· 7%'r‘fz0¤0 5+0%:: Pr~F6c>¤1·EYM¤¤/Mc¤d0ws#8 §2F*E¥éE|VE¤ ;¤¤PY
9,0. Box 3300 JuN162006 0 *
FZ0fc¤C€J }4r`fZ
Emi ___ ___ ,_ 00;j§.. P éiwzw
C//VITE0 STATES DISTRMT COL/RT
Fm THE DIST RIC} OF ARIZONA
/1//:THA/UIEL HE/H2/\i$ {cmu ¤3~I"12f| PHA f’1HM[mE¤.)
P|C1;|'\`B;’p'p, I
lp}.!£\I/UTI FF`?) IQECQUEST
vs. l FOR *PRODuc,TJi0/U 0F
Jwsepn M. ARD¤0;0J¤+¤i ,
D:~pcnc{an{·5 /
pursuawl- +0 Rafe 3‘1‘}F»:c}. R. CSU, *H·¤e|0l0Zn1L{1(¥`
p€2L|’€5+ C/C'p€A&{Q§q'{5 PPOGJUCE CiG`CUY"1»€•’1·-[iS
g {i5+¢¢{ [/\e{*ca`n !,0H—|¤In Q5 ck}/5) by 'CJPO1/{c}.'n0) Hm;
p]0·'¤{i10F` 1,0H-h Cgpfcs.
= [· An)! and grfevanccjj C0M(,>[0»'n1L57 0i` O7Lh€f`
;l¢JCum».=;m£S 6Y`€*C€:V&c! ‘H’1a cjc/p¤·:nc:j0mL5 cr ‘H’\€;i` &3€*·1’lL5
ged; l’V\0c[i`5¤n 5·H*ceJ·J¤I’! c0nc0m}n5 m.Q5-I·nc0{me¤·{ and
ViG[Q'h’0n cpp HQP+ Vs Qfl&{ RUXCSGFIOI Rétgufqf-}YI{Oâ€
¤~P inmdc by 0feP¢.4C/M46) /+100 ;i’0»fJ>/ crp AQ@.‘4f0·/3
.·Uw0J· was given ·}"¤ S6?. RFCZ0//6: ;0{wL[n ·Hm=;9w,1=;v0ncc:»
Qnci ¤M[ memorancfqj iw/.·_a.$JrI_9c.1L{v
smc; O'u¤c)2003·
Case2:03—cv-01924—I\/IHI\/I—IVIEA Documeqi 23 Filed 06/16/2006 Pag010f4
gx pmy ONG! POHCZ{C$/ 6{H`ECL+:UC$/QF ;TI.S"LLf`d¢Cl‘Z£r;¤’°}
+0 5+Q*p`P COf]C€{`1'\;YI5 })Of}Cl/};1!â€|\9 SYWJEI/·¤H6¢`S) ;°¤Mp}¤:··'n—,{5
G`? "HW°€*-7*+5) 'CISOH 6XG +0 lil'] YV1CL`{'€~§`-;`C$ be,
"l'T‘qv\S‘p€i" 473 COCJ.f"'|l’ when arti IWOLASCGP
Jn 3*LI.
/hx?/` and cl/{ P@If¢1;?Jirec·+IUc5!¤r {ns1Lm¢:%:.m
+o S"`<-hop COIWC€(`(\¢;fig {Pan crfn Mq0{fScA;nMa1{·@$ +6
=§Clp€¥`;O{` COUrf"{" ‘CO{" 'q'h€;{` C2J€.U"'lL {POM
Hwsm {/i.¤:+ 3% L D; U Slnerhcp O-Pgcews,
3 7 P
LL !jf¤’\\/ GUNS! OH \Q¤£!yC:iC5 &{4If`€L'HD’€SjC$(` :ur'\S`}'I"b£C»[·kH7$
+6 5-»`£'C;'P‘p 9OF/'E'.‘{`f\;nf) IY\fV\cb`£`€ LQ-9(’]{ -§€I°[/,1-(C`€~S {`OCEO/UPGS
por {`€5p ¤n.:[»'nj +0 pro-Sc in mmLeS {*eZu·esfP¤R
C¤<5€ }cw>5 ¢·=nc( ·p¤`][nj YY\c¤~%{c·rl5 w[HqZ.·q ca ‘Hw1e4[){
W\c=¤h‘n€¤"/ ]O0*Hr\ {vw 3c{\€-Pct} ,{)0§0u!cz‘{’f0r•. gmc} In Sc;jf`“€ga}»'c=n,
S» '-n'\€L Y\¤‘fV\C. (Tp U;|f`*€G‘{‘0¢f` Ol"5£AP€f`U{$G(` Op Inm¤1Lc
Z~v;_gq[ S€¤"\/tiff`. in June, crp 3003 +}nr‘c>u5}1;\OO$(
f ém Any and ce/[Q p¤Hc{&5/ 0[é1"6cqL[ve:·)¤rfn5%·fuc%.'¤n
+<> Smvsrnfnj f:)|"`0<1E26Z(;U‘€_'j arp $e‘;cu"CLIn]`r"5 ;nr’VLa`l'C.`5
CBN cme! /€QCz{ cJOCum€r1lL 6U\O{ f"Cf"¤Olf[r\3 ,930:/ O/OCc¢M»@*F»]L£
‘p{"OV"'\ \'\¤iS CEI! C2*â€\O{ Cc:V\‘["I`cz bQV\Cj,rf'\j `H'}€~5E, 1{‘{"€m5 Gnd
`H\C¤•'\ df€—$"{'OY`\/{P'}? `H'\€YY\ [A)H'\(\du+\m¤[(;*jj cm H`€!*|¢(ZC» /»|5‘/`.
