Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

Exhibit A-1
Case 2:02-cv—O2255—PGR Document 151-3 Filed O9/16/2005 Page1 0f4

Q:
{:,5
J,}
·‘§;. N
{if KQ __
·ig¥ S ..
‘»;> 3 E
‘»
.· 3 sgi? ‘·s.·_g
vs - Q = ¤°¤
v ~ it 3
g = scgé ;5¤5
s LE ·:s~-5.* :..2:-5
4 EEEE ‘~‘EE:"
{Ao 3 EEQE .·s:‘¤§
xé 5 §5;§ 5;:55
rtg ·&*. 5;;- :>~S3;
’ · ‘ Q ¤¤
iz $55 ::55 55€5¤
En ·_;.,§; 229,5.} 5SE§$
4 ¤`U‘·—. Ei = :`,`g
E $555 5=EE ¤°;5
>· ¢=¤`· »;”`E ·¤F »»°·
·¤ ¤~· '= x. ~—s···“
?¤¤° —~=a·.¤s E;~:° ‘s¤¤5z
`§o ag`; n E; ¤·»§g¤.__
L8- =5.§§ f:,§—=:. 5 ~’°~:
·¤5¤· go ac ;¤ "·7¤·‘2x
&g¤§~·~¢§_ ~%'¤’ §`§"·S.¤
ki rx g >.¤·:eE ¤·¤‘;* ¤
N @555 was 5:5:
`
wig :§~55 Eg?} :5$“55
**24 °‘ &°_§?· 8:31*2. ;`E`§`§g
5- *5525. kggsf
`
iu ‘*§§·—°~ ¤¤:¤·&
{ °»¥ *5552: Sggsg
y, ¤.§>°*» SQ `H gg
I`? .E···“2 »». ’*~ "`5E“'Z‘·»:
;~ g§"·- .;¤ IE°·‘2¤¤»~
an =¤ ; . E:-sww
x ~55= s= **55
·‘· ~ ¤ \•
v? §·`= :55
M "¤
5 555: 555
1 ·\ 5x` .,,=¤
gl; _¤_§_g.2 SE;
' : = Etu
a2.: .__¤4`
~ " —=¤ ·~E
‘ ¤55~: :<:»
=>';¤."5·~. =.:¤`G
é ~¤s¤;ss s~¤5
}; __E~¤_,_- Uxaa
zf lg §§·w==§_ ¤E·»
* E¤·;¤_~5_:—= ~·5'·=
F- EEG¤¤>.'SE §'C;E
ii? s§5°z€ 5gaE
ww :»:§.: ·¤ —-5
rn ` ·... E
5* E“s§=5; =¤=·<
V E .Bg\¤_’* ?"¤·>,
gz _.,,,_.`:¤¤ .¤_,¤E¤
S ¤°"E 'CP·¤
°· u§E’·`.IEg ;=—¤&,
_ M ...§,’ _'¤w E*¤z¤
····h.¤.—¤¤ =~¤
. ·~.§`q¤q E§1`,`_`=
$’ MQ Sgaw

r v¤§§§`
~? 'QU
% '*.» ‘§ ,-5
.2; ':· 5 M E § A
E 5 is 5. 5 ~5 5 ~
2 ug wagé "¤¤,;` S
Y tm. E"¤¤ ·”‘;*~¤ 5 A
¤- ae `55~¤ S5°¤¥* 2
<<» _\,§ Egg'; fggissg ¤
;~ ~5{;§ 5¤¤&— 5 a
'·¤ ‘·."‘
Q ~, $*55 ·*·=».~. S35-¤.§ E
v' ».§ "°$.:`¤¤. g~S"·— r:
=·¤=.· E‘*»¤‘·¤~ ¤?‘¤E: V
·g~. °·‘\: ¤¤‘—9: =~;¤¤
S iv g°‘;_$¤ v 4;>.
E; -,g§ Mazza —:§S.__.
4 cn .5¤"¤ ¤~¤-:¤ `¤ E*=.·$,.
•.. B E¤¤¤·— ¤.··»`,¤ »¤
H agi ·g&» g§;§§ §,§s5%:
Z :,9.. EGE ..¤;~§ =~¤°'°Z’·E
035% §s€E %zE§~a §¤aEE5i°
¤ 5 =`g
U2 * ~555 5¤555 5555:;
_
w.A§ ${2 =E’S&`§ s~5—§5.
Zg ZL =' Q; `§§§‘¤.__ E¤u‘:~§
OQ 1 §§¤ ¤¤.‘"Ew >=E:=°'E
c` —» EE ¤.,·=¤·: ·°»¤¤¤
r-• x "' 3 »¢°¤·»··· ¤>,*—¤¤g
9-· 4: #455: 3;-5:451,
4 < "'¤&¤.°° ¤"‘*··2°`·=»
·; lfggsé s§°¤='$
[-• N ·..g_; ‘—\*`§·5;
Z ‘$» ·.. ‘·'s.\•k¤§
hl · q- ;Ep\._g=¤¤
In * ¤§§ =-s-sin
af ¤.¤‘¤ 2;: -¤
Q * GSE $5
En ;"< 53 •.`
‘° ' '*¤= ¤.¤·.
