Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 1 of 18
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO Civil Action No. 01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB M.D. MARK, INC., Plaintiff, v. KERR-McGEE CORPORATION and ORYX ENERGY COMPANY, Defendants. ______________________________________________________________________________ PLAINTIFF'S BILL OF COSTS ______________________________________________________________________________ Plaintiff, M.D. Mark, Inc. ("MD MARK"), by and through her attorneys, Pelz & Associates, P.C., files the following Bill of Costs: CERTIFICATION PURSUANT TO LOCAL RULE 7.1A Counsel for Plaintiff has attempted to confer with counsel for Defendants. Plaintiff's counsel paralegal conferred with Greg Goldberg regarding the filing of the Bill of Costs. It has taken an inordinate amount of time to prepare the Plaintiff's Bill of Costs. A copy of the Bill of Costs was provided to defense counsel on Thursday, October 4, 2007, but due to the deadline to file the Bill Costs, Plaintiff's counsel is filing the Bill of Costs on October 5, 2007. It is
believed that Plaintiff's counsel and the Defense counsel have agreed to continue discussing the Bill of Costs.
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 2 of 18
INTRODUCTION A prevailing party is entitled to recover costs against a defendant. Fed.R.Civ.P. Rule 54(d). The types of costs that are generally taxed in favor of the prevailing party in a federal litigation are set by statute 28 U.S.C. § 1920, 1923 and 1924. Fed.R.Civ.P. Rule 54(d) lists seven separate categories of costs specifically allowed and Form AO133 "Bill of Costs" lists nine separate categories of costs specifically allowed, plus one category of other costs allowed. The list of allowable costs is not exhaustive but merely illustrative of the costs the Court should consider. In many cases, the district court will also be precluded from denying costs merely because the prevailing party failed to pray for them in a pleading. Flynn v. AK Peters, Ltd., 377 F.3d 13, 26 (1st Cir. 2004) and Port of Stockton v. Western Bulk Carrier KS, 371 F.3d 1119, 1121-22 (9th Cir. 2004). The Circuits are not always uniform in their approaches to these various factions. Knology, Inc. v. Insight Commc'ns Co., 460 F.3d 722 (6th Cir. 2006). One Court of Appeals has explained that denying costs is "in the nature of a severe penalty" and, as such, the party opposing the taxing of costs will be obligated to offer a reason why the prevailing party ought to be "penalized" by a refusal of costs. Rodriguez v. Whiting Farms, Inc., 360 F.3d 1180, 1190-91 (10th Cir. 2004). Moreover, once the prevailing party demonstrates the amount of its costs and that they fall within an allowable category of taxable costs, the prevailing party enjoys the "strong presumption" that its costs will be awarded "in full measure". Concord Boat Corp. v. Brunswick Corp., 309 F.3d 494, 497-98 (8th Cir. 2002), mandate amended, 318 F.3d 1156 (8th Cir. 2003). A. CLERK AND OTHER FEES AS AUTHORIZED BY FED.R.CIV.P. RULE 54(D). EXHIBIT 1 Date 2-16-2001 Total Amount Description of Cost Statutory Filing Fee - Complaint $ $ Amount 191.00 191.00
B.
DEPOSITION EXPENSES FOR TRIAL AS AUTHORIZED BY FED.R.CIV.P. RULE 54(D).
