Free Motion to Dismiss - Rule 12(b)(1) - District Court of Federal Claims - federal

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 1 of 17

Public Works Projects Project Number Description Date Submitted Hopi Response BIA Response

Tuba City Hospital/High 1 School Complex

Construction of Greyhills High School and additional housing for Indian Health Service personnel 6/00/1967

denied

approved by BIA

Tuba City Mutual 2 Help Housing

ROW for electric powerline extension to serve Tuba City Housing Project

12/1/1971 approved by Hopi Tribe

7/24/72; Cameron Water and Extend water and sewer to Cameron 6/28/76; 3 Sewer Extensions residents 8/4/78

no response

approved by BIA

Rare Metals 4 Housing

Repair of water and sewer system at former Rare Metals Uranium Processing Site

1/1/1974 approved by Hopi Tribe

Pasture Canyon 5 Irrigation

Proposal to Improve Pasture Canyon irrigation system to benefit both Navajo and Hopi farmers

3/5/1974 denied

Gap/Cedar Ridge Water and Sewer 6 Systems

3/18/75; IHS proposal to provide water system 4/4/75; to benefit 30 homes in Gap Area 2/23/77

ignored

approved by BIA

7 N 20 Right of Way

Survey Road (N 20) from Gap North to Coppermine Request to approve right-of-way for paving existing road (N 21) to serve Red Lake and Kaibeto communities, including BIA schools

4/23/1975 denied

8 N 21 ROW

4/23/1975 denied

N 6120 Right of 9 Way

Survey unpaved road (N 6120) from Cedar Ridge

8/14/1975 denied

N 6130 Right of 10 Way

Survey Road (N 6130) from Cedar Ridge to Gap

8/14/1975 denied

N 6110 Right of 11 Way

Survey unpaved road (N 6110) west of Highway 89 at Cedar Ridge

8/14/1975 denied

Sewage Lagoon, 12 Tuba City

Request to repair leaking sewage lagoon adjacent to Moencopi Wash

12/30/1975 unknown

Allen Construction 13 Co.

Request Permit to remove 700 cubic yards of gravel east of Moencopi Village 00/00/1976

approved by Hopi Tribe

HIS proposal to provide adequate Van Zee Water and domestic water and waste disposal Waste Lines (IHS facilities for 14 families residing near 6/28/76; Van Zee 11/22/76 14 NA-74-551)

denied

approved by BIA

Red Lake Power 15 Line

Request to provide electrical service to Red Lake Community Housing Project, school and medical facility

8/7/1976 denied

approved by BIA

Cameron Sewage 16 Lagoon

Request for sewer line and sewage lagoon

8/11/1976 no response on record

approved by BIA

Kerley Valley Water Request for sewer line and sewage 17 Distribution lagoon

8/11/1976 denied

approved by BIA

Gap/Cedar Ridge 18 Powerline

Request to provide electricity to homes in the Cedar Ridge Community

8/11/1976 ignored

approved by BIA

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ166

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 2 of 17

Public Works Projects Project Number Tuba City High School and Indian Health Service 19 Hospital Description Date Submitted Hopi Response BIA Response

Construction of Tuba City High School and Indian Health Service Hospital

1/1/1977 approved by Hopi Tribe

Tappan Springs 20 Water Line

HIS proposal to develop a water system to serve 11 Navajo families that reside in Tappan Springs Area

2/23/1977 ignored

approved by BIA

Moenave Water 21 Distribution

Develop domestic water and sewer system to serve 12 Navajo families

2/23/1977 ignored

approved by BIA

Cedar Ridge Water 22 Distribution

Develop water distribution system to provide water service to 30 families Community Water System to provide water and sewage services to 50 families which have never had a domestic water supply HIS proposal to develop a domestic water supply and sewer system to serve 23 families living near the Old Tuba City airport

2/23/1977 ignored

approved by BIA

Cedar Ridge Water 23 Distribution

1/27/1978 ignored

approved by BIA

Indian Health Service Water 24 System

8/4/1978 no response

approved by BIA

Rare metals 25 Powerline

Extension of powerline to Rare Metals

2/8/1979 denied

West Tuba City 26 Water Distribution

IHS Proposal to develop community water system to provide domestic water to 31 Navajo families

