Free SO ORDERED - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:07-cv-00753-JJF Document 33 Filed O1/08/2008 Page 1 0f 2
a , _ In IN THE STATES DISTRICT COURT ‘ I · .
‘ _ I TCR DISTRICT OE DELAWARE- . n 92 A
I _ I SIEIQIIE DIAGNOETICS ep;-·_qtAT1©Ng,yN@,, _ · ‘. _ I_ I -
COIlANGE· INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, .
I ` I I Plaintiffs, - ‘ v I " ‘ ‘
l ss. _ ` ._ _ Civil Acti011N¤. O7—'?53 IJF ‘ ‘ _
I I ABBOTT DIABETES-CARE,I II _ I
y _ INCORPORATED, , · : L_ _ I · .= _ `_
E ABBQTTDIABETES CARE SALES I DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL ‘
H I _CQRP`ORA”I`ION, · I _ ·
BAf£ER_HEALTH_CARE,LLC; . _ I ‘ _. _ I A
I DIAGNOSTICS DEVICES, INC., , _ A I I
, Ltsjiiisé>si `I 1?rt>ié*2$i:B*1i§}}i1iUiC·AL ét‘jRi>C$t SANVITA INQCRPQRATED, . j - - _ _ ‘ “
. P.¤fs¤¤ss*¤¤-_ . A · I I ‘ I _ I
I _.._ I ____ . I .
A _ ‘ I _ ~ ··I " _ sé-Nv1rA INEIIZERPORATED ‘ _ -
_ I I‘I?1ei1Itifi’S?IiIQ€hé,-P.],ji§QS“0s1icsiII®bei·eti0rIs, Inc. andIQ¤fa11ge Intematioiial Limited,
_ J `as i‘ROCHEI",I filed B. Complgint for Patent Iniiingement
A _ I Ii§"&iiINnnnnibnn 21, 20U7,e.l1egiug i:nfri11gement0fU.S.Patent
Iietiitidant Santtita Incertsorated ("SANVI”I`A"). _ I
I - sinne ef the C0mp1air1t,· ROC1;IE_eud SANVITA have dismissed the acts qf
QEUQGII-'E`II”}f1'—i[lg€IIfiICIIIt:1?$K_?S&§NVITA· ·z:lleged-in the- Complaint.- In the eeurse of ttiese discussions,
sziisixxtny hes innate-iiiéfsiixesi-nniseptnnénwsnnsin.ii0eiaé;?">f-3* ?` ·-`‘“ · . I _ ‘- ‘
I L ‘I`` i A `‘II I A A

‘ Case 1 :07-cv-00753-JJF Document 33 Fnled O1/08/2008 Page 2 0f 2

Q 2:522%iii?-@?2?·isi5§§§2§§€ =?E2£-3 JV. sl? 5 : Tai E5.}; £.€..;·:é2f:=?¥2 2*i:Q2§.E%*}§;E§**%i32FE?2;.iS;j Q.§ §€.`2=§ . $:225 :€Zi2: 2` V?¥= .9 I: V=-2 QT- -*T:2 FIQ *;; 27-*3:af-i? EL3.; .¥§;§2'?e:2Q€:V.Vi5F;.:2¥.*Vt?F?22 *25** *§I;:€ .`f%$éJ%;€ ?E§§.’ 2€é2§:Ei§?$.E€E§iii5f?&222?2€i
· MV ;§{if{§!L€Q€;QCE§:E*}Eli?.: : 232. .22.: l*‘;fgF.`{`E·E*:EE 2222:22.;·;aV·:=.2:-:22.V2:=.a:-V.1;2=2V:2::-:22--2:·=;;-;_;=~·=_·.2 2222-:5.%. ‘,r; 1. `;; ;`::~.;{.§.;:; QI@11:,IEj·;E€·E`¥-ELEEI--LEE: -V:e=-1-2V.: ?·;$$i:€·—.€-':.:1-E-iii':i;;E:2.?§L;’:'$E'--i£EgLLE22;’*531;`é31·:.:§;1;.é::;:g§-Q
` I

