Free Reply to Response to Motion - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

\£¢—;$%¤-Per M. ‘.5e.ne¤;ck FRED .,____LODGED
•°¢DC.‘·&· \\?:•'-}9~3 ___ RECEIVED COPY
2*; eji;. igrijmn ¤L *3 5231 - 5%::0 CLERK LJ S DISTFHCT COURT
?\QM_m£‘* 112 ie; BY DISTRICTOFARIZQSJQPUW
"IN "T\·\'E UNITED STATES D\$TP-ACT C,Ou.R‘T
FOR THE D\ST?~\<`."T SF F=?~\‘2.0r~IA
L?~\"3'TOFER M, SENECA, Nc. Cv 03-850-P¥\><—%'RB
Plath-\+i?F, \ l l
REPH xw $uP?ev:Y oe Menon
V Te s·rmv.E DEFE:~wm~1‘T$` Saceub
MOTION FOR 5uHr‘\A'R‘< ‘.TuDGME¤~J’T
%‘T4>~:·:=a ci Aznzowh, e+ 41.)

?\0»\(~.-¥}·¤`, K.¢—€s&¤·Yer \"\. %€,·naccx, pg @4 Merebj ·p{\€S his
P~<=.p\·j in 5¤.mpp¤c·\- 0-C Hs M¤—\-i¤¤ ·\~0 `5—h—{\Le De·?e.n<;¥¤m-\:5` %ee.¤¤d
Mohan For Bummcmj `;Yw:\3men~'•r_, ae £¤\\ows$
Fire-¥_ `De$e¤e\cm—\·s° respcnae pre$2n·\-s no c03e¤·\ qrgq Me¤+,*
bu.-X- Oxmoum·¥5 +¤ no mere. -H·»¤m an i§¤¤¢—¤.—\-Ce elenebé.
Mesir —Ca-’r¤~\ ie ‘De¥e¤d¤.¤¥s’ can-¥e¤·\·i¤¤ +\¤¤-\· Hqej "presc-zrueclu
-H·q;;¢— c\¤.?m in -H·»eic· Answer, is Fd.K·C€v.P. \l(j)» I-K: is um—
<;\;5Pu-\e¢`\ +\¤¤·\¤ We; ·pi\e$ cx Rude IQ ·~·»¤-\»¤¤··»J Duc. Ne. QJ, \¤.,.—¥
Qxcludaél `H65 Chim. A¢¢<=·¢d>·-· Aho \"\" up QSQQNO EL
Fur-Uwerl ·¥\¤c·j wlsk jh: {mpg-\—& ‘\’\¤e.\r -€¤\Q\ur€. on ·\*\¤ls C0u¢—·¥;y
¤;¥e.¤s{¥>l5 beequse +\»:s Comin- di& n¤-\- deshlne-`\re. ·H¤1s. as cn c\¤rm_
$unc,\¤ cx c,¤n·’ce¤·\··P¤¤ is ·prYvc>\¤u5. e
* Thug, Ts ne c\A<;pu—\e. ··H¤¤c\· ·\*\·»e. ¢:\¤;¤m¤¤¥a+I¤¤ issue f`E.Y"’\0¤T.n$!
Case 2:03-cv-01350-SRB D0cument13% Filed O2/16/2006 Page10f4

