Free Response in Opposition to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

Exhibit A-4
Case 2:02-cv—O2255—PGR Document 151-6 Filed O9/16/2005 Page1 0f2

6

X
ifi A
, C'.
. ~ .5
~ e 0 A S
ET $3 5 =
8: 5 E &
Q·•· E ’¤ cu
Q U
I3 0
%§ E E
' O vs
0 ° '·· ,5
E 5 § é A ...
Y O E L- E':
HY E E E
¤ O
f ' § 5 -2
E- 2 E 5 2
i 0 ·°° S S g A
; 5, § 5 5 5 z
**1 > C; e: L:
W Q ~= O E S
.·'* g § g E
` < 0 8 E
Il; -0 § °° E é §
· .. A :2
<¤ 5 ; BQ A wg 3 V 2;
T u. L. § § -¤ E Z
— 3 5 == V 2 5 s ¤ V
E ‘:¤ fg B; ': L2 A ~ 5 5 g 2
< A
5 $3; E 2 5 ~§ si 35 A @5 g
A xg 0 " E ni S = K BQ >.° 0 5* "-’ E ¤¤
g. ‘·-· W zu 3 V3 0 ·-J 0 ·— J: "'
In ¤ ¤¤ "’ — -¤ ·· ea 0. " E "‘
S 2 _,= `° .%*8 5, g ·¤ T: V E 5 5. ¤ lg
O -5 g m§g..-_§ °·’.,T gr vé 0 ‘E
H = ·-· ·.. 2 ‘° ·-· u. ° E r .¤ U
E M V} N _ q 5 U -· A _] U
gg ~'°’ g ¤ ¤ E <¤ 0 -0 g -2 -¤ = V v U
H ... '-· •·’ 0 'G "' A "" '° ¤0 *5 m
Q ,,,0 ¤,_mE,.,·E.o ,5 *-0 .5 = N,
< *;.2E 2¤&"’E#‘3>7· .9 £§ ¤'3;§§ g° .5
E 0* 2 _g=¤>>§2§.¤ ZG E0 351330 ‘; >
E 0 “ Z, E U .¤1> ’¤ A 3 E 5 =¤ :1 $
’ L) § . n- ···· q = . E Q
W :.·7`]§’,,;-,%-1: ° .0 Il`: EE,_E E 2
Z " Ezgwog § Q 52 8§.2‘ ea 5
Q . “· a 5 E ¤ E $.§ 2 x ..¤§ 5 5 2
E 35; § g gg ¤:5¤ 52 E g
g S · g E 5 5 E ¥ a 5 »·s § E
`· V ° 0 ‘·· ’¤ -8 0 Q? •-· " .<¤
Z .... 'U ¤ L. V g: Q. -
hl § .·¤ E qg ¤_ = U LE U
5 ¤ z @6 &2§2 E 5 é
i., W ».» 8 aa ., 0 .5 5 un
Q .;; Q I5 : 5 5 V .8 ‘¤ E Z
0 p O E .2 E E ., ,§ °
’ °’ 0 0. •-· "‘
I · S _;-_ E ,.\ 5 *5 O 8
G Z. U ‘“ § é E *.2 ¤ E.
4 Z` E nc 5 E ° U L5
§ Q E A ‘* E Eg E z
`:: E ¢: ° ·°
5 €=; g .2 LE E E
Q 'Z A 0 E E
L *5 'S E g U E
0 5 ¤ 2 <
Q ·¤ S "= EE 0
` “ E s: $9 "’ E ¤
G xg g D J E Q) § .2
Z § E E as § Di S
< EY c> ° E E - ~— =¤ S
, Z 8 eu > ev: 0 .E *·• U
V 0 -0 A ·· gg ·-· § m
gy —..I 2 5 g 5 g g 5 § 3 *2
;i~.. 0 E 5 2 E E E E ¤ E
O ¤ g :> c 3 %· ji ié
"’¥ G ‘ >
§ ·> § ig S .2 g fig 5
jj 0 E {D § -8 5 0 {E
M E ° Q > E E ‘•· %° .§
.,.·‘ i E ._ 8 A .. g 5 E ¤ .,
¤ .5 A Q E 5 A s E ~
> Z ... m
V W 0 .. 8 g o 5 ‘g -5 O
U 2 6 O E 8 •-· eu EG S
M x: '° V. 0 M O E U ...