3/26/1979 denied

approved by BIA

Preston Mesa 27 Powerline

ROW for electric powerline extension to serve families in Preston Mesa

8/30/1979 ignored

approved by BIA

Extension of existing water Kerley Valley Sewer distribution system of approx. 3,500 28 Extension feet

4/11/1980 approved by Hopi Tribe

29 Tuba City Landfill

request for public landfill in accordance with Public Health Code

7/8/1980 record unclear

appears to be approved

Tappan Springs request to extend electrical service to 30 Powerline extension 3 families in Freeze Area Two part request to drill another NTUA Water Well to serve the NTUA Water residents of the Tuba City area, and Well/Forest lake to extend the existing power line from 31 Powerline Black mesa to Forest Lake

8/13/1980 no response

6/18/1981 approved by Hopi Tribe

Tuba City Water 32 Irrigation Project

no description

00/00/1982

approved in part by Hopi Tribe

Cedar Ridge Pre33 School

Proposal to build preschool facility for unserved area

5/13/1982 no response

Gap/Bitter Springs 34 Powerline

Extend existing NTUA powerline from Gap north to Bitter Springs Housing Project

4/14/1983 denied

Rare Metals Uranium Mine 35 Reclamation

Cleanup of uranium processing facility (Rare Metals Uranium Mine Reclamation) Hopi Letter to Arizona Public Service Company stating Hopi's view that providing electrical hookups would be in violation of the law

5/3/1983 approved by Hopi Tribe

Arizona Public 36 Service

6/23/1983 blank

Not actual proposal

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ167

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 3 of 17

Public Works Projects Project Number Description Date Submitted Hopi Response BIA Response

Arizona Public 37 Service

request for easement for 12kv electric line

3/21/1985 no response

Bodaway/Gap 38 Water Extension

Extend existing water service to additional families

10/19/1987 no response

39 Cameron School

Request by superintendent of school district for Hopi Tribal approval of Cameron School

8/16/1988 no response

Request to build temporary structures for the annual Western 40 Western Navajo Fair Navajo Fair

10/19/1988 approved Hopi Tribe did not actually deny, but instead stated that the request should come from the Navajo Nation

Coalmine Mesa 41 Chapter House

Request for construction and renovations of projects within Chapter

00/00/1989

denied

Cameron Vendor 42 Village

Development of site for use by local arts and crafts vendors in Cameron

1/3/1989 unresolved

43 State Highway 64 Hidden Springs Water Rehabilitations 44 Project

Request for right-of-way easement Develop artesian spring to conserve run off and eliminate seasonal water shortages. For family and livestock use.

1/10/1990 no response

1/26/1990 denied

Proposal to expand and renovate existing sewage lagoon to prevent 45 Gap Sewer Lagoon further leaking and contamination

denied expansion, but 2/16/1990 approved renovation Hopi Tribe did not actually deny, but instead requested additional information

Gap/Bodaway 46 School Expansion

Replace existing primary school with new school Request to renovate Bodaway chapter house, which can no longer be used as community facility because of safety concerns

2/28/1990 denied

Bodaway Chapter 47 House

4/9/1990 approved by Hopi Tribe

Erect Billboards Request to put in waterline extension to benefit District 3 permit holders grazing livestock south of well 3KCoalmine Mesa 312 and U.S. Highway 264 and to 49 Waterline Extension prevent traffic accidents and resulting Proposal to remedy seepage from community Sewage Lagoon, which poses health hazards to humans and livestock

48 Billboards

5/15/1990 denied

8/13/1990 no response

Cameron Sewage 50 Lagoon Repairs

9/24/1990 approved by Hopi Tribe

Proposal to remedy health and safety concerns caused by underground 9/26/90; 51 Coalmine Mesa Fire mine fire burning in Coalmine Mesa 10/14/91

approved by Hopi Tribe

Request to build temporary structures for the annual Western 52 Western Navajo Fair Navajo Fair

9/26/1990 approved by Hopi Tribe

53 Gap Sewer Lagoon Relocate and expand sewer lagoon

10/22/1990 ignored

approved by BIA

Tuba City/Moenkopi Sewage Treatment 54 Plant Request for modifications

2/20/1991 approved by Hopi Tribe

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ168

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 4 of 17

Public Works Projects Project Number Description Date Submitted Hopi Response BIA Response

55 Bridge Surveys

Request by BIA to survey 6 bridge locations

2/20/1991 denied

56 Tuba City School

Request to drill for water

5/2/1991 no response

Hopi Tribe apparantely consented

Cameron Abandoned Mines DOI proposed clean up of Reclamation Project abandoned uranium mines in 57 #1 Cameron

5/15/1991 approved by Hopi Tribe

Dine Association for Build residential and treatment center Handicapped for severely handicapped Native 58 Citizens, Inc (DAHC) American children

7/1/1991 denied

build temporary structures for 59 Western Navajo Fair Western Navajo Fair Cameron Abandoned Mines DOI proposal to clean-up remaining Reclamation Project contaminated abandoned uranium 60 #2 mining sites in Cameron

7/8/1991 no response

2/25/1992 no response

approved by BIA??

