Free Motion to Dismiss - Rule 12(b)(1) - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Page 1 of 10

EXHIBIT B
NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION

Tuba City Hospital/High School Complex

Tuba City

TYPE OF REQUEST HOPI RESPONSE DATE OF REQUEST 06/00/1967 Construction of Greyhills High School and additional Denied housing for Indian Health Service personnel

DATE OF

RESPONSE 06/00/1967

Tuba City Mutual Help Housing

Tuba City

Filed 06/02/2008

Cameron Water and Sewer Extensions

Cameron
Tuba City
Rare Metals

Tso, Emmett
Rare Metals Housing

Approved 12/00/1971 Extend utilty right-of-way to Tuba City housing project No response on record 7/24/1972, Extend water and sewer to Cameron residents 8/4/1972, 6/28/1976 00/00/1973 Replacement of burned out home, in existence long Denied

12/29/1971

7/21/1976

before the Bennett Freeze
Pasture Canyon
Gap/Cedar Ridge

Pasture Canyon Irrigation

00/00/1974 Repair of water and sewer system at former Rare Metals Uranium Processing Site 3/5/1974 Proposal to improve Pasture Canyon irrigation system to benefit both Navajo and Hopi farmers
3/18/1975, Indian Health Service proposal to provide water 4/4/1975, system to benefit 30 homes in Gap area 2/23/1977 4/23/1975 Survey road (N 20) running from Gap north to

Approved
Denied

2/9/1979

6/23/1982
Ignored

Gap/Cedar Ridge Water and Sewer

Systems

Document 106-23

N 20 Right-of-way

Gap/Coppermine
Red Lake

Denied

9/9/1975

Coppermine
N 21 Right-of-way

4/23/1975 Request to approve right-of-way for paving existing road (N 21) to serve Red Lake and Kaibeto communities, including BIA schools
8/14/1975 Survey unDaved road (N 6120) from Cedar Ridge

Denied

9/9/1975
Denied Denied 8/14/1975 Survey road (N 6130) from Cedar Ridge to GaD 8/14/1975 Survey unpaved road (N 6110) west of Highway 89, Denied at Cedar Ridge 12/30/1975 Request to repair leaking sewage lagoon adjacent to Unknown Moencopi Wash

N 6120 Right-of-way N 6130 Right-of-way N 6110 Right-of-way
Cedar Ridge Cedar Ridge Cedar Ridge

9/9/1975 9/9/1975 9/9/1975

Sewage Lagoon, Tuba City

Tuba City Tuba City

1/19/1976

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Allen Construction Co,

00/00/1976 Request permit to remove 700 cubic yards of gravel Approved
from gravel pit located east of Moencopi Vilage

4/13/1976

Van lee Water and Waste Lines

Van lee

6/28/1976, Indian Health Service proposal to provide adequate 11/22/1976 domestic water and waste disposal facilities for 14 familes residing near Van lee
Red Lake

Denied

9/15/1976

Red Lake Power Line

8/71976 Request to provide electrical service to Red Lake
Community Housing Project, school and medical

Denied

Oct-76

facilty
Cameron Sewage Lagoon

Cameron
Kerley Valley

Kerley Valley Water Distribution
Gap/Cedar Ridge Powerline

Gap
Unknown

No reSDonse on record 8/11/1976 Request for sewer line and sewage lagoon Denied 8/11/1976 Request to provide a domestic water distribution system to serve familes living in Kerley Valley 8/11/1976 Request to provide electricity to homes in the Cedar Ignored by the Hopi Tribe Ridge Community 9/8/1976 ADDlication for new construction

9/15/1976

Nez, Renie

No reSDonse on record

l~

EXHIBIT

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ131

Page 2 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION

Tuba City High School and Indian Health Service Hospital Tappan Springs Water Line
Indian Health Service hospital Tappan Springs

Tuba City

TYPE OF REQUEST DATE OF REQUEST 00/00/1977 Construction of new Tuba City high school and

HOPI RESPONSE
Approved
Ignored

DATE OF

RESPONSE 00/00/1977

2/23/1977 Indian Health Service proposal to develop a water
system to serve 11 Navajo families that reside in