¤;fT-;-?.#=;`:;2 = 3 .i:=-::1*:- ;*· -22;-:222.2-2:;-2>22222-2-2-1:22222V.¥:@2-2: ¢‘-- 2 22A
-;.:;:2-.2-.-27--;.:a::2$;_:;-22:2:;.1;; +2:.2:;:.;=.;.;.;= -.2.; I —;=; . z;;;.g;;.;..;;;;-.2.:.V;.;;2:::;.ea;.;.:_;:;;::..=;;;=;:c;:7·;.:¤:;.;.z:1=.2;2;:-=_.2~2==2_ ;V22;22;4

· =`-
= *~ *‘‘ V 33=

·‘*· * ‘·‘· ···· ··3- ~·-— 2 =-·· - -=3·= V - .··3 q:2::.-.-.-2:2-:·:-w:z::=i2i=.V .r_·:<2V2-=2;<¤ .‘-e z
‘ =‘=
: 2. 2.;.-; .¤=:.V$.~r:.-.2;:2.2.;-V:¤; :;.5;; .;:2::223:22 :2::12- V;=2=
3’3

2 fas-:2?€5?=?£2=!g:·:*:**?I:*ii=2-.12.:5.é==&ié2$1:2*%252224212%-2-=.azs·:E.: L;:i2..::£¤I?z·z;¤5..;;:3`[€éE&3i&$-·.2§..;.€i.2;?€s:?F22E2’?§-??§§5¥l>27-3%:5: :-1:s V=.V.:~: 2 :2 2·:;V.V2=22·r;f.s :22 fra `~.i ze:-2:=2e2:~.:2.2-2. 2-2-2V=:2:2:
2 &:!ifi::.·my:.·¤.:£.2.§1.:22é%S&S:£s2:%2.222&.3£é:ésiw5€F3:&*222222P2€s2i&;2;222¤.¤2222 5:+152;.klL15?£§J§5¤VT:V¥—~:E=¤-I-$4I=¤-2Eé2:;:-I-*&2;.s.2=-2II§a:£V§V·::§&l:-?E':&;¢;-:*.;:2-2:2=:~rI2:.=:=[~::;:.:.=2=:.. ;:=I.aa: .:·.V.é—·:..=%22-·?s~=I:=·J·¤=¤-¥:¥2iE@@.5:; ¤:V=::Ir··::.I]:~=¥=·=i=.=V;V·=·=2.-:..2 2-:: V:-.2..:-.V.=2-: 222 :2::::.:22:2e2::221=22122=.-:‘22.P£
2 Eigijiii {$2.;*EEE?E5‘7.'$€Cti%}5"€?'?E&€=¤=£=,*£2;i2§2E&EEiiE}§;:;€’¥§;Ei§&::¥€&L252E;;iI‘.2i2.. ;;gg;5_;;|f . F- i; ~. 2 -w_. ..; ·:gq.,:~:·--<—·¤‘·-·-M-:.-I IY~-5:;;; -·=§i¤- =·--5. -2 -2: V:-5..--:g::2:¤·:—L¢!·¤·;2= IF·¢=·V‘-4é}.fLQf-*¤·E=2..' ¤22a;.;.._.==—r§+ NV}! I2-*%·=:II?E"¥Q§;_€§L;"§§*§_: :-.-3-2.:::;;_;:·:-.—:;-:V;;:;:;2V::;;:.:};¤¤ -‘ .3;:1:2 5;$=·
i ?4’?2@éE‘Cé:§1=¤€ fj fi-;-2i:¤ :2%;.
2 `‘‘` *‘I“·=“"V‘*¥“‘“VI*V‘.IEI‘:*V**‘V*-*'*.:`*“--` `I **2- 1*-' *I» ii-?-¤5’==Zg:* V-#2>=:*=¥=¤a.=::¤ V·:E*·**F*I"gj·*Q.'.<*éM2l1%=:;%%<:¤¤V»V¢-2;:--»5 g-gjw.-~:~;g;2:=;V:-_;g.;.:;:.:.2. ·.--.=:;=g;=:g§sg5;.;32;=xp.-;·V;.=5;:;,=¤-z
eeee
. $2:.:: .;‘. ;¤2V=.-:2:;::jV:.Vs=:=:·.-Ir-=4¤;2¤.;·;V2 .2..:;:21:22:..:2.2;-%&
‘3*
:2:21-222..5522.22%;:2~aF%&;:;-:.::-;:152-:22:22-L2-==¤¤é=2a2-3:22:3.:si .an-.2:..-222;:::3=::;·:;;:;::;·:; ~: .-iw-.-;-a2=-2?2·:F;éE-:;; iV;§.j .2YV=-2=.: =.22V{=::2.·2.=.:i·:-. ::.2’.=5--5;-{ .22Vgg5,:;;;{;g2}ggg-gi
2 §;$=-; 2 :::-:;:--*22: :·- ·.··· ri —-».· ;;:¤s;:.V;-:2a¢-VV:=;2::.:-::::1:2. »-; 1i e-~. :2: 3`e= =.._;,.—..<;=.:::»;.:.-..2-22:;.: ~.=· w;.;;. :;;_..;....._;2.;-:....=

