Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW
Document 13
Filed 09/08/2006
Page 1 of 6
!
"" #
!
$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $
% ' ( * ' ' &! () +) ,. #0 / " 1 " %" 2 & 1
3&
4 15 3% " 6 1 "" 2 & / &/ " 1 #" 3& % &4
% /"- $ % 4 /" % 4 75 " & "
" #
" % 1% & / " 1 " & &
4 5 1 % 6 % % #"" # " / #" 1% & 3" #" 7 4 : % ;$! # " #"
/ #" " % 1 8 (* % 4 " &
""/ % % * " #" 9, %% <&= !
&/ 6 1 % 4& 3% % 6 6%
" % - 7 $ 6 % #" 4 8 (* 1 &
81 "
8 # %& 1 & % "
& " #
# 4 : > 21 " 6 " 04 5 2 "
1 #/ " 8" 5"" #" 8 < 41&6 8 % 2 8/ &&/ 1 " % 8 & 1# " " " "" % 4 > 2 1; 4 5 1 % 6 % &4 & % 4 0 " 3" ! " 6 " " / #" 1% " % 1 ! /! 5 ! / &/ 1 %4 " " 1
% &8 1 "
" " / " 8 " 1 8/ 0 # "% 3 " 1 " & / 1 1 ! -" % 8 (* " 1 %
8% *9 *
' ' ? @' 78 +) , ' $ 1& 0 ". 2 1/
& " " " < 4 1&6 8 % 8 / 8 " " %1 ;$ " 3 > %&
6% " # 0 18 " & 8 33" 8 0 % % '@ ' @!
8 " % < 4 % 8 * 9! * 4 " 3 " >
" " / " 8 7: " 1 "
4& 8 &"8 33" 8 # #/ 0 4 &/ % " 1 " 33" 1
# 4& " % / 8 (* & " " "< 41&6 8 % 4& 8 / 6 % " # 0 8 " " % 1 18 " ! 8" 5"" #" 8 & 1# " 1 #/ " 5 4 > 2 1 4 5 1 % 6 % & &4 " % % 8 # 2 " 6 " " / #" 1% # & " #= 1 & " % - 7 $7 $7 $ 8 (* # 10 "/ % & &&/ # "
4 0 " 3" " % 1
4 % % 0 4" 8 # % & 1 & " < 1" % "
1A 1& 4 > 2 1 % 8 362 < 4 4 1A 13" & % 4 % "/ " " 6 " % " "/ " " #"
Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW
Document 13
Filed 09/08/2006
Page 2 of 6
4 1/ #" % &/ & "" 1 5 3
"
2 " 3!
"% # 8
" % - 7 $7 $7B$ 1A 1& 4 > 2 1 % 8 (* "/ " " 6 " %& # 8 % " "< 41 &% 5"1A " & 5 % 61 " "/& 2 %3 1 % # #% / 8 3" &! 41 # " % 8
18 1 1A 1# 5 4 % " % #& " / " 2 " #" # 10 "/ % 3" 0 1 " & " " < 1 <& 4 > 21 & " 6 "
4 0 " 3" " % 1
" & &&"
- 7 $7 $7 $ 1A 1& 4 (* "/ " 3/ & % " 8" C 3 > "# (! ' , #"" # ' B2 & 6 / %
8 1% % %6 1 " #!
1 & % 6 1 "&46 & " <% 4 / 1 1 1
4 3" 4 8 % & " "
% 5 <" 4 6 1 " % 5 " < 4 4 % 1 % " " " & " # " / 4 % 1 3 2 &&/ " / 3" 4 # 7B$ 4 "5 " & " 4 &/ & " 5 & " #! 1# 0 # # % " & > & %
" " " 9 6 35 1 # 8% " % %61
4 & 0" # 4 1"
1A 13" & % " % - 7 $7 $7 $ "/ " 8 (* +! " 41 "
4 1&6 8 % 4 " <% 4 1A 13" " " " 1 "/ " 4 3"% 4 " " " 3 > % & % <4 4 8 36 1 " " %
&
"
2 #
4& 8 &"<"" " 1 #
4 & 4 6 1 "&464 # % " <% 4 % 6 1 % & % " % - 7 $7 $7 $! / " 1 1 1 / 6 &" 8 (* 1A 13" 4 & &%5 " & "/ " " ,! 4& / & " #!