Deposition expenses, when the transcript is received in evidence or was otherwise reasonably necessary for the trial (Smith v. Tenet Healthsys. SL, Inc., 436 F.3d 879, 889-90 (8th 2
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 3 of 18
Cir. 2006) and allowable deposition expenses may include costs for videotape depositions. BDT Prods., Inc. v. Lexmark Int'l, Inc., 405 F.3d 415, 419-20 (6th Cir. 2005). EXHIBIT 2 Date 4-11-2002 5-9-2002 5-20-2002 5-24-2007 5-28-2002 5-29-2002 5-30-2002 6-14-2002 6-18-2002 11-11-2002 11-11-2002 Description of Cost Deposition of Marilyn Davies Patterson Reporting & Video Service, Inc. Deposition of Thomas A. Russell Schaker Court Reporters Deposition of Glenn Morton Hazlett & Bowen Reporting Moye, Giles, O'Keefe, Vermeire & Gorrell, LLP Consultation with John E. Moye Deposition of David Christian Legalink Dallas/Stanley, Rice & Associates, Inc. Deposition of Carlos Salazar Legalink Dallas/Stanley, Rice & Associates, Inc. Deposition of Brian Lindsey Legalink Dallas/Stanley, Rice & Associates, Inc. Professional Civil Process Houston Service of Process of Subpoena for Deposition on Dan Hahn Deposition of Dan Hahn Legalink Dallas/Stanley, Rice & Associates, Inc. Deposition of Glenn Morton Hazlett & Bowen Reporting Bjork, Lindley, Danielson & Little, P.C. Conference with Peter A. Bjork, Esq. (Special Master); Peter A. Bjork, Esq.'s Attendance at the Deposition of Glenn Morton Moye, Giles, O'Keefe, Vermeire & Gorrell, LLP Preparation of John E. Moye's Expert Report Deposition of Jay Skinner Esquire Deposition Services 3 Amount 559.05 542.65 485.00 5,000.00 697.92 622.75 585.75 50.00 494.61 687.50 2,850.00
11-14-2002 1-16-2003
5,000.00 298.23
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 4 of 18
Date 1-16-2003 1-17-2003 1-30-2003
Description of Cost Deposition of Robert Quillin Esquire Deposition Services Deposition of Brian Lindsey Esquire Deposition Services Moye, Giles, O'Keefe, Vermeire & Gorrell, LLP Telephone conference with John E. Moye, John E. Moye's preparation for deposition and attendance at deposition Deposition of John E. Moye Attorneys Service Center, Inc. Deposition of Paul Schlirf - Esquire Deposition Services Deposition of Robert Lowe - Esquire Deposition Services Robert E. Lowe - Attendance at deposition Deposition of Tricia Dark Cherne Allied Advanced Reporting, Inc. Deposition of Marilyn Davies, Volume 2 Allied Advanced Reporting, Inc. Deposition of Robert Gray - Attorneys Service Center, Inc. Bjork, Lindley, Danielson & Little, P.C. Finalize Order re: Moye expert fees for deposition and serve and file the same Deposition of Patricia Horsfall - International Reporting, Inc. Deposition of Darren E. Helm Professional Reporters Video-Deposition of Marilyn Davies Attorneys Service Center, Inc. Deposition of Carlos Salazar Esquire Deposition Services 4
Amount 298.23 230.13
5,000.00 328.80
1-30-2003 2-27-2003 2-28-2003 2-28-2003 3-5-2003 3-5-2003 3-7-2003 4-14-2003
639.30 774.95 900.00 253.85 253.85 745.30
325.00 813.20 417.00 569.70 571.53
4-25-2003 5-8-2003 2-12-2004 3-11-2004
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 5 of 18
Date 3-11-2004 3-11-2004 3-11-2004 4-5-2004
Description of Cost Deposition of Tom Schultz Esquire Deposition Services Deposition Charges Exhibits for Carlos Salazar and Tom Schultz Esquire Deposition Services Meeting Rooms Fee March 11-12 Marriott Houston Central Oklahoma Legal Services Service of Process on Mid-Con Data Services and Darren Helm for Subpoena for Deposition Deposition of Marilyn Davies, Vol. II Attorneys Service Center, Inc. Deposition of Marilyn Young Esquire Deposition Services Deposition of Marilyn Davies Esquire Deposition Services Video-Deposition of Ann Lane Hazlett & Bowen Reporting Moye White LLP John E. Moye's Supplemental Expert Report Official Court Reporter Therese Lindblom Court reporter for trial - Deposit Official Court Reporter Therese Lindblom Court reporter for trial (9/17-9/26/07) $
Amount 571.52 29.50 655.59 100.00
4-6-2004 4-15-2004 4-23-2004 5-25-2004 8-29-2006 9-17-2007 9-27-2007 Total Amount
241.00 516.06 250.00 1,377.50 850.00 2,500.00 2,001.20 38,788.44
5
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 6 of 18
C.