I =‘=
2 33‘33 2·;‘fT if- 3-·= J2=:iii-éV:¤%-:-2*:*2F**2¢V§2i*JVaf2*<52%f:*i-2* .‘-` §2..2-2-$2-r:2=ie;=:<

, :£3`V.i-j::.i.'i7i ~ -3:: i 552: i;;E*:T?E-J£’-2`=i;T§§¥·£2§§§=`.V2;=`V`e.TZ.'i§ F?5‘.i 2 :`i:§;~;=é‘ ‘_?.:;.2§*·E 2Q;.`?V 1 {iii: ‘ i-F=fJ~ `EF Qi: .*2=`;}.£5.;`.€?élZ€¥2:T=:‘El-ii ;Y;i.:2‘E§.iEZ;l~ EQIP: *;§.':FL= ;}'Z1*.§?2§.,;§j,§2¢;§.3Fg§,:2§§L¥ §§§§§2FPg§€§;§;§5 f2.;=Qi.E.2_$
I
2 `ll ‘**-*2-*2 -e‘-e-
=*‘ m=:=::=¤:.=:¤.::=::.:¤::·.:::::·=:e::.5-ZEE@&E§*£B5£!§£=.i,- L. Vi.; ,sZ: » .zi;Vai.. .:4:¤ ,2=.VV V` saw _:: -5:; 5;;.1.;: -2.V V2;_ = *1-; V; ;V..-;·= V 2:; V f' . ;V;VV ·'*‘' V VV‘VV 722; g_V="g;>jg--V.?j_j_§VV*_;;.2§.;·gg=:,;,.;§¤_-;.§s~_
.;t_»x,. .#Q.;E- ;?_-
2 V».‘1
I V.‘ »‘·
- :';;;:ig';E;%_E1g:§rjgaggga::§5g;;_:j{E-:1:·:::V5 IVW--’:.*:;F_;:g..*, *,* eq---El.---:-·-;::.:.:»·':·· ·-:.:.·; Eb: V".; 22-..;.éV ",..:...·.:.·1.: .::2.;-;.-_` ::;-:;;..,2;... :._;`..r·..;.;.n;..:EI ·:,: 5 - ,` Z- ES `J in ;::..:\;.2»:..£.·,:_;1;=.;r-;;:V.r,` :_ .r.. :.;}.1.::::, ` L:_`.§£;__`-:-_ I-_;-EU.--gg:-;_Ee*
g
3‘¤.V ,V-’