6/29/1977

(Cameron)
Moenave Water Distribution
Moenave Water

Distribution

Filed 06/02/2008

Cedar Ridge Water Distribution

Tappan Springs area 2/23/1977 Develop domestic water and sewer system to serve Ignored 12 Navajo families 2/23/1977 Develop water distribution system to provide water Ignored
service to 30 familes
1/27/1978 Community Water System to provide water and sewage services to 50 familes which have never had a domestic water supply 8/22/1978 Provide electrical service to residence 8/4/1978 Indian Health Service proposal to develop a domestic water supply and sewer system to serve 23 familes living near the Old Tuba City airport
Denied

by Hopi Tribe

Cedar Ridge Water Distribution
Cedar Ridge

2/14/1978

Zahaney, Rose Indian Health Service Water System
Tuba City

Denied

2/2/1979

No response on record

Rare Metals Powerline

Rare Metals

Document 106-23

West Tuba City Water Distribution

Tuba City

2/8/1979 Extension of Dowerline to Rare Metals 3/26/1979 Indian Health Service proposal to develop a
community water system to provide domestic water

Denied Denied

2/9/1979 4/23/1979

to 31 Navajo familes
Preston Mesa Powerline
Preston Mesa

8/30/1979
1/7/1980

Bennett, Bobby James
N 21 Right-of-Way

Tuba City
Red Lake

2m1980
4/2/1980

N 21 Red Lake - Kaibeto Road
Red Lake

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Kerley Valley Sewer Extension

Kerley Valley

4/11/1980

Right-of-way for power line extension to serve familes without electric service Hook UD to electrical service Request to approve right-of-way for paving existing road (N 21) to Red Lake and Kaibeto communities, including BIA schools Request for right-of-way for road construction/improvement of existing road which serves communities and schools Extension of existing water distribution system of approx. 3,500 feet

Ignored
Denied Denied

2/14/1980 2/24/1981

Denied

9/11/1981

Approved

7/14/1980

Tuba City landfill Tappan Springs
N 21 Right-of-Way

Tuba City
Tappan Springs

7/8/1980 Request for public landfill in accordance with Public Record not clear Health Code 8/13/1980 Request to extend electrical service to 3 families in No response on record

10/23/1980

(Cameron)
Red Lake

Freeze area
10/22/1980 Request for right-of-way for road construction/improvement of existing road which serves communities and schools 4/16/1981 Request for approval of a homesite lease for family that has resided at location for years 6/18/1981 Two part request to dril another NTUA Water Well to serve the residents of the Tuba City area, and to extend the existing power line from Black Mesa to Forest Lake community
Denied

6/23/1981

Lane, Keith & Dorothy

Wildcat Peak
Tuba City/Forest Lake

Denied

6/4/1981

NTUA Water Well/Forest Lake Powerline

Approved, conditioned on Navajo approval of Hopi request

7/2/1981

2

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ132

Page 3 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
Haskey, Mike

LOCATION

DATE OF

TYPE OF REQUEST

HOPI RESPONSE
Denied

DATE OF

Tuba City water irrigation project

Tuba City Tuba city

REQUEST 00/00/1982 Replacement of bumed out trailer 00/00/1982

Initially tabled - subsequently approved Area A, but not Area B

RESPONSE 3/10/1982 6/23/1982, 8/13/1982

Saganitso, Victor Sr. Cedar Ridge Pre-school
Cedar Ridge

Tuba City

No response on record 3/22/1982 ReDlacement of existing home 5/13/1982 Proposal to build preschool facility for unserved area No response on record

Filed 06/02/2008

Keebahe, Norman

Cameron
Tuba City

Bilagody, Stella

Mott, Bily
Tacheeni, Jack and Mae

Bodaway/Gap

6/28/1982 Replacement of inadequate housing (old 16'x 24' frame structure with no utilities) for paraplegic and family 7/6/1982 Replacement of 1-room shack ("without proper covering") for elderly Navajo woman with severe degenerative disc disease 7/6/1982 Replacement of existing "two-room shack, with an incomplete structure in the back"
7/6/1982 Replacement of dilapidated one-room shack with plastic tarp outside
7/6/1982 Room addition to existing residence 7/6/1982 Replacement of dilapidated hogan for grandmother and grandchildren ReDlacement of stone hogan Bathroom addition to existing residence Replacement for deteriorated residence Request for aooroval of homesite lease Request to build replacement house because his current home is "literally falling apart"

