Free Motion for Miscellaneous Relief - District Court of Arizona - Arizona

!" " # $ % % & ## % ")&( *"+ ( , % # " - ./ # *0 1 . 2 "3 0 4 &5 6 # " ) 7 8 6 # " ) 7 # 6 # " & ) 7 & ##6 # " ) ## $ 8 9 8 # % / 3 " % )3 $. : ( 3$ '

!2; 9< = ,,' 2@>!!.

> ,?: !

% / ,' %D !

4

4*;E49 %

*" # 8. 8 !>: , =: % A9!>/ B %',2> %2'>/ / =**A@ %' . : . ,% 9C C %/ =**A@ %' * ,@. : . ,% 9 8 # ! #$ & $ " ($ * " % ' $ &) (+% ) & (! $ , #0 $ * . $ , , .$ % /) +

9 8 % )3 $. : 3 ( ## (

#. 0

) 8 # > % -* F

(" %G

B % F9 8 & .0

#

#

/3" % . : ( 3$ #0 ( ( 50

C &C 5

% /3" ( 3$ ( #0 " .

#G &$

&$ ) - #0 % ( # #

- *" # 8 8

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 1 of 19

5 ( #0 9 8 )

8) 7 H ) # ( #

*" # 8 0 ( 8 " 83 ) 7$ ( - 7 8 ( # ( #0 # 20

#& 7 & # ( 7

#0

# ( "

&

( #0 $ 8 " ) # # (# " 3 7 ( &$ #0 # #0 8" " 5

8" (" $

(3 # 3

( 8* )

*" # 8 8 #0 # ( 5 #0 9 8 ) #. # 8"

2$ )3 $) # " # "# .

#0 9I 5( #0 9 8 58 " ( # 0 #. #0 $

8" ( # &7 # # # #0 89 8 . 5 .

( # % )3 # " 5 5 " " # 5 0 *" # 8 8 # # 1 " 0 #" ( " $ ) #

# (# - # )

3 # *" # 8 8 #

8 / )) $ ( 5) # ( 3 # " 8" > 3 $ 8#

" 8#0 "

3 #- ")

8 / )) $ ( & #0 *" # 8 I 8 ) # 20

( 5) # 20 % ( # ") " $ 0 #" 8 # "# ) .

( )) $ 7 5) # ( 58 " ( 7 ( # # (# - # ) ## "

5 ") # & ) #

0 *" # 8I 8

3 #

") 8 1 " ( " $

+ &1 % +1 *" # 8 2$ 8 & 5

% + 3$ 2$ $ 5 %I 0 ! " ) "& #0 ( 50 0 $

. * )

%I

& %I )

0 5 8# "

# "# " "& 0

8# "5 . #0 #

"

3 #$. "

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 2 of 19

3 # ( ) * : 3 #

8#0

&

0 + ,! $" ; 0 * . #0 )

#$!#% &

'

( ) *

. 8&

%I 0) 5 . 8# 2$

%!'. ? &

. 3 ) #

*" # 8 2$ 8 -

# #0 " =3 #0

- 50 #0 )3 $. # "# "

3 ) #

7$ &

H " # #( ( 0 " 5

) 5

0 # # ) "# . " / 2 43 0 3 / 2 0 3 5 5 )3 " 1 " 0 ( " $ - !- " 6 # !

8 " . 1 1 : "#

#$!#% ( ) & *

+ -

,! % & #$!#% & #$& ,"

5 43 5

. *" # 8 2$ 8 * ) +

# 50

%I ;( )

>

(

# . A ! #&

: 57 . #0 # ( ) * " ( #)

: 57 3 )3 $ #" # # + * ) . + * & # $* )

- #5 # ) #

0

)3 #. "

# ,! $

(.

3 3 # 3 &( ) * ) # &$

#0 0

- !- 6 $! " 20 $ $" & 0 ( $ ") 8 J # ( 8 &" 5 $ 3 # &$ 2$

8 #0 (

#

8 1 " ( 0

$$! % &( ) 6 * : 1 "0 ( )) # ) 3 $ 5 " # ) # ( # # #0 #0 0 K 3 "5 " ( # &$ )) # ) &$

) . *" # 8 2$ 8 ( $

#0 # *" # 8 5 # 0 ) 8 &$ 2( & 0)

" 5 & ##"

# # 8 " )) # ) (

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 3 of 19

*

)

( 5

# "3 0 &$ ( # 80

8 ( & # .

