Free Joint Status Report - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 1 of 15

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 2 of 15

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 3 of 15

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 4 of 15

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # Def. Ex. # Joint List?

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 5 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle

Joint Trial Exhibits
1 1 Yes Unnumbered (Dep Ex. 8) J0002347 Puget Sound Naval Shipyard [Collective Bargaining Agreement/CBA] Dep Ex. 8 NAVSHIPYDPUGET instruction 12532.1A environmental differential pay plan under the federal wage system. Dep Ex. 19 Employee grievance 05153-K (Def. Ex. 3 & 4) Employee grievance 05153-K (Def. Ex. 3 & 4) Employee grievance, 05153-K. Dep Ex. 69 Employee grievance decision, shipwright highpay grievance No. 05153-K. Signed by Tallman. Dep Ex. 70 Employee grievance decision, shipwright highpay grievance No. 05153-K. Unsigned. Dep Ex. 71 Employee grievance decision, shipwright highpay grievance No. 05153-K. unsigned with marginalia. Dep Ex. 72 Employee grievance decision, shipwright highpay grievance No. 05153-K. Signed by Tallman. Dep Ex. 74 Mascioli Employee grievance 05518K. Insulator asking to be added to grievance. Dep Ex. 96 Settlement Agreement - Mascioli grievance 05518-K resolution. Dep Ex. 89 Memo from Winkler to Tallman re High pay for shipwrights. Dep Ex. 17

4

67

Yes

J0001860-1873

J0001860 or J0004050 J0001056 A80-90 J0001039-1052

5 5 6

3 4 43

Yes Yes Yes

J0001056-1066 J0001056-1066 J0001039-52

8

46

Yes

J0000626-27

J0000626

9

45

Yes

J0000724-25

J0000724

10

44

Yes

J0000722-23

J0000722

11

47

Yes

J0000707-08

J0000707

12

61

Yes

J0060717-18

J0060717

15

62

Yes

J0001017

J0001017

18

5

Yes

J0000628

J0000628

19

9

Yes

J0060759

20

6

Yes

J0000776

21

7

Yes

J0000922-923

22

8

Yes

J0000775

Council grievance, Insulator and Shipwrights 05153-K, 05154-K. Dep Ex. 106 Email from Walls to Hamel re J0000776 moving the high pay grievance to second step. Dep Ex. 55 Email from Walls to Ellis re moving J0000922 the high pay grievance to second step. Dep Ex. 57 Email from Tallman to Hamel et al. J0000775, J0000924 re grievance hearing on high pay. Dep Ex. 56 J0060759 1 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # Def. Ex. # Joint List?

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 6 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range J0000770

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle

23

10

Yes

24

11

Yes

J0000925

25 26 27 28 29 30 31 38 39

12 28 29 34 35 42 40 48 51

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

J0000773 J0000772 J0000768 J0000936-937 J0000933 J0000918 J0000920 J0001034 J0001053

41

30

Yes

J0000730-732

Email from Hamel to Tallman re procedures for grievance hearing on J0000770 high pay (with handwritten notes) Dep Ex. 58 Email from Ellis to Talman et al re J0000925 discussions after grievance hearing on high pay. Dep Ex. 59 Email from Tallman to Hamel re J0000771, J0000773 witnesses for grievance hearing on high pay. Dep Ex. 60 Email from Tallman, Hamel, Niemi J0000772, J0000921 et al. Dep Ex. 61 Email from Tallman to Niemi. Dep J0000768 Ex. 103 Email from Walls to Tallman. Dep J0000936 Ex. 64 Email from Walls to Hamel and J0000933 Aiken. Dep Ex. 105 Email from Ames to Tallman, Niemi J0000918 et al. Dep Ex. 68 Email from Ames to Niemi. Dep Ex. J0000920 67 Email from Winkler to Ames and J0001034 Niemi. Dep Ex. 94 Email from Niemi to Ames. Dep Ex. J0001053 95 Memo re "High pay grievance shipwright work. - Summary of J0000730 Union's position and investigation. Dep Ex. 11 J0000781, A55 EG meeting Minutes. Attended by Aiken, Hamel, Tallman, Jaynes, Niemi for 05153-K. Dep Ex. 3 Handwritten notes re high pay grievance hearing. Dep Ex. 21 Request for information from Hamel for 05153-K. Dep Ex. 63 Memo re resolution Council grievance No. 05273-K. Council grievance for #05273-K. Dep Ex. 98 Numerical ranking of workers for high-pay calculations for 05153-K. Dep Ex. 22 List of personal names, badge number, and social security numbers with numerical ranking for high-pay calculations for 05153-K. Dep Ex. 23