First request ignored.ISecond request denied

8/26/1982

Denied

8/26/1982

No response on record

Bodaway/Gap

Denied

8/26/1982

Document 106-23

Yellowhair, Kahn Watson, Stella
Rare Metals

Coalmine Mesa

No response on record No response on record

Nez, Chee

Tisi, Charlev

Tacheenie, Jennie
Keebahe, Norman Neztsosie, David
89/264 Junction
Kelly, Andrew, Sr. Gap/Bitter Springs Powerline

Coalmine Mesa Bodaway/Gap Bodaway/Gap Cameron
Tuba City/Moencopi

7/6/1982 7/6/1982 7/6/1982 7/28/1982 9/29/1982

No response on record No response on record No response on record No response on record No response on record

Gap/Bitter Springs

1/20/1983 Requesting waiver of homesite lease. 4/14/1983 Extend existing NTUA powerline from Gap north to
Bitter Springs Housing Project (located outside

No response on record

Denied

11/30/1983

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Rare Metals Uranium Mine Reclamation

Rare Metals

Freeze) 5/3/1983 Cleanup of uranium processing facility under federal Approved program
Various

APS

6/23/1983 Hopi letter to Arizona Public Service Company containing Hopi's view that by providing electrical hookups APS would be violating law

Kelly, Andrew, Sr.

Tuba City/MòencoDi
Bodaway/Gap

Bilagody, Stella
Mott, Anna

1/20/1984 Requesting waiver of homesite lease, 7/13/1984 Request for 12 x 20 reolacement house 7/13/1984 Widow with five children requests replacement of
severely dilapidated shack with a house

No response on record No response on record No response on record

Tacheeni, Jack and Mae
Manygoats, Margaret

Bodaway/Gao Tonalea

No response on record 7/13/1984 ReDlacement of dilapidated one room shack 7/13/1984 Replacement of dilapidated hogan with two bedroom No response on record

house
Yellowhair, Kahn
Means, Kee John

Coalmine Mesa Cameron

7/13/1984 10'x 12' addition to existing housing; renovation 10/16/1984 Connection to electric line for auadrioleoic Navaio

No reSDonse on record
ADDroved

6/20/1985

3

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ133

Page 4 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION

DATE OF REQUEST

TYPE OF REQUEST

HOPI RESPONSE

DATE OF

RESPONSE

Anderson, Bob
Tuba City

Filed 06/02/2008

APS Black, Emma
Bodaway/Gap
Maize, Henry
George, Kenneth

Tonalea
Coalmine Mesa Bodaway/Gap
Bodaway/Gap Bodaway/Gap

11/19/1984 Use of Pasture Canyon water for HUD housing Hopis contend that the use of the Pasture Canyon water is construction by building contractor development, and consent is required, Subsequent Navajo request denied No response on record 3/21/1985 Request for easment for 12kv electric line 10/21/1985 Replace 16'x 16' hogan, which collapsed due to age No response on record and structural deterioration No response on record

Bodaway/Gap Water Extension
Nez, Wille and family
Arizona, Hotachellie

8/5/1986 Replacement of severely dilapidated hogan (20' diameter) 10/22/1986 Replacement for collapsed hogan 10/19/1987 Extend existing water service to additional familes

Denied

11/21/1986

No response on record

Document 106-23

Dodson, Raymond and Christine Cameron School

Tonalea Cameron

Denied 10/26/1987 Replacement of small (16'x 16') dilapidated hogan Approved "under protest" with 00/00/1988 Replacement of hogan condition that replacement be of original dimensions No response on record 4/19/1988 Construction of electric line; hook up 8/16/1988 Request by superintendent of school district for Hopi No response on record Tribal approval of Cameron schooL. At present only
K-3 attend school

