Case 1:04-cv-01067-MSK-CBS
Document 276
Filed 09/12/2008
Page 1 of 6
! "# ! $ ++ ,
% ! & # ' $ #
(
)
* * )
++ , 5 *+5 .
+
. , ( . ( 6
+ + /++ + 0 + +1 3 , - ( *- * * *2 . * 4 ,& 7 * * *:+ , + (5 8 5; 53 . 55 5 .
- 5 )- * * + +
*+5 5( 8 . 3
9 4 ) 5+ )* ,
. ( * . 83 * . ( 8 . ** , - + - *5) 8+ + * + ++ - 63 * * 4 * 4 * 5 ) + , = > + < 48+ + * )+ 5 * *5) 5( * .+
. ( 9 * , . (- + * 7 8 " + (- ,8 . 48+ + +
53
+ 5<
* )+ 5 * , + *- *5) 5( * .( 5 ++ -) 5< +
53 .
- 63 * * 4 * 4 * 5 ) + , ? -* + ( )
5 - + (9 *+ < . 7,
" + (++ 3 + *, *8 63 - < - *< . *+ + < + ++ - 5 .( + ( *, 3 7 *( , 4 < - 9 5 . ( 8 6* * * +
5 (. ,<
Case 1:04-cv-01067-MSK-CBS
Document 276
Filed 09/12/2008
Page 2 of 6
" + (++ 3 + . *+ -* ) + A .5( - 5 9 + 55< 5 "5
+ ,
. 9 5( + - * 5 ) * * 5 8+ + .
) +5+ @ +) ++ 3+ + , ) +5+
. 83 * . ( 8 . ** , * : 8+ + * + (
. 9 5( + - * 5 ) * * 5 8+ - * ) + . + +) @ B " + (++ 5+ + . * *,
.5( - 5 9 + 55< 5
6* )* ( . 5 (. + 5 < ** 4+
) +5+ @ +) + 8) .* 5 +<
" + (++ + . 8) . * , ) +5+ @ +)
+4 5
" + ( * . 83 * . ( 8 . * 5+ * , * : . 8+ + * + ( ++ + * , = 4< 5 + > 5 8) ,5 * 8 4 5 + 8) .* 5 +< ) +5+ @ +)
+
. (3 ++ - . (- + + 3 + ,5 * + + *+ 8 ) +5+ @ +) "5 . + . ( 8 . + ,5 * * 3+ 8
+ 4 5 ,
- 35 5 +
+ 4 5 ,
- 35 5 +
4< +
) +5+ @ +) "5 . + . ( 8 . *+ ** 9 7, + . , ( . + + *
. 8+ 5 < ?
) +5+ @ +) " + ( * . 83 * . ( 8 . * 5+ * , * : . 8+ + * + ( . , ( . + +< 5 * ) +5+ @ +) +
(* . * **+ 9 7 + "5 + * ) 8+
. + . ( 8 . *+ 5 &* 4 + *- + + &* * 9 7, + - * + * + ) +5+ @ +)
* . -* * ,) * + + + 8+ < 5
=
Case 1:04-cv-01067-MSK-CBS
Document 276
Filed 09/12/2008
Page 3 of 6
" + (- , . + . *
5 9 -*)*5+ + + .- -5
+ *8 5 + ( ,. ( 5+ * 8
. .
+ + * +* * +, .- 4 3 ( * - , * + ) 5 4 , * , 3( 3 A . + 8+ 4 *
*5+ 8) .+ +5< +5+ @ +) * +* - , * 8 .
