Case 1:04-cv-00163-GMS
Document 264
Filed 09/25/2006
Page 1 of 8
IN THE UNTED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
DONALD M. DURKIN CONTRACTING , INC.
vs.
CITY OF NEWAR , et aI. Defendants
and
: CASE NO. 04- 0163- GMS
CITY OF NEWAR Third-Party
vs.
Plaintif
DONALD M. DURIN CONTRACTING FEDERAL INSURANCE COMPAN and URS CORPORATION Third-Party Defendants
ST. PAUL FIR
& MARIN INSURANCE
COMPAN Intervenor
APPENDIX TO FURTHER SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF OF PLAINTIFF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SANCTIONS UNDER FEDERA RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 37(b). (c) and (d)
POWELL , TRACHTMAN , LOGAN
CARE & LOMBARO, P.
Paul A. Logan
Delaware Supreme Court il #3339
475 Allendale Road , Suite 200 King of Prussia , P A 19406 Telephone: 610- 354- 9700 Telefacsimile: 610- 354- 9760
Attorneys for Plaintif and Third Party
Defendant Donald M. Durkin Contracting
Dated: September 25
2006
KOP:350748vl 3514-
Case 1:04-cv-00163-GMS
Document 264
Filed 09/25/2006
Page 2 of 8
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DOCUMENT
Carol Houck Handwritten Notes of Telephone Conference dated September 2003 City of Newark Delaware Council Executive Session Meeting Minutes dated
February 2 ,
PAGE
2004
KOP:350748vI3514-
----.-...__.. -- -= -.-
___ =--.........._......._=.._ ..---'-----" ...,. '" ... ... .. _-.---'........
~~~ -\ .---.- ---------~~~-- '--'~~~ ------.\." '\~~~ \- ~~~ --..--------=== -----'- ... ~~~ ~~~,-------() "---(/ ---.--------
.._-
-------
..._.
_..__.__..
___...._._-----...--..-.-...-...-.-.-+- __.--"''''''--'--''--,,,-,----,,,,--,--, '-'-'-j.. _- ... --.-. _._-_.._.._ _----_.. =-' ._._..._._-----_..__._.._-_.----'--'-----"----"-"---, _-_. '''_'-'------'--'-----_.._---._.__....-.--. _._--_... .. .._ ...
._...._ ......... ..-..-.
-'--'
...
_'_'_- -'''-'- "",-" --. ---. "--
..__.
...__._._-_........._-_....._...__. ,,,,, ._.__.._ --.._
Case 1:04-cv-00163-GMS
Document 264
Filed 09/25/2006
Page 3 of 8
IDL..
'I
? 0
.J_...__
kxf
h"_"'" ..
._...m._.
alCU
fl_
\A_..
'h"_'
2-""
?h
fu
rKn dOeSVl
!2oS$1Jl_
(2, /' \,.'0", . -1-L.. \ L'
UJ
. b
wnO-
n.w i +
+-5 Wrkl
~m3-_
tf
h. Wil
Df-
cr!-t OL Ob...-----
L.
0YeY
JO\o
-=il
4Um5
12Y\
*"
(\
-\,-\.-'. .. '" . .. " .
,-,.(' . "" .
\ \
..
' ..., , . .,
,..
.' .'
...
.. ". '''' .. . . .. ..... ...' ''' ..' ... ,. ,. ... . .
.. .. . ... .._....
~~~~ ". '.
....--. ..___.. . .--.
Case 1:04-cv-00163-GMS
Document 264
Filed 09/25/2006
Page 4 of 8
7f (\e-ti Ilt-
10% M
/0
. \ VI
5h Ue.
tIb
WoY
PYV
LVI r
\.JWA
JKt,
"leV\ ?\
reJ Xo.
no I cl
V1
:ht I
PCU '7ftd Atat
... -t
fd00 .
s-I
vi. VhccoJ
lh.S1wlbL .
T;f
fuJt
JiCW
OcCM Cjo% cM aff)OYs
-()m
Y\. O\)G
w::!
bfo
to/1,11
If)
1 \
t LC)v.
\h
yo.
- \f \ntD
e,\e6.V\ ()u.
