Free Motion in Limine - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 1 of 10

!

"" # !

$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $

%&! ' ( * ' ' () +) ,.# " /0 1 " %& "1 2

3&

"4 (' ,' :' 9 # *' % ; "

& "# "1

56 "4 /"& %

& 7 3% "& 8 1 $ / &/ # < 5 " " # # & /

%

/"& ('

$ % "= / " < < # "1 5%1 ! 2 $

< "0 "& % " # < 5 $ ; "& 3% 2 % %1 " "> " ? %4 "# " % 0 @1 %4 < "1 ; 1 & <% & " %; " @%A &&/ " ""

< 0 8 &% ? "1

;& < &" 1 "0


< 1 ; #

41 < " " 1 &< 8& % 1

@%= B 5 $ " &/ ; <

"& 3% 2 8 % # 1 "#

% ; < &"& "= "8 % ; "=" "1 < "

"& 3% 2 & 8 1 1 " %1 38 < 3" 8 %8 " ;

8 1 %&"& 5
3 "# % 8 %8 1 %&"# &&/ " ;&

" " &" = * ) *( $B # 59$ " # < / 1 &! " " "

"# % ; 1 & < % & "

; 1"& @"" ! < 1 @1 ; # %4 # 41 < %; " " " 1 "38%2 " ""& %1 %1 3"1 "38%2 % @ ""& "# 3 # 1 < "< " 2 1 "1"# % ; " " % " 1 "1 & ; 6 " @ "&&"&!7 1 "0 @%= " # %1 @%= " # ; 1 %1 " 3"1 "38%2 @%A "" "" 1 < "< " 21 "1"# % ; " & ; 6 " % " 1 "1 " @%= &!7 " "< 2 " " # C& < &" % "# %1 2 " " # C& " %/ 3 " % # ; 1 # " 1 &< 8 % ; 8 %1 "& 3% 2 % 1 " 1 3 @1< "1 % " " # C& "= A & ! ; ? ; " 1 &< 8 % 1 @1< "1 8 %1 "& 3% 2&; #A "= / "# %1 ; & 3" 1 &% & & 1 1 ! ? C& 1 %/ " < # " " " &" %1; ; " % "= / " 2 " # < A "1 < # " " %/ 1 & < % & % ; ; ; "1 %&" &&/ " ;& < &"
Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 2 of 10

< &"


"0 2 # "# "3% & 1 56 " "

0< %33/ < % & A 4"" " #; @ "

; "

3"3A & % "1

# &%1 $ &7 &&/ "

"&&"& %1 ; "

@%= & 1 1 0 1 & < % & 4;< 1 % " "0 # ; " 3 "# % " " &" = :9) :+ &! % " " :-) 9 -) ,$

;& < &" 5
# 5A # / $ %< 3" & 4;< 4"1 % ; " &&/ " ;&

<" "#A %1&" 1 2

# &%1 &

## % < < ; 1 & < % & % % "1 " = &!

< &" 5
3 "# %

" " &"

-) 9+$ 5< "< " 2 ; 6 1 %&"# % " 8 %8

;& < &" 8 "&" & ; A & < &&/ % ; "# 1 " " " "1 ; < 1A % " % / 56 # && 0 3" % %1 0 < 1" < %8 % & % " /1 2

< %3"

= 1 3" "

%

1# 0 " / "& 1

1# 0 $ # 1 0 ; 2 1 ' ' 7 / " " '! "& %1 &C "

; ? " "2
% # "1 " ; " 3 " 4

%1 0 # 3 0 ;

% "1" # < # " " "3% & 1 ; 1 "

3% 0 % ; ; 0 "1 &

"& %1 5 $ %%?< &;8 % & % & 1 " # % "# < %

"& 3" & ; %/ ;1 1? 0% ; 1%8 % & 5 $ 1 0 "& " ;& "& 3" & ; / # 2 0 < 1" <"& " "1 /1