PRINTING FEES AS AUTHORIZED BY FED.R.CIV.P. RULE 54(D). EXHIBIT 3 Date Description of Cost Color copies and binding Kinko's. 25 copies at $.75 each ($18.75 + tax: $1.45) Preparation of exhibit notebooks for usage at trial. Black and white photocopies and binding at Kinko's. 1,524 copies at $.12 each ($182.88), 1 copy at $121.92 each ($91.44), Tabs 1 tab at $5.90 each ($5.90), Drilling 350 copies at $.01 each ($3.50), Binding 48 copies at $.05 each ($2.40), Oversize 2 copies at $3.00 each ($6.00) and Bond 8 copies at $.75 each (6.00) Preparation of exhibit notebooks Vol. 1, 2 and 3 for use at trial. Copies of Exhibits. Additional set of copies of exhibits. Oversize color copies of maps used as exhibits for trial Marathon Document Solutions, Inc. 11 copies at $8.99 each ($98.89 + tax: $7.63) Preparation of exhibit notebooks for usage at trial. Preparation of 12 juror exhibit notebooks for trial National Legal. Copies of exhibits for trial. Color copies for trial Kinko's. Color copies for trial Kinko's. Copies during trial. Copies during trial. Copy charges during trial-in house- September 2007 6 Amount 20.20
8/16/07
8/31/07
308.31 551.75 262.00
8/31/07 8/31/07 9/13/07
106.52
9/13/07
4,045.26 34.51 19.17 26.77 22.95 758.25
9/19/07 9/21/07 9/26/07 9/26/07 9/30/07
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 7 of 18
Date 9/30/07 9/30/07 Total Amount
Description of Cost Copy charges during trial-in house- September 2007 Color copies of deposition designations used at trial Kinko's. $
Amount 683.75 398.82 7,238.26
D.
WITNESS FEES AND EXPENSES AS AUTHORIZED BY FED.R.CIV.P. RULE 54(D).
Witness fees and witnesses' travel and subsistence expenses, where the witnesses' testimony was material, relevant, and reasonably necessary to the case are taxed in favor of the prevailing party in a federal litigation. Marmo v. Tyson Fresh Meats, Inc., 457 F.3d 748 (8th Cir. 2006).
EXHIBIT 4 Date 7-27-2007 7-31-2007 9-11-2007 9-14-2007 9-26-2007 9-30-2007 9-30-2007 9-30-2007 Total Amount Description of Cost Trial Witness Fee Expense Ann Lane Magnum-Diego Priority Services Service of Process for Trial Subpoena to Ann Lane Trial Witness Fee Expense Robert Gray Witness subsistence Leon Herzog accommodations (9/16/07-9/19/07) Witness subsistence Marilyn Davies lodging during trial Expert Witness Fee for Trial John E. Moye Airfare for Witness - Leon Herzog Airfare for Witness Marilyn Davies $ Amount 75.00 172.00 20.00 696.98 1,045.14 5,000.00 488.83 1,650.00 9,147.95
7
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 8 of 18
E.
FEES FOR EXEMPLIFICATION, COPIES OF PAPERS NECESSARILY OBTAINED FOR USE IN THE CASE AND PRINT COPIES OF PAPERS AS AUTHORIZED BY FED.R.CIV.P. RULE 54(D).