Q N
$91: E.; ¤ 5 *=
:.5. ·<~E Sas g 5
O ‘*¤“a "?¥% €= z=? °.,
E., [‘?·° =¤§—¤ @5 %€2 ?¤
gg Z§¤§ §—¤ 35,% S.? ~5
/· .4 Q
E is 2555 zi 5Eé EE ,55
3 EN .1: _` x ‘
E2 -:2.. Em ~¤s lg s§§
Q 82 ·¤-Q g, . ..: ¤.=·~ Q-
`¤. 'H~E*§* 3° 5255, ~; EE?
¤,., ¤·E¤ ¤».§ ··>:,¤ Q Ek.
; M ». gw ~ ·`;
¤. §..r¤§: ,_, _¤_::> <¤ Eco
"‘ ~-§E:& e§°.A § E? si 2;%
if *— ¤ 522 2 as 5:, ¤s¤
si Q ggé 555s 55. 5:5.
Q ¤"§ EEE? Ss "*-sa
· ¤ == ah `·a 2 ~
·: ¤.,,; *@9; E` ~§t
ii; ¤§_ $5*~— M-E 'E»,"*g
¤~,, E.; €=‘5.§_ §¤ "s·`E§·S
`mg gag ez "3§\, ~>, ·—*=’~E
*”¤· s =·‘ ‘=~¤=·=·; §= 25ms
31-3 H =‘¤ =.,,= ¤ =—¤¤·;
5; 3*; B5 :.¤_§= ggg \.-E_;
5 ~— ah .,‘~£ ¤=s —5—5¤
#*3 >`~ ¤»> ¤ °—= =
i-: gg ==~ 5 ., :5.5 `cgfcs
'éz 5 °R ·— ·s ~~g ~.z¤.=:
M c5 ”*< E 2 :‘·
Mg . g 2¤= E~g wi?
A §,_ gg 3EgE E ., Eg3=
52 gwéa =y ~ =§ Y; a 2
E3 o =· §?» ENES ·¢‘¢.'$S.
... 14 · , U
##56 E3`}? ¤·$ E§¤¤E 2*%
'ggv. sgi;} $5) ;‘§Z8'§ FEE
»_gE-`5 ·¤§ 5:1 AEGEB
J: .v= 5 = ° ¤. ’¤ J wk
=¤°'S ..·“ Bg _E`·—·¥.. `¤.“
Z ·¤ $2 ¤- 0 ra ·`\»
\ 4 gg; -; 3.2;,%*3 j,,·5
.5 · C Z
~ <`·..¤_; ¤ , =E;§; Sag
,5 { ::=¤g NJ; ..... .:3
y.; G-¤:¤ "‘ g¤’° *=¤‘¤
< uU~-4 2 mr: Epi`,
K} Q Kxgi E"•·1:·— ¤
`x ;_ ¤*’.§ %’·¤%'»8‘5 §?`.§
’»* =¤ §.§'52§ T·.$····
i “§ §<°5~— `EEQ
» =» - M 5..=· ;=;¤;
Jo is E =E_g&Z‘ :`>;
#2 =- ¤¤ SU P ~s:;
ni {BE UE 533jo 5`,·\
» =. s- u.-- ,` Q
*2 uc -3;: Elggun. agww
~E 0·v` LE E \2§E
, *-5 Bm - ., 3 5 -.5; 5
‘ >» W U 0 Q
@9% 5** @2 ” E éb &2§~¤
gg., EE :E' lg E "">~§
5%; rag gw fi q,¤§T·;_ E ,
·.*·,, 2: :35 EE .2EuE S
$*2 "¤y; '=§ ”c£c E>. 8
$55 gg; §°§ ..·» ¥»* ~Z ¤i·§=
zésa 2;;; gig ,=§ §§§§ §§gg
* E E-— ” ¤.‘” 0
gig ¤8&§ Eg`? -§m Té=° 8¥`£2
ai.; ` E§__ 3°E g g Eg E-¤§,9`
zgs a§¤:;·g Egg gs aggb gégg
n. a` ¢"u ·—··¤. ... : · _
#2,,; _—..L$E5 axg ais, gEZ§f§ jig E
!;,,a,w· » _ E cnc E: négoug >_
"»;~,§J _·~5 ¤..¢:,, ,. ·-· NQ
Q —{·;€A_,<`¤, bw} , Lg Eg g g [ E ¤_;£ §
xi l§§¤§'£ V ?*·?1§;PQ;—(~i·?`u,‘~»~» , , C.}; ·j E g , ¤ 3 1 3 E ·.. 3
;%* {‘»‘ w§&;·$@@p;»,w 9a ggggg ¤i°¤
5 y;,§$;;, 4,, _f:‘#*>~m·&g;;,, ~~¢¢:i;g {agi.; E E ¤ < .. :2 5 é g §:E
.- wi wg Aww »$ ~~/5 ·,·¤’¤‘» > A ... E; Q E J: E4 ~¤ 2 0 -¤
gp <5,.‘ * A ’Z;1~, · Mzéy`, *?" »»»y*5»Jl_ ¤ 2 Eq · , ,_ .. .5 Q G ,_ A E 7, *5 $4
