Free Motion for Summary Judgment - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 1 of 14

Defendant's Exhibit C

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 2 of 14

.

perUSDA-Forëst Servi.cë
TERM GRAZING PERMIT - PARTS

FS.2200-1Q (9/85)

Page

1

of

1 AND 2

Permittee Number
02281 Permit Number 08-1250

(Reference FSM 2230)

PART

1

Sacramento Grazing Association

of

P.o.

Box 596

hereinafter

Wee, NM 88354 (Post Office Address, Including Zip) (Name of Permitee) authorized to graze livestock owned by the permitee upon designated lands called the permittee, is hereby Lincoln (X appropriate box) administered by the Forest Service within the under the following terms and conditions: National Grassland XNational Forest ( L
1. Description of range. The livestock shall be

grazed only upon the area described as follows: àeeerieed

-e ei"eiel ¡eel "a~e a"tl/or delineated on the attached map dated A/~vem be 2-' ¡ elwhich is part of this permit. (Strike out item or items not applicable.) - ,
2. The number, kind, and class of livestock, period of use, and grazing allotment on which the livestock are

permitted to graze are as follows, unless modified by the Forest Service in the Bil for Collection:
LIVESTOCK

NUMBER

KIND

CLASS
C1C

PERIOD OF USE TO FROM

GRAZING ALLOTMENT

.

553

Cattle

03/01

02128

Sacramento #217

3. It is fully understood and agreed that this permit may be suspended or cancelled, in whole or in part, after written notice, for failure to comply with any of the terms and conditions specified in Parts 1, 2, and 3 hereof, or or the instructions of Forest any of the regulations of the Secretary of Agriculture on which this permit is based, oficers issued thereunder; or for knowingly and wilingly making a false statement or representation in the
permittee's grazing application, and amendments thereto; or for conviction laws or regulations or State and local

for failure to comply with Federal

laws relating to livestock control and to protection of air, water, soils and vegetation, fish and wildlife, and other environmental values when exercising the grazing use authorized by the whole or Jnpart orQtherWìsemddífed,atany time-during tlìe permit. This permit canarso be cancelled. in about bylaw. regL,!a,t1.o;Execufíveorder; allotment brought term to conform with needap charigøi; mariagement plans, land man.agement planning,numbers permitted or ?easpns of use necessary because of

resource condiHons. Or1he lardsde-st;ribedother.vìse being un3vailà.ble for grazing. Any suspension or
cancellation action may be appeated pursuånt to 36 CFR 251, Subpart C.

4. This permit supersedes permit (8)

November 27,1989

. to

Sacramento Grazing

issued
I HAVE REVIEWED AND ACCEPT THE TERMS OF

Association
THIS PERMIT
DATE

;¡

(/ ~;t r~~ _-.J J¿. .... VII" IP l'

dT~RE OF PERMitTEE OR HIS AUTHORIZIËD AGENT NAME (PRINT) flEST OFFtCER

" - § ~(l-l Yl

ii /Z3)¡'1
TITLE

Max E. Goodwin

District Ranaer

~rh3A1 7 I

1 HAVE REEW TMEPRVISIONS Of nu
?e~M)lJNCLUD!~G. THE ALLOTMENT ..li

Â~ ?eTHE~MlnEEï''' :;.. ,1q .. ..'" ,,-,,'. ; /Ç"I)--IU.;..;o.... /i.lr;;,'

srnatu801 Fo Of Ða
.,

8004304

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 3 of 14

.

PART 2 - GENERAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS
1. Validation

of Permit. The issuance of a Bill for Collection and payment Of fees and actual turning on at

least 90 percent of livestock the first grazing season after the permit is issued wil validate this permit for the
number, kind, and class of livestock, grazing allotment, and period of use for the particular year.
2. Bil for Collection. Each year, after validation and prior to the beginning of the grazing season, the Forest
Service will send the permittee a Bil year the kind, number, and class of use, the grazing allotment, and the grazing fees. This bill, when paid, authorizes use for that year and becomes part ofthis permit. for Collection specifying for the current

of livestock allowed to graze, the period

3. Payment of Fees.

The permittee wil not allow owned or controlled livestock to be on Forest Service~

administered lands unless the fees specified in the Bil for Collection are paid.
4. Administrative monies that Otset anr. Credit Reporting. Pursuant to are payable or may become

payable from the United States, under

31 USC 371Sand CFRPart 3, Subpart B, any this permit, to any person or

legal entit not an agency or subdivision of a State or local government may be subject to administrative offset
for the collection of a delinquent debt the person or legal entity OWes to the United States. Information on the. person's or legal entity's responsibilty for a commercial debt or delinquent consumer debt owed the United
States

shall be disclosed to consumer orctedit reporting agencies.