Fees to "exemplify" documents (which may include reimbursement for many methods of illustration, including models, charts, graphs, and sometimes even computerized presentation systems) are taxed in favor of the prevailing party in a federal litigation. Cefalu v. Village of Elk Grove, 211 F.3d 416, 427-28 (7th Cir. 2000). Fees to print copies of papers necessary for use in the case (BDT Prods., Inc. v. Lexmark Int'l, Inc., 405 F.3d 415, 419-20 (6th Cir. 2005) (which may, in appropriate circumstances, include the electronic scanning and imaging of documents) are taxed in favor of the prevailing party in a federal litigation. EXHIBIT 5 Date 12-7-2001 12-13-2001 12-26-2001 2-28-2002 5-16-2002 10-18-2002 11-15-2002 12-13-2002 1-13-2003 2-7-2003 4-30-2003 5-30-2003 11-13-2003 Description of Cost i-Legal, Inc. imaging, scanning, OCR, label and code Copy Corps Legal Document Support Sys. Copy Corps Legal Documents Support Sys bates numbering i-Legal, Inc. Scan/OCR/Date Code i-Legal, Inc. Scan/OCR/Electronic Bates/Blowbacks i-Legal, Inc. Scan/OCR and Date Code i-Legal, Inc. Scan & OCR i-Legal, Inc. Scan, OCR, Date Code (KM Series) i-Legal, Inc. additional CDs i-Legal, Inc. KM Series, scanning, OCR and Electronic Bates labeling i-Legal, Inc. Scanning, OCR, date code KM series i-Legal, Inc. Scan & OCR i-Legal, Inc. Scanning & OCR, Bates Labeling, Blowbacks 8 Amount 506.62 18.76 53.45 266.30 470.64 687.83 720.44 282.96 53.93 310.58 305.86 62.55 346.91
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 9 of 18
Date 1-23-2004 3-16-2004 3-16-2004 9-30-2004 10-31-2004 11-30-2004 12-31-2004 1-31-2005 3-1-2005 3-31-2005 9-15-2006 3-15-2007 9-26-2007 9-30-2007
Description of Cost i-Legal, Inc. Scanning & OCR i-Legal, Inc. Scanning & OCR i-Legal, Inc. KM Series Scanning and OCR Zara Media design and production of graphic projects Zara Media design, production of graphic projects Zara Media Design of Graphic Projects Zara Media Design and production of Graphic Projects Zara Media Graphic Projects Zara Media Design of Graphic Projects February 2005 Zara Media Graphic Projects Zara Media Production of graphic projects National Legal Litigation copies Zara Media Multi-media presentation re: trial Courtroom Technologies, Etc., John Kinsler Technical Assistance at Trial scanning of exhibits, create powerpoint exhibits for opening and closing and attend trial $
Amount 146.14 151.26 30.20 543.75 2,306.25 3,130.45 581.25 1,443.75 356.25 2,010.00 450.00 41.77 168.27 7,921.40
Total Amount
23,367.57
9
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 10 of 18
F.
COSTS INCIDENT TO TAKING OF DEPOSITIONS AS AUTHORIZED BY FED.R.CIV.P. RULE 54(D).
EXHIBIT 6 Date 4-11-2002 Description of Cost Mileage expense pick up client, Marilyn Davies, from the Denver International Airport for her deposition on 4/11/02 Parking expense - pick up client, Marilyn Davies, from the Denver International Airport for her deposition on 4/11/02 Car Rental San Antonio, TX for the deposition of Thomas A. Russell on 5/9/02 Lodging San Antonio, TX for the deposition of Thomas A. Russell on 5/9/02 Parking expense Denver International Airport while in San Antonio, TX for the deposition of Thomas A. Russell on 5/9/02 Parking expense Denver International Airport while in Houston, TX for the deposition of Carlos