. ¤§@‘*~;g_¤,~»F ~»~¤»s·m,·®>*~ ‘ {J .‘ ·£·¤» .2E** ¤ ¤>§.. N, En
¤..`,;g { > mul. www *:·~,s¤ M »~ .: ug ».E·S ¤ bv-¤
l<·§;;4(‘\ 5 gi} Z§§;’*i§ f égyfiia ;g:§ T `“r»?qg;; 4 ’~:YQ-?` ". ;> · *2 E § 2 2 § E 9 :5
` ww ~ ;‘.>x%€`*$é »5 ,;·» ·»~· ¤J;;·-ih, ·G?··r"·~,. ~` ’$~ · -§··- E2 gf;
M, =, ’=;#» ,.,>·¢~,»§y>-r·§;~- ‘ sw': ·¤ an *~ ,»·;~,, ¤ Ea. E
" kw»;·5 ZW KY` . » "’*¥*¤*L. “’ M ’*L#W;,‘*`*"“£v » :2. <= E*5=
W.; =,.»,»,_;(7 ·¢·J,M;» ¤ ;;,·*_,:;A{;5;?4~;,U¢;{» ·( < ogm.,
` ; , _ ` 5 ;» pa,} Ja; " mizaw,,2‘·2·~§»i{,*r wi ;;{·`P¤¤~, ?’ *5
V », f"] Mm; :—¢·oi,;¤·<$g;_._`¤,<¤¤:»,;,§·$5_i_\:~~gd,
C ’~$· “{“~¥“L·`£,I§<~‘§’*?i ~,i°Y1’~V··$`¥’?£`.’;’**Z":€;iY;"~;gi:"*$¤» ·‘ \.
ESG ` X “ J T"¤·'·}— ;:A`>’ w»é;;n·L饧*<#w,T%'F1;~’{2:`=iL§g,¢,.‘.,., » ~
2nO 4 ig`:] ( Lyn] _*__PZ‘,%tXi'1§é\ ,.2*14 _—»·g‘. **?6;)'>>};)> A/),»A< {’·
· -CV **-**27** W ?Y?;,;,<;<»y_i‘·,‘*“»;~q,¤r¢‘>Qq>··§{*;L.£§*'·’z_ Ji r»;§~j
v\,\:~»;m ,· ;`;1UQ»,4A rxrxtzvgl _`r)_)‘ NES/`(" ~ >,;;)§\» A 5 »
" ~~y·‘,,, 5f` hx »· K "yv; 5, _ `
5-PG ~·‘,gk§,J ,£,j;_1F;_;_w ,*¤—_<»;.. Hx _\P.
‘ R "‘R`¤’j,j_·:§‘1`,"»"q,VZ¤Yf5’ "_
DOCUITI °` $.`€1?="·—a;/ ‘ S
I " l'\·1:A;" §

i&‘ ` °` w
*2—' E 53; Q ·¤§.§
$1 ·¤·~.>_·¤g` ,A·.. _g>·.
Q5 ¤»=;-¤. o·¤ .,,;» s>
3* »:·~···»¤-: ;»_¤» :..E E
m .¤¤¤.:~¤—- ~=»> ;·~¤>,__
gr »°?‘@¤`%2 3‘·¥ s ·<=·<
5; 5-_¤=»~,=¤ -.;—= ¤<»·<':
»" =¤85¥— @$5 ~§*.*
+ ~5¤ 5i ~xs~5
g, ¤·~·`iEi; §’E EE·¤'§_~
:*¤ E .:
M 5¤=§=‘ ;` 5§§~§
M A~» :~ , 5 w
p ¤E*>_i gi; gs©=;
4 `lbzxnh *3 •»;—=
T; ‘·~·= :¤ °¤ Exwwg
M ~ ~ga~ “¤& =2$EE=
J' E¤·>Z'¤E= ES~ ,°—-§,¤=,•`1
5*35.5sE mg gggaaug
_; _.:¤ K3 g‘E__ .: M;
w ggaggg ¤== 5¤¥*5E
S, Z¤_Mi;;>._ :1* ::‘E¤;x_·¤k;
f = 525 FS Z~s?§°
9 ‘;s‘·$s5: 555 aiww
N 5$;g> ¤¤: g5E€¤=
Aa “)qL§ 50 h=Q‘=b
P 3%§·=$§ 55* $3295E
E5§f@¤ §s§ ;5s5%§
‘ :’:,_.¤§ -¤:E L*§‘E·»§··
¤ *'*·:3*·¤ "'“ *5**652
E ¤¤“**= A A 22E E=€i‘¤
F TQ€E§; g 3E 53% =§‘§€§
° :5*: '~· cc E»—· ¤ §.~»·¤°
3 £58§%: 5 55 :25 £§55§s
E E Q 5*5 2
A ·¤ —. -· LEU N
5 55 :$ 5 555:;
£§ §A xx. w §&3c¤·-¤
•- U ¢A"' "
`Q Eg E? an E,¤»¤EE3
@5 =§1, gg EgE$*¤
A \1_ 30Q=—
*,5 55; 5+5 §%55T‘€i
g 52 :5; 53 5=w5;e·
Q 0-E `~¤]2 GEQ g·1E€,"‘€]§
,·, ·-· " ·- L: ... 543; Mh;
xA ¢¤° Eg ¤°¤. .,, E= `.