I VIIII
. =. s:::;:.a¤z¤.2·;.: 2- ::1. -4222--221EV .:212 =.= 22 -s-2 2e V.·..· .2--Et-=2 .:= 3:.::2:-<;-2;..:-2:+:.2V:z-2;-2V: :i¥i?.`3E .1-2532§22.a2*=T-.*$%·.s*
‘ *=- 2:..zV.¢=»;V;i;. ,·—=. ;_I ..=.V;.;222:;:22;.2..5-:22:::;.2s=;.2:aV2;.-rs: IV.V s.z.2=:..::.2;.:.--=-= »I=.== ...;·
I 2V 2
:
+.2::+:;.;.2.V.¤e.;;---:.2.:2.:.2 --I- 22-:-- -‘·.- . ¢-=;i;·#.: 2·;.:V:;V; Iee. .:.-;:-:2;; 3-.—,e.:=;;:s..-e I=== V
I = r$.izT2V~* r-:-;;:€.Q%V . VVI ‘+ % :..V @2;.- s122:;V2a.22-.·;;2=:;:A:z2;:>;:..;-:.I;:2: -=--V 2 e?-EI
I ---:1;;:::-:-22::6:2-+%E-2-2::2-;;}:;:2-1E?:Ié%*L%EE.E£EF5€*?'i¥.F·¤'*LE¥.%EEééi£*£'§€:£E*22¤22=1:;22¤¤22<;;.,V@,.2 -223- --V:.:.;..2:'-:;!2"2¤.:-V¢¤*'F~.';V :.Vir1 V_ .=‘2‘“`Vg..:.1V*V-'-2;:,--.·'€'.= = =-'1;·;"’..-"’V.‘; ·;;·:?:"§•i.:.=.E$;·...;J: EA ':·§"`I.Z¤iLi._:,;.:.·.: .; .· -.; :.:-4;--..==2.=-g:.;=-:-.:7..2-_¢.;_t‘_V`;'=.EE.,-:;F::ZV._V5.;£;S ,*15.,1
I V I·-` ` IS? 2- ‘s¤sV-:iH11d.:f-¥%s¥aSs ` -afcd·w1tJ12th1si- 3; 61**- *1 98;]:: ‘" ¤I3*6G13S"t1tL*i JJ-:zu?-;¢;:V2-¤..2.2= IVI- li
V;· ..;V
- .I - .3-..;¤.2V. ·2.i:¤¤:>2 I.‘»V ; - VII=· 5.: ».=V .2 ·;II 22 2.;. VI-. .:.2 -V-=.= .-..>.==.¤.® 2V...-.;1.:: 3=3= #22:.1-.:22.2 IV- sz;-;=:-:.:.2.-a·‘22.22r.*V.2.V.2=:?-.2:-F
··I_ -
.-- I=..-_I -,--
; at-EcE2:222221.2.=1&!>2&é‘I*5£iF*¤LE2h;: 5:15:sai5IV;E2E·§Z;E§I.:%.€::2i1S;;i.5::y.§"E2E£!-:;:3m:. .... _:;..¤;:§i§;.;§:j§5;.:;gi;2'§V£·I§.E.*3.;; g-;§-1_=-Ti:-_.‘.5i:.t.=V;.--V. 2.3=;V·¤Vigj §.V;g_V.I=V.§V:2V...$2;.=z.2§-&:.;;.2:.:;2.2_2j:;:2¢fs:»22 =- _=.= -2; r-`r 5_;-:3 -;.5 -;;.2. .>=. ==~ =·-..-.;=;{..%:V-2Vg-.V 2.‘_2;{‘;*;;-_-;;.~`;_-._=}.;-:_; ::.2.;:.;:.;:. ;:g;=::._g;:
