Free Motion to Certify Class - District Court of California - California


File Size: 1,033.9 kB
Pages: 19
Date: August 1, 2008
File Format: PDF
State: California
Category: District Court of California
Author: unknown
Word Count: 2,979 Words, 16,554 Characters
Page Size: 613.818 x 844.364 pts
URL

https://www.findforms.com/pdf_files/cand/196232/29-10.pdf

Download Motion to Certify Class - District Court of California ( 1,033.9 kB)


Preview Motion to Certify Class - District Court of California
Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

Document 29-10

Filed 08/01/2008

Page 1 of 19

Exhibit P


........


Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI
CONAM INSPECTION INC.

Document 29-10 Coast Products LLC Page 2 of 19 bp West Filed 08/01/2008

~

T"" T""

co

Contractor:

CONAM INSPECTION

bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson

Work Description
Piping & Vessels

o
o
Job Number:


o

Employee Name:

Gerald Lee

";"'~~!"~!f,:-ji'C:~~M~l
5/10/2004 I
5/11/2004 5/12/2004 5/13/2004

66163 66163 66163 50489

I


API 510 API510 API 510 API 510

I
I

6:00 6:00 6:00 6:00

I
I

1630
I 10 I 10
1630
I 10 I 10


I I I

I I I


I


I I

I 1630
I 10 I 10

I
1630
I 10 I 10


I


Total

o
onsumables/Comments:

'~ffl~~t~:q~J,~~
50489
66163


10

30


10

30


UT:
MT:

PT:
Film: 4.5x10 = 14x17 = 4.5x17

=

8x10 =

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI
__ CONAM INSPECTION INC.

Document 29-10

Filed 08/01/2008

Page 3 of 19

bp West Coast Products LLC

Contractor:
Employee Name:

CONAM INSPECTION

bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description Piping & Vessels

Gerald Lee

Job Number:

5/10~
5/1112004 5/1212004 5113/2004

70601 70601

I
I
I

API 510 API 510 API 510 API 510
6:00 6:00 6:00 1630 1630 1630 10 10 10 10 10 10

I
I

70601 70601

Total

40

o

o

Consumables/Comments:

70601

40

40

UT: MT: PT: Film: 4.5x10 = 14x17 =

8xlO

=

()

o o
o

~§;,t~~

CO
CO

(j)

