Free Response to Motion - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 1 of 9

ATTACHMENTS

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 2 of 9

00-D-0039-0006, Ft Meade, MD As-of: Modification 0004, May 2003 CHANGES PER MOD. 03 (SAME NUMBER OF UXOs) (PER SLATER & ADAMS TESTIMONY)

CLIN / Task Description

Amount

Amount

Items

Revised Amount

Net Increase

$27,526.29 $27,526.29 $27,526.29 0008AA Task 1 - Site Visit & Records Search $72,298.60 $72,298.60 $72,298.60 0008AB Task 2 - Prepare Work Plan $35,989.10 $35,989.10 $35,989.10 0008AC Task 3 - Perform Geo Proveout $13,936.72 $13,936.72 and Office Trailer Setup $13,936.72 $413,066.29 -$37,589.03 0008AD Task 4 - Geo Survey & Anomaly Reacq $76,218.56 $76,218.56 $76,218.56 0008AE Task 5 - Perform Location Surveys and Map $131,289.66 $144,433.07 -$13,143.41 $131,289.66 0008AF / Task 6 - Vegetation Removal $2,041,082.38 -$185,738.50 $1 855 343 88 i i $1 244564:68; i !$3099908:561 0008AG / Task 7 - Perform UXO Clearance $32,769.34 $32,769.34 $32,769.34 0008AH / Task 8 - Final Disposition of AEDA/Rng $112,924.59 $75 749;81 i i $188 674:40 $124,229.47 -$11,304.88 0008AJ / Task 9 - Perform Quality Control $37,909.74 $37,909.74 0008AK / Task 10 - Removal Report $37,909.74 $31,678.54 $31,678.54 $31,678.54 0008AL / Task 11 - Meetings and Com. Involvement $23,593.19 $23,593.19 $23,593.19 0008AM /Task 12 - Provide UXO Support to Gov't (T&M) $3,074,731.29 -$247,775.82 $2,826,955.47 -$247,775.82 -9.10% $1,572,184.64

Decrease due to Acreage:

Previously agreed upon (09JUN2004 LTR) weather impact:

$13,104.00 CDA Interest Through 3/8/07 Total with CDA Interest $104,745.12 $1,442,257.94

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW
00-D-0039-0006 CHANGES PER MOD. 03 (SAME NUMBER OF UXOs) (PER SLATER & ADAMS TESTIMONY)
Area name Green Trail S/N (1.5-lane road) Red Trail (1.5-lane road) Orange Trail (1.5-lane road) Yellow Trail (1.5-lane road) Pine Trail (l-lane road) Forest Habitat Trail River Trail Upland Dog Training Area Scout Site #1 Scout Site #2 New Marsh (water edge to tree line) Cattail Pond (water edge to tree line) Bailey Bridge Marsh (water edge to tree line) Rieve's Pond (water edge to tree line) Lake Allen (water edge to tree line) Stables Ball Fields (next to Hwy198) Wildlife Feeding Areas I & H Range 1 Area "W" Blue Trail (1.5-lane road) Wildlife Loop (2-lane road) Little Patuxent River (from Bailey Bridge to RR Bridge) GTS/N RT OT YT PT FH RV UD Sl S2 NM CP BB RP LA ST BF WF R1 AW BT WL

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 3 of 9

UXO or UXO-like Items
85 6 5 17 30 35 0 37 46 6 9 5 0 0 112 69 16 10 167 76 10 233 0 974

Task Ord Acreage 5.10 6.50 5.60 6.10 1.30 5.40 0.70 21.00 3.30 2.10 1.00 2.10 0.15 0.50 14.20 13.30 6.10 41.60 80.00 19.00 10.80 37.20 1.10 284.15 AVG

UXO or UXO-like Items/ Acre 16..7 0.9 0.9 2.8 23.1 6.5 0.0 1.8 13.9 2.9 9.O 2.4 0.0 0.0 7.9 5.2 2.6 0.2 2.1 4.0 0.9 6.3 0.0 3.4