42

15

Yes

J0000781-792

43 44 45 47 49

13 32 41 38 Included in 52

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

J0000780 J0000935 J0060767 J0060766 J0004236-44

J0000780 J0000935 J0060767 J0060766

50

Included in 52

Yes

J0002508-13

2 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # 51 Def. Ex. # Joint List? Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 J1035 is included in Deft TX 52 First page is Deft TX 59 31 Yes

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 7 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range J0004279-82

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle Numerical ranking of workers for high-pay calculations for 05153-K. Dep Ex. 27 Numerical ranking of workers for high-pay calculations for 05153-K. Dep Ex. 28 Numerical ranking of workers for high-pay calculations for 05153-K. Dep Ex. 24 Numerical ranking of workers for high-pay calculations for 05153-K. Dep Ex. 29 Name, badge, social security number, and total hours for high pay calculations. Dep Ex. 30 Name, badge, social security number, and total hours for high pay calculations. Dep. Ex. 31

52

Yes

J0002514-17

53

Yes

J0002488-99

54

Yes

J0004287-90

55

Yes

J0002492-95

56

Yes

J0001035-38

58

Yes

J0001281-85

J0000701

Employee grievance (Cooper), Insulators 05154-K High pay grievance work operations identified by BMTC as warranting high pay, 05154-K. Dep Ex. 10 Meeting notes - EG meeting step 2 insulators, 05154-K. Dep Ex. 62 Date, type, and line item for Don Baker's high-pay calculations. Dep Ex. 32 Detail sheet for high-pay calculations. Dep Ex. 33 Shop 57/64 overtime poll. Dep Ex. 35 Badge, name, grade, OT, and leave. Dep Ex. 37 Combined leave use for various people. Dep Ex. 38 Name, OT hours, and leave hours. Dep Ex. 40 Date, type, and line item. Dep Ex. 42 Leave history W.L. Jaynes. 64RL. Leave history D.E. Baker. Leave history D.S. Peterson.

60

Yes

J0000728-29

J0000728

64 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89

60 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52

Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

J0001314-28 J0003056-058 J0002529 J0002532 J0002527 J0002539-542 J0002528 J0002608-613 J0002614-616 J0002617-619 J0003053-055 J0003059-060

J001314

3 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 Def. Ex. # Joint List? Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 8 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range J0002714 J0002722 J0002573 J0002601 J0002602 J0002683 J0002738 J0002740 J0002745 J0002908 J0002941 J0002956 J0002985 J0003061 J0002585-586 J0002653-654 J0002676-677 J0002691-692 J0002724-725 J0002748-749 J0002802-803 J0002822-823 J0002826-827 J0002832-833 J0002837-838

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle Leave history P.T. Lengowski. Leave history T.R. Pugh. 758T. Information for you about Christopher Gal S/57 (169342). Leave history J.H. Sampson. Leave history T.J. Main. Leave history J.A. Campbell. Leave history J. Ezell. Leave history D.W. Harper. Leave history R.N. McDonald. Leave history J.C. Zieser. [Dates and days worked with overtime and leave used.] 75MI. Leave history R.E. Perry. 54SB. Leave history M.J. Hayden. Leave history T.L. Kemper. Leave history M.M. Pinkerton. Leave history M.B. Morgan. 75MI. 64SB. 75WB. 75WB. 75WB. 75WB.

4 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 Def. Ex. # Joint List? Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 9 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range J0002874-875 J0002879-880 J0002895-896 J0002986-987 J0002994-995 J0003034-035 J0003062-063 J0003066-067 J0003068-069 J0003082-083 J0003101-102 J0003110-111 J0003216-217 J0003220-221 J0002596-598 J0002645-647 J0002663-665 J0002671-673 J0002686-688 J0002752-754 J0002755-757 J0002771-773 J0002815-817 J0002930-932 J0002967-969

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle Leave history G.A. Griffis. 75MI. Leave history B. Fischer. 64FM. 64FM. Leave history J.T. Glitch. Leave history D.J. Leible. Leave history D.D. Forbes. Leave history K.L. Cockerill. Leave history E.W. Williams. Leave history R.D. Blankenship. Leave history A.W. Cooper. Leave history R.J. Kadleck. Leave history K.J. Wall. 64SB. Employee leave data information. Leave history J.M. Groat. 75WB. Leave history D.D. Pinkerton. 75MI. 75MI. 64SB. 75WB. 64SB. 75MI.