5. Interest, Penalty, and Administrative Costs. Pursuant to 31 USC 3717 and 7 CFR Part 3, Subpart B,

interest shall be charged on any payment or fee amount not paid within 30 days from the date the payment was due. Interèst shall be charged using the most current rate prescribed by the United States Deparment of the Treasury Fiscal Requirements Manual (TFRM-S-a020.20). Interest shall accrue from the date the payment was due~ In addition, in the event the account becomes delinquent, administrative costs may be assessed. A penalty of S percent per year shall be assessed on any payment or fee amount overdue in excess of 90 days from the date the first billng was due. Payments wil be credited on the date received by above payments falls on a the designated collection officer or deposit loction. If the due date(s) for any of the the charges shall not apply until the close of business on the next workday. non-workday,
6. Term of Permit. This permit

is effective until Novell be,rZ.~.i~nless waived, cancelled, or otherwise
end of the term Subject to modification deemed necessary by the Forest Service.

unless waived, cancelled, or otherwise terminated as provided herein. The pèrmittee has first prionty for
receipt of a new permit at the

In orderto update terms and conditions, this permit may be cancelled at the

end of the midyear of each

decade, beginning with 1995, provided ¡tis reissued to the existing permit holder for a new term of 10 years.
7. Ownership Requirement
permit. the permittee wil furnish all evidence çf ownership requested

use of the by the Forest Service. Livestock purchased and subsequently sold back to the original owner, or to an agent, assignee, or anyone representing 24.month period without prior written approval by the or acting in concert with the original owner, within a Forest officer in charge will not be considered valid ownership of the livestock.
(a) Only livestock owned by the permittee areauthonzep to graze under this permit. To exercise

(b) Base propert owned and used by the permittee to ciualify for a term grazing permit must meet minimum base propert requirements approved by the officer in charge.

Page 2 of.1

SG04305

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 4 of 14

. Range and Livestock Management e. 8.(a) The allotment management plan for the land deScribed on page 1, Part 1 is part of the permit, and the permittee wil carry out its provisions, other instructions, or both as issued by the Forest officer in charge for the area under permit and wil rei:Uire employees, agents, and coJ'ractorsand subcontractors do likewise.
(b) Tle number,kJnd, andclas,so.f HyesIocl(, periOd of\,se,andgraiinRaltoiment specified in the permit may ForestOnícer in charge!o be needed for resource protection. Except in

be modlfedwhen de.!erlT¡he.d by the

extreme emergencies where resource conditiO'ns are: being seriously affected by livestock use or other factors, of a scheduled reduction of numoers of livestock or period of such as fire, droughtior insect damage, notice. given one (1) full year before a modification in permitted numbers or period of use under a term permit will be use becomes effective, This does not apply to annual adjustment in grazing as provided for in Section8(c).
(c) When, in the

judgment of the Forest Officer in charge, the forage is not ready to be grazed at the beginning

of the designated grazing season, the permittee, upon request of the Forest officer, wil defer placing livestock on the grazing allotment to avoid damage to the resources. The permittee wil remove livestock from Forest
grazing season upon request of the Forest Service-administered lands before the expiration of the designated officer when it is apparent that further grazing wil damage the resources.
of livestock on the allotment during the period including any modifications made as provided for in in greater numbers, to be grazing on the allotment Section 8(c). If livestock owned by the permittee are found on theanhual Bil for Collection, the or specified or places other than permitted In Part 1 hereof, or at times unauthorized use rate and may face suspension or cancellation permittee shall be billed for excess use at the of this permit
(d) The permittee wil allow only the numbers, kind, and class specified iii Part 1 hereof or the annual Sil for COUection, (e) The permittee wil not allow owned or controlled livestock to be upon any area of

Forest Service-

administered lands not described in

either Part 1 hereof or the annual Bil for Collecion.