4/19/1988 10/21/1988

locally. Other students must
commute 40-50 miles daily

Black, Helen
Johnson, Dorothy

Bodaway/GaD Bodaway/Gap

Denied 9nt1988 Housing reDairs 9nt1988 Repairs to 20-year old house; electricity and running Denied

9/9/1988 9/9/1988

water
Secody, Mary

Bodaway/Gap
Bodaway/Gap Bodaway/Gap Bodaway/Gap

9nt1988 Woman and 2 young children request renovation to Denied
provide adequate winter shelter; electricity hook-up

9/9/1988

Secody, Marie

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Blackhat, Alfred

Blackhat, John
Yazzie, Victoria
Maze, Henry and Rena Hoschaine, Edward and Darlene
Redhouse, Lee
Secody, Marie

9nt1988 Family with 5 young children living in 12' x 16' house Denied request repairs; electricity hook-up Denied 9nt1988 Insulation for hogan; water and electricity Denied 9nt1988 71 year old man requesting renovation of 25-year old dilapidated house; electricity
Tonalea
Bodaway/Gap Bodaway/Gap Bodaway/Gap Bodaway/Gap
Tuba City
Red Lake

9/9/1988

9/9/1988 9/9/1988

9nt1988

Mother and child living 100 feet from electrical

line

Denied
request hook up to electricity

9/9/1988

9nt1988 Request hook up to electricity 9nt1988 Request hook UP to electricity
10/12/1988 Renovation and addition to existing housing 10/12/1988 Renovation and addition to existing housing

Denied Denied

9/9/1988 9/9/1988

No response on record

Approved renovations but not

10/26/1988

Western Navajo Fair
Stevens, Flora

Goodman, Theresa

addition 10/13/1988 Request to build temporary structures for the annual Approved Westem Navajo Fair 10/28/1988 Renovation of deteriorated home, roofing, walls and No response on record floor No response on record

10/19/1988

11/7/1988 Repair and addition to existina housina

11/17/1988

4

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ134

Page 5 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION

DATE OF

TYPE OF REQUEST

HOPI RESPONSE
Denied

DATE OF

REQUEST
Stevens, Flora
Red Lake
Whitesinger, Paul

RESPONSE

Tuba City

Coalmine Mesa Chapter House
Cameron Vendor Vilage
vendors
Homer, Marie

Coalmine Mesa

Cameron
Bodaway/Gap

12/20/1988 Request for reconsideration 12/22/1988 Request of Navajo suffering from progressive kidney disease to connect his trailer to nearby community utilities 00/00/1989 Request for construction and renovation of projects within Chapter 113/1989 Development of site for use by local arts and crafts

No response on record

1/12/1989

Denied

12/6/1989 Unresolved
Denied

Filed 06/02/2008

3/10/1989 Replacement of existing home (14'x 22' wood shed with dirt floor; no insulation; entire roof leaks) with a 16' x 32' one-bedroom house for a family of 5 3/10/1989 3/10/1989
Replacement of small 13'x 14' hogan (used by family of 6) with one-bedroom house with water line, plumbing, sewer, and electrical hook-up Replacement of severely dilapidated 1950 trailer (9'x 18') with 16' wood addition (residence for 2 adults and 6 chiidren);IRequest replacement with 2bedroom home with plumbing, sewer system, water line, and electrical hook-up Replacement of cardboard and aluminum one-room shack (for family of 5 with a quadriplegic child) with a two-bedroom house with utilities Replacement of 18'x 23' shack with two bedroom house for family of 7 persons: addition of plumbing, sewer system, water line, and electrical hookup

11/15/1990

Short, Bily
Tonalea
Cameron
Dougi, Delfred

Denied

6171989

Initial application ignored,lResubmitted application

8/26/1989 denied

Document 106-23

Willams, Lester
Dodson, Harry

Tonalea Tonalea

3/10/1989 3/10/1989

Denied

6171989
Denied

6171989

Bilagody, Stella

Tuba City

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

8/22/1989 Replacement of 18' x 16' wooden shack with 16' x 32' one -bedroom house with plumbing, sewer system, water line, and electrical hook up. (Resident is a Navajo widow who suffers from degenerative disc disease, which severely restricts
Bodaway/Gap Coalmine Mesa

