Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 1 of 12
EXHIB
IT 12
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 2 of 12
EXHIBIT 12
Objections to Counter Designations
LAKE BARRETT
Counter Desi2nation
Objection
Incomplete , no objection iftr. 120:22- 121:7 is included Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay
April 22, 2002
121:8137:17-
May 8, 2002 1044: 1- 1064:22
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; excessive (20) pages Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay
Incomplete , no obiection iftr. 66:18- 20 is included No objection No objection No objection Incomplete , no objection iftr. 125:23- 25 is included No objection No objection
May 10, 2002
1152:20 - 1154:22
May 14 , 2002 66:21 - 67:14
69:8 - 70:8
72:19 - 73:9
87:7126:1 - 132:13
134:19 - 135:22
143:12 - 144:13
May 15, 2002 363:25 - 364:19
No objection
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 3 of 12
RONALD MILNER
Counter Designation
Objection
No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection Beyond the scope of the original
designations/inadmissible hearsay; designation should include tr. 310: 19- 311 :22 for completeness.
May 1, 2002 68:25 - 69:12
107:22- 108:25 132:2- 133:4 139: 11- 139:25 140:15- 140:24
May 2, 2002 301:10- 310:18
304:5- 304: 15
305:2- 305:22 317:24- 318:21 325:24- 326:7 330:23- 332:24 391:13- 392:17
393 :5- 394: 19
396:2- 397:2 May 3, 2002 417:11- 418:16 419:1- 419:14 435:16- 436:5 440:13- 441:2 441:21- 443:8 443:16- 444:8 448:2- 448:8
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection
No objection
No objection No objection No objection No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 466:1- 5 is included No objection No objection No objection No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 496:9- 25 is included No objection No objection No objection No objection
450:12- 451:18 454:11- 455:22
465: 14- 465 :25
475:8- 476:15 486:12- 486:20 487:12- 448:5 488:14- 489:10 493:4- 496:8 506:7- 507:7 512:5- 512:15 513:2- 513:21 514:4- 514:13
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 4 of 12
RONALD MILNER CONT'
514:22- 515:18
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay
May 7, 2002
No objection
592:14- 592:19
2002 6:9- 10:18
May 7,
No objection No objection No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 40:5- 11 is included Incomplete; no objection iftr. 42:2- 5 is included Incomplete; no objection iftr. 43:9- 44:24 is included
32:21- 33:24 38: 1 0- 40:3 40:12- 40:19 41:8- 42:1 42:6- 43:8 May 8, 2002 52:8- 53:19
56:23- 59: 19 61:18- 62:15 73:10- 73:24
77:3- 77:20
Incomplete; no objection iftr. 53:20- 56:21 is included Incomplete; no objection iftr. 53:20- 56:21 is included Incomplete; no objection iftr. 59:21- 61: 17 is included No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 106:1- 6 is included Beyond the scope ofthe original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; also incomplete; would require IT. 139:1No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 203:5- 25 is included
90:7- 90:24 98:8- 98:19 99:8- 100:3
100: 18- 1 02: 1
103:1- 105:24 106:7- 106:20
136:17- 137:8
138:6- 138:25
174:5- 175:11 184:17- 186:11 193:13- 194:20 196:8- 196:24 197:23- 198:4 202:15- 203:4
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 5 of 12
RONALD MILNER CONT'D
204:1- 207:12
208:7- 209:5
210:2- 211:7
211:24- 216:2 220:14- 220:24 233:7- 234:9 256:11- 257:10 271 :23- 272:3 272:14- 273:4 279:10- 280:3 280:12-281:2
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; also incomplete; would require tr. 207:13- 208:5 Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; also incomplete; would require tr. 209:6Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 221:1- 16 is included No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 281:3- 6 is included
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 6 of 12
SUSAN KLEIN
Counter Designation
iection
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay
April 24, 2002
57:10-
April 25, 2002
354: 17~355:13
435:16- 438:22 451:18- 452:18 468:11- 469:3 440:20- 448:1 490:13- 492:9
Beyond the scope ofthe original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection No objection No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 492:10- 12 is included
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 7 of 12
ALAN BROWNSTEIN
Counter Designation
iection
No objection No objection No objection No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection Incomplete , no objection iftr. 117:19- 118:10 is included No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; also incomplete; would require tr. 193:22- 194:4
