dated 03/23/03 Counseling Report dated 11/28/01 Notice of Suspension of 30 days or Less dated 02/04/02 Approval an Assignment of Light Duty Request dated 02/13/01 Light Duty Extension Memo: A. 02/05/02 B. 03/06/02 No objection assuming the Exhibit is for the relevant time frame No objection assuming the Exhibit is for the relevant time frame Foundation; FRE 403; incomplete exhibit

P21

P22

P23

P24

P24 Hearsay

P25

P25 Relevance; Confusing; Misleading P26 Relevance; Confusing; Misleading P27 None

P26

P27

P28

P28 None

P29

P29 None

P30

P30A & B None

* Defendant reserves the right to object to whether exhibits are relevant to the jury trial or, if applicable, the Court's decision concerning equitable remedies. Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM Document 124-3 Filed 06/01/2007 Page 5 of 7

P31

P32

P33

Statements re: Nixie mail and Light Duty A. 11/23/01 Angelita Martinez B. 01/08/02 Ernestina Mendez C. Undated ­ Jerry Romero Executive Order re: Special Leaves of Absence to be Given Disabled Veterans in Need of Medical Treatment. Defendant's Responses to Plaintiff's Interrogatories

P31A though C Hearsay; Relevance; FRE 403

P32 FRE 403; Foundation; Relevance

P34

Plaintiff's Pay Check Stub from USPS Letters from USPS re: Plaintiff continuing on rolls: A. 5/20/02 B. 6/5/02 from Joyce Coolen C. 7/5/02 D. 11/21/03 E. 1/5/04 Letter from USPS dated 6/5/02 re: Temporary Change of Schedule. Tape Recording of Client calling into the USPS Letter from Plaintiff's Psychiatrist, Dr. Paul Lo

P33 Reserve right to objections at trial depending upon purpose including Foundation; Relevance; FRE 403 P34 Relevance; Foundation P35 A through E Foundation; FRE 403

P35

P36

P36 Foundation; Relevance; FRE 403 P37 Foundation; Hearsay; FRE 403;

P37

P38

P38 Foundation; Hearsay; FRE 403; Plaintiff refused provide Dr. Lo's medical * Defendant reserves the right to object to whether exhibits are relevant to the jury trial or, if applicable, the Court's decision concerning equitable remedies. Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM Document 124-3 Filed 06/01/2007 Page 6 of 7

report

P39

Document 053 re: Clerks and Positions

P40

Defendant's Responses to Plaintiff's Requests for Admission

P39 None if this is the same as Exh. 7 to Jung's Deposition, otherwise reserve the right to object at trial Preserve objections in responses; FRE 403: Relevance

* Defendant reserves the right to object to whether exhibits are relevant to the jury trial or, if applicable, the Court's decision concerning equitable remedies. Case 2:04-cv-00429-MHM Document 124-3 Filed 06/01/2007 Page 7 of 7