? / ; < &; 8 % & % " 1 "1 1 #5 $ %1 3"# 8 " %

/ % 81 " "# 8 "< % " ; < ; 18 % " " 1

1# 0 # 1 & "1"# ; 1%8 % & % ;& 1 " ; / # 2 0 < 1" <"& & " "1 /1 "# ; 1 "

4; "

81 8 "< % ! "& %1 &

&4

&% 8 % " ; 3%1 ; & = 2 1 1 " " &

"1 % 2% " % ; " " "& 3"

% "#; & " "11 %1"# 2 3%/ % "8

=A " & 1 "# % ; " " "

1# 0 ! "38 % # "1 ; " "" # < 1<"1F ; 1 & < % ; "& " 1 2/ 1 " " " %/ C& 1 &&/ & " "# % ; " % % ; " " % 1 %3 ; "&" & 38" <&

= &; "1 # &""? % " & "& 3" @%= &C " 1# 0 ! "& 3"

1 /" %# < "" #

" # < % 1 & <% & " " " 4%/# 1 ; %< & ; "1 / "

%/ C& 1

" 12 2 1 "

Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 3 of 10

" 1 "1

&"8 1 " 8 1 "1 8 &; & ; @ "

#; @ " "&&"&C 8 &% "1

"&&"&C /# & "1

= # < % ; " "

@%= & " % "

#% ; & & 4" "1 % ; 4 "&" A ; 2 " "& %1 &C

# 0% ; = 4&! "

"&&"& ; & 8 &% "1

? %4 "# " % 5 $ ; 0 "

"& 3"

&8 " # %8 % & 3 # 1 " 1# 0 %15 $ ; " 1# 0 < # % "% #

"& %1 & "

;& < &" 5 $ ; "=& " < %1%8 % % " " "1 %1 0 3 # 1 & "1 0 &8 " # %8 % & % 1 1 ; "&" % )8 1 "& # ; 1 #& " %/ ! 1

; # / " %< 3" & 1 "# % " /# & "1 # 0 & 1" & "

1 & <% & 3

% ; E "& % & %4 A %1 ; " / " " " "&&"& 4 ; 1 1 % % ; 1 & < % & "0 # "1 % # "1 " 3

12 ; 8 %1 " 1

"& 3% 2% &/ ; 4 < &&/ " A ; 2 "


; . # 1# 0< &" 1 1" " " " " 1 "& 3" " 1# 0 !

0; "

; 8 %8 " 1 %&"# "& 3% 2 # " # < & 1 " " " " % ;

54;< ; & 8 %A 1

& %$ "%

; "

1 / % % &/ ; "& 3% 2 & 3%1 8 "G#< %# < < " 1/ ;& < &"! #/ # & "1

; &&/ " "& 1 & <% &

%1 "1 ; ""# % / 2"= %1 ; # "% " 8 " " " # 0 & 4 &"% & 3" 4;< %/4" 0 & ; ;

& % ; / 1 "# "&" " 2 3 "#1 " " < " #

% &/ ; "& 3% 2 %1" # < < " "! " # < & 8 1 1 "! " " 8 %8

< %1 02 "= / % % ; 8 %8 < # < & " 1 %&"# "& 3% 2

!

<&

; & 38" "

< & ; @

; "

1# 0

"& %1 ## % < &/ ; @ & % " "& 3" "&&"&

"&&"& 5%1 2 % ; 8 &% "1 "1

$ A %1 # 1 0 %1 "1 ; 1 " " / " ;& < &"!9

1# 0 4 ; 1 1 % ; 1 & < % & "0 # "

; " %1 ; @ "1 " "

9

; &% " "= "8 % % ;& 1 ; < " < " " %33/ < % & A 4"" " # / 3&" 1 3"3A % "1 1# 0 # 41 < %; % @ " " " 1 1 0 =%8 % &&/ A "0 # "# 2 9

Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 4 of 10

< # % 2 "& 2 1 1 0 1 & < % & / # ? A % ; & %1 %/ "0 # "1 " 2 "1 ; %&" A 4"" " &&/ " ; @ " "& 3" ;& < &"!