CO

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI
~~~==!FCONAMINSPECTION INC.

Document 29-10 Filed 08/01/2008 Page 4 of 19 bp West Coast Products LLC

bp

.Contractor: Employee Name:

CONAM INSPECTION

bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description Piping & Vessels

Gerald Lee

Job Number:

5/24/2004 5/25/2004 5/26/2004 5/27/2004

I
I I I

50489 66163 70601 70601

I

API 510 API 510 API 510 API 510

I

6:00 6:00 6:00 6:00

I

1630 1630 1630 1630

I 10 I 10

I

I

10

I

10 10

I
I

110

I

I 10 I 10

'I

Total

'0

o

onsumables/Comments:

70601 50489 66163

20 10 10

20 10 10

-MT: -PT:
Film: 4.Sx10 =

UT:

-

o o
o
CO
(0

o

14x17 =

N

-..I

_

CONAM INSPECTION INC.

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

bp 29-10 Document West Coast Products LLC Page 5 of 19 Filed 08/01/2008 bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description Piping & Vessels
Job Number:

bp

Contractor: Employee Name:

CONAM INSPECTION

Gerald Lee

5/31/2004 6/112004 6/2/2004 6/3/2004

Holiday Pay I
I I I 70601 70601 70601

I
I

I 8 I 8
10

API 510 API 510 API 510

I 6:00
I
6:00

I 1630 I 10 I 10
1630 I 10 I 10

I 6:00

I 1630

I 10 I 10

Total

I 38(

Il 38 1)0

~

I

0

~onsumables/Comments:
~1~{\~;.i~;~,:'~~,,;/h'.;< ,:.IT"~~

·C···'H'i\'R·"G'·E'··/·A·r::d#·;,\!;..-r:O·.·~':·AL······H·· ,.OU',"· R"Sl"'l';:.~!> '~~~i_'~:~" · ,T· '", ;.;;. ,,; . ., ·j":!:/~·;' :.~.-.,;: .<: '-i.,A;;,', ~,j';i~DT: .,-,..::.~~ ;J.\:,.
;J..

70601

30

I

30

UT: MT:

PT:
Film: 4.5x10

=

=fd.-.. lid ~ 1/ 4.5x17 = 8x10 =
<

"

f'\

I,

]7~

CJ

o

o o
.~

o

-,

i"~--r ·;·~I/>\.:

0> .......

CJ'l

0>

..-- ·_·--T-·····,·m T ,---..

¥

I'

to· · · · · ·

'-.~

···

~

···

_~

....

p,-.'

.._ ··-

~.-

.' . · . . · I

. '" ,

.· "

"r-··T'·· .. ...
~_

. -= CONAM INSPECTION INC.

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

bp West Filed 08/01/2008 Document 29-10 Coast Products LLCPage 6 of 19
bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description

Contractor:
.. Employee Name:

CONAM INSPECTION

Gerald [ee

Piping & Vessels

Job Number:

;;,:·.;,','6i~a~:::t:';
6/21/2004

.;'i~~MM~~~ffi~~~s,t:iiJ·>· '6;~~'~~i!j;~
6:00 6:00 1630 1630 10 I 10 10 I 10

70601 69877

API 510 API 510

6/2212004
6/23/2004 6/24/2004

70839

API 510

6:00

1400

7.5 I 7.5

ITT\
Total

I 27.5 ( 2'7.51

J

I

0

I
70601 70839 69877

I

C/'6onsumables/comments:

··,¢>,,(j,g~F,~:;:~Ji,":,i~11~:~i."~m';;;~T';;~
10 10
UT: MT:

7.5
10

7.5
10
I

~.J/.lJ
4.5x17 Mise;

Y-R IZ

I'J

.1"

J6 -

/1

PT:
!=i1rn' 11 I:iv1 () -

=

0'

o o 0)
,l::..
0) 0)

o

14x17 =

:'SIG,.a,,*$l:JRE;~~iI~'·£)

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI
- - 77 CONAM INSPECTION INC.

Document 29-10 Filed 08/01/2008 Page 7 of 19 bp West Coast Products LLC

('f) L() (0

...

N

Contractor:

CONAM INSPECT/ON

bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description
Piping & Vessels

Employee Name:

Gerald Lee

u

o

o

11/15/2004 I 11/16/2004 I 11/17/2004 I 11/18/2004 I 11/19/2004 I

87466 87467 87466 87467 70601

I I
I

API 510 API 510 API 510 API 510 API 510

I I I I I

6:00 6:00 6:00 6:30 6:00

10:30 1630 1630 1630 1200

4

4

I 10 I 10

I 10 I 10
I 9.5 I 9.5 I 6 I 6

I I

Total

39.~~1

L'1\

0

~nsumables/Comments:

~;!f[~~G~tei~i~'.~~1~f)t %~~i~~m!l~w.~~l
87466 87467 70601

14
I
I

19.5
6

I 19.5
I
6

UT: MT:

PT:
Film: 4.5x10

;/7 -~~
/7

/l

/J

= 14x17 =

4.5x17 Mise:

=

8x10

=

i~r§~N~liim:R~1f;";

.

CONAM Inspection & Engineerig Services, Inc.

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

bp West Coast Products LLC Document 29-10 Filed 08/01/2008 Page 8 of 19
bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson Work Description: ... __ .. Vess.el & Piping

Contractor:

CONAM I & E.S.,lnc.
. Time Time Out ." 16:30 16:30 10:00 16:30 14:30 Total

Employee.Name:.Gerald. Lee
~

...Job #. :5l5.59/.881.97 . .
Name
Film

.....,.

.~ha ..gel

5T

OT

DT Hrs
Quantity Sq. Inch

"',iD,~tE!;;)~ '. Afq~No.,

. Craft Class API 510 API 510 API 510 ("Af1510 \

In 6:00 6:00 6:00

Hrs 10 10 4 10

Hrs 10 10 4 10 6

Hrs

Equipment

Materials

Quantity

Tech/Asst

10/2/2006 10/3/2006 10/4/2006 10/5/2006 10/6/2006

69634 69634 69634 69634 69634

/

6:00 6:00

A 1510/

8

2