% &" / 2 &/ 4 A" 8
4 % 2 &&/ % 6 1 % & % 4& 3% % " " 1 / 6 &"
& <4 4 1 6 " " 4& 8 &" ! 2% " #" 8 <48 " 4
4&
1 #/ " 8" 5"" #" 8 < 41&6 8 % 4 8/ &&/ & 6 " % 8 # 1# " " " " " 1&" ! 8 8 1 % 1& 4 "#" " :8" 5"" #" 8 ; & : 4 A / # 1# " " / 2 & 4 8 / <% # & " %1 /
" 1 %
# &/ 8" / % <48 %5 &" #" & % % 4 &&/ 6 4 8 " " 6 " 36 % % 1&/
8 11 " #" 8 <"" &/ 3 " 7< 4 / 10 1 % 4 D# 8 % 2 " 1 5 # % " # " / 8 1" " % 18 &&$!; 1
! % 33 && % " @ + !@# ' - ' 79 4 1 ' @$ 74 # 0 " 3% 2 1 ! ' % &
5 > 2 1:8" 5"" #" 8 ; % &4 5 1 2 6 " 1# " / #" & % #" 8 % % 1 6 % " 2 > 6 2 #/ 1 " 16 1 3" &$E F 1/ # ! " " # " +@ " & #! 16 1 "% ! @( @+, ! @ 7 " #! ! ' $ ' G# @,+ !@# ' 7 " (( #!
1 ' ($ 7 6 1 & ! ' 6
# " 6 1 " 3% 2 4 # :8" 5"" #" 8 ; % &4 5 1 >" & " 1# " / #" & % (' 7 * 9$ 7 % ! " !$$E % & " )( * 6 1
/ % 3 % 2& % F 7A % 0 ! ! " ! % ' " 1 8 / 6 ! +)+* * ! % 33 && % " 9+ ! ! ! 7 1 $ (,
+, 7 ' @$ 7 > 2 1 6 % 8 # :8" 5"" #" 8 ; ' 6 "& 1 #/ " 1# "
Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW
Document 13
Filed 09/08/2006
Page 3 of 6
4 % 3 % #1 " 1
6% % 16 &
% "& 1
#
&" " 3"
0 " 3" &/ 8" 1" D1 $! /2
% &4 < 4 %
62 3" < & 3 #" &" " 3" % % % % ) 2 "8 3 % 6 1 1 1 1 6 1 "&% 9! " /" 1& % 6 1 % & % 4& 8 &" 4 1 / 6 &" " 7: 1# 0 < & % 3" ;$ 1 # 8/
&&/ & 1 " % <4 4 1 " " " " 6 1 "&46 " 1 % %& 6
1# 0
# %" " & 61 #
2 <4 4 1 4 " " " # 8 &4 % 8 "
" % & 8 15 " & 1 % / #
# && 0 " &" 1 "2 6 14 &" # 6 /8 #
# &%# 8
1# 0 <4 4 1 4 6 1 "&G 1 & " % &/ 4 % % & % " " " 1 1 8 6 <4 4 1 " " 1# 0 # & 6 1 "& 4 # 4 6 " 1 " %
1# 0 4 # " % % 8&/ & 8 3 5
%" 1 6 " >6 % & 1 3 & 1) 1 %
" 3" & &
# <4 4 1 4 6 1 "& % " " " 1 "" &! 1& * ! < 4
1# 0 18 " 6 % " 2 " " # 16 1
1#" " 36 % % 4 16 1 "&46 " 1
& % 4 " & "8 # % " % % "> " 61
1# 0 6
6 % #" 4 #"" # 1 # " " 8 1% % %6 1 % #
/ 2" " /" 3 " >8 # #
5 28 36 2 0 " 3" 7 ! > @' @' & % 1" &! ( +$ %3 1 )* # 1
18 1 7 ! > @ 9$ " 1 " % #& ! #" 3% 42& " 3" & %
18 1 7 ! > @' @' #% / " % #& &! - 9$ 8 3" % B F%
5 F 8% < 4 8/ " 3" & < 4 " 3" & 8% 8/ # 3%
" H% F7 ! > @ )@ ($ < 1 &!