"& 3" & % ; ; "1

3 12 " " # C& 8 %8 1 %&"#" # < % < " " %33/ < % & "38%2 ""& # " " # &%1 # & %"& % # "1

"&&"& %1% ; @ "1

#&< && ; / " @

1# 0 5&/ ; & <

" " &" = :( &!

:-) *9$ % ; " "

# / %< 3" & 5&/ ; & < "& %1 &!

" " &" = *+) ' $ 1 1" " &! ' " 1

% ; "

1# 0

; " / 33"1% ; " @%= &$! " ***!

@%= & & 0 "# " / &/ 1 % ;

% &/

0 0 ""3" 1 &

4 ; "4 "& 3" <

&

; " # < % "

0 ""3" 1 "" 4; %

"4

8% # 1 "#

@%= & 5"= / 0 " < # / &"E " A / 2 ; " ; / " 33"1%

&% &"1 "# & ; 8 1; &" " /<

# &%1 % ; " #& " % %1 0 "

@%= & " 0 0 " "# *** #

< 1" < %8 % & /1 2 8 1 "1 8 5 % &; ; 1 " "1 "&

"1 && 0 "# ; %8 % & %&" ; "

# < &; %

1# 0 @ &"# % $! ; 8 1 "1 8 " &;

; # < % @ " "

@%= & 1 ""3"# " "# 2 < 3"# = A " & "

"< "1 *** "3A

# 8 1 8 "

1 "# % ; 1 & < % % " '+ ; ' " % ; 3"3A & % " "1 C& #& = 1 / &! " 1 & 0 "4 " "

; 1 *** =1 / &! " " 1 @%= & A %/ ; " 1 0 < &/ 0 & "4 & # &%3"

# &%1 # # 2 %1# 3 0 & / "& 2 < 3"# A ; 2 "

"0 2 1& 0%/ % ; "# " @%= & % " ; 1 *** " @%= & " # &%1

%4 < % "

=A " & 8 1 " 8 "

;& &/ 4 & A %/ ; # 1 0 "&8 " # / %< 3" & C& %1 " "

% & 0 "# A ; 2 " "& 3"

# &%1 1 " 4 & &% " 2 ; % &C %

@ % 1 / 3&" # 1 0 ' ! 1 / ' "1 1 / 3&" 4 ; 1 1 ! 1 # "4 %3 1# 0 ! / ;< < %33/ < % &
Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 5 of 10

# < %4 "# 0 ; ? 0 %1 = # < "!

; "

@%= & ## % 1 2% " "

"4

&

%1 "

"

# &%1 &

# ""# ; " #1 0 ; / " 1 & <% & 1 1 % ; 1 "0 # " 3" %

@%= & ; # % < " %

< 4 ; ; "

1# 0

"& %1 & ; " 4 ;

; 1 & <% & "

;& < &" ; " % 8 &% "1 1# 0

? %4 "# " % 0 "& %1 &C "

;& < &" "& 3" 3 12

#; " % ? %4 "# " % ; 0 " &/ ;8 1 "1 8 < &; !

" " # C& 8 %8 1 %&"# " # < 1 1 0 ; " " "0 # " "& 3" & A % ; < " & % 2 "1

@%= &C " "4 &

"& 3" %1 " " ! "

5&/ ; & <

" " &" = ' &! +) 9$ %1

# &%1 5
3 "# %

" " &" = :+$ # ! %"& % 1 "< ; " " &&/ " ;& < &"!

% ; "

/# ? 0; 1 & <% & "1 " # # < & % " " "" < 1 ; %/ ! 9'

; 1 %&"# "& 3% 2 " %8 # "1 (' #,'

# / @" = / "# & < # "& 3% 2% 3 "# "& "1 % & ! !

6 & % % 28 %8 A 1 /1 % 1 "1 / "E "# 1" "

% ; &&/ A %1 ; < 1 A 8 "
9+, 9,: 5 *:9$ 5< ( 9

9( 5* ;

1 *-($ !