Lender 18 \A.5.¢· $\9\5A(¤) ·=··<¢\ Cb}, Q C¤Q·—+ is onlj +¤
dekrmtne ».Q\,.e-wer Q pwsenep ··—Q2$e¤\ C·_\Q:.“5 X-\~Q+ me \€<3QUg, {friv-
<>lc>Qs or M¤\p.;;W$, -€Q:\e¤\ —\~o s~\Q-\e Ck e\cJm_, or seeks mQQe·F>·qj
rQ\:e-F £¢—¤m QQ ¢·—~-Q.··e. c\e¥e.~dQ¤—\r. 1¢L_•·\· (Wm; (3)- 1+5 pw p==se is
hw" ‘\’¤ \n0~v€, 0; C»0ur"\‘ See" ¤v"\' €’.v€,rj {Bam;) qa;} E.v€.nj QhC.¤'“¤rj {55\.4{,a
LEM Ae-Ve¤dQ~¥s. was Ceeéré @Q»»e·\&¤¤ as nd: +¤ Qe¥ Q5 QQx.·\\¤(5 oounseh
In ieek, JMS CWA mQe% $9ee;¥r¤e\\.j ex ehda an ceeqe. melee
Ke s4¤.+..<\~Q or A .~Q.mQ:¤s, De¥e.¤&Q¤—¥s° reverse. c.¤..,—¥Q.¤·\—i¤»~. is c¤.·~.—
+mq -»e we a¤+e.`+ A Congress. l
See,.-,A, D€'{:€nd4¤‘\‘S s-here ’ x>x¤.;.`+z&© "a.¤ee ner" .;¤(Ae5+ we im +\Q—» me £e;xe¤\ ae e»eb`¤Qe+ "+L..—$
?5S-na., (D¤¤,..N¤. B5 q—\» Q.: IO—\\) "Ykra as —L\5e. \—‘\ere\j sQ5:·-3 A does QQ-k
mem Hf —h~Qe..
¤e¥enem.+S JN0 M emqercee QF. ae JM £¤C+Q. r—>1¤.»‘+·+@ m+.,,.¤j
grew-»·\ec\ ¥eQ~\—5 {A his Response (Bm. Nu`--;. Q+ Q-B), P\q;..·\a£E elemlj
demehs-K-¤~qJ,@\ wA\¤ -YQe~\s. —\\¤Q+ ·H»e §ssQe ems. e>s\¤QQs+ec\. In ¤dAJ·H¤nJ
?\Qi¤-K-HPF p¢ese.·Aee\ Hue COUF`\` W;-Ha we cQ¤·e¤X— pr—e.<.eQ\e¤% .`»· +Me
%QP.~emQ Geer-\ Qné Nin-¥\·~ C.t¤—eQ:*v de~»¤¤s.·\···Q+$¤3 under ·\·hQ. Kew
?\Qa¤-H-€\Y ea \»»QQs-RA. (1_g,_ ¤·\· \\·\?•_, e·»¥:-Had "Flnin-\£·FF Ex hans-\-ed
A\\ Claims Friar +o F·i\in5 $•·si+.")
°'T\¤:.~A_ be-Cehaem-¥s do M+ Aa$?Q+e. +\¤¤& Meewr poke.; On sehrnjl
¤Q+tw~ QP 2-¥e,-`S. vc.-»\Q~\ee +Le l7i•—s·\· Am•¤&mu»·\·, me Ae —\·\.ej p.·e;=.e,,+
Q eegenie mgm Menie +\~Q¥ +‘•·»ej 6-¤ ¤¤% —¢~`¤\Q·¥e Jane R\.uxPA,
F¤Q¢~+\,, @\e:¤+i—FF‘<. q,\¢.:~»s GFQ Q¤+ “¤e~" nor me +\»·ej QH °°ex+e¤s¤¤¤”
QP QH on-S. "SMQ Q\-mm; were se C\€.Qr SQ +he C¤~.P\Q:¤+ (BQ;. we. I Q+
*5-5%) *c\~Q+ me 5e¤*¤~·s <¤r~g¤~»e¤-¥ e,e...\d lee made -\~\·»Q—\ he :s·&—.e.e wes
Case 2:03-cv-01350-SRB D0cumen"?137 Filed O2/16/2006 Page20f4