I

-----~ .1- "'
f-.

"\\/
)
)


\/

Weekly

Total

42

40

2

0

Comments:

,.,/7

@IJfl~~;§~~I;;~~ .'
69634

.mO'tFAbH0URS
........};: "'. ,", '.. ; ,·f .....
";.~,,

... "

, .....

. S:r
42

OT ;: I
2

Q ):

}I.fl_

I

(0/1/t6
(
(

42

1/
Additional Equipment/Materials:

I

Mise:

o o

()

o


Billable Totals
'" " ,."" .... .... " '" ."

42

42
·. " .·. ,
0" '" dO

2

0

~1
"'i"

' , -~mr7:~
.. , ... ,.· .

..",,'~'~~'

· ~ "1','-,"
~".
J'

~f1"'"
.

;:,._'-"~:

:r-tolf'f3' . . .··l'b~~l~t . -:',·' f.,~'1 . JI§~lf~lIt ;"'~~',~:".~. <,~'"
i

'

, .,~ ~
Ii

.,
" ' "


,

........

.,f:::o..
-......j
. . .

-......j

i i i "

· iI ·.

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI
CONAM Inspection & Engineerig Services, Inc.

Documentbp West Coast08/01/2008 LLC 29-10 Filed Products Page 9 of 19
bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson Work Description: API 510 Sr

Contractor: Employee Name:

CONAM I & E.S., Inc.
Gerald H Lee

Job #:58095/94573
Name' . .' Materials QUantitv
Tech/A$s,t

Ii

F

I

Date
12/4/2006

Ghargef AFC No. 69634 69634 69634 69634

nme
Craft Class Holiday Sr. API-510 Sr. API-510 Sr. API-510 Sr. API-510 Sick Pay In 6:00 6:00 6:00 6:00

Time Out 16:30 16:30 16:30 16:30

Total Hrs 10 10 10 10

~I

. UI

' U·I

Hrs . Hrs. ·Hrs 10 10 10 10

.. Equipment..

1215/2006
12/6/2006

12/7/2006

Weekly

Total

40

40

0

4

Comments:

CHARGE/AFC#

TOTAL HOURS

ST

OT

DT
Additional
EquipmentfMaterial~

69634

40

40

...,..-:;-4' A j x1
Mise:

IJ

II

.
iii

~

....

~

o o

()

Billable Totals
',... m

40
i'

40

0

0

o ...... ......
.......

OJ
)ililNIU i

l8.I · .'
.'~.,.!'

,-

". ,.

.,.

.

,;.

...'",
'

"

.,.
....
-"..', . . ~

!

i
,
II, 11 I '1
')ill

oil

i·j

jill.oM i.hili.l,dl

II

.1

i

iii I i 11

t

io'

.Iii

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

Document 29-10

Filed 08/01/2008

Page 10 of 19

Exhibit


-----

-----

- - =- CONAM INSPECTION INC.
Contractor;
Employee Name:
Date
Chargel AFC No.

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

Document West Coast Products LLC Page 11 of 19 Filed 08/01/2008 bp 29-10

CONAM INSPECTION

bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description: RT Assitant
Total Hrs ST Hrs OT Hrs DT Hrs
Job Number: 83756/45936
O~S.
....

Steve Taylor
Craft
Class Time· .. Time In Out

0.5.
Explanation

T.S.No.

Mileage

COMME~tS;

.

Office use only

r/-:? I
'1/

2fY;l~
~&'/d5'

I2rIbJ'7"
)
I
J
I

Ibp4

e>~9c>

/0
/0
/(J

/0

~#"1" A~yZ?

l~p.Q

e2.7o

/11
/(7

(,(2- I~ glll t;"
.

/

I'-(?f?
I".r>

o~~o

/" \J
I

l
'2iJ/2t;
O'2.~o

!AI'?

10

/0

I LfC 1)1
\
GbIA.RG.EIAFC#

··

II

~ \ ~

'"

~onsumableSJCOmments:

TOTAL HOURS;.
.. $T

·· ' ·· !"


OT";
;:t>T··

UT: MT:
PT:


fAlf;;;
j

~


Film: 4.5x10

=

4.5x17 Mise:!?

=
./

8x10

=

.---- ..

o

......>.

o o

14x17

SIG~A;fLJfU::: . . i T ..:2. 7

=

.?

W W CO

~

i~ll

I"

""!1'W'

'!

If
ii I
11

~""

cg~61~r: \. .....: "£'""1"1 .
~':.~'"

...

pi

I'

! ! I t

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI
'r

!!In

Document 29-10

Filed 08/01/2008
,.,

"' · .

lSi'

Page 12 of 19
",,"'

"0',,

"I

N

co

(J)

bp West Coast Products LLC

N

CONAM INSPECTION

bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description:

U

o

o

~

II
:1

Effi~I~Jii~Name: 5-7£j /£
. ·., . . ;·&)i::-~1~;·-,,:· ;~i;; .·;·~·;, ...


MYA- f!)/Z-·
~.~~"


t,p?r
O.S. Explanation

Job Number: S.;2.2IG.

.' .,:;.~:~fj {&f«~rg~1
/7/I".3k'l-isl
1~'I"kll2..81.2

-~tlY~~'q~(';~e~Nb:

Craft Class

In

Time Out
t:? :;?-

I

Total Hrs

ST Hts

,.e:.-r 45>7
sl

I~ 19 e7

I

O.S. Mileage

--,e-?
COMMENTS

'3 e:> I 10

/'"
/0

11-.

!ytJoPfA7'#R

______

I

~j.;;i

i?'1
~i··

£--r /1>'1"/ I /6/l' ~ 1e>'2. '3 ~ I/o I
I02-:'}o

1/'71~,IotA2.~/;2>16-r A-~§-r I/~&'o

liP
1/1)

In

j2.;;L:;:;¥I2.~/.z. -r I u- /ls~~r
~

7 7
I

~

7

".11' ::::~
";iii .",)~.,

I£..CJf:'

IO~'3l!:l

UJ

,II:
;~f
;}?!i
..

:;~
""~

TlCfCl

~,

I~
f/"l
J

.:..~{f#,

,~>;~

Ii~

itll

I_~~;.
....."'" .

't'~

to

<.I.. I."

ITOTAL HOWR@

Sr'
ij'C)

I

oi

I}I]
.

~)nsumables/Comments:
I

"";.'

"

~g/:zs::1

I

"l'c

I

'I
I

UT: MT:

I

I

PT:
Film: 4.5x10 = Mise: 4.5x17 =

;L;;!t-~
8x10= 14x17
~

,I
'I

lSlGrtlATQ:~E: - ;;r/2~~7
"=./

11

~

7

,.~~~,