O- cpm:] au CUSS) O{¤1I•â€c:C'l'}UG5/ Gl" ;rn5·Huc1l·bf\$ its 5·y(‘q1/AQ
Q<>v€*`h{a r*¤>·<;c.c}r.¢r*c5\ ··(1¤ 0{e5‘[‘¤t`· fn ci\5¤nq} QI‘c·pc:~ ’P :Y\Mct'!G
Caé{é(g:¢3-dM¤`(?Q9®4é|@Iy{M-@IgQq·l—|—Qp7é,[gyqgLi23 YFiEd OF;/16/2006 Page2;‘)Zr O 5
..;2_¢
g· ‘Pwx7 éind an P¤[[;:{c$/c1irec’PIv·€5/or {¤s{·mc{··‘cm$ 7%
_§+q£P governing —{)f`c>cec>{u¢`e~S Pc? mvesh Qjrfnj Comp/¤{m’:s
Hp ‘O€.+c»'\4'{¤f\ 6'P"p;C·&{" $<;~I.`c;:·’*;n5 fqyvxcgcss +5 p}\>/,$.·'C0/O/
6{S5Qf.1H' c2¥\O‘Hf\€¥` ;¥\ |'V\Ci‘l"€r
Cla ThE. PlCi:¥°\'l`(I£'pI5 C0:/*·xP}e+€ YVIGCZKCZQI TELOPGZS CIVIC
JQHE 9003 bdheh LJGS "ILOO +6 YV]€G!r2€'[
bEiC4CzL»{S€ (Tp Q
/O·= ANY /055/ [1{5{`S)6{` @LHT€f`c/0CC!m€u‘fC0TL¢‘G¤ Y`€‘p}€C{‘•'Hj
grfevanccg ·C·`!e:J by M¤:w{.’Sc>¤1 In M01(c5 Pfam O—unr;20¤3
+0 much 200%
H. Any qw! qi! O/O¤m€.~+_g memiccl 1;))/any 5%qP¢‘
YY\€P`Y'tbC(` Of" +l’\<::P CODWL$¢{ ntf} {WZSPOWSE. *0 (Tiny 9}°l·€l/QIICGS
`HNQ iD}C!:n‘!’[·p·p {Pom JUOEQOOS 4*:/{ MQPC-A ,2005
ydoncerning He, IISSUQS {rx HMS civil COM)O/¤.‘.»·£
ZZ./Um»1c5 ang} Jgb +.'1LHc5 G1';] In m¤1Lc L§9c¢/
j5ETVl{CC$ 5U,P@sr[#r;5Of` cam;] cm ¤~H1er IOQPSOHS H¤07L
§d"€ irfll/Ovxffép EVN *Q'lI`n9 1"*’WcZ>`h`¤>!'\ if p{`O··5€ tknMc!/{LE and
'prljlihj {nMg1L€5 ["~&cLL;€.5%·‘&3f` LCSQZ YV-]CZ¢€|°1y€l&f
L }3· Name cmd] Job -H4-H6 and €mP}c¤>/ee Humber mg Hwa
Df:(Ou·L\/ 5\f\cf`;‘·pF Cc>ur"`}' -T¥"qr\5,Q€P1I'a"`¤'G¤ C31Q"p¤¥CCY` {/dbd
I"?-’@M5€d +0 WLQKE WIP, +0 my YA}'1]"'|*'\E`$$ V¤'c>{c;·1L{¤r1 PPO-bOT!'¤i¤N
hmm'¤_g because. Imc! mD!0gc{ Cm my CjO7L}’1€5 CMO! D»O·
WQGIE mmol DAD. \Q0b€f*5¤Yl ··{`r_p¤5€1V Caé;é;2uQ;.%餧019%-l\vH¤¤\/I-MHA5..$D0¤m;zwe¤@@&¢:~#il@¤Y®aG/@/2006 Page 3 of 4
{Ll. An)! cmd all- 0/cscumeml;5 Cf*c¢11(©0{ by any Sfle/Upto
5+¤@·P member from June, 2003 +0 c!q7L&: Gcncernmj
;55Ue5 010 HMB p[¤f!11LP·p'P c'{t/nsf Cc:m,O{¤{n+-
’H¤C$» /5 0!c2y¤01O June) QGOQ »
by:/{/
F@P€kj0E·\5 mnsl HM'5 as
dcz>r¤~P Uu¤€j3~C>OC¤) TO;
Jésepk I. L/qi}
R€;b€aCc;q 50 $5L;>m·~~/
Ue>,p¤r|~ Cc>un·Px/ }O;H‘0•"r\€{`€:.\5
Ch/Il Dil/['3.'O_f\
§€¢;¤.·~.‘+y cg/4{·~ Ex/:!¤{.‘nj
211 1/\}On·H0 C€n·H“ca[ P¤uc.),_§.—,iI+c[I0O
‘pF1¤cniX) /j[NZcn<:x @5609-QZOQ
Case2:03—cv-01924—I\/IHI\/I—IVIEA D0cument23 Filed 06/16/2006 Page40f4
Case 2:03-cv-01924-MHM-MEA
Document 23
Filed 06/16/2006
Page 1 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01924-MHM-MEA
Document 23
Filed 06/16/2006
Page 2 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01924-MHM-MEA
Document 23
Filed 06/16/2006
Page 3 of 4
Case 2:03-cv-01924-MHM-MEA
Document 23
Filed 06/16/2006
Page 4 of 4