5 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # 141 142 143 144 145 146 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 160 162 163 164 165 166 167 Def. Ex. # Joint List? Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Included in 52 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 10 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range J0002976-978 J0003038-340 J0003075-077 J0003095-097 J0003121-123 J0003173-175 J0002703-706 J0002762-765 J0002935-938 J0003027-030 J0003128-131 J0002781-785 J0002903-907 J0003003-007 J0002915-920 J0003011-016 J0002621-627 J0002923-929 J0002883-890 J0002786-795 J0002551-560 J0002583-584 J0002599-600 J0002707-709 J0002864-867

Deft Bates range (if any 75MI.

Doctitle

Leave history F.A. Green. Leave history J.L. Rogers. Leave history M.C. Bessler. Leave history L.R. Dawson. Leave history D.J. Hurm. 64FN. 75MI. 64SB. 64FN. Leave history B.W. Cain. 64FN. 75MI. 64FM. 75WB. 75MI. 75WB. 75WB. 75MI. 64FN. Locator report. Leave history J.L. Minaker. Leave history D.S. Boyle. 64FN. Leave history R.L. Cook.

6 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # 168 169 Def. Ex. # Joint List? Included in 52 Included in 52 14 36 37 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 11 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range J0002911-312 J0003188-189

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle Leave history I.E. Garris. Leave history B.J. Lantrip.

J00059158, A67 J0000932 J0000930 J00001035, J0001067, J00024882548, J00025513255, J00042134352, A91-94 J0000713

52

Yes

63

Yes

7 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # Def. Ex. # Joint List?

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 12 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle

Plaintiffs' Additional Trial Exhibits
2 Pltff only Dep Ex. 13 (no bates numbers) Federal wage system, S8-6, S8-7 and S8-8. 1997 Update. Appendix J schedule of environmental differentials paid for exposure to various degrees of hazards, physical hardships, and working conditions of an unusual nature. 1998 Update Employee grievance decision, shipwright highpay grievance No. 05153-K. [signed by Aiken and Tallman] Extension of time limits for Insulator grievance 05518-K Email from Benton to Brown re Mascioli Email from Niemi to Ames re Mascioli grievance Settlement agreement on - behalf of (OBO) grievance No. 03875E. Dep Ex. 43 Handwritten note (undated) re Paul Scott's call to Hamel. Dep Ex. 107 Email from Seaton to Hamel re Shipwright lawsuit. Dep Ex. 108 Email from Seaton to Tallman et al re High pay grievance issue. Dep Ex. 77 Letter from Seaton to Holcomb re Grievance No. 05153-K, Walter Jaynes and Paul Scott. Dep Ex. 76 Fax transmittal from Tallman to Dan Schremser. Dep Ex. 73 Letter from Tallman to Dan re memo from shipwright general foreman. Dep Ex. 48 Fax transmittal from Niemi to Laferty Letter from Niemi to Gary re BMTC control No. 05273-K PSNS job order No. 9701-23-GRVU. Dep Ex. 104 Planning schedule - 1999. Dep Ex. 25 Calculations of hours and pay

3

Pltff only

Dep Ex. 14 (no bates numbers)

7

Pltff only

Dep Ex. 18 (no bates numbers) J0060716 J0001019 J0001016 J0001329

13 14 16 17

Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only

32 33 34

Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only

BMTC000056 BMTC000062 BMTC000057

35

Pltff only

J0059103-04

36 37 40

Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only

J0000624 J0000625 J0059105-112

46

Pltff only

J0060768

48 57

Pltff only Pltff only

J0004253 J0004171-75

8 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # 59 Def. Ex. # Joint List? Pltff only

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 13 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range J0000702