Navajo Arts and Crafts (Cameron) 61 (NACE)

Improve existing tribal arts and crafts enterprise

3/12/1992 no response

Business site renewal and requests 62 Junction Enterprises for improvements

4/28/1992 ignored

approved (I22)

Windmill #3A-149 -- replace storage tank and apparently 63 Little Cowboy waterline extension

8/14/1996 approved

Windmill #3-T-541 -Moenkopi Wash 64 Area replace storage tank

8/15/1996 approved

Tonalea to Coalmine Mesa 65 Powerline Extension powerline extension

8/14/1996 denied

Cedar Ridge 66 Powerline Extension powerline extension

8/20/1996 approved

Tonalea Chapter Application for 12 67 bathroom additions bathroom additions Red Lake Waterline Extension

unclear

approved

68

water line extension

unclear

approved

Navajo Arts and 69 Crafts

tribal arts and crafts enterprise

unclear

approved

70 Waterline Extension waterline extension

unclear

Hopi requested additional information

Survey work (N608, 71 N6731, N20, N21) survey work

unclear

approved

Solid Waste 72 Transfer station

solid water transfer station for Gap/Bodaway Chapter

4/28/1997 approved

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ169

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 5 of 17

Public Works Projects Project Number White Mesa Regional Water System and 73 associated ROW Description Date Submitted Hopi Response BIA Response

Indian Health Services Projects NA00-B03; NA-00-B48; NA-00-M79; NA00-N24; NA-00-N25; NA-00-N26; NA00-B83; Gopher Spring Extension unclear

approved

Enclosed Solid Waster Fille site and Enclosed Solid Waster Fille site and Associated Landfill Associated Landfill Tract (Cedar 74 Tract (Cedar Ridge) Ridge)

unclear

approved

Rare Metals Water and Wastewater 75 Project (NA-00-N10) Cameron Sewer Lagoon Expansion and Associated Right of Ways (NA76 98-860)

Rare Metals Water and Wastewater Project

2/22/2001 approved

Cameron Sewer Lagoon Expansion and Associated Right of Ways

11/00/2000

approved

Moenave Power 77 Line Project

Moenave Power Line Project

unclear

approved

Bodaway/Gap 78 Elementary School

Bodaway/Gap Elementary School

unclear

approved

White Mesa and Gopher Springs 79 Extensions Construction of water supply and waste disposal facilities with 80 associated ROWs in

unclear Construction of water supply and waste disposal facilities with associated ROWs in Southeast Cameron

unclear

approved

12/14/2000 approved

construction of water supply line, North Cameron wasterwater disposal facilities, and Waterline extension bathroom additions for 25 homes 81 project (SFA-15-00) with associated ROWs

6/14/2000 approved

waterline extension 82 (for David Begay)

waterline extension (for David Begay)

2/25/1997 approved

waterline extension 83 (8.5 miles)

waterline extension (8.5 miles)

10/22/1997 unclear

Windmill #3K-329 -- replacement of water well, well tower 84 Rock Pile and water storage tank

6/5/1999 approved

Gap Pre-School 85 Construction

Gap Pre-School Construction

5/13/1982 approved

Coal Mine Mesa housing 86 development

Coal Mine Mesa housing development

unclear

denied

Windmill #3K-325 87 (Owlhead Windmill) repair windmill

unclear

unclear

South Cameron mutual Help 88 Seweage System

construction of sewer outfall line and sewage lagoon to serve the Mutual Help housing project and existing homes (55 homes) at Cameron unclear

unclear

approved by BIA

construct modern laundromat; convert building spaces to motel rooms; rmodel store interior and restrooms 89 Gap Trading Post consent for renewal of the business lease; replacement and improvements to underground Junction Enterprises gasoline tank; renovations of and 90 (Mini-Mart) improvements to convenience store

unclear

unclear

4/28/1992 approved

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ170

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 6 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