~~~:s:'CONAM INSPEcrfON INC.

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

bp West Coast Products LLC Document 29-10 Filed 08/01/2008 bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description:
~~

Page 13 of 19

L()

o

o CO ...

:0 ntractor:

CONAM 1& ES

~ mpJoyee Name: .>~~
~ CD
~

/&.
0.8.
Film
Quantity

Job Number~y~·
Name
Sq. Inch
Tech/Assistant

o o

o

'"
co

Date

Charger

Craft Class

Time
In

Time

Total

ST

OT

DT
Hrs

O.S.

T.S. No.

n..
<'>

WONo.

Out
13.C"'O

Hrs

Hrs
f

Hrs

Exp[anatJon

Time

Officeuseorw
I

WK/O"j /71'f;£ ~ co ff;;2-~ ..... I
I

O(,QO

: ~/t'Z91'.S"'" f-P~~
78/2-$". -r/J--r

/,,&1

I' ~r;
/0170

'i" " - ..... tI_
V

0""A-'f6"'-S t.f(J"AI J. l~
;ks"".1

~

/'t, /J,. /1J ~c~

V~7
10
~

As,.r'T

(//:'00

"1

..... ...

co
CD
~

/<77791.

Pr Ih.>f
h-Ik"!>r
0
-~.
?

IPI9()

,ec;o
1/(;0

7.

>

,

~

I1#Qtf1t/T'

/fA ;-To

I.e

')

...
?/?-c..-/

(
!O?7f2
Ot:eO

F

S
-:2-- l -

I

7-~~2C ? '

}1-<;$t

Ii!' :> I I
;)O'D

I

I

j

I
..;.

