I SI¤c1v1n¢>v»\rYI.C\c¤f\< ADC¤N=|I33‘7Q. RECENEU _d_f(;0PY
'q$?C‘T»\
CSOYI, ·— _
3 ex ¢]v~·z¤v»cx 357}; wqob CLEHKU$D,STR‘ewc0g¤T
4 P¥¤·;•·n+·'cC—P;O Se BY {31sTFuGT OF Amgcgépu-W
5
6
7 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
g DISTRICT OF ARIZONA
9 Shann011~1\=14ehagLLj.la.:lg.,....â€. SW, .+., -EHCLHCE)
11 V. Response +0 PIaln+i¥¥'; M0+;,,,,,
for SuMvr•‘lQry J·¤·tdavv•1@v3+
12 ValueOpti0ns, Inc.,e+. ul., ‘
I3 Defendant.
14 ‘
ig k ?:n{n+}Y¥,S\ann0n michael CMYK, {>ufSuar1+ —k:» Rujq Sb,F€d-R.C¤:r·p. ,
HEY 'EPMS `*° D"C*f·""m€y'5 ’€$P¢`>»·1S€ ·k> P\¤¤¥»·»+.'¥TL< Mp+.by, EW
17 Sumrnqry 1~\»{A3VV\€YI+, I5 YVIO‘*‘:Dn SHDMIA be gfqn+ed q-S
18 `DF-Cruvwklcyk response Felles €h+:l`€`)· vn ¤.nq;}vm`55§LLg ev;¢]e¤C€
19 TMA ‘*"‘?¤[>p0f+€¢` CQWCIMSOYY 5+¢¢+€»vn@n+$ by cvunge,] ».:\¤{C|,, m—q_
20 '"S"¤‘°€**¤+ dw/n viewed a5¢z·'ns+ %2. S+¢>.ndqr`& Féquieed under S
21 •`¤.1.1Q p ; · . ,
22 Qppigu ` *1 -I/L3 HBPIY ·s 5uH:•pt‘·I·ed by #1 p\€Qc}m3g 0,, SME)
comm memofandum up Fel +S A ' '
23 DL_§eC+;OnS 3+0 Dr. Cruwlme r C *:2 QW ‘ q·.4,"f'£10¤`·"}~€5 qq;] 44%
24 WA A ’ l {S on ceverjhqg S4-q+e4~,€y1·} ,,.[Z FglC.g.S
DL éd\+`0“Q`I S+q`+Q"â€â€™Q"+ 0; ;Q.C+S In 0PPOS2+•`OY}.
25 Res e-HZ H 3 · -
26 pe M y MLM-++eA =H1.$ 5*21.1), J O¢,46Le,r Jgpgrp,
.S`kqn••1¤v·• H.C\qr·k-· Hq¤;•;·H /Prg5g_
28
ase 2:O3—cv—O1344-EHC-HCE Document 270 FiIed10/10/2006 Page10f4
I
_g I †4 “
..;...- ~ A;O;l2% s£$.-.¤Rj:EL §¤JmiucL Y€w..
_m___ ____ ml; I; JI; Qgqlgtg MA ,;\`5PQ5g __QE Qgcglqmllil ,,m$,iF,Pm;;.¤;gA _______w_
. W. . “ ¤.x¤,;ms QI AEEEUSQS.? gggiéé Qgge, Eg, 52m+i 54;;; gg. 3[jZ,,_A
. _ _W m 22, ;;2_,g5 L1 1&¤> ____ +»_m _
;Eu.$&_S d
W n N l w“’; M.* .§;%MLEEBQm q¥E .`A· ¤3.,;1s. , _ Q »: ;»% thm. {.4-ieP¤s·l+;myJzj
-,,.. '*0 ...-.Q.Am;T ,,c1:}w. ` ’ ’ ' " A '
pe. isL_g,..g.e.g»•.{¤e gw ..
MW gg; H12 ;4{sL_¥.;.;jg;;; n__ _____w ¢
- M.» ` é %f.*'Q w gJ.m+;.m jgm" §g.mmgx§y
¤ , ?‘ 4Qwm¤¢$_mu$x ;»L ¤.»¤kL£»J¤;¤+4·4_ ..
` ¤}:>¤;¤_4¤;J.z>.
,._._ w.,___ drkgimiigqted LY and .g+...i¤..c.Le¤L.:l¤*a;> g$;§¤HauLi , J w ; -.-:4 ·
.--_-_ --... .·;L ¤m . iLL¤M£Q·ghpmjLe____e;LQLji; m?a_
E QQ\,L}A__`_h€_____Q__¢£ !1Z}‘tQ QL€,e,, [J5, y;. ]2.'§Llg , HAimE_Q,_;{
-?-- Ag LLj59¤ S? »§j°*‘Q.`;, !it]gj),’ gig; é g1\§;£: Fg. Pggsg ’ .. , E , . ,_ ·