0 0 *" # 8 2$ 8 # # ) . #0 # *" # 8 8 5 *

#3

#K

.

)) # ) (# ) . 5

/ # 5 . # & ( 0

8*" # 8I 3 8

# #

( 5 - 5 &" 7& # 5 # &( # *" # 8 2$ 8 0 - 5 & 5( # ) 0I 3 5 #0 > 5 3 8 ) ,- " !, + &1 $% +1 & *" # 8 9I 5( 8 / 0 ; 7& 7 9 8) 4 ) 4 ) $ ) 8H #) # ( -! . : ## $+ $- $# $, # . 0 ) &$ 0 " # $ 8 3 3 ! %, " % # # # 58 %I # 8 )0 "9 # )3 $) # " 0 /) #0 %

$$! % % " 6 ( $ $ . 5 . 8 # 5 #0 5 5

" #0 3 - ( " ,6 , !

,#! ,,&43

0 ( # " 3 )& / # 3 0 ( .

8

% 4*" # 8 2$ 8 3 0 ( #

5 5 # 7 9 8) 2 0 .

,

!

& ,$!,% 8 & 8- )

7 9 8) *" # 8 9I 5( 8 # 29 ; ++# +, " 0 0 7 9 8) (# " 0 - 5 #

: " 20 ( ( 0 50 # # 5 #0 3 0 ( )

#0 )3 $) #. " 7 9 8) , $ &4 % & 5

+ ! +

- - 4 ,! $& 7 9 8)

9I 5( 58 ) 6 6 +

8 H #" "# # ( $ # #) +! 5 * 5 5 / # 5

$&43

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 4 of 19

,% " 2$ 2$ , * "

9I 5( / # 5 )3 " 5 5

I 3

3 8 ) #

8( # # 0 /)

#0

#0

)3 $ " 9I 5( 4 85 5 )

#0 *" # 8 8 I #

)3 " #0 #

" & ( " # # &" 7& <

9I 5( ,% !$+&

+#&43

85 5

6 ' 9I 5( +) 7 9 8) #5 # & /) 0 H # ( # ) " " # # #0 : # $. ( $ & &43 2$ . 3 " 5 5 8 ) # . &

- + ,! /) ( 80 " " 3

! #" )) 3 8 ) # ) 5 7 9 8) + 0 & H # ( 0 #0 # &( # /) /) & # ) 8 ". " *" # 8 2$ 8 #0 # # $6 " 20 # !$ # " # 8 0

$6 !$+&( ) * 9I 5( " 20 0 # "3 0 8) * 0 1 # #0 # 0

$. *" # 8 2$ 8 / # 5 # # ) " " 8 )

9I 5( 0 0 . 0 0 # 8 ) # 8 #.

/ # 5

0$ *" # 8 9I 5( 8 # "0) 0 0 H # / ( 0

#0 # *" # 8 2$ 8 #0 # 0 #

" #0 # 0 0 " # 7 9 8) 9I 5( 7 9 8)

# " &$ *" # 8 2$ 8 #! & ,&43 0 5 5 &$ #0

#0 # 0 0

,, $6 $ " )3 $ " # #0 & + ) # %" & %0 2( 0

#0

") #

#0 # 0 0 $ ,

+- +- + 6 ( ) # & * I 5 * "5 # " 8 1 "0 ( 4 '" -

*" # 8 9I 5( 8 (# 8 > 0 2 # #) $. A

#0 - .>5

"5 " / ".

/ # 5 . > 0

* ##

7 9 8)

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 5 of 19

8 "5 " )

0 0 (0

$" ) # )3 # "

*" # 8 " 5 8 " - ") #

#0 # 0

)3 "

# % 4*" # 8 2$ 8 #0 # *" # 8 9I 5( 8

& ( #0 # -

&( % 4*" # 8 2$ # 8 +$+!+$ "

$ #+(/ ,% $ (+$ + ) >( " # 8 J #0 3 # 8 " 8 # # . . #0 > % -* 3 ) " 5 !0 #0 ( "
#0

8#0

" " >(

8% -" *

( 3 ) # #0 7

83 # 8 " 8

# (

$ 50# # .