1 Tso, Emmett

Replacement of burned out house

00/00/1973

Denied

2 Nez, Renie

Application for new construction

9/8/1976 No response on record

3 Zahaney, Rose

Provide electrical service to residence

8/22/1978 Denied

4 Bennett, Bobby James

Hook up to electrical service

1/7/1980 Denied

5 Lane, Keith & Dorothy

Request for approval of a monesite lease for family

4/16/1980 Denied

6 Haskey, Mike

Replacement of burned out trailer

00/00/1982

Denied

7 Saganitso, Victor Sr.

Replacement of existing house

3/22/1982 No response on record

8 Keebahe, Norman

Replacement of inadequate Housing

6/28/1982 denied

9 Bilagody, Stella

Replacement of 1-room shack

7/6/1982 Denied

10 Mott, Billy

Replacement of existing two-room shack Replacement of dilapidated one-room shack

7/6/1982 No response on record

11 Techeeni, Jack and Mae

7/6/1982 Denied

12 Yellowhair, Kahn

Room addition to existing residence

7/6/1982 No response on record

13 Watson, Stella

Replacement of dilapidated hogan

7/6/1982 No response on record

14 Nez, Chee

Replacement of stone hogan

7/6/1982 No response on record

15 Tisi, Charley

Bathroom addition to existing residence

7/6/1982 No response on record

16 Teacheenie, Jennie

Replacement for Deteriorated residence

7/6/1982 No response on record

17 Keebahe, Norman

Request for approval of homesite lease

7/28/1982 No response on record

18 Neztsosie, David

Request to build replacement house

9/29/1982 No response on record

19 Kelly, Andrew Sr.

Request for waiver of homeside lease

1/20/1983; 1/20/1984

No response on record

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ171

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 7 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

20 Bilagody, Stella

Request for replacement house 7/13/1984; 6/26/1984

No response on record

21 Mott, Anna

Replacement of dilapidated house

7/13/1984; 6/26/1984

No response on record

22 Tacheeni, Jack and Mae

Replacement of dilapidated house

7/13/1984; 6/26/1984

No response on record

23 Manygoats, Margaret

Replacement of dilapidated house

7/13/1984; 6/26/1984

No response on record

24 Yellowhair, Kahn

Room addition to existing residence 7/13/1984; 6/26/1984

No response on record

25 Means, Kee John

Connection to electric line Use of Pasture Canyon water for HUD housing construction

10/16/1984 approved

26 Anderson, Bob

11/19/1984 Denied

27 Black, Emma

Replace hogan

10/21/1985 No response on record

28 Maize, Henry

Replace hogan

8/5/1986 No response on record

29 George, Kenneth

Replace hogan

10/22/1986 Denied

30 Nez, Willie and Family

Replace hogan

10/26/1987 Denied

31 Arizona, Hotachellie

Replace hogan

00/00/1988

approved

32 Dodson, Raymond and Christine

Construction of electric line; hook up

4/19/1988 No response on record

33 Black, Helen

House repairs

9/7/1988 Denied

34 Johnson, Dorothy

House repairs and electricity hookup

9/7/1988 Denied

35 Secody, Mary

House repairs and electricity hookup

9/7/1988 Denied

36 Secody, Marie

House repairs and electricity hookup

9/7/1988 denied

Hopi Tribe appears to have approved, not denied

37 Blackhat, Alfred

Insulation for hogan

9/7/1988 Denied

Denied

38 Blackhat, John

Renovation of house; electrical hookup

9/7/1988 Denied

Denied

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ172

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 8 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

39 Yazzie, Victoria

Electrical hookup

9/7/1988 Denied

Denied

40 Maze, Henry and Rena

Electrical hookup

9/7/1988 Denied

Denied

41 Hoschaine, Edward and Darlene

Electrical hookup

9/7/1988 Denied

Denied

42 Redhouse, Lee

Electrical hookup

10/12/1988 no response

Hopi Tribe appears to have approved

43 Secody, Marie

Renovation and addition

approved renovations but not 10/12/1988 addition

44 Stevens, Flora

Renovation of house

10/28/1988 no response

BIA approved

45 Goodman, Theresa

Repair and addition to house

11/7/1988 no response

BIA approved

46 Stevens, Flora

Request for reconsideration

12/20/1988 No response on record

BIA approved

47 Whitesinger, Paul

Electrical hookup

12/22/1988 denied

Hopi letter is not a denial

48 Homer, Marie

Replacement of home

3/10/1989 Denied

unclear (BIA requested additional information)