! ! : ($ 50 1 9( 5

3 " % "= / " 1" " < # 1 4

"& 3% 2 $B

0 +' ! # * 1 & <% & % & % 1" " #; " &&/ " & %

1 0"= / % % 3 < &

"&& 4; %&" "& 3% 2< < "# % "1 (' 56 # < 4;< " " ; "&&"& ;& < &" #

; < &" A %1 ; < 1$B " " " " %/ &"" &% &

# && A"7 3 $!

0 ; "& 3% 2% ; @ " " ; % "& " &&/ "

@%= & < < & 1 & < % & % ; ; " % "1 "1 3 12 # / %< 3" < ! !

&; #A "= / "# %/ " < # ! 1" " ! ""

1" # < 1 1 0; 2 " " "0 # %&" 1 & < % & & % "# "& %! ' )5 "# ! ! 2 ( 0%

% "< # & 1"& /

' 9$ 5; # 0 ' % 63 &

/ 8 A &; %1 "1 ; # / / "# # %< 3" & 1 1 0 ; 3 1 " "0 # " ? # & % &/ G % #&< "1 $! A"< % 2

1 =&; "18 %# <&7 & % 1 " " 1 / "

+

Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 6 of 10

" " # C& 8 % "1 1 1 0 ; 1 "0 # " / # &< "& & 1" " "1 %1 1 & "& ; ; 4 "2 / "! 1

"& 3% 2 %

; "&" 4

"&&"& @%= & "

%1"= 38" ; 8 % "1 4 ;1 1 % ; " 1 & "0 # "

"& 26"0 1 0 ; & " % H 1 1 # " "0 # %1 1" < 8 0 0 B3"" % D

@%= C&IA & "&& " / "& 1 @ %3 0 0

*** 4;< 1 "# ; "&/ "# 3 " "

0 4 ;1 1 & "8 "&" %& "

# / & 1

" ) 1 %& " # ""&

1 1 0 ; % &" "0 # " 38"3" 0 ; % &" "

%8 % & 1 & < % B # ; & "8 " & 1 & < % !7 " " # C& "&&

% "# :

& # "# / / 0&

', '

-!

; & ;& "& 3% 2 / ;& < &" #

# 1 "# " # < < < & 1 & < % & 4;< 1 % ; &/ G % " " " % "1 ; " " A"< &; #A "= / "# %/ " < # ! 3 "1 ; / # %%? & " #1 # "&& 0@ 12 !

< 1 @1 C& 8 %8 ; # %4 1 %&"# "& 3% 21 1 06; 1 1; "0 # " "&" < ; 0 "1 3" " % 0 &"1 "# % @ "# 3 !!! % & %1 0 %8 % &

1 "&/ % ; &/ 8 " A %" C& 1 " % <" 1 0 ; " 0 #&&"3

#%1#&8 2 0 28 "&" J 1 ; % &" "

%; # / "1 %< 3" & "= 8 1 & <% &7 # ! "& %1 &

<8 "# = < &"E " < % % / "& <& ?

5"38 &"& # "# ; # $

2 1 "1 < % " " " 1# 0 %; "

1# 0 %1 & "& %1 4 ;% 2 & # ; 1"& @"" "&&"&C %4 "" # ;& &

# & %< &"#&% " 2% / ; " % < 3"# !

=A " & 4;< ; " ; " ;1 1 % "0 # 41 < " "

% " "= "8 % < # % # 1" " 1

% 8 %8 1 %&"# "& 3% 2 1 1 0 % ; 1 & < % & "0 # "1 /# & "1 # 0% ; "

# ; 4 "&"

= < &"E " < % %8 % & 1 & < % & % / "& 1# 0

8 % "1 ; 1 & & 382 1 1 0 "0 # % 1" " &"!