-. ..V. . .. .4H;»Lmji:§£d; y ¤;Lt5_¤§&»__LLi>s_i“£YhQm:b;¤Mg;j¤`q3 QML
»-- —|-§éd&H:i¤¤r1a}é+x J?qLxs ._¤LLLQ1%;¤>;q1—¤,§Mm _
---» Q¤»f@¢4L¤ (¤.5T&;;L.1\, B.£.(.`,..).e.“@Q___
enc; In
e——» - »&»f -.-—E¢cH¤L¤. ley;$M¤P¤;¢;dJ a;9ms&$ \ ` »;¤
—»Y~—---»J£&\s·LC@¥£;5Lc ·n;4¤LeLm_¤g_ug»;¤;e;g¢iveg bal _
__-.` W . gs gxk", L §j;C,_.
C ggé-?2$§;EJ:“xF) Y3l 4-`I CYI _>Hci1@{`]27O FiIecW`O/1WZ§T)G Page 2 0fZl `“
, . __-..-..-- cumxmuiingi. A r»_L&L;isTQka¤,_aJ¤ i$%MmWW_
_r m»n.-l-- -... ` dmissLB1e._.QcLam;; ¥ §.i_HcQ bXgyA,w
..-_-----.--.- W- A cLs--.»z2 W A.. ¢Ls Lm5me&¤_". b2.>;ecâ€;“u¢;Lk>m;L_Li._{p-_.--_.
L;.;m&;$@. __ ____ ___________ ______ uA,_ _________,“__M____________
` Dz£&~c1¢Lnj \.¤L _ , A£L` wp»tp »;
W-.._.-.---..-.----_ lfY\ , ___,h_,__
A * Ti;¤ uns2. N A.e¤yj;¤5%-¥?I§\T?·i?hi`?Q¤i;¤J#$K; ALQA Q @m$;I;.d;;,;,‘L*¢·g¤a\ glgkit
, ""“{¤"2` L" L3 A .9¥;;_+; ;mA4 ¤,;Pmp¤;eL5;x1 €1;5‘.k: l`. gi E
» *m£;O wl E
_, A ...
___ ___A W cmd ` ¤; Jig¤ y12.L, I};. C.mmI¤[g>¢ Eg'. EQA Jig Pr;¤;»;Ld
____ ________ __4_ Q n Jr-` J,.;aA°Hq *1*:1 ¤.c‘2?M.c•..·I·g g_•;LA__q_PP1’;¤PQg`Qf;& SML Q`.•3¤`b;[,j7_
,_;Q+€mgmi;gg_..;&\_AL\;5e_¤qLJC€ :m5‘.§£>g.~€m€ in 1,,; Mngk
505 Q m¤;i;ik,4;;¤m\ ,.;.5gDt MA 6.- pg;
____________ +¤ gg <1¤lQ!Q+g and gPErQp,g`Q;Q sm; £L`,glL;];+
%N%% m_ - _ . .,w;.£,._-.¤. AP?LQ?I;1@ 5_;;_L___
. . A ggglggfqp; ww ``
r;DQ££!7\C‘.C11*’1+..-. ,• .1. .- .. * . . . ‘
____ )_?_w___i#|;DLi,_§_l4.?_P_Q_[i____ QS Lil-15 E2? P`QSl i;On S'%LiIr:·!!"L`·E—Z-!Q'IP¥- Q1,. éfit bQ}_Ki3__MA
{nge]; k`;m 3»q,§;`.:};I€5 Plql-¤};'.;{ gig q _$gm_m_g_r*
._?_MJ;¤A_gu¤.emj·..---L¤ .... , LEE •;e;pe.e+ Q·4. { [y .
..__--%1]+Ag
_“_ , l wi", ,.4:., 2-·
k EDATF skqnnan M· Clark-P|n•n+i — ‘ ¢·Sq_
m n___ __________A_M_#?n___________ m___
A
_ ''’. U n-__E;§|£5§Y) SiE{)YO1 344E%Y|—TCkE EHrf1`éTig§"` OWO7.’2T)â€( é1`§;*é4(§“ }6f`4 "“`
’ Q·¤`g£m‘\ Ji? One, \·¤¤1»»dwrI++en COP), mimd 10/5}% +¤:} [`_\q;·L,’
2 u.s,¤1$+m+ Coufhgandra DQ, O'c‘mm¤»~ us. €0._1,—+p,m,SQ
3 5+12-*50,*101 W· \¢d¤$L.}nS+0n 5+- , SPC~/ , Phgewix J
4 A¥`1‘Z.0V¥Q ‘5$OO'3·Ri12
5
6 §&;@h¤ndwrZ++ew ¢i»1=y mcdled a0/S/Ob +0; 1x1¤1·1;ng , Kclsrucf,
7 SLOJQZTCF/?T2’gZgPLE5JST}R7 "" S‘°°""""‘°"Q` *<*7»S~1*/O»
8
9 _ -, ____“,,_,,__m_ V. _ 0. -- .. ,.4 . -2,. .. ..
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
E8
» _ 19 .
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
asc 2:03—cv—01344-EHC-HCE Document 270 Filed 10/10/2006 Page40f4
*-1
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 270
Filed 10/10/2006
Page 1 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 270
Filed 10/10/2006
Page 2 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 270
Filed 10/10/2006
Page 3 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01344-EHC-HCE
Document 270
Filed 10/10/2006
Page 4 of 4
United States Free Forms
Canada Free Forms
United Kingdom Free Forms
Australia Free Forms