5% " 0 8 % & 1F 1 " 8 / 3 1 8 &4 8 % & 0 8/ @' @ , @ , $ @ ( @(* " " $ > 1 & " 1
3 4 B 1 " 7 ! > @ +$ % "0 " 8 0 # 2 ! 1 >4 " " 1 % 7 ! > &! @ 9 @ * 8 &4 " " "
3 & " 1# 0 0 " 3" < 4 1 1" # 18 1 7&" " ! " % #& " !0
0 #5%& %F
! > @ '@ &! 8 & #5
/ #
# 8% 8/
0 18 1 7 8/ 0 10 1 " % #& # "/
" 3" &$ 7 ! > @' @@ $ &! * ' ! 1# 0 6
# 6 1 "&46 >1 / & 1 " 1
# % 3& ) 7 ! @@9 @@* 1 $! # 8 &4 4 <"" 1 & "1# % 1 1" % & &&/ # 5 " 2 " 1 % 7&" "
& % 4 " & " 8 % 4 &6 " # % % & " > " " 1 6 6 % #" #"" # 1 # < 4 1#"8 1 % 3 (' (- 9' 9) ) ! > 9 ,, * &!
" ! !0
! > @ )@* &! ,)9@ * ) ' * ,
9)
+' +- - ) ) ' @$ ,@
&& 0 3"
# &&/ 36 % 3 1" & F
0 " 3" & 7&" " ! 1" " !0
' @* - 3 1 ) % ,$ F ) 1# 0 10 & < 4 G& 4
" 3" &
# %4 1 41 12 #% / " #)6 8 3"
% " #" 8 0
@
Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW
Document 13
Filed 09/08/2006
Page 4 of 6
1&6 8 % 4 6 % " 2 # % 0 % & 8 15 " " " " 16 1 5 % / # > @ - @ $ & <" & & 3 &! 7 ! >@ ' ! $! ! 6 & % 4 " % % 8&/ & "8 3 5 1#% / 8 3"
# && 0 " % 4 6 1 "&467&" " ! # 1 " !0
!
% " #" 8 08 &4 8 15 % & 5 4 % / 2 "
" %& & 1
8 % 4 1 & " % 4 &6 " # % % & % " " 1 " 1 6 8/ 6% & " 1" 5 4 1 # 2 "
1# 0 " %& 13 & 1 %
6 % #" #"" # 1 #
< 4 " #" 8 % "
1 & 8 % & " "" 1# ! > &!
% 6 % % 4 8 15 % % 4 &6 " # % % & % 11 " % / " 1 6 +) (- ,,) 9' * ( ) +)
1# 07&" " ! " !0 -) ' @$ & <" &
)@* - )9@ * ' +) , 1 B"0 13
#" % % " 3% 2% 6& &
& %4 < 4 6 " > 6 % 6 " % " 1) 1 %
&&% " < 4 4 8 # "
&6 " # % % & <% # 5 36 % " 5 1/ % 4 8 15 % % 4 &6 " # % % & % 1 6 / " 1 # 2 " " % / " 1 6 1# 0 0 " 4 & " " 3% 2 " #" 8 # 4 & " 4 6 18 % " 6" 4 &6 6 8 & % 4 / #" 2 08 1" 8" " % 1" " 1 /1 &! /4 8
4 1 & " % 4 &6 " # % % & % " 1 " 1 6
1# 0 7 $ 8" " 1 #
# "& 8 % % 4 # "" & 1F 6 8 & % 4 % % & 4 # 5 " 8 % 4 6 1 "&E7 $ 1 " 1 " 1" " 6 " 2 4 " 1 % # % "" 0 % 4 "/ 2 <" 1 1 " "A 4 % % & 6 & % & 75 F 08 &4% % 4 " / 2 " 6 % 2 / "A $ #
4 6 % 0% 8 &48 15 % & %8 #/ ## % " % % / % 8 4 8 1" 8" 6 18 " " /1 & 6" #E # 7 $ ! 6 % #" #"" # 1 # * ' +) ,