; 4 "&"

"&&"& # ; " ? %4 "# " % ; % 0 " 1 / 3&" ! 1

"& 3" !

; ; "1 =%8 %

4; ; # < % %33/ < % & 4 ;

1 %; ! " &

1 @ %3

"1; 4 ; 1 1 " # "4 %3

1# 054;< %8 % ; 1# 0 "& 3"

%

2 &&/ "

;& < &" &"" % " 9 &/ 1$ ; 8 "

"& %1 ## % & 1# 0

" 00 ; @ " " 28 %

"&&"& %1 2 # < 4 ;1 1 % ; 1 " "0 # " ### % < &/ 4 ; ; @ % " ,

"&&"& 1 1 0 ; =< &"E " < "0 # " % / "&

Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 7 of 10

%1 2% ; 3 "1 "&&"& #

"11 "

0; 1 "

"& 3"

1# 0( !

; "& 3% 2% ; @ " " C& "1 #&< && % & /

2 " # < 1 1 0 % ; 1 & < % & %1@ " " "0 # "1 # && A"! 3 4

1 1 0&/ ; 1 & < % & & ; & "0 # < / 2 3 "1 !7 ; @ " &&/ " " %

,' 1 /1 ; "E "& "&&"& ;& < &" ; " #; "

"&& ; " 6 "1 8 &%

? %4 "# " % ; 0 " ? %4 "# " % ; 0 " ? %4 "# " 0 ; 1 " "# ; "

@%= & ; " % 8 &% " "1 <

1 & <% & 1 1 0 ; "0 # "

# 3%1 & 0 " 1# 0 "& %1 &

2 ; " % 8 &% "1 3 ? 0 ; 1 " ""

"& 3" ! ,' B

"& 3% 2 &; # ; " %1 A "= / "# % %/ "1 " " < # "& ! "1 # ,*9 ! # **, "F "&&"& 4; %

;& 0 %/ # & 4" ! 1 1 *: $ 5 !

' ' 5 '; '

1 0 "= / % % 3 < & "

"& 3% 2 % 4 "= < % "&

< "# 8 &% ? "1

? %4 "# " % ; 0 "

% ; # " # $B " " 1 0 %4"1 3

! 1 / "E "

-9 ! / 8 #,,' ,,+ 5 ! ! ! ' 9$ 5 8! '

< 1C& "= / % % 4 %/ < & ; 4 " ! "&& < "#8 &% ? "1

"&&C& "& 3% 2 1 1 0 ; 6 " "0 # " ? %4 "# " % &/ ; 0 < " $!

% ; 1 & < % 74; " " "1

; 1 %&"# "& 3% 2 " %8 "& 3% 2 # # < " "

# # < & 1/ < " " "G# %/#@" &" 3" "&&"& #; "

# # && % 3 % % @%= & " & 4"

/; < (' 9 & ; "

; "& 3% 2 % ; @ " " 8 %8 1 %&"# " # < 1 1 0 ; / # & " " "0 # " "1 ; %&" 1" " % / &&/ " < % " ;& < &" <

# 0 % % ; & %1 1 & < % & % ; ; & "1 "1 A " " / ; " & &%3" 3 1 "1 0 & %/4" 0 "# A ; # 0 ; 2 " "1 < %1 02 < # &; # A %/ "

" "1A 1 " " "

2% ; 8 %8 " 1 %&"# "& 3% 2 # " # < " " #A 4 & " % 2 3"!

18 "G#< A / # " # 2 1/ " 2 / " (' 9!

"= / "#/ # < # "1

& 8 "G#< A ; #& 1< % < / A ; 8 "&" 1 / "# 2 " &"# 2 " 1 % ;&
(

% % <

2 4 ;

A 3 "&

3

21 " "

3 "1 !

