Free Redacted Document - District Court of Delaware - Delaware

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 1 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRlCT COURT FOR THE DISTRlCT OF DELAWAR

GLAXO GROUP LIMITED )

v. )

Plaintiff, )

) )

Civil Action No. 04-171-KAJ
)

TEV A PHACEUTICALS USA, INe. and )

TEV A PHACEUTICAL INUSTRlS )

LIMITED )) Defendants.
)

CONFIDENTIAL FILED UNDER SEAL

APPENDIX SUPPORTING TEV A'S BRIEF OPPOSING GLAXO'S BRIEF CONSTRUING THE DISPUTED CLAIM TERMS OF U.S. PATENT NO. 5,036,249
YOUNG CONAWAY STARGATT & TAYLOR, LLP Josy Ingersoll (# 1088) Adam W. Poff (#3990) Karen E. Keller (#4489) The Brandywine Building 1 000 West Street, 17th Floor P.O. Box 391 Wilmington, DE 19899-0391 (302) 571-6600 kkeller(fycst.com

Mark D. Schuman (Pro Hac Vice) Ronald A. Daignault (Pro Hac Vice) Jeffer Ali (pro Hac Vice) Jeffrey C. Brown (Pro Hac Vice)

MERCHAT & GOULD P.C.
3200 IDS Center 80 South 8th Street Minneapolis, MN 55402
Attorneys for Defendants Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc. and Teva Pharmaceutical Industries, Ltd.

DB0J:157833.1

058956.1011

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 2 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

T ABLE OF CONTENTS

Exhibit Number
G

Appendix

Description

Number
M026M029
5,068,259 Patent with occurences of Ilethanolll highlighted and

numbered
Excerpt from deposition of

H

M030M031

Bradley Anderson taken June 8, 2006

DB01:2157833.1

058956.1011

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 3 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

EXHIBIT G

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 4 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

-

o
i::j

~1

~ d

1J Á'lmJ 1llmo;u'liEss, ~SE~~ S.J, ~.:liE;;;

UND STATE DEPARTM OF COMMRCE
United States Patent and Trademk Offce
May 20, 199

.,!

;.¡

TIlS is TO CERTIFY THT ANXE is A TRUE COpy FROM TH RECORDS
OF THS OFFCE OF:

U.S. PATENT: 5,068,249
iSSUE DATE: November 26, 1991

By Authority or lhe

COMMSSIONE OF PATENTS AN TREMARKS
...;.~

.-. 't.!'

tt'
M026

:; ~(J J~
H. L. JACr:
Cer Ofcer

G 000001

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 5 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

f
:,1

-: :.-:.':'~:'..:i-_s.::-,-- ~..';".i_

. .
(11) Pa Num

.!

United State Patent (19) Log
; -. ~

(S4) AQUEUS RAIN COMPONS
1

(7~ iin Dm R. La RD Ei¡ù

STA.~

('61 ~ oi. IX FOREGN PATE
~UI~ Fra. :iiom M9U Ui:
~ ii.w 1I9t Ui J:¡d . .

('~ Da of Pa

5,06,29
N01.26.191

~,!

fi

(7) AAgi GI Gr ~ Lo Ei
rill .A Na. 49
(2) Fi Ma 14, Ut

. OT PUUCATIONS

Oi ~ ~10i40 (1982).

Jl us A, Dc

Oi ~ (1*101 (1916)

"j

(63 Co\Ì ors. No ~6J Apr. i. 19&9. al

:o 11. 1m. ~ (m Iq (arii or ra or 1 (30) F.. ~Uii XlÐ- 1m1 1J st d ARC!tb is ai by 2 Pr - l6 ò. i: 1m rGB) p1ys~..tAe A1

cl ..bi Íl " ~-i or Se. No tJlM2

Pr ~_Db Gu ~n: £. Wadde ~tAt, or FinlBa l. Thai At

ot~ (StIu.sa.' A6 31/ th iiti u a. No J: Ia a. SH/,m (n)FW d Sc '14/-41, 41 ('81

.¡ ;'l!

:¡
i

'i..