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle Employee's designation of representation (Cooper) for Insulator grievance, 05154-K Memo re summary of Union's position and investigation on High pay grievance insulators 0515-K. [Work situations cited.] Memo re Insulator High Pay Grievance - shop 64 insulator work, 05154-K Meeting minutes by Mary Walls re insulators, 05154-K, with cover re Payment of the 25% high pay differential Email from Ames to Niemi re Ext requested / insulator grievance 05154-K. Email from Hamel to Niemi re Request for extension. Minutes from Second Step meeting on employee grievance decision, insulator high pay grievance No. 05154-K. Request for personnel action for Aiken. Dep Ex. 83 Verification of personnel action for Aiken. Dep Ex. 86 Verification of personnel action for Aiken. Dep Ex. 85 Request for personnel action for Aiken. Dep Ex. 84 Request for personnel action for Aiken. Dep Ex. 87 Request for personnel action for Aiken. Dep Ex. 88 Employee grievances 10/01/1997 06/17/2002, complete list. Plaintiffs' ER 1006 Trial Exhibit #1. Sources: Deposition Exhibits 22, 23, 27, 28, 24 and 29. Defendant has source documents. Name of author: Kristi Emigh, Paralegal, Garvey Schubert Barer-Plaintiffs' counsel. Plaintiffs' ER 1006 Trial Exhibit #2. Sources: Deposition Exhibits 29, 30, 31 and J0004171-0004175). Defendant has source documents. Name of author: Kristi Emigh, Paralegal, Garvey Schubert BarerPlaintiffs' counsel.

61

Pltff only

J0001288-90

62

Pltff only

J0001277-80

63

Pltff only

J0000733-47

65 66

Pltff only Pltff only

J0001303 J0001301

67

Pltff only

J0001286-87

68 69 70 71 72 73 74

Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only

PF40 PF95 PF94 PF38-39 PF35-37 PF32-33 J006097-714

75

Pltff only

76

Pltff only

9 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # Def. Ex. # Joint List?

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 14 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle Plaintiffs' ER 1006 Trial Exhibit #3. Sources: Deposition Exhibits 29 and 30. Defendant has source documents. Name of author: Kristi Emigh, Paralegal, Garvey Schubert Barer-Plaintiffs' counsel. Plaintiffs' ER 1006 Trial Exhibit #4. Sources: Trial Exhibits 79-166. Defendant has source documents. Name of author: Kristi Emigh, Paralegal, Garvey Schubert BarerPlaintiffs' counsel. Leave history of G.D. Hanberg. Leave history of J.V. Schnoor. Leave history of J.A. Barth. Start and end dates for various workers Leave history of R.W. Harper. Leave history of N.M. Peterson. Summary of Date, Type, Class and Hours - 75MI. Start and end dates for various workers

77

Pltff only

78

Pltff only

129 147 161 170 171 172 173 174

Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only Pltff only

J0004832-833 J0004792-794 J0004813-820 J0004435 J0004563-566 J0004875-877 J0004885-886 PSNS000817818

10 of 11

Case 1:04-cv-00856-GWM
Jaynes et al. v. US US Court of Federal Claims 04-856C (Miller) Pl. Ex. # Def. Ex. # Joint List?

Document 105

Filed 09/20/2006

Page 15 of 15

Joint Trial Exhibit List

Pltf Bates Range

Deft Bates range (if any

Doctitle

Defendant's Additional Trial Exhibits
2 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only J0057956 J0000793 J0000797, J0001081 J0000808, J0000939 J0000850, J0000945 J0000949 J0000857, J0000952 J0000858, J0000953 Collective Bargaining Agreement June 2003 Grievance Exhibit A CFR Alleged Violated - Note Grievance Exhibit B - Docking log 1/1/91 - 12/31/98 Grievance Exhibit C - Position Descriptions Grievance Exhibit E - EDP back pay 6 yr limitations Grievance Exhibit F - Email from Winkler re fall protection briefing Grievance Exhibit G - Civilian Leave and Earning Statement: Bradley Boals Grievance Exhibit H - Attendance Sheet: Jamer Saez

23

Deft only

J0000860, J0000883, Grievance Exhibit I - Note re J0000955, definitions J0000957, J0000979 BMTC000050 Grievance Brief BMTC000003 Table of Contents BMTC000143-154 Exhibit E to Grievance Brief A54 J0000934 J0000919 J0001054 J0001055 J0003596-3704 Request for Information from Hamel Email from Walls to Hamel and Aiken Email from Ames to Hamel Email from Ames to Farman Email from Mitchell to Niemi Detail sheets Letter to Rep. Dicks from Hamel Email from Hamel to Aiken, Beaton re Letter to Rep. Dicks Unfair Labor Practices Charge Letter re Unfair Labor Practice Charge Withdrawal of Unfair Labor Practice Charge Jeffry Dostie Grievance and Decision Garris Grievance and Decision Instruction 12532.1 (with notes) Instruction 12532.4 Declaration of Barry Joe Aiken

24 25 26 27 33 39 49 50 53 54 55 56 57 58 64 65 66 68 69

Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only Deft only

J0000905 A95 J0059121 J0001850 J0001852 J0001856

11 of 11