;& 8 "G#< & 8 1 < 12& 0 1/ " /

3

% ; "=" " " " # C& 8 % "1 & " # % 1 "1 % = A 1 "# " ; * A 4"" " 1 @"" # 1 %; &/ ;")3 3 ? % 1 "1 < % ! ! " < "& " " " -

"1 ") 1# 0 !

Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 8 of 10

1 1 % ; "& 3% 2 #" # < 1 "0 # " " " " #&%3" 3"3A & % "1 8% # ; 1 "# " @%= &C < 3 " " "

0% ; "

@%= & 4; 1 &/ 0 "4 " % " ; " &" 8 "3 &" ; 1 "4

& &

# &%1 # # 2% & /

@%= & 4 ; = # < " "! # < ; "

; " & % " # < % &/ 8 "1 " " 8 %1 ; "

@%= & & 0 "# &" "1 # / " %< 3" & "= 1 2 8 "&& ; 18 "&" < " 1 " "4 & ! ;& < &" & 3"1 2 " "4 /; 1 "1

#&< 3 0 ; 1 " 8 % &/ ; # < " "< < "! "= 38" % ; 13
"# 0 " "< "1 4"1 " " A" % ; "

%1 "1 " " "%

& %1% ; & "1 "% ; " "& %1 &

@%= & 54;< ; 1 % $ &/ ;A " ; "2 " < "; %1 & % 8 %A 1 # # &%1 & "& 3" & / # ? A ; "1 " 2 " # "4 & 8% # 1 "# 1# 0 "& 3"

1 2 &"8 1 " 1 & < % & " " 12 2 1 "1 " " @%= &! " "

# < % ; " "

@"2 # ;& 8 "G#< % 1/ " 1 & <% % 9 ; " 3" #; %; 1 & <% & " "1 /; 1 "1 % % %

; " "" # ""

""# % / 2 "= %1 ; 8 " " 4 &; % "& "1"< G

@%= &C "

;& < &" & 4 & " 5 $ % "1

(' 9!

%/ &"1 ! %33 && % "1 -' ! !

! + 5 **+$ 5 %

0 ; 6 I 1 / % % ; " # < 4%/#1 /1 ; 8 H %# < " " " "E " " <& / # 2 0 ; < 1 "& "1 " ; 0

# / " %8 %1/ 2 % "= %1 5 $ ; "E 8 8 " " "0 8 %&"< % "# 1 /

#5 $ ; " ; " % !7 $B

%/< %3" % ; "

# ; 1 &% & %1 ; %/< " " %3"!

"&8 # % "

4%/# ; " % A 0 " " / # 1 # %1 ! D / &! ! & 8 A " # < % %4 8 %A " " 1 "= " # / " % &/ & 8 1 A "

# / " %8 %1/ 2 % 1 / 8 "E 8 "A " %33 && % "1 :*

% "1 "= C& 8

! ! : ' : ( 5 *:-$ 56 = / % % < & # && % 4%/# 1 3 "&/ '+ '

/ & 8 1 < 12 8 1 1 " 4; " / 8 %8 " 1 3"!7 %= ! $B

%33 && % "1 :' ! ! *-

5 *:9$ 5"= / 0" # < % % ; & 3 < # " " "1 8% 1 ;& %1 % 2

18 1 "1 8 A / 6 I < & # &; & "< &" H % % "1 12 ; "

; "&" % ; 8 1 "1 8 H; < 1I 4%/# ; " % "= 3 " ; "1 &; & " %/ " < 1 & "&/ " < 8 1 "1 8 ; &; ! ;& 4%/#0 " 1 2"= # 8

/ # 2 0< / % ; "1 &" "

; &< " % H; < 1C&I E 1 # " %8 " %/ /2

" "< 1 /1 H; < 1I % 1 ; < &"& % "E " " %/ 2 " :

Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 9 of 10

; "&" 8 1 "1 8 & 3/ &; & &&" 2

"%/ 2 4 ; ; < &"& % & "

; "