,; 3 5 § u §....¢:o;:
W * ° ¤¤a ¤¤59¤
x~ N3", EE: E3; »E{EEg_*~*•
K §£~ 50§ bag Eds-5§§
5*2 -¤ E5 =¤Z¤ :5 ¥6o.x$§::_
$2 5"° ¤ ‘•': E5"'? `·*~
‘W §*§ €“% €§E &?E.%§E
W Tgi &§¤ E“§ ¤E3b§¤E
· “2— s°w ~5~ ;E;@-g;
, 5-° <@ Ang .:,..NUw...¤
U. gui §_“E ¤>":: °-§::E::¤».
»~ Z`.? Ea 2 .¢ 2 ·v;;¤==
5 5·5 5 2 *:5 :gs¤x°&
·¤ .¤~m —~u =;>° 5 ·¤5EE,_
B.-` .-` Bun »`;>¤> =,·;E vga `Q
·» u cv ·u:¤O L- - : ·E.;¤~
"‘= “ u¢E =».,>‘= »8`° ¤ Evo-=¤
gz 3 E gis Es~ = ¤» 5%
V V K3 V wg 05 O¤·.‘E:.E=¤¤
X *2 ¤c

5 ¤~ -
‘·· *:5 ww; ¤ <:;=
- W €?§§B& v9: §&&§
g M `Z—.¤· =:§ =*S`?
\= = xu§E =¤ ,:5§¤é
U Q 555555 <;€ 5;¤~~¤
W M 3b§»Z°< @555 gééig
W ~ »· - ~ .5
· p_§¤f*·~.‘:*.» `E`! :¤’;_`*».lA_
, ~,;"¤>;=¤·5_ :=§·cE .91°§.·=&§
E , 555*555 &§5= ~=A~E~
,· 5;;*-Lug, ¤»~¤ ¤ 5~¤
D- w ¤°¤¤·· °.¤-¤·~ 5b ~¤
Z 7€*¥E€E°»: ·°=|>~&E ~‘?’5;·E*§»`?
— Q §¤§~§$§ ééfg E5¤%:§
¤ M §~;§;5: 55E; 55*525
Q § ]5;;§55 5¥§; giégfg
¤sh¤:c‘.§~—F 2¤'§£*q>,_
•·¤ 8 ia. ¤¤°5 2: == — **:5
;¤_ 5 55555:5 552: $@555
Z ° =%§5§”E ¤,€§ agzzog
g E °’·=~°S·*·=·5° ‘“°$S·¤ §;§{~°<·¤
Q; 2 ¥Zg:;;E 3 3; ‘¤:& ;s¤~€;
UN': *~=¤\»:—‘3 : ¤: :3*~§ u-¤°i;,
¤ §§b¤~E~ ° °° :2$: “&~¤»5
(2éZ >··¤.¤¤:¤k E E5 kowv. E¤‘S‘E:·¤
» 3.:
c` Q}: ¤ am•·‘
Ga ya =a 55 5 ==:
v-4 »¤. E: Q Q_ cn.;
HQ `·S S-9*: ...m:E
< “¤§e% iBE ””s8§
quhg u-~ 35 Q
F y;`g.!‘=.§ ,.7-*; nufji.
Z ESEE :*3: gEE=;>_§
E ·IE'¤§.. EEE ·:.;3;=¤·¤
W *ԤaE Egg gmg E5
a`;7§EUB¥ 'USS cEE£`“’E
"~F§§ 5¤g 5 GEE5
g ¤5E§g»5 5H* C5&§85
w=S¤:a ¤5¤ ¤9v 5
z ~$§·~s=¤· 55: §‘°;»E;¥
*S°**E¥° EEE wgvncg
Ln lhfgwb °*·‘ ¤·:.3;_ .5
_ ~¤N¤:» -5 -·..m Ec
G ¤"‘:1 ·»¤ M manu u
,»»‘,:,a_‘¤> ,.o,¤ ··-..m_,a___
[-4 ,s¤‘¤§·E¤ ¤.>·u ggasui
fgm‘< §< 2 ..5 ·- eu I
Z »~ >` ` vuz v=:--‘§ 3
< g¤5§“5 —¥5~ :==*°5
·¤¤g-§¤ A »—»- Egg'; u;E’5Eg
= @§§:5§ E EE *255 “g¤2y~
Q ,¤>.55E.5 == =¢ “;g§» °:g»·»B
z¤¤<~¤ 5 55 E5¤¤ £¤u555
Q
g Q 5 Ei:
1* REE
· g gv 5%- $,555
~q &g5~ 55E =ga3¤
‘ 55g§ x5; §55=5
A *3*% isa 5£Ei»”
’ °""£¢z c" —"? <¤€
‘ **5 ¤E§ 55.3
ggng 535 Emg.E?