ununswn +o <:>~ ·-eqecmbke men A ¤m\:Mmj :¤—\eu:ge¤ee,
C¤w.se\ <:.cxnncr¥ ¤+n;x..u+e ker inc<>mg>e:¥cnce on-xs +ms Come.
Bedrte.-» PMSA does M4 pecBe.:¤=·._ me ¤\\¤W} ·\-we C¤¤¤—+ ·h¤ guide ¤.
,,,xex.?,,,C;q,.+ B5 JM um, SM; an semen wma use Q CWA lim Q,.
a...P¤r+»ex mxwmx X-¤ an qcjvkue pm-——\ am, _“·x2 %u‘)rE,m@, C0ur‘¥’ T€.;`€.¢‘¥€'.A Gu ~'\@{3‘h'\'EnQ.A \"‘¤ECl>L/L{`r`€•’\•·\€n"\'
’•m\e\:¤~.5 +\.q-‘+ a. s\»¤·~—¥ QAA P\¤n~¤ s-\—¤.+¤..···»e¤-‘c is 5v.·g;?c.{e.-»—\¤ +¤ qpprqase
<;\e¥e¤d¤¤·\·S c-? w\··==·¥ 4%% »»»»»s+ be peepema -\¤ ·~»ee+. See $wicr| v $or¢m¤s¥.%.U.S. _._, aaa *5.C+, 912. (200.:0,
Finqtlj, De¥`e¤c\¤n·¥s do n¤+ <;¤e¤+e»·] w.‘+\¤ anj cuheref-·+ or-gw
men-x ar ems xm, +b.¤.¥ enaer —we £e¤+5 P\¤:,.++4F¥ CMA e» do +\.ej dzspeh he qppheqhen ei? -H».e »·.Oe+ e.m—€n+ preeedemk OA
exkquswem, .·\eMe\j §w':Ier w. Riamda., P¤e+e¢· v. Nessie, and B_•E¤__L.
v. Veleff (cmd :». Maven/Respwe G+ aa-ns),
in as d:£F;e..x+ —\» cmg;.-.e +k:s CWA mtcng a»~ 4?qv¤r OQ bell
%¤<5.¤m-’cs w¥·.e¤ {Jr is qndispdedl wi-\·\¤ c,¤3e¤—\- ¤\.·—3“meA+, -Hn¤+ P\¤l4+»‘—|¥
e.x\n I1(Q?` MA %\¤¤+ -\’\~e issue-, em cznlj be m:$eA bj wsj J \*'eA.?..¢3v.?.
\9.(b}.& P\¤.*:.·.·\+R? is e.·v\·l·\·\ed —\·<=· r.¤s·¥s .3
REsv&c·r1=uLul ‘5uBm·¤E¤ %1;=,.£€E dal O-F Feksme.-j_ Qloce
K?`\‘5"\'D?E(l MxcHAEx. BE ECA, EE0 is
A

°· See ggpene, 3\'5 Fxsa noe, ms (sw cw. awe;)
5 P\¤;r.· is e reueaxrn pw en CWM1 Maw we Aneipleg
elueedewa Jn Cue-Lznell ‘1;%,._.F-% OP. ns4.<,¤; u—n T`""`
3
Case 2:03-cv-01350-SRB D0cument137 Filed O2/16/2006 Page30f4

0mc;u~=m. cm! one cow e? Jrm
I QUFQ DUE
i 0*5; §€.k¤ruL¤·rj,_ 3~.OO(¤, +01
"T'\h(>_ ·\·\~¤n0roJ¤\& 5~·'·$¤`n Y-. B°\'\‘°¤
unem $@5 ivif-**~`¤* T¥-¢a<·-
Oman ONE Cc•P*\ mehed ·¥¤:
1 5*-'L$¢·»m\q
Mhraed {Yer 'De-?e¤dq¤+s
Bw.
LMS
e
` " V ""' ’ ' ' "' ‘







e .
Case 2:03-cv-01350-SRB D0cument1‘(§7 Filed O2/16/2006 Page40f4

Case 2:03-cv-01350-SRB

Document 137

Filed 02/16/2006

Page 1 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01350-SRB

Document 137

Filed 02/16/2006

Page 2 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01350-SRB

Document 137

Filed 02/16/2006

Page 3 of 4

Case 2:03-cv-01350-SRB

Document 137

Filed 02/16/2006

Page 4 of 4