49 Shorty, Billy

Replacement of hogan

3/10/1989 (resubmitted 10/9/1989)

denied

BIA approved

50 Dugi, Delfred

Replacement of house

3/10/1989; 7/26/1989; (resubmitted 10/5/1989)

ignored

Hopi Tribe actually approved in part

51 Williams, Lester

Replacement of house

3/10/1989 (resubmitted 10/9/1989)

Denied

52 Dodson, Harry

Replacement of house

3/10/1989 (resubmitted 10/9/1989)

denied

BIA approved

53 Bilagody, Stella

Replacement of house

approved renovations but not 8/22/1989 addition

54 Blackhat, John

Repair roof

8/28/1989 approved

55 Begay, Glenmore

Replace hogan

9/13/1989; 1/2/1990

denied

Hopi Tribe reconsidered and granted in part

56 Dougi, Delfred

Replace trailer

10/5/1989 approved

57 Begay, John and Sarah

Replace house

2/13/1990 approved

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ173

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 9 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

58 Williams, Lester

Water line hookup Replacement of residence; electric hookup

2/21/1990 no response

Hopi Tribe actually approved

59 Manygoats, Bessie

5/4/1990 denied

Hopi Tribe actually approved

60 Yellowhair, Joe

Replacement of hogan

5/4/1990; 10/22/1990

Denied

61 Loretta, John

Replace structures

5/7/1990 Denied

62 Blackhat, Joe

Replace structures

5/8/1990 Denied

63 Keebahe, Margaret

Replace hogan

6/12/1990 Denied

64 Badonie, Susan

Construct house

8/10/1990 no response

Hopi Tribe actually approved

65 Dandy, Cora

repair house

8/28/1990 approved

66 Farrell, James

Renovate and repair house

8/31/1990 approved

67 Farrell, Betty

Renovate house and build hogan

8/31/1990 approved

68 Begay, LaVonne

Replace burned-out home

9/17/1990 approved

69 Adams, Bill

Replace hogan; add utilities

9/18/1990 approved in part

70 Begay, Jessie Lee

Replace burned-out home and add utilities

9/18/1990 approved in part

71 Yazzie, Gene and Lucinda

Replace burned out trailer

9/20/1990 approved

72 Yazzie, Larry

Replace hogan

10/2/1990 denied

approved by BIA

73 Homer, Rose

Add bedroom and repair

10/2/1990 approved in part

approved by BIA

74 Hoschaine, Darlene

Replace shack

10/9/1990 denied

approved by BIA

75 Homer, Marie

Replace shack

10/16/1990 Denied

76 Secody, Grace

Replace burned out hogan

2/12/1991 Denied

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ174

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 10 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

77 Mott, Anna

Replace Roof

5/7/1991 approved

78 Dugi, Sherman and Louise

Repair existing structure

5/8/1991 approved

79 Keebahe, Tom

Repair existing structure

6/19/1991 approved

80 Bedonie, Susan

Renovate and repair house

8/10/1991 approved

81 Smith, Stanley

Replace burned out house

10/1/1991 approved

82 Manygoats, Marie

Replace deteriorated home

10/21/1991 approved

83 Whiterock, Jerry

Replace residence

11/3/1991 approved

84 John, Lorraine

Replace burned out house

11/13/1991 approved

85 Smith, Sadie

Replace shack

11/13/1991 Denied

86 Widehat, Phyllis

Replace burned out house

11/14/1991 approved

87 Martin, Mary

Replace burned out house

11/15/1991 Denied

88 Johnson, Ernest

Replace house

12/2/1991 approved

89 Homer, Gary

Replace house

12/4/1991 approved

90 Curley, Lucinda and Neal

Replace house

12/5/1991 approved

91 Black, Towlie

Replace hogan and add utilities

12/13/1991 approved in part

92 Yellowhair, Loren

Replace burned out trailer

12/16/1991 denied

Hopi Tribe actually approved

93 Bilagody, Elizabeth and Harry

renovations

1/2/1992 approved

94 Tohonnie, Elsie

replace shack

1/15/1992 approved

95 Homer, Joe

replace hogan

1/16/1992 Denied

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ175

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 11 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