"8 8#

5 ( 8#0 # #

) (

K

))

H # (

8" .

8 #
#0

K / 9 5 0= ) . ) # # 8 . #0 "& 3 7 " ( 8#0 # # (# 0 &$ #0 # 8 .0

%

: #0 # # 8 8 3 # #

- 7

# -

#

- #0 ) 7 / 9 5. ) # #

( # # " 50# & 8#0 3 ) (# " H ) # ( - 7 3 7 ( # 5 > % -* M0 #0 (# & . #0 # ) #

- . 3 " ;

( # F)( # 1 ) ) # "8 . . # ) (# &$ #0 3 3 3 7 ( 8 I

( L )3 # " #0 3 # #0 # # #0 ## )3 # . #

#0 #0 3 0 >9 /

88 ( / .

G / 53 0( 9 (# ) $ # #( # # &

%

? 83 . " (#

= (

- #0 #

3 3 # . #0 3 8 # 8 #0 . #0 3

#0 3 # 8 " 8 3 # 8& " 8

#0 ( 3 7 # ( #0 ")

3 # " #

)3 # 4 ( "

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 6 of 19

;

. *" # 8 0 ( & 8 " 3 # 8 . . -

5

#0 5 (

8) 7 - 7 (

&

( #0 $ 8 "# ( #0 . 8

# 8 & #0 #0 8 # $ & #0 3 # 5 #0 5

8#0 # # 8 3 ) #" 3 3 # & " 3 8 #

9 8

#

" (8 " 8 #

3 7 (

"& "

" 8 #0 *" # 8 I . 8

+ &1( % +1 + #( , , +$ " 1& $ #$ & ( & 4" $ 4 4 %$ 20 F ) # ) " #$ 8 #$4 #0 8 #( "& *" # 8 & ( 8 50# / # # : ,/ # # G 5 ( # 7 ( H ) # ( 8 8 8 #0 3 ) - 7

% 4+ % , ( &,

# # #

8

#

#0

") / 9 5. ) # 8) # #0 3 )( # 5 3# # 8) 7

: / 9 5. )

)3 " : 5 # #0 )) 3" # 3 ( # ( # ( 20 #

, #( " # +

: ) ,/ # 20 #0 & ) ( 8# ) . 3# ( ; "5 # " ( # # (# 5

- #0 3 # 8 " 8 #0 ) # #0 # ") #
#0

#0 5 ( %

(# % ( # 8 3 " 8 ) 3 8 # 3 # # 8 &

( # 0 " #0 # #0 F ) # # 85 ) 5 " #0 " " 20 8 8 # "$

G

H ) # ( #0 "5 " ( # 50 #0 # 8 "5 "

( . " ( #0 50

( "3 &") 8 "$. #0 )) # ( #0 . #0 # 8 8 # # " 5#0

(# 1 " 3 # ( # 8 ) #

0 *" # 8 0 8 "$ ( ( 5 *" # 8 I " ) 8 ) #

(8 8 )

"$ # " 8

# )

. " ( #0 & #0 50 "5 # "

1 " 0 #" ( " $ # ( # 50 #

) #. #0 )

8 1 " 0 #" ( " $

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 7 of 19

)) 5 8

#

#

(

20 8 #( " & I 8 0 " # $ & %8 " $ # # 5 ") %8 "5 # "

5 (

8*" # 8 2$ 8

I

")-

#" 8 ) *" # 8 9I 5( $ 8 #. 0 *" # 8 8 5 # 80 .0 %

8 8

# " 5#0 8# ) # % #0 ; " $ " $

*" # 8 2$ 8 : 8 #. *" # 8 8 "5 # " 3 #

& 5 ) 9I 5(

# & " 8 &$ 0 #)

)3 # 0 " - .

" # #0 # ) 3 $ / )3 $ " ( 8 "5 # " *" # 8 9I 5( 8 ( # &$ ( #0 . ) #0 0 & # # ( # ) ) # #0 .

8 ) / 3 )& # 0 *" # 8 8 )3 $ " & ) 5 0)

( $ 8 8 . ( # 5 5 # 0 (# # " 8 # "- " #0 8#0 0 #0 ") #0 ( & # # 1 3 # & # .0 #0 8 8 #

*" # 8 2$ 8 ( # &$ #0 " # #) 0 #0 &( # 5 0 #) #0 3# ( 5 ( 5 "5 "

") # #.