\ f\
lO\.\6 1\1
to \NorY\
-? \j--f'
L.O'fd\h.
fJ\
\Co
'Dn
C)\Jest?QrJ
(Qblem5
'ftM
-_..__.._....... ......_.._--' _._-_. ""' ""- '"'--""-"'''-''. ''''''''' .."..- -"--""- .--. ........ ... """' - - ...- ...... ."... .__... ,--""'-"-"...-'--"'\.' - ". ._.. " ..... ._.._- .-_...,,..-. -",. ",.,"-"""....._........ ..._.._ _...._._.. --- -"-' .-'-"'-"-.' ,,,- ,,,,,, ,-,,'''''-- --'' ''-'''--''- '---- ...._._- ....._.._. ._. ._... ""-,-,-, .._._._..,.__.__.__.__.,..._._---_._--_...__ *' --'" ,,--"' .__.. -- ....... _........_............,........... ",,' ....... ... """".""" ....... "". .. .._-_. ...._._... ... ..._.. ............''--''-''. .._. ..'-. "'..--. -,_....,_....,,-_. ..__..._.....'-'---'-' ...--. """ -.. ... _.., ...""''''---' ..",..- ''- ' ..._ - .._ .... .-. ''----- ......._ ......... .-... ''--''' "'''---''''''.'-'-'''''' ..-
==:=: -------------
-..
-_.
- --_.
-----.-----..- -------...---...........---..-----.--_ ,---""-_.-------'-- ----"-' ~~: -_._-_._.._.._-==: ----------'''--------_..---_._ "-"- -"" :=:_ :=- -------------''------''--' -.-.-' ==== *"--"-- -------- '------_._- "'-------''-'- -'-'------- ._---- --.----..---. --..----------.. ----------..--.-..----_.-----__.Document 264 Filed 09/25/2006 Page 5 of 8
:--
Case 1:04-cv-00163-GMS
=:J
Dl_.
ur.
Q1=9/Jj
hR....
uPiti1
:1iN .-
i! \!
i0- T(lCiIi1i11iff: tlld
7._---
U -:--------o--....
il_-
=--C
;;I--
r l-L1ni
VI
9--'''--'''------'-_
6Lf o:--J1e_---.-.-.-lJ__
ff_________
\A CA
\ n A
LuJ\-\.
==-ify-
qll
"__0
===
01/10/2006 TU 1:04-cv-00163-GMS Case 13: 18 FAX 302 655 3697
N-10-2006 121
~~~
Filed 09/25/2006
3023667067
&. .
Ak & Rerron 264 Document
aB PM CITY
SECRETARY' S OFFIOH
006/031 Page 6 of 8 02l20
CI OPtUAR DlWAB COVNEDSEON
FEARY2.
'I03prt
at
9:40
Na B8,p.
OodMtAal. 0I 0w J4 ad Re, J)fi5
tt
Abt!
SCs
O:ud Coci MemJo It
Dad J. Ate:.
, IV
Di
G1
Mme
Su A. at.Sa Be A. ta1ak
Ca
l'k Pro, P.R., 1m
Paul
OIF.
loeDolW Fb J're Ge &mll
PtI: Ba Sp CoUf1
reoi an
/1..
Lo, tp
.i
OOTE UTGATJ. Mr. Lo aq!a dle. 'W evm prle wi cont Be Ch Intru= Pal
of t1e
c:U1
th Co J3,
C0
fo Ihe
ot
the
with
t1
as to wor vd tle Oi., bqus tMe wa a dis The lUy co ba uk fo Id th pt mp Ib pothbut atoW netime, W8 .w Rf 1d He coue th st wo.. aaed_1d IUre to tc th bo 'l toll to CO 1) 'I IU COpa wo 1i ao
Mr. Co
Ci.
CO
Tiht.
00
Do M.
S) pu
tM be wa
Du. wi
eotm
Qp QlChfisl tbo
Mr. Lull (or out
fA
ft
105
CO
by
1'eo
to Jint1t dto
It
ou fobid; or4-) tt co
Jtec 2) Je w hoor th
an th pt1ea with
wa au Qt(y opti
wo1d then
Mr. tuft them
exne4 te pr1e1l Wi
fh CO of 8t eo He aontlue by II di WR la CM if 8b c:nc wu thcr we 11 dtspte co of
re pocour.
of
out th
Ia ft,
.I
of the
c:
--. CI
'60, 00.
di not
aJ fo ublUon 10 U1
NEW 14287
..