, <'¤ 5, vg" GE_E§‘=u¤
g: ¤ Su; *5 §=2§§
» sgzg aH_ :5~§B5
‘* 5=~E =¤¤ ~25=5~
gg Eg:.-j`,_, §E;¤.’:5¤
1 ¤ 5 ¤@5 ~5~=¤5
5 E5 55; SZ·ii55
" §_ 5 Zio- -‘€-’,E"°*v°
; Kwgg ¤>§ ¤¤gé&;
5 L¤g;°- 9,,5 255...;;;*
5* 5~-$ wz 2&*-¢,
E ,__ .,·§_5£:- §,>·& ;_,<..i53g·
A; _'.. -52: GJ *"_,
=i 5~5§55 :55
z 5 555.%% Eén Eo3E£E
W
`E W g ;€:
i
ix ,¤ U gr g_ 'E¤.E
R E Mu S35 ..m;§B
»` ¤°§° E.-==... §’3u¤
4; u=°· -¤2'.¤S¤
_ .. 7 N·- mv __·- ,
A cxgg 53E =£E;$¤
=? 3"‘*¤¢ ¤"'5 2*3;,5*%
5 siéw 5E; 5;; Em
·> ·¤¤··•: Qu;. E#·=u>_·-·:
$5 {uga -¤¢= G g-5¤·c
’L 5“c” 585 “ ”EEE
x? xg;. E=:·§°§¤¤
· $*:*2 `EG'25 B¤q§E°"
vi E8-.:} 55: éiiégg
is I-*··· 5 EEE ¤uE~¤°E
» m éu 55: 555 5
,2* W 5; ...•-E ·- , Eg
sj En; ·53— ¤E·=‘g·»¤
¤ SMQE ¤>° ¤¤¤5¤:
n ¤~~¤ ~ ~ 555 §~
__ Egig :;;:):5 »&»..-gd;
Q A ,_¤‘§_*:···;~ ‘&'>E 5..5-Egw
: ;_!a·-· ;='·= =¢::= .5
Q ?=’ *’=~·‘5¤ 55 ..85 uyagvg
g Q GEO? ·—·•.. .-uv
2 5 5 5.%& E€$ E¤c555
<‘*· i,»P"4`*"“<":’E J * ri`, ` Q'; UP ’“"*·‘!U:<;§§.{j:’¤;;°(:~ ·;‘;< _~*n»:,_‘»g~»
—QMw~*;U»%NW»¤.·»~ L! r ¥¤WiY; ;g*k~&J **V~” ~;”··h
.»¤ ~~» —=¤ ·~, A.,¤/ p · *»m M·¤¤ »; A¢~
I N , AM /, . 4 Ai, U A >I»»: N , A . M ‘ . `l <,.*. W n. ` ( _,.Y I; £ y W ,5 4 ¤({~lI~{ A D H. _w
M, fyi; if ¥’§?#i?·";:? ““‘i*,—¤ ·’ WIP g`»L·‘£’ :g$\`—*‘; 'L gi?} iff 1?’e*· ?L`¤):j"€¢fs";&%x}?g?€—»”"E"i"`~ " ;”“`*?Z Q g
‘.,, zhxjw , Mx U) I 5 $5 ` , > >_¤ J ,· fm * ., # 'L, » 1fv% / · ‘ :# Jiri , ~ ·< { 'U \. I>,”¤\" I ¤;>` xj , v '
g%$&? *”€W~JM” §
g~€*z<»<<‘;§y*"’<»T$~»;,'»~—?~§@§ ’f~»{¢i»?~fi*° » ·—»w’,§$*"n » »w§%§’;v*§» £¤§<§*’gi2°:lA,‘w—"` p`. `;.~· w §—'L· » · `
.·.*>L ‘} _ M; 4*; _ y\ Q; M' A, _·:·~v A _ fl, (4 _ ‘
8 i§§~j>_j;§y;j;~; 1 > ` »x§i¥:—$€§ pz _A iw:} ¤ gl;/(Q 3 L; %§\ F, ft; L ii V V §§5}>P· > { (xiv/Y ry gfv) Q is ' Q
¤¤A»¤’,&`—%?` ·’,$°L=¢w4 i`~¤,Ew€#¢~»3"~}w ‘\#»»~·»*\ ¤i~¢ii~\ .?,C¤€,» ,*1:,* ·, x5 A;»;m*<~4‘2,w.,» , ¤e..~7~ ,¥—i> YUM i,·v~ .
•
A ` g

4;
EE ,
w&§sp
y5§¤:;·¤L¤
#}:::°“‘·:
»‘ ~=§,§~&= \S..
,#:w2~= ¤¤·=
·¢=·s’S¤`E ‘:E“E“
5* qc., ¤¤,·E_`,E ·e
I>,gS>·s; °~s~~s .H 3
r§¤5§°9,·»> .§_§§E‘¥ §&%§
W = ·~·’¤¤. M "*`¤ ‘··-.3
‘*‘€¤§L\=¥· §·E¤`6§ 5Z* ·
+2'=···¤&°‘;" ~g==,_, *—¥&G
?,=¤°5 2 ”¤-=·.:, 3~*—t‘·
ri, ~°;·E¤ ¤.E¤"*··: '§Q¤“‘
*’·¤¤; wu —¤~·E=°¤E :,m*°
*¤"~:q¤:a *··;¤·5 =¤°~·
5 L¤_ ,¤ »..,¤ ~--¤,¤
,A¤~·<-{E§ `»..,.§,,q ;,~§
f··¤5*..<&S · ¤§=·.,~· ¤=
.·~:‘·¤».=¤.~" ¤·E·»E“ °E€>.