" #

0 :

"- "3 0 ( 4 1 " ( #0 0 #0 # -

( 8 "5 # " 0 3# ( " " $. 1 " ( #" $

& # #

0 8#0 *" # 8 8 % & ( "5 # " )3 # - $ 5 8 "

0 *" # 8 )3 8 " 3 # #0

20( . " ( & #0 *" # 8 " ) #0 # #0 $ #0 50 8 # ) #. #0 8 #( "& ( 8#0 # ) # 5 ( # 3 # ( 5#

1 3 0 ") -

# 5 8

1 " 0 #" ( " $ #" $

5" *" # 8 0 - 8 " # $. 8

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 8 of 19

# 8 #0 8 # $ -

H ) # 8 3 ) (

- 7

#0

0 ( #0 "

8

&

+ &1( % +1 720 ) " $

+ #( , , &

+$ , ( ##, 5" (+% , 6 , % $ &, ( 1 ( #0 ) 5 ""

4 & # # : 8

8 # #0 # " 8*" # 8 " ) " 8 )) H # ( # . # . #0 #0 ( 8" -" -

# &" 0 ")

8 #G / 9 5. ) 8 8 # "5 " ( . #

0 *" # 8I 8 3 ") 8 # (

( 0 #0 # 8#0 - (" + ## #

. #0 % ( # # -" -

( # "0 - # 5 " " )) H # ( 8"

0

")

#0

0 ( & "

: / 9 5 . #0 ) " # # #( # 8 #0 ( % # #( # ) 5 & ( - 3 ( 8" ; 0 "" 0 3" 3 " + # 8 # 20

( # 0 " #0 # #0 3 # 8 8 " # " 8 "$ 3 # "5 " #& #0 5 #0

# &" 0 3# #

))

H # (

8 ( 0 #

" 5 5 #0 # #0 : " ,/ (# 1 " 3 "$ #0 #. ) # " ( #0 50 # #- * # &" 0 3# # 3 &$ #0

3" # 3

#0 # 3 # 8 " 8 ) $

- " 3 " $ 8 "$ " ( # 4 20 #0 ( # #0 # ( & " :

( ( 1" 3

(# =/ #0 .

" 8 *" # 8 " ) " 8 ( )) # ( #. #0 #. #0 ) H # ( 8 8

& ( 50# ( ")

8 # #0 # #0 8"

8 # (

# 8 #( " #( #

( 0 - # " ))

## #

( # 0 " #0 # #0

8 # ( . " ( & #0 *" # 8 I " ) #0 50 8 # # &" 0 )) ( H # ( #0 8" ) 5 8 # "" 8 ) 1 " ( # #

) #. *" # 8 8

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 9 of 19

& " . 3 (

0 *" # 8I 8 20( . 8#0

") 8#0 - (" +

# 0 ## # 9

-" # -

8 8

# "5 " ( . # " # "0 - # 5 " "

. #0 % ( #

0 *" # 8I " ) 8

! 0 *" # 8I %" ) 8 2 3 - & " #0 # #0 #
#0

# J (# # #0 # 0 ( 80 ( # &7 " ) K . #

1 "0 ( "

) #.

0 *" # 8 )( # 0 8 #0 # #0

3 0$ (#

(# 8 (8 8 #" $ # ) # " #0 " 3 0$ &" $ 5 -

1 " #( K ( -

3 - - #

" #0 #

)3 $) # " . #" $ ( #. # - ( ## ( . :

&( 2 (# " #

) # @ A B0 / 9 9 0 #0 ( # ) # 5 #0 #0 . " (

' 8 )5 . ) # 5 #0 8 H ( ) (8 8

%

3 - - . #0 - #$. 0 #0 # . #0 0 #0

$ 8#0 8 8

" #0 " $ # 8

0( " # 5. ) )3 $ I "

# (

3 8 ) ( # -" 3 &7 $

) # )( # & & #0 &7 # - " $

&( - ( ; # & 0 - # 0 #0 # ( # ) 3" 3 . 0 8#0 *" # 8I 8 # #0 "5 " # ( # 0 (# 0 ") 3 8 8 *" # 8I 8 )3 " 1 "0 ( "5 # " 0 # 8 8 ) # # 8 #( " #( # 3 # " : $ #0 # " " " "