Salazar on 5/29/02 Lodging Houston, TX and Dallas, TX for the deposition of David Christian on 5/28/07 and the deposition of Carlos Salazar on 5/29/02 Parking expenses Houston, TX - Renaissance Building - for the deposition of David Christian on 5/28/07 and the deposition of Carlos Salazar on 5/29/02 Gasoline expense Houston, TX Airfare, hotel and rental car for the deposition of Dan Hahn on 6/18/02 Dan Bonifazi, Esq. Advantage rental car for the deposition of Dan Hahn on 6/18/02 Harlan Pelz, Esq. 10 $ Amount 22.10
4-11-2002
7.00
5-8-2002 5-8-2002 5-8-2002
69.31 92.23 58.00
5-27-2002
47.00
5-27-2002
255.61
5-29-2002
64.00
5-30-2002 6-13-2002 6-17-2002
1.62 480.00 41.39
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 11 of 18
Date 6-17-2002 6-18-2002 6-18-2002 6-18-2002 11-19-2002 11-19-2002 11-19-2002 11-19-2002 1-14-2003 1-15-2003
Description of Cost Taxi Dallas, TX- for the deposition of Dan Hahn on 6/18/02 Harlan Pelz, Esq. Hotel Houston, TX - for the deposition of Dan Hahn on 6/18/02- Harlan Pelz, Esq. Gasoline expense, rental car Houston, TX- for the deposition of Dan Hahn on 6/18/02 Parking expense Denver International Airport - for the deposition of Dan Hahn on 6/18/02 Airfare to Houston, TX for the deposition of Glenn Morton on 11/11/02 Lodging in Houston, TX for the deposition of Glenn Morton on 11/11/02 Parking expense Denver International Airport for the deposition of Glenn Morton on 11/11/02 Dollar Rental Car - Houston, TX for the deposition of Glenn Morton on 11/11/02 Airfare to Fort Worth, TX for the deposition of Jay Skinner and Robert Quillin on 1/16/03 Travel from airport to hotel - Fort Worth, TX for the deposition of Jay Skinner and Robert Quillin on 1/16/03 Transportation from airport in TX for the deposition of Jay Skinner and Robert Quillin on 1/16/03 Parking expense - Denver International Airport for the deposition of Jay Skinner and Robert Quillin on 1/16/03 Lodging - Dallas, TX for the deposition of Jay Skinner on 1/16/03 Airfare to/from San Antonio and Houston for the deposition of Brian Lindsey on 1/17/03
Amount 54.50 168.73 5.34 30.00 243.50 666.38 34.00 206.95 604.00 20.00
1-16-2003 1-16-2003
9.95 44.00
1-16-2003 1-16-2003
88.64 519.50
11
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 12 of 18
Date 1-29-2003
Description of Cost Parking expense Denver International Airport for the deposition of Jay Skinner and Robert Quillin on 1/16/03 Lodging San Antonio, TX for the deposition of Jay Skinner and Robert Quillin on 1/16/03 Frontier Airlines travel to/from Houston, TX for the deposition of Paul Schlirf on 2/27/03 and Robert Lowe on 2/28/03 Hertz Rental Car Houston, TX for the deposition of Paul Schlirf on 2/27/03 and Robert Lowe on 2/28/03 Marriott Houston, TX for the deposition of Paul Schlirf on 2/27/03 and Robert Lowe on 2/28/03 Parking expense Denver International Airport for the deposition of Paul Schlirf on 2/27/03 and Robert Lowe on 2/28/03 Frontier Airlines travel to/from Houston, TX for the deposition of Tricia Dark Cherne on 3/5/03 and Marilyn Davies on 3/5/03 Thrifty Car Rental Houston, TX for the deposition of Tricia Dark Cherne on 3/5/03 and Marilyn Davies on 3/5/03 Parking expense Denver International Airport for the deposition of Tricia Dark Cherne on 3/5/03 and Marilyn Davies on 3/5/03 Marriott Hotel Houston, TX for the deposition of Tricia Dark Cherne on 3/5/03 and Marilyn Davies on 3/5/03 United Airlines airfare Calgary for the deposition of Patricia Horsfall on 4/25/03 Parking expense Denver International Airport for the deposition of Patricia Horsfall on 4/25/03