charge may, at anytime, place orfastén or require the permittee to place or fasten appropriate marks or tags that will identify them as livestock permited to graze on lands administered by the Forest Service. When requested by the FOri3st officer, the permittee Wil. and removal dates, gather permitted livestock to at any time during the permitted periôd of use, including entry
(f) The Forest officer in upon livestock co.vered by this permit

enable an accurate count to be made thereof.'The Forest Service may, at its option,gather and hold for
counting all

livestock 9razingon the allotment. upon which this permit is based, permit unless the permittee has

(g) Only livestock marked, tagged, or branded as shown in the application and as may be required under Section 8(f), wil be allowed to graze under

th is

advance written approval from the Forest officer in charge to do .otherwise.
(h) The permittee will pay the improvements charge that costs of, perform, or otherwise provIde

for the proportionate share of cooperative
in

and management practices on the perrhittèd area when determined by the Forest offcer such improvements and practices are essential to proper protection

and management of the

resources administered by the. Forest Service.

(i) This permit is issued and accepted with the provision that the permittee wil maintain all range
improvements, whether private or Government-owned, that are assigned for maintenance to Improvements to be maintained repair; .orderliness,and safety acceptable to the Forest Service.

standards of

and acceptable to maintenance are specified in Part 30t this permit. The Government may maintain or otherwise such actiôn wil be to its advantage.. irnprovesaid Irnprovements when, in its opinion,
Page 3 of J;z
')::

,(

SG04306

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 5 of 14

.

9. Nonuse. At least 90 percent of the livestock permitted must be grazed each year, unless the

Forest officer in charge approves nonuse. Failureto place livestock on the allotted range/pasture without approved nonuse

may result in cancellation of the term grazng permit in whole

or in part.

10. Protection. The permittee, or the permittees' agents and employees, when acting within the scope of

their employment, and contractors and subcontractors wil protect the land and propert of the United States
and other land under jurisdiction of the Forest Service covered by and used in conjunction with this permit. Protection wil include taking all reasonable precautions to prevent, make dilgent efforts to suppress, and report promptly all fires on or endangering such land and propert. The permittee wil pay the United States for land or propert, including range improvements, resulting from negligence or from violation any damagé to its of the provisions and requirements of this permit or any law or regulation applicable to the National Forests

System. .
11. General.
(c) The pennittee wil ownership of livestock, immediately notify (d) The

(a) The Forest officer in charge may at anytime require the pennittee to give good and sufficient bond to by the United States through insure payment for all damage or costs to prevent or mitigate damages suStained the permitee's failure to comply with the provisions and requirements of this permit or the regulations of the it is based. Secretary on which
area described in this permit is withdrawn (b) This permit wil be cancelled, in whole orin part, whenever the from the National Forest System by land exchange, modification of boundaries, or otherwise, or whenever the area described in this permit is to be devoted to a public purpose that precludes grazing.
the Forest officer in charge of any change in control of base propert, or other qualifications to hold this grazing permit.

permanent Improvelients construetedtite,(jtjting foruseìncónJunCIionwlththis permit are

the

property 01 the. Unitád. Stales GovemmentùnlÊfs~ speciflcallydeslgnatedotharwtseør covered bya coopérative agremeht. .. They will notberêrroyed norcompensaled tor uponcancèllation oj this permit. except ìri the Ncitíonal Forests in the 16 conligúous Western States when cancelled, In whole or in part, to In the event of such cancellation on the National devote land to another public purpose ¡ncludirig disposal. Forests in the 16 Contiguous Western States, the permittee will be compensated for the adjusted value of approved range improvements installed or plàced by him.
(e) The permittee may not transfer,

assign, lease, or subletthis permit in whole or part.

(f) This permit includes the terms and conditions of Part 3 hereof, consisting of page 5 through I 2
which follow.