. #0 7 $ ( (# # # )

3 # # #0 . 8

8 1 ") ( 8 # #0 # ( "5 "

8&$

20 . #0 7 $ ( 1 " ( - " # #0 ( 0 #0

"0 " (#

- ( " *" # 8. 8

0 #0

" ) &$ #0 # 8#0

- ( "*" # 8 20 7 $ 8 ( "5 " ( #. #

" " 0 - # "

- #$ #0 "5 "

3 - -

0 *" # 8. # 8

# )

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 10 of 19

(# 0 #0 #(

3 0$

" #0 " $ &" $

#

5

0( " # 5. ) #0 #0 # *" # 8I 8

)

8 8

- ( ##

. " #0 7 $ " $. ( ( # -" &7 $

# 8 0 #0 #0

3 8) & #0 &7 # - " $

"0 - # " 8 8

# )

-

) #

- # #0 # 3 # ( *" # 8 " 8 ! 0 *" # 8 0 8 3 # # 0 8#0 # 8 8 # 8 #( " #( # 20 # 8 #0 $ 8 . #0 3 #0 # H ( )) 5 8#0 3 ) #0 7 $ # 5 ( ( - 7 8"

- (" + 8 # #0

## #

*" # 8 8 #

# # 4 / 9 5. )

! 0 *" # 8I %" ) : - " 9 8 8 8 20 "5 " *" # 8 2$ 8 *" # 8 2$ 8 . " $ (# ( #3 4 &" 8 20 8 # # #0 H ( # I ( ") 3 # -" 5 # "5 # " % #. . 0 #0 # ") 0 ( . "5 " # #0 # 0 *" # 8 8 &$ 4 5" # 5 # #8 #0 0 #0

#A5 " ( : 3 # . 4 C -# -. 4 # "5 " 3 3 # # 02 #0 # I

/ # # ( 3 . )3 $ " 5 ( .

" 0 - # 3 - #0 # "

2 #" D: " & " : #$ # #0 7 $ # ( )3 $ # *" # 8 2$ 8 . #0 3# ( I #0 ) -" # (

1 " 0 ( " $ &$ *" # 8 2$ 8

% 8" # #

3 )3 #

*" # 8 9I 5( 8 #0 1 " ( ) I "5 " # # ( # 20

( 3 % -

5 5

)

8

#0 H # ( : #0 5

8 0 #0 8-

( " " &" 8 #0 $ " 5 # 5 &" 8 ) #8

( 3

(#

( "&" #$. . %

)3 $) # "

# *" # 8 9I 5( 8

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 11 of 19

8 0

#0 # #0 5 & 0 -

)3 $ "

1 #0 # #0 )3 $ "

&" (

# 3 - # &" 8 " # # $ &$ #0 . ( 3 ( 3 I # 0 - # 5 )3 $ " 20 #

# 3 )3 $ #" - # 5 H ( 5 5 "5 " 8

$ $

3 - #.9 5 ) -" # . ( ) 0 #0 0 #0 ( #. ( 9 " $ 0 #0 % 1 #

#(

3 #( # 3 0 5 5 .

3 =/ .

#0 0 ) #0 7 $ # ( #0 ) 1 " ( ( #.

*" # 8 9I 5( 8 % &" ( &$ # # (

0 #0

( " " &" 8 #0 $ # 3 - #

5 & 0 8 $3 - # #)3 # " *" # 8 8

*" # 8 9I 5( 8 #3 #( # 3 I 3 )3$ "

&" 8 " # # $

% 20 "5 " ( #0 # *" # 8 2$ 8 1 " 0 #" ( " $ 5" #0 7 $ $. ( I -

9I 5(

! 0 8#0 *" # 8I 8 )3 # " 8 8 # "5 " ( "5 # "

") 8

) #

#

0 0 #0 # 0

"0 - # "

3 # " -" # $ ( # #0 "5 " # " # "0 - # 5 " " #

8#0 *" # 8I 8 3" 3 *" # 8 8 #0 0

3 # " 3" $ 3$ # 20 8" 8 .( 8 # -

0 "5 # " . #0 7 $ (

20( . 8#0 ## #

- (" + ))

/ 9 5 . *" # 8 ) 8 5" $ # #

# &" 0 #0 #

H # ( - 7

# 8 #0 $

H ) # 83 ) (

/ 9 5. )

,% $ , +) 1 !8 8 $ 8#0 8& #0 3 ( # # 50 5

+ &1(8 , ) $ " &+ $ $ $ $" +$& $$ ) % % +1 " ( % / 9 ) 4 , 1% & 8#0 3 ) - 7 # # # #0 ) #. 8#0 8 . # # # 87 ( 7$ ( 8 ( " .