IO~lD;

fi-s.s.r

I?"~o

3

3> '" r

0~
J

:t.,s: -;2./ MrS"" I/o~'for:: ~;:; /f:>sr

2~

()¥'O
09~o

09'_30

>
~

>
r

I--

J4T'3'(:I

'
-

0'

:z:
UJ

CJ ""'"

==> m
(J
~

HARGEJAFC#
Ip 779'.e3

10TALHOURS

51

OT
/.~

DT

Ia '" .... 2BlZ-S-

II
12..~

/1 1/
f)f 12

\/8'-', fl k_ ...

~-

romments
,

....
CD

10

~

10;2. 9"oS:

/2

1Y"
~

co
10

6 B 7r:J"5

(p
/'
~

'" I <» '" I
::r

co

c>

."'"


OTAL:

-1~r

11/

I.S

SIGNATURE:

'~I'''

7//--

~

t-'
"''7
I

A_

----

...

_---

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI bp

Document 29-10 Filed 08/01/2008 Vvest GOaSI t-'roaucrs LL\.J

Page 14 of 19

('i') (j)

cx::>

Contractor: CONAM INSPECTION Employee Name:

bp Coordinator:

c.RfJn Cfarkjon

Work Description:

P-r

u

o

...... o

f'...

Consumabres/Comments:

UT:


MT:


PT:

Film: 4.5x10 Misc:
Total Hrs

=

14x17=

a

0.0

0.0

0.0

SIGNATURE:

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI
CONAM INSPECTION INC.

bp 29-10 DocumentWest Coast Products LLC Page 15 of 19 Filed 08/01/2008 bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
Work Description: RT Assistant
Job Number: 54144/50157

bp

00

.......


t- t-

N

Contractor: Employee Name:
Date
7/25/2005 7/26/2005 7/27/2005 7/28/2005 7/28/2005 7/28/2005 7/29/2005

CONAM INSPECTION

Steve Taylor
Craft Class

u
. T.S.No.
.Office use only

o

o

I Chargel
AFCNo·.
I I
28125 28125 28125 28125 105153 29382 29382

005.. ·. Explanati9n

I

CQN,I,M~NffS

RT Assistant

6:00 6:00

1630

10

I RT Assistant I I RT Assistant I
I I

I 1630
I 1430

I 10
I 10

10 10
8
I

I
I

6:00· I 1630

RT Assistant I 6:00
1630 6:00

I 8
I 2

I I I

RT Assistant I 1430 I 1630
I
1000

2

I RT Assistant I I RT Assistant I

I 2130 I 3 I I 4 I

I 2 I 4

I 1

47 I 40

6

1

Consumables/Comments:

~t:lA~GE/J{~~.# ." ,,1· ]@ffi~&ffl·@~ij.~i
U1~

'st
38

,··om
2

·I;·DT
UT:
I 1

I

38
2

1015153 29382

I

I

7

6

MT:

pt:
Film: 4.5x10 = 4.5x1 ~=1215 8x10 = 160

w/r~ 14x17 = 8330 :$;~N~~:~l~E.t~· ffi~'

-// .
I


..


Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI
~ CONAM INSPECTION INC.

Document 29-10 Filed 08/01/2008 Dp vve:::H VUa~L r I VV,,","'l";)

L..L.. ......

Page 16 of 19
'.

N

,:~II; ~~k·:v '~\;. ,,~,_

I.()

N

Contractor: Employee Name:
Date

CONAM I &ES

bp Coordinator: Ron Clarkson
zAr,,-E:'.a-Time

\~~'l!", , . ",rl

/7-£//,eCraft Class

Work Description:
Total ST OT I DT
Hrs

;:?r
o.S.

~5-r. O.S.
Film
Quantity

Job Number:
Name'"
Sq. Inch
1:r~S.: No.'