:~ Page 4 of i:i

SG04307

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 6 of 14

Pae~. s:--ür---Ti------

_GRAZING PERMIT - PART 3
(Reference FSM 223Ö)

a USDA - FOREST SERVICE

Permittee Number

02281
Permit Number

08-1250

Management Practices. Continued..)
Special Terms and Conditions

1. Authorization Required. Each year the perniittee wiiffie with the District Ranger an application for changes
from the use specified in the term grazing permit. It is to be submitted substantially in advance of the desired or in part, will be reflected in the ensuing Bil for grazing season. Approval of the application, in whole Collection.
are not paid by the date specified Theron and livestock are placed of yearlong permits, are on) the allotment, term permit numbers andlor season of use may be on (or in the case suspended and/or cancelled. In addition, grazing use by livestock during the delinquent period wil be assessed
If fee assessed through the Bil for Collection at the "excess

use rate"minus regular fees if already paid and applicable. .
1

2. Maintenance of Range Improvements. Permittee maintenance assignments are shown on pages (s) /0 ê I

of this permit and are further identified on the map which accompanies this permit. -3. Livestock the current grazed in excess ofthe numbers. outside of the period use, or of a class or kind not

authorized in

Bil for Collection.
approved, in whole orin part, livestock grazed in excess of authorized excess livestock must be the "excess use or unauth.orized use rate." In addition:
(1) For first offense

(a) When the annual application is

numbers must be removed from lands of the National Forest System. Grazing use by assessed at

cases, the term grazing permit may be suspended or cancelled by the

percentage of

excess numbers exceeding 10 percent of current authorized numbers. If the excess is 110
(2) For second offense cases, t~e term grazing permit will be suspended or cancelled by twice the

percent or greater, total suspension or cancellation may result.

percentage of excess numbers. If excess

is 50 percent ,or greater, total ;

suspension

or cancellation wil result.

oCcurring during periods of suspension, the term grazing permit wil be cancelled by the amount of the suspension in effect or by twice the percentage or excess numbers involved
(3) For second offense cases

whichever is greater.
(4) For additional offenses, the termgrazin9 permit may be cancelled in whole or in part without regard to the percentage of excess.
4. Livestock Counting. The permittee wil notif the District Ranger

at least 5 days before livestock enter the present the livestock for counting National Forest System. If requested by the District Ranger, the permittee will any time therêafterduring the permitted season. The District Ranger may round up and prior to entry, and at counting all permittee-OWnèd livestock on the allotment. hold for

.
8004308

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 7 of 14

Paqe b of I"J-e! USDÁ - FORES i SERVICE GRAZING PERMIT - PART 3
(Reference FSM 2230)

FS-2200-1 Db ~~

Permittee Number

02281

08.1250 II Permit Number

Management Practices.

Continued...)
emphasis areas and not

5. WeUandandTt¡reetgOe~Q.ndaog~red PlantExclosures. . ExclosuteS designated Òn the àttched
Sa.cråmento AfIotment Hang! Improvement! Allotment Map are part of the considéred special

Sacramento Allotment. LtveStockuseisnot.permitted within éxcfos!.resand will be rømoved ina

timely manner,

Responsibilities for Construction and Maintenance of Structural

Improvements or for Range Rehabiltation.

A. liThe permittee, contractor, lessee, or operators shall be responsible for the protection from damage by their actions of all the cultural resources so identified by the Forest Service within the affected area. In addition, they actions orthe actions of their their cultural resources caused by shall be liable for all damage to the identified agents or representatives. The permittee, contractor, lessee, or operators shall immediately notify the Forest Service Project Administrator or Contracting Officer if any damage occurs to any cultural resource and in the area in which damage has occurred until authorized to proceed. All provisions of immediately halt work Resources Damage Assessment Handbook are incorporated by reference herein." the Region 3 Cultural
B. Travel is permitted only on designated open roads and trails as outlined in the Uncoln National Forest LMP. requirement are noted as follows: ËXceptlons to this

1. Transporting materials and people toa project covered by a permit modification.
2. Transporting or treating sick or injured livestock.
3. Maintenance of Govemmentwindmils, pumps, generators, that require

transportation öf heavy materials or

special equipment.

4. Salting and/or supplemental feeding plans wil be approved in conjunction with annual permittee plan.

5. Entry into pastures or units not scheduled f?r use by Permittee Plan wil require an entry permit.
6. Additional exceptions wil be considered for

approval in the annual Permittee Plan or by entry permit.

a.Breaking ice in

livestock drinking troughs b. Checking pipelines pumping units c. Hal.ling of fuel and operating

Damage to the resource

created by the permittee in conjunction with travel off road or on closed roads and trails

wil be repaired by the permittee in a timely manner.