&$ 3 # # " 3 7 ( 3 3 # 3

4 / 53 .

: / 53 . #

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 12 of 19

3 3 ( " ( # "# " #0 # ( # #0 ) #

#0 "# " "5 " (# 1)

)3 $ . ( " # ) 5 " ( ) # #

#0

5 9

)

# )3 $I 5 #0

!)3 $) # " (# 8 8

#

9! >: 3 " .

3 ( # # #0 ( ( %

)3 $I ) # - 7 " ( #0 # #0 20

#0 # & #0

H ) # 8 3 ) ( # #0 # )3 $ # # (

) # ( 20 #0 # 8 ( "

#0 3 # # " 7 3 ( 3 3 # 3

8#0 3 # 8 " 8

( 20

(# 8( " ( 20 0 #

)3 $ 1 3

& 3 7 ( 5

&$ 0 - 5 " # " 5 #0 5

3 #8 # #8 " 8 $ 87 $ ( 1) 8 (

(# "

(# 1 " 3

#0 # 8

0 " "

3 # 8. #0 7 $ " 8 ( #0 1" # 3 ( 20
#0

( 0 - # " 5-

- (" 0 " $ )3 $ 8 $ 8 # 0 8#0 #0 $ -

)3 $) # 0 # $ " 5 0) 0 ( 3 # 50 # #

1" # 3 ( " % 50

&$ #0 #0 # # )

#0 # ( 0 # (#

H (

)3 $ I "

(# % ( # 8 3 " 8 ) 3 8 #0 # #0 # # 87 ( ( # N #0 " 8 8

# 5 #0 # #0 8( #0 ) ( # #

3 3 " $

&$ #0

3 # # "3 7 (

)3 $

20 % ( # 0 " #0 # F20 )3 $O "5 " 8 ( # &$ #0 3

(# 3 3 " $ 8# ) # #

#0 3 # # "3 7 ( )3 $ " 4 ; . #0 3 7 ( # # . #0 8 #0 3

& " 88 #( " #$

#0 3 # 8#0 7 $ G ( (

#

#0 3 # # " 7 $ 8 ( 5 8 % "& " #" $ ( # 350

8 (

#0 #

( " 8# #0

(# " 8 (#

8 ) 0 - 5 #0 7 ( " )$ : #

# 5 #0 .

$ 3 # # "& "( "

8 8 #

*" # 8 I 8

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 13 of 19

% M " , # '&# " *" # 8 I 8 ) 3 # #0 ) ( # # ( # &$ "5 " 0 "5 # " 8 8 ) : 80 #3 3 " 8 ) ( 5 #

2 3 # 8 8

" 8*" # 8 I % : 8 # ##) 3 #0 # # #

2 8 "5 "

2 5 #0 1 " ( I ( # )3 " ") 8 8

*" # 8 2$ 8 " #

( # &$ ) . 3 # # % . #0 " 8 #0 " # )

5 ) # "- " )3 $ " 8#0 "5 " 0 # "5 " )

#0 # *" # 8 2$ 8

") # 0 - & "5 # " ( 3 ) #

# " & ( #0 ) "# # &$ *" # 8 2$ 8 *" # 8 9I 5( 8 I .

*" # 8 9I 5( 8 8 #. ) #. 8 )3 $) # " #0

$ 8#0 #

*" # 8 9I 5( 8 0 *" # 8 2$ 8 " 5 3 7 ( #0 # 89I 5(

#0 5 .