M027

13 0-0000'2

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 6 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

.¡

i'j

:,

A Cot or ad inYa an iq AQUEOUS RAIN COMPONS oii foll¡i=e emi 0( th Suc aisrorll
No. 07/J,6 Ii Apr. 28 1989, Il iion Prly th reai pH or th fonulou ii ob ..iu is a ~ or Se. No 07/131,.2. fi ti by th -= of &pe bul% u1cs Optiy

i

5,068,249
2

phlogiYaa a. . \' in wa, Tl ipll Is i. ""fi of apli Su. ~ pm iiii divc ~ agt.~

SfABIl. WI EIL lion may CI ri l.c1or Ol or ii 0i.1

7

;:1 t::

ui Ít . ai.....;~.Br ~ti th is re= toiaii Eu of.-s: 'V ¡I)' ii or Of an de ia th Put phy¡iy -i IS c: Xade Sl lI~yleeul_ i. 'Spe No. il cdul 1Ita ~ll &¡cm 0:. 1$696 In
CQmn,l.iicn foron-l p& ad aM . uI th of. Ci-4a!l liar a hycl.(:-l
.,
::.¡

ne pn ~ rd ia ~ c:ta, lltqto · Plw ex af as&i_~. I.iiiia.oc ot lI aa åii th hi 10 vo . ~ tlvo on /l. ai H. ll Ewia R&ii fNS-dil-)mi-i. =o aImile lI~ h~ etyl. mc liyijylJeIJ-mi-i.i:l,l_ ¡r~aiar a:thy!.

De II, 19&7, DO -l0l tb coti _y Wo i: oth coveiuoi

ad !x ac i. pH or s. in th iy aù co tlyli

ofth (o: co s: ~ io hydy~lcii -l hyd)'Ylme-

fa ~ ai an -i of II or mup. Bo be hylÙ~ hydrylcdulc=
Br Pi Ap No Gn 21~ de IO IO ~ &ol a. S1

th Is i. d= of ll aa bu IÏ et or ~ we as meylolÚ etyle\l.

ll Sol soaå BPC ai a 1lvo as re Es of il ""ee àiude SI

In th ~ th is n: to \i (on tl CI M Cr hu Is =itly wlih the Û0 (er or ai pote ~.t an th nt ~ ~ pe 10 in fo CUe 2D20 mnef
an CDlei an or of aq fonaicó lilnve'nThin-r ot~ ll=i pe 10 fo d= II lb I' fo n. ~ 10 zi ~~ I,, fotli mi om

&he iai: tf( h& i. pH wl th n. 6.7... ll CO cL ~ ir th on (Ol

sc -a li fonii ai nu I! of iita flvQQ qi in1l 'm' di &Dor "" or mo or it ~y -._ ii ~ ~. ~ lIVO ai

7 an fo Ìle: ad ll rorul pl fc: oi a wcYIam bu is prc:th co
oe (p). .iw== a¡t ai a fl. ~ wi. ~inly be mt !x ¡ive i. souton

h~anlUlitoapIofa¡y sc~ cr as & pc of

8

a. =a pb oc oo cI Fo ~ bl wi !h I' 2. to 10%, ai ~ ('ciy ~ th fu al ro o:y1 cdu10l as & ~ J3 a¡i. a pr ~ a: 0( ~ ei es 74%.t\ rorvi Cl bc 5 to 1~. mo aacnt in

n_ eo lie i. sly sr sh. wi i. ~ Il th ni or 10 to 100 ~

ii ii iiae ba roi an mor pa- -l mdoc Ol Qf i: of lb pb~ologiy

lie ov tbQO Bn Pa th.wiy orTh &qby ti((er orldOl lIe in ~ rOl ti No is~ .t ~ypc Co &n I.\l IolatÎ or We mve
9

3

eoti wl Is oa cr of ~ ~e pcenly.~ di &Dor In aq fo=e iuti. ~ il ~ sa ~ -i in t\ r= or iats tb aù ~~ -.. foc. Aa iU1. ai 0(& ronul aog to im is pr tZ liJn of a pu mc th Ìl ii l: rci In ti exle t\ rdve

etl to !bpc a ~ ~ Th aq fo *X¡ to th Úlentiòii nm i. pr ii rocul it ei &p
tnon iny be iuiiy ml by th addiix 0( -i wi aq ioli Qf ~ or th vù

iiy aa '- fonii ror or ii ~Ie aI ~ wi ~ the eupi-

4
5
.~

lt. Pr th &m ~--..m.i'~.. ~~.. th co " Wr, 6 ~ 74% w/v. . 60 ~-.-? i-~~..,* ll
sw th th ~i._ (octi hu th _L____~ .. ~ onliqli.Honoo... (I)) avlO..
,.,

ia ex a.or ii id to __tlri m.y 7. pl~ sa
Th ai .. -' ir th fou. is

th ~iti-~' IUIel- èi. ccaiib ii.an rian llpr 0( fi ba~a an 0( apxi is . at fo ~.t II pa A111 jO iJ th ra pH t\ bu ir