Amount 30.00
1-29-2003 2-24-2003
127.26 213.50
2-26-2003 2-26-2003 3-1-2003
366.62 600.78 62.00
3-3-2003
193.50
3-5-2003
164.54
3-5-2003
30.00
3-5-2003
55.82
4-18-2003 4-22-2003
1,716.12 45.00
12
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 13 of 18
Date 4-22-2003 4-25-2003 4-25-2003 5-6-2003 5-7-2003 5-7-2003 5-7-2003 5-8-2003 2-12-2004 2-12-2004 3-11-2004 3-11-2004
Description of Cost Travel expenses transportation - Alberta for the deposition of Patricia Horsfall on 4/25/03 Parking for the deposition of Patricia Horsfall on 4/25/03 Lodging Sandman Hotel, Calgary for the deposition of Patricia Horsfall on 4/25/03 Parking expense Denver International Airport for the deposition of Darren E. Helm on 5/8/03 Taxi for the deposition of Darren E. Helm on 5/8/03 Airfare to/from Oklahoma City for the deposition of Darren E. Helm on 5/8/03 Lodging Renaissance Hotel for the deposition of Darren E. Helm on 5/8/03 Taxi for the deposition of Darren E. Helm on 5/8/03 Mileage expense for the video-deposition of Marilyn Davies on 2/12/04 Dan Bonifazi, Esq. Parking expense for the video-deposition of Marilyn Davies on 2/12/04 Dan Bonifazi, Esq. Rental car Texas - for the deposition of Carlos Salazar and Tom Schultz on 3/11/04 Lodging Marriott, Houston, TX Meeting rooms for the deposition of Carlos Salazar and Tom Schultz on 3/11/04 Airfare Denver to Texas for the deposition of Marilyn Davies on 4/6/04 Fuel Rental Car for the deposition of Marilyn Davies on 4/6/04 Enterprise Rental Car San Antonio, TX - for the deposition of Marilyn Davies on 4/6/04
Amount 87.52 29.00 70.77 30.00 20.00 286.50 158.06 20.00 8.16 10.00 210.05 448.64
3-24-2004 4-6-2004 4-7-2004
429.70 15.91 71.23
13
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 14 of 18
Date 4-12-2004 4-13-2004 4-15-2004 4-15-2004
Description of Cost Airfare Denver to Oklahoma City - for the deposition of Marilyn Young on 4/15/04 Taxi - for the deposition of Marilyn Young on 4/15/04 Taxi - for the deposition of Marilyn Young on 4/15/04 Taxi to the airport and from the airport - for the deposition of Marilyn Young on 4/15/04 Harlan Pelz, Esq. Taxi to airport in Oklahoma City and from airport in Denver - for the deposition of Marilyn Young on 4/15/04 Lodging - Oklahoma City - for the deposition of Marilyn Young on 4/15/04 Lodging Meeting Room at Renaissance Hotel - for the deposition of Marilyn Young on 4/15/04 Airfare to/from Houston, TX - for the deposition of Marilyn Davies on 4/23/04 Parking expense Denver International Airport - for the deposition of Marilyn Davies on 4/23/04 Fuel for rental car Houston, TX - for the deposition of Marilyn Davies on 4/23/04
Amount 439.70 20.00 40.00 40.00
4-15-2004
40.00
4-15-2004 4-17-2004 4-21-2004 4-23-2004 4-23-2004 Total Amount
163.37 363.61 423.70 30.00 9.10 $10,903.91
14
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 15 of 18
G.
OTHER COSTS: DELIVERY SERVICE/FEDERAL EXPRESS AND SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE (ITEMIZE), AS AUTHORIZED BY FED.R.CIV.P. RULE 54(D).