96 Haskey, Mike

replace mobile home

1/17/1992 Denied

97 Sloan, Leonard and Family

replace hogan

1/22/1992 approved in part

BIA approved

98 Rock, Mabel

replace hogan

1/23/1992 approved

99 Benally, Shirley

addition to residence and repair

2/6/1992 approved in part

100 Littlefoot, Bahe

Replace deteriorated home

2/11/1992 approved

101 Jean, Harry

replace hogan

2/28/1992 (original); 6/17/1992 (revised)

approved

102 Littleman, Huskie

replace hogan

3/2/1992 Denied

103 Bennett, Esther

replace home

3/12/1992 approved

104 Tsosie, Harry

add to home

3/16/1992 approved

105 Cody, Rosemary

replace home

3/17/1992 approved

106 Johnson, Lee

Replace building

3/19/1992 approved

107 Yazzie, Sally

Bathroom addition to existing residence

3/19/1992 approved

108 Mann, Alfred

replace hogan

3/19/1992 (original); 6/16/1992 (revised)

approved

109 Yazzie, Zella

add to home

3/30/1992 approved

110 Edgewater, Zella

replace hogan

4/14/1992 approved

111 Yazzie, Sandra

utility hookup

5/5/1992 approved

112 Scott, Leonard

add bedroom

7/23/1992 approved

113 Manychildren, Mary Lou

replace trailer

7/31/1992 approved

114 Boone, Allen

replace home

8/6/1992 approved

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ176

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 12 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

115 Benally, Millie

replace hogan

8/12/1992 approved

116 Keams, Madge

replace home

8/19/1992 approved

117 Colorado, Wilson

replace home

9/1/1992 approved

118 Bennett, Bobby James

replace home construction of threebedroom replacement structure

9/9/1992 approved

119 Zilth, Leo

unclear

approved

120 Dickens, Edward

construction of onebedroom house

unclear

approved

121 Preston, Lavon

replace structure

unclear

approved

122 Hoschain, Hannah

replace structure

unclear

approved

123 Secody, Tom

unclear

unclear

approved

124 Yazzie, Kee

unclear

unclear

approved

125 Watson, Lena

unclear

unclear

approved

126 Attakai, Elroy

unclear

unclear

approved

127 Hanks, Laura

unclear

unclear

approved

128 Bennett, Esther

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 denied

129 Dougi, Kee

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 denied

130 Dougi, Jean

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 approved

131 Begay, Lena

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 approved

132 Jefferson, Lorraine

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 approved

133 Lane, Henry

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 approved

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ177

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 13 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

134 Tso, Billy

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 denied

135 Grey, Tom

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 denied

136 Shaw, Florence

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 approved

137 Fowler, Mary

finish construction of house

5/16/1996 approved

138 Onesalt, Edwin

home replacement

unclear

approved

139 Dougi, Belle

home replacement

unclear

approved

140 Farley, Lillie

installation of cistern and septic tank unclear

approved

141 Delmar, George

replace structure

unclear

approved

142 Butler, Billy

replace structure

unclear

approved

143 Hoover, Thomas

replace structure

unclear

approved

144 Bennett, Ella

replace structure

unclear

approved

145 Secody, Isabel

replace structure

unclear

approved

146 Secody, Marlinda

utility hookup

unclear

approved

147 Wilson, Joan

unclear

unclear

approved

148 Bedonie, Gilbert

unclear

unclear

approved

149 Tracy, Nita

unclear

unclear

approved

150 Brown, Belinda

unclear

unclear

approved

151 Begody, Pauline

replace structure

2/22/1996 approved

152 Saliego, Kee

unclear

unclear

approved

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ178

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 14 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

153 Begody, Westley

unclear home site lease; construction of new home; utility hookup

unclear

approved

154 Belone, Wilfred

4/9/2003 approved

155 Yazzie, John B. and Shirley

new home with utilities

11/13/2000 approved

156 Yazzie, Frank and Bessie

new home with utilities

11/13/2000 approved

157 Teller, Darlene

home site lease; construction of new home unclear

approved

158 Roan, Elvan and Laura

home site lease; utility line hookup

2/24/2004 approved

159 June, Jacqueline

replace burned out structure

1/13/2004 approved

160 Begay, Judas and Nora

construct new home and utility hookup

1/15/2004 approved

161 Goodman, Alice and Theresa

construct new relocation home and utility hookup

1/15/2004 approved

162 Jasper, Lena

construct new home and utility hookup 8/28/203

approved

163 Todacheene, Lance Yale

construct new home

unclear

approved

164 Curley, Alex

water hookup

unclear

approved

165 Badonie, James F.

replace home and utility hookup

unclear

approved

166 Bilagody, Elvin and Bessie

utility hookup home site lease; construction of new home; utility hookup home site lease; construction of new home; utility hookup home site lease; construction of new home; utility hookup