poti oa . wci~hi tu ollh COple (oci: is wi th tm¡e 1.,. to 10'. ll t:

t-y is be S to 109 ..Iv, lt eiy

Prer cointitl ~ to i. ln

k~ ..~~
If¡ "w,...., "'.. s-_ i-lo 1'_
hi ." S1 10

CUl(

10

an lh in whi lh pH of ll aq fooi is

ii an dl byd¡= anha

sa a: dlii ~ po di' oras for e:Je orboha or çi pl

- esy 1 to 1. Th rt pH of th ron. i& i: prenly oò by ll UI olllle bu 65

will th rm¡e 6.5 to 7.J, puy 6. to 7.4 ai

'l
'l

'l

c¡

ia .,

(on (ar on ~ or ai ele

1 åa: 1. A ~ ootl wh li &l aq

~~~~t~~;''::l''; ~~~~-:::~~-.~mrON, .' ~~ .,. . ~. ~_. ,. .
M028
G 000003

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 7 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

h! ..!

.¡

j

ï
.:~J -::1 , ! i

11

::; ".j
'.1

12
13

::j
~J ~~ ., .¡
.'1

OQ th coplet. f=ul 10 lL A Pliti cot: wl íi an "luc
i bavig a pH in th WIse 6.8 Co 7.-4. In COg 1$0 ai f1 pc 10 ml i1

1 co 7% fx 8% weigbVvo= ~ 10 ml "' ~ as fn bu

i l-coAù¡ theCOon acg~Co 10J,pc 10 c:ci"C~&ttItfn b& ii ni pe on i.% Co l(t Wd¡¡volum.~ A ii COonas ii cled ii cl ccplei . c: ..Ii.i ml cl 3. A ~ea 1$0

o:ti havi a pH ia th rae5of 6.1.:. th c:ci"C &it is 2Oio m¡in cl i A ~i: copo &C¡ Co c: 1, wl=i 9. A ~ca COan as cl nie

aly acledTciVC'1l1lfot~coai 1,10 ml cl ~dli: fn i.20 mg t.c sai" lh sa o(~ si pe wh=i th as ll b& iag a ~

am of nie anor Ole or mo ph)'logi a. A Pb.lIca comptian as cled in cl

. .3 . 4
5,068,249

.. A ~"ial co¡xti iw¡ Co cå OllOti of rati sic fOt or a.

j

f=

c: ul . . . . .
i "'be iad pH is ob by tl = ofbi sa l:
20
25 30

i bavig & pH i. th WIse 1.0 to 7.3. th r&ii 7.0 to 7.3 im Wo ~ 1% 10 8% 14

S. A ~ eoti icg 10 cl e: u fr ba sa ~ havig a pH in

1. A ~ea =po a=g 10 cl ii A ~ co ~tocl i ~ as nue ii the for of th hyd U wl Sl pH is ol by th us of bier sats

'- A ii CO a=g Co cå 1$ wefÍam~ OI th co fo.

I J "'ì

::1 , i

OJ ..1 .!

JJ

~

M029

~, ~'l'-~.~
G 000004

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 8 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

EXHIBIT H

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 9 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

1'"
1

~

1
, I l l' - . . , , ' ¡~~~O" "fT"', ".", i '(': ¿; Lr tJ

2 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

3 FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

4 ---- ----- ------- -------- ---- --- ---- -- --x

6 -Plaintiff¡ 7 against 5 GLAXO GROUP LIMITED¡
8 TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS USAf INC.,

9 and TEVA PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRIES

10 LIMITED,

11 Defendants.
~
'?

12

Civil Action No. 04-171

13 -- ---- --- --- - --------- --------- - - -- - - --x

14 101 ParkNew York, New York Avenue
15

June 8, 2006
i 6

9:05 a.m.

i 7

i 8 Videotaped Depos it ion 0 f Expert Wi tness,
19 BRADLEY ANDERSON, Ph.D¡ taken pursuant to Agreement

20 before Rita Persichetty, a Notary Public of the
21 State of New York.
22

23
24
:~.
i' "(

ELLEN GRAUER COURT REPORTING CO. LLC 126 East 56th Street, Fifth Floor New York, New York 10022

25

212-750-6434
REF: 80918

M030

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 10 of 11

REDACTED VERSION ­ PUBLICLY FILED

53

1

AN DERSON

2 3
4

5

6
7
8

9

10
11 12 13
14

f\ed3cted

15

16
17 18 19

20 21

22
23
24

25

M031

Case 1:04-cv-00171-GMS

Document 140

Filed 08/04/2006

Page 11 of 11