8004309

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 8 of 14

USDA - FOREST SERVICE

GRAZING PERMIT - PART 3 (Reference FSM 2230)

Management Practices. Continued.
Special provisions

and Requirements

The base propert for this permit is identified as follows:
W 1/2, SW 1/4 Section 31, T18S, R10E., NMPM

Changes in base propert must be applied for and approved in writing by the Forest Supervisor.
Lincoln National Forest Short Agë Calf Policy

On yearlong ranges, calvés under six (6) months of àge, as of January 1, shall be permitted on the allotment an obligation. By or on April 1, these calves and wil not be counted as involved until March 31 without charge and charged for shall be removed from the allotment area or shall be counted against the term permit numbers
at the current rate.
On seasonal.ranges., calves under six (6)rnonths ofåge, as of

January t, shall be permitted on the allotment
term permit numbers and charged for

involved unti March 31 without charge and wil not be counted as an obligation. By or on April 1 ¡ these calves
shall be removed from the allotment area or shall be counted against the

at the current rate.
On seasonal ranges, all cattle six (6) months and over entering on B.n allotment wil be counted toward term permit numbers and charged fOr åt the current rate at the time of entering the allotment.
At the time of taking applications, each permitee shall report the number of

calves under (6) months of age to be

on the allotment as of January 1. This number wil be recorded on the application form.

SG04310

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 9 of 14

~ÕREsr SERVICE
(Reference FSM 2230)

Page ~ of /:z I

FS-220Q-10b (9/85)

Permittee Number I'
02281
Permit Number

L. GRAZING PERMIT - PART 3
Management Practices.

08-1250 i

I

Continued...)

Special Terms and Conditions

Approved Special Rules of Local Associations. (List applicable special rules pertaining to this permit and to
management and development of the, resources,. which have been approved by

the Forest Supervisor.)

Rules of Management:
Section 1: Eligibilty.
Eligibilty for membership in the association wil be limited to those persons stated in Article II Section 1 of the Sacramento Grazing Association By-Laws.
Section

2: Distribution of non-use fil-in.
Association By-Laws.

Any member who waives his privilege to graze wil notify the Association asstated in the

Other members of the Association may choose to graze these numbers, but must first have the approval of the Association Board of .Directors.

Section 3: Livestock Management Responsibilties.
.ntil a long range Allomènt Management Plan is prepared

for the Sacramento AlIotnent, livestock moves and management requirements wil be handled through the Allotment Annual Operating Plan that is prepared at th~

annual application meeting. The Board of Directors wil be responsible to ensure that livestock are maintained in the agreed upon pastures. In emergency situations the schedule may be temporarily changed prior to notification and approval of Forest Servce.
Section 4: Improvement Maintenance.

Improvement maintenance needs wil be specified in the Allotmènt Annual Operating Plan. The responsibiltY for
maintenance on all structural and non-structural range improvements are assigned to the Association under the terms and conditions of the Term Grazing Permit (Part 2, Section 8, Subparagraph I.)
Section 5: Bulls, owned by individual members of the Association, wil be put On at the ratio bulls are of mixed breed and are allowed to serVice cows

of 1 to 20. These other than the owners. This is agreed to by the Board
salt

of Directors and can be changed only with their approvaL.
Section 6: A. Assessments for range management, improvements and

fees based on the number of cattle

entitled to be grazed wil be levied by the Board of Directors on an annual basis.

B. Other assessments for unforeseen expenses wil be made based on the number of cattle entitled to
be grazed.

Section 7: Fees
. The Association wil furnish the District Ranger with a list of

permittees and their permitted numbers prior to the

. grazing season eaCh year and wil be responsible for payment of grazing fees.

SG04311

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 10 of 14

.
l

FS-2200-10b (9i85

USDA - FOREST SERVICE

GRAZING PERMIT. PART 3
(Reference FSM 2230)

Permittee Number Fpage q of / ~ Permit Number 08-1250 I 02281

Management Practices. Continued...)
Special Terms

and Conditions

The renewal of this permit and its Allotment Management Plan is subject to compliance with the standards and guidelines outlined in the Lincoln National Forest's Lad Management Plan approved October 31, 1986.

As the Plan is updated, revised, or rewritten, those standards and guidelines wil also become a part of this
Grazing Permit and, if appropriate, the Allotment Management Plan. To and guidelines, monitoring wil be a part of

insure compliance with the standards existing and newly developed Allotment Management Plans.