’ 5 L¤ .2 g 6 #*2 .. Z 5 g g
XQT1 >, 5 V Q 2 "I .3 Q 8 E··
2 ··;.· B _¤ (3 cn *.7; >_ § 0. ...
> · .¤ gg 5 A Q 2 2 — G5 5
fi § Lu .. -0 -¤ LL A § ui E` g § E
.5.: vi 5 S 5 x zz 0 ° 5 ‘°€ 3
N 5 3 .2 ¤- u. jg > E 8 M w E
Aw 9 =¤ ,,, .b 5 -- W as C
W g 8 E -2 L? ¤ ” I a `E
.T cm .., ··.: g O = E - :3
“; ec v ¤_
;g 5 E E S vi U E g» 0 5 E
{K 2 > .3 E EQ E D: °s‘ O '5 2 °· °’
E3: §§§~.§ LgU‘;,g g § .5
. . EQ (2 _·,; 5 .,. 5 gz > S $ ..
*¤ U 5 3 5 “ U ·· 2 ¤ *2 °’
.¤ E .2 ¤¤ ~ A-. ·. A ¤~
QS? §§"2’;¤5 5§<5¤·§ 2 .5 *5 3
%2§§?» E5‘§§£> :2 E E E
°°§§¤Z Qwgé § E 5 5 x
é` 2 5% E Ee S E E g § ¥
*»;;2“i».z..·§ gg 2 Q ? °§ E A E < < éé ·»=
”— 2** *i, "` , Y“—; ‘{;'·}’.,.—. .. cn "' g
§?z?~:q·; Q .·jV> Nj; _: 2..... 0 g ·¤ § M SZ U E § E E E =
· ~ 545 N ~.i>°·.*...¤.’e rg? ·~·u~»*h (D ,_, E ,5 >< U E 3: ·,.. 0 U .9
AQ gy 3.,4, A F2);. ?1,$·,A$.X’»=; ¤;s:;§2*~ Wi , ·-. E ... {.11 y. N ec K ,.4; on 1:
° , gx] ·. V ¥$,A,;2,__§ ;~./_.lU ,(:.?;;;\( , _ ${5 E J . -¤ M .6 E 3 O
uz; .t..a¤k~¤;. . " "‘*· 3 2.; V E 5 E M gg ‘;,, ¤.
RN} Q ii J ‘ , gx} 2 y ` QIVVK"`.; gglfé -5 ih +*2; I¤*·<`<· .’ V) > E '8 O 0 Q
‘°¤ ` ,, g . -4 . 1,* •’ — ‘ " s1,§f;»?¤ ?¥C§A;;§( )~’"‘ `g. V., E (A "’ •.. "‘ ‘·-
H5 5** · —··’ ?,__ · 4 “ ·..¢¤~£ g +:4;. ...4. ~·:·.f aw. E ·¤ 8 m § gy
» ‘>·=%<. ‘ zi".; 5 ‘ ° ‘ www ~·***?5%<$i?’i·`i" ‘V‘» Q Q 5 ·= 5 M "’ E
.» x·I2`.‘ · #· . ·· . , , A — ·P.:·$ [ % .’~iq*¥.;i.1·f"%._Q _. IL; K m
Eu 2. ·=··¤·B -=·€. Q,. ¤»~$»·Zf~‘;.·.- ‘‘‘·’ ¤?¤%·¢.¤».. § A ¤¤ #*3 E G
» . . · gm, gi. · ·.»z: ..5 ··.¤... .~¤<¢. . .~.;. w &,..~¢;~».,. ¤ A 0.
U joy ._‘ _/ i; ·¤_;M_‘·‘.¤ . ,· Hy A,§f';yi n lhyv U? ;>.\, lj{{~h: ( _¥;· Wg? ;A\,¢».!, ( Z Q 3 5 >< {Q W
mz 0. ?~ ··;Q1g*~, l" ’— li`1@‘¤? . X `·z·x§:@w·§’•`;§¥*?¤.é’·’»·*’ . M "M;. $.9.% V 3 ;» .0 ¥-U 2 3
» ¢G$ ’ *25** ‘¥”‘·’“¤ " 9 "’?‘$?‘* ‘§" mi $”??IY“:§‘¥?%€232*"`§` ·¥*` “~’1¥".¥¤= 5% . nc 0 E g E.
V H ` °(=}§§ `3" \L?¤”{~ W; kw? i EErL.;;~}°=‘G~ ~·?5\r»? L *§€`?`$~.{x {7}; ‘4`;;J;"£E{)*4l{ F; pix ;~·*; Tw'. V 0 U IM ’<