&

4% 8 1 "1 8 $! &; &!7 &"1"& # 1

1 / % % ; 8 %8 %# < " 1 %&"# "& 3% 2 ; 1 ! " ; " 4%/#A "1 " 1 % ; "

# " # < 4%/# 1 /1 " " "E " @%= &C 1 & < % " "&&"& "& 2 A %/ 1 " # < 2 " "! %/ C& 3" 1

% 1 &4 ;

% " < % " % ; 1 & < % & 4;< ; @ ; " ; " 1 & < % & 3" % "# ; 8 %8 " 1 %&"# # / %< 3"

#" < % ; ; " /; < 3 && "

"= & % % ;& < &" & / "< 1 8 "&& 2 0 & 4; " ; 1 " "1 " " "& %1 & #; 1 " "& 3" E "& % /

#4 & " / % ; "

#; % ; " 1# 0

& & 382 % < % 1# 0 !

1 ; 3% 3 "

"& % ; "

% &"E " /

2 ; 8 %8 " 1 %&"# "& 3% 2 #

" # < &; #A "= / "# " " %/ " < # ! ! ; "1 # % # ,' "" # < & "& # " 1 1 "3& "E 1 = / % 2 %A /" < & % ; " &/ 3%/ A" 8 %A"3& 8 1 1 %&"#/ # "1 " # " (' (' 9 #

% ; &/ & "1 A

1 8 %A"3& 4 ; ; 8 %8 2 1 " 1 %&"# C& "1 %

" # < " "!

;& 8 %8 1 %&"# " # < " "


< %33/ < % & ; " 1# 0

#; < " %33/ < % & A 4"" @ "

#% ; & ; & % < "< % "1 % "& %1 & #

"& %1 4 & % < & # "# %11 "# % A ; & % "1 " 2 " % ; " ;& / 1# 0 # % # "& %1 &

3%& < &"& 4 & % ? %4 ; 1 " /# "1 "& 3" (' (' 9 < %

; 3" ; # # % 3 ? " "2 "< "# "

1# 0 ! # ,'

% A 0 "= / "# & #&< &&"# A " " < # / % # && A" ; 1 2 / # 3 " & "1 :' #

;& " # < & " " &2

< ; /; ? " "

"< 1 % & "&& 2

*' !

;& < &" & A %/ ; " 1# 0K % ; 1 &% & & " " A @ %/ ; "

1# 0

"& %1 & "& %1 &

#; 1 "

"& 3" %1

@%= & %1% ; " "1

#% ; 1 & < % &! "1 "&&"& #; "

"# A " 5 $ ; "& 3% 2 % ; @ % " " % ; < &"& "1

@%= & " 4;< ;

5 $ ; 1 "& 3% 2 "

# 59$ ; " # < % % ; 1 & < % & " " " "1 *

Case 1:05-cv-01067-MCW

Document 12

Filed 09/08/2006

Page 10 of 10

"4

&

4& &

"& 3"

# &%1 %1 # / %< 3" & 4;< # ; % (' (' 9

%


" # % #

"

# &%1 %1 "4 & / /; "

3/ A "= / "# / # & " < # "1

# ,' !

< "# ; 1 2 " # < < " & " " % % ; " #*' ! 1# 0

0< %33/ < % & A 4"" "

% )8 1 "& ('

4;< ; " % < "< % ; % #(' 9 # &% %1 0 "# 1 ! :'

"& %1 3/ A "= / "#/ # & & " < # "1

% ; %1 % 01 &% & " "0 "

C&

% %

3 " &; #A %/ "

"&8 / 2&/ 3 "# "< A

&J 1 ! ? &% LLLLLLLLLLLLLLL LLLLLLLLLLLLLLL ! "4"2@ " 9' " / % ; 3"1< & " " "4 M%1 "4 M%1 ' * ? ? ' " "8 % "> ) +*),:,, ; < 3 "> ) +*),999 &

" =@! / ; 0 &E ! . %; ! % & &E !

"# "8"3A : ' , > "1 '

'