The Sacramento Allotment lies within portions of Management Areas 2B Alamo, 2C Grapevine, 20 Sacramento

River, 2E Uppèr Penasco, 2F Mountain Park and 2F-RNA Haynes Canyon RNA. The specific standards and
guidelines which apply

to èach Managèment Areas are outlined in the Forest Plan.

wil' cooperate with the District Ranger in

Based upon the District's priority schedule for the developing an Allotment Management Plans, the permittee of the formal Allotment Management Plan on the the development completion of the NEPA analysis for the Sacramento Allotment prior to the end of the yéar 2000. Upon
allotment; the Term Grazing Permit will be

appropriately updated and/ormodified in conformance with the

National Environmental poliey Act and the Lincoln National Forests Land Management Plan.

Other
In accordance with 1995 Rescission Bil, the Sac:ramento Ranger District wil issue you a Term Grazing Permit management and permited numbers wil be reflecting the currently permitted livestock numbers. Livestock
evaluated during the NEPA analysis scheduled prior to the end of the year 2000.

Base propert owned and used by the permittee must continue to meet the minimum base propert requirements approved by the Forest Officer in charge.
It wil be my responsibilty'ás a permittee to

insure that my livestock are properly branded while on National

Forest lands;

I ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THE PROVISIONS OUTLINED IN PART 3 OF THIS GRAZING PERMIT HAS BEEN REVIEWED WITH ME.
I ALSO CONCUR

WITH THESE PROVISIONS AS WRITTEN.

11- t;"":; -17
DATE
I ,. ~ :.' '.~"K a d'f'

l "-, 7
DATE

8004312

Case L1NCOLN NF

1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4 SAC ALLOTMENT Filed 04/29/2008
IMPROVEMENTS

Page 11 of 14

IMPROVEMENT NAME

KIND
STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK. STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK STOCKTANK PIPELINE PIPELINE PIPELINE PIPELINE PIPELINE

#
2580 2585 2587 2606 2608 2614 2615 2621 2623 2624 2627 2633 2634 2637 2640
2641

SACRAMENTO GRAZING ASSOCIATION

UNIT MAINTENANCE

RESPONSIBILITY
. WALLOW ST TK
RUSSIASTTK KERR STTK
KARR STOCK TANK LUCAS STOCK TANK
1

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

FIRSTTK
BIRD ST TK

BURLESON STOCK TANK JENNY STOCK TANK TAL STOCK TANK HOME STEAD ST TK

BROWN STOCK TANK
WILLS STOCK TANK MOORE STOCK TANK SEED STOCK TANK STALK STOCK TANK HAY STOCK TANK POWDER STOCK TANK LIGHT STOCK TANK BURNT RIDGE ST. T TURKEY ROOST ST. T L.S. ST.TK. #1
LS. ST.TK. #2

1 1
1 1 1 1

GOOBLER ST. TK

JSKESSTTL
END RIDGE ST TK

BUGSTTK
PASTURE RIDGE PIPELINE MCAFFEE PIPELINE MCGREGOR PIPELINE MOORE RIDGE PIPELINE
NE PIPELINE

2643 2645 2646 2652 2654 2655 2655A 2656 2664 2665 2672 2658
2631A 2674A 2684

1
1 1 1 1

1.
1 1

SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA
SG.A

6.6 2.6 2.4 2.6

R02252
2611

BENSON SPRING
DARK CANYON SPRING
SEEP SPRING

SPRINGDEVEL
SPRING DEVEL SPRING ÒEVEL SPRING DEVEL SPRING DEVEL SPRING DEVEL SPRING DEVEL

MOORE SPRING DEVEL WRIGHT SPRING DEVEL WATERHOLE SPRING DEVEL LUCA SPRING WRIGHT SPG WATER GRAPEVINE STORAGE RESERVOIR DRINKER MOORE STORAGE
CAB. DRY WATER

2616 2635 2658 2660
2661 2591 2660A

CHALK HILL WATER ALAMO WATER CAB ROUNDUP WATER
ALAMO WATER

STORAGE STORAGE STORAGE STORAGE TROUGH TROUGH TROUGH TROUGH TROUGH

2674 2677A 2685 2595. 2595A 2595B 2595C

25950

SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA 0.7 ESCONDIDO 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA 1 SGA SGA 1 1 SGA
1

SG04313

. Case LINCOLN NF

1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4 Filed 04/29/2008 SAC ALLOTMENT
IMPROVEMENTS