,·»—5`,·»¤‘.:·§ If-..,:=9 s·¤9=
;§E~·»»$E~§ ,§"S=?· fl:‘¤E
=<¤¤»¤=~·5 §=>%zS" ¤¤¤§’a
; #§>., kc -E·,; ».¤¤ .» 5
O {R ` ·‘··wS k·¤\
·¤ ¤“·:¤= *•:.5¤¤¥ z ·.
5°S¤§¤*·& E&:§¤.: ¤§§¥
z¢‘:e¤...¤-=~ ..,,, w ¤·..,__5
§ ` ww: ¤,_ A4 *·¤
·5~>:g°¤5g¤§ ~¤e =·s 2*5, i
‘¥=;»i—~= $·§E‘:=3 E&§=
~&¤`·'$s3·~ =..»¤··== ·.~··=.~
:¤==·‘é·—==§ ¤· °¤“ ==5.s‘
,¤5¤$:-i§ ;=§Ss§ §.§:=
,g§°·¤: ,_|E¤-Em:. _.._E_v;<>,_
§§:§E #4 ¤¤:» `¤¤¤=,,_g
=; ~» °;~i.§·q§S *<»\§¤;
,.5. g ,,5._;·..;· &;·,~*·,,
i¤ $. :%=»¤¤ ~=2¤*
».= ug —¤;,:_g¤ ·E¤-*°*
¢·*¥¤°§2 "S =.:‘°€`E
${?2§’?§E€ E: = 7—
w ,.;;E“ 2: SE. E =-s
Plas? E: 5sEg :.¤- ®
*E;»·55 %sE§€... ;.¤g¤ ··. .__ 5
QEEEE .ié:s§z —5;§§$ ¤ 5
’.‘* " ·.. .¤
{1.:5 *5®*—·—=g ===~·»§§%z
·, ¤¤E w gssu ¤¤¤>·~·~—¤
‘¤—s& &%>~:==% iiéiaésg
~~~%¤~— “¤é3s§‘E·= E§..>~¤;·—>.
*’.;gsE° 2*2:;,,;: stggggjgx
§{>~:¤§ °§E_‘¤¤·’—¤° Eus aww §
?=—-¤=» %=¤*·¤°g£ ~¤~§~¤¤‘c-·
»"$‘s$’—g a5_:¤£§h¤ EaE¤;~—Z—;=
`·= ¤ `..¤···E¤¤>»¤= ¤¤¤*¤¤&.g—.¤»
·`° w-g T·"¤¤¤¤**YE¤ ¤E§= uu"
»E.&·~¤ xE¤=.5<>- .» ¤·S7S;¤¤¤§
l&§;%SE.B ‘~=`E;;—s,E¤ ;§~`5,$aE§"
EENQU ¤·§&:=»¤~#¤.¤ :·~,;:,&u:_-=§
§§€=5 is=§;§;¤ $gE:g¤;:;
`,==# ~·»·E " x `.¤»
425Vé. g‘:.:sS§* €E§°§a§*%5
~
2*-¤.`: °Eq§¤§_..§ ~.:¤_§”‘;·_..,‘E¤u
$§?E §"é<*$¤¤§.., E7—¤=·§¤»sE
» ‘* E¤~¥~s€s ¥%€?¥ :5*
*5 ¤‘S¤E§a§·E E<>~"»¤=·—§
é . a ¢§%g;.=z %.:§%s€E;
`*·=.S= ·°°~¤==5¤ ©c;¤·¤*·s ~
•-n ~$·§_=‘*.¥ "¤.¤ :¤·»~¤¤·;§°
z ¤% egg u_;° ·¤;’~3~¤.;¤Q
§"·°>‘:§ ‘·E.~·¥E 3 5'5_~§`,E&§
U ·==§Q¤.: :€..= ..-= "*=%&=€ ,.
m E s¤%s SESS ¤:= M = * a
‘e%€5:# =—s€= =s= .5 2
*.~§s·2= §‘*'€·"E· %¤·§ =§,_¤·¤, V
» A ¤° °*‘¤ ¤»~·E`¤ ¤`. xw
L .:~.;~¤.¤— -s:,_·55···~·¤·_g =¤§..·-»
¤E:=€§ égwzé
E “€§§=‘ “‘°`®E5 EE`? SME.2
‘ - ¤ saw .¤ ¤¤
¤ %§s£§ €§§=S§§;;¤ ¥s5§§
Ld ‘§¤EG§ $§¤‘=§¤¤·;_¤EE§ §:§~<’
Z ·E§·—5·€ E>`¤J§§$¤u`S¤ g§~·5‘5
`* ·-, sp T:·~_
Q gafgs $§§¤;:E§§»: §§;¤;§
Lic; ¤. .; ¤—S§_¤..¤.E= ¤:3;¤
§a·¤S°§ —·`6`5`G¤n§__§§\,§ ¤»€° ¤__
¥§9" §`J&‘“'¤·~=···=~ §°‘°¥'5
¤ E¤.2E :=¤¤§%a€&; *¤*~¤
¢ gtggav :%***5 =~-:.5,: **529.