I EV =5V:? za -:: rV:.V=¢.V-V‘;=·ZV-2~2.V2%:V=TI·- -*I*€?'¥€I§¥§"*iEiE:""??T22E=§Ti*·5*5YVi.V.i `§€:iI— 2*:;:2. .*2 *2.:5 `I`` 2 "=TEE:}=2-.:1C=:-<:=2.'-»:~:=-2::};-2V:=.2==.-2 §¥2=22E..·*-=-=`i*-
·.V.= 2 .-12 .=-== .r:.;~s=I22-2.::::2: Vr-. V... -2- :=—:¢- U-E VV_=V ;Vi:.=.:.&2.:_:-.—;.; .~»:V.. >:; -c-V2-.:.;·=4=*--.·i2¢.V1-sé
" `V `; ‘ .€2 .3. ‘V;V§22 -2%* '. I I L ."*?"`.2 ’§.=:-Y EI? =";E:I-53 Vb "VV.i:=: `.* -V=2 Ei _.V‘_‘jV.‘i‘:i;:;;r .,‘, V ; :."1`.ii`.`*-=€;,¢`Y-*55?`:`=§
--% V;·; 2 »=.V .-·:. .I.
2 *;*5:: -FE§C*i€~Q5`V; $.*;..2: ”2..:Z V:.tj-V5·*2.51=`21*_*F.1·.;-§;.?=*L;1§§·§‘;*j.;2.2‘.V. {..]:5- J-2. _V..;{_.V;V2 I-,2;:-’2.?f-.1;I·1V;2j;=§ i:*.:.=Iii-·:`·.*·P;..;-:`Z-1:*:`:-5C¤E`.2.2i?V=3f§=?*-::
" .`V- "‘-.
. -.?:.V2=2:·~. *.2 :-:V=» .; ..*.‘ ·-.. 2.:+ - ·._ 2V-¤=..V;..-.= ; VV=.= a.-V.VJV.=;¤: I=. 1..;.;.-; A.·.. -
E .... ` *25.*:. V‘--Q hi} .-.5. V:Z.I.i` E l*Vé2..V§2*-;*§.-. 3*.-l?.* :*.5;25-¥T-2E.;*i2.2-2V·£2*ia%*§;-1**2-*-if2E2$*»i2:?;22;2
.... e:. ·V V 3i -=%Vf e.......... . 2..:2.-:.-.:.:¤:.....:..... : ~*=V .V :2:: 21 Q-: .:1-::2-:* :22 {:2 2?I"=:5I:‘.E‘€}: Q- `f2 -:2**.% Viz:-;V2>12.·=*.1`Zi.2
;;
_-:.= V ·:I- ..,_ ,·—=:_-
-:_:
V_V: V..V- fi
I ,::= ; -¤=-¤ :.:V ;=:·31&;*:séi=Vii.~;V;=- i-=2.1;-2 2-2-t.-a;V—.a:=.;:a;;2_=;..:2. _:_V 5:
Q 2:2£&:=§&.:Q?1§**:22s¢2a;g3; VV‘` ’· Q§Q§§*`§*"*****·**'*=·****gj J- rig.-;] ggjj.Q._‘_E‘;:*`i ij-.E_’-.*g**._·-g 2:; ;:EVf€"gVf:`*&§:§*·Q; ‘`·‘ -g_‘¤=j‘j 212·‘1;·~:g2:§5§;=¤2;§:g_.¤·::g§;.{. g;`j;V2_2—.:.g:_· *;*2 { ::;.2-.-5.2:;-;-.2.-. 2.-.; E-:-.-._--x:-:_.;-:;;..:5.