Page 12 of 14 SACRAMENTO
GRAZING ASSOCIATION

. WOODS

CABIN WATER TROUGH WATER TROUGH RIDGE WATER TROUGH CULP DRINKER TROUGH
NELSON NW A.B. AB FENCE
NELSON EAST A.B. AB FENCE

2595E 2596F 2595G 2677

1 1 1 1

SGA SGA SGA SeA

RUSSIA FENCE AB FENCE
SAC N.E. A.B. AB FENCE. ALAMO-DRY A.B. AB FENCE
EAST ALAMO A.B. AB FENCE
AC.SCOTT ABLE A,B. AB FENCE

SAC - AQ.CH. A.B. ABFENCE

2575 1.3 MI SGA 2582 1.6 MI SGA 2592 3.1 MI SGA 2593 1.4 MI SGA 2594 1.3 MI SGA 25983.8 MI SGA 2642 3.9 MI SGA 2647 2.8 MI SGA
2648 3.5 . SGA

SAC. EAST A.B. AB FENCE

LAZY S NORTH BDRY AB FENCE ESCON-MCGREGOR AB FENCE

2651 0.7 MI SGA

2667 1 SGA
2670 4.7 SGA

MCGREGOR W. NFB AB FENCE
MCGREGOR S. NFB F AB FENCE MCGREGOR S. N.F. AB FENCE EAST MCGREGOR BDR AB FENCE
LUCAS. RUSS CAN A.B. AB FENCE

2671 4 SGA 2671 A 3.1 SGA
2673 4.2 SGA
R02504 0.8 RUSSIA ALLOTMENT R04440 1.3 E.K. BLUEWATER ALLOTMENT
RÖ2203 2.7

EK-SAC A.B, AB FENCE
NEL -AV WS-CAR DIV AI FENCE ALAMO~MULE PAST DIV AI FENCE

DRY.SACAB AB PENCE
AQUA CHIQUITA-SAC AB AB FENCE

DRY CANYON ALLOTMENT

SCOTT ABLE -SAC AB AB FENCE

R02177 1.1 AQUA CHIQUITA ALLOTMENT R02178 1.5 SCOTTABLE ALLOTMENT

RIO PENASCO AI FENCE
BURNT-LA S. DIV AI FENCE LA S-WRIGHT DIV AI FENCE

S PAST RIDGE AI FENCE
CULP-MCGREGOR AI FENCE ALAMO EXCLOSURE AI FENCE
WILLS CORRAL HOLD AI FENCE
WRIGHT SPRINGS TRAP AI FENCE
PENASCO CORRALS & SCALE CORRAL

2578 2601 2605 2653 2659 2666

1.1 1,4 5.1 2.2 6.6 0.6

SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA

2El76 0.5 SGA

2597 1 SGA
2639A 1.9 SGA

BENSON CORRAL CORRAL

TAL CORRAL CORRAL
THOUSAND MILE CORRAL CORRAL

DARK CORRAL CORRAL

WILLS CORRAL & TRAP CORRAL

SID WEST CORRAL CORRAL
GRAPEVINE CORRAL CORRAL LUCAS.DARK-BEN TRICK TANK

DIRlY DRAWERS TRICK TANK

2683 2609 2612 2617 2625 2638 2639 2657 2678 2590 2607
2620 2626 2678 2662

2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1 1 1 1

SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA SGA
seA SGA SGA SGA

LEAD TRICK TANK
CULP TRICK

DURLESON TRICK TANK

26.19 1 SGA

HOLDER TRICK TANK TANK MOORE TRICK TANK

SG04314

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 13 of 14

SG0431S

Case 1:04-cv-00786-SGB

Document 35-4

Filed 04/29/2008

Page 14 of 14

ExèlosureFences
(FotestServlce Maintenance
. Rêspåñslblllt)
r"'z /
"-"..

J...\
THIS MAP IS A PART OF GRAZING PERMIT
N...O.. 0....8. ..12...5.0.....188. U... ED. TO.. ..SACI. ..... .... ...... ..E.:...NI........D ..........

GRAZING ~QNON II l',.,
BY ~ ...... . ..... .... ... . 1)R .AN .

SHOWS THE ALLOTMENT SPECIFIED IN THE PERMIT

..,r- ,i ,

.~..-,.-

~i

'!

.!!

SG04316