N :‘·"" ¤:& ¤\""¤a· %·»··¤ “
Y s;°2~ ¤~:.E»°°¤¤‘é =.<‘·'¤~
VJ • °.E’=¤ ¤ »..E .·~·EE¤._¤- ..§,E¤·§
Z¤`Z¤~·s=é= .=.,°`r5~¤»¤ :·= ae
Og`- *·>.§, `:€5 E¤?==i u;¤·4=,
cxV 5 B‘¤=»¤·4‘*E~=‘* ·»*‘E—:‘
..._L» gas? =;;._;_§»;¤·5 »»§¤ ¤
F ”* *-5 . ¤~·;5‘:§¤¤.E¥¤Eb .2 °°f!
< ¤,¤¤_g_E,§_ m x =uL,··¤;,¤,, ».-·g,¤=_
{-50 E. E ·¤=n§g¤·g» ».§¤,E5
¥ T»°“g =•— 0 { _ ¤; "—==..
»·¢`°>E:. ¤¤°¤ mw: 'g§¤l;u
%’§•a¤.<·.s wuz; Q ¤*~- FE] `:»·¤`°2§§$§-g g_ —·‘&.§ ws
cn .:4B$%’..§.§1 .. ..5-.=1¤; ~
$§%€.E¤.¤`°8 Bg_:`E;_ §
,i.§_¤E§§;'§g E=.gg= V
¤. 4.:2. -¤ s =¤¤~=
»*E§;§¤i§§2 $5535 >§ = .¤
·€,;¤¤__§¤° :¤E..é~§_ Q";}-wv .=
,,g83¤,,3·· 932=¤ <..§* x
“· %*=¤~2&¤=~';E §··E"‘E *$—€— W
€> ¤`é;¤~.§§s§ 23,;; ·%§E£§ EE
pq .5** EE.»¤_g g9.:<>>~ ~SE°‘-·¤¤'5;
~>·E¤¤¤ .50 ·—u¤¤ q¤6w'°: :
¤¤ ,»..g§gB,‘¤g §E.¤;i_g -—·;sa¤g~¥
< -g§;=:E@5=» ¤§“=;== ·§=s:==s.5€
::> 3¤'G"‘ *— · EE =· —°-»*·°
G ¤’H :._ E ¤. m,¤.,,,·< ¤i =.¤¤`
Q ;::i¤g§°'uR vg'§¤E·`= :·¤ ¤"u`¤=
,¤u_u,,, `;·¤5v· >° ”='; L;"¤:5'.;`E¤··‘:§*_
z§E‘·-Cc;‘5§ 2§¤¤¥= ·¤9¤.;,_,$·=..
°?~&·—g ¤ -».¤=~’* ‘·3=~~ °"¤
¤_ c: .... `E wu .¤<¤=·
··< ,, :5; 8;u§.¤_,: ·~.,E5f>."~3
»; E 'U SESRE: °··'s°§:ES9_
E S gc: ¢1:~`,s ¤E.¤··`=°g¤u
· ¤.. .,.,_ =¤·.=.§.¤. ¤=~¤°—¤
;¤¤¤. an Uug » •··¤ §¤Z.°"`°.:E»
,%.-53 -5 ·;,·; 2 . ¤*~ ;=-¤·~·=
¤"¤¤5“···5a2£ 8 is `=€§¤·§="`
`*§5E,g·§_E,.»¤.; =~.2¤·.. ‘•·— ‘g °-5E
o ·¤,,,, ....,.¢:=¤¤ ·-...¤u>. EE, ·4·»~
‘.E¤g.‘°<>§·= “'g§ is Q EEG
w°6E·2·§5§¥Eg· g`°"E,—& §§;(§`%`$§§
·*·-éeséé ~¢·» a€..€= ¤&;~·¤=.
<¤» >& *¤v"§ E=·¤<.·—S! ’¤¤.%¤
» _Sg¤§¤,5[E_E ;*°§: >~
·g·· ';°·3K. ¤ E 2:2
;,_;§§.E_5g.¤.,é... m9.¤¤¤ EE
*§ ·-..'}E°‘§E.,s §Eg%’* cn.?
-0;:55.-miw-z., .= .i¤E W,
`*·.?=.'a._;§-5** 8; -252335 F>
’·E§·E.. —-¤5§•...<¤ m'¤=u§ EQ
(Lo ..=<¤.¤ §_cE ¤ .: Q:
.¤s¤¤¤g§§-§2 `§?;·Ei'5 R
;`cuE,§5g_“53—§ c-§5{’§ ug
E·¤¤E"°"EE°'—· °"‘5·§. SLE
my ¤..¤-5.. ¤";§¤$=~'9 ¤ ¤“E°*— 1:%
zé == *P·?:‘·§ ¤ ·E§ ·`
;¤u_S°¤,.gPg5u?= > °-¤>_ $~
=¢€§§=¤s@5= 23*5:5 as
$¤ Sglgz E :5-5,·»_ »<¤.
;; ¤ g ¤z,¤°$··:. uu.