Replacement denied; approval limited to renovation and small

9/26/1989

addition to existing structure and
utilities

Blackhat, John
Begay, Glenmore
Dougi, Delfred

abilty to walk to and from outhouse) 8/28/1989 Repair of collapsed/damaged roof and ceilng 9/13/1989 Replacement of hogan illegally torn down by Hopi
Tribe on July 15, 1989

Approved Denied

9/12/1989 11/9/1989

Cameron

Begay, Glenmore State Hiqhwav 64

Coal

mine Mesa

10/5/1989 Replacement of severely dilapidated 1950 trailer (9'x Approved, conditioned on moving 18') with 16' wood addition (residence for 2 adults trailer to another site and 6 chiidren);IRequest replacement with another trailer (previous request for replacement with 2bedroom home with utilties was denied) Approved on certain conditions 1/2/1990 Replacement of hogan ilegally torn down by Hopi Tribe on July 15,1989 1/10/1990 Request for right-of-way easement

11/9/1989

1/12/1990

No response on record

5

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ135

Page 6 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION

DATE OF REQUEST

TYPE OF REQUEST

HOPI RESPONSE

DATE OF

Hidden Springs Water Rehabilitation
Hidden Springs (Bodaway)

Project
Begay, John and Sarah

1/26/1990 Develop artesian spring to conserve run off and Denied eliminate seasonal water shortages, For family and livestock use

RESPONSE 2/26/1990

Bodaway/Gap

2/13/1990 Replacement of home completely destroyed by fire

Approved with condition that replacement be of same size and materials as original structure

2/26/1990

Filed 06/02/2008

Gap Sewer Lagoon

Gap

2/16/1990 Proposal to expand and renovate existing sewage
lagoon to prevent further leaking and contamination

Denied expansion. Approved renovation.
Denied

Willams, Lester Gap/Bodaway School Expansion

Tonalea Gap

Bodaway Chapter House

Bodaway

Document 106-23

Manygoats, Bessie

Tonalea
Bodaway/Gap

Yellowhair, Joe

2/21/1990 Request to hook-up to community water line 2/28/1990 Proposal to replace the existing "primary school" (three dilapidated trailers located adjacent to the community sewage lagoon) with a new school building and playground 4/9/1990 Request to renovate Bodaway chapter house, which can no longer be used as community facility because of safety concerns 5/4/1990 Replacement of substandard residence with larger residence; connection to electric lines, cistern and pump, septic system 5/4/1990 Replacement of a 20' dilapated mud and log (request for ceremonial hogan on existing homesite with a 20'

No response on record

3/23/1990

Approved

5/15/1990
Denied

6/6/1990

Denied,

6/6/1990

(request for

reconsideratio wood frame ceremonial hogan; hook up to adjacent
n 10/22/1990)
electrical line

reconsideratio

n denied

John, Loretta

Bodaway/Gap

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Blackhat, Joe

Bodaway/Gap

5/71990 Request to replace three residential structures Denied. destroyed by fire in 1987 and 1989 with one twobedroom house (for family of 5); connections to electricity, water, and septic tank 5/8/1990 Replacement of dismantled mud and log hogan with Denied permanent replacement housing (a one-bedroom house for a family of 4) (hogan dismantled when
main beam cracked and hogan became
Tuba City Shadow Mountain

12/3/1990 6/6/1990

6/8/1990

Bilboards
Keebahe, Margaret
Badonie, Susan

uninhabitable) 5/15/1990 Erect bilboards 6/12/1990 Replacement of collapsed hogan;IConstruction of
'temporary ceremonial hogan

Denied. Denied

6/14/1990 6/20/1990 8/10/1990 Construction of a home 8/13/1990 Request to put in waterline extension to benefi

Coalmine Mesa waterline extension

Coalmine Mesa

No response on record No response on record

District 3 permit holders grazing livestock south of we1l3K-312 and U,S, Highway 264 and to prevent traffc accidents and resulting injuries due to livestock crossover