I

u

o

o

T"""

""

I Chargel
WO N9. I

. Time

In

Explanation

. Time

Tech/Asslab!ljt: ,,/:OtIIeeuSe O!W

'7/;13

~25'1 J(i-r ;4sG-;- !l:'/-' ',7-CJC7

7ft"
11/1
7(?-0 7/?-0

1?J?'2:s1
/'

(

lo~o~ l,~o~ ~l

I

I

I

7

zL~:r
lli~fa~

ot(!;1#!:)

I

/").-0

I

t,

'.-~ ··.···'~r .~.
~

"C"",,&;~~,@liJ p

/7 ~

/

-

I I

I

\
I

I
" .1

I

7/"2-/ ;2£"2:5
1/

~c7.o

I

/L

"0

I/o

1/7
[7

//I'\'h
eH~t~:GEJAFC#
TOTAL HOURS·: ".

;:'~i'I~\:

Comments
~

.... :~';"

..

.:t~yt~·
..

:,
.

~~-::

';\
~{

.

'7/
TOTAL:
:.1 .

pl

'."

\

,

.

.,;.,

SIGNATURE: .. ..
.

~~
~

"-

7;~2

T

'../7

~~:":':~il~~:~:~'r:r~:~
"\"
-.

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

Document 29-10

Filed 08/01/2008

Page 17 of 19

Exhibit R


~-

-~----~~--

~--_.~~----

-

-

--

-

~--

~-

~---

~~-

~---

~

~--

---

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

Document 29-10
Document 21

Filed 08/01/2008
Filed 04/09/2008

Page 18 of 19
Page 1 of 2

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

FULBRIGHT
A

&

..JAWORSKI L.L.P.
FLOWER STREET

REGISTERED LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP

555 SOUTH

FORTy-FIRST FLOOR

Los

ANGELES. CALIFORNIA 90071 WWW. F U L B RIG H T . COM
(213) 892-9200 (213) 892-9494

C BERTOLD [email protected] DIRECT DIAL: (213) 892-9363

TELEPHONE: FACSIMILE:

April 9, 2008

VIA ELECTRONIC FILING Hon. Susan Illston United States District Court Northern District of California 450 Golden Gate Avenue Courtroom 10, 19th Floor San Francisco, CA 94102

Re:
Your Honor:

Lee et al. v. ConAm, Inc. (Case No. C 07-4956-81)
Letter confirming the parties' resolution of discovery dispute


In lieu of an opposition to Plaintiffs Gerald Lee and Steven Taylor's letter brief filed with the Court on April 2, 2008, Defendant Conam Inspection and Engineering Services, Inc., submits this letter, on behalf of both parties, to confirm that it has reached an agreement with Plaintiffs' counsel to resolve the discovery dispute previously submitted to this Court. By that agreement, Defendant will provide the names and last known contact information for its current employees and for all former employees, employed with Defendant during the statutory class period, to a third-party administrator, to be selected by the parties. The third-party administrator will send an "opt-out" letter to a randomly selected group consisting of one-third of Defendant's current emploYees and all former employees identified. Once the opt-out deadline passes, those current employees and former employees' contact information will be released to Plaintiffs' counsel. Plaintiffs also reserve the right to seek the contact information for the remaining employees at a later time if need be. The foregoing is a complete and accurate description of the agreement reached between Plantiffs' counsel, Steven Tindall and Ellyn Moscowitz, and the undersigned, on behalf of Defendant. In light of this agreement, the parties respectfully ask that the Court consider

70279601.1
AUSTIN. B£l..JING ·
DALLAS ·

DENVE~ · DUBAI ,. HONG KONG. HOUSTON. LONDON.

Los

ANGELES. MINNEAPOLIS

MUNICH. NEW YORK. RIYADH. SAN ANTONIO.

ST.

LOUIs. WASHINGTON

DC

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

Document 29-10
Document 21

Filed 08/01/2008
Filed 04/09/2008

Page 19 of 19
Page 2 of 2

Case 3:07-cv-04956-SI

Hon. Susan Illston April 9,2008 Page 2 Plaintiffs' letter brief withdrawn. In the alternative, we request that the Court issue a Minute Order acknowledging the parties' agreement to informally resolve the discovery dispute. Respectfully submitted,

~~~o)Candace Bertoldi
Fulbright & Jaworski L.L.P.
Counsel for Defendant Conam Inspection and
Engineering
cc: Steven Tindall (via electronic delivery) Ellyn Moscowitz (via electronic delivery)

70279601.1