" + (- , . + . *
5 9 - - + + &* + * + * + ) 8+ - -5 ( ,. ( 5+
* +, .- 4 3 ( - + + &* + * * + * + ) 8+ ) +) @ B = 7 9 - 8< + = ,* 8+ , * " + (- * .- 4 3 ( -5 . + , C 5 *+5 . * * * 7 + . (7 9 . (7 9 . . *+5< 5 . + *+5 . 9 -
5 4 , * , 3 ( - + + &* + * 3 + * + ) 8+
*5+ 8) .+ +5< +5+
* +
9, - . + )*
+ <
-5
( * 8< 5 *
- 9, . (
5+ + , * ,
*
8 . 3 5+ ,
+ *8 )
* -* ( + 5 +5 * <
9 - + (- *<" + ( * , . + , . 8+
9 . (- *< + , == => * 4 +< + - * = =? )+5 * = . (3 ++ * 53 ++ + , + * .( + )- 5 ).( * 4 +5 + 3 ( + - * . + 5+ -5 5 ( 5< " + ( * 8+ + . 5 " + ( * 8+ + . 5 5+ . (3 + + * 4 +< + - *
5+ . (- , . , * ,+)+ + + 9 4 3 @ * 5
3+ ) 55 6, 8+ (4 * + 4 ( 3 +5< * 5 + 9 9 - . ()+5 *
-*3 ( +5 + 5+ 5 * 4 - , .+
. 5 4+ 9 , *+ <
>
Case 1:04-cv-01067-MSK-CBS
Document 276
Filed 09/12/2008
Page 4 of 6
= + =A <
.(
9 - 9++ +
. ( * 5. + 8) +
* + 5 - 3
*
+ 8) .+ * * 5- (, + +5 + + 5
+ 8) .* + *+ 4 + 8) .+ +3 , + +
- * 33 7 * - * . @+ + 6 < + ++ + ) =B >
. ( 3 +< *+ - + 3 * ,5 * + 8 3 ++ + -. + 3 * + ** 5 .+ <
. (,5 7 5 8+ +, + + 5 5 -* . + - , + ++ 9 5 5+ <
4 + 8+ *
4 . , , 4 -5 + + > >= >> 4 5 5 5
) 55 3+ * + 8) .* 3 * ,5 + + ) 55 3+ * , , ( 3 * ,5 +
8 7 9 4 +5 + * , 8 7 9 4 +5 + * , ( , ,5 * 5+ 8
< < 4
" + ( * . 83 * . ( 8 . + . 8+ + * 3+ . + 5 < 9 9 * - *( - ++ + 85 + 5
,9 9 5 - ++ ( +
( 8+ < > ,5 * 8 *( 85 >? ) + 9 5 .( * > , 5 + * 8 + 8+ < " + (++ 3 + . *+ + , 5 ( 9 ++ (- , 8 7 -* . + , + * , 5< + ,9 9 5 + 5 " + (++ 3 + . *+ + -* 5 9 + * + 55 ,9 9 5 - ++ ( + 5) * + , + 4 5 + 4 * 5 5 < ( 8+ < + 4+ + 5 4 + 5 5 ,9 *4* 4 ++ + , 4, 9 9* - ++ +
. ( 9 * - + (++ - , * 7 . * . * 5- + . 5 , 5 <
9 9 * - *( - ++ + 85
5 3( 9 9 5 + 4- * - 3( ) * ( * + ( < ,. ( , , (
95 - 5 ( * -(< (
( + - 9 5 * -( ,9 ( 5<
4 + , . (3 ++ 5 +5. 8 7 - 5+ + 5 + * + + + ,
Case 1:04-cv-01067-MSK-CBS
Document 276
Filed 09/12/2008
Page 5 of 6
+ 5)+ ( . 3 + -5 = -, . 5( 8 ,
+ + + = ) 83 *
A % D *+ . " *+ . ( FFF 6 FFF ( 6 *+ . + + ) A = B >> B >> B G , + ( + * 5
" ! "# 55 5 . & 55 5 .
. 5E - 5 )- * ; * + - 5 )- * * + 55 5 . = @ + + * A = !+ + )- + = ; & 58 + = ; ,+ 4 4
?
Case 1:04-cv-01067-MSK-CBS
Document 276
Filed 09/12/2008
Page 6 of 6
- *3 + . ++ . *
+ + + = = ) 83 *
A
+ * +
+ E &5. + 9 -9 5+ , # 5 8 , *55+ ,+ 5; 8 *+ * 73+ ) G.8
. + - *4 4 , + + 9 - - +7 + * ( ( 4 * 5 5( 4 + 9 4 8 +
5E : +! ( ( *6 : +! ( ( *6 + - + + . + *
*+ .