Dandy, Cora

Tonalea

8/28/1990 Renovation/repairs to existina housing

Approved

9/27/1990

6

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ136

Page 7 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION

Farrell, James

Tuba City Tuba City
for insulin dependent

DATE OF TYPE OF REQUEST REQUEST 8/31/1990 Renovation and repair of existing home

HOPI RESPONSE

DATE OF

RESPONSE

Approved certain repairs but not complete renovation

1 0/9/1990

Farrell, Bett
ceremonial hogan
Begay, LaVonne

8/31/1990 Renovation of existing home and bathroom addition Denied repair of ceremonial hogan; approved home
diabetic; repair of existing

10/9/1990

renovation and addition

Adams, Bil

Filed 06/02/2008

Coalmine Mesa Cameron

9/17/1990 Replacement of burned-out home 9/18/1990 Replace unsafe hogan with hogan of identical size; addition of plumbing, electrical wiring, cistem, septic tank, and drainage field

Approved Denied all utilties; approval

9/26/1990 10/18/1990

limited to same-size replacement of existing structure

Begay, Jessie Lee

Moenave

9/18/1990 Replacement of burned out residence; connection of Denied request to connect to residence to community power and water lines community utilties;IApproved replacement conditioned on limitation to same size and location, even though family has

9/24/1990

9 members
Yazzie, Gene and Lucinda

Tuba City

9/20/1990 Replacement of burned-out trailer with frame
addition with 24' x 32' two-bedroom frame house for
a family of 5

Approved

9/26/1990
Approved

Document 106-23

Cameron Sewage Lagoon Repairs

Cameron

Coalmine Mine Fire

Coalmine Mesa
Tuba City

9/24/1990 Proposal to remedy seepage from community Sewage Lagoon, which poses health hazards to humans and livestock 9/26/1990, Proposal to remedy health and safety concems 10/14/1991 caused by underground mine fire buming in

10/26/1990

Ultimately approved following

12/17/1991

negotiation

Coalmine Mesa
Western Navajo Fair

9/26/1990 Request to build temporary structures for the Western Navajo Fair
10/2/1990 Replacement of 26' diameter hogan (676 sq, ft.;
inhabited by two adults and six children) with two

Approved
Denied

10/9/1990

Yazzie, Larr
Homer, Rose

Gap/Bodaway
Bodaway/Gap

11/1/1990

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

bedroom home
10/2/1990 Addition of bedroom and bathroom to existing residence (744 sq, ft.) to accommodate 8 full-time residents;IRepairs to existing structure

Denied additions, plumbing, electrical wiring, cistern and

11/1/1990

Hoschaine, Darlene

Tonalea

Homer, Marie
Gap Sewer Lagoon

Bodawav/GaD

Cameron
Tuba City

Tuba City/Moenkopi Sewage Treatment

1 0/9/1990 Replacement of 25'x 16' shack (used by family of 6 persons) with 42' diameter hogan; plumbing, electrical wiring/hook-up, cistern with pump, septic tank, and drainage field 10/16/1990 ReDlacement of existing shack 10/22/1990 Relocation and expansion of sewer lagoon based on adverse health and safety considerations; raw sewage currently discharged into wash Request for modifications

pump, and septic tank; approved only repairs Denied

11/15/1990

Denied Ignored

11/15/1990

Approved

Plant

3/26/1991

7

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ137

Page 8 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION

Secody, Grace
Tuba City

DATE OF TYPE OF REQUEST REQUEST 2/12/1991 Replacement of elderly woman's burned out hogan; only structure rernaining at homesite is a brush

HOPI RESPONSE
Denied

DATE OF

RESPONSE 3/15/1991

ramada
Sewage Lagoon, Tuba City
Bridge Surveys Tuba City School Mott, Anna

Tuba City Tuba City Tuba City

2/20/1991, Modifications to current lagoon to meet health and 4/22/1991 safety needs
2/20/1991 Request bv BIA to survev 6 bridge locations 5/2/1991 Reauest to dril for water 5m1991 Emergency replacement of roof and internal electric wiring destroyed by fire
5/8/1991 Repairs to existing structure caused by fire 5/15/1991 Department of Interior proposed clean-up of contaminated abandoned uranium mines in Cameron area