0

. " ) #0 # )3 $ " 1 " 0 ( " $ 0

# #0

&

0. $

#0 ) I "5 "

*" # 8 2$ 8 & 8) 5 . # 8 0 : # &

1 "0 ( I I I

) # # #0 )3 # " ") A

( & " 0 " 0

"8 #0 7 $ # 0 ( #3 # #

*" # 8 2$ 8

# #0

$ 8*" # 8 9I 5( 8 *" # 8 9I 5( 8 I ") 8 " $ 8 0 #)

( & 3 7 " ( &

# 3 ) # #0 7 $ # 0 ( #0 # #3 #

)3 # "

( # # #0

# *" # 8 2$ 8

( #0 . *" # 8 2$ 8 9I 5( ) (# #0 # 5 & # 8 # ( $ : #

% 8 #0

" 8- $ $ *" # 8 2$ 8 I "5 # " "5 "

0 #

*" # 8 8 8 1 " ( # &$

*" # 8 9I 5( 8 ( & 3 7 " (

" 3 # $ ") )

/ 3 )& #

" #0 7 $ # 0 8 (

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 14 of 19

*" # 8 2$ 8 %

#0 #

# &

# $

& 8

*" # 8 9I 5( 8

-

)3 $ "

&$

20 7 $. 0 ( ( ) # # %

5 & #0 *" # 8 I " 5 # 8 " " ( ( #0 . # &$ )&

# 5 #0 . ) $

)3 3 5

8 5 #0 &$ #0 *" # 8 8 #

5 #0 *" # 8 I " 5 # 8 " *" # 8 " & 0 8 " $ # #0 ( " 0 (# " ") 8#0 5 8

# #8 5 8 $ # #) 20 #

) 7$ ( 8 9 8 9 8

0 ) $ )3 3 " ## &( #0 $ # # # #" # # 8 "# $ &$ 20 H ( 5 # # #8 5 $ 8 # 5 "( "

#0

0 ) #0 # # # 0 " " ( #0

# 3 7 (

8 #0 *" # 8 I 8 # " )$

- (" " $ 3 # " $ ( " #&

#0 *" # 8 I 8 # # 87 (

( #0 . & 5 8

*" # 8 . #0 8 3 # # % 8 ( " 8

#" 8 # $ 8

0 *" # 8 8 2 2 5 #0 . .

($ M " " 8 ( 8 ) 8 8

: *" # 8 I % 8 8 #0 . -" -

20 *" # 8 I 8 8 8

5 "5 # "

87 $ (

" 3 -" # 8 8 # #) 3

3 - (" 1 " $ 3 8 8 # )3 $ "

# 8 #( " # $ G &$ 3 " "

# "5 " # #

*" # 8 0 8 8 # 8#0 7 $ ( ( (# ( 0 # (

" ## )3 # " # 0 - 5 #0 ) % ; . " ) - . #0 0 #0 &$ #0 0

F)( $ #0 # #8 & ( $ # " H (

5 *" # 8 8 (# 8 -" # (

1 " #( #0 # ( 0 #0 0 3 " 3 8 1 " (

#0 7 $ # ( (# )3 "

3 8

8 &$ 0 #0 # #

- ( " *" # 8 8 " 8 " 8 $ H ( - # #0 7 $ # (

- ( "*" # 8 8 @ A B 9 9 . .

- ( "*" # 8 8 # ) 0 #0 #0

20 "

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 15 of 19

"5 " )3 $) # " 0 #0 # # "5 " *" # 8 8 : ) #- 8 "5 " " $ # ) *" # 8I 8 1" # 3 ( " # # #

(#

(8 8 #

#" $

-

3 - - # ) # ( # #

" #0 #

#

8

0 *" # 8I 8

&( -

( #0 . #0 7 $ ( % 0 #0 H ( % #

"0 - # " %# 3" 3$ 8 8 ## "5 "

0 0

- ( "*" # 8 3 8

3 # - *" # 8 20 7 $ 8 ( # # # )

" " & " 0 #0 )3 #

0 8#0 *" # 8I 8 20 #0 # - (" # ) 3 #. #0 7 $ ( % # "0 - # " )3 $ #>5

& 0 " " &" 8 #0 8& #0 ) # " &" . 0

"& " 3 ) ##

&" 8 #0 7 $ # ) ( #0

" # # 8 # 5 #0 " $

3 # " -" # $ (

0 8#0 *" # 8I 3 8 5 " " H ( 8 ) 0 3 #

( 5

M 0 " *" # 8 2$ 8 " 5 0 /)