Actual Acreage Completed 5.10 6.50 5.60 6.10 1.30 5.40 0.70 27.60 3.30 1.80 1.00 2.00 0.10 0.50 10.50 14.70 4.10 60.00 60.00 5.10 10.80 37.20 0.70 270.10 AVG

UXO or UXO-like Items/ Acre 16.7 0.9 0.9 2.8 23.1 6.5 0.0 1.3 13.9 3.3. 9.0 2.5 0.0 0.0 10.7 4.7 3.9 0.2 2.8 14.9 0.9 6.3 0.0 3.6 20.20% over 3/AC :r 2/AC

NON-AREA G SUBTOTALS

Area "G"

AG

448

22.30 AVG

20.1

8.47 AVG

52.9

164.34% over 20/AC

OVERALL TOTALS

1422.0

306.45

278.57

9.10% decrease in acreage

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 4 of 9

CONTRACT DISPUTES ACT ("CDA") INTEREST ON GOVERNMENT ESTIMATE (MODIFIED TO CORRECT SCOPE OF MOD. 03 TO 82 ACRES)
GOVERNMENT ESTIMATE (MODIFIED TO CORRECT SCOPE OF MOD. 03) CALCULATION PERIOD: September 7, 2005 thru March 8, 2007 BASE AMOUNT: $1,337,512.82 Calculations by Semi-Annually Fluctuating Treasury Interest Rates September 7, 2005 - December 31, 2005: 4.5% x 116/365 x $1,337,512.82 January 1, 2006 - June 30, 2006: 5.125% = 2.5625% x $1,337,512.82 2 July 1, 2006 - December 31, 2006: 5.75% = 2.875% x $1,337,512.82 2 January 1, 2007 - March 08, 2007: 5.25% x 67/365 x $1,337,512.82 TOTAL (thru March 8, 2007) Interest accrues at: $5,771.46 per 30 days or $192.38 per day through 06/30/07 $1,337,512.82 corrected Estimate Amount $104.745.12 Interest thru 03/08/07 $1,442,257.94 TOTAL w/CDA Interest (thru 03/08/07) $34,273.77 Total CDA Interest
$19,128.27

$38,453.49 $72,727.26 $12,889.59 $104,745.12

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 5 of 9

00-D-0039-0006, Ft Meade, MD As-of: Modification 0004, May 2003 a. CHANGES TO FORMULA PER MOD. 03 (SLATER AND ADAMS TESTIMONY) b. INCREASES UXOs AND/OR UXO-LIKEs (PER SLOVAK TESTIMONY) ] Decrease due Amount I to Acreage

CLIN / Task Description

Revised Amount

Increase due to Items

Revised Amount

Net Increase

$27,526.29 $27,526.29 $27,526.29 0008AA / Task 1 - Site Visit & Records Search $72,298.60 $72,298.60 $72,298.60 0008AB / Task 2 - Prepare Work Plan $35,989.!0 $35,989.10 $35,989.10 0008AC / Task 3 - Perform Geo Proveout $13,936.72 $13,936.72 $13,936.72 and Office Trailer Setup $413,066.29 -$37,589.03 $375,477.26 ili$336277~43571~754:69! 0008AD / Task 4 - Geo Survey & Anomaly Reacq $76,218.56 $76,218.56 0008AE / Task 5 - Perform Location Surveys and Map $76,218.56 $131,289.66 $144,433.07 -$13,143.41 $131,289.66 0008AF / Task 6 - Vegetation Removal 661i645:9853516;989:87 $2,041,082.38 -$185,738.50 $1,855,343.88 0008AG / Task 7 - Perform UXO Clearance $32,769.34 $32,769.34 0008AH / Task 8 - Final Disposition of AEDA/Rng $32,769.34 :ii $1011135:26 $214;059i85 $124,229.47 -$11,304.88 $112,924.59 0008AJ / Task 9 - Perform Quality Control $37,909.74 $37,9O9.74 $37,909.74 0008AK / Task 10 - Removal Report $31,678.54 $31,678.54 $31,678.54 0008AL / Task 11 - Meetings and Com. Involvement $23,593.19 $23,593.19 $23,593.19 0008AM / Task 12 - Provide UXO Support to Gov't (T&M) $3,074,731.29 -$247,775.82 $2,826,955.47152 099 058:68 ;i$4;926;0~; -$247,775.82 ....... Decrease due to Acreage: -9.10%