No response on record

Filed 06/02/2008

Bodaway/Gap

Denied No response on record Approved, on condition that family not connect house to community

4/22/1991

5/17/1991

electric power lines
Dugi, Sherman and Louise Cameron Abandoned Mines Reclamation
Project #1

Cameron Cameron Cameron
Tuba City
Tuba City

Approved Approved (following negotiation)

10/2/1991 11/5/1991

Keebahe, Tom
DAHC

Document 106-23

Western Navajo Fair

Bedonie, Susan
Smith, Stanley
Tuba City
Manygoats, Marie
White

Tonalea

6/19/1991 Repairlrenovation of existing home (roof, windows, etc) 7/1/1991 Non-profi residential and treatment center for severely handicapped Native American children 7/8/1991 Request to build temporary structures for the Western Navajo Fair 8/10/1991 Renovation and repair of existing house

Approved
Denied

7/19/1991

11/25/1991

No response on record

Approved on condition that floor area of existing structure will not be increased

9/17/1990
10/1/1991 Replacement of burned out wood frame house Iv deteriorated home 10/21/1991 Replacement of serious 11/3/1991 Replacement of residence dangerous to health and safety of occupants 11/13/1991 Replacement of home destroyed by fire (same size, same location) 11/13/1991 Replacement of 21'x 13' shack, deteriorated beyond repair with two-bedroom home for family of 6; intemal plumbing, cistern and drainage 11/14/1991 Replacement of home destroyed by fire 11/15/1991 Replacement of home destroyed by fire (full/parttime residence for 6 adults and 7 children, all in same extended family); replacement house would have been smaller than original house 12/2/1991 Replacement of existing home with similar structure

rock, Jerry
Gap
Kaibeto

Tonalea Tonalea

Approved Approved Approved
Approved

10/15/1991 12/13/1991 12/13/1991

John, Lorraine

2/11/1992
Denied

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Smith, Sadie

1/16/1992

Widehat, Phylls
Martin, Mary

Tuba City

Bodaway/Gap

Approved Denied

2/11/1992 1/16/1992

Johnson, Ernest
Homer, Gary

Cameron
Bodaway/Gap Tonalea

Approved
12/4/1991 Replacement of dilapidated home 12/5/1991 Replacement of existing hogan with substantially larger home, Note: Applicant is a member of the Hopi Tribe married to a Navaio

1/16/1992
Approved Approved

Curley, Lucinda and Neal

1/16/1992 1/16/1992

8

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ138

Page 9 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION
DATE OF

TYPE OF REQUEST

HOPI RESPONSE

DATE OF

REQUEST
Black, Towlie

Bodaway/Gap

12/13/1991 Replacement of existing hogan for elderly woman with medical needs (on kidney dialysis); addition of plumbing and electricity

Denied request to hook up to community water and electric lines; approved simple

RESPONSE 1/16/1992

replacement
Yellowhair, Loren
Bilagody, Elizabeth and Harry Tohonnie, Elsie
Tuba City Tuba City

12/16/1991 Replacement of burned-out mobile home (12' x 60' ) Denied with a small (24' x 32') house

12/30/1991

Filed 06/02/2008

Black Falls

1/2/1992 Renovation/repairs to existing home 1/15/1992 Replacement of small shack (deteriorated beyond
repair) with small one-bedroom home with electricity, cistern, septic tank, and drainage field

Approved

Denied requested replacement which was larger than current residence; approved septic tank

2/11/1992 2/27/1992
Denied

Homer, Joe

Bodaway/Gap
utilities

1/16/1992 Replacement of deteriorated hogan with same-size structure; connection to sanitation facilties and 1/17/1992 Replacement of mobile home destroyed by fire with

2/27/1992
Denied

Haskey, Mike

Tuba City

3/10/1992

permanent house
Sloan, Leonard and Family

Bodaway/Gap

Document 106-23

1/22/1992 Replacement of small mud hogan (330 sq. feet; on Denied replacement, but verge of collapse) with two bedroom home for family approved utiity hook-ups of six with medical problems 1/23/1992 Replacement of existing hogan (deteriorated beyond Approved repair) with smaller hogan/utilties at same location;

