E h ` b `t H
llf03,.·*200B 1412B Fliii URRICK SILIBUH 'v'.°.LLE't’ t)02_r()t)3
Case 1:04-cv-01371-JJF Document 433-9 Filed 11/21/2006 Page 2 of 4
DRRICK, HERRINGTCIN Er SUTCLIFFE LLP
1000 masse Roan
memo Pans, cn 94025
tel ssa-sia-moo
fax 650-614-7401
G R R I C K WWW.ORR|CK.CUM
Brian H. Vanderlanden _
. t 9 (650) 614-7629
N¤W=mbL= ’· —°°6 ..V..d......t..is.,.....t.......
viA FACSIMILE
Howard G. Pollack
Fish & Richardson P.C.
500 Arguello Street, Suite 500
Redwood City, CA 94036
Re: Power lgtqggations, v. Fairchild Semiconductor et gl. (CA 04-1 §Z l ||[)
Dear Howard:
As I mentioned in my letter of October 30, 2006, the color photo plots that were taken of
Mr. Beasom’s test wafers are available for inspection at our offices. Please contact me at
your earliest convenience to arrange a time for inspection.
Your letter of October 26, 2006 rnischaracterizes the lnrersil test wafers, test devices, and
accompanying documents as a new production. Mr. Beasom discussed these test devices at
hisjanuary 26, 2006 deposition, and stated that he “provided those to Legal as a part of the
response to the subpoena? Mr. Guy stated on the record that he expected these to be
produced from third party Intersil. Both Fairchild and Power Integrations had ample
opportunity to depose Mr. Beasom about these matters. Power Integrations cannot claim
reudice, as it was well aware of the existence of these test wafers, had the o ortuni to
P l _ _ _ PP
explore that during Mr. Beasom’s deposition, and knew that these would be relevant to
establish reduction to practice at the invalidity phase of the trial.
Furthermore, the fact is that Fairchild does not have control over Mr. Beasom’s test wafers,
devices, and documentation, or the actions of Mr. Beasom or Intersil. Indeed, to this day
Intersil resists providing the actual test wafers and devices to Fairchild. Fairchild did not
even learn of much of the accompanying documentation until recently. Nonetheless, _
F aitchild has ensured that everything obtained from Tntersil is produced to Power
lntegrations well in advance of trial and as soon as Fairchild learns of it. Should Power
lntegrations wish to inspect the wafers and test devices themselves, it is Faircl·iild’s
OHS West:26tll17675.2
`ll.··"09f200E l*°l»:2T FAX URRIBK SILIEUH '·.·'P.LLE'l·' ()()3j()03
Case 1 :04-cv-01371-JJF Document 433-9 Filed 11/21 /2006 Page 3 of 4
O R R I C K
Howard G. Pollack
November 9, 2006
Page 2
understanding that Intersil will make them available at the law offices of Shore Chan in
Dallas, Texas. Similarly, it is Fairchild’s understanding that lntersil will make these materials
available for inspection in Wilmington, Delaware, immediately before 11;ial.
Sincerely,
Brian H. VanderZanden
BHV:ma5
cc: William j. Marsden, _lr.
Frank E,. Scherkenbach
Ol-I5 Wcsc:26U1'17675.2
11/03/2008 14:28 FMI UHRIUK SILIBUH IIALLEV 001f003
Case 1 :04-cv-01371-JJF Document 433-9 Filed 11/21 /2006 Page 4 of 4
DRRICK, HERRINGTON E SUTCLIFFE LLP
_,____<,.,,,. . . ·— · - —~. 1000 Muse Roan
F g;· ~ · ~ ·· f . MENL0 PARK, CALIFORNIA 94015
I , 0. . jjj, fi ,. l lf fl. D ,., TEL 650-614-7400
` E I FAX 650-614-740l
O R R l C K I I www.0nnIcI<,c¤M
I NOV? I
I. % . - I
A c. __;
FAX TRANSMISSION
N b 9 2006 N0. or PAGES»5
DATE ¤V€T¤ cf , (1NcLu¤|N
name EBI
Brian Va11derZandcn (650) 614-7629
TO
name aampanylfinn tel fax
Howard G. Pollack Frsu & Rxcuannsou 1=.C. (650) 839-5071
William]. Marsden, Jr. FISH & Rrcwmnscm I-•.C. (302) 652-0607
Frank E. Seherkeubrrch FISH & R1c1-1A11Ds0N P.C. (617) 542-8906
RE Power Intcgmdoxzs TG Fairclzdd Semicauductcg et aL
MESSAGE
Please see attached.
C-M-A 10414-25[7703] Originals V/ill Not Follow By Regular Mail
IF You no NOT RECEIVE ALL PAGES, IPLEASE CALL (ES0)614-Taos as soon AS 1=0ss1¤LE.
notice to recipient
TH; Ipzromwmou qonnmzn m THIS r¤csu»uLE TRANSMISSION I5 INTENDED TO BE SENT aww TD THE sTA‘rE¤ ADDRESEE DF THE TRANSMISSION. IT MAT BE PFIOI'€CTE¤
Enom UNAUTHORIZED us: on nnsswnnmun sv THE xrrnanev-•:LIErIT EENILEGE, THE .·:rr0RNEvw0n1<-Pu0¤ucT DDCTRINE, on ANY OTHER APPLICABLE PRIVILEGE. IF YOU
ARE NOT THE STATED ADDRESSEE, YOUR RECEIPT DF THIS TRANSMISSION WAS UNINTERDED AND INADVERTENT. AND YOU ARE HEREBY NDTIFIEO THAT ANY REVIEW, USE,
¤1;;rI1m,·.11¤N, mrmuurnou, on cepvma ur rms cumuunrmou I5 sT1ucT1.v rn01·u¤|TE¤. mu arr 41.50 Arm ·r¤ Nunn us mmumv rv mrnuunr mv T0
RETURN THE ORIGINAL DOCUMENT TO U5 IMMEDIATELY BY MAIL AT THE ADDRESS ABOVE. THANK YOU IN ADVANCE FOR YOUR COOPERATION-
0Hs WHS'I`:26I`II 11269.1
United States Free Forms
Canada Free Forms
United Kingdom Free Forms
Australia Free Forms