Free Objection - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

I Marshall Meyers (020584)
2 Ian Pryor (022651) {
KROHN & MOSS, LTD. Q
3 111 West Monroe, Suite 711
4 Phoenix, AZ 85003
(602) 275-5588 j
5 (866) 385-5215 (facsimile)
6 Attorneys for Plaintiff
7 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
8 FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
9
10 CHARLES DE SHAZER, ) Case No,. CIV 03-869-PHX-PIM (
) ]
H Plaintiff, ) PLAINTIFF’S OBJECTION S TO 3
l2 ) DEFENDANTS’ TRIAL EXHIBITS
Ve )
is )
I4 NATIONAL RV HOLDINGS, INC., )
and FREIGHTLINER CUSTOM )
15 CHASSIS CORPORATION )
I6 ) Q
17 Defendants.
is
19 Pursuant to FedR..Civ..P 26 (a) (3) as modified by the Honorable Judge Silver’s
20 Scheduling Order in this matter, Plaintiff hereby files Plaintiffs objections t
2* Defendant’s proposed trial exhibits. .....
22
Trial Description Plaintiff’s
24
Exhibit Objection *"
25
National RV Exhibits
26 ;
51.. RO #16046
27 (NRV-00002-002I-NRV-00002-0023)
28
52.. Window sticker (NRV-00002-0001)
I ........
Case 2:03-cv—OO869-FJIVI Document 178 Filed O1/27/2006 Page 1 of 4 `

' 53. Tradewinds Owner’s Guide (as attached to Mr. PRE 402, 403,
2 Roddy’s Affidavit in support of`Nationa1RV’s 701, 802 16
summaryjudgment motion) C P R. 700.8
3 and estoppal ?
4 54. Roddy inspection photographs NRV—Photo 1 through 402, 403, and
5 NRV-Photo 25 (as attached to Mr. Roddy’s Affidavit in 802 as to *
6 support of'National RV’s summary judgment motion) affidavit ,
·r 552 RO# 3341 (NRV—00002—0024 through Limited
8 ` NRV—00002-003 1) objection to
dealer opinions
9 involving
ultimate issues
I0 and statements
ll involving
character under 7
12 402, 403, 602, *
13 802, 16 CP .R.
700.s aaa
1** FRCP 26. j
15
56 National RV repair record of 5/ 12./99 consisting of Limited
267 7 iiii RO#s7 2237837, 2237847 and 223875 iiii 7 7 70l5j<5ction tb 7 7 7 7 7 7 7
E7 (11 pp.) dealer opinions
involving
13 ultimate issues
,9 and statements
involving 2
20 character under f
21 402,403, 602,
802, 16 C.P.R. if
22 700.8 and
22 FRCP 26..
24 57 National RV repair record of`9/15/99 consisting of RO# Limited
25 21977'S (4 pp.) objectionlto
dealer opinions Q
26 involving
27 ultimate issues
and statements
28 involving
character under
Case 2:03-cv—OO869-FJIVI Document 178 Filed O1/27/2006 Page 2 of 4

1 402, 403, 602,
2 802, 16 CPR
700.8 and i
3 FRCP 26. ‘
4 58 Gas reimbursement request and payment records (5/99) F R.E.. 402, Q
5 `A ($100.00) (3 pp.) 403, 408, 802 ’
6 402,
701, 702, 802
7 901 & 16
i iiiiigiiiiiiia-»i Exhibits CIF R4 §"’°r8
9
10 59., FreightlinerlWarr‘a11ty history on Mr. DeShazer’s motor F .R.E. 402, 403 I
home (FCC000l-0017) duplicative & j
ll cumulative ;
I2 60.. Freightliner Custom Chassis Warranty Information
rs (FCC00l8-30)
14 61. Jody Adams’s Inspection Report, with attachments 802
1 5 (PCC0031-39)
16 62 . Freightliner Invoice for the chassis used to 402., 403
ity manufacturer Mr. DeShazer·’s motor home (P CC—0l74- ;
79) j
is ,
19 63., Inspection video tapes (FCC00042l—423) 402, 403, 802, ‘
901 . 6
20
21 RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED this 27th day ofianuary 2006
23 By: s/Marshall Meyers
Marshall Meyers
24 Ian Pryor
25 KROHN & MOSS, LTD. .
lll W, Monroe, Ste. 7ll
26 Phoenix, AZ 85003
27 Attorney for Plaintiff
28 j
Case 2:03-cv—OO869-FJIVI Document 178 Filed O1/27/2006 Page 3 of 4 `

1 Filed electronically on this 27th day of January 2006, with:
2 United States District Court CM/ECF system
3 E
4 Courtesy Copy mailed this 27th day of January 2006, to: N
5 Hon Frederick J., Martone
6 United States District Court, District of Arizona
401 West Washington
7 Phoenix AZ 85003
8 Notification sent electronically via the Court’s ECF system and mailed on this 27`lh day of
9 January, 2006 to:
*0 Mr. William M., shaman
ll Quarles & Brady Streich Lang LLP
12 Renaissance One
Two North Central Avenue
13 Phoenix AZ 85004
14 John C. Hendricks
15 Attorney ‘
Meagher & Geer PLLP
16 8800 N Gainey Center Dr Suite 261
17 Scottsdale AZ 85250
*8 S/cathy Bop];
19 Cathy Bopp 7
20
22
24
26
27 T
28
4 ..
Case 2:03-cv—OO869-FJIVI Document 178 Filed O1/27/2006 Page 4 of 4 Q

Case 2:03-cv-00869-FJM

Document 178

Filed 01/27/2006

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-00869-FJM

Document 178

Filed 01/27/2006

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-00869-FJM

Document 178

Filed 01/27/2006

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-00869-FJM

Document 178

Filed 01/27/2006

Page 4 of 4