5..1: 2..: *.*- 2V:i..;:;2.=.=2;.2 x2..=;:;a
2 :·*- ,‘. V ..‘ .· _.·.
A .2 VV-: V. IIV2>V2s::II22=:.:V:.; .=. :.2 a.2&V:22=;¤ -1 22:2-i .·.V =j·2&·: V=:€;::.2;s1::V¥
E =€="?.¢·-:f·:=::>=:a:“:gII.-`E=’*Z£’5::£:;·&¤--:2-·=¤=:-2-*i:—--s¤|;eF.—j—¤->=»==rifqIL.l1J=]'gii,;-Lfff-2-1I1=:.iI!.g<¤{‘-:.g.:.:»·-:. .·$·4—;:;-..V-·: ···· :3 :··.;¤;.V ... .; E 2: . ; ~ ·- -. mz. J. --I·-I·>I·~--·¥?- —*~-S{1—¢?1¢IF;-**1-·-'-{2I-l=='. CSE. ·. V- .],' 1. I I II I-I I Ir;-¤.-V-;--;;,; . .. :-,: ;. :.;.:-: ..., -.;-.::-.. .. :·;..=::
, eg1-%;;.;;:;;;:EZVQ`Ei?-Ei_;w._EE@§E:?£a;§_i:Egfffgaw.3..-.:-:1::-:=f::»:=·.::~`.- --; :‘" ;·-:-e·—1=.'¢·..=- .~·e-:-·~;-:-·-·--;.-:·;- -~~-~ -1-;_j;;;;;€-.-{_ _: V- -i it-.._:;Eé {Enya: :5;:: 1;::: -:2--:-:: ;. :::.2;. _-.:2-:.2.:;;: . gf- =r: 2-¤:a»zE`:_;.. -5-..-Q. H_VE;;{=-...;_.¤.:.{` ;. .-.__;E;- -;.3..- :5.5 ;, .5;-
.V=. ·.*.V -.·V
2:*::2 2—2:i¤s;:, .2 :.2;.22. -:;;..3; gag-2:: :.-V2:.-,1._< ..
2 ..V T:. 1 ... —-V. . T. VIV==VVV-VVV»-VVV-‘‘VV i -I`V i - :1 ‘V ·VIV‘ VV‘V‘‘VVV 32.. ·VI`VVV :2 V" 225-; *V‘ `‘‘* VV‘V .i=.-rj-V-:¤2¤ .-_= 2: VV·=V 2::2;. ».V- ;eV2-.V-1.::-.a
: ..V. ..·. 2 ...V
: --—· > V-—- - =··= ·--·· 2 *-=- ·V-VV ·V=V :.2.;: -- ..:-:..2:.2:.:;2:;:V=;2-==-:2.*s;2=- ..V- ;=-. ·-V- *.:—.;;.::.=·:=y»;-.
I ¤-V ?·-’·I .-I2;-?*I:;;Y.V‘?I = .: V.V. 2%;- I; 2 2:¤2*?I;=?EYV22;¤.;...1 »... .:.».....e:...:2-¢;:<:-r=e
:;*15 Z=.=.i.Te§.i-i:1;?:;:: ·. >*V f~Z 2*:*- :‘::iZ: *-:2 ¥;*¥V:. `2ZVV iw: ..:Ji-:?:;5;`~2:£E. 53;.52*: Vi<:VVé:·VV