No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection No objection Incomplete , no objection iftr. 443:3- 9 & tr. 444:9- 14 is included
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original
designations/inadmissible hearsay; excessive designation;
April 9, 2002 54:1 - 55:20
59:1- 61:6 62:24- 64:21 75:19- 77:19 79:488:5- 89:8 115:14- 117:18 132:18- 133:2 194:4- 197:17
April 10, 2002 294:7- 295:19 319:19- 320:11
391:18- 393:2 395:16- 398:24 412:5443:10-444:8
April 11, 2002
547:5-
549:7- 552:14 554:25- 556:25 562:4- 564: 17
564: 18- 576:2
582: 13- 583: 14
585:16- 588:10
595:19- 597:1
599:1- 601:25
designated testimony concerns hearsay within hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; incomplete , would require tr. 583:16- 585:15 Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; also incomplete; would require IT. 583:16- 585:15 Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 8 of 12
ALAN BROWNSTEIN CONT'D
623:10- 626:4
637:4- 640:14
696:24- 698:1
724:25- 725 :24
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection
May 23, 2002 20:323:14- 24:10 25:4- 28:12 33:17- 37:19
110:14- 113:8 140:3140:15195:21- 196:15 226:1- 229:11
June 14, 2002
No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection
253:19- 255:10 287:21- 288:1 295:6- 298:5 308:6317:11- 320:24 395:14- 397:24 422:24- 424:3 437:10- 438:7
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 9 of 12
ROBERT CAMPBELL
Counter Desi2nation
Objection
No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection
No objection No objection No objection No objection No objection
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Incomplete , no objection iftr. 118:13- 21 is included
June 13, 2002 19:17- 21:1 59:18- 60:3 76:11- 77:21 80:8- 81:1
87:5- 88:22 95:25- 96:11 113:17- 114:15 June 14, 2002 392:12- 393:9 396:19- 397:9 412:23- 413:16 January 29, 2003 565:14632:8-
May 6, 2004 81:18- 83:21
115:3- 118:12
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 10 of 12
NANCY SLATER- THOMPSON
Counter Desi2nation
Objection
Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection No objection
April 21, 1999
54:19 - 58:7
68:1068:24- 70: 17
73:19- 74:13
82:1082:18- 83:10
130:5- 130: 19
132:18- 133:24 133:25- 135:12
164:23- 165:13
176: 11-
195:16- 199:9 April 22 1999 212:1- 214:10 214:11- 215:1 220:7- 221:3 225:25- 226:24 230: 17- 231:4 237:15- 239:3
245:17- 246:4 251:23- 253:10 253:22- 254:11 257:23- 259:24 265:4- 268:21
No objection No objection No objection Incomplete; no objection iftr. 226:25- 227:2 is included No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection No objection No objection No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; designated testimony concerns hearsay within hearsay No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay
June 13, 2002
43:21- 44:12 61:18- 62:20
87:24- 89:4
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 11 of 12
NANCY SLA
TER- THOMPSON CONT'D
No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection Beyond the scope ofthe original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay No objection to IT. 149:9 - 153:14 Tr. 153:15- 21 is beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay; contains hearsay within hearsay No objection
92: 19- 93 :20
114:13- 117:18
119:4- 119:17
125: 18- 126: 15
131:12138:4- 139:2 145:11149:9- 153:21
158:18- 160:3
160:18- 162:11
Case 1:98-cv-00126-JFM
Document 856-14
Filed 09/03/2004
Page 12 of 12
VICTOR TREBULES
Counter Desi nation April 17, 2002 42:10 - 45:17
52:11 - 54:4
Ob . ection
93:18 - 96:18
97:1 - 103:22
113:18 - 116:14
Beyond the scope of the original desi ations/inadmissible hearsa Beyond the scope of the original desi ations/inadmissib1e hears a Beyond the scope of the original designations/inadmissible hearsay Beyond the scope of the original desi ations/inadmissible hearsa Beyond the scope of the original
desi ations/inadmissible hears a desi ations/inadmissible hears a
122:10:124:18
146:12 - 148:1
Beyond the scope of the original
Beyond the scope of the original desi ations/inadmissible hearsa Beyond the scope of the original desi ations/inadmissible hearsa Beyond the scope of the original desi ations/inadmissible hearsa No objection Beyond the scope of the original desi ations/inadmissible hearsa No ob' ection
No ob" ection
April 18,
2002 268:4 - 270:8
273:12 - 274:14
302:10 - 306:16 381:5 - 382:14
39:5- 22 afternoon session 2002 April 19,
5:21 - 8:19