EXHIBIT 7 Date 12-26-2001 5-20-2002 5-23-2002 5-28-2002 6-18-2002 10-18-2002 11-8-2002 1-6-2003 1-7-2003 1-8-2003 1-17-2003 2-7-2003 2-10-2003 2-14-2003 3-4-2003 3-13-2003 Description of Cost Delivery Charges US District Court (2), Attorney Hammond and Judge Boland Delivery Charges, DE Express, Robert Gray (expert) Delivery Charges, DE Express, US District Court Delivery Charges, DE Express, Clerk, US District Court Delivery Charges, DE Express - US District Court Delivery Charges, DE Express John Moye (expert) Delivery Charges, DE Express John Moye (expert) Delivery Charges, DE Express John Moye (expert) Delivery Charges, DE Express - Robert Gray (expert) Delivery Charges, DE Express, Federal Court Delivery Charges, DE Express, i-Legal Delivery Charges, DE Express - Robert Gray (expert) Delivery Charges, DE Express Clerk of the US, District Court Delivery Charges, DE Express - Robert Gray (expert) Delivery Charges, DE Express - Robert Gray (expert) Delivery Charges, Federal Express from Allied Advanced Reporting-Deposition transcripts of Tricia Dark Cherne and Marilyn Davies (3/5/03) Delivery Charges, DE Express John Moye (expert) 15 $ Amount 38.00 8.00 8.00 16.00 28.00 14.00 8.00 8.00 10.00 20.00 18.00 8.00 8.00 10.00 10.00 27.97
5-6-2003
8.00
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 16 of 18
Date 7-2-2003 8-19-2003 10-23-2003 11-20-2003 11-21-2003 1-23-2004 4-2-2004 4-26-2004 6-17-2004 6-21-2004 6-25-2004 9-14-2004 1-26-2005 3-23-2005 10-19-2006
Description of Cost Delivery Charges, DE Express,- US Courthouse, Denver Delivery Charges Allstar Courier Express - John Moye (expert) Delivery Charges Allstar Courier Express - US Courthouse, Denver Delivery Charges Blast! Express Inc. from John Moye (expert) Delivery Charges Blast! Express Inc. Special Master Bjork Delivery Charges Blast! Express Inc. USDC, Clerk, Denver Filing Fees Central Oklahoma Legal Service Process Fees Delivery Charges to John Moye (expert) Delivery Charges USDC, Denver, CO Delivery Charges US District Court - Denver Delivery Charges US District Court Delivery Charges Zara Media Delivery Charges Mazon Assoc Blast! Express Inc JAG Delivery Charges Mazon Assoc Blast! Express Inc JAG Transcript Motion Hearing on 9/14/06 on Defendants' Motion to Strike Plaintiff's Supplement to 2003 Expert Report filed 9/11/06 Mileage expense - mediation Parking expense - mediation 16
Amount 8.00 9.15 10.50 10.50 12.20 9.15 100.00 12.20 11.13 12.93 12.93 13.52 12.93 13.30 140.80
2-7-2007 2-7-2007
7.76 10.00
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 17 of 18
Date 3-5-2007 6-27-2007 9-13-2007 9-15-2007 9-26-2007 9-29-2007 9-30-2007 Total Amount
Description of Cost Other Professional Trial Supplies Other Professional Judicial Arbiter Group Settlement Conference Delivery Charges Federal Court House Trial Supplies Office Max Trial Supplies Trial Supplies Trial Supplies Office Max $ BILL OF COSTS TOTAL:
Amount 161.55 784.00 21.65 61.32 52.79 32.98 499.92 2,269.18 $ 91,906.31
DATED:
October 5, 2007. Respectfully submitted, PELZ & ASSOCIATES, P.C. s/ Harlan P. Pelz Harlan P. Pelz Daniele W. Bonifazi 1873 South Bellaire Street, Suite 1401 Denver, CO 80222 Telephone: 303-691-5600 Facsimile: 303-691-5606 ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
17
Case 1:01-cv-00413-JLK-BNB
Document 270-2
Filed 10/05/2007
Page 18 of 18
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on the 5th day of October, 2007, a true and correct copy of the foregoing PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO AMEND THE JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO FRCP 59(e) was faxed and placed in the United States Mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Scott S. Barker, Esq. Gregory E. Goldberg, Esq. HOLLAND & HART, LLP 555 Seventeenth Street, Suite 3200 Post Office Box 8749 Denver, CO 80201-8749 303/295-8261 Fax s/ Allison E. Goldstein_____ Allison E. Goldstein
18