. IV—
if 1 : VV ` i‘ ¥?2E.¥:"2. VZV*=25£:ii:" :9 as "’ ```` TQ' ?é..Y.;Z =. :. :'§ ’.·`i·? *JI- F`.·i§*l·< ·2"’Z'??`:' :"’E*;2·1VV*.f§.-`Vf-.£§§:VE=.=?:7.:it?-F?§·22?~.=322iV=-2*3:12.
‘V=‘ F
.;;-:.;...2::.-wp 1 -·~— :·- ·::-.v:..,..-;·.¤... . 4- #.2. I-!;=:..-..;.-..·-u--:r»-er-*·.»»~.·..yr. n.. . .... ..::.... .. .:.:~.... .. . . . ..,. .. I ->¤.·--~- .~ .. .. ». .-. . - -: -.,:-;;- ;--q-.. -2-- .- . .. .... . . .... ............ .
‘ ~..· 2--:;2:..=:.=:-=V.i2V=:;;:·¤I·;·.·;;-;:¥?¥·:-· .. 4;*. -..· ==:::».222···=--:2-2 ....;._·—;.;:..:_;·:;:; ;::::·~<=2.=:=s'r2==2:+—2=~¢:%=V52¤;51~‘Jf¤22`.
.V·
2 :‘-. .V·~V: V::= I-.-`~Y€'°€?TI.?`~¥°?I.`-·?V.2‘=*YY*%}=`F;? iii; if-tif =i`a€`.IZZ2`I:;I-"Z=`E€*; i.‘:;:i·2.:J-i- -.-.*22 ‘»‘=
: -:::;-}.::2 mx;zh;.::1:::::1rmr::w:::.::c£--ze:2:::-..-:5:-":::I5;:-.'--E:i!{;E';.E;...-·:.=.·:·;·:::.;*?:1.-BI. E-i ‘= -¢= 2 V -T-1*2 E"-::¥i**:=- *<" - V ‘* V**V- ·- >V YV 'cz M - -2-: =VV ::• V a: ; . 1: ' -. ¤ .. ‘‘‘‘V ·. :-·:.:-. ¤. ::;V-‘¤5‘;*;EE *772} [5;:-.3 ;{;.j;._.;Vg ggihgjg u-E
.2¤2V©g2.:.22n2:2:;:::2%:222:22:22222222222:23;;;--2222.2.E;2·:¤2:2::::::22;:?.::;-::22.:.‘22.:—.;V.=.:2..:=;€.‘%·*2- 2 =.-:.*4*-.:£?=.;5£.`·.l':Vf*.EJ..§.i%.2"=5V2*=.2*=2§~ *2 * ~. ;.L" * V ~- 2V; _ ;:—V **2. .=i~::.·::2~;2.=2.V::~==.fV.-222t:.:=>-:=:=.-2.:1
.*”` ·=--:
2 =.¥!=*Z- ’;`.**2.`€2 1;* ***¥· : -===*= 3-%-:.:; 2V ’¥E*=·V'~.*V- V- %===--- " :. V. 2*5::*-?2`*-§;1·:-Z-:-`=
g jg sz .--. -_};‘;2~j-..;;;.5:.1-.;_·j V_·.‘ 9:: ~..r;- .*-V. 3- .V-_ 1.;...3;;.
*5 . . · V; Z-V>j‘V;—:”:l£ . lik . V ;j ._V. ; V f I ii?. EQ?} rg.
Z:
E !*2*.‘:}L**=;*fY?éJ"I‘%>I?E%E‘i%:¥f='i ‘VV* f*i*=VViIVf?¥¤V."€§.:f =`. 35 ‘V.* *22-"1`VV.-.*2
= =;·¤a;=-2::.: ·::;;::·;::;·..-::-:;:::::-;;;.$.~(.;1‘F`[iii;,;}.*;;3?;,eiz§“;;jE:V-;;;-[3;; 2:Vs;:V2Q;;;V-:.;1—2=V;:V .; ~ gz 5,; :V 1_ . I . ._ - -; : , ···· -. ·.:; _ - .- .7 -- V.V: : . ;· · ..¥i~~;4f;;‘,g-:;-*;-2.:-::.::;¤:_.5-:3:-:-27;::.: :;;;e:;:;5;5=tV.=V25.V§J=VV= ;a¤=;- j=.3*;;.-‘.q pg *2 .. . :. V;;_ jl I: .·.·; ;. gjj :-g. ;._g;
::.— · I -=-. ._--
.-*.' ·‘.. .—*` ‘.’ .’V`*`
.V~V. ..2-‘ VV--.
2 V'‘‘ ‘V'V
I 25V;-Zi "..: :.-·=2Q.. .‘.= .. "V-V. ; Cgi-:-2.2*: --"- ?>.V2·é%:. ..V.‘ 2

.-.. :
V-.2;·V:222:oe2X22.2:22=.:::-2.;::.2:2-*2::::-2-1 -—.2 ::-:2::2-:::-==.:.·.:¤:—:se--:.-::2·::=¤2:.-. :V -V=-2:-=e2:2::·¤2=:2-:2-==----2:-·2 VVV- VVVVVV VV’V::‘2:-2: :-%V=-->A

Case 1:07-cv-00753-JJF

Document 33

Filed 01/08/2008

Page 1 of 2

Case 1:07-cv-00753-JJF

Document 33

Filed 01/08/2008

Page 2 of 2