, 5 ¤ 5»¤ws 5*
`< ?~ E E" B-€“¤ ¤§
U ».·- ¤°··- ‘<¤ ¤
’.:°· ng ...Z°¤ vi ag
·%‘•-2 ¤¤5 -— , 8
*¤~5" `5=s¤§ *3 *
v > Q`! ». 3 ‘*
’·~§%g¤$g@°“§ QMS., ETS
,‘·¤ °° '•* E = 2
.e95·E§°€;= ¤.a ¥*§
(yuan gu__§_ >·mg` E S
··.2 u=¤_ ···H .·5.¤ u 0
*S.~&*¤ géiies $5*%% °`
x,(E·g%‘§§.‘;§-5E 0E;
)..: o "‘
¥i•5·§·E_§§-uvauin ggui z`
»g —.-s··¤z. ==s% C
v§E,· ··5o...° :·. ... ,,
,,c;.._;_.,v= uw-·> : =¤ ··—
”E_,¤¤.;‘5'°;g.¤ 'E'...·E G
`§—·8?¤·.-. °U§Ou-N va <
“§ ;;·€!—=::>.°E mg
,§.;...¤§§'E§g...§g gu:. E
.£:n;` g` 8--*3 5-ES U
. m · Z
~EȎ;,= ggagw g~ 5 s
¤2:¥g...§,,.mcu‘; 59E E
Saiigé 2¤E·¤ »s¥ "·
gow o.g'•:··u~ >¤u¤· 3
¤ ·-.5E ..¤ ¤ E U
z‘E‘$&aE5§@&E “·*; *-1
Y: ¤, BEE " xj
>*;§’?‘§¤2~€¤»¤; ..4. *3 2.; 3 5 E" ¤~¤
R ¥;¤;$.4 A , 0
a ,>*<%s{qf1‘»} .·»¤,,;., 5 ¤ 5
xv ;_ ¤» `;,¤_`_x~;;y; {qq? ·; B -§ E3
vi?{$`i~1"*~?Aj»~ < `m·».»E.””°\m’{· U‘»*~ ·~». °’E
>njé»."=fL ~¤!‘~»,,r‘4 "(. ·.¤—‘~¤<, v.·».
Zfg!E*§g¥‘.;.?z§(é’j1Q.~°e~MQ?}{ ’i,"f‘§X ~,··»·`X ....,) J LE
X :, . \~‘»..3»‘ VV *~, ’».,* ' > » ‘,» ‘— ,~. ‘ ju , ,_, "
2;Z~;#§T"?*@i·».~,’T"»=»§·i¤;.,‘> A} . = ·—:;’* ¤~
U.;;;;i»;4:—~;*;;.;...$;;> x:’~¥·y.. V(“’—,? . qy ` * J}, 3%
"“<,v J ‘ .¢· »”.;i`~-*"" ~ .’~~.~,»¤
E @’¥§~:»¤¤i;~\¢;’·A.1·`·,·* }_,· J *;?`*%~°\'? ’ *¤t$<.—»L—· ~,j"%· __~ (gw ' .» f- *`·* ’-Tl lf < $,3*; M? it: —, it~»· E rx
¢,.L `¥,~,;¤\z . » » ,. · mtg ~ idx ~ , » ,» ·y‘ . ~».i
n Mm. Mw w . ··!» **—nq»»: » ‘ » »» . #1 » **· »~— .»·; · .
‘ “,’.‘i·’, ;<·»§.,,¢;;·* *, , , · * i ,.
* ·»—*~*?%mi» :»· ‘=*."T···&§’~>:<><‘?»., ·4 .1 .9 >_4¢. .¢», ,
»*1`."·’%:¢·`}*;ia$ `""I.··¤.:iP *}’·—.fq \ `¤'*i ‘.1¢‘·”j".'·*·».w
,;. »—>, · » ¤¤¤»~,pj¤~ 2.,. *¢Z}*·¤. Lg; , h. . l 4}, *.5·; ;,\ ’;‘
*’ ~ ‘ · .a’,;.$’•‘·2»¤~.,·‘.· —?*>*·s:·,g§;,»*;·.·P· »‘ O W {V2. ~s°· \, ¢*~ A * F,
* ‘·,¤ ~A ~¢ ~ ,¤ .`2·’]>'¢·,. ~ _ ‘ »
° /. · · '* N: ··l‘:¢`< * wx; if/~\»·»;~ ¤, ~• .» ~ `
` N /‘¢~» * ` .¤ AQ,. <, ,.) 0, ,~ , * * *
Y iu; y 1 `¤);A“?;{2.1;.i¤ if §$ ;:gr\\M·*.%\4§h’4, i L /j)é)${_ {ff
` C ‘ · r. {/»»»**(:<¢z‘ `§??¢,~ »»>,. “»~·`~; gF¢¤*~‘f., J · V> I .·'» ~~ 3
asg ` 7" "~‘?§’ )""“’i¢,_·;·_§T*»»»’1.»**'*¥*$5:~~;>r§*—“$?'<»¤3* -
CV‘O2255 .·~3»,#¥s~* §
·PG|Z{ DOC »’ ·¤·N »j,;i~3'?l»

Exhibit A-1

Case 2:02-cv-02255-PGR

Document 151-3

Filed 09/16/2005

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-02255-PGR

Document 151-3

Filed 09/16/2005

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-02255-PGR

Document 151-3

Filed 09/16/2005

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:02-cv-02255-PGR

Document 151-3

Filed 09/16/2005

Page 4 of 4