2/27/1992

Rock, Mabel

Tonalea
Tuba City

2/27/1992

Benally, Shirley
Littlefoot, Bahe

diabetic Navajo in poor health 2/6/1992 Addition to current residence; repair
2/11/1992 Replacement of severely deteriorated frame house

Request for addition denied; repairs approved

3/10/1992
Approved

Tonalea
Cameron
Tuba City

3/10/1992

Cameron Abandoned Mines Reclamation Project #2

2/25/1992 Department of Interior proposal to clean-up No response on record remaining contaminated abandoned uranium mining sites in Cameron

Jean, Harr

2/28/1992 Replacement of existing hogan (deteriorated beyond Denied; revised application for

4/9/1992

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

repair) with small one-bedroom home; connection to same size replacement approved

utiities (500 ft. away)
Littleman, Huskie
Coal

mine Mesa

Bennett, Esther
Navajo Arts and Craft

Bodaway/Gap

Cameron
Bodaway/Gap

3/2/1992 Replacement of hogan (deteriorated beyond repair) Denied with hogan of same size for elderly couple with multiple health problems 3/12/1992 Replacement of existing home (deteriorated beyond Approved repair) with small one-bedroom house No response on record

4/9/1992

9/15/1992
3/12/1992 Improvements to existing tribal art and crafts

enterprise

Tsosie, Harr

3/16/1992 Addition to existing home to relieve overcrowding (512 sq. ft,; 8 full-time residents);IRepair to exterior walls (rotting fiberboard, intended for use in

Approved

4/22/1992
insulation) 3/17/1992 Replacement of home

Cody, Rosemary

Cameron

Approved

4/22/1992

9

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ139

,,

Page 10 of 10

NAME OF NAVAJO/PROJECT
LOCATION
DATE OF

TYPE OF REQUEST

HOPI RESPONSE
Approved

DATE OF

REQUEST
Johnson, Lee

Cameron

3/19/1992 Replacement of severely dilapidated and unstable residence (piece-meal assemblage of trailer parts and scrap wood) for 2 adults and 7 children); addition of cistern, drainage field, and septic tank 3/19/1992 Bathroom addition/electrical wiring to meet medical

RESPONSE 4/22/1992

Yazzie, Sally

Coalmine Mesa

Approved

4/22/1992

needs
Mann, Alfred

Tonalea
Tuba City
Tuba City

Filed 06/02/2008

Yazzie, Zelia
Edgewater, Zelia
Junction Enterprises

3/19/1992 Replacement of unsound hogan with one-bedroom Denied house for family of 4; addition of electrical wiring and intemal plumbing 3/30/1992 Addition to mobile home to accommodate 9-person Approved family; home repairs

4/22/1992

5/22/1992
Approved

4/14/1992 Replacement of dilapidated hogan and waterline
hook-up for elderly woman

5/22/1992

Cameron Cameron

4/28/1992 Business site renewal and request for improvements Ignored
5/5/1992 Utility hook-ups for elderly, insulin dependent woman 7/23/1992 Addition of one bedroom to daughter's existing
home; utility hook-ups for elderly, handicapped

Yazzie, Sandra
Scott, Leonard

Approved Approved

5/22/1992

Tonalea

9/8/1992

Document 106-23

Manychildren, Mary Lou
Gray Mountain

person 7/31/1992 Replacement of trailer destroyed by tornado with two, Approved
bedroom house for family of 4

8/11/1992
8/6/1992 Replacement of home damaged by tornado 8/12/1992 Replacement of collapsed hogan
Approved Approved

Boone, Allen
Benallv, Mille

Keams, Madge Colorado, Wilson

Cameron Tonalea Cameron Cameron
Tuba City

8/19/1992 Replacement of home damaged by tornado Approved Approved 9/1/1992 Replacement of home damaged by tornado Replacement of existing home (roof and walls caved
9/9/1992 in)
Approved

9/8/1992 9/8/1992 9/8/1992 9/8/1992

Bennett, Bobby James

9/15/1992

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

10

Exhibit 22 to United States' Motion DOJ140