Previously agreed upon (09JUN2004 LTR) weather impact:

$13,104.00 CDA Interest Through 03/08/07 Total with CDA Interest $146,006.39 $2,010,393.25

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 6 of 9

00-D-0039-0006 a. CHANGES TO FORMULA PER MOD. 03 (SLATER AND ADAMS TESTIMONY) b. INCREASES UXOs AND/OR UXO-LIKEs (PER SLOVAK TESTIMONY)
UXO or UXO-like Items GTS/N RT OT YT PT FH RV UD $1 $2 NM CP BB RP LA ST BF WF R1 AW BT WL 85 6 5 17 30 35 0 37 46 6 9 5 0 0 112 69 16 10 167 76 10 233 Task Oral Acreage 5.10 6.50 5.60 6.10 1.30 5.40 0.70. 21.00 3.30 2.10 1.00 2.10 0.15 0.50 14.20 13.30 6.10 41.60 80.00 . 19.00 10.80 37.20 UXO or UXO-like Items/ Acre 16.7 0.9 0.9 2.8 23.1 6.5 0.0 1.8 13.9 2.9 9.0 2.4 0.0 0.0 7.9 5.2 2.6 0.2 2.1 4.0 0.9 6.3 Actual Acreage Completed

Area name Green Trail S/N (1.5-lane road) Red Trail (1.5-lane road) Orange Trail (1.5-lane road) Yellow Trail (1.5-lane road) Pine Trail (l-lane road) Forest Habitat Trail River Trail Upland Dog Training Area Scout Site #1 Scout Site #2 New Marsh (water edge to tree line) Cattail Pond (water edge to tree line) Bailey Bridge Marsh (water edge to tree line) Rieve's Pond (water edge to tree line) Lake Allen (water edge to tree line) Stables Ball Fields (next to Hwy198) Wildlife Feeding Areas I & H Range 1 Area '~/V" Blue Trail (1.5-lane road) Wildlife Loop (2-lane road) Little Patuxent River (from Bailey Bridge to RR Bridge)

UXO or UXO-like Items/ Acre 16.7 0.9 0.9 2.8 23.! 6.5 0.0 1.3 13.9 3.3 9.0 2.5 0.0 0.0 10.7 4.7 3.9 0.2 2.8 14.9 0.9 6.3 0.0
3.6 20.20% over 3/AC

5.10 6.50 5.60 6.10 1.30 5.40 0.70 27.60 3.30 1.80 1.00 2.00 0.10 0.50 10.50 14.70 4.10 60.00 60.00 5.10 10.80 37.20
0.70 270.10 AVG

1.10
974 284.15 AVG

0.0
3.4

NON-AREA G SUBTOTALS

105 Fi~e sio~akAreaS 30 UXOS ~h Zeros)

Area "G"