1# 0% 4 / % # B1 &4 % # & " 1 / " 3" &! & 1# 0 6 ! > &! )@* - )9@
% #" 8 1 I # % "& 0 % 4 1 # " " 1 4 " % 4 "
& % 4 6 " >6 % 6 " " 1) 1 %
" 3" & 4 # 5 & " 2 % & 7&" " ! " !0
< 4 % "0 8 1" 8 % % & 8 1 1 /1 2 6 % 3
+) (- ,,) 9-
' * ( ) +- - ) - #% / ) ' @$ 8 3" # 4 6 % & 1&/ " 1 "
% 8 8 1 0 4 1# 0 % " " ! > 9)@* - )9@ &! 16 1& % 4 "% "
# 1& 1F 0% 4 % % & " " 6 * ' +) , @,) (- - 9,) 1&"% 4 "
0 4 1 1 3 7&" " ! "" % " !0 " 1
9) * (,) +- @,( @,, @,$
#" " > 1
1&" # 6 " % % "0 8 1" 8 1 /1 2
/ % 4 / % # B1 &4 % # #/ 0 ' '7 ! > @@()@@" " 1 / 1 ' &! $ " 3" & 7&" " ! " !0 ! > @ )@ - 4 &! $ " 8 &
# 5% " 0 8 % & 1F 1 " 8 /
(
Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW
Document 13
Filed 09/08/2006
Page 5 of 6
#5 @
8 &4 "& % " "
1# 0 % & " 1 " & " 8 7&" " ! 1 " > " " !0 # 4 #" % % " 3% 2% 6 " 6& & G& " 6 1 >"
! > @' )@ &! * 1 ! && 3
@ 9 @ * "! 5
@ ( @@ @(* $ @!
& % 4 " & " 8 % 4 1% & 3% & % 8 1" 8" "> " " / / /1 & 1#" " 36 % % 4 16 1 "&46 " 1 # %4 1#% / " 8 3" % #8 "" & 6 1&
# & % F18 " 5 4 8 "" # 2 " 6 % #" #"" # 1 # 1 3 4 6 1 "&46 % " 1 # 3 1 0 +9) +*
1# 0 3" "& 35 1 < 4 8 1" % #" 8 % 1&6 "
0 4 < 4 < " #1
# 4 1 & " % 4 6% " 2 13 " 1 " 16 1 % 8% & % 4 8/ " - ) - @ )@ - * $! (! " 4 " %& 7 ! > * & 1 &! )
1# 0 % 4 # "
#/ 5 % " 0 1F 1 " @' @ )
,),* ' 9) ' (9) +' * * @) +
8 # %& % 4 6 8 % % " % % " 6 8 (* 4 " 5 " & " &&/ & "
& " #
# 8" 5" " #" 8 < 4 1&6 8 % 4 8/ 1# " " " " 6 4 5 1 % 6% " / #" 1%
4& 8 &" 4 & 5 " 6 % % #" 5 " 16 / # 2 !
4& 8 &"&4 /# 5 &4 " % # 5 1 "5 #"" # % " # % 2
+
Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW
Document 13
Filed 09/08/2006
Page 6 of 6
6
1&6 8 / 2 1A " & 4 " " "/& !
4 % 10 " / 1
4&
G&
% % % 4 B/ #" % 1 % % "" # 1 %
" " / 2&/ 3 " &6 8 5 # &J 1 ! F &% KKKKKKKKKKKKKKK KKKKKKKKKKKKKKK 1 ! F &% HB @' " / % 4 3" 8 & " " 1 " H% F H ' * * < 1 ' ),' "" 4 " 7 $ +* 6% = ),9,, 8 3 " 7 $ +* & = ),@@@ )3 = 3 &% L #5 6 % !8 3
" >B! / 4 0 &A ! . 4 ! % & &A % !
" " " "9 ', #= 6 35 1 '
,