WV . `2 r¤*i ‘ ’~.i‘;;‘.’;x:( ’f:_y§»L‘* ’:‘ {www J "jé .. _`;\’%,€*w J; 1* {.=€* ¤ 1 ¤· . V` ,'€>; · ?)x_ N ·=V~.Es} xp, * ,, ·;, fps, ypnb ¤,.,;> ¤»· w h’~~· .¢.1,.·€’a<; r ,_,
.;.a=· ”‘ *‘ *·· " s . G 2 »~..i> ··»·.~· T z¤!i’*‘.·‘· .¢., W A Ap.?} ‘= .9 %¤;2=»·‘ "‘%. MM ¤";#4 ¤¤ vn 5
.: wm 1 ¢ r;e><.' V¤¤¤;,.· "— ».=*r:;¤?~.·.’¤‘ EJ ¥‘§·#s¤i°"E·? g¥¢.2;'r%?»~ ·¢ ?‘»·»%.'vF4-.*5 mp. E ¤_ U
C 1.; gv ,gq;g.;..é$;$.E’,5*..wi} in my gg; gyj, il, épjje. g,.__,.w3 $§.;·# gs? `,/égyggyw < § E Q
·»=»»*»<,».¤>». =y··.2 . ·: M Sw » .;:—.·?~*;—. .»
as ww. ~»; ‘·5._E§ 3 gfgxy xgg L J? my ·;f‘z, .z=—1_;, ,`.§Y*,€E2‘j.",f}<§? ?§;§¥C;.1·. ._ E g
G 2 ‘»’£N‘»} ¢.¤§‘{¤ ‘¥,,\2¤~_ if 4*,. `{i·} _ <
_ 4..2 K) ·_y» n ____* ,*1- . ;_A QW. ·.:; Ag,. n '¤_§¢,‘\·,— .¤—<; - ;.,*;¢·#_i· Hg. :.3;. *.};.1 E
.02 ‘”>a*‘§?Z¥§*§"’¥;i- gg, .§’;"‘».;.¤ ?"¤*‘.3.·.g .. ·* .=/Mi .z";—*·¤3.w ¤;¢:.;_§$:"‘*¥z»`,"‘»¥"# .,
- . .;~ 1; ri ? ...x;..»_.;e‘{; $’-i}#S·3»t·§‘§.:· , 1 N; A `~~‘ 2 fj}; 1;:. 1;%** »¢i§?$:.:_’“3_..;`§¤;;g5
CV·O22 ` ”*>¥2§ E Yi? é5?(¢§~;.
* . ( ·# ., .5 _ ,~ .. ’ ,‘ »;‘ g; w ‘;. .2* ·‘f..~’1*.. _ x»—.~~.» A ,` '
55 ¢¤¢`¢;:s¤§*m¥%§{&I.·§§ri¤+.<¤¥§§§
·P A>».»;1 §¤·"·’*;§»:<4~‘ ~·,.>.. · ¤·.~>¤ Jp * , ; ; A ·* ~» wi? •¤ .¤—·. wd. :;·{2.
R "‘* ~.¥;f*~=€.% ‘E»>;¥~·¢ ’>¥. 3%% xi 1**: H 1** gi ·» ‘v·.z·1>¢ .<».2:¤$s
Fi 3;; 2 »;,,%¤.2é.:. .:5 M »<€a %·> wg; .~ag.r.·*·~ ....>g;&:i
DO ("”r?¢¥’?’~ :2: =$?E` *1 Qé~¥¥3$Ji>” . ;#‘¥§Z*°— -E'£1$¤£Z‘;?°?¥z" ~Yi·»% C ’ ·*§%£§¤ *, /~*. ,,?»\_¤¤ ~; 95,,** *§» .E ,·, Umg "@`¢5i¥=*’~ ‘,-:?‘*¥?$¥‘.S@ &;;"‘i*~*. ¤ .**2i·i.·r‘.é*~§;.;¤ii-·
gag. i.i';a< . .; _ _..¢,;>..y §§,j;·» i‘f_:-;v?~;.;;f&**€.'
nt “` $@2 Q §`;."·. —)‘.·"·t1i*H£";r‘F*€§§
51 q $$:.5.. )¤w._{\ ;{·4J.a;,;gE
- ‘ &§_· mv { ’ *‘..M ·-_X,··§~i[, `.;*~·
6 ;§?*i.§€:Qg;£;j§§..a
. .,,:2; i’_,I » £*,+.' ,1;;
Fugd * my »~.¤_.~¢§i¥§.¢.;.;;§
O . ,.~;X>;;;5¢% —_
9/16/ 2
2 ;= _
Q
x
pag §
9 2 O Q
T 2

Exhibit A-4

Case 2:02-cv-02255-PGR

Document 151-6

Filed 09/16/2005

Page 1 of 2

Case 2:02-cv-02255-PGR

Document 151-6

Filed 09/16/2005

Page 2 of 2