01/10/2008 TU 13: 18 FAX
pg
Case 1:04-cv-00163-GMS
Document 264
Filed 09/25/2006
3029887067
Page 7 of 8
OO7l031
302 655 3697 Akin & Herron
JAN-10-2006 12137 PM OITV SECReTARY' S OFFICE
03120
Mr. Cott
on th
pqee He wa awa
1aed th
prt wa tbugb
Mr.
ch or.
"
Chen
th dite de with th 6w th th c:tr w; Ih jo at auh a lo bid, th 001) way h co1d m.
Mr. CottU fel
mic:ta
lan
di no
wOJ 70" an to an CX wa noted th WM tb ge to inepn enn=i op. Wh the mr th wa I've faul an ad Bty fr UR. CoUD in Ih hI wa CO ab fUofco. Mr. Con beus of1h DID Th
, it
ctty
Cmudu1e bu
aJ tiu1t." so aug.deco coet dw
CUfttl feitWi
He
Mr. Cot
th
by sag
th dI cotr wa
moey le
Ie
th(!
fi is pr Md not on at tbtoqueti th th de pr. 'l # gall bean wh th chp mfer$1I m or
10 finis
Ie eo
infQnned
ea
it wa' hith do tfc, to degn Wh
by 6IUJI th
th preo and th 8URy
wJo bi OD th
COp1y hlt dec1 Cfat Th
quti wa
rewh th
by
wa enou
fi more
Mr. Gowi fet it wa li queson of th pele . tJt an bag to go to cour ag. He fet tb ba Co be a way Co 1hc prect by the en of ' 04 on budget cvet tbab they an expetl! wI 8Is d1 CUs caee wa wrg. Mr. wa co(1t th 1b teoi wod be bu by 1M et of th
op
Mr. Ba
10
fi th
doe by G. N. Riharn" curt it de .s wa
the
Mr.
dw
pr
fe soils on 1Ie tI fo
fi
Ca
Co Ib
the
ther Wi $6,
4 miU lef fim th p
auat prTe bc the Assa (mt) tJS'
anet
the
ms. Af GN ha:
The sed wa
ba
fur it
op. Th fit tbt coer stap may review of cm' CXpuden by
lo e:l.
ct an serv. cite two WM th the mattng an tb slop was U1cak.
FaIi
" Th
UM, it wa
aled P,. GN des de
inepden tninttg
tllI t Ute
updutng th
to UM
se
. ek
" ma
not vitt th 1Ste
nOt 10 ewWltc
. Igor dees of sucxt
longe than da
ig
ason sifi Btltzreg
Wd diSOiOt wttb UR'
IItc IU
po ccdians; th
px
. fica a
" Idw!t lower af
suMIt\t t1g
that th coer IO or fte unrest fiur 8J uns le.
lary in tefS; lo .top ha ad stiJondur placen an meis
of th endm
of Fabc!orm mattng ptce on $lop
'Fri ma
st
IId
reoJr if CO sos on th
NEW 14288
. )
Case 1:04-cv-00163-GMS Document 264 01/10/2006 TU 13:18 FAX 302 655 3897 Ak & Herron
JAN-l0-2006 12=87 Ptl CITY SECRETaRY' S OFFICE
Filed 09/25/2006
30236B7087
Page 8 of 8
008/031
P, 04/20
sp data. UB ba st
and
de3
Mr. Prty wa also aut)ll thae GNR mab is wiO\ WldD 610 sire Dr fit
in the
P1'
_Ie an cotrta an
wo an att mt de pu an wa stng ag de dota
a1cgQ/J
tc
tMt th
of th
cl with
Dfth deign.
bJd let
reoi
the sit&
bu as de ba it wod In a pe he tfe su comp 1f tw we an not dJt al th Bxt ade.y.
th th
bidd tXutd td
Mr. Pr aug
Wba
fi
ha be
1f ne ste &1td
do md
be
wh st nee to bequa a
be to
cfe. B4
drlment so
it WM
A. 'ney
invc
peed
hae
't:
Itd
'l
be noing
10:57
fuef
diiQs. 1M
Bxve Seon wa atoumed.
Sus A.
Cit
Se
btk. MM
NEW 14289