unclear

approved

167 Bia, Andrew and Cara Jean

unclear

approved

168 Billy, Llyd and Nora

unclear

approved

169 Allen, Rosie

unclear

denied

170 Bracker, Norma Jean

unclear home site lease; construction; utility hookup

unclear

approved

171 Bighorse, Darrell Reed

unclear

approved

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ179

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 15 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

172 Begay, Mamie Yazzie

homesite lease home site lease; construction; utility hookup

unclear

approved

173 Yazzie, Johathn and Corina

unclear

approved

174 Nez, Ronald Herbert and Flora

unclear

unclear

denied

175 Belone, Frank and Diane

utility hookup home site lease; construction; utility hookup

unclear

approved

Alcott, Mike and Hatathlie, Carol 176 Jean

unclear

approved

177 Belone, Patricia

construction of new home unclear

approved

178 Denetsosie, Lester and Zonnie

construction of new home unclear

approved

179 Burke, Jimmie and Irene

home site lease

unclear

approved

180 Chee, Keith

construction of new home unclear

approved

181 Manywhisters, Sonny

construction of new home unclear

approved

182 Hanks, Emma

construction of new home unclear

approved

183 Begay, Leo H.

construction of new home unclear

denied until further review

184 Grey, Tom

unclear

unclear

approved

185 Bennett, Esther

unclear

unclear

approved

186 Hadley, Jerry

construction of new home unclear

approved

187 Keetso, Charlene

construction of new home unclear

approved

188 Sloan, Charlie

construction of new home unclear

approved

189 Chee, Rose

unclear

unclear

approved

190 Scott, Doc

unclear

unclear

denied until further review

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ180

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 16 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

191 Hoover, Thomas and Anita

utility hookup

unclear

approved

192 Little, Laura

unclear

unclear

unclear

193 Cattlechaser, Dennis

unclear

unclear

unclear

194 Bilagody, Elizabeth

water hookup

unclear

approved

195 Keebahe, Tom

renovation and repiar work

unclear

approved

196 Zahne, Dewey

replace burned out structure

1/26/1996 unclear

197 Begay, Lena

replace burned out structure

1/26/1996 unclear

198 Neztsosie, David

unclear

unclear

unclear

199 Ashike, Violet

Repair and addition to house

11/7/1988 unclear

BIA approved

200 McCabe, Alfred, Sr.

Repair and addition to house

11/7/1988 unclear

BIA approved

201 Babbitt, Louise

powerline extension

unclear

unclear

202 Shorty, Billy

construction of ceremonial structure

1/9/1990 unclear

203 Williams, Lester

construction of ceremonial structure

1/9/1990 unclear

204 Shorty, Billy

construction of replacement house

2/5/1990; 8/10/1990

approved

205 Miles, Cecil

construction

unclear

denied

206 Gleason, Mary Lou

construction

unclear

denied

207 Dickerson, David

construction

unclear

denied

208 Bahe, Benjamin

construction

unclear

denied

209 Wilson, Harriet

construction

unclear

denied

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ181

Case 1:88-cv-00508-EGB

Document 106-25

Filed 06/02/2008

Page 17 of 17

Individual Tribal Members Name Description Date Submitted Hopi Response (according to Plaintiff) BIA Response

210 Lewis, Dennis

construction

unclear

denied

211 Begay, James

construction

unclear

denied

212 Begay, Percy

construction

unclear

denied

213 Francis, Michael

construction

unclear

denied

214 Coppermine First Baptist Church

homsite lease request

unclear

approved

215 Bilagody, Michael S.

utility hookup

unclear

approved

216 Preston, Johnny and Mary

homsite lease request

unclear

approved

217 Preston, Lucita

homesite lease

unclear

approved

218 Jean, Harry and Mae Lee

homesite lease

unclear

approved

Exhibit 24 to United States' Motion DOJ182