AG

448

22.30 AVG

20.1

8.47 AVG

52.9

164.34% over 20/AC

OVERALL TOTALS

306.45

278.57

9.10% decrease in acreage

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 7 of 9

CONTRACT DISPUTES ACT ("CDA") INTEREST ON GOVERNMENT ESTIMATE (MODIFIED TO CORRECT SCOPE OF MOD. 03 TO 82 ACRES) AND (INCREASES FOR SLOVAK TESTIMONY)
GOVERNMENT ESTIMATE (MODIFIED TO CORRECT SCOPE OF MOD. 03 & SLOVAK INCREASES) CALCULATION PERIOD: September 7, 2005 thru March 8, 2007 BASE AMOUNT: $1,864,386.86 Calculations by Semi-Annually Fluctuating Treasury Interest Rates September 7, 2005 - December 31, 2005: 4.5% x 116/365 x $1,864,386.86 January 1, 2006 - June 30, 2006: 5.125% = 2.5625% x $1,864,386.86 2 July 1, 2006 - December 31, 2006: 5.75% = 2.875% x $1,864,386.86 2 January 1, 2007 - March 08, 2007: 5.25% x 67/365 x $1,864,386.86 TOTAL (thru March 8, 2007) Interest accrues at: $8,044.96 per 30 days or $268.17 per day through 06/30/07 $1,864,386.86 corrected Estimate Amount $146,006.39 Interest thru 03/08/07 $2,010,393.25 TOTAL w/CDA Interest (thru 03/08/07) $47,774.91 Total CDAInterest $26,663.29

$53,601.12 $101,376.03 $17,967.07 $146,006.39

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 8 of 9

O0000000000000000000000000000000000000000~OOxO

~0o~00<<00~00m =

0 , ,~ ~%, z~

0,

~qq<<~ , , ,~

z ,<~~0 , , , , ~4~44~

~

oooooooooooo'oooo~

0~$88~

Case 1:06-cv-00146-TCW

Document 20-2

Filed 04/30/2007

Page 9 of 9

UXOs With Zeros
DATA.anomaly weight (Ibs) type 3 6 UXO 3 6 UXO 3 6 UXO 6 UXO 3 3 6 UXO 3 7 UXO 7 UXO 3 . 3 7 UXO 0 10 UXO 0 3 UXO 3 10 UXO 2.5 0 UXO 2.25 3 UXO 3 8 UXO 3 8 UXO Discriminate Item 3" Stokes 3" Stokes 3" Stokes 3" Stokes 3" Stokes 3" Stokes 3" Stokes 3" Stokes 37 mrr 37 mrr 37 mrr 37 mm 37 mrr 37 mrr 37 mrr Townsend Opinion l=UXO4ike . item 0=Non UXOqike item F e dO 1 UXO 1 UXO 1 UXO

No, 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61

Target ID ST-6MD-019 ST-6MD-023 ST,,6M D-044 ST-6M D-045 ST-6M D-060 ST-7MD2-082 ST-7MD2-083 ST-7MD2-177 W'L-009-078A W'L-009-213 '¢¢L-009-242 tA~--009-272 WL-009-272A WL-gMD-543 WL-9MD-592

Area ST ST ST ST ST ST ST ST WL ~ WL WL WL WL ~

depth (in) length (n) dig date 29-Jui-03 4 14 7 14 29-Jui-03 29-Jul-03 18 14 29-Jul-03 8 14 18 14 29-Jul-03 15-Aug-03 18 14 15-Aug-03 19 14 18-Aug-03 15 14 14-Aug-03 8 10 14-Aug-03 5 8 6 16 16-Sep-03 15-Aug-03 12 12 22-S ep-,03 10 10 10 16 13-Oct-03 13-Oct-03 4 16

w~dth (in)

comments 3" stokes unfuze~ 3" stokes unfuzed 3" stokes unfuze~ 3" s~okes unfuzed 3" stokes 3" stokes unfuze~ 3" stokes 3" stokes plugged 75mm 60mm mortar stokes fuzed -30ram mortar fuzed HE 60ram mortar, he fuzed 3" stokes mortar, fuzed 3" stokes mortar, fuzed

cl (mY)

c2 (mV}

16.54 60.77 151.63 10.7 10.7

Remark UXO4ike UXOqike UXOqike UXOqike UXO-like UXO4ike UXO-like UXO4ike 15.2 UXO4ike 56.91 UXOqike 153.87 UXO-like 10.71 UXO-like 10.71 UXO4ike UXO÷like UXO-like

1 uxo
1 UXO 1 UXO 1 UXO 1 UXO 0 UXO 0 UXO 0 UXO 0 UXO 0 UXO 0 UXO 0 UXO
36 UXO