( 8 5 # # 8 3 3 #8 )

*" # 8 9I 5( 8 # 1) ) $ H ( 0

3 8 ) 0 # $ A

20( . #0 7 $ ) $ & ( #0 . # )3$ 0 " % #0 8 #( " 8# " # #0 # )( # & 8 ( - 7 . 20( . 0 0 #0 $ # ( " #0

/ 53 . #0 (# 0 "

0 8#0 *" # 8I ( 8 3 8 ( / 53 . #

/ 53 . #0

( 7$ ( 20 7 $ ( " #0 # #0 (

# & 3 ) ## -

8& #0 *" # 8 I " 5 # 8 " 1 " 0 # " 20 ( " $ 5 5 # 8*" # 8 8 #. #0 #0 # &" # (# 0 ( " #

) # #

)3$ # " -

) $ "5 " # # #0 9 8 5 #

3 7 (

7$ (

# 8 & #0 3 $ #" 1 " 3 # # " #

8#0 # # 8 3 ) # #

- #0 *" # 8 8

#0 5 (

8) 7

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 16 of 19

*" # 8 8 # 5 #0 3 7 ( 1 # #

#

# 8 & #0 #0 $

H ) # ( # 5 #0 5" 9 8 $. # ( "

$ # 0 - #0 (# " 7$ ( 8 (

#

( #0 . # $ 5 *" # 8 I 8 #0 9 8 # # #

3 #8 " (" $ "

H # #0 (

(# #

- #0 *" # 8 8 #0

3 # #

$ 8 ( #. 5(

/ ;= ; >2 2;' / B ?: ', A>'@. * %

$J C

$ % % & ##

!" " # $ % & ## ## $ 8 9 8 %' * ,@. : ,%

#

%/ =**A@

:0 &$ # 8 #0 # $ ( # . 5( :" # "$ # " ) ## #0 8 5 ( # # #0 = / 9 # # % ( # ) %" I '8 &$ ( 5 #0 % C 8 !% / # ) 8 8" 5 $ # ) ## " 8 , # 8!" # 8" 5 # #0 8" " 5% C !% 5 # #J / 3 # 0 # $ .! H ',2'@ : !,! * , % # " - (. / # ( *0 1 . ## $ 8 *" # 8 8

. 5

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 17 of 19

:8 #0 ( # 8 #0 $ 8#0 8 5 5 # 8!" # ) " 3 # 5 3 8" " 5J

#: ( 3 $ ( # ) #0 8" 5 # & 3 . # #0

20 ; &" 9 % )3 " & " = # / # 9 # # % (# # / 9 $ 'I% = / % ( #0 ( / # P ( M M 0 5# / . / # *% *0 1 . 4 C $ % % & ##

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 18 of 19

:

:

!1 & # 0

( . D ": 3 5 . 4 . ($ . " D ":. 3 5 :

2 . K 2 . 2 .

.

3 89 3 # # . . . .

2 #) 4 .

$ 8 4

.

2$ . . .

3 89 3 # # . 4 3 89 3 # # . . . . 2 .

2 #)

$ 8

2$

.

!1 & # 0

($ " 35

. Q

Q

2 #) Q ..

$ 8A

: 57 .

!1 & # 0

/ 3 )& # . %0 - . 3 5 ( !( 35 . * . . . 2 ) . 2 .

3 89 3 # #

2 #)

$ 8 $

!1 & # 0

3 89 3 # # . 35 3 89 3 # # 4

2 #)

$ 8

$

!1 & # 0

2 #)

$ 8 0 /)

". "

!1 & # 0

($ . " 35 . . . ( 35 . .

2 3 89 3 # # 2 # ) $ 8 #0 9I 5( . . . . . . . . Q . Q . . . Q . . . . 2 . . 9I 5( &$ . # 0 . 35 3 89 3 # # 2 #) $ 8*

. .

!1 & # 0

/ # 5 .

!1 & # 0 !1 & # 0 !1 & # 0

8 -# 8 #0 8 *( 0 ($ " 35 . Q ' 3 3 2 . .

#0 9I 5( 2 #) $ 8? " . "

3 89 3 # # .

Case 2:03-cv-01408-DGC

Document 79

Filed 08/22/2005

Page 19 of 19